Family Division of the High Court · Decided 25 July 2023
VHK v VHL
Feedback & support[2023] SGHCF 34 · Case no. Divorce (Transferred) No 2504 of 2018 · 7 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff (the “Mother”) and the defendant (the “Father”) solemnized and registered their marriage in Singapore on 19 March 2013 and married again (as recorded in their joint summary) on 28 March 2013 in the United States of America (“US”). The Father is a 57 years old American citizen residing in the US where he works as a specialist doctor. The Mother is 48 years old and is a Singapore citizen. She holds a master’s degree from a university in the US. She was formerly the owner of an online tutoring business and a part-time account manager. Her current employment status is unknown.
- [2]
[2] The parties lived in Hawaii from 2013 until they relocated to Florida in 2014. Their daughter was born on 26 March 2014 in the US (“the Child”). She is now 9 years old, and holds both Singapore and American citizenships. In early 2016, the Mother left the Father and moved back to Hawaii with the Child, where she subsequently filed for divorce in September 2016. However, pending the outcome of her divorce application, the Mother had relocated to Singapore with the Child in early 2018. Therefore, given that she was no longer domiciled in the US, her divorce application in the US was dismissed on 30 May 2018 for lack of jurisdiction.
- [3]
[3] On 31 May 2018, the Mother commenced divorce proceedings in Singapore. Interim judgment of divorce was granted on 13 November 2018 and the ancillary matters (“AM”) were heard by Tan Puay Boon JC on 15 November 2019. Prior to the AM hearing, the parties made numerous applications to the court, concerning interim maintenance, interim access to the Child, and cross-applications for committal proceedings. The following were some of those interim orders made:
(a) under FC/ORC 2667/2019, the Father was to contribute monthly interim maintenance of $4,055.00 and $2,400.00 respectively for the Child and the Mother with effect from March 2019;
(b) under FC/ORC 1705/2019, the Father was granted interim access pending the making of the ancillary orders; and
(c) in committal proceedings brought by the parties respectively in FC/SUM 2447/2019 and FC/SUM 2977/2019, both the Mother and the Father were found to be in breach of FC/ORC 1705/2019 and fined.
- [5]
[5] The AM orders were not operationalised smoothly and led to further disputes between the parties — the Father requested for further arguments, and the Mother complained to court on two other occasions. Tan JC heard these matters on 12 November 2020. By this time, the parties had discharged their counsel, and appeared in-person. At the hearing, the parties raised issues concerning access orders made by JC Tan. The main issue was the Father’s allegation that the Mother had been violating the video access orders — that the Mother was uncooperative and did not want to communicate with him directly. The Father further said that the Mother had been disruptive during the stipulated video access times, by hanging up the call on him and pressuring the Child to hang up on him. He said that the Mother’s conduct amounted to parental alienation, which had caused the video access arrangements to “deteriorate to the point where [the Child] doesn’t talk at all anymore”.
- [6]
[6] After hearing the parties on 12 November 2020, Tan JC made amendments to the original AM orders, of which the following are pertinent to the present proceedings:
(a) for urgent travels involving the Child, notice of travel is to be provided to the Father as soon as practicable if there was no opportunity to give one month’s notice;
(b) for travels involving the Child, the Mother is to provide the contact number of a third party whom the Father could reach in the event of any emergency;
(c) the first visit of the Child to the US, subject to the prevailing restrictions on travel because of the Covid-19 pandemic at that time, was to be in 2021 during the Christmas vacation. The first visit of the Child to the US during the summer vacation was to be in 2022, subject to mutual agreement and to the prevailing restrictions on travel due to the COVID-19 pandemic; and
(d) video access sessions by the Father to the Child are to take place on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Sundays. Each session is to commence at 7.30pm Singapore time, and would be for a minimum of 15 minutes and limited to a maximum of 30 minutes.
(a) that the Father’s committal application in HCF/SUM 27/2022, the summons for variation of the access orders in HCF/SUM 235/2022 and the summons to vary the care and control orders in HCF/SUM 133/2022 are to be adjourned to a date to be fixed;
(b) in the interim, that the Child is to be taken into custody by the CPS as soon as she returns to Singapore;
(c) the CPS is to ensure that the Father has access according to the existing access orders, with video-link access to take place without the presence of the Mother; and
(d) liberty to the Father to apply for two weeks full access.
- [12]
[12] I asked the Father whether he was still having video access with the Child. He said that it was practically meaningless because the Mother turned off the microphone so that the Child could not speak. She also turned off the speaker so that the Child could not hear him. I asked if all he had was just to see the Child’s face on the screen. He said not even that because the Mother used the Child’s hair to cover her (the Child’s) face.
- [16]
[16] Had the Mother applied to have the warrant rescinded, it would likely have been granted upon terms that she returns and brings the Child before the court. The Mother is still at liberty to so apply. Until such time as she does, she remains a fugitive of her own volition.