General Division of the High Court · Decided 23 June 2026
Mild intellectual disability did not rebut presumed knowledge; importation proved
Public Prosecutor v Thina Vengades Rao
Feedback & support[2026] SGHC 137 · Case no. Criminal Case No 16 of 2025
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
Mild intellectual disability did not rebut presumed knowledge; importation proved
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [154], [156], [157]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Laws this judgment relies on
Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The accused, Mr Thina Vengades Rao (“the Accused”), is a 29-year-old Malaysian male. He claimed trial to the following two charges of importing controlled drugs without authorisation, in contravention of s 7 of the Misuse of Drugs Act (Cap 185, 2008 Rev Ed) (“MDA”):
(a) the first charge pertained to ten packets containing not less than 4,512.6g of granular/powdery substance that had been analysed and found to contain not less than 42.18g of diamorphine; and
(b) the second charge pertained to one packet containing not less than 490.4g of crystalline substance that had been analysed and found to contain not less than 330.8g of methamphetamine.
- [2]
[2] After a ten-day trial, I found the Accused guilty of both charges and convicted him accordingly. Upon conviction, I sentenced him to a global sentence of life imprisonment and 24 strokes of the cane. The reasons for my decision are set out below.
Facts
- [3]
[3] At the material time, the Accused worked as a lorry attendant for a Malaysian company based in Johor Bahru – Dickson Agro Trading (“Dickson Agro”) – that delivers bean sprouts to Singapore. His job involved assisting with loading bean sprouts onto a lorry in Johor Bahru and accompanying the lorry to Singapore.
- [4]
[4] On 18 December 2020, the Accused accompanied one of Dickson Agro’s lorries (“Lorry”) from Johor Bahru to Singapore. The Accused sat at the front passenger seat of the Lorry, which was driven by his colleague (“Lorry Driver”). The Lorry arrived at Woodlands Checkpoint at 5.43pm, at which time the police were conducting routine operations at the Cargo Clearance Centre (“CCC”) for lorry arrivals. At about 5.50pm, police officers directed the Lorry aside for an inspection. They then proceeded to conduct checks on the Lorry Driver while an officer from the Singapore Immigration and Checkpoints Authority, Checkpoint Inspector 2 R Subramaniam (“CI2 Subra”), conducted checks on the Accused.
- [5]
[5] After getting the Accused to alight from the Lorry, CI2 Subra climbed up the passenger side of the Lorry’s cabin. Kneeling on the seat of the front passenger seat, CI2 Subra proceeded to inspect the space behind the front passenger seat (ie, behind the backrest). For better visualisation of the front passenger seat, two photographs of the Lorry’s cabin (captured from the passenger’s side) are set out below. The right photograph shows the front passenger seat with its backrest folded down, allowing the viewer to see the space behind it:
- [6]
[6] When CI2 Subra shone his torch into the space behind the front passenger seat, he spotted a dark blue bag bearing the Nike brand (“Blue Nike Bag”).5 He then climbed down from the Lorry’s cabin and asked the Accused to retrieve the Blue Nike Bag from behind the front passenger seat. The Accused replied that the Blue Nike Bag was too heavy, to which CI2 Subra insisted that he retrieve it. The Accused thus climbed up the Lorry’s cabin to retrieve the Blue Nike Bag from behind the front passenger seat. It was undisputed that at this point, the Blue Nike Bag contained bundles wrapped in black tape – referred to in this judgment as “black bundles”. The Accused took a few minutes to retrieve the Blue Nike Bag from behind the front passenger seat, prompting CI2 Subra to query about the delay. The Accused replied that the Blue Nike Bag was stuck. Eventually, the Accused managed to get the Blue Nike Bag out from behind the front passenger seat and passed the same to CI2 Subra.
- [7]
[7] It was from this point that the accounts of the Prosecution and Defence witnesses materially diverged:
(a) According to CI2 Subra, when the Accused handed the Blue Nike Bag to him, CI2 Subra had shone his torch into it only to see that it was empty. Sensing that something was amiss, CI2 Subra climbed up the passenger side of the Lorry’s cabin and, once again, shone his torch into the space behind the front passenger seat. This time, he spotted the black bundles there. CI2 Subra reached behind the front passenger seat to take out one of the black bundles. He showed the black bundle to the Accused and asked him what it was, to which the Accused replied that he did not know. CI2 Subra placed the black bundle on the seat of the front passenger seat and reached behind the front passenger seat to take out a second black bundle. CI2 Subra asked the Accused what this second black bundle was, to which the Accused again replied that he did not know. CI2 Subra then placed the second black bundle on the seat of the front passenger seat, together with the first black bundle. According to CI2 Subra, even after he had taken these two black bundles out from behind the front passenger seat and (after showing them to the Accused) placed them on the seat of the front passenger seat, there were still more black bundles in the space behind the front passenger seat.
(b) The Accused, on his part, explained that he had taken some time to retrieve the Blue Nike Bag because it was stuck behind the front passenger seat. To release the Blue Nike Bag, he had to tug at it with some force. This caused the zipper to come open, allowing the black bundles to tumble out of the Blue Nike Bag. Still, the Accused maintained that (contrary to CI2 Subra’s account), the Blue Nike Bag was not empty when he passed it to CI2 Subra. The Accused maintained that even after the black bundles tumbled out of the Blue Nike Bag, there was still one black bundle remaining in it when he handed the Blue Nike Bag to CI2 Subra.
- [8]
[8] Suspecting that the black bundles contained drugs, CI2 Subra had then notified the Central Narcotics Bureau (“CNB”). At around 6.10pm, three CNB officers – Woman Staff Sergeant Goh Li May (“W/SSgt Goh”), Staff Sergeant Muhammad Munawwar bin Mohamed Ismail (“SSgt Munawwar”), and Staff Sergeant Abdul Hafiz bin Roslan (“SSgt Hafiz”) – arrived at the CCC. SSgt Hafiz noticed that the Blue Nike Bag was placed on the seat of the front passenger seat, along with the two black bundles that CI2 Subra had retrieved from behind the front passenger seat and shown to the Accused. SSgt Hafiz also spotted more black bundles in the space behind the front passenger seat. He then took one of the two bundles that CI2 Subra had placed on the seat of the front passenger seat and asked the Accused if he knew what it contained. The Accused replied “chemical”. SSgt Hafiz then used a scalpel to make a cut in the black bundle and saw brownish granular substance inside. SSgt Hafiz showed this to the Accused and asked if the latter maintained his answer, to which the Accused repeated his response: “chemical”. SSgt Hafiz then proceeded to retrieve the remaining black bundles from behind the front passenger seat. According to SSgt Hafiz, he retrieved an additional five black bundles from behind the front passenger seat which, together with the two black bundles that CI2 Subra had taken out and placed on the seat of the front passenger seat, amounted to a total of seven black bundles. After ascertaining that there were no more black bundles in the Lorry’s cabin, SSgt Hafiz seized the seven black bundles and placed them in a resealable bag. The Blue Nike Bag was also seized. The Accused and the Lorry Driver, as well as the seized items, were brought to the CCC office where SSgt Hafiz recorded the Accused’s first contemporaneous statement (“1st Contemporaneous Statement”).14
- [9]
[9] Thereafter, the seven black bundles were transported to the CNB Headquarters for processing, where they were found to contain: (a) ten packets of granular/powdery substance; and (b) one packet of crystalline substance. These were despatched to the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”) for analysis. The HSA subsequently issued reports confirming that:
(a) the ten packets of granular/powdery substance were collectively found to contain not less than 42.18g of diamorphine; and
(b) the packet of crystalline substance was found to contain not less than 330.8g of methamphetamine.
