Part 13: Civil Appeals before the General Division

111. Application of this Part 112. Request for further arguments before Judge 112A. Submissions by leading and junior assisting counsel 113. Civil Appeals from the State Courts to the General Division Appeals from District Judge and Magistrate to the General Division under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Rules of Court 2021 Appeals from District Court and Magistrate’s Court to the General Division under Order 19, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court 2021 Appeals from the Employment Claims Tribunal 114. Civil Appeals from Registrar to Judge in chambers 115. Civil Appeals from Tribunals to the General Division, and applications to the General Division for a case to be stated or by way of case stated

The directions in this Part apply to civil appeals before the General Division (excluding appeals under section 55 of the Medical Registration Act 1997).

All requests for further arguments pursuant to Order 18, Rule 28 or Order 19, Rule 21 of the Rules of Court 2021 must be made by way of Request filed through the Electronic Filing Service and should, either in the Request electronic form or a document attached to the Request:

state the party making the request; (b) identify the Judge who heard the appeal; (c) specify when the order concerned was made (if the request is made after the Judge has given his or her decision); (d) state the provision of law under which the request is made; (e) set out the proposed further arguments briefly, together with any authorities; and (f) include a copy of each of the authorities cited.

A copy of the Request should be furnished to all parties to the appeal.

All Requests should be addressed to the Registrar.

&x20;Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 96 of these Practice Directions, in the event that a party is represented by more than one counsel in the conduct of proceedings under this Part, junior assisting counsel are ordinarily expected to make part of the submissions at any oral hearing.

&x20;Lead counsel is to inform the Court at the start of the oral hearing which issues would be addressed by the lead counsel or the junior assisting counsel.

&x20;Unless otherwise directed by the Court,

&x20;counsel should ensure that he or she confines himself or herself to the issues to be addressed and that there is no overlap in the issues being dealt with by different counsel for the same party; and \ (b) &x20;counsel must not repeat, clarify or expand on any submissions that have been made by another counsel for the same party.

&x20;Nothing in this paragraph detracts from the responsibility of lead counsel to ensure that all counsel making submissions are adequately supervised and able to handle the tasks assigned to them.

Appeals from District Judge and Magistrate to the General Division under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Rules of Court 2021

Where an appeal is filed under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Rules of Court 2021, each party is to tender 1 hard copy each of his or her written submissions and bundle of authorities (if any) to the Registry not less than 5 working days before the hearing of the appeal.

The written submissions filed under Order 18, Rule 21(5) of the Rules of Court 2021 should not exceed 35 pages (including the cover page and table of contents). The written submissions must include a cover page and a table of contents. Parties are to note that where the Court allows the prescribed page limit to be exceeded, fees are payable under the Fourth Schedule to the Rules of Court 2021.

The party must, in lieu of the bundle of authorities, file a list of authorities (that corresponds to the table of contents of the hard copy of the bundle of authorities) into the case file using the Electronic Filing Service within the timelines prescribed in Order 18, Rule 21(5) of the Rules of Court 2021. The bundle of authorities (whether in hard copy of soft copy) must comply with the requirements under paragraph 101(5) to (11) of these Practice Directions. In particular, where the bundle of authorities consists of more than 1 volume:

the table of contents of all volumes of the bundle of authorities must be placed at the beginning of Volume I; and (b) each volume must have a table of contents indicating the authorities that are contained in that volume.

Appeals from District Court and Magistrate’s Court to the General Division under Order 19, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court 2021

Where an appeal is filed under Order 19, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court 2021, the appellant must tender 1 hard copy each of the following documents to the Registry not less than 5 working days before the hearing of the appeal:

the record of appeal, the appellant’s Case, the appellant’s core bundle of documents and the appellant’s bundle of authorities; and (b) if applicable, the appellant’s Reply (if any), the second core bundle (if necessary) and the appellant’s second bundle of authorities (if any).

Where an appeal is filed under Order 19, Rule 14 of the Rules of Court 2021, the respondent must tender 1 hard copy each of the respondent’s Case, the respondent’s core bundle of documents (if necessary) and the respondent’s bundle of authorities to the Registry not less than 5 working days before the hearing of the appeal.

The table below sets out the prescribed page limits under Order 19, Rule 19 of the Rules of Court 2021 of the following documents:

S/NDocumentPrescribed page limit(a)Appellant’s Case35 pages(b)Appellant’s core bundle of documents (excluding the written judgment or grounds of decision of the lower Court and the extracted order of the lower Court)55 pages(c)Respondent’s Case35 pages(d)Respondent’s core bundle of documents35 pages(e)Appellant’s Reply20 pages(f)Appellant’s second core bundle25 pages

The page limits set out in the table at sub-paragraph (6) include the cover page and table of contents. The appellant’s Case, the respondent’s Case and the appellant’s Reply must each include a cover page and a table of contents. Parties are to note that where the Court allows the prescribed page limit referred to at sub-paragraph (6) to be exceeded, fees are payable under the Fourth Schedule to the Rules of Court 2021.

