Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 19 Jul 2022
Contents

General Division of the High Court

Tiong Sze Yin Serene v Chan Herng Nieng

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHC 170Case no. Suit No 400 of 2020

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The defendant, Dr Chan Herng Nieng (“Dr Chan”), is a psychiatrist with his own psychiatry practice at Capital Mindhealth Clinic. He has been practising medicine for more than 17 years.

  3. [2] The plaintiff, Ms Serene Tiong Sze Yin (“Ms Tiong”), is a Senior Business Development Manager in Precious Medical Centre. She met Dr Chan at a social event in or around 21 December 2016. They soon started an intimate relationship in early January 2017. At or around the end of April 2018, the relationship took a dramatic turn for the worse after Ms Tiong discovered WhatsApp messages in Dr Chan’s mobile phone which revealed that he had been unfaithful. The relationship rapidly went south and Dr Chan decided to end the relationship at the end of May 2018.

  4. [3] From the time they first met in December 2016 to the end of their relationship in May 2018, Dr Chan was a senior consultant psychiatrist at the Department of Psychiatry of the Singapore General Hospital (“SGH”).

  5. [4] This case is, at its core, a lover’s spat. After the relationship of Ms Tiong and Dr Chan came to an end, the actions taken by Ms Tiong resulted in, among others, police investigations against her for attempted extortion. Ms Tiong also complained to the Singapore Medical Council (“SMC”) against Dr Chan and his good friend, Dr Julian Ong Kian Peng (“Dr Ong”). Dr Ong, in turn, sued Ms Tiong for defamation. When Dr Chan spurned Ms Tiong’s love she started a campaign of revenge against Dr Chan and Dr Ong as she concluded that they treated women like sex trophies.

  6. [5] Ms Tiong claims that when she and Dr Chan were in a relationship, Dr Chan acted in breach of his duty of care to her as his de facto patient when he gave her Xanax, an addictive drug, which was classified as poison under the Poisons Act (Cap 234, 1999 Rev Ed) (“the Poisons Act”). Ms Tiong claims that she suffered side effects from consuming Xanax and became addicted to Xanax.

  7. [6] Ms Tiong claims a further and/or alternative cause of action under the rule in Wilkinson v Downton [1897] 2 QB 57 (“Wilkinson”) for the psychiatric harm Dr Chan allegedly caused to her. She alleges that Dr Chan had told her that he was committed to a long-term and exclusive sexual relationship with her. Subsequently, Ms Tiong suffered a mental and emotional breakdown when she discovered that Dr Chan was having sexual relations with other married women during their relationship.

  8. Background to the dispute

  9. The relationship between Ms Tiong and Dr Chan

  10. [7] Ms Tiong and Dr Chan first met at a social event on or around 21 December 2016. She was then still married to one Mr Jeremy Ho Wei Chun (“Mr Ho”). However, the marriage was already on the rocks as Ms Tiong had engaged in an extra-marital affair with one Mr Chris Koh (“Mr Koh”) before she met Dr Chan. The affair with Mr Koh ended in 2016. Nevertheless, Ms Tiong filed for divorce against Mr Ho sometime in February 2017. The divorce was finalised on 20 November 2017.

  11. [8] Dr Chan, on the other hand, was not married and he is a bachelor.

  12. [9] After the first meeting in December 2016, Ms Tiong and Dr Chan started an intimate relationship in or around January 2017. The relationship was generally smooth from January 2017 until April 2018. They would regularly spend time together and engage in physical intimacy.

  13. [10] From 7 April 2018 to 25 April 2018, Ms Tiong and Dr Chan went on a trip to Eastern Europe (“the Eastern Europe Trip”). On or around the night of 22 April 2018, while Dr Chan was asleep, Ms Tiong unlocked Dr Chan’s mobile phone using his thumbprint. Ms Tiong then accessed Dr Chan’s WhatsApp conversations with his close friend, Dr Ong, a colorectal surgeon who operates Julian Ong Endoscopy & Surgery Pte Ltd (“JOES”). The conversations contained sordid details which strongly suggested that Dr Chan and Dr Ong were leading highly promiscuous lifestyles by having sexual intercourse with other married women, sometimes in groups (“the Whatsapp Messages”):

  14. [11] Aggrieved that Dr Chan was physically intimate with other women, Ms Tiong took screenshots of the Whatsapp Messages (“the Screenshots”) and confronted Dr Chan with the Screenshots.

  15. [12] On 25 April 2018, after Ms Tiong and Dr Chan returned from the Eastern Europe Trip, their relationship began to break down irretrievably. Although Ms Tiong intended to continue with her relationship with Dr Chan with a view to marrying him, Dr Chan was not keen to continue with the relationship. When it was clear to Ms Tiong that Dr Chan wanted to end the relationship, she took matters into her own hands to seek revenge on Dr Chan. Between 29 May 2018 and June 2018, Ms Tiong demanded from Dr Chan a Cartier watch and $10,000, which was later increased to $150,000. She also sent the Screenshots to Dr Chan’s family members. Subsequently, Dr Chan made a police report against Ms Tiong for extortion. He stopped responding to Ms Tiong on or around 31 May 2018. This marked the end of Ms Tiong and Dr Chan’s relationship.

  16. [13] On 15 January 2020, the Singapore Police Force (“SPF”) issued Ms Tiong a written warning in lieu of prosecution for the offence of attempted extortion under s 385 of the Penal Code (Cap 224, 2008 Rev Ed) (“the Penal Code”).

  17. Dr Chan gave Ms Tiong Xanax tablets

  18. [14] During their relationship, Dr Chan gave Ms Tiong Xanax tablets to help her cope with her anxiety. Xanax, also known as Alprazolam, is listed as a poisonous substance under the Schedule to the Poisons Act. Dr Chan did not register Ms Tiong as his patient at the time he provided her Xanax.

  19. [15] By virtue of his profession, Dr Chan was in a position to procure Xanax from the SGH. Upon Dr Chan’s request, his colleague, Associate Professor Lee Tih Shih, prescribed him Xanax. Dr Chan then gave Xanax to Ms Tiong without registering Ms Tiong as his patient of SGH.

  20. Background history

  21. [16] While the following background developments relating to Ms Tiong and Dr Chan’s history are strictly speaking not material to the case at hand, they are relevant to understand the context of the parties’ relationship. Thus, I shall briefly narrate the background history of the parties’ disputes which came about after Dr Chan ended the relationship with Ms Tiong.

  22. The Singapore Medical Council complaint

  23. [17] On 18 June 2018, Ms Tiong lodged a complaint against Dr Chan to the Disciplinary Tribunal of the SMC. In the complaint, Ms Tiong stated that Dr Chan had failed to highlight the side effects of Xanax and even increased the dosage of Xanax when she raised concerns (“the SMC Complaint”).

  24. [18] Between 19 and 23 June 2018, Ms Tiong sent emails attaching the SMC Complaint to several of Dr Chan’s colleagues, claiming, inter alia, that Dr Chan and Dr Ong were colluding “to take advantage of other vulnerable woman patients” (“the Defamatory Emails”) (see Ong Kian Peng Julian v Serene Tiong Sze Yin [2020] SGDC 94 (“the Defamation Suit”) at [4(a)]).

  25. [19] In February 2022, the SMC notified Ms Tiong that it was suspending Dr Chan for five months. Dr Chan has lodged an appeal against the decision.

  26. The Defamation Suit

  27. [20] Dr Ong brought a claim in libel against Ms Tiong for disseminating the Defamatory Emails to others. In the Defamation Suit, the district judge (“DJ”) dismissed Dr Ong’s claim in libel on the basis that Ms Tiong had successfully proven the defence of justification. The DJ’s ruling was overturned on appeal. In Ong Kian Peng Julian v Tiong Sze Yin Serene [2021] 3 SLR 980 (“the Defamation Appeal”), See Kee Oon J found at [85] that Ms Tiong failed in her defence of justification. There was insufficient evidence that Dr Chan capitalised on his trusted position as a doctor to target Ms Tiong, as Ms Tiong was in an existing intimate relationship with Dr Chan which developed well before she became Dr Chan’s de facto patient (the Defamation Appeal at [54]).