- [10]
[10] A urine sample was also taken from the Accused for testing. This was subsequently found to contain methamphetamine.
Parties’ cases
- [11]
[11] It was not in dispute that the Accused was in possession of the Blue Nike Bag and that he knew that this contained the black bundles, although he claimed not to have known exactly how many black bundles were in the Blue Nike Bag. Arising from these facts, two statutory presumptions were at play:
(a) the presumption of possession in s 18(1)(a) of the MDA, which the Prosecution relied on to establish that the Accused was in possession of the drugs in the black bundles; and
(b) the presumption of knowledge in s 18(2) of the MDA, which the Prosecution relied on to establish that the Accused knew the nature of those drugs.
Defence’s case
- [12]
[12] The Accused sought to rebut these presumptions by claiming that he thought the black bundles contained chemicals for cleaning toilets. Specifically, he claimed that one “Deva” had passed him the Blue Nike Bag while they were in Johor Bahru and asked him to bring it to Singapore, where the Accused was to then pass it to Deva’s brother “Mages”. According to the Accused, Deva had informed him that the black bundles contained chemicals that could cause a virus if touched – an explanation which the Accused claimed to have believed. The Accused testified that when Deva handed him the Blue Nike Bag, Deva assured him that the chemicals in the black bundles would not cause any issues at the customs checkpoint – the customs authorities would at the very most discard the chemicals if they were not allowed to be brought in.
- [13]
[13] Fuller details of the Accused’s account as to how he came to deliver the black bundles for Deva were set out in his second long statement recorded by the CNB on 26 December 2020 (“2nd Long Statement”). The most salient portions of the 2nd Long Statement are set out below:
(a) On the evening of 17 December 2020, ie, the day before the arrest, the Accused was attending a friend’s party in Johor Bahru. There, he was introduced to Deva. Deva had asked if the Accused could deliver food and clothing to Deva’s brother, Mages, in Singapore. The Accused agreed. Deva had then asked for the Accused’s contact number, which the Accused provided. The relevant section of the 2nd Long Statement is extracted below:
The party ended at about 4–5am on the morning of 18 December 2020, ie, the day of the Accused’s arrest.
(b) At about 12 noon on 18 December 2020, Deva communicated- with the Accused via WhatsApp, repeating his query as to whether the Accused could make the delivery to Mages in Singapore. However, this time, he asked if the Accused could deliver chemicals (as opposed to food and clothing) to Mages. Deva also asked the Accused if the customs authorities would be fine with this, to which the Accused replied that the items would be allowed into Singapore so long as they were permitted by the customs authorities. The relevant portion of the 2nd Long Statement is set out below:
(c) At about 4pm, Deva turned up at the factory in Johor Bahru where the Accused worked and met with him. During the meeting, Deva passed the Accused the Blue Nike Bag, asking him to bring it to Singapore and pass it to Mages at Kranji MRT station. The Accused opened the Blue Nike Bag and saw the black bundles inside. This was the first time that the Accused had seen such bundles wrapped in black tape, not ever having seen such black-taped bundles before. He had then taken one of the black bundles out of the Blue Nike Bag and asked Deva what it was. Deva replied that the black bundles contained dangerous chemicals that could transmit a virus if touched, to which the Accused promptly dropped the black bundle back into the Blue Nike Bag. The relevant portion of the 2nd Long Statement is as follows:
The Accused was not told by Deva how many black bundles were in the Blue Nike Bag, nor did the Accused count them.29
(d) The Accused then took the Blue Nike Bag from Deva and placed it behind the front passenger seat of the Lorry. Less than two hours thereafter, the Lorry was ferrying the Accused and the Blue Nike Bag to Singapore, where the Accused was arrested at the Woodlands CCC.
- [14]
[14] In his third long statement recorded on 28 December 2020 (“3rd Long Statement”), the Accused elaborated further on what Deva told him about the black bundles. Specifically, the Accused recounted how Deva told him that the black bundles contained chemicals for washing toilets and were dangerous, as anyone touching them could contract skin problems and a virus. The relevant portion of the 3rd Long Statement is set out below:
During the trial, the Accused retracted the portion of the 3rd Long Statement where he recounted that Deva told him that the chemicals were for washing toilets. The Accused clarified that while Deva told him that the black bundles contained chemicals that could cause a virus, Deva did not elaborate that the chemicals were for washing toilets. Rather, the Accused clarified that it was the Accused himself who surmised that the chemicals were meant for washing toilets.
- [15]
[15] The Defence also contended that the Accused suffered from mild intellectual disability (“ID”) and that this condition rendered him more gullible than others. According to the Defence, this explained why the Accused had been particularly trusting of Deva when the latter told him about the contents of the black bundles, when normal people might have questioned Deva’s motives.
- [16]
[16] Furthermore, the Defence submitted that the chain of custody over the drugs had not been proven by the Prosecution beyond reasonable doubt.
Prosecution’s case
- [17]
[17] The Prosecution’s case was that the Accused knew that the black bundles contained drugs. It submitted that quite apart from the operation of the presumption of knowledge at [11(b)] above, the evidence sufficed to prove that the Accused knew about the nature of the drugs in the black bundles. To support this contention, the Prosecution raised the following factors:
(b) The constant evolution in the Accused’s account of what he thought the black bundles contained.
(c) Various circumstances that rendered the Accused’s claim of being ignorant about the black bundles’ contents implausible.
- [18]
[18] The Prosecution also rejected the Defence’s claim that the Accused suffered from mild ID, maintaining that he did not have ID and was, in any case, not so gullible as to have been misled by Deva about the contents of the black bundles.
- [19]
[19] Finally, the Prosecution maintained that the chain of custody had remained intact from the seizure of the seven black bundles until the point when the packets of drugs in them were sent to the HSA for testing.
My decision
- [20]
[20] I begin with an overview of the law on drug importation under s 7 of the MDA. This offence has three elements – see Adili Chibuike Ejike v Public Prosecutor [2019] 2 SLR 254 (“Adili Chibuike Ejike”) at [27]:
- [21]
[21] It was undisputed that the Accused lacked authorisation to import the drugs in the black bundles. As such, the elements which were contested in this case were the possession requirement and the knowledge requirement. The key issues in this case were thus as follows:
(1) Whether the possession requirement was satisfied, ie, whether the Accused could be regarded as having been in possession of the drugs in the black bundles when he transported them to Singapore.
(2) Related to issue (1), whether the chain of custody over the black bundles and the packets of drugs extracted therefrom had been sufficiently established, such that what was in the Accused’s possession could be linked to the HSA reports at [9] (which certified the drugs as containing not less than 42.18g of diamorphine and not less than 330.8g of methamphetamine).
(3) Whether the knowledge requirement was satisfied – ie, whether the Accused could be regarded as having known of the nature of the drugs, if they were indeed in his possession.
(4) Related to issue (3) above, whether the Defence had successfully demonstrated that the Accused suffered from mild ID and, if so, the impact this would have on the knowledge requirement.
My conclusions on each of these four issues are set out below.
Issue 1: Whether the Accused was in possession of the drugs
- [22]
[22] The Accused was – without a doubt – in possession of the Blue Nike Bag as he had intentionally transported the same. The next question was whether he was in possession of the black bundles in it. For that, he must have been aware at the material time that the black bundles were in his physical possession. As explained in Adili Chibuike Ejike (at [31]):
- [23]
[23] In the present case, the Accused clearly knew that the black bundles were in the Blue Nike Bag. Upon receiving the Blue Nike Bag from Deva, he had opened it and taken out one of the black bundles to ask Deva about it – see [13(c)] above. The Accused must thus be regarded as having been in possession of the black bundles at the material time. His possession of the black bundles in turn triggered the presumption under s 18(1)(a) of the MDA, which reads:
As the drugs were contained in the black bundles, the operation of s 18(1)(a) of the MDA meant that the Accused was presumed to be in possession of these drugs.
