Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 15 Jul 2024

Singapore International Commercial Court

Renault SAS v Liberty Engineering Group Pte Ltd and another matter

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC(I) 22Case no. Originating Application No 9 of 2023 (Summons No 18 of 2024)12 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] In a claim under a guarantee, Renault SAS (“Renault”) obtained judgment against Liberty Engineering Group Pte Ltd (“LEG”) for €5,250,025.61 and interest. LEG appealed against the decision, and applied in separate applications for (a) a stay of enforcement of the judgment; and (b) an injunction restraining Renault from presenting a winding-up application against it founded on the judgment: both until the disposal of the appeal.

  3. Background

  4. [4] The judgment was issued on 14 February 2024: Renault SAS v Liberty Engineering Group Pte Ltd and another matter [2024] SGHC(I) 6. The facts and the reasons for the decision are there set out, and will not be repeated here.

  5. [5] Thereafter,

  6. (a) On 19 February 2024, Renault’s solicitors served on LEG a statutory demand pursuant to the provisions of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (2020 Rev Ed) for payment of the judgment debt and interest. The effect of the demand was that if the judgment sum was not paid or secured to Renault’s reasonable satisfaction within 21 days, LEG would be deemed unable to pay its debts and Renault could apply for it to be wound up.

  7. (b) On 5 March 2024, LEG’s solicitors advised that they had instructions to file an appeal in respect of the judgment, and asked that Renault “hold all timelines in respect of the Statutory Demand in abeyance” and “hold its hand in the enforcement of the Judgment” pending the outcome of the appeal.

  8. (c) On 12 March 2024, Renault’s solicitors advised that Renault was “prepared to agree not to execute on the Judgment” on condition that LEG provide satisfactory security, being either a bank guarantee for the judgment sum on terms satisfactory to Renault or payment of the judgment sum into court.

  9. (d) On 13 March 2024, LEG filed an appeal against the judgment. A notice from the Registry advised that the appeal was fixed in the sitting of the Court of Appeal between 29 July and 8 August 2024.

  10. (e) On 12 April 2024, LEG’s solicitors advised that LEG did not agree to the proposal for security, and that it would be filing applications for an injunction to restrain Renault from filing a winding-up application against it and for a stay of enforcement of the judgment.

  11. (f) On 17 April 2024, LEG filed the applications, being:

  12. (i) HC/OA 365/2024 in the High Court (“OA 365”), seeking an injunction to restrain the presentation of a winding-up application on the basis of the statutory demand pending the final determination of the appeal; and

  13. (ii) SIC/SUM 18/2024 in the substantive proceedings in the Singapore International Commercial Court (“the SICC”) (“SUM 18”), seeking a stay of enforcement of the judgment pending the disposal of the appeal.

  14. (g) On 22 April 2024, Renault’s solicitors advised that Renault was prepared to agree not to execute the judgment or apply to wind up LEG pending the resolution of the appeal, if LEG provided to Renault satisfactory proof that it had assets of the value of the judgment debt with interest and undertook not to dispose of assets up to that value.

  15. (h) On 2 May 2024, OA 365 was transferred to the SICC, where it was renumbered SIC/OA 7/2024 (“OA 7”), and was fixed for hearing together with SUM 18.

  16. (i) There was no evidence of LEG’s response to Renault’s proposal of 22 April 2024, but it was evident that LEG did not accede to it.

  17. [6] The two applications were supported by affidavits of Mr Benjamin Howard. With the transfer of OA 365 to the SICC, the parties agreed that Renault would file a reply affidavit by 16 May 2024, and it filed an affidavit of Mr Bruno Moustacchi (“Mr Moustacchi”). The evidence was completed by a further affidavit of Mr Howard, provided in draft on 30 May 2024.

  18. [7] The hearing of the application was fixed for 19 June 2024, with prior written submissions. In the result, the applications were heard only a little over a month before the anticipated hearing of the appeal.

  19. [8] Mr Chew Kei-Jin appeared as lead counsel for LEG. Mr Liu Zhao Xiang Daniel appeared as lead counsel for Renault.

  20. There was no occasion for the restraining order

  21. The power to stay enforcement pending an appeal

  22. [12] However, LEG’s application was on the ground, and only on the ground, of the pending appeal. As is evident from Lee Sian Hee (trading as Lee Sian Hee Pork Trader) v Oh Kheng Soon ( trading as Ban Hon Trading Enterprise) [1991] 2 SLR(R) 869 (“Lee Sian Hee”) at [3], in such a case the power to grant a stay properly stems from s 45 of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1969 (2020 Rev Ed) (“the SCJA”) and (in this case) O 21 r 6(1) of the SICC Rules. Reflecting s 45 of the SCJA, O 21 r 6(1) of the SICC Rules provides:

  23. [13] That is, a stay of enforcement pending an appeal is granted in the exercise of the power to otherwise direct in O 21 r 6(1). Mr Chew submitted that O 21 r 6(1) simply picked up the general power and a direction otherwise was given through an application under O 24 r 2(1), but I do not think that is correct. The terms of O 21 r 6(1) are against it, with the specific reference to the appellate Court, the language of “otherwise direct” rather than reference to the general power, and the use of the same language in O 21 r 6(2) which does not have a corresponding general power; in Ellis v Scott (1964) 1 WLR 976 it was held, in relation to the broadly equivalent English rules, that the power to otherwise direct a stay of enforcement pending an appeal was a separate head of power from the general power to grant a stay; and the submission cannot stand with the explicit reliance in Lee Sian Hee on the power to otherwise direct, without reference to the general power.

  24. Special circumstances must be shown for the exercise of the power

  25. [15] These principles have been adopted in many subsequent cases, including by Vivian Ramsey IJ in CPIT Investments Ltd v Qilin World Capital Ltd and another [2017] 5 SLR 148 as the principles applicable in a case in the SICC. In Strandore Invest A/S and others v Soh Kim Wat [2010] SGHC 174 (“Strandore”) at [7], Quentin Loh J summarised the approach to a stay of enforcement pending an appeal:

  26. [16] In terms of a threshold, then, although I would prefer not to use that description, the threshold is that of special circumstances as explained in these cases.

  27. Special circumstances were not shown

  28. [24] Mr Chew’s submissions included, perhaps faintly, that the hearing of the appeal was not far distant, and that it would not be a hardship on Renault if it were precluded from enforcing the judgment until the disposal of the appeal. It may be that Renault’s initial enthusiasm, shown by the prompt service of the statutory demand, has waned with a perhaps leisurely progress of the applications. But I did not think that the fact that the appeal is fixed for hearing at or shortly after the end of July 2024 was or contributed to special circumstances warranting a stay. While unlikely, it is possible that the hearing of the appeal will not take place as anticipated, and it is by no means certain that the outcome will be immediately known. And where LEG has not otherwise shown special circumstances, Renault’s prima facie entitlement to the fruits of its litigation should not be taken away on the assertion that it would not thereby suffer hardship; that would be an unjustified diminution of its rights.

  29. A conditional stay of enforcement pending the appeal was nonetheless ordered

  30. [25] Although I did not think that special circumstances had been shown for a stay of enforcement until the appeal, Renault’s submissions included that it was agreeable to a stay on condition that the judgment sum be paid into court pending the disposal of the appeal. LEG had declined that course, but in the circumstances, I considered that (as was done in Viet Hai Petroleum at [53]) it was nonetheless appropriate to grant the conditional stay of enforcement as an opportunity for LEG which was not opposed by Renault.

  31. Costs

  32. Conclusion