Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 14 Oct 2020

Court of Appeal

Singapore Air Charter Pte Ltd v Peter Low & Choo LLC and another

Feedback & support

[2020] SGCA 99Case no. Civil Appeal No 163 of 201933 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The issue in this appeal may appear to be a rather dry procedural one: which of two competing judgment creditors has priority of claim in respect of the balance proceeds of sale of the judgment debtor’s property. Indeed, this impression may not be dispelled upon reading the judgment revolving as it does around statutory interpretation and reconciling court enforcement procedures with the statutory regime. Having said that, clarifying the legal position in this regard will, we hope, be of assistance not only to the litigants before us but also to future judgment creditors pondering how to enforce their judgments.

  3. Background

  4. The facts (Part 1)

  5. [2] The facts are straightforward. The judgment debtor in question is one Mr Danial Patrick Higgins (“the Debtor”). He co-owned an apartment unit in Pasir Ris (“the Property”) which was mortgaged to the second respondent, Malayan Banking Berhad (“the Bank”). On 26 September 2016, judgment was entered against the Debtor in the sum of US$340,500 in favour of the appellant herein, Singapore Air Charter Pte Ltd (“SAC”). Two years later in March 2018, judgment for $394,254.13 against the Debtor was obtained by the first respondent herein, Peter Low & Choo LLC (“PLC”) on account of its legal fees when it represented the Debtor in the action taken by SAC against him. Because the Debtor did not settle the judgment debts, both his creditors took steps to enforce their respective judgments against the Property, using the execution procedures provided for by the Rules of Court (Cap 322, R5, 2014 Rev Ed) (“the Rules”). These procedures are time-sensitive in that they are valid for only limited periods as prescribed by the relevant provisions in the Rules and the legislation regulating the ownership of registered land, the Land Titles Act (Cap 157, 2004 Rev Ed) (“the LTA”). The Property is registered land falling under the LTA.

  6. [3] We now digress from the facts to describe the provisions which set out the possible enforcement actions available to a judgment creditor in respect of real property owned by the judgment debtor. Thereafter, we will come back to the various steps taken by SAC and PLC to attach the Debtor’s interest in the Property.

  7. The legislative and procedural scheme

  8. [4] As is well known, the LTA provides a comprehensive scheme for the ownership of immovable property in Singapore. Most land in Singapore, which term includes apartment units like the Property, is registered on the land-register maintained by the Registrar of Titles. All dealings with a piece of registered land must be entered in the land-register. Generally, interests in registered land must also be notified on the land-register to be effective. The foregoing is stated by way of general introduction only.

  9. [5] Part XIII of the LTA is entitled “Writs and Orders of Court” (“Part XIII”). It is the chapter of the LTA that deals specifically with enforcement action taken by a judgment creditor against registered land belonging to a judgment debtor. There are sections in other parts of the LTA that might have some bearing on issues raised by an enforcement action, but any consideration must start with Part XIII.

  10. The facts (Part 2)

  11. [10] We now go back to the steps taken by the parties herein to attach the Property in satisfaction of their respective judgment debts.

  12. [11] We list first the steps taken by SAC:

  13. [12] As far as PLC was concerned, the steps it took were as follows:

  14. [13] In the meantime, the Bank had been making efforts to sell the Property. These efforts resulted in an option to purchase being issued in November 2018 and in a mortgagee sale being effected on 13 December 2018. The proceeds of sale were more than sufficient to satisfy the indebtedness due to the Bank and the question then arose as the whether the Debtor’s share of the surplus sales proceeds (“the surplus proceeds”) ought to be paid to SAC or PLC.

  15. Proceedings below

  16. [15] The High Court judge (“the Judge”) heard submissions from PLC and SAC. The Judge decided in Peter Low & Choo LLC v Singapore Air Charter Pte Ltd [2019] SGHC 89 (“the Judgment”) that PLC was entitled to the surplus proceeds in priority over SAC. His reasons were as follows:

  17. (a) Priority of third parties’ interests in relation to the surplus sales proceeds should be determined with reference to the date at which the Property was sold (Judgment at [12]).

  18. The appeal

  19. [17] SAC was dissatisfied with the decision of the Judge and applied for leave to appeal the same. Leave was granted by this court on 19 July 2019. Parties were directed to address various questions in their respective cases. It was subsequently decided that the court would be assisted in dealing with these questions by an amicus curiae.

  20. [18] Accordingly, on 7 November 2019, Associate Professor Alvin See Wei Liang (“Prof See”) of the School of Law, Singapore Management University, was appointed as amicus curiae. Prof See was asked to address a number of questions which were, in large part, the same as those that the parties had been asked to address. The questions were:

  21. (c) Would either or both such instruments referred to in (a) above need to be registered for the purposes of priority under s 37(5) or s 48(1) of the LTA?

  22. (d) If the instrument identified in (b) above is registered under the LTA, can it be renewed or extended and, if so, please identify the legal basis. Specifically, does such an instrument, once registered under the LTA, have an expiry date after registration? In answering this question, please address s 134(1) of the LTA, which suggests that the registration of the writ of execution shall lapse and the power of the Sheriff to execute (presumably pursuant to a writ of seizure and sale in Form 83 of Appendix A of the Rules) shall be extinguished at the expiration of one year from the date of registration.