- [24]
[24] The Defence’s submissions contended that the statutory presumptions under, inter alia, s 18(1) of the MDA had been rebutted. Yet, these submissions offered no explanation whatsoever as to just how it had been rebutted. In attempting to make sense of the Defence’s contention, I noted that an accused person can rebut the presumption of possession by demonstrating that the drugs were planted in his bag or vehicle – see Obeng Comfort v Public Prosecutor [2017] 1 SLR 633 (“Obeng Comfort”) at [35]. Under such circumstances, he cannot be said to have known that the drugs were in his physical possession. Viewed from this lens, there appeared to be one angle which neither the Defence nor the Prosecution had touched upon. As explained at [7(b)] above, the Accused claimed that as he was attempting to retrieve the Blue Nike Bag, its zipper came open, allowing the black bundles inside to tumble into the space behind the front passenger seat. This then had to be juxtaposed against the Accused’s position that he did not know exactly how many black bundles were in the Blue Nike Bag – he claimed only to have known that there were multiple black bundles in it. That being the case, was it possible for any of the black bundles seized from behind the front passenger seat (see [8] above) not to have dropped from the Blue Nike Bag? Put another way, could any of the black bundles found behind the front passenger seat have been planted there by someone other than the Accused, prior to the Lorry’s departure to Singapore? If so, this could potentially pose an obstacle to establishing the possession requirement, at least in respect of any such planted bundle(s).
- [25]
[25] While this was not the case run by the Defence at trial, I nevertheless examined this issue for completeness. In doing so, I noted that when SSgt Hafiz recorded the 1st Contemporaneous Statement on the evening of the arrest, he specifically asked the Accused:
A perusal of the 1st Contemporaneous Statement clearly showed that the Accused’s possession of all seven black bundles was never in issue. SSgt Hafiz had referred to the “7 black bundles” and the Accused, in the course of his answer, alluded to the Blue Nike Bag containing “all the black bundles” which, viewed against the immediately preceding context, must have been a reference to the “7 black bundles” that SSgt Hafiz had just referred the Accused to.
- [26]
[26] More importantly, the thrust of the Accused’s case was that all the black bundles came from Deva, with nothing on the record to suggest that Deva (or anyone acting on Deva’s behalf) might have climbed up the Lorry and planted any of the black bundles into the space behind the front passenger seat.
- [27]
[27] I therefore concluded that the Accused had failed to rebut the presumption under s 18(1)(a) of the MDA. In other words, the presumption that the Accused was in possession of the drugs in the black bundles – triggered by proof of his possession of the black bundles – stood unrebutted.
Issue 2: Whether the chain of custody was broken
- [28]
[28] A further contention raised by the Accused pertained to the chain of custody over the drugs after they were seized from the Lorry’s cabin. Even if the Accused was in possession of the drugs in the seven black bundles, the importation charges would be undermined if a reasonable doubt existed as to whether the drugs seized from the Lorry:
(a) might not be the same drugs sent; or
(b) might have been contaminated prior to being sent,
to the HSA for testing. Such reasonable doubt would certainly stand in the way of me ruling that the Accused was in possession of the drugs that were the subject of the HSA reports at [9] above, upon which the charges were premised.
- [29]
[29] It is trite that the Prosecution bears the burden of proving, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the drugs analysed by the HSA were indeed the ones seized from the Accused. In Mohamed Affandi bin Rosli v Public Prosecutor [2019] 1 SLR 440 (“Affandi”), the Court of Appeal explained (at [39]):
- [30]
[30] The Court of Appeal in Affandi also cited (at [41]) the case of Lai Kam Loy v Public Prosecutor [1993] 3 SLR(R) 143, where the Court of Appeal admonished (at [38]) that:
Notwithstanding this, the Prosecution in the present case did adduce evidence from every individual who handled the seven black bundles, as well as the packets of drugs extracted therefrom, to demonstrate an unbroken chain of custody from the point of seizure of the black bundles to the point when the packets of drugs therein were sent to the HSA for analysis. From the evidence, the following chain of events that can be pieced together:
(a) As explained at [7(a)] above, CI2 Subra’s evidence was that he had taken two of the black bundles from behind the front passenger seat and shown them to the Accused, before placing them on the seat of the front passenger seat. He then left both the black bundles there, with the other black bundles remaining behind the front passenger seat.
(b) CI2 Subra was then relieved by the CNB officers arriving at the scene. They included SSgt Hafiz, who saw the two black bundles placed by CI2 Subra on the seat of the front passenger seat, as well as the black bundles behind the front passenger seat. As explained at [8] above, SSgt Hafiz retrieved five black bundles from behind the front passenger seat. During this process, the Accused was standing outside the passenger side door and could see SSgt Hafiz retrieving the black bundles. SSgt Hafiz then placed all seven bundles in an empty resealable bag.
(c) W/SSgt Goh then took custody of the seven black bundles and the Blue Nike Bag, after which the party returned to the CCC office with the Accused and the Lorry Driver. There, W/SSgt Goh had at two junctures handed the seven black bundles to her fellow CNB officers for purposes of statement-taking:
(i) At around 6.59pm, she handed the seven black bundles to SSgt Munawwar to facilitate the recording of the Lorry Driver’s contemporaneous statement. After showing the seven black bundles to the Lorry Driver, SSgt Munawwar returned them to W/SSgt Goh.
(ii) Shortly after, at around 7.19pm, she handed the seven black bundles to SSgt Hafiz to facilitate the recording of the 1st Contemporaneous Statement from the Accused. Upon conclusion of the recording of the statement at 8.13pm, SSgt Hafiz returned the seven black bundles to W/SSgt Goh.
(d) At about 8.43pm, at the CCC office, W/SSgt Goh handed the seven black bundles to Woman Senior Staff Sergeant Siti Hawa binte Sulaiman (“W/SSSgt Siti”), who brought them to the CNB’s B3 office. At about 9.44pm, W/SSSgt Siti placed each black bundle and the Blue Nike Bag into individual tamper-proof bags and sealed the same, in W/SSgt Goh’s presence, before putting the seven black bundles into a locked cabinet.
(e) About 5½ hours later, at about 4.10am on 19 December 2020, W/SSSgt Siti withdrew the seven black bundles from the locked cabinet and handed them to Assistant Superintendent Ng Zhi Hao (“ASP Ng”). ASP Ng also took over custody of the Accused and the Lorry Driver and escorted them from the Woodlands Checkpoint to the Tanglin Police Divisional Headquarters, where he left both men to serve a “Stay-Home Notice” pursuant to COVID-19 measures.
(f) Thereafter, ASP Ng brought the seven black bundles back to the CNB Headquarters where, at about 6.03am, he handed them to Woman Inspector Tan Lye Cheng, Michelle (“Insp Michelle”).
- [31]
[31] At 6.07am, Insp Michelle and three other CNB officers commenced the processing of the seven black bundles, within the Exhibit Management Room (“EM Room”). As to what happened during the processing, this could be gleaned from the evidence of Insp Michelle and the three other CNB officers, ie, Assistant Superintendent Fernandez Anthony Leo (“ASP Anthony”), XT3 Haifaa binte Mohamed Anwar (“XT3 Haifaa”) and XT3 Lee Jia Ying, Cheryl (“XT3 Cheryl”). The processing of the seven black bundles was executed as follows:
(a) The seven black bundles and the Blue Nike Bag were placed on clean sheets of brown paper, with labels placed against each item, and photographed. The Blue Nike Bag was labelled as “A1” while the seven black bundles were respectively labelled as “A2” to “A8”.
