Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 17 April 2020
SK Lateral Rubber & Plastic Technologies (Suzhou) Co Ltd v Lateral Solutions Pte Ltd
Feedback & support[2020] SGHC(I) 09 · Case no. Suit No 6 of 2019 (Summons No 13 of 2020) · 22 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Facts
The parties
- [2]
[2] SKL is a company established under the laws of the People’s Republic of China. Its business includes the manufacture and sale of polymer parts (“parts”) used in electronic consumer goods. Lateral is a Singapore incorporated company, engaged in the supply of electronic components for such goods. Lateral has no manufacturing facilities of its own, and outsources the components from companies such as SKL.
Background to the dispute
- [3]
[3] In 2011, SKL and Lateral entered into an agreement (“the Agreement”) under which SKL was to manufacture and supply parts for Lateral, which Lateral would in turn supply to Apple and perhaps others. Business was done for some years, but the relationship deteriorated and ended in acrimony in 2017.
- [4]
[4] SKL claims USD 10.3 million from Lateral, for parts supplied and for tooling procured, equipment purchased and expenses incurred for the manufacture of parts.
- [5]
[5] Lateral’s defence to the parts claim is that, by virtue of “operational realities” and a course of discussion and conduct, payment of SKL’s invoices was due only when Lateral’s cash flow permitted it to pay (“the cash flow defence”). To this is added that one Wei Fengpin, said to be the controller of SKL, had engaged in conduct intended to damage Lateral’s business and “take it out as a competitor” in favour of other entities he controlled. It is alleged that Wei himself is responsible for Lateral’s cash flow problems and its subsequent inability to pay, and that the proceedings themselves are part of a scheme to drain Lateral’s finances (“the Wei conduct”). As to tooling, the defence appears to be that SKL was not entitled to payment unless Lateral’s customer had agreed to pay for the tooling and had paid, or until Lateral was being paid for the parts produced by the tooling. The claims as to equipment and expenses were simply denied.
- [6]
[6] SKL’s reply to the defence includes that the Wei conduct is not relevant.
- [7]
[7] Lateral counterclaims against SKL on a number of grounds. First, it says that it paid USD 1.1 million for parts supplied, which parts were then found to be defective, and that SKL had refused to repay it. Secondly, it says that SKL owes it USD 1.3 million, such sums being the amount paid to a casings supplier for casings required by SKL for the manufacture of parts. SKL had allegedly agreed to repay Lateral but had so far failed to do so. Thirdly, Lateral claims that it owns a large number of items of equipment purchased and held by SKL for the manufacture of parts. Lateral claims damages for wrongful detention or conversion of the equipment. Fourthly, Lateral says that SKL wrongfully ceased to supply parts under the Agreement, which it alleges by discussion and conduct was or became a long term supply agreement, and claims damages for its breach.
Procedural history
- [9]
[9] In April 2018, SKL applied for summary judgment. The hearing of the application was delayed by an application to amend the defence and counterclaim and applications to file affidavits. An amended defence and counterclaim was allowed, and in January 2019 the application for summary judgment was dismissed by Kannan Ramesh J on the basis that Lateral had a defence of set-off against SKL’s claim.
- [10]
[10] In May 2019, the defence and counterclaim was again amended. Over the next five months particulars were requested and given of the defence and counterclaim and of the reply and defence to counterclaim, with a number of disputed applications. Following amendment of the claim, the defence and counterclaim was also again amended. Lists of documents were filed in November 2019.
- [13]
[13] Pursuant to leave given on 2 March 2020, on 6 March 2020 the defence and counterclaim were amended yet again. Until then, Lateral’s defence to the parts claim had been that payment of SKL’s invoices was due only when Lateral received payment from its customers (“the pay when paid defence”). In the amendments, it became the cash flow defence. Other directions were given, and have been given, leading to a trial fixed for seven days commencing on 21 July 2020.
The present application
(b) that SKL is ordinarily resident out of the jurisdiction (“the foreign plaintiff basis”).
The Impecuniosity Basis for the power to order security
- [19]
[19] The impecuniosity basis rested on s 388 of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed), providing –
- [24]
[24] Secondly, Lateral referred to paragraphs in SKL’s affidavit asserting, without detail, likely effect on its business of the current COVID-19 pandemic, and stating that in such circumstances it would be unjust to require SKL to provide security “especially since any cash flow issues that SKL may experience in the current economic climate is also largely attributable to Lateral’s failure or refusal to pay SKL…”. Lateral magnified this in submissions to an admission that SKL “may be experiencing cash flow issues”.