  28. The Derivative Action Suit

  29. [21] On 25 September 2019, Ms Tiong bought the minimum traded lot of 100 shares in HC Surgical Specialists Ltd (“the Company”), a company seeking to acquire 19% of the shares in JOES (Dr Ong’s company), with a view to attending the Company’s annual general meeting to convey her concerns about its acquisition of the 19% stake in JOES. On 27 May 2020, Ms Tiong commenced a statutory derivative action under s 216A(2) of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) seeking leave to bring an action in the name of the Company against its chief executive officer (“CEO”), alleging that the CEO had breached his director’s duties in connection with the Company’s acquisition of the 19% stake in JOES.

  30. [22] In Tiong Sze Yin Serene v HC Surgical Specialists Ltd and another [2020] SGHC 201 (“the Derivative Action Suit”), Chua Lee Ming J dismissed the application. Chua J found, inter alia, that Ms Tiong had failed to discharge her burden of proof that she was acting in good faith. Chua J also observed that she was “so motivated by vendetta, perceived or oral, that [her] judgment will be clouded by purely personal considerations” (the Derivative Action Suit at [76]).

  31. [23] In Civil Appeal No 129 of 2020 (“CA 129”), the Court of Appeal upheld Chua J’s decision to dismiss Ms Tiong’s claim, finding that Ms Tiong’s claim was “wholly unmeritorious”.

  32. The parties’ cases

  33. Ms Tiong’s case

  34. Medical negligence

  35. [24] Ms Tiong’s primary claim is that Dr Chan, as her de facto doctor, owed her a duty of care to ensure that she would not be addicted to Xanax. Dr Chan breached his duty of care when he freely gave Xanax to Ms Tiong without (a) ascertaining the suitability of Xanax for her; and (b) ensuring that she would not become addicted to Xanax. Ms Tiong argues that Dr Chan supplied Xanax and Trazodone, which is also listed in the Schedule to the Poisons Act, to her in a “free and easy manner” for “recreational, rather than prescriptive, use”, as he failed to first assess that Ms Tiong was indeed suffering from Generalised Anxiety Disorder (“GAD”) before prescribing the drugs. He also failed to caution her against drug dependency and to keep clinical notes. The fact that she and Dr Chan were in an intimate relationship during the material time made her a vulnerable patient, as she believed that Dr Chan would be attentive to her medical needs.

  36. [25] According to Ms Tiong, Dr Chan gave her one strip of Xanax tablets (ie, ten tablets of Xanax) per month from February 2017 to March 2018 and approximately 100 tablets of Xanax per month for April and May 2018. However, I must highlight that during the trial, Ms Tiong resiled from this pleaded position on the number of Xanax tablets that Dr Chan gave to her. The exact number of Xanax tablets Dr Chan gave to Ms Tiong is one of the key factual issues of the trial and I shall consider it in full at [93]–[108] below.

  37. [26] Ms Tiong also argues that Dr Chan neglected and completely abandoned his continuing duty of care to treat her medical condition when he ended their personal relationship at or around the end of May 2018. Dr Chan should have registered her as a patient of another psychiatrist if he wished to have sexual relations with her.

  38. [27] As a result of Dr Chan’s breach of his duty of care, Ms Tiong suffered damage in that she became addicted to Xanax and suffered “side effects of the high dosages of drugs given to [her] by Dr Chan”. These side effects include, in the short term, drowsiness, confusion and slurred speech, and in the long term, cognitive difficulties and aggression. Her increased aggression is evident from the manner in which Ms Tiong confronted Dr Chan at his clinic in front of his staff and patients on 13 June 2018.

  39. The rule in Wilkinson

  40. [28] Ms Tiong’s alternative cause of action is based on the rule in Wilkinson. Ms Tiong argues that Dr Chan induced her to enter into and/or continue with their relationship by intentionally informing her that “he was committed to having a long-term and exclusive sexual relationship with her” (“the Statement”). Dr Chan made the Statement sometime around February 2017 and repeated the Statement on numerous occasions. By virtue of the Statement, Ms Tiong entered into an intimate relationship with Dr Chan. To support her claim that Dr Chan made the Statement, Ms Tiong relies on WhatsApp text messages exchanged between her and Dr Chan in November 2017, some nine months after Dr Chan made the Statement, where Dr Chan repeatedly threatened to end his relationship with Ms Tiong as she had violated his trust that they were seeing and having sexual relations exclusively with each other. They only patched up their relationship when Ms Tiong promised to cut off any further contact with her “exes”, namely Mr Ho and Mr Koh. I pause to note that Ms Tiong has not specified the exact Whatsapp message(s) she relies on as supporting evidence to suggest that Dr Chan made the Statement.

  41. (1) The falsity of the Statement

  42. [29] Ms Tiong avers that Dr Chan knew that the Statement was false based on the following grounds. First, the WhatsApp Messages between Dr Chan and Dr Ong show that Dr Chan was in fact having sexual relations with multiple women while he was in a relationship with Ms Tiong. Therefore, he knew that the Statement was false when he made it. Second, during the Defamation Suit, Dr Chan admitted that he had sexual intercourse with another woman, E, while he was still in a relationship with Ms Tiong (the Defamation Suit at [20(c)]). Dr Chan also admitted during cross-examination that (a) Dr Ong had asked him for someone to bring to a sex party; and (b) Dr Ong had suggested that Dr Chan invite Ms Tiong to engage in a foursome with them.

  43. [30] Ms Tiong argues that Dr Chan had no justification or reasonable excuse for making the Statement knowing it was false. In other words, Dr Chan actually had no intention to be in an exclusive relationship with Ms Tiong or consider marriage with her. Ms Tiong avers that Dr Chan’s sole motive in making the Statement was to induce her to have sexual relations with him. Subsequently, she was induced into sexual intimacy with Dr Chan by the promise of a long-term exclusive relationship.

  44. (2) Ms Tiong’s psychiatric harm

  45. [31] Ms Tiong discovered that the Statement was false when she read the WhatsApp Messages on or around the night of 22 April 2018. As a result of the discovery, Ms Tiong suffered adjustment disorder with anxiety.

  46. (3) Dr Chan intended to cause Ms Tiong psychiatric harm

  47. [32] Ms Tiong argues that Dr Chan intended to cause her psychiatric harm by making the Statement which he knew to be false. Ms Tiong points to the following facts:

  48. (a) When Dr Chan made the Statement, Dr Chan knew that Ms Tiong was experiencing turmoil in her marriage;

  49. (b) Dr Chan was well aware that Ms Tiong was suffering from anxiety;

  50. (c) Dr Chan and Ms Tiong were in a de facto doctor-patient relationship; and

  51. (d) Therefore, Dr Chan was well aware that Ms Tiong was in a vulnerable state and any further mental or emotional distress would cause her psychiatric harm.

  52. Dr Chan’s case

  53. Medical negligence

  54. [33] Dr Chan does not dispute that as a medical professional, he owed a duty of care to Ms Tiong to ensure that Xanax provided was appropriate for her consumption and would not cause her harm. However, Dr Chan argues that he did not breach his duty of care to (a) ascertain the suitability of Xanax for her; or (b) ensure that she would not be addicted to Xanax. Dr Chan argues that Xanax was indeed suitable for Ms Tiong’s consumption, based on, inter alia, the following:

  55. (a) Ms Tiong was prescribed Xanax by subsequent psychiatrists that she consulted after the fallout of her relationship with Dr Chan sometime end of May 2018. It is incredible that Ms Tiong would continue to be prescribed Xanax by different psychiatrists or that she would continue to procure Xanax from different psychiatrists if she suffered side effects from consuming Xanax.

  56. (b) The contemporaneous communications exchanged between Ms Tiong and Dr Chan do not support Ms Tiong’s assertion that she suffered side effects from her consumption of Xanax.