(b) XT3 Haifaa and XT3 Cheryl had then proceeded to cut the wrappings of the black bundles to take out their contents. XT3 Haifaa explained that prior to cutting the black bundles, she noticed that one of them had “a partially cut mark”, although she did not specifically relate this to the cut that SSgt Hafiz had made with a scalpel on one of the black bundles (see [8] above). Upon cutting the seven black bundles open, it was found that:
(i) A2 and A8 each contained one packet of brown granular/powdery substance;
(ii) A3, A4, A6 and A7 each contained two packets of brown granular/powdery substance; and
(iii) A5 contained (inter alia) one packet of white crystalline substance.
The seven black bundles were thus found to collectively contain ten packets of brown granular/powdery substance and one packet of white crystalline substance (collectively, “the 11 Packets”).
(c) As XT3 Haifaa and XT3 Cheryl were cutting the seven black bundles open to extract the 11 Packets, they found that all of the 11 Packets were leaking. XT3 Haifaa testified that she could not tell if the leak was caused by their act of cutting of the black bundles open (to take the 11 Packets out) or whether the 11 Packets were already leaking before that. The 11 Packets were then swabbed by XT3 Haifaa for DNA and photographed by XT3 Cheryl. Given the leakage, powdery residue could be seen on the brown paper when the 11 Packets were being photographed. Thereafter, the 11 Packets were placed in resealable bags to preserve exhibit integrity, with the residue placed in the resealable bag containing the specific packet from which the residue had leaked.
- [32]
[32] The processing of the seven black bundles (and the 11 Packets extracted therefrom) ended at around 10.08am, following which XT3 Haifaa and XT3 Cheryl left for other duties. As for Insp Michelle and ASP Anthony, they remained in the EM Room from about 10.15am to about 10.20am to weigh the 11 Packets. Insp Michelle recorded the weight values in the investigation diary. After the weighing was done, the tamper-proof bags containing the 11 Packets were then sealed. As it was already Saturday morning, Insp Michelle brought the 11 Packets to her office within the CNB Headquarters and locked them inside, before leaving for the weekend. Only she could unlock her office as she held the only key.
- [33]
[33] On the morning of Monday, 21 December 2020, Insp Michelle returned to her office and retrieved the 11 Packets, which then passed through the following hands:
(a) At about 9.30am, Insp Michelle handed all the case exhibits (including the 11 Packets) to Inspector Muhammed Ridlwan bin Mohamed Raffi (“Insp Ridlwan”).
(b) At about 10.28am, Insp Ridlwan handed the case exhibits (including the 11 Packets) to Sergeant (3) Kovalan s/o Gopala Krishna (“Sgt Kovalan”) at the CNB Exhibit Management Team (“EMT”) office. Sgt Kovalan placed the 11 Packets inside a locked metal cabinet in the EMT office and kept the key to the cabinet.
(c) Sometime before 4.55pm, Sgt Kovalan retrieved the 11 Packets from the locked metal cabinet in the EMT office and handed them to Sergeant (3) Muhammad Sufyan bin Mohamed Khairolzaman (“Sgt Sufyan”). At 4.55pm, Sgt Sufyan handed the 11 Packets to the HSA Illicit Drugs Laboratory for analysis.
- [34]
[34] Notwithstanding the evidence above, the Defence raised the following issues to cast doubt on whether the chain of custody was indeed intact:
(a) Firstly, the Defence argued that there were questions as to how many black bundles were inside the Blue Nike Bag, especially since the Accused claimed not to have even known just how many black bundles were in it (see [24] above).
(b) Secondly, the Defence argued that there was uncertainty about the circumstances surrounding the custody of the black bundles while they were still at the Woodlands Checkpoint, given the following:84
(i) No photographs were taken of the black bundles when they were at the Woodlands Checkpoint.
(ii) After being removed from the Lorry, the black bundles were locked in a cabinet in the CNB’s B3 office at Woodlands Checkpoint by W/SSSgt Siti (see [30(d)] above). Yet, Insp Michelle made no checks on the black bundles while they were locked in that cabinet.
(c) Thirdly, the Defence challenged the process by which the black bundles and the 11 Packets within them had been processed by Insp Michelle and the three other CNB officers at the EM Room in the CNB Headquarters. Specifically, the Defence contended that the processing suffered from the following irregularities:
(i) The Accused was not present in the EM Room during the processing of the seven black bundles.
(ii) During the processing, powdery residue from the drug exhibits had leaked onto the brown paper (see [31(c)] above). Yet, there were no photographs focusing specifically on the spillage, ie, in isolation from the 11 Packets. This, argued the Defence, gave rise to questions as to whether the spillage was only from some of the 11 Packets or from all of them.
(iii) Although Insp Michelle had weighed the 11 Packets and recorded the values in the investigation diary (see [32] above), her conditioned statement failed to stipulate what these values were. This, argued the Defence, left a question mark over the weights of the 11 Packets, while they were still in the EM Room.
(iv) The 11 Packets were sealed in tamper-proof bags only after they had been weighed by Insp Michelle and not before. Insp Michelle testified that when XT3 Haifaa and XT3 Cheryl were done with photographing the 11 Packets and other exhibits, these were placed into tamper-proof bags without the bags being sealed. The tamper-proof bags were sealed only after the 11 Packets were weighed by Insp Michelle (see [32] above).
(d) Finally, the Accused took issue with the fact that the drug exhibits were in Insp Michelle’s office over the weekend, from the morning of Saturday, 19 December 2020 to the morning of Monday, 21 December 2020 (see [32] above).
- [35]
[35] The following sets out my assessment of each of the four points raised by the Defence above – all of which in my view hold no merit.
- [36]
[36] Firstly, as regards the contention that the Accused did not know how many black bundles were in the Blue Nike Bag, I failed to comprehend how this was even a chain of custody issue. Based on the evidence, there was nothing to suggest that any of the seven black bundles originated from anywhere other than the Blue Nike Bag, which had in turn been in the Accused’s possession at all material times. As explained at [25] above, the Defence’s case contained no suggestion to this effect – the Accused did not insinuate that any of the seven black bundles had been planted in the space behind the front passenger seat by someone else. Even if he did not know the exact number of black bundles in the Blue Nike Bag, while he was transporting it across the border, this did not alter the fact that he was in possession of the Blue Nike Bag’s contents.
- [37]
[37] Secondly, in relation to the window of time when the black bundles were still at the Woodlands Checkpoint, the Accused failed to identify any break in the chain of custody that might have occurred during this period. The fact that no photographs were taken of the black bundles while they were at the Woodlands Checkpoint is of little impact, given the comprehensive testimonies of the witnesses establishing that the black bundles seized from the Lorry were indeed those eventually sent to the CNB Headquarters. The evidence showed how the seven black bundles from the Lorry had been seized by SSgt Hafiz and passed to W/SSgt Goh, who then handed them to W/SSSgt Siti. W/SSSgt Siti had then locked the black bundles in the cabinet in the CNB B3 office, before taking them out and passing them to ASP Ng (who then transported the black bundles to the CNB Headquarters). That Insp Michelle did not check on the black bundles after they were placed in the cabinet by W/SSSgt Siti is also immaterial as there was no suggestion that anybody could have tampered with the black bundles while they were stored there. W/SSSgt Siti testified that she had locked the cabinet after placing the black bundles inside, unlocking it only to take the black bundles out and pass them to ASP Ng. When the Defence cross-examined W/SSSgt Siti on this, she made it clear that no one else had the key to the cabinet except her.
