District Court · Decided 19 December 2025
Yip Kie Sie v Denis Lim Boon Jin & anor
Feedback & support[2025] SGDC 325 · Case no. [2025] SGDC 325
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] Yip Kie Sie (the “Claimant”) was the chairman of the 17th management council (“MC”) of MCST No. 2573, the Heritage View Condominium (“HV”) until the 6th meeting of the 17th MC held on 22 January 2020. Denis Lim Boon Jin (the “First Defendant”) was elected at the same meeting as chairman for the remaining term of the 17th MC as well as the 18th MC until 16 December 2020 when Chan Kheng Choo Lena (the “Second Defendant”) became Chairperson for the remaining term of the 18th MC. The Second Defendant was the Secretary of the 17th MC.
- [2]
[2] This is the Claimant’s claim in defamation against the First and Second Defendants.
The Claimant’s Case
1st Set of Defamatory Words
- [3]
[3] The Claimant claims that on 22 January 2020, at the 6th meeting of the 17th MC, the Defendants published or caused to be published the following statements about the Claimant (collectively the “1st Set of Defamatory Words”):
- [4]
[4] On or around 6 or 7 February 2020, the Defendants published or caused to be published minutes of the 6th meeting containing the 1st Set of Defamatory Words on the notice boards of HV. The 6th meeting of the 17th MC was attended by the other members of the 17th MC and the meeting minutes published on the notice boards of HV were accessible to all the residents of HV.
- [5]
[5] The Claimant claims that the 1st Set of Defamatory Words, in their natural and ordinary meaning meant and were understood to mean that the Claimant had abused his authority as chairman of the MC and/or that he had done so to advance his personal pecuniary interests and/or in disregard of HV’s interest.
- [6]
[6] The Claimant claims that the 1st Set of Defamatory Words were calculated to disparage the Claimant in his capacity as the chairman of the 17th MC and were maliciously made. The Defendants had personally benefited from making the defamatory statements. On the back of these statements, the First Defendant requested the Claimant to step down as chairman and moved an un-tabled motion of no-confidence against the Claimant which was seconded by the Second Defendant. This resulted in the First Defendant being nominated and elected as chairman in the Claimant’s place.
2nd Set of Defamatory Words
- [7]
[7] In or around mid-October 2020, ahead of HV’s Annual General Meeting (“AGM”) in end October 2020, the Defendants published or caused to be published a complaint to BCA against the Claimant about his alleged misuse of authority as chairman of the MC to procure repairs to a damaged table at the BBQ pit to advance his personal pecuniary interests (the “2nd Set of Defamatory Words”). In their natural and ordinary meaning, these words meant and were understood to mean that the Claimant had abused his authority as chairman of the MC and/or to advance his personal pecuniary interest and/or in disregard of HV’s interests and were calculated to disparage the Claimant.
- [8]
[8] The Claimant claims that the 2nd Set of Defamatory Words were maliciously made. On or about 26 November 2020, BCA informed the Claimant that having concluded its findings, BCA would not be taking any action in the complaint. The Claimant informed the MC of the BCA’s findings contemporaneously. The First Defendant, who was the chairman of the MC, and the Second Defendant, who was the Secretary of the MC, would have known of the BCA’s findings but no clarification was made to the MC.
3rd Set of Defamatory Words
- [9]
[9] On or about 30 or 31 October 2020, at HV’s AGM, the First Defendant published or caused to be published the following statements (collectively the 3rd Set of Defamatory Words):
- [10]
[10] In or around 2021, the First Defendant published or caused to be published the 3rd Set of Defamatory Words when he approved or caused to be approved the minutes of the above-mentioned AGM at the subsequent AGM in 2021.
- [11]
[11] The Claimant claims that the AGM in October 2020 and/or 2021 were attended by various residents of HV and that the minutes of the AGM would be published and made accessible to all residents of HV.
- [12]
[12] The Claimant claims that the 3rd Set of Defamatory Words, in their natural and ordinary meaning, meant and were understood to mean that
- [13]
[13] The Claimant claims that the 3rd Set of Defamatory Words were maliciously made. The First Defendant had personally benefitted from making these defamatory statements as they justified his nomination and election as chairman of the 17th MC following the no-confidence vote against the Claimant at the 6th meeting of the 17th MC.
The First Defendant’s Case
1st Set of Defamatory Words
- [14]
[14] The First Defendant does not admit publishing the 1st Set of Defamatory Words and denies that they are defamatory. The First Defendant pleads the defence of justification and qualified privilege.
Defence of Justification
- [15]
[15] In respect of the First Statement, the First Defendant claims that at the 5th meeting of the MC on 18 December 2019, the MC had sought confirmation from the Claimant as the then chairman, on whether the new agreements with the managing agent (“MA”), Smart Property Management (Singapore) Pte Ltd (“Smart Property”) and the general cleaning contractor, Acteef Cleaning Specialists Pte Ltd (“Acteef”) had been signed. This was because the existing agreements had already expired and the MC had already given its approval for the new agreements to be signed with the Claimant being tasked to put that into effect. When questioned, the Claimant was unable to provide any satisfactory explanation and merely claimed that Acteef had changed its business name and/or merged with another entity and some paperwork had to be done before Acteef could sign the new agreement. The Claimant further claimed that in the meantime, a novation contract had been signed.
- [18]
[18] In respect of the Fourth Statement, the First Defendant claims that the members of the MC had sought clarification from the Claimant on why he had a meeting with the MA (without knowledge of the other MC members) on an official matter relating to the employment of one Alison Chia, a staff of the MA. A fellow member of the MC, David Wong, was asked by the Claimant to attend the meeting but was specifically told not to disclose the outcome of the meeting with the other MC members or that the Claimant’s wife, an ex-member of the MC, was also present at the meeting. The Claimant’s explanation for his wife’s presence at the meeting was unsatisfactory.
