The text
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT Under the provisions of clause 2(d) of Article 46 of the Constitution of the Republic of Singapore, the following Members have been granted permission to be or to remain absent from sittings of Parliament (or any Committee of Parliament to which they have been appointed) for the periods stated:- Dr Beng Kian Lam, Arthur - from 22nd to 23rd January and from 16th to 21st February, 1996. Mr Chay Wai Chuen - from 22nd to 25th January and from 12th to 24th February, 1996. Dr Wan Soon Bee - from 27th to 31st January and from 24th February to 1st March, 1996. Dr John Chen Seow Phun - from 30th January to 3rd February, 1996. Mr Peh Chin Hua - from 30th January to 6th February, 1996. Mr Chew Heng Ching - from 30th January to 2nd February, 1996. Prof. S. Jayakumar - from 1st to 3rd February, 1996. BG Lee Hsien Loong - from 1st to 6th February, 1996. Dr Wong Kwei Cheong - from 5th to 6th February, from 12th to 15th February and from 28th February to 1st March, 1996. Assoc. Prof. Walter Woon - from 5th to 20th February, 1996. Mr Peter Sung - from 9th to 14th February and from 5th to 10th March, 1996. Mr S. Chandra Das - from 10th to 18th February, 1996. Mrs Yu-Foo Yee Shoon - from 11th to 14th February, 1996. Encik Sidek Bin Saniff - from 12th to 22nd February, 1996. Mr S. Dhanabalan - on 14th February, 1996. Mr R. Sinnakaruppan - from 17th to 22nd February, 1996. Mr Stephen Lee Ching Yen - from 20th February to 3rd March, 1996. Mr Heng Chiang Meng - from 23rd to 27th February and from 4th to 19th March, 1996. Dr Michael Lim Chun Leng - from 27th February to 8th March, 1996. Mr Davinder Singh - from 27th February to 22nd March, 1996. Mr Bernard Chen - from 29th February to 8th March, 1996. Assoc. Prof. Ho Peng Kee - from 22nd March to 10th April, 1996. TAN SOO KHOON Speaker Parliament of Singapore
ASSENTS TO BILLS PASSED The following Bills were assented to by the President of the Republic of Singapore on the dates stated: 30th January, 1996 (i) Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (Amendment) Bill 1996; (ii) Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore Bill 1996; (iii) Local Treasury Bills (Amendment) Bill 1996; and (iv) Evidence (Amendment) Bill 1996. 2nd February, 1996 (i) Government Securities (Amendment) Bill 1996. TAN SOO KHOON Speaker Parliament of Singapore
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - PROPOSED LAND BRIDGE - (Linking Andaman Sea with Gulf of Thailand) asked the Minister for Trade and Industry what will be the impact on Singapore's economy of the proposed land bridge linking the Andaman Sea with the Gulf of Thailand.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - PROPOSED LAND BRIDGE - (Linking Andaman Sea with Gulf of Thailand) Mr Speaker, Sir, the proposed land bridge is part of Thailand's Southern Seaboard Development (SSB) plan. It is not the only land bridge project being proposed in the region. Malaysia has also proposed a Penang-Songkhla land bridge within the Indonesian-Malaysian-Thailand Growth Triangle economic cooperation framework. The two projects will involve substantial investments in roads, pipelines and port infrastructure. The viability of the projects will depend on how competitive the costs of unloading, transportation and reloading of cargo are, in relation to the existing alternatives. As the preliminary feasibility study into the project has not been completed yet, it is premature to assess the projects' full impact on Singapore. The two land bridge projects are being proposed at a time when the Asia-Pacific is growing rapidly and trade is expanding. The port of Singapore will grow with the region as long as we continue to provide the shipping community with good service at competitive rates. In particular, the Port of Singapore Authority must strive to maintain its competitiveness through skills upgrading, sound management and investment in infrastructure and technology. This way, Singapore can meet the keener competition posed by emerging regional ports and other infrastructure projects like the proposed land bridges.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) asked the Minister for Trade and Industry whether he is satisfied that Singapore Power has done enough (i) to improve efficiency and productivity and (ii) to control costs internally, as means to improve company profitability rather than through tariff increases.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, I am satisfied that the former PUB Electricity and Gas Departments, and now SP, have been operating efficiently. I am requesting the Clerk to hand out the comparative charts for Members' reference. Mr Speaker, while waiting for the charts, could we proceed to the next Question first and I will take up this Question in a few minutes' time?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) All right. [Later - After Question No. 5]
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Mr Yeo, your charts are ready. Would you like to give your answer now?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Thank you, Sir. As I was saying just now, I am satisfied that the former PUB Electricity and Gas Departments, and now SP, have been operating efficiently. The Clerk of Parliament has distributed the comparative charts (Cols. 749 - 762) and Members may wish to refer to them. charts -