- [38]
[38] Moving on to the Defence’s contentions about the purported irregularities when the drugs were being processed in the EM Room (at [34(c)] above), I found that these failed to disclose any breaks in the chain of custody.
(a) Firstly, the fact that the Accused was not present in the EM Room when the seven black bundles were opened and photographed did not taint the process. The CNB had its reasons for placing the Accused in the Tanglin Police Divisional Headquarters despite the processing having been conducted in the CNB Headquarters – this was to comply with COVID-19 quarantine safety measures (see [30(e)] above). More to the point, the inability of an accused person to observe the processing of the drug exhibits does not mean that the chain of custody is broken for the duration of non-observation. I can do no better than echo the words of Philip Jeyaretnam J in Public Prosecutor v Yogesswaran C Manogaran [2024] 6 SLR 624 (“Yogesswaran”) at [45]:
In that case, the accused persons were present during the weighing of the drug exhibits but absent when these exhibits were subsequently photographed and sealed. Jeyaretnam J held (at [46]) that the Prosecution had established an unbroken chain of custody through the evidence of two CNB officers who were present throughout the photo taking and subsequent sealing of the exhibits – the officers attested that the drug exhibits did not (contrary to the accused persons’ assertions) get mixed up. Reverting to the present case before me, the processing of the black bundles and the 11 Packets extracted from them had similarly been attested to by multiple individuals: Insp Michelle, ASP Anthony, XT3 Haifaa and XT3 Cheryl. All of them had testified and subjected themselves to cross-examination as to how the drug exhibits had been handled in the EM Room. There was nothing to suggest that the chain of custody was broken at any point during the processing or when the 11 Packets were subsequently weighed and sealed in tamper-proof bags.
(b) As regards the Accused’s concerns about how powdery residue from the drug exhibits had leaked onto the brown paper, the purport of this submission was unclear to me. If the concern was with contamination, the CNB officers had explained that after the 11 Packets were photographed, they were placed into resealable bags, with the residue corresponding to each packet being placed into the resealable bag containing the packet from which the residue had leaked, to maintain exhibit integrity – see [31(c)] above. More importantly, there was no suggestion that the brown paper on which the seven black bundles had been placed, opened and photographed contained drugs from any other source.
(c) Next, the fact that Insp Michelle did not stipulate the weights of the 11 Packets in her conditioned statement was irrelevant. The Defence did not allege any discrepancy between the weights of the 11 Packets as recorded by Insp Michelle in the EM Room, as compared to the weights recorded at any other stage (eg, when they were weighed by the HSA). Under cross-examination, Insp Michelle re-iterated that she had recorded the weights of the 11 Packets in the investigation diary but the Defence did not even see a need to ask her for the recorded figures. Plainly, the weights of the 11 Packets as recorded by Insp Michelle was never an issue.
(d) Finally, the Accused did not explain why the processing of the exhibits should be viewed as tainted in any way, just because the 11 Packets were sealed within the tamper-proof bags only after (and not before) they were weighed in the EM Room. There was nothing to suggest that the weighing process itself might have tainted the integrity of the 11 Packets in any way.
- [39]
[39] Finally, the fact that Insp Michelle locked the 11 Packets (as sealed in tamper-proof bags) in her office for the weekend also did not break the chain of custody. She explained that no one else had the key to the office except her (see [32] above). There was also no suggestion of any unauthorised entry into her office over the weekend, while the 11 Packets were stored there. The Court of Appeal in Affandi was faced with a similar factual matrix, ie, where the seized drug exhibits had been locked in the investigating officer’s office over the weekend. The court rejected the defence’s argument that the possibility of the exhibits having been tampered with while they were in the investigating officer’s office broke the chain of custody (see Affandi at [54]–[55]). The Court of Appeal remarked (at [56]):
Those remarks applied with equal force here, as regards the duration of the weekend when the 11 Packets were locked in Insp Michelle’s office.
- [40]
[40] I thus found that the Prosecution had established beyond reasonable doubt that the chain of custody, from the point the black bundles were seized from the Lorry’s cabin to the time when the 11 Packets were sent to the HSA for analysis, remained intact throughout.
Issue 3: Whether the Accused knew about the nature of the drugs in the black bundles
- [41]
[41] I now turn to the knowledge requirement, which was the focal point for the bulk of the disputes in this case. Given that the Accused was presumed to be in possession of the drugs in the black bundles, he was also presumed – by the operation of s 18(2) of the MDA – to have known about the nature of the drugs in the black bundles. That subsection states:
In Obeng Comfort, the Court of Appeal explained the purport of this presumption (at [36]):
- [42]
[42] The Court of Appeal then held (at [37]) that an accused person seeking to rebut the presumption must do so by proving, on a balance of probabilities, that he did not have knowledge of the nature of the drugs in his possession. In doing so, the accused person should be able to say what he thought the drugs were, so as to allow the court to assess if the presumption had indeed been rebutted. The Court of Appeal explained (at [39]):
The Court of Appeal then observed that the assessment of the accused’s claim as regards what he thought he was carrying would be “a highly fact-specific inquiry”: Obeng Comfort at [40].
- [43]
[43] The following sets out my assessment of whether the Accused had managed to establish, on a balance of probabilities, that he did not have knowledge of the nature of the drugs in the seven black bundles. I concluded that the Accused had failed to do so. That conclusion was grounded on the following findings by me:
(a) Firstly, the Accused’s reaction when the drugs were first discovered strongly suggested that he did know of the contents of the black bundles.
(b) Secondly, the Accused’s account of how he came to meet Deva – being the person whom the Accused claimed had passed him the black bundles and who was thus the central figure around which the Accused’s entire defence revolved – was underpinned by a highly material lie.
(c) Thirdly, there were numerous other factors which showed that the Accused’s claim to ignorance was simply not credible.
Each of these findings is covered in turn below.
The Accused’s reaction when the drugs were discovered
- [44]
[44] The Prosecution’s case was that after CI2 Subra spotted the Blue Nike Bag, the Accused had clearly tried to obstruct him from examining its contents. Specifically, the Prosecution contended that the Accused made not one but two attempts to resist passing the Blue Nike Bag to CI2 Subra, as set out below:
(a) When CI2 Subra first asked the Accused to bring the Blue Nike Bag down from the Lorry’s cabin, the Accused tried to sidestep the request by saying that the Blue Nike Bag was too heavy (see [6] above). It was only after CI2 Subra insisted on seeing the Blue Nike Bag that the Accused climbed up the Lorry cabin to bring it down.
(b) Even when the Accused was retrieving the Blue Nike Bag, he took a few minutes to take it out from behind the front passenger seat of the Lorry’s cabin, to the point that CI2 Subra had to query about the delay. The Prosecution’s case was that the delay was attributable to the Accused taking steps to empty the Blue Nike Bag of the black bundles before handing it to CI2 Subra. As set out at [6] above, CI2 Subra’s evidence was that when the Accused eventually brought the Blue Nike Bag down and passed the same to CI2 Subra, it was empty.
- [45]
[45] The Accused denied that he deliberately emptied the Blue Nike Bag of all the black bundles before passing the same to CI2 Subra. As detailed at [7(b)] above, he claimed that the Blue Nike Bag was stuck behind the front passenger seat and, when he yanked at it, the zipper came open. This resulted in the black bundles tumbling out of the Blue Nike Bag and into the space behind the front passenger seat. Based on this, the black bundles had thus fallen out of the Blue Nike Bag inadvertently. Furthermore, the Accused disagreed with CI2 Subra’s account that the Blue Nike Bag was empty when the Accused passed it to him, contending instead that there was still one black bundle in the Blue Nike Bag that was handed to CI2 Subra (see [7(b)] above). The Accused’s contention was presumably to convey the notion that if he was still handing one of the black bundles to CI2 Subra, it would not be open to this court to infer that the Accused was trying to hide any of the black bundles from CI2 Subra.