- [19]
[19] In respect of the Fifth Statement, the First Defendant claims that it is the conclusion from the First Statement to Fourth Statement.
Defence of Qualified Privilege
- [20]
[20] The First Defendant claims that the statements were uttered on an occasion of qualified privilege i.e. a meeting of the MC. Given that the statements relate to matters of the HV estate and the Claimant and the First Defendant were members of the MC, the duo had a common or corresponding interest in the subject matter of the statements and it was the First Defendant’s social, moral or legal duty to raise those matters.
- [21]
[21] The First Defendant denies any malice. In publishing the minutes, the First Defendant was acting in his capacity qua chairman of the MC and in accordance with the provisions of the Building Maintenance and Strata Management Act (“BMSMA”) which require the minutes to be published by 10 February 2020. Prior to the publication of the minutes, the Claimant was given the opportunity to provide his input on the draft. After the Claimant refused to approve the first draft, a second draft was circulated incorporating some of the Claimant’s comments. The Claimant refused to comment on the second draft and refused to approve it. It was only thereafter that the MC proceeded to finalise the minutes. As the published minutes contained the Claimant’s explanations as to why he disagreed with the allegations made against him, a reasonable reader of the minutes would not conclude that the Claimant was guilty of the allegations and the Claimant is thus not defamed.
- [22]
[22] The First Defendant denies that he was actuated by malice as he was validly elected as the new chairman following the disgruntlement of some members of the MC with the conduct of the Claimant qua chairman.
2nd Set of Defamatory Words
- [23]
[23] The First Defendant had written an email dated 30 September 2020 to BCA (the “Email”) stating that in the First Defendant’s opinion, the Claimant’s conduct in relation to the damaged tabletop may have contravened sections 60 and 61 of the BMSMA.
Defences of Justification and Qualified Privilege
- [24]
[24] The First Defendant pleads the defences of justification and qualified privilege and denies that he was actuated by malice. The BCA is the controlling body in respect of MCs and the First Defendant was merely carrying out his duty as the chairman of the MC to seek clarifications from the governing body on the propriety or otherwise of the Claimant’s actions whilst he was the chairman.
3rd Set of Defamatory Words
- [25]
[25] The First Defendant denies that the statements are defamatory. Even if the statements are defamatory, the First Defendant pleads the defence of justification and qualified privilege.
Defences of Justification and Qualified Privilege
- [26]
[26] The statements were made at the AGM, being an occasion of qualified privilege. The First Defendant, as the then chairman of the MC, had a social, moral or legal duty to publish the statements and the attendees, the subsidiary proprietors (“SPs”) of units in HV, had a common interest in the statements. The statements were made without any malicious intent but were to explain to the SPs the circumstances under which the Claimant was voted out as the chairman of the MC.
- [27]
[27] The First Defendant denies that he was actuated by malice. The publication of the meeting minutes was required as a matter of law under the BMSMA.
The Second Defendant’s case
1st Set of Defamatory Words
- [28]
[28] The Second Defendant denies publishing or causing the publication of any words defamatory of the Claimant during the 6th meeting of the 17th MC or on the notice board.
- [29]
[29] Minutes of the meeting were prepared by the MA. The first draft of the minutes was put up on the notice boards of HV on 6 February 2020 at about 10 p.m. after it was approved by the MC. Following a complaint from the Claimant, the MA removed the first draft of the minutes from the notice boards at about 10 a.m. on 7 February 2020. The council then held an urgent meeting on 8 February 2020 to discuss the Claimant’s complaints and consider amendments to the draft minutes. The Claimant did not attend the meeting. The MA subsequently circulated a second draft of the minutes for approval which was put up on the notice boards of HV on 10 February 2020 after the MC had approved them. The Second Defendant did not sign either the first or second draft of the minutes. Following yet another complaint from the Claimant, the MC met again on 26 February 2020 to consider the Claimant’s complaints and consider amendments to the draft minutes. The Claimant attended this meeting. At this meeting, the MC agreed on a third and final version of the minutes which did not contain any of the words the Claimant complained of. The MC also agreed to include an addendum prepared by the Claimant putting forward his position on the issues (the “Addendum”). The third and final version of the minutes was the only version of minutes that contained the Second Defendant’s signature and it was the only version that was circulated to all SPs by email. The Addendum was also circulated to all SPs by email.
- [30]
[30] The Second Defendant claims that the notice boards of HV are all located in the basement carpark and one notice board is outside the MA’s office. Both these locations are not frequented by most residents of HV.
- [31]
[31] The Second Defendant denies that the 1st Set of Defamatory Words are defamatory. In the context of the meeting, the words meant or were understood to mean that
Defence of Justification
- [32]
[32] The Second Defendant relies on section 8 of the Defamation Act 1957 and claims that the statements in paragraph 31 are true in substance and in fact for the following reasons:
Defence of Qualified Privilege
- [33]
[33] If any defamatory statements were published in the context of the MC meeting, the Second Defendant claims that they were published on an occasion of qualified privilege as the meeting of the MC was limited to members of the MC and representatives of the MA, all of whom had an interest to receive information in relation to matters pertaining to HV.
- [34]
[34] The Second Defendant’s words were in relation to affairs of HV and acts of the members of the MC, including contracts entered into by HV, repair and replacement of common property and the duties of the members of the MC. She had a legitimate duty and/or interest to communicate the words to the MC members and representatives of the MA, who had a legitimate interest to receive and be informed of the same.
- [35]
[35] As for publication on the notice board, under the BMSMA, the MC is required to display on the notice boards copies of the minutes of council meetings for a period of not less than 14 days.