  57. [34] Dr Chan claims that in or around the second week of May 2018, Ms Tiong told him that she was experiencing bouts of anxiety and verbally requested that he gave Xanax to her. He alleges that Ms Tiong observed that he had taken Xanax to help him rest during the Eastern Europe Trip. He first provided her with one tablet of Xanax. When Ms Tiong found Xanax to be good and there were no side effects, Dr Chan gave her another 13 tablets of Xanax for short-term use. Dr Chan denied giving Ms Tiong the large quantity of Xanax as alleged by her. Furthermore, Dr Chan asserts that the large quantity of Xanax Ms Tiong alleged Dr Chan had provided to her significantly exceeds the quantity of Xanax procured by Dr Chan from SGH, as evinced by the SGH’s prescriptions of Xanax for Dr Chan.

  58. [35] In any case, even on Ms Tiong’s account of the quantity of Xanax provided to her, there is no evidence that the quantity of Xanax is inappropriate. This is because any associated risk of dependency from the quantity of Xanax she alleged was provided to her is low. In fact, Ms Tiong was prescribed an even larger quantity of Xanax than what she claims Dr Chan had given her over a shorter period of time by one Dr Lee Kae Meng Thomas (“Dr Thomas Lee”), a psychiatrist from Resilienz Clinic Pte Ltd (“Resilienz Clinic”) she consulted after her relationship with Dr Chan had ended.

  59. [36] Dr Chan denies that Ms Tiong suffered any damage, and avers that Ms Tiong has failed to prove that whatever alleged damage she has suffered was caused by Dr Chan’s breach of duty.

  60. The rule in Wilkinson

  61. [37] Dr Chan submits that Ms Tiong’s claim under the rule in Wilkinson is “clearly unmeritorious”. First, there is no evidence to prove that Dr Chan made the Statement. The Statement appears to be a figment of Ms Tiong’s imagination. Second, “there is no basis to suggest [the Statement] was made with the intention to cause [Ms Tiong] physical harm”. Third, Ms Tiong “also falls short of demonstrating that she suffered physical harm as a result of [Dr Chan] conveying the Statement to [her]”.

  62. The joint expert

  63. [39] Initially, before the commencement of the trial, Ms Tiong intended to call two medical experts to testify for her. They are Dr Thomas Lee from Resilienz Clinic and Dr Wong Meng Kong from the Newcastle University Medicine Malaysia. On the other hand, Dr Chan wanted to call Dr Rasaiah Munidasa Winslow from Winslow Clinic, Promises Healthcare as his expert witness. Eventually, the parties decided not to call their respective experts as they had agreed to be bound by the evidence of a single joint expert. The parties came to an agreement to appoint Dr Lim Yun Chin (“Dr Lim”), a consultant in psychological medicine at Raffles Hospital, as their common joint expert. Dr Lim gave evidence on, inter alia, the applicable ethical rules binding medical professionals like Dr Chan and the risks of Xanax consumption, including the chances of addiction.

  64. Issues to be determined

  65. [40] Dr Chan agreed that he owed Ms Tiong a duty of care to ensure Xanax was appropriate for Ms Tiong’s consumption even though she was not his registered patient of SGH. Thus, it is not necessary for the court to determine whether Dr Chan owed Ms Tiong a duty of care when he gave her Xanax. The main issues regarding the claim that Dr Chan breached his duty of care to Ms Tiong are as follows:

  66. (a) Would a reasonably experienced psychiatrist in Dr Chan’s position (ie, who was in an intimate relationship with Ms Tiong) administer Xanax to Ms Tiong?

  67. (b) How many tablets of Xanax did Dr Chan give to Ms Tiong, and across what period of time?

  68. (c) Would a reasonably experienced psychiatrist in Dr Chan’s position have foreseen that Ms Tiong would become addicted to Xanax based on the number of tablets given by Dr Chan?

  69. (d) If Dr Chan had breached his duty of care to Ms Tiong, did the breach result in harm to Ms Tiong?

  70. [41] The main issues regarding the claim under the rule in Wilkinson are as follows:

  71. (a) Did Dr Chan make the Statement?

  72. (b) Was Ms Tiong induced by the Statement to enter into and/or continue with their sexual relationship?

  73. (c) Did Dr Chan, when making the Statement, intend to cause Ms Tiong psychiatric harm?

  74. (d) Did Ms Tiong suffer psychiatric harm as a result of her discovery that the Statement was false?

  75. My decision

  76. Medical negligence

  77. The applicable law

  78. [42] The present case involves an interesting application of otherwise trite tort law principles, ie, the duty of care owed by a doctor to his patient who is simultaneously his paramour. Therefore, it is useful to outline the applicable principles in greater detail.

  79. [43] It is axiomatic that to establish a claim under the tort of negligence, the claimant must demonstrate that (a) the defendant owes the claimant a duty of care; (b) the defendant breaches this duty of care by acting (or omitting to act) below the standard of care required of him; (c) the defendant’s breach of duty caused the claimant to suffer losses; (d) the claimant’s losses are not too remote; and (e) such losses can be adequately proved and quantified (Spandeck Engineering (S) Pte Ltd v Defence Science & Technology Agency [2007] 4 SLR(R) 100 (“Spandeck”) at [21], citing Clerk & Lindsell on Torts (Sweet & Maxwell, 19th Ed, 2006) at para 8-04).

  80. [44] In Spandeck at [73]–[85], the Court of Appeal laid down the applicable test to determine the existence of a duty of care:

  81. (a) First, the claimant has to satisfy the threshold question of factual foreseeability, ie, whether the defendant ought to have known that the claimant would suffer damage from his carelessness.

  82. (b) Second, there must be sufficient legal proximity between the claimant and the defendant for a duty of care to arise.

  83. (c) Third, if the first two questions are answered in the affirmative, the prima facie duty that arises should not be negated by countervailing policy considerations.

  84. [45] As for the standard of care that the defendant in cases of medical negligence is held to, the applicable law is derived from Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582 (“Bolam”) and Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232 (“Bolitho”). The Court of Appeal in Hii Chii Kok v Ooi Peng Jin London Lucien and another [2017] 2 SLR 492 (“Hii Chii Kok”) held at [101]–[102] that the Bolam test with the Bolitho addendum (“the Bolam-Bolitho test”) applies to determine the standard of care in the context of diagnosis and treatment. A summary of the Bolam-Bolitho test was provided at [76] of Hii Chii Kok and I reproduce the relevant excerpts below:

  85. My findings

  86. [46] I observe at the outset that Dr Chan also does not dispute that he owes a duty of care to Ms Tiong. Accordingly, whether Dr Chan and Ms Tiong was in a de facto doctor-patient relationship may not be pertinent as that inquiry goes only towards supporting Ms Tiong’s case that Dr Chan owed her a duty of care. Therefore, the only issue that is before me is whether Dr Chan has breached his duty of care owed to Ms Tiong by giving her Xanax.

  87. (1) The general professional standard

  88. (A) Applicability of the SMC Ethical Code and Ethical Guidelines

  89. [47] During the trial, Ms Tiong relied heavily on the SMC Ethical Code and Ethical Guidelines (2016 Edition) (“the ECEG”) and Dr Chan’s admission during the Defamation Suit that he acted in breach of the ECEG by giving medication to Ms Tiong.

  90. [48] The Introduction and Preamble of the ECEG states as follows:

  91. [49] It is clear from the above that the ECEG was developed with input from members of the medical profession and is influential in guiding a doctor’s exercise of his or her clinical judgment. Dr Lim also confirmed that the ECEG is applicable to psychiatrists.

  92. [50] In Ang Peng Tiam v Singapore Medical Council and another matter [2017] 5 SLR 356 (“Ang Peng Tiam”) at [78], the High Court with three Judges observed the following of the SMC Ethical Code and Ethical Guidelines (2002 Edition):

  93. [51] Reading the above extract together with the Introduction and Preamble of the ECEG cited at [48] above, it is clear that the ECEG functions as a guide for doctors in the exercise of their clinical judgment. A breach of the ECEG does not ipso facto lead to the automatic conclusion that a doctor has acted in breach of the general professional standard, though it may suggest that the general professional standard may not have been complied with. Thus, a professional conduct guide serves as a common accepted practice for professionals in that particular industry to adhere to unless there are good reasons not to do so. While a professional conduct guide may inform the court as to the applicable standard of care that may be expected of that professional, that is not the be all and end all. An inquiry as to whether a professional has breached his or her standard of care is ultimately a fact-centric inquiry that requires the court to consider all the circumstances of the case. Indeed, in Johnson v Bingley [1997] PNLR 392, the English High Court held with respect to the UK Law Society’s Guide that a breach of the rules in that guide does not ipso facto and of necessity lead to the conclusion that the solicitor was negligent.

