General Division of the High Court · Decided 15 August 2024
VMax Marine Pte Ltd v Singapore Salvage Engineers Pte Ltd and another appeal
Feedback & support[2024] SGHC 208 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 40 of 2023 · 4 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background
- [2]
[2] In DC/DC 779/2021 (“DC 779”), VMax brought claims against Singapore Salvage Engineers Pte Ltd (“SSE”), arising out of a contract for salvage master and consultancy services. SSE counterclaimed, alleging that VMax had breached the same contract. The learned District Judge (“DJ”) dismissed all of VMax’s claims and allowed SSE’s counterclaim in part. VMax and SSE appealed against the DJ’s decision, in HC/DCA 40/2023 (“DCA 40”) and HC/DCA 41/2023 (“DCA 41”) respectively.
VMax’s case
SSE’s case
Decision
- [11]
[11] There are three issues to be determined.
(a) First, whether this Court has the jurisdiction to receive and consider VMax’s costs appeal. This raises the question of when a Court is considered functus officio.
Whether this Court is functus officio
- [15]
[15] O. 42, r. 10 of our ROC 2014, draws on similar concepts as that in Re Harrison and Rule 40.2(2)(b) of the UK CPR. It states:
- [16]
[16] The learned authors of Singapore Civil Procedure 2020 vol 1 (Cavinder Bull gen. ed.) (Sweet & Maxwell, 2020) (“White Book”), state at paras 42/5/8 and 57/1/33:
Whether VMax is disentitled from raising an appeal against the costs order below
(b) In Ser Kim Koi, the plaintiff asked to be allowed to file a single notice of appeal in respect of both the main judgment and the costs judgment (at [6]). The court agreed. The plaintiff eventually filed two separate notices of appeal, in relation to the main judgment and the costs judgment.
(c) In The “Luna”, the appellant had applied for leave to amend the notice of appeal they previously filed in respect of the merits, to include an appeal against costs (at [92]).
Whether this Court should exercise its direction to vary the costs order
Kwek Mean LuckJudge of the High Court