  23. (e) If the instrument identified in (b) above which has already been registered under the LTA cannot be extended beyond the one-year period commencing on the date of the registration under the LTA, can it nonetheless have priority over similar instruments registered at a later date which had not expired?

  24. [19] At the hearing of the appeal, therefore, apart from the parties’ submissions, we also had the benefit of a written opinion and oral submissions from Prof See. We take this opportunity to express our gratitude for the learned and thorough contributions of Prof See which have been very helpful in our analysis.

  25. Applicable provisions of the LTA and the Rules

  26. [20] Before we set out the submissions of the parties and our analysis, the relevant legislative provisions and rules of court are cited in more detail for ease of reference.

  27. Part XIII of the LTA

  28. [21] First, we set out the relevant provisions of Part XIII of the LTA. These are as follows:

  29. Order 47 Rule 4(1) of the Rules

  30. [22] We move on to the court execution procedure set out in O 47 r 4(1) of the Rules. This Rule provides as follows:

  31. [23] Next, we set out Form 83:

  32. [24] Form 96 is as follows:

  33. The issues and SAC’s submissions

  34. [25] There are three broad issues to be dealt with in this appeal. They are as follows:

  35. (b) What is the period during which the instrument so registered would be binding on the land and can the registration be extended upon the expiry of that period?

  36. (c) How do the answers to the first two issues impact on the priority of the claims of the parties and are there any other provisions of the LTA that are of assistance in answering this question?

  37. [29] Finally, SAC argues that the justice of the case was with SAC as:

  38. (b) SAC took all steps necessary to enforce its judgment and complied with all obligations and timelines;

  39. (c) SAC was confronted with unclear law on whether the unity of title of joint tenants was exigible in an execution;

  40. (d) SLA’s repeated delays contributed to the conundrum and confusion which resulted in three to four months’ delay instead of the published seven to 14 days;

  41. (f) The Sheriff was stymied as he could not sell the Property without the consent of the Bank, it being the mortgagee.

  42. Our decision

  43. The correct form for registration

  44. [30] We start with an observation which may seem obvious. This is that the substantive law on the registration and enforcement of writs of execution and orders of court against registered immovable property in Singapore is governed by the LTA. The provisions of Part XIII of the LTA must therefore be the first port of call in determining what must be done and how it must be done. As for the Rules, these are a body of procedural rules meant to assist parties in, among other matters, complying with or invoking substantive law provisions. The Rules cannot affect the provisions of the LTA in the sense that the meaning of terms in the LTA is not controlled by the usage of similar terms in the Rules. Rather, the terms in the LTA find their meaning from the statute itself either expressly or by way of general principles governing statutory interpretation. It cannot be said therefore that because the Rules prescribe a particular form for implementation of a court procedure and term that form a “writ”, that form is also, ipso facto, the “writ” referred to in any particular provision of the LTA.

  45. (a) The judgment creditor has to file a Form 83 Writ and an undertaking, declaration and indemnity in Form 87; and

  46. [45] We end this section of the judgment with a brief historical note. The Rules with which we are dealing in this judgment came into effect in 2014. However, the provisions of O 47 r 4 have been in their present terms since the iteration of the Rules of Court published in 2012. In 2012, Form 96 and Form 83 took their present configurations. Prior to that these forms had different numbers and different labels. However, as Prof See explained, since 1970, the Rules have all along been consistent as to the content of the form that must be registered under the LTA for execution purposes. The contents of Form 96 have not changed since 1970 when it was Form 88-A and was labelled “Writ of Seizure and Sale in respect of Immovable Property”. Form 88-A became Form 83 some years later but the label remained the same. The present Form 83 was previously Form 96 and was entitled “Direction to Sheriff/Bailiff in respect of Writ of Seizure and Sale for Immovable Property”. If the prior labelling conventions had been retained in the 2012 amendments to the Rules of Court, some confusion could have been avoided. The previous labels more clearly reflected the true functions of the respective forms than the present ones do.

  47. Effective duration of a registered writ of execution

  48. [46] The effective duration of a writ of execution would appear to be completely determined by the provisions of ss 132(1) and 134(1) of the LTA. Under s 132(1), the writ only binds or affects registered land when particulars of the writ have been entered in the land-register. Under s 134(1), registration of a writ lapses at the expiration of one year from the date of registration, and the land thereupon ceases to be bound by the writ. Thus, the binding effect of the writ commences on the date of registration and ceases one year from that date.

