Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 11 Aug 2022
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

WBI v WBJ

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 22Case no. District Court Appeal No 164 of 202110 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The parties married on 2 December 2014. Divorce proceedings commenced on 1 July 2020 and interim judgment was granted on 13 November 2020. The Husband, aged 42, is a Singapore Citizen and the Wife, aged 39, is a Malaysian Citizen and a Singapore Permanent Resident. Both are teachers by profession. They have two children who are six years old and four years old respectively.

  2. [3] The Wife appealed against the DJ’s decision on the grounds that:

  3. (a) the DJ erred in finding that parties’ indirect contributions ought to be 50:50;

  4. (b) the DJ erred in according a weightage of 70:30 in respect of parties’ direct and indirect contributions;

  5. (c) the sale proceeds should be used to pay off the outstanding mortgage loan as well as all sale-related expenses, with parties making CPF refunds from their respective share of the net sale proceeds;

  6. (e) the DJ wrongly considered the exchanges of draft consent orders between parties as offers to settle when determining that she should bear the costs of the proceedings.

  7. [4] On the issue of the parties’ indirect contributions ratio, the Wife said that the DJ erred in attributing a ratio of 50:50. The Wife said that she was the primary caregiver of the children, a homemaker and the party who paid for the bulk of the household expenses. She also said that she made indirect financial contributions towards the family during the marriage, including purchasing furniture, home and kitchen appliances, paying for the children’s daily expenses and for the babysitter. The Husband said that the DJ’s decision should be upheld.

  8. [6] As to the weightage in respect of parties’ direct and indirect contributions, the Wife said that the DJ erroneously relied on the decision in UJF v UJG in according a weightage of 70:30 in respect of parties’ direct and indirect contributions respectively. She said that the case of UJF v UJG could be distinguished, as it concerned a marriage that was 4.5 years in length and there were no children to the marriage. The Wife said that an increased weightage ought to be given in respect of parties’ indirect contributions and suggests that an equal weightage is appropriate. The Husband said that the DJ’s decision should be upheld. In my view, the weightage assigned by the DJ is reasonable. The parties did receive a considerable amount of assistance in caring for the children – neither party had shown a substantial amount of care towards family life to justify a greater weightage on indirect contributions. Hence, a weightage of 70:30 in favour of the parties’ direct contributions was fair, resulting in a final ratio of 67.3:32.7 in favour of the Husband. If the DJ had found that the parties’ direct and indirect contributions are to be given equal weight, the ratio would be 62.35:37.65, which is not substantially different from what was determined. I am of the opinion that in future, the court should refrain from tinkering with the weightage of the parties’ direct contributions, and, instead, adjust the ratio of the indirect contributions to achieve a just and equitable distribution. Direct contributions are invariably the actual financial contributions made by each party and are determined through findings of fact. Once determined, it is irrational to dilute or increase what had been determined to be the direct contribution of each party.

  9. [7] As to the CPF refunds, the Wife said that the parties ought to make their CPF refunds from their respective share of the net sale proceeds of the matrimonial home, as opposed to making the refunds from the gross sales proceeds. Her counsel argued that this would be just and equitable because it will provide the Wife, the party with the comparatively lower salary and who has care and control of the two children, with funds to purchase a property for her to bring up the two children. Counsel referred to the case of Tay Sin Tor v Tan Chay Eng [1999] 2 SLR(R) 385 (“Tay Sin Tor”), which states (at [11]):

  10. [8] The Husband said that the parties’ CPF contributions were the joint contribution for the acquisition of the matrimonial flat and there is no reason to distinguish the refunding of parties’ CPF monies from other common deductions, such as the outstanding mortgage loan and sale-related expenses.

  11. [9] I agree with the DJ’s approach in ordering the CPF refunds to be made from the gross sales proceeds, before apportioning the sales proceeds between the parties. With respect, the reasoning in Tay Sin Tor is flawed. The court in Tay Sin Tor correctly held that CPF sums are “not loans” but “assets of the parties”, but it then contradicted itself by likening CPF sums to personal loans, which are not required to be repaid before division. I respectfully disagree with Tay Sin Tor that the liability to repay CPF sums used for the continuing payment of a matrimonial home is a “personal obligation”. That description has no helpful meaning in determining whether CPF contributions ought to be paid before or after distribution of the gross proceeds of sale. When CPF monies have been used to buy the matrimonial home, they are used for the benefit of the family and are obligations undertaken for the joint benefit of the marriage. They are part of the matrimonial assets and should not be treated as a class separate from other deductions.

  12. [12] In the present case, no such unfairness arises or is evident. The Wife said that the DJ’s approach would result in her receiving over $15,000 less in sale proceeds as opposed to if the CPF refunds were made from the parties’ share of the net sale proceeds. She said that she earns comparatively less in gross monthly income, has care and control of the children and would have to find an alternative place of residence for herself. In my view, her gross monthly income ($5,591) is not significantly lower than that of the Husband’s ($7,356). The children also do not have any exceptional needs. In the circumstances, the shortfall of $15,000 is not sufficiently material to warrant disturbing the orders of the court below.

  13. [13] On the issue of maintenance for the children, the Wife said that the DJ erred in arbitrarily stating that the children’s reasonable expenses were $1,500 and $1,200 respectively, without further explanation. Further, she said that the DJ erroneously determined the income ratio between parties to be 52:48, when in fact the ratio should be 56.8:43.2, based on their gross monthly income from March to May 2021. The Husband accepted that this ratio is more accurate.

  14. [16] The DJ had referred to the Family Dispute Resolution minute sheet dated 14 May 2021 and was of the view that the Wife had changed her mind on a clause in the agreement. It was not unreasonable to have taken this into account, given the substantial time that could have been saved had the Wife not changed her mind after an agreement had been reached during the mediation proceedings. I did not think that the DJ saw this strictly as an offer to settle, as the Wife claimed.