Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 23 Feb 2023
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

VWJ v VWI

Feedback & support

[2023] SGHCF 7Case no. General Division of the High Court (Family Division) — District Court Appeal No 68 of 2022 Choo Han Teck J 15 February 20235 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The appellant (the “Mother”) and the respondent (the “Father”) were married on 5 January 2020. Their son (the “Child”) was born in May 2020 and is presently two and a half years old. This appeal arises out of the decision of the District Judge (the “DJ”) in the cross applications of both parents seeking care and control and access to the Child under s 5 of the Guardianship of Infants Act (Cap 122, 1985 Rev Ed). Parties could not file for divorce because at the time of the applications, they had not been married for more than three years.

  2. [4] Counsel for the Mother, Ms Kulvinder Kaur, pointed out that service of the appellant’s case was effected at 8.59 am on 15 November 2022, which was a day late and was thus deemed as withdrawn. Rule 827(1) of the Family Justice Rules 2014 (“FJR”) requires the appellant’s case to be filed and served within one month of the Registrar’s notice. Mr Fernandez submitted that the deemed withdrawal under Rule 827(5) of the FJR for non-compliance with Rule 827(1) of the FJR is only limited to filing and not service. In support of this, he says that the time for the Respondent’s Case to be prepared only runs upon receipt of service and not filing. He further submitted that whereas filing may easily be effected by e-filing, the same cannot be said for service of documents, as litigants-in-person may evade service, thus leading to service not being in compliance with Rule 827(1)(b) of the FJR. I do not agree with this interpretation. The plain wording of Rule 827(5) of the FJR requires the appellant to comply with Rule 827(1) of the FJR which contains both the requirement to file (Rule 827(1)(a) of the FJR) and the requirement of service (Rule 827(1)(b) of the FJR). Mr Fernandez’s example about litigants-in-person evading service does not assist him in this case, because the respondent was represented by counsel, and the papers could have been served electronically. But I accept that in some cases, service on litigants-in-person may not be carried out in time, but that would be a justifiable basis to seek an extension of time under Rule 827(5) of the FJR, as a genuine attempt was made to comply with the rules in Rule 827(1) of the FJR. This was what counsel ought to have done, rather than assuming that the court will be indulgent just because he was fractionally late. Deadlines laid down in the rules and by the court must be adhered to strictly. The application for an extension of time for non-compliance of any degree, is a matter of procedural fairness to the other party and courtesy to the court. Nonetheless, as the delay in service was only a day and as Ms Kaur did not press her objection, I proceeded to consider the merits of the appeal.

  3. [9] The final point raised by Mr Fernandez is that the Father remains a full-fledged international flight steward and there was no evidence to show that the Father was transitioning to becoming a ground trainer which would enable him to be with the Child on a regular basis. This was, in my view, an incorrect statement. The DJ found as a fact that the Father had been placed on a Regional Flying Scheme which puts him on “turnaround flights”, meaning that the Father would be back in Singapore by the end of the day. This finding was made on the basis of the Father’s affidavit where he set out his flying schedule. It is clear that this arrangement made his job no different in terms of hours from any other regular office job, allowing him to return home to the Child after office hours. If there is any change to this, the Mother has the option to file an application for variation, but as the evidence stands, I see no basis to disturb the DJ’s findings. I also note that the Father has undergone courses to transition into a ground trainer which would eventually allow him to cease flying altogether. On the basis of the evidence before him, the DJ was satisfied that efforts had been made for the Father to become a ground trainer and I see no basis to challenge that finding. However, even under the Father’s current Regional Flying Scheme, I do not think that that there is any irregularity of working hours that may undermine his ability to care for the child, and should there be problems in the future, the Mother is at liberty to file for variation.

  4. [11] Finally, while the DJ did not base his findings on the marks on the Child’s body which were used by parties to disparage each other’s ability to care for the Child, I affirm the DJ’s observation (at [24]) that:

  5. [12] Indeed, when a family has broken down, the welfare of the children comes to the fore of the law’s concern. Even if the parents were to see themselves as at war with each other (though they should not), they must not weaponise their children in any aspect or stage of their dispute with each other. Every child should benefit from the love of both parents, and true love is demonstrated by reining in spousal acrimony to ensure that continuity of co-parental love for children post-divorce is not merely an ideal, but a reality.