- [36]
[36] The Second Defendant denies that the discussions during the Meeting were conducted with any ulterior motive or with a lack of honest belief by the Second Defendant.
2nd Set of Defamatory Words
- [37]
[37] The Second Defendant denies publishing or causing to be published the complaint to the BCA. The Second Defendant denies that the 2nd Set of Defamatory Words are defamatory. The Second Defendant claims that the words had the natural and ordinary meaning set out in paragraph 31(b).
Defence of Justification
- [38]
[38] The Second Defendant relies on section 8 of the Defamation Act 1957 and claims that the statements in paragraph 31(b) are true in substance and in fact for the reason set out in paragraph 32(b).
Defence of Qualified Privilege
- [39]
[39] The Claimant, both Defendants and Ronie Ganguly were members of the council at the material time. Mr Lim Chong Yong was a director at the BCA, the government authority that oversees management corporations within Singapore. The publishing of the 2nd Set of Defamatory Words was done by way of an email to the BCA and limited to council members who were office bearers and one BCA officer/director in ensuring that matters of repair and replacement of common property within HV were done properly.
- [40]
[40] The council members who were recipients of the Email had an interest to receive information in relation to the management of HV and how the repair and replacement of damaged common property was undertaken by interested parties. Mr Lim Chong Yong also had an interest in receiving the information. The Second Defendant had a legitimate duty and/or interest to communicate the 2nd Set of Defamatory Words to the council members of HV and the BCA, who had a legitimate interest to receive and/or be informed of the same.
- [41]
[41] The Second Defendant denies that the words were meant to disparage the Claimant. The Second Defendant played no part in the preparation and sending of the Email to BCA and had no ulterior motive or a lack of honest belief in relation to the same. The First Defendant appeared to have drafted the Email to seek advice from BCA rather than to disparage the Claimant.
- [42]
[42] The First Defendant only shared BCA’s response with the Second Defendant on 11 November 2020. At this time, given that the 18th AGM was held on 31 October 2020, there was a change of council members. Even if the Second Defendant had a duty to provide the said clarifications, it would not have been possible as the 17th MC was no longer in existence.
Issues
- [43]
[43] It is not disputed that the statements referred to the Claimant. To establish a prima case of defamation, the Claimant has to establish that the statements were defamatory and were published.
- [44]
[44] The following issues arise for determination:
1st Set of Defamatory Words
- [45]
[45] On the Claimant’s pleaded case , the 1st Set of Defamatory Words were published at the 6th meeting of the 17th MC as well as contained in the first version of the minutes of the 22 January 2020 meeting which was put up on the night of 6 February 2020 and which was removed on the morning of 7 February 2020.
Were the words published by the First Defendant?
- [46]
[46] A defamatory statement is actionable only if it has been communicated to a third party who would reasonably understand it to be defamatory of the claimant. A person who originated a defamatory statement with the intention of publishing it is liable for the defamatory publication. Liability also extends to one who authorised, participated in or procured the publication of the defamatory statement: Loh Siew Hock & ors v Lang Chin Ngau [2014] 4 SLR 1117 (“Loh Siew Hock”) at [21].
- [47]
[47] The First Defendant does not admit publishing the words at the meeting on 22 January 2020.
- [48]
[48] However it is clear from the transcript of the meeting on 22 January 2020 that the First Defendant was the one who questioned why the letter of intent for the MA was undated , questioned the Claimant on why the MA contract had yet to be signed and why the cleaning contract had not been signed . The First Defendant was the one who alleged that the Claimant had unilaterally overruled the council by instructing Sebastian to halt the replacement of the filters . The First Defendant also alleged that the Claimant had requested the technicians to repair the damaged tabletop without going to the condominium manager and that there was a conflict of interest which the Claimant did not declare and that it was improper . The First Defendant accused the Claimant for his lack of openness and transparency and proposed a vote of no confidence and raised the issue of the meeting with Desmond without the knowledge of the council members and without explaining why his wife, the former chairman, was in the meeting . In the circumstances, I find that the First Defendant had published the 1st Set of Defamatory Words at the 6th MC meeting on 22 January 2020.
- [49]
[49] As for the minutes of meeting, it is the First Defendant’s position in his affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) that he caused the minutes to be published. The element of publication was therefore satisfied in respect of the minutes.
Were the words published by the Second Defendant?
- [50]
[50] The Second Defendant claims that she did not say the 1st Set of Defamatory Words and did not sign the 6 February 2020 version of the minutes. The Second Defendant claimed that there is no evidence that she was the one who put up the minutes or gave instructions for the minutes to be put up. Instead, it was the First Defendant who instructed the minutes to be put up on 6 February 2020 pursuant to (i) the Claimant’s instructions as the chairman that procedurally, minutes should be put up on time and even if there are inaccuracies, it is alright as the minutes have not been adopted and passed yet ; and (ii) the majority of the council approving the minutes , including the Claimant himself.
- [51]
[51] While the Second Defendant argued that she did not utter any of the defamatory statements at the meeting, the transcript showed that she had raised the issue of the letter of letter not being dated and had asked the Claimant to explain why the MA contract as well as the cleaning contract had not been signed and why the Claimant did not share the soft copy MA contract with them . She highlighted that the Claimant, while chairman, had only one vote and if the others had agreed on something and he disagreed, he should approach them to explain why he disagreed . She also pointed out that the Claimant was not transparent enough to own up to the damaged tabletop and highlighted that the Claimant lacked transparency in failing to explain to them what had happened in the private meeting he had with David Wong, his wife and Desmond .
- [53]
[53] Against the backdrop of the private chat where the Second Defendant was seen to be gathering information to confront the Claimant with the intent of removing him as chairman, I find that the Second Defendant had published, or at the very least, participated and procured the publication of the 1st Set of Defamatory Words at the meeting on 22 January 2020. The element of publication was therefore satisfied.
