Court of Appeal · Decided 9 July 2021
BQG v Public Prosecutor
Feedback & support[2021] SGCA 68 · Case no. Criminal Motion No 19 of 2021 · 4 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] This is an application pursuant to s 397 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed) (“CPC”) seeking leave to refer a question of law of public interest to the Court of Appeal. The applicant and a co-accused claimed trial in the General Division of the High Court to charges of serious sexual offences in HC/CC 40/2019 (“CC 40”). Before the trial had even commenced, the applicant and the co-accused filed HC/CM 20/2021 and HC/CM 28/2021 respectively, seeking that the Prosecution disclose witness statements of the complainant and her boyfriend. The High Court judge (“the Judge”) refused to grant the motions. The applicant thus filed CA/CM 19/2021 (“CM 19”) pursuant to s 397(1) of the CPC (ie, the present application) seeking leave to refer a question of law of public interest to the Court of Appeal. The co-accused did not make a similar application. The question that the applicant seeks to refer is: “Whether the Public Prosecutor should disclose to the Defence the witness statements of prosecution witnesses who are also witnesses to be called at a criminal trial”. The applicant alternatively asks this court to direct the Prosecution to refer the question to the court pursuant to s 397(2) of the CPC. In response, the Prosecution argues that CM 19 should be summarily refused under s 397(3B) of the CPC.
- [2]
[2] The relevant parts of s 397 of the CPC read as follows:
- [4]
[4] In the present case, there has been no determination whatsoever by the General Division of the High Court in the exercise of either its appellate or revisionary jurisdiction. Indeed, it is a case which engages the original jurisdiction of the High Court instead. For this reason alone, the present application is not only misconceived but is also an abuse of process of the court. Quite apart from the clear and unambiguous language of s 397(1) (which meaning would have been obvious to any reasonably competent lawyer), counsel for the applicant, Mr Wong Siew Hong (“Mr Wong”), himself admitted during a Case Management Conference (“CMC”) conducted on 24 May 2021 that there is no recourse to s 397 when the General Division of the High Court is exercising its original jurisdiction. He further admitted that the General Division of the High Court in CC 40 was exercising its original jurisdiction. It therefore beggars belief that Mr Wong, an experienced criminal law counsel, would nevertheless proceed to file the present application when it was clear beyond all reasonable doubt that the Court of Appeal did not possess the necessary jurisdiction to even entertain the application to begin with (also bearing in mind the fact that the Court of Appeal is a creature of statute and is hence only seised of the jurisdiction that has been conferred upon it by the relevant provisions, whether derived from the Supreme Court of Judicature Act (Cap 322, 2007 Rev Ed) or elsewhere (see, for example, the decision of this court in Ng Chye Huey and another v Public Prosecutor [2007] 2 SLR(R) 106 at [17])). In the premises, the present application must fail in limine.
- [7]
[7] Finally, the applicant’s alternative prayer that this court direct the Public Prosecutor to refer the question at [1] above to it is fatally flawed since, as already explained above, this court does not possess the requisite jurisdiction to consider that question to begin with. Further, s 397(2) of the CPC provides that “[t]he Public Prosecutor may refer any question of law of public interest without the leave of the Court of Appeal”. It is evident from this provision that the discretion to refer is conferred on the Public Prosecutor and the court cannot compel him to exercise it.