  94. [52] Therefore, this instant case is not about whether Dr Chan had breached the professional standard of a psychiatrist when he gave Ms Tiong Xanax. The governing body that regulates and polices the professional conduct of psychiatrists is the SMC. Instead, Ms Tiong’s claim is that Dr Chan was negligent when he gave her Xanax. This resulted in her experiencing several side effects and her consequential addiction to Xanax. In the course of the trial, Ms Tiong’s counsel spent a considerable amount of time to show that Dr Chan had breached the ECEG when he gave Xanax to Ms Tiong. Ms Tiong alleges that she is Dr Chan’s de facto patient.

  95. [53] In my view, as I have reiterated above, the central issue is not whether Dr Chan had breached the professional standard as prescribed by the ECEG. Instead, the issue is whether Dr Chan was negligent when he gave Ms Tiong Xanax. Turning to this inquiry, there can be a situation in which Dr Chan could have complied with the ECEG to the very letter and therefore did not breach any professional standard, but could still be negligent in giving Ms Tiong Xanax. Conversely, there can be a situation in which Dr Chan could have breached the ECEG and yet not be negligent in giving Ms Tiong Xanax. In addition, there can be a situation in which Dr Chan could have breached the professional standard and also be negligent in giving Xanax to Ms Tiong. This third scenario is Ms Tiong’s allegation. In this situation, the court should not be concerned about whether Dr Chan breached his professional standard but should focus on whether Dr Chan was negligent when he gave Ms Tiong Xanax.

  96. [54] However, as Ms Tiong spent a considerable amount of time at the trial and in her submissions alleging that Dr Chan had breached his professional standard, I shall examine this matter, although I stress that it is clearly not relevant to the outcome of her claim.

  97. [55] Ms Tiong argues that Dr Chan breached the following Guidelines in the ECEG when he passed her the Xanax tablets prescribed to him by SGH:

  98. [56] Counsel for Ms Tiong also made reference to the SMC Handbook on Medical Ethics (2016 Edition) (“the Handbook”) at B1.2, which appears to be inconsistent with ECEG Guideline B1.5. The Handbook states as follows at B1.2:

  99. [57] Counsel for Ms Tiong accepted that when the Handbook conflicts with the ECEG, the latter prevails. The Preface to the Handbook makes this clear:

  100. [58] Therefore, in my assessment of whether the general professional standard has been breached, I place greater weight on the ECEG. My reliance on the Handbook is limited to when the meaning of the ECEG is unclear.

  101. [59] Together with the ECEG Guidelines reproduced at [55] above, Ms Tiong also relies on Dr Lim’s expert opinion that Dr Chan “ought to have formalized [sic] her treatment according to the SMC Guidelines or refer [her] to his colleagues” if Dr Chan deemed her to suffer from an adjustment disorder with anxiety. Ms Tiong also relies heavily on Dr Lim’s expert evidence as follows:

  102. Ms Tiong relies on the expert evidence of Dr Lim to argue that the standard of care of a doctor when treating his loved ones “should be higher than if they were just ordinary patients”. She claims that Dr Chan had “[f]ailed to observe a low threshold for referring out when she was emotionally affected by discovering his unfaithfulness through the lurid details from the [S]creenshots” [emphasis in original].

  103. [60] Dr Chan claims that while he did conduct a psychiatric assessment on Ms Tiong, he did not deem Ms Tiong to be suffering from “any psychiatric disorder, be it an anxiety disorder or adjustment disorder”, although she might have symptoms of anxiety, stress, chest discomfort, shortness of breath and had trouble sleeping.

  104. [61] Considering the ECEG Guidelines cited at [55] above together with Dr Lim’s expert evidence, I find that Dr Chan’s conduct is consistent with and does not infringe the ECEG.

  105. (B) ECEG Guideline B1.5

  106. [62] First, according to Dr Lim, ECEG Guideline B1.5 provides that doctors may treat a loved one not registered as a patient if the loved one suffers from a “minor condition”. Dr Lim also opined in his expert report that “[t]he nuances from this statement seem to me that there are rules but no rulebook”. In court, he explained the preceding sentence as follows:

  107. [63] It is clear from Dr Lim’s testimony that there is no blanket rule prohibiting doctors from providing medical care to their loved ones. On the contrary, ECEG Guideline B1.5 is a permissive rule specifying that doctors may provide medical care to their loved ones where the patient suffers from “stable conditions, minor conditions, or in an urgent/emergency situation when no other suitable doctor is available in a timely manner.” According to Dr Lim’s expert report, the question is whether the patient’s condition fell within one of these descriptions in the view of the doctor at the time he assessed the patient:

  108. [64] According to Dr Chan, he observed that Ms Tiong suffered from symptoms of anxiety, but did not suffer from a psychiatric disorder:

  109. [65] Given Dr Chan’s view that Ms Tiong did not suffer from a psychiatric disorder, it can be inferred that Dr Chan assessed Ms Tiong to be suffering from, at best, a minor condition. This is consonant with Dr Lim’s expert report:

  110. [66] According to Dr Lim, the term “self-limiting” describes disorders that run their course in a short-lived manner, ie, only over a brief period of time. An example of a self-limiting minor episode is infrequent anxiety attacks. A patient suffering from a self-limiting minor episode would recover without treatment. Dr Lim’s expert evidence supports Dr Chan’s own testimony that he deemed Ms Tiong to only be suffering from symptoms of anxiety, a minor condition, and not a formal psychiatric disorder. Accordingly, Dr Chan’s prescription of Xanax to Ms Tiong falls within the permissive rule in ECEG Guideline B1.5.

  111. [67] Further, Dr Lim also gave evidence that he would have been similarly prepared to prescribe Xanax to a loved one:

  112. [68] Having regard to the above, Dr Chan did not breach ECEG Guideline B1.5 when he gave Xanax to Ms Tiong. It follows that Ms Tiong’s claim that Dr Chan’s prescription of Xanax to her ran afoul of ECEG Guideline B5, which is a general statement that doctors must only prescribe medicines to “patients under [their] care”, fails. In any case, I note that Ms Tiong was not registered as Dr Chan’s patient and is best characterised as a loved one. Thus, the applicable rule would be ECEG Guideline B1.5 and not ECEG Guideline B5.1.

  113. (C) ECEG Guideline B1.1

  114. [69] As for ECEG Guideline B1.1, the explanatory note in the Handbook provides that doctors “need to be careful not to allow [their] personal prejudices and biases to influence [their] management of [their] patients”. In a similar vein, it is clear that ECEG Guideline B1.1 does not equate to a blanket rule against providing medical care for one’s loved ones. The key inquiry is whether there is evidence that the doctor displayed any personal bias towards his loved one which had a causative link to his management of that person.

  115. [70] As stated at [64]–[65] above, Dr Chan had conducted a psychiatric assessment of Ms Tiong and in his judgment, found it appropriate to treat her. There is no evidence that any personal biases had crept into this assessment. In his expert report, Dr Lim also expressed an objective opinion on Dr Chan’s prescription of Xanax to Ms Tiong:

  116. (D) ECEG Guideline B1.4

  117. [71] As for ECEG Guideline B1.4, I am of the view that Xanax is neither a “controlled drug” nor a drug “with significant potential for dependence or psychiatric care”. Parties agree that the term “controlled drug” has a specific legal definition in the Misuse of Drugs Act 1973 (2020 Rev Ed), and that Xanax is not a “controlled drug”. As for the second definition, Dr Lim opined in his expert report that the risk of dependency associated with Ms Tiong’s own consumption rate of Xanax in the quantities she alleged is low and the daily intake is “still within the recommended maximum daily dose by the international authorities”. Dr Chan similarly gave evidence that the risk of dependency associated with Ms Tiong’s consumption of Xanax he gave is low. According to Dr Chan, his provision of limited quantities of Xanax for a short period of time does not amount to providing psychiatric care. Given Dr Lim’s expert evidence, which the parties agreed to be bound, the quantity of Xanax allegedly taken by Ms Tiong would not result in “significant potential for dependence or psychiatric care” [emphasis added].