- [54]
[54] I accept that the Claimant had on 4 October 2019 taken the position that the timeline for putting up minutes of council meetings should be followed and that amendments to minutes of meeting can be made at the following management council (“MC”) meeting . I note that after the Claimant had given his comments to the minutes on 4 February 2020 at 11:27 a.m. , the Defendants together with David Wong, Ronie Ganguly and Krishna discussed the amendments among themselves and excluded the other four council members from the discussion . After discussion among the group of five, the Second Defendant made the final edits to the minutes on 5 February 2020 at 4:25 p.m. and instructed the MA to accept the changes before sending the final draft to the five of them for approval . In relation to the final draft of the minutes sent by Cassandra, the condominium manager at that time, on 5 February 2020 at 6:08 p.m., the Second Defendant had replied on 5 February 2020 at 9:55 p.m. with only two amendments . After the First Defendant approved the minutes in the group chat of five on 5 February 2020 at 9:41 p.m. , he sent the minutes to all nine MC members on 6 February 2020 at 8:23 p.m. and the minutes were put up on the notice boards shortly after.
- [55]
[55] It is therefore clear from the sequence of events that the Second Defendant approved of the minutes which were put up. It was her oral evidence that she constituted one of the majority who agreed on the minutes and that the instruction for the minutes to be posted was given by the First Defendant copied to all council members and that the MA posted the minutes pursuant to the First Defendant’s email . On the stand, the Second Defendant conceded that while the MA team may have been the ones who physically put up the minutes, they would have done it only with her approval and direction, including on the night of 6 February 2020 . Given that the Second Defendant was the Secretary of the MC, this would have fallen within the scope of her statutory duties under section 56 of the BMSMA to attend to matters of a secretarial nature in connection with the exercise of the council’s functions. That the finalisation of the council minutes lay within the purview of the Second Defendant as Secretary was also consistent with the representation by Cassandra to a resident on 21 March 2020 . In the circumstances, I find that the element of publication for the minutes was satisfied in respect of the Second Defendant.
Were the minutes put up on all 19 notice boards?
- [56]
[56] On 11 January 2020, the Second Defendant was indicated as having instructed the MA to post the minutes of MC meetings on all notice boards as they take precedence over less important notices which should be removed when the minutes are put up . Subsequently, at the council meeting on 22 January 2020 , the Second Defendant stated that it has always been the past practice to have the minutes displayed on all the boards for all the residents to view and that the practice should be continued. On the stand, the First Defendant agreed that this was the case and that in accordance with past practice the 6 February 2020 version of the minutes was put up on all notice boards .
- [57]
[57] While the Second Defendant took the position that minutes were only placed on basement notice boards in each tower and not on the ground floor notice boards , I did not find such evidence credible given the Second Defendant’s position recorded in the minutes of 22 January 2020 that the past practice had been for the minutes to be displayed on all the boards.
- [58]
[58] There is evidence that at least one resident would have seen the minutes, given that she sent an email to the MC and MA on 25 February 2020 in relation to different versions of the minutes .
Were the words defamatory?
- [59]
[59] The first version of the minutes reads as follows (with added emphasis on the 1st Set of Defamatory Words):
- [60]
[60] The Claimant claimed that the 1st Set of Defamatory Words meant and were understood to mean that the Claimant had abused his authority as chairman of the MC and that he had done so to advance his personal pecuniary interests and/or in disregard of HV’s interests.
- [61]
[61] The First Defendant argued that the fact that the Claimant did not delete the statements when presented with the opportunity shows that he did not find them to be objectionable then and allowed them to appear in the 6 February 2020 version of the minutes as long as his comments were added. I do not think that the fact that the Claimant did not object to the statements meant that the statements were not defamatory. The test of whether a statement is defamatory is an objective one based on the perspective of the reasonable third party. In addition, the 6 February 2020 version of the minutes had included the responses from the council which the Claimant did not get to comment on before they were published and which cast a different light on how the statements would be read and understood. The minutes were to be read as a whole and the 1st Set of Defamatory Words would be considered defamatory if it tends to lower the Claimant in the estimation of right-thinking members of society generally or cause the Claimant to be shunned or avoided or expose him to hatred, contempt or ridicule.
- [62]
[62] I do not think the statement that the Claimant had omitted dates when approving documents and could not explain satisfactorily to the council why he had signed the novation cleaning contract but not the main cleaning contract is defamatory in and of itself. The omission of dates when approving documents could well be attributed to a momentary lapse. The implications of a novation may not be well comprehended by an ordinary reasonable person. Hence, the inability of the Claimant to explain why a novation agreement had been signed but not the main cleaning contract is unlikely to lower the Claimant in the estimation of right-thinking members of society. I do not think that the statement would be understood to mean that the Claimant had abused his authority as chairman of the MC to advance his personal pecuniary interest and/or in disregard of HV’s interests.
- [63]
[63] Similarly, I also do not think that the statement that the Claimant had unilaterally overruled a decision of the MC on the replacement of 2 tank filters for the lap pool without prior discussion and consensus from other council members was defamatory in and of itself. Read in the context of the paragraphs and minutes in which it appears, the circumstances in which the Claimant had asked the managing agent to stop proceeding with the replacement in order to investigate the matter is set out in full. The statement would therefore not be understood to mean that the Claimant had abused his authority as chairman or did so to advance his personal pecuniary interest and/or in disregard of HV’s interests. As set out in Chan Cheng Wan Bernard & ors v Koh Sin Chong Freddie & anor appeal [2012] 1 SLR 506 at [18], where there are a number of possible interpretations, some of which may be non-defamatory, an ordinary reasonable reader will not seize on only the defamatory one.
