Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 8 Feb 2023
Contents

Appellate Division of the High Court

Safie bin Jantan v Zaiton bte Adom and another and another appeal

Feedback & support

[2023] SGHC(A) 8Case no. Civil Appeal No 107 of 202110 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Background

  2. [1] Mr Safie bin Jantan (“S”) is the appellant in AD/CA 107/2021 (“AD 107”) and the first respondent in AD/CA 108/2021 (“AD 108”). His present wife, Ms Zaiton binte Adom (“Z”) is the appellant in AD 108 and the first respondent in AD 107. Mr Safie’s ex-wife, Ms Nafsiah bte Wagiman (“N”), is the second respondent in both AD 107 and AD 108.

  3. [2] We dismiss the appeals in AD 107 and AD 108. These are the brief grounds of our decision.

  4. Decision of the Judge

  5. [5] In OS 1014, the Judge of the General Division of the High Court (the “Judge”) held that S was personally liable to pay Z the sum of $205,359.80 as restitution for unjust enrichment. He noted that S conceded that in 2015, S owed a personal obligation to return Z the sum of $205,359.80. The Judge found that S and Z had shared a common intention for either S or Z to become the sole owner of the Flat in exchange for Z’s Moneys. He found that once the Moneys were handed over to S, the funds were at S’s free disposal and S was enriched. S’s choice to direct N to deposit the cashier’s orders into her CPF account did not detract from his enrichment. This enrichment was at Z’s expense and it was unjust as there was a failure of basis, which was the common intention for S to become the sole owner of the Flat. As the Appeal Board’s decision would result in the Flat’s entire net sale proceeds going to N, the basis had failed.

  6. [6] The Judge dismissed all the other claims made by Z against S and N.

  7. Analyses and Observations

  8. [8] As a third party to the divorce proceedings between S and N, Z can only pursue her purported interest in the Flat by way of independent civil proceedings. The Appeal Board referred to the principles in the Court of Appeal (“CA”) decision of UDA v UDB and another [2018] 1 SLR 1015 (“UDA”) and the High Court decision of UDA v UDB [2018] 3 SLR 1433. It applied the same reasoning in these decisions and held that the Syariah Court exercising matrimonial jurisdiction over divorcing parties had no jurisdiction to determine the substantive rights of a third party to the divorce proceedings.

  9. [9] What then, could someone in Z’s position have done? In UDA, the CA explained (at [54]):

  10. Decision

  11. [12] We agree with the Judge that on the facts and circumstances of this case, S had been unjustly enriched by the Moneys and is liable to return the moneys to Z. S had requested the Moneys from Z, and Z had intended to transfer the Moneys to S. In 2015, Z was already in a relationship with S, described by Z as an “unregistered marriage”. To Z, S was her husband and they were acting as a team planning to acquire ownership over the Flat. S then used the Moneys in ways he thought would benefit him. Perhaps he had not considered that upon a divorce, the Flat could be divided by the court in a way that gave him no interest in it. But even if he had not considered that, he still had the opportunity to run his case as he thought fit during the divorce proceedings. Whether he could have benefitted or been “enriched” from his use of the Moneys by asking the Syariah Court to treat them as his direct contributions in dividing the matrimonial assets, was for him to pursue. The Appeal Board had held at [78] of its Grounds of Decision (Appeal Case No. 32/2019) that:

  12. [16] We find no merit in the appellants’ arguments against the Judge’s conclusions in respect of the other claims. We do not find any error in the Judge’s conclusions that Z fails in her claims based on institutional constructive trust, remedial constructive trust, presumed resulting trust, Quistclose trust, proprietary restitution and equitable lien.

  13. Conclusion and Costs

  14. [19] We dismiss the appeals, AD 107 and AD 108.

  15. [22] The usual consequential orders will apply.