Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 24 Feb 2022

General Division of the High Court

R Manokaran and others v Chua h Ah Leng and others and another suit

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHC 39Case no. Suit No 1044 of 2018

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The plaintiffs in both actions (“the Plaintiffs”) were holiday makers who were travelling from Genting Highlands back to Singapore on 31 August 2016. They were on board a double decker luxury coach (“the Bus”). En route to Singapore, the Bus was involved in a road accident. The Plaintiffs sustained injuries. They now claim damages.

  2. Facts

  3. [2] The Plaintiffs in both actions are as follows. In Suit 1044 of 2018 (“Suit 1044”), R Manokaran (“Manokaran”) and Muniandy Barvathi (“Barvathi”) are spouses. M Priyatharsini (“Priyatharsini”) and Navindran s/o Manokaran (“Navindran”) are their children. In Suit 1307 of 2018 (“Suit 1307”), Wee Chye Hee (“Wee”) and Xie Lianzhu @ Ye Lianzhu (“Xie”) are spouses.

  4. [3] The first defendant (“Chuah”) was the driver of the Bus at the material time. The second defendant (“Zenwan”) was the registered owner of the Bus.

  5. [4] Grassland Express & Tours Pte Ltd (“GET”) and Grassland Express Pte Ltd (“GE”) are companies incorporated in Singapore. GET and GE are the third defendants in Suit 1044 and Suit 1307 respectively. For convenience, I shall refer to them collectively as “Grassland” (in the singular) unless it is appropriate to identify each entity separately. The Plaintiffs booked two-way bus trips from Singapore to Genting Highlands. Manokaran booked the trip for his family from GET’s outlet at Boon Lay Shopping Centre (“the Boon Lay Office”), Singapore, on 20 August 2016. Wee did the same for himself and Xie at GE’s outlet at Golden Mile Complex (“the Golden Mile Office”), Singapore, on 25 August 2016.

  6. [5] The journey from Singapore to Genting Highlands on 28 August 2016 was uneventful. On 31 August 2016, the Plaintiffs boarded the Bus to return to Singapore. The Bus departed the Mushroom Farm Bus Terminal, Genting Highlands, at about 3pm that day. The Plaintiffs were seated on the upper deck of the Bus.

  7. [6] At around 4.40pm, Chuah was driving the Bus along the left-most lane of Karak Highway towards Singapore. The Bus then swerved from the left-most lane of Karak Highway towards the road divider on the right. It collided with the road divider, spun and overturned onto its left side (“the Accident”). The Plaintiffs were injured in the Accident. The Plaintiffs plead that the Accident was sudden and occurred “without any warning and/or signal”. They also plead that they believed that the Bus belonged to Grassland and that they knew nothing about Zenwan or its relationship to the Bus or Chuah.

  8. [7] As the trials for both actions are bifurcated, I need not say more on the nature of their injuries.

  9. The Plaintiffs’ claims

  10. [8] I now outline the Plaintiffs’ claims against each defendant.

  11. Chuah – negligence

  12. [9] The Plaintiffs claim that Chuah’s negligence in the “driving, management and/or control” of the Bus “caused and/or contributed to” the Accident. Pleaded particulars of negligence include that Chuah failed to: (a) keep a proper lookout; (b) see and/or give way to any and all other vehicles; and (c) take evasive measures to avoid the Accident.

  13. [11] The following efforts were undertaken to notify Chuah of the trial. The Setting Down Notices and Setting Down Bundles for the trial against Chuah were served on him at his last known address in Malaysia. His last known address was obtained from his counsel’s Notice of Ceasing to Act as Solicitor filed on 18 May 2021. The Plaintiffs also instructed solicitors in Malaysia to take out an advertisement in Malaysia in the English, Malay and Chinese newspapers informing Chuah about the setting down of the action. The Registry also sent to Chuah the Registrar’s Notices dated 20 April 2021, 23 April 2021 and 17 June 2021 pertaining to the trial dates. In addition, the Plaintiffs instructed solicitors in Malaysia to send these Registrar’s Notices to Chuah informing him of the trial dates.

  14. [12] Despite these efforts, Chuah did not attend the trial on 3 August 2021. He also failed to communicate his position to the court or to the Plaintiffs. The Plaintiffs applied to admit all of the Affidavits of Evidence-in-Chief (“AEICs”) filed by the Plaintiffs and their witnesses against Chuah, and for a judgment to be issued on the merits against him. The Plaintiffs relied on O 35 r 1(2) of the Rules of Court (2014 Rev Ed), which provides that:

  15. [14] The Plaintiffs submitted that Chuah was fully aware of both actions, actively participated in earlier proceedings (eg, by applying to set aside the default judgments against him), but ignored all communications relating to the trial. Yet, they submit that he has taken “no steps to contact the Registry, to appoint solicitors or to contact [the Plaintiffs]”.

  16. [16] I was satisfied that the totality of the evidence admitted in each suit established that Chuah had negligently driven the Bus at the time of the Accident. The issue was whether Chuah breached the standard of care expected of a bus driver for holiday makers. Wee and Navindran’s AEICs stated that the weather was sunny and the road was dry. Wee, who was awake at the material time, also stated that there were “no motor vehicles in front of the Bus”. Yet, the Bus swerved from the left-most lane of Karak Highway into the road divider on the right. It also spun and overturned onto its left side. Wee and Navindran further recounted that the swerve was sudden and came without warning. Given the absence of evidence of hazardous road conditions that day which could have contributed to the Accident, and seeing that the Bus had collided into the centre divider with enough force to overturn, I found that Chuah failed to exercise due care when driving, managing and/or controlling the Bus. He is liable to the Plaintiffs for the tort of negligence.

  17. Zenwan – vicarious liability for Chuah’s negligence

  18. [17] The Plaintiffs plead that Zenwan is vicariously liable for Chuah’s negligence in respect of the Accident. They claim that Chuah was driving the Bus as Zenwan’s “employee, servant and/or agent, and/or … authorized driver”. Although they further pleaded, in the alternative, that Zenwan owed a non-delegable duty of care to the Plaintiffs, this was not pursued in submissions.

  19. [18] Zenwan contests its liability on two key grounds. First, it argues that there is no evidence that Chuah’s tortious act was committed within the scope of his employment since Chuah did not give evidence. Second, it argues that the Plaintiffs’ contributory negligence renders vicarious liability inappropriate as the policy of victim compensation is inapplicable. It submits that the Plaintiffs contributed to their injuries by not wearing seatbelts at the time of the Accident. It also relies on the fact that Wee had stood up at the time of the Accident, thereby placing himself in harm’s way.

  20. [19] The Plaintiffs, in response, argue that Zenwan is precluded from raising contributory negligence as: (a) it was not put in issue by Chuah; and (b) issue estoppel arising from the judgment against Chuah prevents Zenwan from re-litigating the question of contributory negligence. The Plaintiffs further submit that there is no evidence that the Bus was fitted with seatbelts and that it was a reasonable reaction for Wee to stand up to take stock of the impending danger.