- [65]
[65] I also find that the statement that the Claimant had secretly arranged a meeting with the MA with his wife (Sim Nyet Moi) in attendance, invited David Wong at very short notice and had failed to inform the council and adequately explain why his wife was involved in this meeting and in what capacity was also defamatory. The reference to the meeting with the MA being arranged “secretly” and David Wong being invited “at very short notice” and the reference to the lack of “openness and transparency as chairman” indicates that the Claimant had something to hide and suggests that the Claimant had abused his authority as chairman in disregard of HV’s interests.
- [66]
[66] In view of the defamatory statements above, the statement that the Claimant was not acting in the manner that was expected of him in the discharge of his duties as the chairman of the MCST was defamatory as it tends to lower the esteem of the Claimant in the estimation of right-thinking members of society generally. Even excluding the statements relating to the contracts and tank filters, I am of the view that the Claimant had made out a prima face case of defamation on the 1st Set of Defamatory Words.
Whether the defence of justification is made out in respect of the damaged tabletop statements
- [67]
[67] The Claimant is not required to prove that the defamatory statement is false. Instead, the burden of proof is on the Defendants to prove the defence of justification by proving that the defamatory statement is true in substance and in fact.
- [68]
[68] It was the Claimant’s evidence that an accidental burn mark was caused to one of the round tables at BBQ Pit E on the night of 30 November 2019. In the morning of 2 December 2019, Cassandra called him to ask if he knew about the damage. He replied in the affirmative and she told him that she would be checking for quotes for the repairs. When Cassandra told him a few days later that she had obtained two quotations from outside vendors but that the quotes seem high, he suggested to her that she should check with Sim, the technician, because he recalled that Sim had previously done some repairs for similar tables. Cassandra told him that she would do so and informed him a few days later that the quote from Sim would be lower than the external vendors. Cassandra also told him that he would need to pay for the repairs which he agreed. Around end December 2019, Sim fixed the tabletop. On or around 3 January 2020, Cassandra presented to him the invoice of $115.87 which was the quote she previously gave him. While he had placed a cheque deposit of $150 with the MA when booking the BBQ pit, he thought that it would be more convenient for him to pay the exact amount rather than for the MA to cash the original cheque and issue him a refund. As such, on or around 7 January 2020, he issued a cheque to the MA for $115.87 and took back his deposit of $150.
- [71]
[71] Secondly, the burden of proof is on the Defendants to prove that the Claimant had circumvented the MA and council; it is not for the Claimant to prove that the statements were false and that he had gone through Cassandra to procure Sim’s services. Bearing in mind it is the Defendants’ burden to prove the defence of justification, one would have thought that it is the Defendants who would call Cassandra or Sim to prove that the Claimant had circumvented the MA. Hence, the fact that the Claimant did not call Cassandra or Sim to corroborate his version of events does not weigh against him. It is also clear from the records of the WhatsApp chat group, which all the council members were part of, that Cassandra had disclosed that it was the Claimant’s unit which is involved in the incident and the discussion moved on.
- [72]
[72] In any event, the transcripts of the meeting on 22 January 2020 which capture what Cassandra said do not show that the Claimant had circumvented her and approached the technicians :
On the stand, the Second Defendant conceded that it was not clear from Cassandra whether the Claimant had bypassed her to approach the technician .
- [73]
[73] Based on the transcript, the quotations for the supply and installation of the tabletops were not selected because the technician was able to source for the tabletop. While Cassandra initially said that she had told the technician to look for the tabletop, she subsequently said that the technician had offered to look for it. She postulated that the Claimant had informed the technician about the table such that when she spoke to the technician, the technician said he could go and try to look for the tabletop. When it was put to her that the technician knew about it and someone must have approached the technician to find a replacement, Cassandra said that the technician could be aware or not and that he did not come to her, saying that the table is spoilt.
Denis Lim (DL)
No. I mean, the point here is that what was the final bill to the resident?
Cassandra Chew (CC)
The material cost and the transport.
Lena Chan (LC)
$115
Cassandra Chew (CC)
Hmm.
Denis Lim (DL)
Whereas…
Krishna Subramanyan (KS)
Would every resident have that facility? Would you give that right to every resident in this condominium? All 600?
Cassandra Chew (CC)
If the technician is able to source for materials, I don’t think why not.
Krishna Subramanyan (KS)
And he’s willing to, (CC: Yeah, provided …) And if he’s willing to do it free of cost, will he do that to every resident? Will you approve him doing that for every resident?
Cassandra Chew (CC)
If the technician is actually willing to help out, then I don’t see any …
- [75]
[75] The First Defendant admitted that he was not able to ascertain whether the Claimant had approached Cassandra prior to talking to the technicians or otherwise and that at the time of the meeting on 22 January 2020, it was not made clear who had approached who first . The First Defendant argued that he had asked the Claimant at the meeting whether the Claimant had approached Cassandra or the technicians first.
Denis Lim (DL)
So, Kie Sie, can I just ask, did you approach Cassandra or the technicians first?
Yip Kie Sie (YKS)
I asked Cassandra to check what is the best, cheapest option. That’s all.
Lena Chan (LC)
Did you speak with Sim directly yourself?
Yip Kie Sie
I asked him, has he repaired this kind of table before? Yes. He has done it. He said, yeah. Maybe he’ll look around and see what he can do.
Krishna Subramanyan (KS)
But it didn’t occur to you that he would be using MCST time?
Yip Kie Sie (YKS)
I said, please don’t go out of your way. Please don’t use whatever MCST money. I will pay for everything. I don’t know the cost at that point of time. So only when Cassandra gave me the bill, she gave me the full receipt. I paid the full receipt. (DL: Maybe we just (not clear)) As far as I am concerned, there was no improper conduct.