Comparison of Productivity Indicators with Regional Power Companies, (B) SP's Electricity Supply Reliability Indicators (Cols. 749 - 762) Firstly, in comparison with other utility companies, SP ranks among the best in terms of many performance measures: electricity produced and sold per employee; installed capacity per employee; thermal efficiency, unit cost, and losses in transmission and distribution. Secondly, the reliability of SP's supply is also high and has been improving steadily year by year. This is so whether measured in terms of system interruption time, supply interruptions per day, interruptions per 1,000 customers, or interruption duration. Thirdly, The World Competitiveness Report has ranked Singapore best in the world for having a power supply infrastructure which meets business requirements. Fourthly, in December 1994, MTI commissioned an independent review of PUB's Electricity Department, in preparation for its corporatisation as Singapore Power. The review was done by Deloitte & Touche, who had been consultants to the British Government when it privatised the electricity industry in Britain, and were therefore experts in this area. Deloitte & Touche concluded that the PUB Electricity Department had been managed and operated efficiently. Their Report gave the following reasons to support their conclusion: (a) PUB's electricity tariff has fallen in real and nominal terms over the past 10 years; (b) PUB has been able to finance additional capacity required without increasing its long term debt even though tariffs have fallen; (c) PUB has efficiently run, well-maintained power generation stations and a sophisticated dispatch system; (d) power losses are very low - the standard of system security is high; (e) unit costs of customer services activities are low; and (f) manning levels have declined although the electricity undertaking has grown by all normal measures of output and activity levels, including maximum demand, energy supplied and customers connected. Some Singaporeans have commented that SP's profitability may be low because SP is over-capitalised or its assets have been over-valued. This is not the case. SP is not over-capitalised. We restructured SP's balance sheet upon corporatisation to give it a gearing ratio of one-third. This is a prudent balance between debt and equity. It gives SP enough shareholder funds to invest and grow without over-capitalising the company. Normally, increasing the gearing of a company will improve its return on equity (ROE) because the cost of borrowing is lower than what the company can earn on its shareholder funds. But in SP's case, this increased gearing only improved its ROE very slightly, because SP's return on equity had been low - only slightly higher than its borrowing costs. On the question of asset valuation, SP's land and buildings were revalued to market value upon corporatisation. The valuations were done by an independent property consultant, Jones Lang Wootton, with inputs from the Chief Valuer. This revaluation was necessary, for SP's accounts to reflect accurately the true costs of producing and distributing electricity to Singaporeans. The land occupied by power stations and SP's office buildings represent scarce and valuable resources, especially in Singapore. There is a high opportunity cost to using them. This cost is as much part of the cost of producing and distributing electricity, as the fuel oil and natural gas which the power stations consume. SP's profitability is low primarily because of the low electricity tariffs. Our tariffs are lower than many countries in the region, even though our land and labour costs are higher than most countries. SP will continue to improve its efficiency and productivity, and to control costs internally to improve profitability. However, this is unfortunately not sufficient. It is therefore also necessary to raise electricity tariffs by 12-14% over 3-4 years, to correctly reflect the full economic costs of producing and distributing electricity in Singapore.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, does the Minister agree that even before corporatisation PUB was already very efficient? Since corporatisation, have we seen substantial improvements or do we expect to see substantial improvements? My second question is on the gearing. If SP is now asked to gear to one-third, who are they borrowing from and what sort of interest rate do they have to pay and what impact does this interest have on the bottom line?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, as the charts show, the former PUB had actually run a very tight ship in terms of capacity per employee, sales per employee, thermal efficiency, etc. So it has already been performing well. But I think there is still room for improvement. As SP regionalises and as they gain access to different modes of operation, I think they should be able to transfer those lessons to their operations in Singapore. We hope to see SP continue to improve on the foundations that PUB handed to them. Secondly, in terms of the gearing, Mr Lee has asked about the impact of the borrowings on the bottom line. Sir, when we corporatised SP and SP geared up to 30%, the Government actually provided SP with an interest-free loan of $1.7 billion, rather than requiring SP to go out into the commercial market to borrow. So in actual fact, the interest-free loan of $1.7 billion represents a subsidy of over $100 million a year to SP.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, can the Minister enlighten the House whether or not the Government plans to continue to extend the interest-free loan to SP or whether this is an interim measure and, if so, for how long?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, this is an interim measure. The Government will extend the interest-free loan to SP for a few years. SP is still in the process of finalising their accounts and their accounts will be ready in a few months' time and we will know the actual picture. Over the next few years, as SP's operations are consolidated, and as the figures become more readily available, we will review whether we need to continue giving the interest-free loan.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Is the Minister aware that the vast majority of Singaporeans would prefer to keep the old structure of PUB where they pay lower tariffs as opposed to paying higher tariffs to Singapore Power so that Singapore Power can be attractively profitable and it could then go on to pay good dividends to shareholders, some of whom may not even be Singaporeans? If this is so, what justification is there to list Singapore Power and what are the advantages to the Singaporean?