  21. Grassland – breach of contract

  22. [20] The Plaintiffs sue Grassland for breaching the contracts entered into by Wee and Manokaran on behalf of their respective families (“the Contracts”). They submit that the Contracts were executed when Wee and Manokaran attended Grassland’s offices to sign a booking form each (“the Booking Form”). They allege that the Contracts were breached by the negligent driving of the Bus.

  23. [21] Grassland’s defence is that it was merely selling tickets on behalf of Zenwan as the latter’s “Authorized Sole Agent”. In the alternative, it submits that it was merely a booking agent for the Plaintiffs and arranged for bus services to be provided by a third-party service supplier. Accordingly, Grassland denies that it owed a duty to the Plaintiffs to take reasonable care to transport the Plaintiffs from Genting to Singapore.

  24. [22] In response, the Plaintiffs dispute the allegation that Grassland was merely an agent for Zenwan or the Plaintiffs. They argue that Grassland: (a) undertook to, itself, provide transport to the Plaintiffs; or (b) was an agent for an undisclosed principal, Zenwan. On either ground, the Plaintiffs claim to be entitled to proceed against Grassland for Chuah’s negligent driving. They further argue that clauses in the “Terms & Conditions” on the reverse side of the Booking Form (“Booking Form Terms and Conditions”) which have the effect of excluding Grassland’s liability for Chuah’s negligence are (a) not incorporated into the Contracts; and/or (b) unenforceable under the Unfair Contract Terms Act (Cap 396, 1994 Rev Ed) (“the UCTA”).

  25. Issues to be determined

  26. [23] In light of the foregoing, the following issues arise in relation to Zenwan’s liability:

  27. (a) Is Zenwan vicariously liable for Chuah’s negligence in driving the Bus at the time of the Accident?

  28. (b) Were any or all of the Plaintiffs contributorily negligent?

  29. [24] In relation to Grassland’s liability, the issues for my determination are:

  30. (a) What is the nature and scope of Grassland’s contractual undertaking under the Contracts? In particular:

  31. (i) Was Grassland an agent for Zenwan?

  32. (ii) Did Grassland undertake to provide the bus transportation service itself, or merely to act as an intermediary between the Plaintiffs and a third-party bus transport supplier?

  33. (b) Did Grassland breach the Contracts?

  34. (c) Were the plaintiffs other than Wee and Manokaran privy to the respective Contracts?

  35. Zenwan’s liability

  36. Whether Zenwan is vicariously liable

  37. [25] Vicarious liability is a form of secondary liability. Under this doctrine, the law holds a defendant liable for the negligence of another even if the defendant had not been negligent at all: Ng Huat Seng and another v Munib Mohammad Madni and another [2017] 2 SLR 1074 (“Ng Huat Seng”) at [41]. There is a two-stage inquiry to determine whether vicarious liability should be imposed, both of which must be fulfilled.

  38. [26] First, the relationship between the primary tortfeasor and defendant must be sufficiently close so as to make it fair, just and reasonable to impose vicarious liability on the defendant for the primary tortfeasor’s acts (Ng Huat Seng at [42]) (“the First Inquiry”). The classical situation in which vicarious liability is recognised is the employer-employee relationship. However, the law does not confine vicarious liability to employment relationships: Clerk & Lindsell on Torts (Michael A Jones gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 23rd Ed, 2020) (“Clerk & Lindsell 23rd Ed”) at para 6-01. Vicarious liability may be imposed in relationships which are closely analogous to employment relationships, and in which context it is fair, just and reasonable to impose liability on the defendant for the tortious acts of the primary tortfeasor (Ng Huat Seng at [62]).

  39. [28] The First Inquiry is satisfied by virtue of an admission in Zenwan’s pleadings. The Plaintiffs pleaded that Chuah was Zenwan’s “employee, servant and/or agent, and/or … authorized driver” at the time of the Accident. Zenwan admitted to this fact in its Defence. Further, in his AEIC, Abdul Ghani Bin Ariffin (“Abdul Ghani”), the director and a shareholder of Zenwan, states that Chuah was “initially employed” [emphasis added] by Zenwan in 2004. He further confirms that the Bus was driven by Chuah at the time of the Accident as “the servant and/or agent” of Zenwan and that Chuah was employed by Zenwan at that time.

  40. [29] However, Zenwan argues that the Second Inquiry is not fulfilled. Its case is that there is no evidence as to whether Chuah’s conduct was an unauthorised mode of doing an act authorised by the employer, as opposed to an act outside the scope of Chuah’s employment. Zenwan argues that it would be vicariously liable for Chuah’s conduct only if the former is proven, but that Chuah’s failure to give evidence is fatal to the Plaintiffs’ ability to discharge their burden of proof.

  41. [30] The Plaintiffs argue that Zenwan is vicariously liable as Chuah negligently managed the Bus and caused the Accident during the course of his work as Zenwan’s employee.

  42. [31] I am unable to agree with Zenwan’s submissions. It follows from my judgment against Chuah that his negligent driving had caused the Accident. In my view, such negligent driving was so closely connected to his employment with Zenwan that it is fair and just for the latter to be vicariously liable. This is because on 31 August 2016, Chuah was negligent when performing the task he was employed to do – transporting passengers safely from one destination to another. For context, I surmise that Zenwan owned buses and employed bus drivers to service various routes, including routes between Singapore and Malaysia. Chuah was employed in 2004 as one such driver and has since accumulated “many years of driving experience”.

  43. [32] In addition, Zenwan created, by virtue of its employer-employee relationship with Chuah, the very risk that materialised. By employing Chuah to drive its buses on designated routes, including from Genting Highlands to Singapore, Zenwan created the risk of Chuah’s negligent driving causing a road accident, thereby injuring passengers on board its bus. Zenwan also failed to persuade me that all precautionary measures within its power had been taken (see [40] below). Accordingly, there is nothing to displace the inference that the Bus passengers were vulnerable to Chuah’s negligence.

  44. [33] In these circumstances, I find that the Second Inquiry is satisfied. I need not go further to examine Zenwan’s submission that Chuah’s conduct was an unauthorised mode of doing an act authorised by Zenwan, rather than an act outside the scope of his employment. The need to prove the former no longer forms part of the test for vicarious liability in Singapore: Skandinaviska Enskilda Banken AB (Publ), Singapore Branch v Asia Pacific Breweries (Singapore) Pte Ltd and another and another appeal [2011] 3 SLR 540 (“Skandinaviska”) at [66]–[68], [71] and [75].

  45. [34] Zenwan further argues that vicarious liability should not be imposed because the policy considerations of victim compensation and deterring employers from causing future harm do not apply. I deal with each policy consideration in turn.