- [76]
[76] The Claimant’s response then that he had asked Cassandra to check what is the best and cheapest option was consistent with his evidence that he had spoken with Cassandra first.
- [77]
[77] The Second Defendant also conceded that she was unsure at the time she read the email of 30 September 2020, and correspondingly as of 22 January 2020, whether the Claimant had asked the estate’s two technicians to procure material to repair the damaged tabletop directly, circumventing the authority of the MA and council .
- [78]
[78] As to the Claimant’s failure to declare or notify his fellow council members of his pecuniary interest, it was clear from the WhatsApp Chat titled “Internal HV 16th Council” comprising all the council members and the managing agent team that when the Second Defendant highlighted the burnt mark on one of the round tables at BBQ Pit E on 20 December 2019 and asked who is the resident, Cassandra had replied in the chat that she was aware and was getting the price of the replacement table top to charge it back to the resident. Cassandra had also replied in the chat that it was the Claimant’s unit . Given that it was already made known that the Claimant’s unit was involved, it was not necessary for the Claimant to declare the same to his council members.
- [80]
[80] As was clear from the email dated 19 June 2020, the MC ultimately laid the responsibility of the incident on the MA. The absence of protest by the Claimant in response to the email did not mean that he agreed with the content of the letter .
- [81]
[81] In the circumstances, I find that the Defendants have failed to prove the defence of justification in respect of the defamatory statement that the Claimant had misused his position as a chairman by circumventing the authority of the MA and council to directly ask the technicians to procure material and repair a damaged table and failed to notify his fellow council members of his pecuniary interest.
Whether the defence of qualified privilege is made out in respect of the damaged tabletop statements
- [82]
[82] The Claimant accepts that the 1st Set of Defamatory Words were made on an occasion of qualified privilege but contends that such privilege has been defeated by malice.
- [83]
[83] In Gao Shuchao v Tan Kok Quan [2018] SGHC 115, it was held at [37] that malice can be found in two instances: (a) where it can be shown that the defendant had knowledge of falsity or was reckless as to the truth of the defamatory statement; or (b) where the defendant had the dominant intention of injuring the plaintiff or some other improper motive, even though he may have a genuine or honest belief in the truth of the defamatory statement. At [39], the Court was of the view that
- [84]
[84] In ascertaining whether the defence of qualified privilege was made out, I had noted earlier the fact that on 7 January 2022, the Second Defendant set up a separate WhatsApp chatgroup with 5 out of 9 MC members comprising the Defendants, David Wong, Roni Ganguly, Krishna Subramanyan as well as Desmond from the MA. The Claimant, Sreekumar, Sharada and Phani Bala were not part of this chatgroup.
- [86]
[86] As set out earlier, the forum was subsequently used to gather information as regards the issues which they were going to raise against the Claimant during the council meeting of 22 January 2020 and to discuss how they would deal with the Claimant . In particular, ahead of the meeting, the First Defendant enclosed in the chat an excerpt from the BMSMA as regards how a management corporation may remove a member of its council from office . The Second Defendant did not express any surprise at the First Defendant’s messages but continued with setting out the information which the Claimant can be confronted with. In the circumstances, I find that going into the meeting on 22 January 2020, the Defendants had an agenda to remove the Claimant as chairman and that the statements were made in support of such goal.
- [87]
[87] The First Defendant admitted that he was not able to ascertain whether the Claimant had approached Cassandra before speaking to the technician Sim and that it was not clear at the time of the meeting on 22 January 2020 who had approached who first . The First Defendant admitted that he did not know whether the Claimant met with the technicians before or after speaking with Cassandra yet he went ahead to make statements about the Claimant circumventing the authority of the managing agent at the meeting on 22 January 2020 and approved the publication of the statements in the 6 February 2020 minutes. Given that it would have been easy for him to verify the facts with Cassandra before making the statements, the First Defendant was clearly reckless as to the truth of his statements, in light of his intention to remove the Claimant as chairman of the MC.
- [88]
[88] Similarly, the Second Defendant was well aware that the condominium technicians frequently help residents with their personal property as at 22 January 2020, given that she had asked Sim to help her to drill four holes into the wall to insert a shelf for her on 26 December 2018 at 4:42 p.m. and Sim had proceeded to help her on 27 December 2018 at around 9:50 a.m. At the 22 January 2020 meeting, Sharada had also conceded that she had previously approached the technician to help and the technician obliged. The Second Defendant conceded that it was unclear from Cassandra during the meeting whether the technician had been aware of the damage before she spoke with him . Given that the Second Defendant was gathering information on the damaged tabletop ahead of the meeting, whether the Claimant had bypassed Cassandra to talk to the technicians was an issue which she could have easily clarified. The failure to do so indicates that she was reckless as to the truth of the statement in her desire to make out wrongdoing on the part of the Claimant.
- [91]
[91] In the circumstances, I find that the Claimant had made out malice on the part of the Defendants and that the defence of qualified privilege is defeated.
Whether the defence of justification is made out in respect of the secret meeting statements
- [92]
[92] The First Defendant argued that the statements were justified as the Claimant had held a private meeting with the MA in which his wife was present. The Claimant failed to inform the council of the meeting and failed to adequately explain why his wife, who did not hold any position in the MC, was involved in the meeting. The Claimant had only informed the council members about the meeting after the meeting was conducted and when asked why his wife was at the meeting, testified that he valued her input and her presence ensured a proper handover . The First Defendant argued that the Claimant’s wife should not have been there in the first place, given that the meeting was to discuss the important issue of the staffing of the MA.
