High Court · Decided 12 February 2019
Public Prosecutor v Leow Ban Leong and another and another appeal
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC 29 · Case no. Magistrate’s Appeal No 9066 and 9067 of 2018/01 · 11 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The first respondent in Magistrate’s Appeal (“MA”) 9066 and 9067 of 2018/01 and the first appellant in MA 9066 and 9067 of 2018/02, Leow Ban Leong (“Leow”), is the chief executive officer of Prelim Construction Pte Ltd (“Prelim”) and a director cum shareholder of Advance Facilities Pte Ltd (“Advance”). These are related companies. Prelim and Advance are two of many companies within the “Master” group of companies, which are controlled by Leow. The second respondent in Magistrate’s Appeal (“MA”) 9066 and 9067 of 2018/01 and the second appellant in MA 9066 and 9067 of 2018/02 , Foo Fang Liong (“Foo”) is a senior manager at both Prelim and Advance. Given that this ex tempore judgment deals with Leow and Foo’s appeals against their conviction, I will, for convenience, refer to them collectively as “the appellants”. The appellants each faced three charges under s 477A read with s 109 of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed), for engaging in a conspiracy to falsify company documents. After a joint trial, they were both convicted on all three charges. Leow was fined a total of $90,000 ($30,000 fine per charge), while Foo was fined a total of $45,000 ($15,000 fine per charge). Leow and Foo subsequently filed appeals against their conviction, while the Prosecution filed cross-appeals against the sentences imposed.
Appeals against conviction
- [4]
[4] According to the appellants, it was one Benson Tan (“Benson”), an agent of PCG, who initially prepared a quotation dated 12 February 2010 (“Quotation”) using Prelim’s letterhead without first seeking the authorisation of Prelim. The price quoted was $2,500 plus 5% per buoy in this Quotation. After PCG approved the purchase based on the price stated in the Quotation, Benson informed Prelim to proceed based on the Quotation.
- [5]
[5] Prelim then negotiated with its supplier of the buoys, Wealth Marine Pte Ltd (“Wealth Marine”) and managed to negotiate the price of the buoys down to $1,500 per buoy. Thereafter, Prelim agreed to perform the contract based on the Quotation drawn up by Benson. Prelim accordingly charged PCG $2,500 plus 5% per buoy.
- [6]
[6] Taking Prelim’s case at the highest, it is clear that by agreeing subsequently to perform the contract in accordance with the terms stated in the Quotation, albeit prepared initially by Benson, Prelim had in fact ratified what Benson had done, adopted the Quotation on its letterhead as its own and therefore confirmed that the contract with PCG would be performed in accordance with that Quotation.
- [9]
[9] I note the appellants’ argument that the Prosecution’s case theory, ie, that the appellants had committed the offence to protect their reputation, was never put to Leow or Foo during cross-examination. However, Leow had stated several times that the MHA was a long-time client for whom Prelim would go the extra mile, and that since Prelim had committed to PCG it had to maintain its reputation. Hence, the court is entitled to draw the necessary inferences based on the evidence before it.
- [10]
[10] It is undisputed that the actual supplier of the buoys was Wealth Marine. Indeed, Prelim had initially submitted a Form D9 to the AGO which declared Wealth Marine as the supplier of the buoys. However, Leow and Foo deliberately suppressed the invoice from Wealth Marine which would have clearly showed that Prelim had purchased the buoys for only $1,500 each. Instead, Leow and Foo fabricated and submitted an invoice, claim form and Form D9 (collectively, the “offending documents”) which falsely specified Advance as the supplier of the buoys.
- [11]
[11] The appellants’ case is that they had created the offending documents to satisfy Benson’s incessant requests for supporting documents to show that the buoys were purchased by Prelim for $2,500 each, which was false. However, the appellants submit that their intention was never to deceive the AGO, which is why they made sure to indicate on the Advance invoice that the price per unit of the buoys remains at $1,500.
- [13]
[13] Accordingly, I agree with the trial judge that this extended warranty was entirely fictitious, and was merely meant to justify the additional $1,000 that Prelim had charged PCG for each of the buoys. The trial judge found that there was no evidence to show that Prelim and PCG had ever discussed the issue of an extended warranty. In this regard, the trial judge was right to reject the Defence’s contention that Advance had genuinely intended to provide Prelim with an extended three-year warranty.
- [14]
[14] Apparently, Prelim paid its related company Advance $136,500 for 91 buoys at $1,500 per buoy and also $91,000 for the additional services which included the extended three-year warranty for the 91 buoys at $1,000 per buoy. The question is whether this is real or yet another fictitious transaction to lend support to the price of $2,500 plus 5% per buoy Prelim had charged PCG. I find it puzzling why Prelim would have wanted to make double payment for the buoys ie, once to Wealth Marine and once to Advance. Indeed, Leow accepted that it made no commercial sense for Prelim to have done so. I infer that the payment of $136,500 (based on 91 buoys at $1,500 per buoy) and $91,000 (for additional services) by Prelim to its related company Advance was intended to create some evidence of a payment trail to support the false fact stated in the fictitious invoice from Advance of having purportedly supplied the 91 buoys to Prelim for $1,500 per buoy when in fact it did not. This shows the devious methods and extent to which the appellants were trying to mask their misdeeds from the AGO and prevent discovery.
- [15]
[15] I also do not consider it necessary to find whether the false documents were prepared on the instructions of Benson or otherwise. I agree with the trial judge that even if Benson had instructed Leow and Foo to create the false documents, they would still be liable for the abetment of the offence.
- [17]
[17] I will now hear the submissions of the parties on sentence.