  46. [36] Zenwan submits that the Plaintiffs were contributorily negligent (for reasons described at [18] above) and are therefore precluded from claiming it is vicariously liable. However, as I later explain, I am not satisfied that the Plaintiffs were contributorily negligent (see [63] and [79] below). This objection, therefore, does not negate the interest in victim compensation in this case.

  47. [37] I turn next to the policy of deterrence of future harm. This was described by McLachlin J in the Canadian Supreme Court’s decision of The Children’s Foundation, the Superintendent of Family and Child Services in the Province of British Columbia and Her Majesty The Queen in Right of the Province of British Columbia as represented by the Ministry of Social Services and Housing v Patrick Allan Bazley [1999] 2 SCR 534 at [33] (affirmed in Skandinaviska at [79]) as follows:

  48. [38] The Court of Appeal in Skandinaviska explained that this policy rests on the fundamental premise that the employer is best placed, relative to everybody else, to manage the risks of his business enterprise and prevent wrongdoing from occurring. In many cases, this premise may hold true. However, in some cases, the person better placed to prevent the tort may well be the victim himself or a third party (at [80]):

  49. [40] I do not accept Zenwan’s submissions. I am satisfied that Zenwan, being the owner of the Bus and Chuah’s employer, was in the best position to reduce the risk of negligent driving causing road accidents and injury to passengers. Although Zenwan insists that it has taken all precautionary measures within its power, this contention is unsupported by the evidence. For one, as I later explain at [63] below, there is insufficient evidence to prove that the Bus was fitted with seatbelts for its passengers. In addition, besides the fact that Chuah was employed in 2004 and is alleged to have had “years of experience ferrying passengers to and from various parts of Malaysia”, there is no evidence of the nature of the training which Zenwan had provided to Chuah, or which Chuah had received before joining Zenwan. Finally, Zenwan has not furnished evidence pertaining to how much rest Chuah was afforded before embarking on the fateful journey back to Singapore, the schedule of Zenwan’s buses and how often Chuah was rostered to drive for Zenwan. For these reasons, the policy of deterrence of future harm applies with full force. Bus owners and employers in Zenwan’s position should be incentivised to effectively manage the risks posed to their customers or passengers in the course of their business activities.

  50. [41] In all these circumstances, it is just, fair and reasonable to impose vicarious liability on Zenwan for Chuah’s negligence.

  51. Whether the Plaintiffs were contributorily negligent

  52. [42] As set out at [19] above, the Plaintiffs raise several objections to the contention that they were contributorily negligent. Two of which are that: (a) the defendant who is vicariously liable cannot raise contributory negligence if the primary tortfeasor has not (“the Primary Tortfeasor Argument”); and (b) Zenwan is prevented from re-litigating the issue due to issue estoppel arising from the judgment against Chuah (“the Issue Estoppel Argument”).

  53. [43] I will assume, without deciding, that the Primary Tortfeasor Argument and Issue Estoppel Argument are resolved in Zenwan’s favour (ie, Zenwan is not barred from raising the issue of contributory negligence). Even if this is correct, in my judgment, Zenwan is unable to prove the elements of contributory negligence. I begin by outlining some basic principles.

  54. [44] Contributory negligence is a partial defence which is statutorily enacted in the Contributory Negligence and Personal Injuries Act 1953 (2020 Rev Ed) (“Contributory Negligence Act”). Section 3(1) of the Contributory Negligence Act reads:

  55. In essence, the claimant must have failed to take due care for his own safety and thus caused loss to himself: Asnah bte Ab Rahman v Li Jianlin [2016] 2 SLR 944 (“Asnah”) at [18]).

  56. [45] The defendant bears the burden of establishing the defence of contributory negligence: Munshi Mohammad Faiz v Interpro Construction Pte Ltd and others and another appeal [2021] 4 SLR 1371 at [37]; Asnah at [113] and [178]. To establish contributory negligence, the defendant must prove that the plaintiff owes himself a duty to take care of his own safety in the prevailing circumstances of the case and that the plaintiff breached the requisite standard of care (Asnah at [19]–[20]). As a general rule, the standard of care expected of the plaintiff is measured against a person of ordinary prudence, corresponding in most cases to the standard of care in negligence (Asnah at [20]).

  57. [46] If the plaintiff is found to have been contributorily negligent, the court proceeds to determine the appropriate reduction in the plaintiff’s damages for his contributory negligence. To re-iterate, s 3(1) of the Contributory Negligence Act requires the damages to “be reduced to such extent as the court thinks just and equitable having regard to the claimant’s share in the responsibility for the damage.” Amongst the many considerations that may fall to guide the exercise of the court’s discretion, the Court of Appeal in Asnah at [118] highlighted two in particular: (a) the relative causative potency of the parties’ conduct; and (b) the relative moral blameworthiness of the parties’ conduct.

  58. Whether the Plaintiffs failed to wear seatbelts

  59. [47] Zenwan submits that all of the Plaintiffs were contributorily negligent for failing to wear their seatbelts at the time of the Accident. It argues that the Bus had seatbelts and that Zenwan had made this a term of their booking. In particular, it blames Manokaran’s family in Suit 1044 for not noticing this term in the Booking Form given that Priyatharsini’s job as a Patient Assistant Specialist required her to explain the terms and conditions of consent forms for medical procedures to patients.

  60. [48] The Plaintiffs instead point to the lack of evidence that the Bus was fitted with seatbelts. They argue that the newspaper report stating that the Manokarans had not been wearing their seatbelts is inadmissible hearsay. They further argue that if the Bus had seatbelts, Zenwan could easily have led evidence from Abdul Ghani or Tan Chor Theng (“Tan”) on this point. Tan is the managing director of Tact Coach & Seat Mfg Sdn Bhd (“Tact”), which repaired the Bus after the Accident. They highlight that no such evidence was led by Zenwan. The Plaintiffs also rely on their evidence that to their best recollection, the Bus did not have seatbelts, or that even if they are unable to recall if there were seatbelts or not, they would have worn the seatbelts if they had been provided.

  61. [49] I agree with the Plaintiffs. There is insufficient evidence showing that the Bus was fitted with seatbelts at the time of the Accident. As such, Zenwan has failed to establish that the Plaintiffs breached the standard of care expected of passengers on a tour bus. My reasons are as follows.

  62. [50] First, the Straits Times newspaper article dated 4 September 2016 (“the ST Article”) exhibited in Abdul Ghani’s Affidavit of Evidence-in-Chief dated 28 October 2020 (“Abdul Ghani’s 28 Oct AEIC”) is inadmissible hearsay. In their Notice of Objections to the AEICs filed on behalf of Zenwan, the Plaintiffs objected to admitting the ST Article on this ground. The article is about Manokaran and his family’s involvement in the Accident. Presumably, Zenwan relies on the portion of the article which reads: “The family, who had not been wearing seatbelts, had been sitting at the upper deck and Mr Manokaran ended up in the stairwell after the crash.” [emphasis added].