  118. [72] During the course of the trial, counsel for Ms Tiong continually placed emphasis on the fact that Xanax (Alprazolam) is listed in the Schedule to the Poisons Act. The mere fact that Xanax is listed in the Schedule to the Poisons Act does not mean it is a drug with “significant potential for dependence or psychiatric care”. As counsel for Dr Chan points out, numerous other common drugs are listed in the Schedule to the Poisons Act, such as Amoxycillin which is an antibiotic commonly used to treat bacterial infections; Simvastatin which is commonly given to lower cholesterol; and Cetirizine, also known as Zyrtec, an over-the-counter anti-histamine which can be bought from local pharmacies without a prescription. The Schedule to the Poisons Act also lists Salbutamol, otherwise known as Ventolin, which Dr Lim noted that “doctors often administer to their significant other only to be used when the latter has breathing problems”.

  119. [73] The above analysis at [62]–[69] also puts to rest Ms Tiong’s claim that Dr Chan acted in breach of ECEG Guideline B1.4. It is clear from Dr Lim’s testimony and the overall tenor of the ECEG that doctors are granted a certain degree of latitude and discretion to determine whether it would be appropriate to treat a loved one.

  120. (E) ECEG Guideline C4

  121. [74] Ms Tiong claims that Dr Chan breached ECEG Guideline C4 by continuing to have sexual relations with her after providing medication to her.

  122. [75] I agree with the counsel for Dr Chan that Ms Tiong’s interpretation of ECEG Guideline C4 is untenable. Dr Chan and Ms Tiong were lovers before he started to give Xanax to her. I agree with Dr Chan’s counsel that it cannot be the case that a doctor who provides medication to his wife to assist her in managing short-term symptoms such as difficulty in sleeping can no longer have sexual relations with her as she would become his “patient”. The correct understanding of this provision is that doctors are prohibited from entering into a sexual relationship with their patients, ie, the situation where the doctor comes to know the patient in his professional capacity as the treating physician. I agree that this prohibition does not apply when a doctor provides medication to a loved one whom they already have a pre-existing sexual relationship with, like in this instant case.

  123. (F) ECEG Guideline B3

  124. [76] Ms Tiong argues that Dr Chan had breached ECEG Guideline B3 by failing to maintain clear and accurate medical records when he provided Xanax to Ms Tiong. The failure to maintain proper clinical records is completely irrelevant to the issue of whether Dr Chan was negligent when he gave Xanax to Ms Tiong. As I have stated above, this is a matter going towards the professional conduct of psychiatrists and which is only relevant in an inquiry before a tribunal convened by the SMC.

  125. [77] Be that as it may, this argument is in any case contradicted by Dr Lim’s joint expert report. Dr Lim states in his report that it is not necessary to maintain contemporaneous medical records when providing short-term, infrequent treatment. When questioned by Ms Tiong’s counsel (Mr Ong), Dr Lim also noted that Dr Chan was not required to carry clinical notes when he provided Xanax to Ms Tiong as this was done through an “out-of-office consultation between a couple”:

  126. (G) Continued prescription of Xanax despite Ms Tiong’s suicide attempt

  127. [78] Finally, Ms Tiong argues that Dr Chan acted in breach of the general professional standard by continuing to give her Xanax even though she attempted suicide in front of him during the Eastern Europe Trip. I note that this point does not appear to be tied to any of the Guidelines in the ECEG, but appears to be premised on Dr Chan’s general duties as a psychiatrist.

  128. [79] Ms Tiong’s attempted suicide in front of Dr Chan is suspect and unsupported by evidence. Though Dr Chan admitted that there was “an incident in Prague” with “a knife”, he denied that it was a violent or suicidal episode. He claimed to have disarmed Ms Tiong “very quickly” and could not confirm that Ms Tiong was holding the knife to her throat.

  129. [80] In any event, Ms Tiong’s assertion is unsupported by contemporaneous evidence. There was no mention of Ms Tiong attempting suicide in the transcripts of the WhatsApp conversations between Ms Tiong and Dr Chan. Further, Ms Tiong’s claim that she attempted suicide after discovering the WhatsApp Messages between Dr Chan and Dr Ong is incongruous with her desire to still marry Dr Chan, in spite of the salacious contents in the WhatsApp Messages (see [170] below). Ms Tiong has failed to establish, on a balance of probabilities, that she had attempted suicide in front of Dr Chan in the first place. I also accept the oral closing submission of counsel for Dr Chan that this allegation did not feature in any of Ms Tiong’s pleadings or her affidavit of evidence-in-chief. Accordingly, this argument is a non-starter and completely irrelevant.

  130. (H) Conclusion on the general professional standard

  131. [81] Having regard to the totality of the circumstances and the evidence before me, I find that Dr Chan did not act in breach of the general professional standard when he gave Xanax to Ms Tiong, his then-girlfriend, without registering her as his patient. Dr Chan’s actions were consistent with ECEG Guidelines B1, B3, B5 and C4.

  132. (2) Dr Lim’s objectivity as a joint expert

  133. [82] Counsel for Ms Tiong raised belatedly during reply submissions that Dr Lim’s objectivity as a joint expert was in doubt as he, inter alia:

  134. [83] I reiterate that parties agreed to be bound by the findings of Dr Lim well before the commencement of the trial. Seen in this light, Ms Tiong cannot now turn around and object to the court’s full consideration of Dr Lim’s evidence on the grounds that the expert evidence he gave was unfavourable to her case. In any event, I find that the alleged shortcomings in Dr Lim’s evidence raised by Ms Tiong at [82] above do not raise any doubts as to the objectivity of his evidence. On the contrary, it is in fact internally consistent with his evidence that “the literature on ethics is clear that physicians have the ultimate say in what they are and are not comfortable with”. It also comports with the High Court’s observations in Ang Peng Tiam that the ECEG is meant to assist a doctor’s exercise of his clinical judgment (see [50] above). I, therefore, find that Dr Lim’s evidence is credible and objective, and continue to accord considerable weight to his expert evidence. In any event, I note that counsel for Ms Tiong states, in his oral closing submissions, that he “unreservedly withdraw any allegation that [Dr Lim] was biased”.

  135. (3) Frequency of Xanax given by Dr Chan

  136. [84] Dr Lim wrote in his report that “[w]ithout knowledge of the dosage used per day and how long the duration was the 90 tablets used, it would not be possible to evaluate the risk of tolerance or physical dependency”. Thus, the length of time for which Ms Tiong was given Xanax by Dr Chan is a critical issue. Ms Tiong claims that Dr Chan started providing Xanax to her sometime in the first half of 2017, while Dr Chan claims that he only provided Xanax to Ms Tiong once in early May 2018.

  137. [85] I find that Dr Chan’s version of the facts should be preferred over Ms Tiong’s version. I shall now explain the reasons for my conclusion.

  138. [86] Ms Tiong’s evidence on this crucial pillar of her case was gravely inconsistent and irreconcilable. She gave at least five different and inconsistent versions of when Dr Chan first provided her with Xanax:

  139. [87] Ms Tiong gave eight different versions on the critical issues of (a) the frequency with which Dr Chan purportedly gave her Xanax and (b) the quantity of Xanax she received from Dr Chan. I summarise these different versions in tabular form and attach as Annex 1 to this Judgment. Counsel for Ms Tiong reviewed the tabular summary and confirmed that it accurately reflected Ms Tiong’s various positions during the course of the proceedings.

