Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 15 Jul 2022
Contents

Court of Appeal

Gaiyathiri d/o Murugayan v Public Prosecutor

Feedback & support

[2022] SGCA 53Case no. Criminal Motion No 3 of 20226 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [3] In particular, we agree with the respondent that Mr Chen’s conduct of CM 3 has fallen short of what is expected of reasonable defence counsel, and would be regarded as improper according to the consensus of professional opinion. Mr Chen had failed in his duty to consider the merits of CM 3 and had facilitated the filing of CM 3 despite it being obviously bound to fail.

  2. [6] More specifically, we consider it likely that Mr Chen had given no consideration whatsoever to the merits or necessity of this part of CM 3 and had simply facilitated its filing at the applicant’s instructions. For instance, although the applicant had access to her children’s medical records from their private paediatrician (which she was able to annex to her reply affidavit for CM 3), CM 3 nevertheless sought disclosure of these records. According to an affidavit filed by the SPS on the respondent’s behalf in CM 3, the SPS had facilitated the applicant’s request for these medical records on 21 August 2021. The private paediatrician subsequently provided a reply with the applicant’s children’s medical reports on 5 October 2021, and the SPS then issued these reports to the applicant. Both the applicant and Mr Chen did not dispute this. All of this goes towards suggesting that Mr Chen had never once considered if discovery of all or any part of those materials sought had been necessary before CM 3 was filed on 25 January 2022. This is also symptomatic of how he had failed to make any assessment of the merits of CM 3 before invoking the court’s processes.

  3. [7] The part of CM 3 relating to the application for leave to adduce a psychiatric report by Dr Jacob Rajesh (“Dr Rajesh”) as further evidence is even more egregious. By way of context, for the purposes of the applicant’s guilty plea, the Prosecution and Defence agreed that the psychiatric assessment by one Dr Derrick Yeo (“Dr Yeo”) was to be taken as reflective of her mental state at the time she had committed the offences (see the Judgment at [2]). The applicant contends that in the alleged further report, Dr Rajesh sets out his disagreement with Dr Yeo’s assessment of her psychiatric condition (see the Judgment at [4]). Leaving the merits of that application aside, which we have observed in the Judgment (at [22]) to be doubtful, it would have been clear to Mr Chen from the outset that this part of CM 3 was bound to fail because the alleged further report by Dr Rajesh had not even been put before us and there was no basis on which we could have considered the application (see the Judgment at [21]).

  4. [9] In any event, there is no evidence to support Mr Chen’s assertion about the applicant’s impecuniosity and the consequent difficulties she faced in obtaining the alleged further report. This point has been raised for the first time by Mr Chen, presumably for his own benefit. In fact, as early as October 2021, Mr Chen had informed the court that the applicant was seeking leave to adduce a further psychiatric report and that arrangements were being made to obtain such a report. Mr Chen never once thereafter informed the court that the applicant faced difficulty in obtaining the alleged further report. Even if Mr Chen’s assertion about the applicant’s impecuniosity were true, it can provide no excuse for his conduct. Mr Chen could (and should) have informed the court about the difficulty faced by the applicant and sought the necessary directions. In fact, if there were any truth in Mr Chen’s assertion about the applicant’s impecuniosity, he would have done a grave disservice to his then-client (the applicant) by failing to ensure that CM 3 only proceeded to hearing when the relevant documents had been obtained.

  5. [10] Mr Chen also claims that the part of CM 3 seeking a Newton Hearing was justified because the applicant had wanted to know if a Newton Hearing could be convened notwithstanding the agreement between the Prosecution and the Defence to adopt Dr Yeo’s assessment of her mental state for her guilty plea (see [7] above). However, given that the alleged further report by Dr Rajesh had not even been put before us, there could be no difference between Dr Yeo’s and Dr Rajesh’s assessment of the applicant’s mental state to speak of, and there was similarly no basis on which we could have considered the part of CM 3 seeking a Newton Hearing.

  6. [13] In this case, a mere good faith belief by Mr Chen in the merits of CM 3 does not assist him because quite clearly, that belief had been held without reasonable basis. The circumstances of this case also do not lend the impression that Mr Chen had acted in good faith. This is because CM 3 had not merely been unmeritorious; it was entirely without basis and so Mr Chen must have known that it was nothing but a waste of the court’s time. As explained in the Judgment, none of the materials for which disclosure had been sought was in the possession of the respondent, a position which Mr Chen must have been aware of (see the Judgment at [13]-[14]). We were also left with no option except to dismiss the application for leave to adduce further evidence because the alleged further report by Dr Rajesh had not even been put before us (see the Judgment at [21]). We are therefore not persuaded that Mr Chen had acted in good faith in facilitating the filing of CM 3.