  63. [51] Insofar as Zenwan relies on the foregoing statement in the ST Article to prove that the Bus had been fitted with seatbelts, the article is hearsay evidence. Since Zenwan has neither argued nor proved that any of the provisions in s 32(1) of the Evidence Act (Cap 97, 1997 Rev Ed) (“the Evidence Act”) apply, the ST Article is inadmissible.

  64. [52] I am fortified in my decision by Aedit Abdullah J’s conclusion in Ajit Chandrasekar Prabhu and another v Yan Beng Kooi and another [2015] SGHC 280 (“Ajit”) that newspaper articles are inadmissible under s 32(1)(b) of the Evidence Act. That provision reads as follows:

  65. [53] In gist, Abdullah J was of the view that articles in newspapers may not be prepared with the same care and accuracy as business records which are admissible under s 32(1)(b) (Ajit at [51]). For the same reasons, I view the accuracy of the ST Article with circumspection.

  66. [54] Even if the ST Article was admitted, I would exercise my discretion under s 32(5) of the Evidence Act to accord it little weight. The ST Article simply asserts that the plaintiffs in Suit 1044 “had not been wearing seatbelts”. However, the Plaintiffs’ evidence is more equivocal. All of the Plaintiffs state in their AEICs that they are unable to recall if they had worn a seatbelt on the Bus. In any case, the ST Article does not clarify whether the Bus was fitted with seatbelts which the Plaintiffs negligently failed to use. Therefore, even taking the ST Article at face value, I find little support for Zenwan’s case that the Bus had been fitted with seatbelts.

  67. [55] Second, I agree with the Plaintiffs that Zenwan failed to adduce any other evidence that the Bus had been fitted with seatbelts. As Zenwan was the registered owner of the Bus, it would have had knowledge of this information. Alternatively, it could have led evidence from Tan on this issue. As the Plaintiffs observe, Tan would have been privy to whether the Bus had been fitted with seatbelts. This is because after the Bus was inspected by the police, the company that Tan managed, Tact, towed the Bus back to its workshop to conduct repairs. Tact has also been servicing Zenwan’s buses for “many years”.

  68. [56] Abdul Ghani’s AEICs dated 24 September 2019, filed in both actions for the trial on Grassland’s liability (“Abdul Ghani’s 24 Sep AEIC”), state that “[a]ll Zenwan buses were equipped with seatbelts on all seats and passengers would be reminded to wear such seatbelts for safety”. However, (a) this piece of evidence is not found in Abdul Ghani’s later AEICs sworn for the purpose of determining Zenwan’s liability; and (b) even if this evidence is admissible against Zenwan, it is merely a general comment that does not prove that the Bus was fitted with seatbelts.

  69. [57] Since proving that the Bus had been fitted with seatbelts forms part of Zenwan’s defence, and the truth of this fact is within its own knowledge or that of its witnesses, I draw an adverse inference against it for failing to lead credible evidence on this point. I do so under Illustration (g) to s 116 of the Evidence Act, which provides that:

  70. [58] Finally, portions of the Plaintiffs’ evidence contradict there having been seatbelts on the Bus at the time of the Accident.

  71. [59] In Suit 1307, Wee and Xie’s evidence suggests that there were no seatbelts on the Bus. In Wee and Xie’s AEICs, they both state that “[t]o the best of [their] recollection, [they] do not think the Bus had been fitted with seatbelts”. Both maintained this position under cross-examination. Xie added that if she had seen a seat belt, she would “definitely fasten” it. The relevant portions of Wee and Xie’s testimony read as follows:

  72. [60] I accept that Wee and Xie do not have perfect recollections of the day of the Accident. Wee admits in his AEIC that he “cannot remember if [he] was wearing a seatbelt during the journey from Genting to Singapore” as it was about three years ago at that time. Xie also testified that she “didn’t pay much attention whether there were seat belts on the coach or not” (see excerpt at [59] above).

  73. [61] Although Wee and Xie’s evidence is not entirely reliable, it casts doubt on Zenwan’s contention that the Bus was fitted with seatbelts. In any case, the Plaintiffs do not bear the burden of proving that the Bus was not fitted with seatbelts.

  74. [62] In Suit 1044, the evidence of Manokaran’s family is neutral because all four family members are unable to recall if the Bus was fitted with seatbelts or if they had worn seatbelts or not. However, each testified that they would have worn the seatbelt if it had been provided. Additionally, Wee’s oral evidence in Suit 1307 was received in Suit 1044 by virtue of HC/ORC 7071/2020 without him taking the stand in the latter suit, and he swore an affidavit of evidence-in-chief dated 23 October 2020 in Suit 1044. These steps were taken because Wee was the only one who claims to have observed that there were no other motor vehicles in front of the Bus before the Accident. Hence, my views on Wee’s evidence at [59]–[61] above apply equally in Suit 1044.

  75. [63] Considering the evidence in totality, I am not satisfied that Zenwan has proved on a balance of probabilities that the Bus had been fitted with seatbelts which the Plaintiffs failed to use in breach of the standard of care expected of them. This is especially given the adverse inference weighing against Zenwan (see [57] above). The Plaintiffs are therefore not contributorily negligent in respect of the non-use of seatbelts.

  76. Whether Wee had caused or contributed to his injuries by standing up

  77. [64] Zenwan submits that Wee was contributorily negligent by standing up before the Bus collided with the centre divider on Karak Highway and thereby placed himself in harm’s way. It stresses that there was “no need to stand since [Wee] was seated at the very front with a clear view of the highway”.

  78. [65] Wee admits, in his submissions, to having stood up “when he noticed that the bus was swerving just prior to the accident”. However, he submits that he “cannot be faulted for standing as that was a reasonable reaction on the part of anyone who was seated without a seatbelt, i.e. to stand up to take stock of the impending danger.”

  79. [66] The relevant issue is one of causation. If Wee’s act of standing up did not cause or contribute to the injuries of which he now complains, he cannot have been contributorily negligent.

  80. [67] Proving causation is a necessary element to establishing the defence of contributory negligence. It is statutorily provided for in s 3(1) of the Contributory Negligence Act, which requires the damage suffered by the plaintiff to “result” partly from his own fault. In my view, the presence of causation should be determined before the court apportions liability by weighing factors such as the relative causative potency of the parties’ conduct. I regard the factor of relative causative potency as going to the comparative strengths of the causal links from each party’s conduct to the injury sustained by the plaintiff. This factor therefore presupposes the existence of a causal link between the plaintiff’s conduct and his injury.