- [26]
[26] The requisite condition for the impecuniosity basis has not been made out.
The Foreign Plaintiff Basis for the power to order security
Exercise of the court’s discretion
Ordinarily resident out of jurisdiction
- [31]
[31] Lateral’s affidavit evidence did not identify any particular difficulty in or considerations regarding enforcement in China, beyond saying that there is no reciprocal agreement on enforcement between China and Singapore. SKL agreed that there was no such agreement, but in its affidavit evidence pointed to a Memorandum of Guidance between the Supreme People’s Court of the People’s Republic of China and the Supreme Court of Singapore (“the Memorandum”), as “providing a framework for a simplified process of recognising and enforcing” Singapore judgments in the Chinese courts and vice versa.
- [34]
[34] Other factors to which the parties referred may be summarised as –
(a) the strength of SKL’s claim;
(b) possible cash flow issues; and
(c) overlap between the claim and the counterclaim.
The strength of SKL’s claim
- [36]
[36] The relative strengths of the parties’ cases is a relevant consideration. The court will not enter into a detailed consideration of the merits, unless a high probability of success one way or the other can be clearly demonstrated: Ong Jane Rebecca v Pricewaterhousecoopers [2009] 2 SLR(R) 796 (“Ong Jane Rebecca”) at [22] – [23]. But this does not exclude concluding that the plaintiff has a good chance of success (Amer Hoseen Mohammed Revai v Singapore Airlines [1994] 3 SLR(R) 290 at [52]), or noting matters bearing on the relative strengths. Thus in Tjong Very Sumitomo v Chan Sing En [2010] SGHC 344 at [42] –[45] the Judge identified implausibility in both the claim and the defence, and in Sembawang Engineering Pte Ltd v Priser Asia Engineering Pte Ltd [1992] 2 SLR 290 at [25] the Judicial Commissioner noted that two matters “stand out on the pleadings” from which he was satisfied that the plaintiff’s claim was bona fide and had a reasonable prospect of success.
- [37]
[37] At least as to the parts, Lateral does not deny that they were supplied, and it does not seem to deny responsibility to pay for the tooling subject to conditions as to when payment is due. In his reasons on the summary judgment application, Kannan Ramesh J noted that Lateral had not provided any evidence that it had not been paid by Apple, and said that this raised doubts in his mind “about the efficacy of the defendant’s argument on the ‘pay when paid’ obligation”. The pay when paid defence has now become the cash flow defence, following those observations and only when the defence was amended for the fifth time. A commercial agreement, for dealings in the millions of dollars, that payment should be made when the debtor was able to pay, would be unusual, and the late pleading of the cash flow defence raises doubts similar to those voiced by Kannan Ramesh J. Whether the defence is made out of course will be determined on the evidence at the trial, but for the purposes of this application I consider that SKL should be regarded as having the stronger case. That is a factor against ordering security.
- [38]
[38] I take into account Lateral’s submission that SKL’s assertion of the strength of its claim “does not square with Lateral being given unconditional leave to defend on SKL’s application for summary judgment”. Summary judgment was refused because the counterclaim provided a defence of set-off. I do not think that, for present purposes, that negates regarding SKL’s case as stronger than Lateral’s.
Possible cash flow issues
- [44]
[44] I do not think the evidence warrants regarding stifling the claim or possible financial stringency as factors in the exercise of the discretion.
Overlap between the claim and the counterclaim
- [47]
[47] The expression “launched from the same platform” was taken from Jurong at [19]. There, the plaintiff (“WSL”) claimed payment for work done under a building contract and damages for wrongful termination of the contract. The defendant (“JTC”) pleaded that it had lawfully rescinded the contract and counterclaimed for damages it had suffered. The Court said –
- [48]
[48] Lateral submitted that there was not a “complete” overlap, but did not elaborate further. It said that it could succeed on damages for breach of the Agreement even if it failed on the cash flow defence.
- [49]
[49] Consistent with the rationale of unfairness (see [45] above), a more nuanced approach than comparison of issues is appropriate, and is supported by and apparent in Jurong.
Decision
- [53]
[53] SKL disputed the amount sought. It is unnecessary to consider this.