Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 16 Dec 2022
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

VEV v VEW

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHCF 29Case no. District Court Appeal No 49 of 20222 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The parties were married in Italy on 14 July 2011. The Father is a 49 years-old English Barrister who works as mediator, counsel and arbitrator. He has dual citizenship, in the United Kingdom and Australia. He is also a Singapore permanent resident. The Mother is 39 years-old and is a part-time pre-school teacher as well as a director of a handmade-chocolate company. She has a law degree and a Masters degree (in law). The Mother has dual citizenship, in the United Kingdom and Ireland. The parties have two children, aged seven and five respectively. The Father filed for divorce in July 2018 and interim judgment was granted on 5 March 2019.

  2. (a) The Husband produced an IRAS notice of assessment in June 2021 as proof that he was earning $4,300 per month. However, the DJ noted that the Husband’s expenses exceeded his declared income, and inferred that he had undeclared income. As the Husband earned an average of $10,000 per month (over a period of three years) during the ancillary matters stage, the DJ took the average of his past and present income over a period of four years. His average income was thus determined to be $8,575 per month. The Wife has an income of $3,000 per month.

  3. (b) With effect from 1 April 2022, the excess payments for the children’s medical expenses not covered by the insurers, or “deductibles”, shall be shared between the parties in the proportion of 75:25 by the Husband and the Wife, in accordance with their income ratio.

  4. (c) In respect of insurance payments, the Wife is to be solely responsible for $454.22 being the payment of the children’s medical insurance premium from 14 March 2022. The Husband is to make direct payment to the children’s health insurance provider, and then deduct an agreed sum of $454.22 from the maintenance he pays to the Wife for the children.

  5. (d) The Husband shall not be retrospectively entitled to any amounts in excess of the monthly sum of $454.22, from the date of the AM Orders until 14 March 2022. The parties through their conduct had acquiesced to the said monthly sum and it would be inequitable to allow the Husband to claim retrospectively for the agreed monthly sum.

  6. (e) That the Husband be awarded costs of $1,500, exclusive of disbursements.

  7. (a) The DJ was wrong to have varied the AM Orders to require parties to pay for “deductibles” in the ratio of 75:25, as this issue was already dealt with in the AM proceedings (the “Deductibles Issue”).

  8. (c) The award of costs to the Husband of $1,500 (exclusive of disbursements) was manifestly low (the “Costs Issue”).

  9. [9] I now turn to the Past Payments Issue. In the AM Orders dated 20 January 2020, the DJ determined that the monthly sum for each child’s health insurance was $248, based on figures that the Wife provided. This amounted to a total of $496 per month. However, in her decision for SUM 3151, the DJ stated that the monthly health insurance should be $454.22 for both children as the parties had “acquiesced to [this] said monthly sum” and that the Husband was not entitled to any amount in excess of this sum from the date of the AM Orders to 14 March 2022. The Husband says that the practical consequence of this is that the Wife would “benefit from a windfall” of $42 x 29 months, that is, $1,218 that she could allocate elsewhere.