Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 30 Sep 2022
Contents

General Division of the High Court

British and Malayan Trustees Ltd v Ameen Ali Salim Talib and others

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHC 245Case no. High Court — Originating Summons No 288 of 2022 (Summons No 2621 of 2022) Vincent Hoong J15 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] In the 1930s, a wealthy Yemenese trader (“the Settlor”) made provisions to distribute the income from his large portfolio of immovable properties in Singapore amongst his family members and their offspring (“the Settlement”). Under the Settlement, each son and daughter of the Settlor would receive two and one portion of the net income of the Settlement respectively, which portion(s) would be passed on to their offspring in a 2:1 ratio that favours male offspring. Each portion would continue being passed on to subsequent offspring within each beneficiary’s lineage unless the beneficiary dies without an offspring or marries out of the Muslim faith.

  2. [2] In the last two decades, four beneficiaries have had their lineages broken in the following manner:

  3. (a) Hana Bte Salem Taleb (“Hana”), who was married to a non-Muslim at the time of her father’s passing in 2001, and who was thus deemed to have died without offspring under the Settlement;

  4. (b) Noor Bte Ali Bin Sallim Bin Talib (“Noor”), who passed away in 2003 without any offspring;

  5. (c) Salleh Bin Amir Talib (“Salleh”), who passed away in 2008 without any offspring; and

  6. (d) Shafeeq bin Salim Talib (“Shafeeq”), who passed away in 2014 without any offspring.

  7. [3] How should the interests of beneficiaries who died without offspring be distributed? After obtaining legal advice, the British and Malayan Trustees Ltd (“the Trustee”) decided to divide and hold the shares of the four beneficiaries (see [2] above) amongst all the surviving income beneficiaries under the Settlement (“the pari passu interpretation”). However, upon Shafeeq’s death in 2014, questions began arising as regards the correctness of the pari passu interpretation.

  8. [4] Being unable to resolve the issue of the proper interpretation under the Settlement, the Trustee took out Originating Summons No 163 of 2019 (“OS 163”). After considering the conflicting legal opinions put forth by the parties, I held that the pari passu interpretation was incorrect. Instead, where a beneficiary like Shafeeq passes away without offspring, his or her share ought to accrue to other beneficiaries who own shares under the same lineage (or portion) (“the branch interpretation”). In other words, Shafeeq’s share under the Settlement ought to remain within his mother Aisha’s portion, in the sense that it ought to accrue to his siblings, who were the surviving beneficiaries under Aisha’s lineage, rather than split amongst all beneficiaries under the Settlement (see British Malayan Trustees v Lutfi Salim bin Talib and others [2019] SGHC 270 at [51]).

  9. [5] My decision in OS 163 was not appealed against. As such, owing to the incorrect application of the pari passu interpretation in respect of Hana’s, Noor’s, Salleh’s, and Shafeeq’s shares, most beneficiaries have been overpaid, while some beneficiaries (eg, Shafeeq’s siblings) have been underpaid over the years. After some accounting, the extent of overpayment (and concomitant underpayment) to the beneficiaries between November 2001 and November 2019 amounted to $2,959,842.

  10. [6] Given the extent of overpayment and underpayment, the Trustee has taken out the present Originating Summons (“OS 288”), seeking directions on whether they may “exercise the [T]rustee’s right of equitable recoupment in relation to the past distributions of income … paid to the beneficiaries under a mistaken construction of the terms of the Settlement, … and, if so, the terms on which such said recoupment is to be exercised”.

  11. [7] In this judgment, I deal with an interlocutory application by five overpaid beneficiaries, namely the 1st to 5th Respondents (“the Group 1 Respondents”), pursuant to O 15 r 13(2)(c) of the Rules of Court 2014 (“ROC 2014”). The rule provides that the Court may allow certain persons to represent any person or class if “it appears to the Court expedient (regard being had to all the circumstances, including the amount at stake and the degree of difficulty of the point to be determined) to exercise the power for the purpose of saving expense” [emphasis added].

  12. [8] According to the Group 1 Respondents, the application should be granted for parity with OS 163, where a similar application was granted by consent. The prior consent, it is said, leads to “the natural inference” that the present application is necessary “for the purpose of saving expenses” as the present OS follows from my decision in OS 163. This is subject to the caveat that the Group 1 Respondents are agreeable for one Mr Mustafa bin Mohsin bin Salim Talib (“Mr Mustafa”) to be excluded from the list of beneficiaries whom they will be representing. Mr Mustafa is an overpaid beneficiary pursuant to the incorrect application of the pari passu interpretation, but he supports the proposal of repayment to the underpaid beneficiaries from 2014, being the date when the Shafeeq’s siblings first challenged the pari passu interpretation, which had gone unchallenged until then.