- [46]
[46] CI2 Subra was not in court to be cross-examined as he had unfortunately passed away by the time of trial. His conditioned statement was thus admitted under the hearsay exception in s 32(1)(j)(i) of the Evidence Act 1893 (2020 Rev Ed). Notwithstanding, I was of the view that CI2 Subra’s account (as encapsulated in his conditioned statement) – when coupled with evidence of the surrounding circumstances – was sufficiently compelling to sustain the conclusion that the Accused did attempt to obstruct CI2 Subra from gaining access to the Blue Nike Bag’s contents. In contrast, I found the Accused’s claims to be sorely lacking in credit, for the following reasons:
(a) Firstly, the Defence was unable to explain how CI2 Subra could possibly have been mistaken in perceiving the Blue Nike Bag to be empty, given that he arrived at this perception only after shining a torch into the Blue Nike Bag (see [6] above).
(b) Secondly, given how CI2 Subra had insisted that the Accused retrieve the Blue Nike Bag despite the latter’s protests about it being too heavy (see [6] above), it must have been obvious to the Accused that CI2 Subra was highly interested in the Blue Nike Bag’s contents. The Accused would thus have been acutely aware that if – as he claimed – all but one of the black bundles in the Blue Nike Bag had just dropped into the space behind the front passenger seat (through the Accused’s own actions, no less), this would have been highly material to CI2 Subra. Yet the Accused simply handed the Blue Nike Bag to him without breathing a word about the black bundles that the Accused knew had just dropped behind the front passenger seat. This omission was plainly incongruent with the actions of someone not trying to hide anything.
In my view, the evidence was far more consistent with the Accused’s act of dropping the black bundles into the space behind the front passenger seat being a deliberate (rather than inadvertent) one, leaving the Blue Nike Bag empty when it was passed to CI2 Subra.
- [47]
[47] During the trial, the Accused tried to explain why he did not alert CI2 Subra to the black bundles that had dropped behind the front passenger seat. Specifically, he suggested that there was no need to alert CI2 Subra to the black bundles that fell out from the Blue Nike Bag because CI2 Subra would likely have seen at least two of the black bundles which fell out. In this respect, the Accused testified that when he had tried to pull the Blue Nike Bag out from behind the front passenger seat (causing its zipper to come open), not all the black bundles fell behind the front passenger seat. One of the black bundles had fallen onto the seat of the front passenger seat while another had fallen onto the floor beneath the front passenger seat, in full view of CI2 Subra. As seen from the photograph at [5] above, the seat of and the floor beneath the front passenger seat appear to be within the line of sight of someone standing outside the Lorry (such as CI2 Subra). If the Accused’s account were true, it would detract from the suggestion that his failure to alert CI2 Subra to the black bundles dropping out from the Blue Nike Bag arose from any desire to conceal them – there would be no need to alert CI2 Subra if he could already see some of the black bundles dropping out.
- [48]
[48] As a preliminary observation, I note that the Accused’s account of how the two black bundles had fallen within CI2 Subra’s line of sight was not captured anywhere in CI2 Subra’s conditioned statement. More critically, it was plainly contradicted by the Accused’s own description of his interactions with CI2 Subra, as captured in the following paragraphs of the 2nd Long Statement:
It was thus evident from the 2nd Long Statement, as extracted above, that the Accused meant to convey the narrative that the black bundles fell behind (and not in front of) the front passenger seat, except for one black bundle remaining in the Blue Nike Bag. The 2nd Long Statement also described how CI2 Subra had then climbed up the Lorry’s cabin and spotted the black bundles behind the front passenger seat. Finally, it went on to record the Accused as saying that to his recollection, two bundles were dropped on the seat (and not on the floor beneath the seat) – this dovetailed with the account by CI2 Subra (at [7(a)] above) that he had taken two of the black bundles from behind the seat, showed them to the Accused and placed both black bundles on the seat of the front passenger seat. SSgt Hafiz had also confirmed that he had seen these two bundles on the seat of the front passenger seat when he arrived at the scene to relieve CI2 Subra (see [8] above). There was nothing in the 2nd Long Statement about any black bundles falling onto the seat – much less the floor – of the front passenger seat, when the Accused was retrieving the Blue Nike Bag. It was thus plain to me that the Accused’s assertion – that CI2 Subra saw two of the black bundles falling out of the Blue Nike Bag – was no more than an afterthought.
- [49]
[49] In a further bid to justify why he failed to alert CI2 Subra to the black bundles falling out of the Blue Nike Bag, the Accused testified that CI2 Subra had, upon seeing them fall out, immediately directed the Accused not to say anything or touch anything. However, the Accused’s testimony about being directed not to say anything had to be contrasted with the subsequent portion of his oral evidence, in which he explained that when CI2 Subra saw the black bundles falling out, he had asked the Accused what those items were (to which the Accused replied that they were passed to him by a friend). This directly contradicted the prior assertion that when the black bundles fell out of the Blue Nike Bag, the Accused was immediately directed not to say (or touch) anything. The Accused nevertheless sought to qualify that it was only after this verbal exchange – in which CI2 Subra asked the Accused what the black bundles were – that the Accused was asked to climb down from the Lorry’s cabin and directed not to say or touch anything. The Accused was evidently unable to maintain a consistent account of just when CI2 Subra issued the directive to him not to say anything. This inspired little confidence about whether such a directive was ever issued at all. Certainly, it was neither reflected in CI2 Subra’s conditioned statement, nor in the Accused’s own statements to the CNB.
- [50]
[50] The Accused’s behaviour was thus strongly supportive of the inference that he had attempted to obstruct CI2 from accessing the Blue Nike Bag. When the Accused failed to fob off CI2 Subra’s request to see the Blue Nike Bag with the excuse that it was too heavy (see [6] above), he resorted to deliberately emptying the Blue Nike Bag of all seven bundles before passing it to CI2 Subra. The Accused’s explanations for his omission to tell CI2 Subra about the black bundles that had dropped from the Blue Nike Bag were unbelievable.
- [51]
[51] Apart from his behaviour, another notable feature of the Accused’s reaction to CI2 Subra lay in his words – specifically his reply when CI2 Subra asked him what the black bundles were. To recapitulate, CI2 Subra’s evidence was that the Accused replied – not once but twice – that he did not know what the black bundles contained (see [7(a)] above). If the Accused truly believed that the black bundles contained chemicals which (according to Deva) would cause no issues at the customs checkpoint (see [12] above), it was inexplicable why he did not simply relay this to CI2 Subra in response to the latter’s query. Instead, the Accused mentioned that the black bundles contained “chemicals” only later, relaying this to the CNB officers who subsequently arrived at the scene to relieve CI2 Subra – see [8] above. The Accused’s behaviour towards CI2 Subra was reminiscent of the facts in Pang Siew Fum v Public Prosecutor [2011] 2 SLR 635, where the accused person who was caught in possession of heroin claimed that she thought that she was carrying precious stones and Buddha pendants. Yet, when the bag containing the heroin was first opened in her presence by the authorities, she showed no reaction upon seeing the drugs. The Court of Appeal in that case made the following observation (at [67]):
In my view, a similar inference could be derived from the Accused’s answers to CI2 Subra (that he did not know what the black bundles were), coupled with his attempts to obstruct CI2 Subra from accessing the Blue Nike Bag’s contents. Viewed collectively, these reactions were highly consonant with him knowing what the black bundles in the Blue Nike Bag contained.