  140. [88] Ms Tiong herself agreed that she gave inconsistent evidence on oath regarding when Dr Chan first provided her with Xanax. The fact that Ms Tiong gave so many different and inconsistent versions pertaining to this critical issue was highly troubling and raised serious doubts about her reliability and credibility as a witness. Further, Ms Tiong’s claim that Dr Chan started prescribing her Xanax in the first half of 2017 is inconsistent with the contemporaneous evidence.

  141. [89] First, during the course of their relationship, Ms Tiong and Dr Chan exchanged WhatsApp messages almost on a daily basis. However, the transcripts of the WhatsApp messages between Ms Tiong and Dr Chan over the course of their 16-month relationship only contained one mention of Xanax on 8 May 2018 which is not disputed:

  142. [90] Second, there was no mention of Xanax in the transcripts of their WhatsApp messages even when the pair were communicating about other drugs taken by Ms Tiong:

  143. [91] The WhatsApp messages at [90] above were sent when Ms Tiong was taking medication to help her sleep. There was no reference to Xanax in the communications, although there were extensive references to other drugs. This suggests that Ms Tiong had not been provided Xanax by Dr Chan from 2017 to 7 May 2018. If she was given Xanax before May 2018, the WhatsApp messages would have mentioned Xanax in their numerous WhatsApp conversations about what medication to take when she was feeling anxious or had trouble sleeping. This suggests that at the time of the WhatsApp messages, Dr Chan had only provided her with Trazodone and Zopiclone (which are not the subject matters of Ms Tiong’s claim), and not Xanax which was only given sometime on or about 7 May 2018.

  144. [92] Ms Tiong alleged that she and Dr Chan met almost daily and, therefore, a large portion of their communication, including discussion on Xanax, was oral and not in the WhatsApp messages. This allegation is difficult to believe. Based on Ms Tiong’s allegation that Dr Chan gave her Xanax from as early as mid-2017, or even earlier from February 2017 (see [86] above), it is strange that there was no mention of Xanax in the WhatsApp messages at all until 8 May 2018 when other types of drugs were mentioned. The fact that Xanax was only mentioned on 8 May 2018 coheres with Dr Chan’s account that he only started giving Ms Tiong Xanax from early May 2018. If Ms Tiong had been given Xanax from early 2017 as she alleged, it is strange that she would respond to Dr Chan that “[t]he [X]anax is good” in May 2018. Therefore, I find that Dr Chan’s version of the facts, ie, that he only started giving her Xanax in early May 2018 is consistent with the contemporaneous evidence.

  145. (4) Quantity of Xanax

  146. [93] On the issue of the quantity of Xanax given by Dr Chan, this is critically important as it will address the pertinent issues of whether Ms Tiong had side effects and whether she is addicted to Xanax. Ms Tiong’s position before the trial was that Dr Chan gave her ten tablets of Xanax per month from February 2017 to March 2018 and approximately 100 tablets of Xanax in April 2018 and May 2018. Accordingly, Ms Tiong alleged that Dr Chan gave her 330 tablets of Xanax in total. Dr Chan’s position is that he gave her 14 tablets of Xanax for short-term use in early May 2018.

  147. [94] Ms Tiong’s evidence on the quantity of Xanax is completely devoid of truth as there was a myriad of incredible critical discrepancies and serious inconsistencies. I find that Dr Chan’s version of the quantity of Xanax tablets he gave to Ms Tiong should be preferred over Ms Tiong’s version. I shall now set out the reasons for my finding.

  148. [95] When she took the stand, Ms Tiong vacillated repeatedly in her evidence on the quantity of Xanax tablets Dr Chan provided to her:

  149. [96] Apart from the above material inconsistencies, there were numerous other serious discrepancies in Ms Tiong’s evidence during her cross-examination.

  150. [97] First, Ms Tiong’s latest and final position on 21 April 2022, ie, that Dr Chan gave her 160 tablets of Xanax from May 2017 to March 2018 (see [95] above), is highly inconsistent with the contemporaneous records from SGH which she sought SGH to produce through the discovery process. Ms Tiong agrees that she has no evidence that Dr Chan obtained his supply of Xanax from sources other than SGH. Based on SGH records, between May 2017 and March 2018, ie 10 months, Dr Chan was only prescribed 90 tablets of Xanax from Associate Professor Lee Tih Shih. The next time Dr Chan was prescribed Xanax again was on 30 April 2018. The prescriptions from SGH records are summarised as follows:

  151. The contemporaneous records from SGH refute Ms Tiong’s claim that Dr Chan provided her with 160 tablets of Xanax from May 2017 to March 2018.

  152. [98] Second, Ms Tiong’s position as of 21 April 2022 is that she had 50 unconsumed Xanax tablets left by end May 2018 and 49 unconsumed Xanax tablets as of 25 September 2020. This position came about on the third day of the trial after Ms Tiong had time to recalculate the number of Xanax tablets Dr Chan had given to her. Ms Tiong’s position is, however, seriously internally inconsistent, as she also claimed that she consumed 20 Xanax tablets in total from June to July 2018 – ten in each month. If the latter claim were true, Ms Tiong should have 29 to 30 Xanax tablets left by September 2020, and not 49 Xanax tablets as she submits.

  153. [99] Ms Tiong’s first explanation for her conflicting evidence was that she and her lawyers had failed to properly track the evidence in her affidavits:

  154. [100] Ms Tiong later claimed that her inconsistencies were due to “memory impairment, or memory loss” as she was “just popping Xanax like candy”. This explanation is a double-edged sword. Ms Tiong claims that she suffered memory lapses due to her consumption of Xanax to explain the inconsistencies in her evidence regarding the quantity of Xanax. This seems to suggest that her recollection of the events and her testimony in court are unreliable and cannot be believed as she is saying that her memory is impaired. Alternatively, she indulges in selective loss of memory at her convenience.

  155. [101] Ms Tiong also suggests that her inability to account for the quantity of Xanax tablets she received from Dr Chan should not be held against her as Dr Chan had acted in breach of ECEG Guideline B5 when he failed to record his prescription to her. As noted by the High Court in Rathanamalah d/o Shunmugam v Chia Kok Hoong [2018] 4 SLR 159 at [82], “the SMC Guidelines relate to ethical proceedings; they may be helpful but cannot necessarily dictate the evidential burdens in civil suits”. Therefore, Ms Tiong’s allegation that Dr Chan had breached the ECEG in failing to keep proper records does not surrogate or satisfy her burden of proving the quantity of Xanax provided to her by Dr Chan. The failure to maintain clinical records is completely irrelevant to the issue of whether Dr Chan was negligent when Xanax was given to Ms Tiong.

  156. [102] In my view, there is a plausible explanation for the chameleonic nature of Ms Tiong’s evidence. As counsel for Dr Chan suggests, it is likely that Ms Tiong decided to change her evidence on 20 April 2022 to ensure that her position on the quantity of Xanax tablets given by Dr Chan was in line with the quantity Dr Chan was prescribed by SGH, as described in Dr Chan’s AEIC and evinced by the SGH records. However, she had also affirmed on oath that she had at least 49 unconsumed Xanax tablets. The fact that she had affirmed as such was brought to Ms Tiong’s attention during the trial on 20 April 2022. According to counsel for Dr Chan, after Ms Tiong was reminded of her earlier affirmation, Ms Tiong realised that her new total estimate of approximately 120 Xanax tablets did not take into account the unconsumed tablets of Xanax, which was why she changed her evidence again on 21 April 2022.

  157. [103] The quantity of Xanax tablets goes to the heart of Ms Tiong’s claim in medical negligence. Thus, her conflicting evidence on this critical issue is fatal to her claim. Her inconsistent evidence on this foundational point also speaks volumes about her reliability as a witness and the viability of her claim. I agree with the counsel for Dr Chan that Ms Tiong appeared to change her evidence on the fly and tailored her evidence on how many Xanax tablets she was given by Dr Chan to be consistent with the quantity of Xanax tablets Dr Chan was prescribed from SGH. In my view, it is no coincidence that the final numbers of Xanax tablets advanced by Ms Tiong is the closest to the 243 tablets Dr Chan was prescribed from SGH.

