Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 12 Feb 2026

Singapore International Commercial Court

DNO v DNP

Feedback & support

[2026] SGHC(I) 2Case no. Originating Application No 4 of 202517 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] DNP was the claimant in an arbitration. The respondent in the arbitration was a partnership firm (“Partnership”). DNP succeeded in the arbitration and was awarded damages of US$33,009.53 and INR22,432,076.68 plus simple interest (“Award”). A counterclaim brought by the Partnership was dismissed.

  3. [2] In SIC/OA 4/2025 (“OA 4”), DNO brought an application seeking to set aside the Award on grounds that: (a) a breach of natural justice occurred in connection with the making of the Award; and (b) the Award was in conflict with the public policy of Singapore. DNP opposed the application on various grounds, including a contention that DNO lacked standing to challenge the Award.

  4. [3] In DNO v DNP [2025] SGHC(I) 24 (“DNO v DNP (Merits)”) (at [58]), I found that the legal personality of the Partnership was merged into and assumed by the company, DNO, such that DNO had standing to challenge the Award. In the same judgment, I dismissed DNO’s substantive application to set aside the Award. These reasons are to be read with the aforementioned judgment.

  5. The parties’ submissions

  6. Pre-Transfer Costs

  7. (a) The first category is work done in connection with the affidavit filed by DNO in support of OA 4, for which DNP claims that costs of $3,700 were incurred (S/N 1 of DNP’s Costs Schedule).

  8. (b) The second category is work done in connection with DNP’s affidavit in response to OA 4, for which DNP claims that costs of $13,000 were incurred (S/N 2 of DNP’s Costs Schedule).

  9. Post-Transfer Costs

  10. [15] There are three categories of work in the Post-Transfer Stage:

  11. (a) The first category is for work done in connection with DNO’s further affidavit and work done in connection with DNP’s own submissions for OA 4. This involved three counsel engaged by DNP, a total of 60 hours of work, and a claim of $29,600 (S/N 3 of DNP’s Costs Schedule).

  12. (b) The second category is for work done in connection with DNO’s submissions, and preparation for the hearing of the OA 4. This again involved the three counsel, a total of 52 hours of work, and a claim of $26,400 (S/N 4 of DNP’s Costs Schedule).

  13. (c) The third category of work pertains to miscellaneous costs arising from, among others, the attendance of three counsel at the case conferences and hearings, as well as the preparation of costs submissions. This involved a total of 44 hours of work, and a total claim of $21,400 (S/N 5–9 of DNP’s Costs Schedule).

  14. (a) SUM 20 was DNP’s application for an increase in the quantum of security for costs. The parties eventually reached an agreement on the quantum, and DNP did not pursue SUM 20. DNO submits that costs should be awarded in its favour but does not specify an amount which should be allowed.

  15. (b) SUM 25 was DNO’s application for leave to file a further affidavit on the issue of its standing to bring OA 4. I granted the application in DNO v DNP [2025] 4 SLR 362 (“DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit)”). DNO submits that the costs for SUM 25 should be fixed at $10,000 plus reasonable disbursements.

  16. [21] Finally, I note that DNO does not contend that the disbursements listed in DNP’s Disbursements Schedule are unreasonable in quantum or that they were unreasonably incurred.

  17. My decision

  18. Pre-Transfer Costs

  19. [28] With respect to the first limb of DNP’s submission, that is, that DNO’s case was bereft of merit, I made a number of observations in the Judgment to the effect that not only should DNO’s various complaints be rejected, but properly characterised, the subject of those complaints could not amount to breaches of the rules of natural justice or bring the Award in conflict with the public policy of Singapore. I made the following observations in DNO v DNP (Merits):

  20. (a) in the opening section, that “a number of DNO’s submissions seemed to proceed on the mistaken view that OA 4 involved an appeal on questions of fact and law” (at [4]);

  21. (b) in the section dealing with the alleged breaches of natural justice in connection with the Amendment Application:

  22. (c) that in any event, DNO “would have been unable to rely on any said breach [of natural justice], given the absence of prejudice and its hedging against an adverse result” (at [127]);

  23. (d) in the section dealing with the alleged inconsistent/defective reasoning of the tribunal, that “DNO’s challenges to the Tribunal’s reasoning were no more than attacks on the merits of the Tribunal’s conclusions” (at [171]); and

  24. (e) in the section dealing with the public policy ground, that there were difficulties caused by DNO’s failure to adduce any expert evidence as to the content of Indian law (at [191]–[193]).

  25. [32] In DKT v DKU [2025] 1 SLR 806 (“DKT v DKU”), the appellant argued that there had been a breach of natural justice in three respects. The appeal was dismissed in its entirety by the Court of Appeal, which described the appellant’s arguments in the following manner (at [1]):

  26. (a) There is no difficulty with the first category, for which the costs incurred amounted to $3,700; it has not been shown to be an unreasonable amount.

  27. (b) I have looked carefully at the second category of work where the claim is for $13,000, because at first blush, the hours spent in relation to preparing an affidavit in response (28 hours) seems to be high. However, when the discount of $2,700 is applied to that category of work, the amount claimed is $10,300. In my opinion, that amount has not been shown to be unreasonable.

  28. [42] As I have said, DNO does not challenge the reasonableness of the disbursements incurred by DNP in the Pre-Transfer Stage. I consider that each disbursement is both reasonable in quantum and reasonably incurred. Accordingly, I allow DNP’s claim for disbursements in the Pre-Transfer Stage, which is in the sum of $4,381.35.

  29. Post-Transfer Costs

  30. However, there is nothing to indicate that the principles set out in Senda International are not equally applicable to the SICC Rules 2021.