The Accused’s false claims about his relationship with Deva
- [52]
[52] A further ground for my conclusion that the presumption of knowledge stood unrebutted stemmed from the blatant lie that the Accused told the CNB about his relationship with Deva, by falsely claiming that he first met Deva on the night before his arrest when he knew Deva long before that. It must be stressed at the outset that this was not a lie pertaining to a supporting actor in the plot, or an inconsequential fib about some ancillary detail. Deva’s involvement formed the centrepiece of the defence. According to the Accused, it was Deva who gave him the drugs and misled him into thinking that they were chemicals. It was Deva who was going to give the Accused instructions on delivering the drugs when the latter arrived in Singapore. That the Accused lied about such a pivotal feature of his case thus severely undermined the credibility of his attempt to rebut the presumption of knowledge. The following sets out the circumstances by which the lie was purveyed.
- [53]
[53] In multiple statements recorded by the CNB, the Accused maintained that he met Deva for the first time at a party in Johor Bahru on 17 December 2020, ie, on the night before the arrest. In the 1st Contemporaneous Statement, which SSgt Hafiz recorded from the Accused shortly after the arrest, the Accused explicitly stated that he never met Deva before the party on 17 December 2020. This was seen in his answer in A3, extracted below:
The rest of the Accused’s answer in A3, in which he recounted what happened when Deva met him the next day – ie, the day of the arrest – and passed him the Blue Nike Bag, is extracted at [25] above.
- [54]
[54] Thereafter, the Accused perpetuated his account that he was “introduced” to Deva at the party, in the following statements to CNB:
(a) His first cautioned statement recorded on 19 December 2020 (“1st Cautioned Statement”).
(b) His 2nd Long Statement, recorded on 26 December 2020. In fact, as seen in the extract from this statement at [13(a)] above, the Accused clearly recounted in this statement that during the party, Deva asked for the Accused’s contact number, and the Accused had provided it to Deva.
For completeness, I should add that after the CNB statements above were recorded, interviews with the Accused were conducted in January 2021 by Dr Koh Wun Wu Kenneth Gerard (“Dr Koh”), the psychiatrist called by the prosecution. In these interviews, the Accused repeated the same narrative, ie, that he had met Deva for the first time at the party on the night before the arrest.
- [55]
[55] However, the Accused’s narrative about meeting Deva for the first time at the party on 17 December 2020, as conveyed by him in the three CNB statements above and in his interview with Dr Koh, was flatly contradicted by a report subsequently issued by the Criminal Investigation Department’s Technology Crime Forensic Branch on 27 October 2021 (“TCFB Report”). The TCFB Report showed that based on records extracted from the Accused’s phone, the Accused was acquainted with Deva well before the party on 17 December 2020. Specifically, the call records for the month of December 2020 showed that there were over 100 calls between the Accused’s number and the number which he said belonged to Deva, from the beginning of the month of December 2020 to the day of the arrest. Records of voice and text messages sent between the Accused’s number and Deva’s number also suggested that they knew each other, even before the party.
- [56]
[56] Relatedly, the Prosecution argued that the call records suggested that the Accused likely carried out deliveries of similar black bundles for Deva in the past. Specifically, two videos were extracted from the Accused’s phone, with one taken at 11.31pm on 4 December 2020 and the other taken five minutes later at 11.36pm. The first video showed a black bundle being dropped into a white bag, while the second showed a black bundle being deposited at the foot of a tree near a bus stop. Shortly after that, from 12.53am to 1.01am, 12 missed calls were made from Deva’s number to the Accused’s mobile phone. At about 1.02am, the Accused answered the call and spoke to Deva for over a minute. During this period, no one else called the Accused and he similarly did not call anyone else. I was of course mindful that there was no conclusive proof linking the depositing of the black bundles in the two videos with Deva, apart from the proximity of the calls. Still, the call records conclusively showed that the narrative which the Accused had repeatedly relayed, ie, that he met Deva for the first time only at the party on 17 December 2020, was patently false.
- [57]
[57] The Accused was subsequently interviewed by the Defence’s psychiatrist, Dr Jacob Rajesh (“Dr Rajesh”), over the course of several sessions commencing in August 2022, ie, after the release of the TCFB Report. During these interviews, he told Dr Rajesh that he first met Deva six to seven months before his arrest. In cross-examination, the contradictions between the Accused’s CNB statements (in which the Accused said that he met Deva only at the party on 17 December 2020) and the account which he gave to Dr Rajesh (that he already knew Deva for six to seven months before that) were put to the Accused. The Accused confirmed that the correct version was that which he had given to Dr Rajesh, ie, that he had known Deva for six to seven months prior to the arrest. The Accused also conceded that this version was “completely the opposite” of what he had said in his statements to the CNB.
- [58]
[58] In his oral evidence, the Accused tried to rationalise the contradictions by saying that he was “in a state of shock” when giving the contemporaneous statement extracted at [53] above. While his statements to the CNB captured him as saying that did not know Deva prior to the party, the Accused explained that he actually meant to say that he did not know Deva well prior to the party – the party being the occasion where both men got the chance to speak at length – and not that he did not know Deva at all prior to the party.
- [59]
[59] Even then, this rationalised narrative failed to cohere with the text and voice messages between both men, which clearly suggested that they were well acquainted with each other, even before the party on 17 December 2020. Set out below are the messages that both men exchanged on 16 December 2020 (ie, the day before the party) – these have been translated from Tamil:
- [60]
[60] The messages providing the most revealing insights were those exchanged between both men on 17 December 2020 itself, ie, the day the party was allegedly held (ie, the day before the arrest). These are extracted below:
Bearing in mind the Accused’s position that he attended the party on 17 December 2020 at about 8pm, the following preliminary insights may be drawn from the phone records above:
(a) The Accused and Deva were already exchanging phone messages within the three-hour window leading up to the Accused showing up at the party. Yet the Accused stated in the 2nd Long Statement that after he and Deva were introduced to each other at the party, Deva had asked for the Accused’s contact number (see [13(a)] above). It was thus clear to me that the Accused, in a bid to portray a more diluted level of familiarity between him and Deva, told a blatant lie – the premise for which had been unequivocally debunked by the phone records. It was impossible to construe this patent falsehood as an inadvertent miscommunication, notwithstanding the Accused’s attempts at [58] above to rationalise the contradictions in his CNB statements. When the Accused was pressed on this in cross-examination, he could offer no explanation save for the incredible tale that Deva did ask for his number at the party despite having exchanged numerous messages with the Accused just hours before that.
(b) It was also critical to note that the party allegedly took place in Johor Bahru. Yet, there was a message from Deva timestamped 18:09 (see the table above), ie, less than two hours before the Accused’s arrival at the party, in which Deva said that he was still in Kuala Lumpur. There were no messages from Deva thereafter intimating that he had arrived in Johor Bahru or alluding to meeting up with the Accused at the party. In fact, although two tables above purported to capture the messages exchanged between both men on 16 and 17 December 2020, they contained no mention of the party (which both men allegedly attended) at all. It was thus highly doubtful whether the party even happened.
