Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 6 Feb 2024
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

WOZ v WOY

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHCF 11Case no. District Court Appeal No 64 of 20233 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The parties were married on 25 September 2011. They have one daughter (“the Child”) turning 12 years old this year. Interim judgment was granted on 16 March 2023. The ancillary matters were heard before the District Judge (“DJ”) below on 7 July 2023 (“AM date”), and the DJ gave his decision on 10 July 2023. The Husband appealed. The two issues in this appeal were —

  2. [2] The appellant sought to adduce public records, obtained as of August 2023, of actual sales of comparable properties to the matrimonial home. Mr Andrew Goh, counsel for the appellant, submitted that this was a more up-to-date price than what was available at the AM date. I did not allow this new evidence. The valuation of matrimonial assets is to be assessed as at the AM date (7 July 2023), with whatever information available as of that date. That is trite, and for good reasons. The court must value the matrimonial property on a fixed date, for certainty and finality. It would be absurd for unsatisfied parties to return to court for a revaluation of the property each time prices move in their favour. This is especially so, in the current market where property prices are likely to rise.

  3. [4] I have no doubt that the Husband is appealing because he desires for a better outcome during his limited access time with the Child. But the Child is turning 12 this year, and she is thus at a sufficiently mature age to evaluate how a parent-child relationship should develop in their case. Relationship building requires time, effort, and patience from both sides. Above all, it is unique in each relationship. It is not amenable to judicial commands, and the courts must leave it to the parents to develop their own bond with their children, each in his or her own way. Sometimes, the court might offer a nudge here and there, but in the end, it must be left to the parent to find the formula. I thus allowed the current access arrangements to remain for now, but I granted the Husband liberty to apply after three months, to see if there is room for change in the access conditions.