- [93]
[93] The Second Defendant argued that the statements were justified as the Claimant had held a private meeting with the MA to discuss estate matters without notifying the rest of the council in advance. The meeting included his wife, Sim Nyet Moi, who was not a council member and whose involvement was neither disclosed to the council beforehand nor subsequently explained in terms of her capacity or role. While David Wong, a council member was invited to the meeting at the last minute, the other council members were not informed of the meeting in advance and the Claimant only provided an update to the MC seven days after the meeting had taken place. Significant issues such as staffing and turnover within the MA’s team at HV had been discussed, yet the Claimant failed to update the council on these issues at the council meeting on 19 September 2019. When questioned about the meeting, the Claimant was unable to provide a satisfactory explanation as to why council procedures had not been followed, why the other council members had been excluded or why his wife was present. Hence, the Claimant’s failure to disclose or explain these meetings and the lack of transparency in handling matters of such significance were accurately reflected in the statement complained of.
- [94]
[94] According to the Claimant , the meeting on 17 September 2019 with Desmond was a follow up on Desmond’s request to meet up after the 17th MC took over in August 2019. He had asked Grace to arrange the meeting because he wanted to discuss with Desmond, the boss of Smart Property, about the turnover issues at HV and about whether Cassandra was a suitable candidate. He agreed for his wife, Sim Nyet Moi (“Nyet”), to join the meeting because Nyet was the immediate past chairperson of the MC and knew about the frequent turnover of the MA staff. She also knew Desmond. He thought that her experience and views would be quite valuable in discussing the turnover issue. He had also asked David Wong, an existing MC member, to join the meeting in a last minute decision, as he thought that it would be good to have another member of the MC present, in case there were any issues. As it was just an informal meeting, he did not think there would be any issues but on hindsight, he was glad that he invited David Wong to join because it showed that he was not trying to go behind the backs of the MC members to make a decision on his own.
- [95]
[95] According to the Claimant , it was Desmond who brought up the staffing or turnover issue at the meeting. Desmond stated that Sebastian and Alison had both indicated that they wanted to leave. While Alison had by that time withdrawn her request to leave, she said she would only be willing to stay until the start of 2020. Hence Desmond said that it would be better to get a fresh and stable team for HV. Desmond said that he would check with his human resources team and get back to the MC on some proposed names for the new team, which would likely include Cassandra, whom the MC had already interviewed. However, Desmond said that he had yet to confirm that Cassandra could be released from her existing condominium (where she was working at the time).
- [96]
[96] The Claimant did not update the MC then because it was only a preliminary meeting and nothing was finalised. He was waiting for Desmond to come back to the MC with some names. David, who was present at the meeting, did not suggest that they update the MC .
- [97]
[97] Slightly a week later, on 25 September 2019, Desmond suggested that Cassandra take over from Sebastian from 30 September 2019 and that there would be a new property officer who would take over from Alison at the end of October 2019, with a one-month period to allow for transition. Desmond himself would take over the overseeing role from Grace, although Grace would still continue to work as part of the MA team. Hence, the Claimant updated the MC on 25 September 2019 at 8:45 p.m. in the WhatsApp group chat between MC members (excluding the MA) .
- [98]
[98] It was clear from the messages in the WhatsApp group chat that in response to the Second Defendant’s question of whether all the council members were consulted before the change in MA personnel, the Claimant had explained on 26 September 2019 that David had joined him in meeting with Desmond and that Nyet had also joined him for that meeting as she would have better feedback for Desmond but Desmond provided his own feedback before they did so. In response to the First Defendant’s questions about why other council members were not made aware of the meeting with Desmond and why Nyet was even present, the Claimant had explained that it was not a formal meeting; just an exploratory one to determine the best way forward and that nothing was firmed up until 25 September 2019 when Desmond confirmed the arrangements. In addition, Nyet had asked for permission to join, similar to when he had asked to come for formal and informal meetings. The Claimant also offered to explain to all the council members in person that Alison could no longer remain and they proceeded to make arrangements for a meeting.
- [99]
[99] Based on the transcript of the 22 January 2020 meeting, David Wong had stated that three things were discussed at the meeting between the Claimant, Nyet, Desmond and him. The first was micromanagement; the second was the need for Alison to leave HV as soon as possible and the third was the relationship between Cassandra and Alison. Desmond stated that the meeting was largely to address the staffing issue. Desmond had also explained that he was the one who raised the issue of removing Alison as he already knew that Allison had plans to move on after her exams. If he wanted to build a new team, he would want everyone in HV to have a long term interest in HV. The Claimant had also explained that Nyet wanted to address some of the things that Desmond may have said as to her being too micromanaging but Desmond was the one who initiated the conversation about taking Alison out of the estate but it was not firm or finalised and that Desmond wanted a fresh team at HV. However, Desmond needed to seek her release, get a new property officer as well as hire an associate director in order to replace the whole team. Post meeting, the Claimant had left it at that as nothing was firm until it was finalised. Desmond clarified that he was the one who wanted a stable team and wanted to rebuild the team. Alison did not have a long term interest so he wanted to bring her back to office. As there will be time needed for handover, he did not commit to any timing at the meeting.
- [100]
[100] It was therefore clear that the meeting the Claimant had with Desmond was not a secret meeting but an informal one, as the Claimant had explained to the council members over WhatsApp on 26 September 2019. While the Claimant did not inform the other council members about his meeting with Desmond prior to the meeting, the Claimant had no intention of hiding this from his fellow council members, given that he had invited David Wong, another council member, to attend the meeting. The Claimant had informed the other council members about the meeting when asked about the change in the managing agent personnel to be deployed at HV on 26 September 2019 and also volunteered the information that his wife had attended the meeting and explained her purpose for doing so. While they had discussed staffing issues at HV during the meeting, it was clear from both the Claimant’s evidence and Desmond’s statements at the 22 January 2020 meeting as recorded in the transcript, that Desmond was the one who initiated the changes in personnel and that nothing had been finalised at the informal meeting. Correspondingly, there was nothing secret about the meeting and there was no lack of openness and transparency by the Claimant as chairman as alleged by the Defendants. The Claimant had explained to the MC over WhatsApp on 26 September 2019 that his wife had joined him for the meeting as she would have better feedback for Desmond and had asked to join him. Given that his wife was the chairman of the predecessor MC, the fact that the Claimant had allowed her to join what was an informal meeting with the managing agent was not anything out of the ordinary and the explanation of her presence was acceptable. There was therefore no lack of openness and transparency on the Claimant’s part as chairman.