  81. [68] The Court of Appeal in Fong Maun Yee and another v Yoong Weng Ho Robert [1997] 1 SLR(R) 751 (“Fong Maun Yee”) at [59] endorsed the proposition, in Clerk & Lindsell on Torts (Margaret R Brazier gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 17th Ed, 1995) at para 3-13, that the principles governing whether the plaintiff’s own fault contributed to his injuries should be the same as those governing whether the defendant caused those injuries. Further, broad common sense should be used to judge cause and effect on the facts of each particular case. These same principles are re-iterated in Clerk & Lindsell 23rd Ed at para 3-62.

  82. [69] To establish the tort of negligence, both factual and legal causation must be proved.

  83. [70] The Court of Appeal’s classic statement of the requirement of factual causation in Sunny Metal & Engineering Pte Ltd v Ng Khim Ming Eric [2007] 3 SLR(R) 782 (“Sunny Metal”) reads as follows (at [52]):

  84. [71] However, even if factual causation is proved, the plaintiff must go further to show that the defendant’s wrongful conduct constituted the “legal cause” of the damage. Where it can be established that a novus actus interveniens has broken the chain of causation, the defendant will be freed from liability. The requirement of legal causation assists the court to determine “how best to attribute responsibility for the claimant’s damage” [emphasis in original] based on convenience, public policy and a rough sense of justice: Sunny Metal at [54]–[55].

  85. [72] It follows from Fong Maun Yee and Clerk & Lindsell 23rd Ed that these principles also govern the determination of causation in contributory negligence. The following remarks add further clarity to the inquiry of causation in the context of contributory negligence (Clerk & Lindsell 23rd Ed at para 3-59):

  86. (a) The defence of contributory negligence is available when the plaintiff’s own negligence contributes to the damage of which he complains. It is not limited to cases where the plaintiff’s fault contributes to the occurrence inflicting that damage.

  87. (b) Contributory negligence remains relevant if the plaintiff contributes to the extent or nature of his ensuing injury.

  88. [73] I now return to the relevant facts of this case.

  89. [74] In his AEIC, testimony under cross-examination and closing submissions, Wee’s position is that he stood up when he noticed the Bus starting to swerve to the right.

  90. [75] However, and crucially, it remains unclear to me whether Wee had sat back down before the Bus collided with the centre divider and overturned. Wee’s AEIC sworn on 23 October 2020 in Suit 1307 (“Wee’s Oct 2020 AEIC (1307)”) states that after standing up, he “did not see any other motor vehicles in front of the Bus” and “immediately sat back down” [emphasis added]. After sitting back down, Wee continued to feel the Bus “swerve” towards the centre divider on Karak Highway. On this account in his AEIC, Wee had returned to a sitting position before the Bus collided with the centre divider. In contrast, Wee’s police report filed on 2 September 2016 with the police in Malaysia (“Wee’s Malaysian Police Report”) states that when Wee was standing, suddenly, the Bus “SWIFTED [sic] TO THE RIGHT AND HIT THE CENTER DIVIDER AND TOPPLE DOWN.” Wee’s Malaysian Police Report suggests that Wee was still standing when the Accident occurred.

  91. [76] In the version of events in Wee’s Oct 2020 AEIC (1307), Wee was sitting down by the time the Accident occurred. If this is true, even if Wee had stood up at some point, Wee would still have suffered the same type and severity of injuries. Any additional danger or risk he placed himself in by standing could have extinguished by the time the Bus collided with the centre divider.

  92. [77] Conversely, in the version of events in Wee’s Malaysian Police Report, Wee’s act of standing up would have a causal link to the extent or nature of his injuries. But for Wee’s act of standing up after the Bus had begun to swerve and remaining standing as the Bus overturned, Wee would have suffered less severe injuries.

  93. [78] I have reservations about the credibility of the Malaysian Police Report. Wee testified that his Malaysian Police Report was not accurate and challenged the completeness of, at least, one part of the report. With regards the latter challenge, Wee claimed to have told the Malaysian police officers that he “stood up and take a look”, but the report only recorded that he had stood up. It is also significant that the Malaysian Police recorded Wee’s statement on 2 September 2016 in Kuala Lumpur Hospital some two days after the Accident. It is unclear to me if Wee was in the right frame of mind to carefully recount the details of the Accident at that time. As Wee testified, his “mind [was] not in a stable condition” then.

  94. [79] In view of these doubts about the completeness of Wee’s Malaysian Police Report and the contradictory account in Wee’s Oct 2020 AEIC (1307), I am not prepared to find that Wee’s act of standing up was a factual cause of his injuries. The question of legal causation is therefore moot. Accordingly, Zenwan has failed to prove that Wee was contributorily negligent for standing up as the Bus was swerving.

  95. Conclusion

  96. [80] Based on the foregoing, both inquiries in the test for vicarious liability are met and Zenwan has failed to prove that any of the Plaintiffs was contributorily negligent. As such, Zenwan is vicariously liable for Chuah’s negligent driving.

  97. Grassland’s liability

  98. [81] While the Plaintiffs’ claim against Zenwan lies in tort, their claim against Grassland is for breach of contract. The trial on Grassland’s liability was completed in an earlier tranche which closed on 25 November 2020.

  99. [82] The outcome of the first issue at [24(a)] will determine whether Grassland is party to the Contracts with the Plaintiffs and whether it is contractually liable thereunder for Chuah’s negligent driving of the Bus. There are several possible outcomes:

  100. (a) If Grassland is an agent for Zenwan, and Zenwan is a disclosed principal, the Contracts are contracts of carriage to which only the Plaintiffs and Zenwan are parties. In this first situation, the agent drops out from the contract: The Law of Contract in Singapore (Andrew Phang Boon Leong gen ed) (Academy Publishing 2012) (“The Law of Contract in Singapore”) at para 15.047. In this first situation, there would be no cause of action in contract against Grassland.

  101. (b) However, if Grassland is Zenwan’s agent, but Zenwan is an undisclosed principal, contractual liability for Chuah’s negligence may be enforced against Grassland. This is because an agent for an undisclosed principal “remains liable and entitled under the contract” [emphasis in original] if entered into on behalf of the latter: The Law of Contract in Singapore at para 15.047. In this second situation, Grassland is liable as the Plaintiffs may elect to sue either the agent (Grassland) or the undisclosed principal (Zenwan) under the Contracts.

  102. (c) If Grassland is not an agent for Zenwan, but merely undertook to arrange for the performance of transportation services by others (as compared to performing the services itself), then it would have fulfilled its contract by exercising due care in the selection of a competent transport supplier: Craven v Strand Holidays (Canada) Ltd (1982) 40 OR (2d) 186 (“Craven”) at [16]; Wong Mee Wan v Kwan Kin Travel Services Ltd and others [1995] 4 All ER 745 (“Wong Mee Wan”) at 749–750. In my view, the foregoing analysis applies if Grassland is an agent for the Plaintiffs.