  158. [106] When she was further questioned on the Paper, Ms Tiong confirmed her position was that taken on 21 April 2022, ie, she was given around 280 tablets (see [95] above). However, she could not satisfactorily explain why she wrote a different total figure of 320 tablets on the Paper:

  159. [108] Given the lack of contemporaneous evidence supporting Ms Tiong’s case and the ever-changing nature of her evidence, it is highly unsafe to rely on her allegation that Dr Chan gave her 280 or 330 tablets. On the other hand, Dr Chan’s version that (a) he only gave her 14 tablets in May 2018; and (b) he could not have given her Xanax tablets as she alleged as he was only prescribed 243 tablets of Xanax from SGH from 8 May 2017 to 21 May 2018 is more credible. Further, Dr Chan’s version is supported by the contemporaneous evidence.

  160. (5) Dr Chan’s alleged breach of duty

  161. [109] Having ascertained that Dr Chan’s version of the facts should be believed over Ms Tiong’s, I shall now consider whether Dr Chan breached his duty of care when he gave 14 Xanax tablets to Ms Tiong in early May 2018. According to Dr Lim, if the 14 tablets of Xanax were taken “over a period of several days or weeks as short-term use, the risk of physical dependency will be very low”. It follows that a reasonably experienced psychiatrist in Dr Chan’s position would not have foreseen that Ms Tiong would become addicted to Xanax just because Dr Chan gave 14 Xanax tablets to her in May 2018. Accordingly, Dr Chan has not breached his duty of care to ensure that Ms Tiong would not become addicted to Xanax or to ascertain its suitability for her.

  162. [110] For completeness, I note that even on Ms Tiong’s account of the highest quantity of Xanax prescribed to her, ie, 330 tablets (see [95] above), Dr Lim’s expert evidence is that the risk of dependency is low. Accordingly, a reasonably experienced psychiatrist in Dr Chan’s position would not have foreseen or would not have thought that there was a good likelihood that Ms Tiong might become addicted to Xanax based on the number of tablets given by Dr Chan. Regarding Ms Tiong’s claim that Dr Chan gave her ten tablets of Xanax per month from February 2017 to March 2018, Dr Lim’s expert opinion is as follows:

  163. [111] On Ms Tiong’s claim that Dr Chan gave her approximately 100 tablets of Xanax per month for April 2018 and May 2018, Dr Lim’s expert opinion is as follows:

  164. [112] Further, Ms Tiong was prescribed 330 Xanax tablets by Dr Thomas Lee over a shorter period of eight months between 23 August 2018 and 25 April 2019 (see [126] below). Ms Tiong alleges that Dr Chan gave her the same number of tablets over a longer 15-month period (see [25] above). Ms Tiong did not allege that Dr Thomas Lee’s prescription of Xanax was excessive or otherwise a breach of his duty. In these circumstances, it is incongruous for Ms Tiong to allege that Dr Chan had given her excessive Xanax.

  165. [113] Moreover, Ms Tiong confirmed during cross-examination by Dr Chan’s counsel (Ms Chew) that when Dr Chan provided her with Xanax, he had advised her on the appropriate dosage of Xanax to consume:

  166. [114] Dr Chan’s advice to Ms Tiong to take one to two Xanax tablets a day is well within the recommended maximum dosage of up to 4mg of Xanax, ie four tablets of Xanax a day, by most regulatory bodies including the Food and Drug Administration of the USA and the British National Formulary. This was also supported in Dr Lim’s joint expert report. Ms Tiong also agreed during cross-examination that Dr Chan was “always very careful to ensure” that she did not “take any medicine unnecessarily”. Having regard to the above, it is incongruous for Ms Tiong to still allege that Dr Chan had failed to ensure that she would not become addicted to Xanax.

  167. [115] Ms Tiong acknowledged in court that before April 2018 when her relationship with Dr Chan began to crumble, Dr Chan was caring and had her best interests at heart:

  168. [116] Hence, even assuming it was true that Dr Chan had given her Xanax since February 2017 he would not have harmed Ms Tiong as they were in a romantic relationship and as Ms Tiong admitted he was caring and had her best interests at heart.

  169. [117] I, therefore, find that Dr Chan has not acted in breach of his duty of care when he gave Xanax to Ms Tiong.

  170. (6) Harm suffered by Ms Tiong

  171. [118] Since I have found that Dr Chan did not breach his duty of care to Ms Tiong, it would be unnecessary to consider the alleged harm suffered by Ms Tiong because of Dr Chan’s breach. Nevertheless, for completeness, I shall now consider the harm, if any, suffered by Ms Tiong as a result of Dr Chan giving her Xanax.

  172. [119] Ms Tiong claims that because of Dr Chan’s breach of duty, she suffered (a) side effects from consuming high dosages of Xanax; and (b) withdrawal symptoms from addiction to Xanax. The side effects from her consumption of and dependency on Xanax include, inter alia, memory loss, suicidal thoughts, breathing difficulties, stress and an inability to fall asleep. Ms Tiong also asserts in her pleadings that she suffered “adjustment disorder with anxiety”, and in her closing submissions she further alleges that she suffered from GAD.

  173. [120] I shall first consider Ms Tiong’s claim that she suffered side effects from her consumption of Xanax. Dr Lim testified that the possible side effects caused by consuming Xanax are drowsiness, cognitive difficulty and slurred speech. Symptoms such as breathing difficulties, stress, suicidal thoughts and an inability to fall asleep are not caused by Xanax. Rather, breathing difficulties are a symptom of anxiety. Dr Lim went further to state that it is not possible for the consumption of Xanax to cause suicidal thoughts, which decisively rebutted Ms Tiong’s claim that she suffered suicidal thoughts as a result of consuming Xanax in high quantities. Dr Lim further testified that the risk of suffering side effects from consuming Xanax is low:

  174. [121] Ms Tiong claims that she began suffering adverse side effects “[a]fter more than a year of consuming” Xanax Dr Chan gave her and that she “had previously shared [her] concerns about these symptoms with [Dr Chan] in November 2017 when [their] relationship was intimate”. However, this claim is contradicted by Dr Lim’s expert evidence. Dr Lim testified that adverse side effects from consuming Xanax, such as drowsiness and cognitive difficulties, would arise shortly after consumption and persist only up to the time Xanax is eliminated from the body. Such side effects would last for approximately four to five hours. As counsel for Dr Chan points out, it is therefore inexplicable how Ms Tiong could suffer such adverse side effects after a year of consuming Xanax.

  175. [122] Dr Lim’s testimony, taken together with Ms Tiong’s lack of objective evidence that she suffered side effects from consuming Xanax, cast serious doubt on her claim that she suffered side effects from consuming Xanax. None of the numerous WhatsApp messages between Ms Tiong and Dr Chan reveal that Ms Tiong had experienced some side effects from the consumption of Xanax.

  176. [123] The vast majority of medical literature put forward by both parties also do not support Ms Tiong’s claim that she suffered side effects. The medical literature cited by Ms Tiong supports Dr Lim’s expert opinion that more than 80% of patients consuming Xanax would not suffer any side effects. For instance, the studies cited in the Medication Guide on Alprazolam by the Federal Drug Administration of the United States of America demonstrate that more patients claim to suffer side effects arising from placebo as compared to alprazolam tablets, and that the side effects from alprazolam occur in less than 20% of individuals. Although the percentage of patients experienced side effects after consuming Xanax is only 20%, I accept that it does not rule out the possibilities that Ms Tiong could fall within this group of Xanax sensitive patients. However, the evidence in this case does not support her claim which was based on self-assertion. Thus, Ms Tiong’s claim that she suffered side effects from consuming Xanax is doubtful.