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, now that we have corporatised SP and the full data are available, I think it is incumbent upon the Government to ensure that the tariffs are correctly priced in order to obtain a reasonable return on this very crucial infrastructure. So whether or not we privatise SP, SP would need to raise its tariffs to obtain a reasonable rate of return. In terms of the privatisation programme, that is a separate matter. As I mentioned just now, the tariffs will have to be correctly set regardless of this privatisation programme. But the main reason for privatisation is to enable Singaporeans to have a direct stake in the economy. This is part of the asset enhancement programme of the Government. We will decide on the privatisation of SP in the coming years.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, the Minister has said that the Government has given SP an interest-free loan. If we were to impute the interest cost into SP, will we still be operating a profitable or loss-making entity?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) With the interest-free loan of $1.7 billion, the return on equity for SP is 7.6%, based on the figures that we currently have. If SP had to borrow, at prime rate, this sum of $1.7 billion, its return on equity will go down to 6.4%. SP will still be profitable. It is just that the return would be lower.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, the employees have transferred their gratuity to Singapore Power as a result of the restructuring. With the delay in listing, what will happen to their gratuity? And will there be retrenchment in Singapore Power's bid to want to be efficient? If there is retrenchment, will the retrenchment benefits be calculated to include the service of the employees since the PUB days?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, the gratuity which has been agreed upon will remain. On the question of retrenchments, I have not heard of any plans to retrench. What SP intends to do is to consolidate the operations and to make sure that the existing staff are deployed meaningfully.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Just now the Minister mentioned about reasonable return on capital investment, and whether or not it is going to be privatised, the increases in tariffs are inevitable. That is what I understand. The question now is: who is the return for - the 12%-14% increases that the Minister proposed over the next three years? Is it for the Government?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, the proposed increase of 12% to 14% over the next three to four years will result in SP having a return on equity of 10% to 11%. Who owns SP? At the present moment, the SP shares are owned by the Government and this represents assets of the people. Why should we ensure that electricity tariffs are set properly? The main reason is that electricity is consumption. It is better that we price electricity properly and let the people and companies decide on how much to use. For example, if a company wishes to have its building lit up like a Christmas tree the whole day, and is prepared to pay the price, so be it, because it is paying the economic price. If companies feel that they want to save on power, then they can decide to light up for a shorter number of hours. And similarly at home, whether to leave the lights on the whole night or to switch them off when they go out for dinner. This is a decision which is within the capability of each of us to make. So once it is priced properly, we leave the decision to you, because at the end of the day we have not just to import all the fuel but the cost of building new stations is also very, very high. A new power station now costs billions of dollars. So it is better that we price properly and encourage Singaporeans to use electricity efficiently so that we do not have to incur any more expenses than we need to.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, I suppose I was right to say that the return right now is for the Government's investment, and not whether or not SP is going to be privatised. The next supplementary question is this. Based on the Minister's answer about tariff, is he saying that electricity tariff in the past was not set properly? And if it is so, why? And when did he discover that it was not set properly?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, it is not that the tariffs were not set properly. The tariffs in the past were set based on the accounting system that PUB had. And based on that accounting system, PUB appeared to be making very reasonable returns. What was the old accounting system? In earlier years PUB had to borrow from the World Bank. As a World Bank borrower, the World Bank imposes on the borrower the requirement that the borrower must use the World Bank's system of accounting. This is so that all the borrowers have the same system. The World Bank's system, like most public sector systems, was a simpler system of accounting and which did not take into account the working capital and operating capital needs of a company. So when SP was corporatised, and SP used the normal commercial accounting system and standards, all these other operating costs were then captured. And these are real operating costs because the working capital of the company can be very significant. We have to price that capital into it. When SP was corporatised, all these figures came to light, and that was when we realised that the old set of tariffs was based on a different accounting requirement and therefore we should use what is the normal accounting system now, which is being applied to all the statutory boards and all private sector companies.