General Division of the High Court · Decided 25 November 2022
Anpex Pte Ltd v Cheng Yong Sun and another
Feedback & support[2022] SGHC 294 · Case no. Suit No 415 of 2021 · 3 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [5]
[5] There was however, also a possibility that s 14(3)(a) of the Act was satisfied. I had previously found in the Substantive Judgment that the first and second defendant misappropriated a total of $578,347.30 from the plaintiff. The second defendant likely had a substantial sum of monies in her bank account, and there was evidence that from August to October 2020, she made several large purchases of jewellery, cosmetic products and beauty services. In the circumstances, there was thus a possibility that she had also obtained legal aid by fraud or misrepresentation, satisfying s 14(3)(a) of the Act. I asked for evidence of how legal aid was applied and approved.
- [6]
[6] Ms Suriakumari Sidambaram (“Ms Sidambaram”), an Assistant Director of Legal Aid from the Legal Aid Bureau (“LAB”), helpfully filed an affidavit explaining the criteria for means-testing and the second defendant’s legal aid application. In particular, Ms Sidambaram confirmed that at the time the second defendant applied for legal aid in May 2021, the second defendant met the criteria as her savings and non-CPF investments were $10,000 or lower, and that she did not own any other property besides her HDB flat. Ms Sidambaram also stated that the second defendant was not asked to furnish her bank statements prior to April 2021, as a legal aid applicant’s wealth is determined at the point of application for legal aid. There was also no reason to suspect that she earned a salary above what was declared in her CPF statements. LAB also did not have any information that the second defendant was concealing assets.
- [7]
[7] From the evidence, I am satisfied that the second defendant was technically entitled to legal aid at the material time. While the second defendant might have had more monies in her bank account at an earlier time, she likely had spent it all by the time that she made her application for legal aid in May 2021, as evidenced by her large purchases from August to October 2020. This did not exclude her from legal aid, as only her bank statements prior to the month of her application were required to be furnished for her application for legal aid.