  177. [124] Finally, I accept the oral closing submission of counsel for Dr Chan that, if it were true that Ms Tiong was suffering from these side effects, no reasonable psychiatrist would have continued prescribing Xanax to Ms Tiong. The fact remains that Ms Tiong continued to be prescribed Xanax by other psychiatrist whom she consulted after May 2018. These include Ms Tiong’s prescription of Xanax by Resilienz Clinic between 23 August 2018 and 25 April 2019 and from BetterLife Psychological Medicine Clinic on 28 May 2020 and 19 June 2020. I accept that, if Xanax was unsuitable for Ms Tiong’s consumption as alleged, there would be no reason why different medical practitioners of her choice would continue prescribing it to her. This was also confirmed by Dr Lim’s evidence at trial. The fact that Ms Tiong continues to receive prescriptions for Xanax from her own doctors after May 2018 clearly suggests that Ms Tiong’s allegation that she suffers the side effects of Xanax cannot be true.

  178. [125] Ms Tiong further alleges that she suffered withdrawal symptoms as a result of Xanax dependency. Dr Lim explained that if a person were addicted to Xanax and he or she continues to have access to Xanax, he or she will not suffer withdrawal symptoms. It is only when the person is deprived of Xanax will withdrawal symptoms manifest in the form of “abdominal cramps, blurred, vision, dizziness, headache and so forth”. Thus, a person addicted to Xanax would increase their dosage of Xanax. If the dosage of Xanax was reduced or if there were prolonged breaks between the periods of Xanax consumption, these indicate that there is no Xanax addiction.

  179. [126] On the face of the evidence, there were reductions in the dosages of Xanax prescribed to Ms Tiong and prolonged breaks in Ms Tiong’s consumption of Xanax after May 2018. After her break-up with Dr Chan in May 2018, Ms Tiong was prescribed Xanax from two clinics, Resilienz Clinic and BetterLife Psychological Medicine Clinic, as follows:

  180. [127] Ms Tiong was not prescribed any Xanax from 25 April 2019 to 28 May 2020, ie, slightly more than a year. Further, the quantity of Xanax she was prescribed reduced drastically from 90 tablets on 8 November 2018 to 30 tablets on 19 December 2018. Ms Tiong claimed that during the period from 25 April 2019 to 28 May 2020 when she was not prescribed any Xanax, she still needed Xanax but could not afford to receive further prescriptions from clinics as she was short of money from defending herself in the Defamation Suit. However, Ms Tiong did not consume the 49 unconsumed tablets of Xanax she was in possession of. According to Dr Lim, the fact that Ms Tiong did not consume the 49 tablets she had in her possession “is definitely, in [his] opinion, not suggestive of a dependent patient”. If indeed she was addicted to Xanax there would not be any unconsumed tablets of Xanax as she would have had to satisfy her addiction craving.

  181. [128] When confronted with the fact that she did not consume the 49 unconsumed tablets she possessed, Ms Tiong claimed that she did not consume the 49 unconsumed tablets as she wanted to use them as evidence for the SMC Complaint and adduced them as physical evidence before the SMC. It is curious then that the SMC Complaint appended a picture of only four Xanax tablets. If Dr Chan had indeed given her so many tablets of Xanax as alleged, an ordinary person in Ms Tiong’s position would have taken a picture of all or as many of them as possible, as opposed to simply a fraction or a “sample” as Ms Tiong describes.

  182. [129] There is no indication that Ms Tiong had sought to increase her supply of Xanax, which would be a clear sign of addiction according to Dr Lim. On the contrary, the facts that (a) Ms Tiong purportedly went “cold turkey” from Xanax for more than a year; (b) the quantity of Xanax she was prescribed decreased drastically from 8 November 2018 to 19 December 2018; and (c) she did not consume the remaining tablets she had are, in line with Dr Lim’s evidence, clear indications that she was not addicted to Xanax. Dr Lim’s opinion is logically convincing and reliable.

  183. [130] As counsel for Dr Chan points out, Ms Tiong’s consumption pattern also reveals that she could not have been addicted to Xanax. During cross-examination, Ms Tiong stated that she consumed Xanax tablets as follows:

  184. [131] The above consumption pattern, taken together with Dr Lim’s testimony, decisively rebuts Ms Tiong’s claim that she was addicted to Xanax:

  185. (a) Between May 2017 to July 2017, Ms Tiong allegedly consumed only five to ten tablets a month. Dr Lim notes that consuming this dosage of Xanax leads to an extremely low risk of susceptibility to physical dependency.

  186. (b) From August 2017 to October 2017, Ms Tiong allegedly did not consume any Xanax tablets. Her ability to stop her consumption of Xanax plainly demonstrates that she was not experiencing dependency on Xanax.

  187. (c) While Ms Tiong consumed 30 tablets of Xanax in November 2017, she claims that she lowered her consumption to ten tablets of Xanax in December 2017. Dr Lim confirmed that a person’s ability to voluntarily break her continuous consumption of Xanax indicates that that person does not suffer from a Xanax addiction.

  188. (d) In a similar vein, while Ms Tiong increased her consumption to 30 tablets of Xanax in January 2018, she again voluntarily lowered her consumption to five tablets of Xanax per month in both February 2018 and March 2018, demonstrating that she was not addicted to Xanax.

  189. (f) In June 2018 and July 2018, Ms Tiong reduced her consumption of Xanax to ten tablets in each month, while also holding onto 49 to 50 unconsumed Xanax tablets during this period. This demonstrates that Ms Tiong was able to reduce her intake while simultaneously resisting the urge to consume the remaining 49 to 50 tablets. I reiterate Dr Lim’s expert evidence that the fact that Ms Tiong did not consume the unconsumed tablets she had with her “is definitely, in [his] opinion, not suggestive of a dependent patient”.

  190. [132] During the trial, counsel for Ms Tiong referred to a diagnosis by Dr Thomas Lee that Ms Tiong developed a Xanax dependency as at mid-2018. However, the reliability of the diagnosis from Dr Thomas Lee is also suspect. The report of Dr Thomas Lee is hearsay as the doctor who made the diagnosis was not called since parties agreed to have the opinion of the joint expert, ie, Dr Lim. The evidence indicates that Ms Tiong exaggerated the extent of her Xanax consumption to Dr Thomas Lee. Ms Tiong claimed that she told Dr Thomas Lee she was consuming three to six tablets of Xanax daily by mid-2018. This is inconsistent with her evidence on her consumption pattern (see [130] above) where she claimed to have consumed 60 to 70 tablets of Xanax in May 2018 and only ten tablets of Xanax per month in June 2018 and July 2018. Ms Tiong’s account to Dr Thomas Lee of consuming three to six tablets daily would yield a total of approximately 90 to 180 tablets consumed per month. Ms Tiong also confirmed during cross-examination that she did not inform Dr Thomas Lee that she had only consumed ten tablets of Xanax per month in both June 2018 and July 2018:

  191. [133] Ms Tiong’s claim that she suffered from a Xanax dependency was unsupported by the evidence. She has failed to prove on a balance of probabilities that she suffered from a dependency on Xanax.

  192. [134] Ms Tiong claims that the symptoms she suffered from taking Xanax became apparent from April 2018. However, this claim is incongruous with the contemporaneous evidence. On 8 May 2018, Ms Tiong sent a WhatsApp message to Dr Chan informing him that “[t]he [X]anax is good” and requesting that he obtain more for her (see [89] above). I agree with the counsel for Dr Chan that it makes no sense for Ms Tiong to express such positive feelings about Xanax if indeed she was suffering symptoms such as memory loss and suicidal thoughts.

  193. [135] Turning to Ms Tiong’s claim that she suffered from anxiety as a result of consuming Xanax or from being addicted to Xanax, I find that Ms Tiong was inconsistent on exactly what form of anxiety she suffered from. While she stated in her pleadings that she suffered from “adjustment disorder with anxiety”, she asserted during closing submissions that she suffered from GAD. Ms Tiong also confirmed that there is nothing in her WhatsApp communications with Dr Chan to suggest to Dr Chan that she was suffering from any anxiety disorder or psychiatric illness. The key evidence Ms Tiong relies on to support her claim that she suffered from GAD are the “couple’s quarrels” between her and Dr Chan in April, July, September and November 2017. This argument stands on extremely shaky ground. As counsel for Dr Chan points out, “just because Dr Chan and Ms Tiong had disagreements in their relationship cannot equate to her suffering from GAD”.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.