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Is the Minister saying that in the past, the operating cost of PUB was not taken into account in the accounting system?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Yes, in the past, under the World Bank's accounting system, for example, work-in-progress was not taken into consideration. And as you know, it now costs about a billion dollars to build a power station. So from the time you start to the time you finish, all those requirements were not captured in PUB's accounts. But under the normal accounting system, all these costs - work-in-progress and working capital - have to be in the accounts. Is the World Bank's system wrong? I do not think so. It is an accounting system which is required by the World Bank and which measures a certain level of capital needs. I think what we failed to recognise was that the World Bank's accounting system was a very simplified form of accounting system. If it had realised that, then PUB would have, I think, moved away from the World Bank's system much earlier.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Two supplementary questions, Sir. Firstly, do we owe any more money to the World Bank where Singapore Power is concerned? And secondly, if Singapore Power were not privatised, what would the Minister consider to be a reasonable return on equity?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) The answer to her first question is no, PUB does not owe any more money to the World Bank and therefore we could have moved away from the World Bank's accounting system earlier. Secondly, if SP were not privatised, what would be a reasonable rate of return? A 10%-11% rate of return would be reasonable. In fact, that is close to what PUB was obtaining when it was using the World Bank's system of accounting.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) The Minister was saying earlier that even after accounting for the interest cost, SP will achieve a 6%-plus return, and he mentioned that a 12%-plus return is even more justifiable. But compared to, say, the case of SBS that obtained listing and aimed for 8% return, why not go for a lower percentage like 8%, rather than going for a higher 12% return? Because in the end, if you are going for a higher return just for the sake of getting a listing, then is it worth it? Should we go for a listing for a higher return?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, I did not say 12% return. I said, 10% to 11% return, lower than what SBS is earning today, and lower than what all the other utility companies are earning today.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, I refer to the Charts distributed by the Minister. The productivity indicators show that the productivity of countries like Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand is much lower than Singapore, whereas in terms of average tariffs charged by regional power companies, Indonesia, Thailand and Malaysia are able to charge lower tariffs than Singapore Power. Why is this so?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, two reasons. Firstly, wages and land cost are lower. Secondly, their energy costs are also lower, because these are all energy producers as well.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, the Minister said that SP intends to maintain the 10% to 11% rate of return under the new accounting system. What is the expected percentage increase of the tariffs if it intends to maintain the 10% to 11% of return?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, as I mentioned just now, SP would need to raise its tariffs by 12% to 14% over the next three to four years. I think what Members may also be interested in is to have a picture of what such increases translate into at the individual level. A 5% increase in tariff - we are saying 12% to 14% over three to four years - would mean that the tariff will increase by about 3% to 5% per year. What will the 5% increase in tariff translate into at the household level? For a 3-room flat, a 5% increase in electricity tariff will translate into a bill size increase of $1.40 per month. For a 5-room flat, the 5% tariff increase will translate into $2.20 increase in the SP bill size per month. And for private housing, since they use more electricity, the private households would incur an increase in bill size of $5.30 per month.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) ( In Mandarin): Mr Speaker, Sir, I would like to ask the Minister whether SP has plans to build new power plants. If so, how many new plants will be built and where will they be built?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, the Government has under construction at this present moment a new power plant in Tuas. This new power plant would have a generating capacity of 1.2 gigawatts or 1,200 megawatts of electricity and the investment would be in the region of about $1.8 billion for the plant. The plant would be ready and operational in the year 1999.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, just now the Minister said that because the cost of other countries is lower than ours, that is why they can afford to charge lower tariff. But please refer to Chart 5 where it is shown that Indonesia's cost per unit produced and distributed, compared to Singapore, is only less than a cent lower. And their loss as percentage of units generated is 14%, compared to 9.2% for Singapore Power. Whereas the tariff charged by Singapore Power, compared to Indonesia, is more than 3 cents. Would the Minister explain that?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Can he repeat that again?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) In Chart 5, Indonesia charges 7.36 cents per unit (that is the cost per unit); Singapore Power, 8.04 cents. The difference is less than a cent. In Chart 6, under "Losses as Percentage of Units Generated", Indonesia, 14%, compared to Singapore Power, 9.2%. And in Chart 12, Indonesia charges 9.77 cents while Singapore Power charges 12.37 cents.