  103. (d) If Grassland is an agent for no one, and undertook to perform the transportation service itself, it cannot escape liability by delegating or sub-contracting the work to Zenwan: Craven at [16].

  104. Whether Grassland was an agent for Zenwan?

  105. [83] Grassland pleads that it “merely sold tickets on behalf of [Zenwan], as [Zenwan’s] Authorized Sole Agent and that the tickets are and were at all material times issued in the name of [Zenwan]”. Grassland avers that the Plaintiffs knew this at the time the Contract was entered into and refer, in this regard, to cl 19 in the “Terms & Conditions” on the reverse side of the Booking Form (“the Booking Form Terms and Conditions”). Clause 19 states that:

  106. The Plaintiffs accept that the “Company” refers to GE in the Wees’ Booking Form and GET in the Manokarans’ Booking Form.

  107. [84] Abdul Ghani’s 24 Sep AEIC states that GET, a company associated with GE, was appointed by Zenwan as its ticketing agent in Singapore since 1992. He explains that both GET and GE would sell seats to passengers on buses owned and operated by Zenwan, but that he does not know what the arrangement between GET and GE is. He also testified under cross-examination that GE is not an authorised ticketing agent for Zenwan. To show that GET is Zenwan’s ticketing agent, Abdul Ghani exhibits: (a) a letter titled “RE: APPOINTMENT OF AUTHORISED SOLE AGENT” from Zenwan to GET dated 24 August 1992 (“Letter of Appointment”); and (b) an email from the Bus Licence Services, Public Transport Group of the Land Transport Authority to Grassland’s counsel dated 24 June 2019 (“the LTA Email”).

  108. [85] The Letter of Appointment states: “It is hereby confirmed that [GET] has been appointed as the Authorised Sole Agent for our Express services running from Kuala Kedah – Johore Bahru/Singapore – Kuala Kedah named ‘Zenwan (M) Sdn. Bhd. – Langkawi Express.’” [emphasis added]. The LTA Email states that “Based on LTA’s current records, [GET] is the authorised ticketing agent for [Zenwan]”.

  109. [86] In response, the Plaintiffs submit that the Letter of Appointment only evidences GET’s appointment as Zenwan’s sole authorised agent in respect of services running from “Kuala Kedah – Johore Bahru/Singapore – Kuala Kedah” (“the Kuala Kedah Route”) and not for any services running between Singapore and Genting (“the Genting Route”). They point out that Abdul Ghani admitted under cross examination that the Letter of Appointment only showed Zenwan appointing GET for the Kuala Kedah Route. This was his evidence in Suit 1044. However, when he had testified earlier in respect of Suit 1307, he disagreed that the Letter of Appointment did not evidence GET’s agency in respect of the Genting Route. The relevant portion of Abdul Ghani’s testimony under Suit 1307 is as follows:

  110. [87] In the final analysis, I am unpersuaded by Grassland’s submissions.

  111. [88] Even if Grassland was Zenwan’s agent in respect of the Genting Route, Zenwan was an undisclosed principal. If so, the Plaintiffs were entitled to elect to sue the agent under the Contracts (as they have done under this contractual claim).

  112. [89] Zenwan would have been an undisclosed principal because the Plaintiffs and Grassland did not contract with each other on the basis of Grassland being an agent of Zenwan. This is for two reasons.

  113. [90] First, cl 19 indicates to a reasonable reader that Grassland was not an agent for Zenwan (or transport suppliers in general). Although Grassland took pains in cl 19 to state that it acted “only in the capacity of agent for passengers” [emphasis added], the same clause does not confine Grassland’s role to that of a mere agent for the transport “supplier”. The logical inference is that Grassland undertook to perform the transportation service itself and was merely sub-contracting the work to another party. Importantly, Grassland still remains liable if the sub-contractor performs the service in a manner which breaches Grassland’s contract with its customer. The fact that the supplier of services may under the contract arrange for some or all of them to be performed by others does not absolve the supplier from his contractual obligation: Wong Mee Wan at 750; Chitty on Contracts vol 1 (H G Beale gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 34th Ed, 2021) (“Chitty”) at paras 22-084 and 22-087. Thus, an objective reading of cl 19 conveys the impression that a customer is contracting with Grassland alone for the provision of transportation services.

  114. [91] Second, as I later explain, the evidence does not establish that Zenwan issued bus tickets (separate from Grassland’s Booking Form) to the Plaintiffs (see [197]–[201] below) at the time that the Contracts were formed or thereafter. The upshot is that the Booking Forms functioned as the tickets which the Plaintiffs used to board the Bus. It follows that the Plaintiffs did not know of the identity of Zenwan or any other supplier for that matter. Even if Grassland were an agent for Zenwan, the latter would have been an undisclosed principal to the Plaintiffs.

  115. [92] Even if I am wrong that Zenwan’s identity and status as Grassland’s principal was undisclosed, there is insufficient evidence to establish that Grassland was Zenwan’s ticketing agent in respect of the Genting Route.

  116. [93] The Letter of Appointment expressly authorises GET to act as Zenwan’s ticketing agent in respect of the Kuala Kedah Route only. GET has no express actual authority in respect of the Genting Route. In Suit 1044, Abdul Ghani also confirmed that there are no other documents which shed light on the relationship between Zenwan and Grassland.

  117. [94] From the Letter of Appointment, there is also no basis for finding that GET has the implied actual authority to act as Zenwan’s ticketing agent for the Genting Route. Implied actual authority may arise in several ways. First, an agent has authority to do things incidental to the fulfilment of tasks he is expressly authorised to do. Second, an agent has the authority to do things a person in such a position usually does. Third, a corporate agent may be given implied authority by the acquiescence of his superiors (Halsbury’s Laws of Singapore vol 6 (LexisNexis, 2021) at para 70.084). None of these grounds apply in this case.

  118. [95] Further, GET does not have the ostensible authority to act as Zenwan’s agent for the Genting Route. To establish ostensible authority, three elements must be proved (Millenia Pte Ltd (formerly known as Pontiac Marina Pte Ltd) v Dragages Singapore Pte Ltd (formerly known as Dragages et Travaux Publics (Singapore) Pte Ltd) and others (Arup Singapore Pte Ltd, third party) [2019] 4 SLR 1075 at [512(b)], citing Banque Nationale de Paris v Tan Nancy and another [2001] 3 SLR(R) 726 at [67]–[69]):

  119. [96] The Letter of Appointment does not at all refer or allude to the Genting Route and there is no evidence that Zenwan represented to the Plaintiffs that GET or GE had the authority to act for it in respect of the Genting Route. Accordingly, the first requirement for ostensible authority is unfulfilled.

  120. [97] The LTA Email does not take Grassland’s case any further. This is because it is silent on the issue of whether Grassland was appointed as Zenwan’s authorised ticketing agent for the Genting Route. It does not, without more, provide a sufficient ground to infer that Grassland’s authority in the Letter of Appointment had been extended to other routes by Zenwan.

