Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 9 Jun 2026
Contents

District Court

Nirmala d/o Thangavellu v Acestes Pte. Ltd.

Feedback & support

[2026] SGDC 195Case no. [2026] SGDC 1953 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [3] One might also doubt the Claimant’s alleged impecuniosity on the face of things. She has been able to pay her own disbursements for court filing fees and transcription fees of around $1,400. She can afford to instruct a quad of senior lawyers (namely, Mr Dube Vinod Kumar (called in 1979), Mr R Kalamohan (called in 1983), Ms Mary Magdeline Pereira (called in 2002), and Ms Shanthi Elavarasi d/o R Kalamohan (called in 2011)) from two different firms to collaborate and work on her claim since May 2022, at the latest. Throughout their labours, her lawyers have not filed an application to discharge themselves on the ground of non-payment of fees. There is also, at present, no allegation from the Claimant that she had taken the “bait” of entering into a contingency fee arrangement with her lawyers — a transaction prohibited in Singapore under s 107(1)(b) and s 107(3) of the Legal Profession Act 1966 — that frees her from paying their legal fees out of her own pocket: Law Society of Singapore v Lau See Jin Jeffrey [2017] 4 SLR 148 at [30(c)]. I now address the Defendant’s position.

  2. [8] The Defendant also claims disbursements of $1,327.70, particularised in a list, which I agree is a reasonable amount.

  3. These allegations were not even wrong since they concerned a different client.

  4. [11] It is more appropriate for the Claimant to consider whether her lawyers have fulfilled their duties set out by the High Court in Mookan Sadaiyakumar v Kim Hock Corp Pte Ltd and another appeal [2020] 4 SLR 555 at [49], since only she would know the instructions she gave and the advice she received, and thereafter to proceed as she thinks fit.