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, there is a chart which is not available here, and that is, the return on equity of the regional companies. It shows that the rate of return for the Indonesian utility companies is extremely low.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Will there be a tax on electricity consumption when SP is finally listed?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) There is a 10% tax on SP bills?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Yes.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Whatever the present figure is, it will still remain.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) That means there will still be a tax on electricity.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Yes. Whatever tax there is now on utility bills will remain unchanged when SP is privatised.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) What is the purpose of a tax then? Is it to cover the present tariffs which are not properly worked out? Or is it really for consumption? As the Minister has said, anybody can use any amount of light they like as long as they can pay. An hon. Member: You pay more.
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Yes. But is the tax to cover for the losses which PUB would have made if the tariffs were properly priced?
SINGAPORE POWER - (Efficiency and productivity) Sir, this tax on utility bills goes to the Government. If Mr Chiam were to refer back to the time when the tax was first implemented, the tax is meant to encourage conservation, since utilities are the biggest users of fuel oil.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) asked the Minister for Communications whether the Singapore Mass Rapid Transit Pte Ltd has published its financial statement and annual report.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Mr Speaker, Sir, as the Singapore Mass Rapid Transit Pte Ltd (SMRT) is not a publicly listed company, it is not required to publish its annual report and financial statements for public information. However, it is the practice of SMRT to release its financial results to the press after the end of each financial year, covering the period from April to March the following year.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Sir, does the SMRT release the whole set of the financial accounts or is it released in the form of only a press statement?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Sir, the financial results are contained in the annual report and copies of the annual report are circulated widely, including, I believe, grassroots advisers as well as all statutory boards. Of course, copies are available in the libraries.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Is SMRT Pte Ltd part of Government's investment or is it solely owned by private individuals?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) The shareholders of SMRT at the moment are 100% Government.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Since it is 100% Government-owned and according to the annual report of MRTC it is an investment, why were the accounts not incorporated into the MRTC's annual report?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Sir, I am not quite familiar with what the Member is driving at but MRTC, if I hear the Member correctly, was actually a statutory board. SMRT, on the other hand, is a company that has been set up to run the mass rapid transit system. The two entities are quite separate and distinct. SMRT, which is the subject of the Member's question in this case, is a public company but not listed at the moment and therefore it has to comply with all the rules and regulations pertaining thereto. It publishes an annual report and all the financial statements that are required under the law are contained in that report.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Should MRTC, which is solely owned by the Government as the Minister has said, be considered as a subsidiary of the Government?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) The Member has got the wrong information. MRTC was a statutory board until recently when it was ---
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) SMRT.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) SMRT is a company. MRTC was actually a statutory board. So there is really no reason why the SMRT accounts should be contained in MRTC's report.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Is the investment of SMRT through the MRTC which holds a special rights share?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) No, Sir. The MRTC is not the shareholder of SMRT. The shareholder of SMRT is actually the Government, mainly through Temasek Holdings.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Since the shareholder is the Government, where is the investment reflected in the Government's financial report, if it is not MRTC?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) As I said earlier, the shareholder of SMRT is Temasek Holdings.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Can I take it that it should be reflected in Temasek Holdings' report?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) It should be reflected in the report of Temasek Holdings in the same way that Temasek's other investments in other companies, such as SIA, etc. are reflected.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Does SMRT lodge its report with the Registry of Companies and Businesses (RCB)?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) As the SMRT publishes an annual report and the annual report contains financial statements, the answer is that if the RCB requires such reports, then the SMRT will comply.