The contents of the appellant’s core bundle of documents must be arranged in the following separate volumes:

Volume A – A table of contents listing the documents included in Volumes A and B, the certified copy of the written judgment or grounds of decision of the lower Court, and the extracted order of the lower Court. (b) Volume B – All other documents referred to in Order 19, Rule 3 of the Rules of Court 2021 and a table of contents listing the documents included therein.

Each volume of the appellant’s and respondent’s core bundles of documents and the second core bundle must start at page 1. All pages (including, where applicable, the cover page, table of contents, separator sheets and exhibit sheets) must be paginated such that the printed page numbers correspond to the page numbers in the soft copy Portable Document Format (PDF) version of the document that is filed through the Electronic Filing Service, the page number must be inserted at the top right hand corner of the page, and, where there are multiple volumes, each separate volume must start at page 1, and every page in that volume must be numbered consecutively.

The party must, in lieu of the bundle of authorities, file a list of authorities (that corresponds to the table of contents of the hard copy of the bundle of authorities) into the case file using the Electronic Filing Service within the relevant prescribed timelines under Order 19, Rule 17 of the Rules of Court 2021. The bundle of authorities (whether in hard copy of soft copy) must comply with the requirements under paragraph 101(5) to (11) of these Practice Directions. In particular, where the bundle of authorities consists of more than 1 volume:

the table of contents of all volumes of the bundle of authorities must be placed at the beginning of Volume I; and (b) each volume must have a table of contents indicating the authorities that are contained in that volume.

Appeals from the Employment Claims Tribunal

In addition to any provisions in the Rules of Court 2021 or other written law, and subject to any further directions made by the Court, the Registrar hereby directs that appeals to the General Division from the Employment Claims Tribunal are to be heard in open court.

Where an appeal is filed under Order 18, Rule 24 of the Rules of Court 2021, each party is to tender 1 hard copy each of his or her written submissions and bundle of authorities (if any) to the Registry within the timelines prescribed in Order 18, Rule 25(5) of the Rules of Court 2021.

The written submissions filed under Order 18, Rule 25(5) of the Rules of Court 2021 should not exceed 35 pages (including the cover page and table of contents). The written submissions must include a cover page and a table of contents. Parties are to note that where the Court allows the prescribed page limit to be exceeded, fees are payable under the Fourth Schedule to the Rules of Court 2021.

The party must, in lieu of the bundle of authorities, file a list of authorities (that corresponds to the table of contents of the hard copy of the bundle of authorities) into the case file using the Electronic Filing Service within the timelines prescribed in Order 18, Rule 25(5) of the Rules of Court 2021. The bundle of authorities (whether in hard copy or soft copy) must comply with the requirements under paragraph 101(5) to (11) of these Practice Directions. In particular, where the bundle of authorities consists of more than 1 volume:

the table of contents of all volumes of the bundle of authorities must be placed at the beginning of Volume I; and (b) each volume must have a table of contents indicating the authorities that are contained in that volume.

Order 20, Rule 3(4) of the Rules of Court 2021 states that the supporting affidavit must include the record of proceedings if that is available and is necessary for the appeal or the application. If the record of proceedings is necessary for the appeal or the application, and is not available at the time when the supporting affidavit is filed but subsequently becomes available, the appellant or applicant should seek permission from the Court to file a further affidavit to include the record of proceedings when it becomes available. To facilitate this, the appellant or applicant should promptly apply for any written grounds of decision, the record of evidence or notes of arguments taken in respect of the proceedings before the tribunal.

Unless otherwise ordered by the Court, each party is to tender 1 hard copy each of his or her affidavits, written submissions and bundles of authorities (if any) to the Registry within the timeline prescribed in Order 20, Rule 5(1) of the Rules of Court 2021.

The written submissions filed under Order 20, Rule 5(1) of the Rules of Court 2021 should not exceed 35 pages (including the cover page and table of contents). The written submissions must include a cover page and a table of contents. Parties are to note that where the Court allows the prescribed page limit to be exceeded, fees are payable under the Fourth Schedule to the Rules of Court 2021.

The party using the hard copy of the bundle of authorities for the hearing must, if directed by the Court, file the list of authorities (that corresponds to the table of contents of the hard copy of the bundle of authorities) into the case file using the Electronic Filing Service within the timeline prescribed in Order 20, Rule 5(1) of the Rules of Court 2021. The bundle of authorities (whether in hard copy or soft copy) must comply with the requirements under paragraph 101(5) to (11) of these Practice Directions. In particular, where the bundle of authorities consists of more than 1 volume:

the table of contents of all volumes of the bundle of authorities must be placed at the beginning of Volume I; and (b) each volume must have a table of contents indicating the authorities that are contained in that volume.