  121. [98] Finally, Grassland did not plead any other bases for their purported agency in respect of the Genting Route. For instance, it did not allege that the scope of its agency, originating from the Letter of Appointment, was widened to include other routes by virtue of the parties’ subsequent dealings or agreement. No evidence was led in these regards either.

  122. [99] For these reasons, Zenwan is either: (a) an undisclosed principal, in which case the Plaintiffs are well within their rights to select to sue Grassland qua agent; or (b) not Grassland’s principal for the Genting Route, in which case the Plaintiffs can only sue Grassland in contract. In both situations, it falls on me to determine whether Grassland breached the Contracts.

  123. Whether Grassland undertook to provide the bus transportation service itself

  124. [100] Since Grassland was not an agent for Zenwan, I am satisfied that Grassland is a party to the Contracts which are alleged to have been breached. However, it still remains to be seen what the nature and scope of Grassland’s undertaking under the Contracts is. The issue, as crystallised by the Plaintiffs, is whether Grassland had (a) merely agreed to assist them to get in touch with a third-party transport provider, or (b) agreed to transport the Plaintiffs to Genting Highlands and back.

  125. [101] Grassland pleads, in the alternative to being the agent of Zenwan, that it:

  126. [102] In its submissions, Grassland argues that it was “merely the booking [agent] and [did] not provide any bus”. It denies having sold any tickets to the Plaintiffs and argues that it only made “booking reservation[s]” for Wee and Manokaran. In effect, Grassland is submitting that it was only obliged to connect the Plaintiffs with a third-party transport supplier, such as Zenwan.

  127. [103] The Plaintiffs take the converse view. They submit that Grassland’s contractual obligation was to transport them to Genting and back to Singapore and not merely to connect them with a third-party transport provider. The Plaintiffs argue that the Contract contains no clear statement that Grassland was merely arranging coach transport as agents for them. In respect of cl 19 of the Booking Form Terms and Conditions, the Plaintiffs argue that cl 19 was not incorporated into the Contract because it is onerous and wholly unreasonable and was not brought to the attention of the Plaintiffs at the time the Contracts were entered into. However, even if it was incorporated, the Plaintiffs submit that cl 19’s application should be “restricted to situations where [Grassland] arranges transportation” and does not “apply to situations where [Grassland] directly sells coach tickets as a principal or an agent of an undisclosed principal”. Further, they argue that despite cl 19 making reference to a third party transport supplier, this does not preclude Grassland from being the supplier of transport. They point out that in Emma Moore v Hotelplan Limited t/a Inghams Travel [2010] EWHC 276 (Ch) (“Inghams Travel”), the defendant-tour operator was held to be the supplier of a snowmobile excursion service even though it had disseminated a welcome pack to its customer making reference to other parties as its supplier.

  128. [104] Further, they claim that other Booking Form Terms and Conditions “gave the impression” that Grassland owned the Bus and/or was supplying the bus transportation to the Plaintiffs directly:

  129. [105] The Plaintiffs also argue that cll 6, 9, 12 and 13, which operate to exclude Grassland’s liability for passengers’ losses and/or to reserve certain rights to itself, are not needed if Grassland was merely their booking agent. On this basis, they submit that the inclusion of these clauses by Grassland “clearly demonstrate[s] that the relationship between [Grassland] and the Plaintiffs was one arising from a contract of carriage”. While the remaining clauses are reproduced above, cl 9 states as follows:

  130. [106] In a similar vein, the Plaintiffs argue that the “clauses” on the front of the Booking Form demonstrate that Grassland entered into a contract of carriage with the Plaintiffs. By way of example, the “clauses” on the front of the Booking Form provide information including the date and time of departure, pickup and alighting location and state “Two way Tkt” under the heading “Description”.

  131. [107] Further the Plaintiffs argue that the Booking Forms are Grassland documents. They highlight that the Booking Forms only feature the Grassland logo and GE or GET’s name but do not mention Zenwan. The Booking Forms are also described as tickets, giving the impression that Grassland provided the transport directly. For this reason, the Plaintiffs also claim to have believed that Grassland was the registered owner of the Bus.

  132. [108] Moreover, the Plaintiffs highlight that Zenwan’s involvement was not brought to their attention. They argue that the entrance of the Boon Lay Office had GET’s name and Grassland’s logo “printed on the front of the office in a large font” while the entrance of the Golden Mile Office had GE’s name and the Grassland logo similarly displayed. The Plaintiffs argue that they were also not informed that they would be travelling on a coach that was not Grassland’s at the time that the Contracts were formed. The Bus also had the word “Grassland” painted on its left side and the back in large letters. Grassland’s website (www.grassland.com.sg) and its logo (the image of a running horse) were also painted on the back of the Bus. The Plaintiffs submit that they did not notice any reference to Zenwan on the Bus. They also assumed Chuah was appointed by Grassland.

  133. [109] In addition, the Plaintiffs argue that Grassland has greater opportunity to insure itself against claims made “in respect of services performed by others” and that the Plaintiffs were not in a position to negotiate any contractual terms with it or Zenwan. They also lament the difficulty of pursuing claims against Zenwan in Malaysia if they did not have a right to sue Grassland. Such difficulty was mentioned in Wong Mee Wan as a policy factor weighing in favour of the first defendant travel company having undertaken to provide certain services to the plaintiff’s daughter with reasonable skill and care (at 754).

  134. [110] From the foregoing, I surmise that the only basis for Grassland to escape liability, by bringing itself within the situation described at [82(c)] above, is cl 19 of the Booking Form Terms and Conditions. I therefore begin by analysing the anterior question of whether cl 19 is incorporated as a term in the Contract.

  135. Was cl 19 incorporated into the Contracts?

  136. [111] The Plaintiffs accept that the Booking Forms were signed by Wee and Manokaran. However, Grassland denies that Wee and Manokaran entered into the Contracts on behalf of their respective family members. I will deal with this issue of privity of contract at [237]–[244] below. For now, I focus on the issue of incorporation of contractual terms. In this regard, the Court of Appeal in Bintai Kindenko Pte Ltd v Samsung C&T Corp and another [2019] 2 SLR 295 (“Bintai”) elucidated at [58] the “well-established principle that in the absence of fraud or misrepresentation, a party is bound by all the terms of a contract that it signs, even if that party did not read or understand those terms”. The court went further to explain that “[r]egardless of whether the terms sought to be incorporated [are] standard or non-standard terms, the onus [is] always on the [party signing the contract] to ascertain what those terms were before agreeing to them” (at [63]).