- [61]
[61] More importantly, even the Accused’s revised account – that he only came to know Deva well at the party on the evening of 17 December 2020 (see [58] above) – could not be reconciled with the messages sent on 17 December 2020. This could be seen in Deva’s message to the Accused timestamped 19:05 in the table at [60] above, about whether the Accused had undergone any checks the day before. By way of background, the Accused had travelled through the customs checkpoint on 16 December 2020. Deva’s message at 19:05 on 17 December 2020 had thus queried the Accused: “How was the checking yesterday. It must have been real warm inside.” In court, the Accused confirmed that the “checking yesterday” which Deva was asking about pertained to the checks that the Accused had undergone at the Woodlands Checkpoint on 16 December 2020. Twenty minutes after that message from Deva, the Accused responded with the following message timestamped 19:26 (see [60] above ): “That day there was no checking inside. Never check anything”. The Accused explained that he was telling Deva that no checks were done at the Woodlands Checkpoint and “everything was as usual”. This exchange took place less than an hour before the Accused turned up at the party, where he supposedly got to know Deva well for the first time and gave Deva his number. It was impossible to fathom why the Accused was discussing with Deva whether he had undergone customs checks when passing through the Woodlands Checkpoint the day before, if both men were still not well acquainted with each other then.
- [62]
[62] Clearly, the phone records demonstrated that the Accused knew Deva, and knew him well at that, long before the alleged party on 17 December 2020. Yet, over the course of three statements to the CNB, the Accused advanced the false narrative that he first came to know Deva only at the party and had exchanged numbers with Deva then. The only inference which can be drawn is that the Accused was actively attempting to conceal the true nature of his relationship with Deva from the CNB. It cannot be overemphasised that the Accused’s account of his relationship with Deva went to the very heart of his defence. That he had repeatedly lied about it inspired very little confidence in the credibility of his attempt to rebut the presumption of knowledge.
Other factors betraying the lack of credibility in the Accused’s account
- [63]
[63] Apart from the Accused’s lies about his relationship with Deva, there were other material signs of the abject lack of credibility in the Accused’s claim to ignorance as regards what the seven black bundles contained.
- [64]
[64] Firstly, as explained at [12] above, his defence at trial was that he thought that the black bundles contained chemicals used for cleaning toilets and could cause a virus if touched. However, his claim to having this belief was undermined by how his statements – as to what he thought the black bundles contained – kept evolving. The following sets out the chronology of the Accused’s ever-changing accounts:
(a) As highlighted at [7(a)], when the Accused was first detained on 18 December 2020, he was asked by CI2 Subra – twice – as regards what the black bundles contained. The Accused had replied to CI2 Subra on both occasions that he did not know. No mention was made of the black bundles containing chemicals.
(b) When the CNB officers subsequently arrived at the scene to relieve CI2 Subra, the Accused was questioned again as to what the black bundles contained. This time, the Accused described the black bundles’ contents as “chemical”. Specifically, the Accused told SSgt Hafiz this on two occasions, once before and once after SSgt Hafiz had used a scalpel to make a cut in one of the black bundles to reveal the brownish granular substance inside – see [8] above. The Accused made no mention to SSgt Hafiz about the chemicals (i) giving rise to a “virus” if touched; or (ii) being used for washing toilets.
(c) SSgt Hafiz had then brought the Accused back to the CCC office to record his contemporaneous statement, during which the Accused was referred to the seven black bundles and asked what they were. In his response (see [25] above), the Accused initially said “I don’t know. I swear I don’t know”, after which he said that he was told by Deva that “they were dangerous chemicals that cannot come into contact with anyone as it is like a ‘virus’.” The narrative that the “chemicals” could give rise to a virus was then repeated by the Accused subsequently, in
(i) the 1st Cautioned Statement; and
(ii) the 2nd Long Statement (extracted at [13(c)] above).
No mention was made in any of these statements about the chemicals being for washing toilets.
(d) Finally, in the 3rd Long Statement, the Accused mentioned for the first time that the chemicals were for washing toilets. He recounted that Deva told him that the black bundles contained chemicals for washing toilets and that anyone touching them could get a skin problem and a virus – see the extract of the statement at [14] above.
From the chronology above, it was clear that the Accused was incapable of providing a narrative that had any semblance of consistency, as regards what he thought the black bundles contained.
- [65]
[65] Furthermore, the delay by the Accused in expressing his belief that the black bundles contained chemicals for washing toilets gave rise to doubts whether he genuinely harboured such a belief. The nature of the “chemicals” would have been highly material, seeing as how that term could conceivably encompass a wide range of substances, from the innocuous (eg, cleaning chemicals) to the illicit (eg, prohibited drugs, hazardous toxins or even explosives). The Accused was explicitly warned when the 1st Cautioned Statement was recorded, one day after his arrest, that any fact or matter which he failed to raise may be regarded as less believable. Yet, it was only in the 3rd Long Statement (see [64(d)] above), which was recorded ten days after his arrest, that the Accused mentioned about the chemicals being meant for washing toilets. If he honestly believed this to be true, it is hard to see why he had waited so long to say it – see also Public Prosecutor v Lee Zheng Da Eddie [2022] SGHC 199 at [50].
- [66]
[66] The Accused’s account of how he came to believe that the black bundles contained chemicals for washing toilets was also marred by a material contradiction. As explained at [64(d)] above, the Accused recounted in the 3rd Long Statement that Deva told him that the chemicals were for washing toilets (see extract at [14] above). However, during the trial, the Accused retracted this and said that Deva did not tell him that the chemicals were meant for washing toilets, and that it was the Accused himself who deduced that the chemicals were meant for washing toilets. Pertinently, this subsequent iteration of his story raised even more doubts about his defence. The Accused had previously worked in two different jobs as a cleaner, but he had never seen washing or cleaning products packed in the same manner as the black-taped bundles. In fact, he claimed never to have seen such black-taped bundles before (see [13(c)] above). That being the case, I found it difficult to conceive how he could have come to deduce – of his own accord and without Deva or anyone else telling him – that the chemicals were meant for washing toilets.
- [67]
[67] The difficulties riddling the Accused’s account thus pointed strongly to one conclusion: Deva never told him that the black bundles contained chemicals, whether for washing toilets or any other purpose.
- [68]
[68] That conclusion was also reinforced by what happened after the Accused was arrested on 18 December 2020. After his arrest, the CNB officers had created a cover story for him to relay to Deva, to facilitate follow-up operations for nabbing the intended recipient of the black bundles. The cover story contained the following key points:
(a) the Lorry was delayed because the Lorry Driver had a fever which necessitated COVID-19 tests at the customs checkpoint; and
(b) the Lorry had just been released and was on its way to Pasir Panjang, so Deva should arrange for the black bundles to be picked up.
- [69]
[69] For context, the messages exchanged between the Accused and Deva on the evening of the arrest, ie, on 18 December 2020, are set out below:
The hiatus in messages between 17:40 and 22:43 presumably reflected the window of time when the Accused was in custody. The message containing the cover story sent by the Accused to Deva was the one timestamped 22:49.
- [70]
[70] Deva’s response to the cover story, captured in the entry timestamped 22:50, was telling. That response made no mention of “chemicals” and instead alluded to “motor parts”. If it were indeed true that Deva had duped the Accused into thinking that the black bundles contained chemicals, this response (referring to motor parts) would have been plainly inexplicable. Even if Deva had somehow caught on that the game was up and the Accused’s message was no more than bait set by the CNB, there was still no reason for Deva to allude to “motor parts” in his message. After all, the “chemicals” narrative was – by the Accused’s own account – coined by Deva to conceal the true nature of the black bundles’ contents. If Deva had meant to maintain the charade in front of the CNB, he would logically have continued using the “chemicals” façade. There was no conceivable reason for him to make a reference – out of the blue – to “motor parts”. When asked why Deva had alluded to “motor parts” instead of “chemicals”, the Accused conceded that there was no reason for Deva to have done so. In my view, Deva’s response pointed strongly to the inference that he never told the Accused that the black bundles contained chemicals. I thus felt compelled to agree with the Prosecution’s deduction as to what must have happened, as set out in the following extract from its submissions:
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.