  49. [48] During the one-year period that the seizure remains in effect, the judgment debtor is prevented from dealing with his land. This enables the sale of the land by the Sheriff free from any adverse interest created by the judgment debtor. As Prof See highlighted, the purpose of imposing a time limit on effectiveness of the writ is to strike a balance between the treatment of the judgment creditor and that of the judgment debtor. While it is important to preserve the judgment creditor’s right to execution of his judgment, it is unfair for the judgment debtor’s right to deal with the property to be affected by the indefinite operation of unexecuted writs of execution. If a writ were to be allowed to have a lasting effect, this would go some way towards undermining the judgment debtor’s interest. As Baalman explains (at p 216):

  50. [49] If the judgment creditor is not successful in effecting a Sheriff’s sale of the land within the one-year period, all is not lost. Section 134(2) of the LTA indicates that a renewal of the writ or a subsequent writ issued on the same judgment may be registered against the land. However, this is not a completely straightforward process. This is because under s 132(6), once a writ has been registered, a subsequent writ shall not be registered until the first registration has been cancelled in accordance with the LTA. This is a reference to s 134(4), which provides that when the registration of a writ lapses, the Registrar of Titles shall cancel that registration on the application of the proprietor or anyone claiming through him. Further, under s 134(3), a judgment creditor is not permitted to use a succession of writs issued on the same judgment to bind land for an interrupted period exceeding one year. Therefore, there must be a lapse of at least one day between the cancellation of the first writ and the registration of the subsequent writ.

  51. Priorities of the parties’ claims

  52. [54] SAC contests the position that ss 37(5) and 48(1) have anything to do with priority of payment as between writs of execution. It pointed out that in Singapore, the registration of a writ of execution under s 132(1) of the LTA does not confer an interest in the proceeds of sale of the land seized. Under the current law, seizure takes the form of a statutory injunction, preventing the judgment debtor from dealing with the land (see s 133(1) of the LTA). It does not create a security interest over the land. As V K Rajah J (as he then was) explained in United Overseas Bank Ltd v Chia Kin Tuck [2006] 3 SLR(R) 322 (“UOB”) at [10]:

  53. Thus, seizure gives the judgment creditor the right to have the land sold but not an interest in the land itself. If the judgment creditor has no interest in the land, s 48(1) would not apply.

  54. [56] In our view, the answer to this question lies in the purpose of Part XIII. The reason for this Part which enables the registration of an execution proceeding by a judgment creditor was precisely to give judgment creditors the ability to satisfy the judgment debt from the judgment debtor’s interest in the land. In this regard, priority between registered writs of execution has not been forgotten. Section 132(2) is the route provided for the ascertainment of priority between registered writs of execution. It states that an entry in the land-register made pursuant to s 132(1) “shall constitute a memorial of registration within the meaning of section 37”. This takes us back to s 37(5) which states that:

  55. [57] The writ of execution registered under s 132(1) is clearly an instrument which affects the estate of the judgment debtor since it prevents him from registering any instrument against his land until the writ of execution has lapsed. Further, any sale by the Sheriff within the validity period of the writ would divest the judgment debtor of his interest so that thereafter instruments executed by him would not be registrable. Thus, the effect of ss 132(1), 132(2) and 37(5) is to make writs of execution registered against the judgment debtor’s land rank in priority according to their respective dates of registration. This is clearly the case when the land is sold by the Sheriff pursuant to the Form 83 Writs but is the situation the same when the land is sold by a mortgagee?

  56. [58] The answer may lie in s 74 of the LTA. Section 74(1) provides:

  57. [59] For the purpose of the present appeal, the words in s 74(1) that need to be considered and interpreted are: “the residue of the money so received shall be paid to the person who appears from the land-register to be entitled to the mortgaged property” [emphasis added]. In the UOB case, it was observed that under this section, a judgment creditor whose writ of execution has been registered can only legitimately claim to have any interest in the surplus sale proceeds after the mortgagee’s claim has been satisfied (at [17]). There the judgment creditor was challenging the mortgagee’s right to conduct a sale of the judgment debtor’s land and this challenge was firmly rejected by the court. For present purposes, the importance of this authority is that it identifies the judgment creditor as a “person who appears from the [land-register] to be entitled to the mortgaged property” even though his right in relation to the same is only to procure its sale by the Sheriff.

  58. [61] The question that arises next is whether, for priority purposes, it is sufficient for a writ of execution to be registered at some point of time before the mortgagee sale or whether at the time of sale it must still be extant, ie, not have lapsed under s 134(1). In this regard, since the right of the judgment creditor (or the effect on the estate of the judgment debtor of his writ) depends on the ability of the Sheriff to sell the land and pay over the proceeds, it logically follows that this right must lapse when the writ lapses and the Sheriff’s right to deal with the land is extinguished. We therefore conclude that only a judgment creditor whose writ is not only on the land-register but is also still valid at the point of sale by the mortgagee can claim entitlement to be the recipient of the residue of the sale proceeds.

  59. Application of principles discussed

  60. [62] The results of the conclusions that we have come to above, indicate that the procedure that a judgment creditor should follow to enforce his judgment against registered land, are as follows:

  61. (d) Fourth, the judgment creditor files a writ of seizure and sale in Form 83 and an undertaking, declaration and an indemnity in Form 87.

  62. (g) Seventh, if the sale is effected by the mortgagee, the surplus proceeds will be paid to judgment creditors who have valid writs of execution on the land-register in the priority in which those writs were registered.

  63. Conclusion

  64. [68] Once again, we express our thanks to Prof See for his learned and helpful submissions.