  13. [10] First, unlike OS 163, where it was not difficult to distinguish between the two groups (ie, those advocating for the pari passu interpretation and those advocating for the branch interpretation), I agree with the Trustee that it is not clear in OS 288 whether the “interests and positions of all the beneficiaries can be clearly delineated”. Even if it is held that the Trustee can exercise its right of equitable recoupment, and even if such right can be practically exercised as against all overpaid beneficiaries (ie, all beneficiaries under the pari passu interpretation), it cannot be said that all overpaid beneficiaries will adopt a similar stance as regards the recoupment. There are at least three classes of overpaid beneficiaries, namely:

  14. (a) beneficiaries who resist the recoupment entirely;

  15. (b) beneficiaries like Mr Mustafa who may be agreeable to some recoupment, for example up to 2014, when the pari passu method of distribution was first challenged; and

  16. (c) beneficiaries who do not resist the recoupment at all, whether because of reasons of equity and fairness or otherwise.

  17. [11] Differences may also occur within the above sub-classes. For example, beneficiaries who are agreeable to some recoupment may differ as to the time in which such recoupment should be cut-off. For this reason, it is not possible to interpret the lack of response by the remaining non-Respondent beneficiaries as intimating consent to whatever position that the Group 1 Respondents will be taking. This is particularly so as the position to be taken by the Group 1 Respondents has not been finalised and may be changed upon deeper research of the relevant authorities as regards the issue of equitable recoupment. Given this, sub-divisions may also form within the Group 1 Respondents at a later stage.

  18. [12] Furthermore, since Hana’s, Noor’s, Salleh’s, and Shafeeq’s shares were all incorrectly distributed pursuant to the pari passu interpretation, it is reasonable to infer that at least some of the remaining 77 non-Respondent beneficiaries will be underpaid, rather than overpaid, beneficiaries. Accordingly, it is likelier that such underpaid beneficiaries would have positions that align closer to those of the 6th and 7th Respondents (“the Group 2 Respondents”), which includes Lutfi Salim bin Talib, Shafeeq’s brother. In addition, sub-groups may also arise amongst the underpaid beneficiaries, for instance as to the appropriate start date for the repayment (if any). It may be envisaged in this regard that beneficiaries sharing Hana’s lineage would advocate for a start date of 2001, when she was deemed to have passed without offspring, while Shafeeq’s siblings would be content to have a start date of 2014, when Shafeeq passed, since an earlier date would have no practical impact on them.

  19. [14] Put simply, there was more than ample opportunity for interested beneficiaries to be added as Respondents in this OS. Against this, the Group 1 Respondents submit that the majority of beneficiaries are located in Singapore and Yemen, and due to the ongoing conflict and civil war in Yemen, the Trustee has experienced difficulty in communicating with the beneficiaries located there. This may have hindered the ability of certain beneficiaries to contact the Trustee to indicate their intention to participate in these proceedings.

  20. [16] To this, the Group 1 Respondents submit that the non-Respondent beneficiaries “may not be comfortable with [the Trustee] representing their interests in OS 288”. Again, this is entirely speculative, and goes against the grain of the Trustee Circulars sent by the Trustee, which explained that the Trustee was not seeking to represent the interests of the beneficiaries. Rather, by the circulars, interested beneficiaries were invited to indicate their interest so that they may be added as Respondents to OS 288 and to provide their viewpoints for the Court’s consideration.

  21. [17] Thirdly, and related to the above, it appears improper for the Group 1 Respondents to purport to represent all remaining beneficiaries in the present OS. O 80 r 3 of ROC 2014 provides the mechanism for interested beneficiaries to be added to the OS, and this was the basis by which the Group 1 and 2 Respondents were joined to these proceedings. It also does not appear necessary, nor is it “expedient … for the purpose of saving expense” (O 15 r 13(2)(c) of ROC 2014) for the remaining beneficiaries to be added as respondents to OS 288. The present OS has been taken out pursuant to O 80 r 2 of ROC 2014, for a determination of an issue pertaining to the administration of the Settlement. This is significant, because whereas O 15 r 4(2) of ROC 2014 provides that “[w]here the plaintiff in any action claims any relief to which any other person is entitled jointly with him, all persons so entitled must … be parties to the action and any of them who does not consent to being joined as a plaintiff must … be made a defendant”, O 80 r 3(2) provides an exception to this general rule:

  22. [18] In other words, for the purposes of the present OS, there is no necessity for the remaining beneficiaries to be added as parties to the action. The mechanism is also clearly in place for any interested beneficiary to be added as a respondent and to provide his or her viewpoint. Despite this and notwithstanding multiple notices by the Trustee for interested beneficiaries to indicate their interest, only the seven Respondents have indicated their interest to being added as parties to this action.