High Court · Decided 18 June 2020
Alternative Advisors Investments Pte Ltd and another v Asidokona Mining Resources Pte Ltd and another
Feedback & support[2020] SGHC 125 · Case no. Suit No 734 of 2018 · 2 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] In this suit, the plaintiffs allege that the second plaintiff lent the first defendant S$2m under a loan agreement dated 22 July 2016 (“Alleged Loan Agreement”). According to the first plaintiff, one Mr Wong Joo Wan executed the Alleged Loan Agreement on the second plaintiff’s behalf. Mr Wong describes himself as the managing director of the first plaintiff and the principal of the second plaintiff. The second defendant is the sole shareholder and director of the first defendant. He is alleged to have stood as the first defendant’s guarantor in the Alleged Loan Agreement under a personal guarantee (“Alleged Guarantee”), and executed a deed charging all his shares in the first defendant in favour of the second plaintiff (“Alleged Deed of Charge”). The second plaintiff tried to assign the Alleged Loan Agreement, Guarantee and Deed of Charge to the first plaintiff. The first plaintiff commenced this suit against the defendants to recover the outstanding principal under the Alleged Loan Agreement, plus interest, and the delivery up of the second defendant’s shares in the first defendant. As it is disputed whether the attempted assignment was effective, the first plaintiff joined the second plaintiff to this action.
- [8]
[8] Turning to the present appeal, the direction that either the solicitor must confirm that his witness’ affidavit binds one or more parties, or another witness must file an affidavit confirming that she and a party to the proceedings are bound by the affidavits of a different witness, is unusual. First of all, every affidavit ought to state on whose behalf the affidavit was sworn or affirmed. It usually begins by stating “I make this affidavit on behalf of …” Where such a statement is omitted so that it is necessary to establish on whose behalf a witness’ affidavit was made, that witness should be the person directed to swear a supplementary affidavit or refile the original affidavit with the necessary amendment. Every person will be bound by the affidavits he makes. If the affidavit was made on behalf of another person without authority, that other person must swear an affidavit disclaiming it. To that end, all that is required is to ensure that all such other persons had been served with the affidavit in question. Solicitors are best advised to refrain from swearing affidavits of facts on behalf of their clients.