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) Since SMRT is of importance to the public because it operates the public transportation system, would the Minister require the SMRT to submit its report to Parliament as well?
SINGAPORE MASS RAPID TRANSIT PTE LTD - (Publication of financial statement and annual report) I do not know what the Member is driving at. As I said earlier, the SMRT, as a company, publishes an annual report. Copies of the annual report are available to Members of Parliament, all Government statutory boards and, in fact, to any member of the public who wishes to get a copy of it. It is publicly available. There is nothing that the SMRT wishes to hide and those reports are available to the Member himself if he so wishes. There is no question of the SMRT making extra efforts to publish its report. All the requirements of a company are complied with by the SMRT and copies of the report are available.
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) asked the Minister for Communications why the announcement of the stations and details of the North-East MRT Line has been delayed.
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) Sir, on 19th January 1996, I informed Parliament that Cabinet has decided to proceed to build the North-East MRT line immediately. I had then said that further details will be announced in due course. Presently, the Land Transport Authority is still finalising these details in conjunction with other relevant agencies. This is a major project, there are many planning and technical issues to resolve. An announcement will be made as soon as these issues have been settled, which is expected to be within the next few weeks.
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) Sir, what are the technical issues or other issues which the Minister mentioned had to be resolved? The second supplementary question is: is it true that the SMRT was scheduled to make the announcement before the Chinese New Year?
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) In planning for a new rail line, there are many land use planning issues that have to be settled. There are many land acquisition issues that have to be settled. These are issues which will have to involve many different Government agencies and as a result of this it is not wise for us to rush the relevant agencies when they finally make their recommendations. In so far as the second question is concerned, I am not aware of what the Member has said.
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) Would the Minister confirm that the details will be released within the next two weeks?
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) Sir, the details will be released as soon as they are finalised. As I said in my answer just now, I expect them to be finalised within the next few weeks.
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) When will it be announced? I suppose the details will include the stations. Am I right?
NORTH-EAST MRT LINE - (Announcement of stations and details) I thought I made it quite clear that it will be announced as soon as the details are finalised.
LAND ABOVE OR NEAR MRT STATIONS - (Development by Land Transport Authority) asked the Minister for Communications whether he will consider introducing legislation to amend the Land Transport Authority of Singapore Act and other relevant laws to allow the Land Transport Authority to develop land above or near MRT stations.
LAND ABOVE OR NEAR MRT STATIONS - (Development by Land Transport Authority) Sir, section 6 of the Land Transport Authority of Singapore Act spells out the functions and duties of the Land Transport Authority. In addition, it provides for the Authority to undertake such other functions as the Minister may assign to it. The Government can decide whether to allow the Authority to develop land above or near MRT stations under this section of the LTA Act.
LAND ABOVE OR NEAR MRT STATIONS - (Development by Land Transport Authority) Sir, is the redevelopment at the bus interchange near the Toa Payoh MRT station undertaken by the LTA?
LAND ABOVE OR NEAR MRT STATIONS - (Development by Land Transport Authority) Sir, the redevelopment of land around bus interchanges at the moment is undertaken as part of a comprehensive redevelopment scheme carried out primarily by the HDB in conjunction with other relevant agencies.
LAND ABOVE OR NEAR MRT STATIONS - (Development by Land Transport Authority) The Minister has said that section 6 of the LTA Act covers areas in which the Minister will assign to the LTA. But does the Minister agree with me that such provisions are too wide? Would it not be necessary to have an amendment to specifically say that the LTA has the authority to develop land near or at MRT stations? At present, if there is any development, it will probably be done by the HDB.