- [101]
[101] In the circumstances, I find that the Defendants had failed to make out a case of the Claimant abusing his authority as chairman in this instance. The defence of justification is not made out.
Whether the defence of qualified privilege is made out in respect of the secret meeting statements
- [102]
[102] The First Defendant claimed that it was improper for the Claimant to have met with the MA privately to discuss about the running of HV and personnel issues as the Claimant did not inform the MC beforehand about the meeting and did not make clear to the MC members what had transpired until the meeting on 22 January 2020 when David Wong stated the items discussed .
- [103]
[103] However, the Claimant had updated the MC about the change in MA personnel on 25 September 2019, after Desmond confirmed the personnel changes on the same day and had also informed the MC on 26 September 2019 about the meeting which had also involved David Wong and his wife . The Defendants were therefore well aware on 26 September 2019 that the meeting was an informal exploratory one, no decisions had been made until Desmond confirmed the changes on 25 September 2019 and the reasons for the Claimant’s wife joining them. The Claimant had also offered to explain in person to everyone in the council why Alison could not remain. In fact, the Claimant had asked the First Defendant to set up the meeting when he is back in Singapore but the First Defendant told them to arrange for the meeting without him. Based on the WhatsApp messages, on 5 October 2019, the Claimant had also offered his place for the MC to meet for updates and issues to be ironed out but the Defendants turned him down and suggested that they discuss matters at the next council meeting on 30 October 2019 instead . There was therefore no basis for the First Defendant to allege that there was a lack of openness and transparency. As indicated in the WhatsApp group chat of the smaller group and conceded by the First Defendant on the stand , the Defendants, Krishna and David also met with Desmond of the MA prior to the creation of their smaller WhatsApp group to discuss issues concerning the management of HV without informing the rest of the MC. The First Defendant therefore had no basis for alleging that the Claimant’s conduct in meeting with the MA privately was improper and that he had something to hide by failing to be open and transparent. I therefore conclude that he had made the statements recklessly and that malice is made out, defeating the defence of qualified privilege.
- [104]
[104] The Second Defendant was aware of the meeting as of 25 September 2019 and accepted that the Claimant did not intend for the meeting to be a secret meeting or keep the meeting secret from the rest of the MC, given that he was accompanied by David Wong, one of the council members . The Second Defendant accepted that the MA was the one who makes the decision on which individual to employ as part of the MA team in a condominium . Hence, no decisions were made by the Claimant at the meeting . The Defendants had also met with Desmond on 4 January 2020 without all the other MC members but nevertheless allege impropriety only on the part of the Claimant . While the Second Defendant argued that the difference lies in the presence of Nyet, the Second Defendant did not explain why the presence of the ex-chairman of the MCST was so objectionable and why the Claimant’s meeting with Desmond, together with David would warrant his removal as chairman. In fact, the Second Defendant had said at the 22 January 2020 meeting that they had the opportunity to ask the Claimant during the council meeting in October 2019 as to what actually happened and the Claimant had explained that his wife wanted to address micromanagement . The Second Defendant was therefore well aware that the Claimant had been transparent in explaining to them what had actually transpired and had explained the reason for his wife’s presence. In the circumstances, I find that in their desire to build a case for the Claimant’s removal from office, the Second Defendant had recklessly characterised the meeting as secretly arranged and the Claimant’s conduct as lacking in transparency when the Claimant had already explained the circumstances of the meeting, including the reason for the wife’s presence and offered to explain more in person, which offer was initially turned down but which was subsequently left to be taken up at the October council meeting. The defence of qualified privilege is therefore defeated by malice.
2nd Set of Defamatory Words
- [105]
[105] On 30 September 2020, the First Defendant sent an email titled “Building Maintenance and Strata Management Act (Sec 60 & Sec 61)” to one Lim Chong Yong, Director at BCA, which email was copied to the Second Defendant and Ronie Ganguly (the “Email”) as well as blind copied to Krishna and David Wong . In the Email, the First Defendant stated that the Claimant had booked a barbeque pit for a private function during which a tabletop was damaged.
- [106]
[106] The First Defendant then proceeded to inform the BCA that the Claimant was removed as chairman by a majority vote on 22 January 2020. The First Defendant stated their firm belief that the Claimant had contravened section 60 and 61 of the BMSMA and asked for BCA’s advice as to whether any actions can be taken against the Claimant.
Whether the Second Defendant had published the 2nd Set of Defamatory Words
- [107]
[107] The First Defendant could not recall if the Second Defendant was involved in the drafting of the email to BCA on 30 September 2020 . The First Defendant’s evidence was that he had sent the Email in his capacity as the then chairman of the MC as it was his duty to seek the clarification or opinion of BCA as there were grounds to believe that the Claimant was in breach of the statutory provisions as well as the HV’s House Rules No. 8 (Occupancy) . While the First Defendant agreed on the stand that he had signed off in his capacity as chairman and the Email was sent on behalf of the whole MC , his evidence was that he did not consult the MC before sending the Email and did not copy the entire MC on the Email . However, no one expressed surprise to him upon receiving his Email .
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.