  31. (a) First, DNO’s Costs Schedule pertains only to the limited issue of standing, and not the costs incurred in respect of the entire proceedings. Without a full picture of the costs incurred, it is not possible to make an accurate comparison.

  32. (b) Secondly, DNO claims to have incurred Post-Transfer Costs of $15,375 solely for work done in relation to the issue of standing. In comparison, DNP’s claim for $77,400 for work done in relation to the substantive application in OA 4 does not appear to be disproportionate or unreasonable.

  33. [51] I make the following observations on DNP’s submission in this regard.

  34. [53] Insofar as DNP seeks to rely on the fact that the hearings in both cases lasted one day, I accept that as a relevant common feature. I also accept that the cases all involved first-instance proceedings under the International Arbitration Act 1994 (2020 Rev Ed), and that no Senior Counsel, King’s Counsel, or Registered Foreign Lawyer was appointed to act for either party.

  35. [54] However, I am unable to accept DNP’s submission (or implication) that the issues involved in the two cases were less complex than that in OA 4. It is unclear how DNP arrived at its conclusion that the issues involved in Gokul Patnaik v Nine Rivers Capital [2021] 3 SLR 22 were “less complex”, apart from its reference to the length of the judgment and the number of solicitors involved. I note that DNP also refers to the same two factors when explaining its reliance on CYW v CYX [2024] 3 SLR 125. I do not consider the length of a judgment to be a reliable guide as to the complexity of a case. There might be reasons, unrelated to the complexity of the case, why one judgment is longer than another. Nor do I think that the number of legal practitioners necessarily provides a reliable guide, unless the number of legal practitioners is much larger than what may be reasonably expected. As I explain below (at [56]), I do not consider that that can be said of this case.

  36. [60] I start with SUM 25. I will make extensive reference to my decision in DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit) (see [18(b)] above), and these reasons are to be read with the aforesaid judgment. The background to SUM 25 is as follows. DNP filed Mr Z’s affidavit on 7 November 2024. In that affidavit, Mr Z addressed the issue of DNO’s standing in detail. From that date, DNO was put on notice of DNP’s case as to its standing to challenge the Award. However, it was not until 26 March 2025, when the parties put forward the case management plan, that DNO gave notice that it sought to file a further affidavit on the issue of standing.

  37. (a) First, although the successful party will ordinarily receive its costs, SUM 25 was an application by a party to be relieved of an obligation it failed to comply with. DNO accepted that it needed the leave of the Court before filing a further affidavit (DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit) at [9] and [16]).

  38. (b) Secondly, it does not follow as a matter of course that the successful party in a pre-trial hearing is entitled to an order for costs. The fact that an application is successful is relevant, and may often be decisive. However, there may be other factors which support the conclusion that the successful party should not be awarded its costs. There were such other factors in this case of this application. The first of these was the extent of the delay. In respect of this matter, I found that there were four case management hearings between 7 November 2024 and 26 March 2025; at none of those conferences did DNO indicate that it intended to apply for permission to file a further affidavit. On at least two occasions, DNO “indicated expressly or by silence that it did not intend to file any interlocutory applications in the future” (DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit) at [38]). I found that it was reasonable for DNP, and the Court, to assume that DNO would not seek to file any further affidavits (DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit) at [40]). The second of the other factors is the explanation for the delay. In this respect, I found that DNO did not provide a clear explanation for its delay in bringing SUM 25 (DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit) at [41]–[42]).

  39. (c) Thirdly, although I found that DNO did not have a tactical reason for its delay in bringing SUM 25, I did find that the delay was the result of “a failure … to consider the matter carefully and/or confused or muddled thinking about [DNP] being ‘required’ to seek the resolution of the issue of standing well before the hearing” (DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit) at [46]).

  40. [63] First, DNO submits that it is clear the Partnership had changed its status to an incorporated private limited entity. I take this to be a submission that DNP should not have opposed the order sought. I reject this submission, because it was by no means beyond argument that SUM 25 should be refused having regard to DNO’s delay in bringing the application. Furthermore, DNO’s explanation for the fact that the Partnership continued to file GST Returns after the incorporation of DNO was not wholly satisfactory (DNO v DNP (Merits) at [54]).

  41. [65] The focus of this exchange was not on whether DNP was seeking to gain an unfair advantage, but rather, the possible prejudice DNO might suffer if the order was refused. This can be seen in my identification of a reason in favour of making the order sought by DNO (DNO v DNP (Leave to File Further Affidavit) at [47]):

  42. [66] In any event, I do not consider that DNP was seeking to obtain an unfair advantage based on the exchange I had with its counsel or at all. In addition to these matters, I observed that the decision whether to allow SUM 25 was finely balanced.

  43. [73] DNO also does not challenge the reasonableness of the disbursements incurred by DNP in the Post-Transfer Stage, and I consider that each disbursement is both reasonable in amount and reasonably incurred. Accordingly, I allow DNP’s claim for disbursements in the Post-Transfer Stage, in the sum of $2,116.02.

  44. Conclusion

  45. [77] For the avoidance of doubt, I record that in accordance with O 21 r 29(1) of the ROC 2021 and O 22 r 6 of the SICC Rules 2021, interest on the quantum awarded above (calculated at 5.33% per annum) will run from the date of this order until the date of full payment by DNO.

  46. Annex 1: DNP’s Costs and Disbursement Schedules

  47. DNP’s Costs Schedule

  48. DNP’s Disbursements Schedule

  49. Annex 2: DNO’s Costs and Disbursements Schedules

  50. DNO’s Costs Schedule

  51. DNO’s Disbursements Schedule