  137. [112] However, the Plaintiffs submit that even if a contract has been signed, “a condition which is ‘particularly onerous or unusual’ will not be incorporated into the contract, unless it has been fairly and reasonably brought to [the signatory’s] attention” [emphasis in original omitted]. The Plaintiffs refer to this as “the Interfoto Principle”, owing to its namesake, Interfoto Picture Library Ltd v Stiletto Visual Programmes Ltd [1988] 1 All ER 348.

  138. [113] The Plaintiffs note that whether the Interfoto Principle applies to a signed contract remains unsettled in English law, as was recognised in Higgins & Co Lawyers Ltd v Evans [2019] EWHC 2809 (“Higgins”) at [77]. Like Saini J in Higgins, I find Andrew Popplewell QC’s exposition of the relevant case law in Do-Buy 925 Ltd v National Westminster Bank plc [2010] EWHC 2862 to be helpful:

  139. [114] As I understand the Plaintiffs’ submission, they argue that the Interfoto Principle should apply to a signed contract when the clause is onerous and unfair.

  140. [115] I reject the Plaintiffs’ submission.

  141. [116] First, the Court of Appeal made clear in Bintai at [58] that only “fraud or misrepresentation” will free a party from the terms of a signed contract.

  142. [117] Second, this question was squarely considered by Judith Prakash J (as she then was) in Press Automation Technology Pte Ltd v Trans-Link Exhibition Forwarding Pte Ltd [2003] 1 SLR(R) 712 (“Press Automation Technology”). Prakash J refused to extend the Interfoto Principle to signed contracts and held that the principle only applied to cases in which there was no signed contract (Press Automation Technology at [39] and [40]). In my view, this position holds true even for contracts between businesses and consumers. It is telling that Prakash J declined to follow the Canadian case, Tilden Rent-A-Car Co v Clendenning [1978] 83 DLR 3d 400. In the context of a business-consumer contract, the Canadian court held that a signature can only be relied on as manifesting assent to a document when it is reasonable for the party relying on the signed document to believe that the signor really did assent to its contents. This does not represent the law in Singapore. Prakash J’s holding and analysis at [39] and [40] of Press Automation Technology were endorsed by the Court of Appeal in Bintai at [61].

  143. [118] I am guided by the Court of Appeal’s endorsement of Prakash J’s reasons, two of which bear highlighting. First, as Prakash J cautioned, “[c]ontracting parties must have a care for their own legal positions by ascertaining what terms are to be part of a contract before signing it” (Press Automation Technology at [40]). Second, she cited Hobhouse LJ’s remark in AEG (UK) Ltd v Logic Resource Limited [1996] CLC 265 that recourse against onerous terms is already statutorily provided for in the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 (c 50) (UK). Therefore, it is no longer necessary to introduce additional strict criteria to prevent particular terms from being incorporated into a contract. Third, and in addition to Prakash J’s views, it would result in unacceptable levels of uncertainty if signatories to a contract were allowed to disclaim terms which they find to be onerous or unreasonable. In these premises, I see no practical need to extend the Interfoto Principle to signed contracts.

  144. [119] Returning to the present case, the Booking Form has been signed by Wee and Manokaran. In addition, it is twice stated on the front of the Booking Form that the Contract is subject to the Booking Form Terms and Conditions on the reverse side of the Booking Form. This will include cl 19. At the top of the Booking Form, in between Grassland’s letterhead and the title “Booking Form”, the following note is printed:

  145. At the bottom of the Booking Form, above the signature line, there are also “Special Instructions” which read as follows:

  146. [120] On an objective reading, I am satisfied that (a) the “terms and conditions printed overleaf” refer to the Booking Form Terms and Conditions on the reverse side of the Booking Form; and (b) the “Note” and “Special Instructions” on the front of the Booking Form incorporate the Booking Form Terms and Conditions, of which cl 19 is a part, into the Contract.

  147. [121] In view of the above, applying the rule in Bintai (see [111] above), by virtue of Wee and Manokaran’s signatures on the Booking Forms, the Plaintiffs are bound by all the Booking Form Terms and Conditions, including cl 19. This is because the Plaintiffs have neither pleaded nor argued any fraud or misrepresentation on the part of Grassland. As such, it is irrelevant whether Grassland’s representatives – Lye Poh Choo (“Lye”) in Suit 1044 and Xing Lina in Suit 1307 – drew Wee and Manokaran’s attention to the Booking Form Terms and Conditions. Although the Plaintiffs also argue that Wee and Manokaran are not proficient in English and were unable to understand the Booking Form Terms and Conditions, Bintai makes clear that the Plaintiffs remain bound even if they “did not read or understand those terms” (at [58]).

  148. Whether cl 19 is unenforceable under the UCTA

  149. [122] The Plaintiffs argue that cl 19 of the Booking Form Terms and Conditions is unenforceable under ss 2(1) and 3(2) of the UCTA. These provisions read as follows:

  150. [123] A contractual term may be rendered unenforceable under s 2(1) of the UCTA without needing to examine the test of reasonableness under s 11. In contrast, for a term to be unenforceable under s 3(2), the party relying on the term must fail to establish its reasonableness under s 11 of the UCTA:

  151. [124] I begin by examining the Plaintiffs’ case under s 3(2)(b)(i) of the UCTA. Preliminarily, for s 3(2) to apply, the Plaintiffs must be dealing as consumers, or on Grassland’s written standard terms of business: s 3(1) of the UCTA. Section 12(1) of the UCTA states that:

  152. [125] The Plaintiffs are consumers as both requirements in ss 12(a) and 12(b) of the UCTA are met. First, the Plaintiffs did not enter into the Contracts in the course of a business, nor did they hold themselves out as doing so. Wee told Xing Lina that he wanted bus tickets “on behalf of [his] wife and [himself] for travel from Singapore to Genting and for return trips from Genting to Singapore.” Manokaran spoke to Lye about purchasing bus tickets “for [his] Family and [himself] for travel from Singapore to Genting and for return trips from Genting to Singapore”. The natural inference is that Manokaran and Wee were booking tickets in their personal capacities and for their families. Second, GET and GE entered into the Contracts in the course of a business. This much is evident from the fact that Xing Lina and Lye, a supervisor and Front Desk Officer with GE and GET respectively, were tasked to “make seat bookings for customers for bus transport between Singapore and Malaysia”. The first limb of s 3(1) is satisfied and thereby avails the Plaintiffs of s 3(2).

  153. [126] In relation to s 3(2)(b) of the UCTA, the Plaintiffs submit that Grassland’s attempt to clothe itself as an agent of the Plaintiffs is an attempt to render contractual performance which is substantially different from that which was reasonably expected of it or to render no performance at all.

  154. [127] Section 3(2)(b)(i) of the UCTA demands consideration of three questions: (a) what contractual performance did the Plaintiffs reasonably expect of Grassland under the Contracts; (b) what contractual performance did Grassland, by reference to cl 19, claim to be entitled to render; and (c) whether that contractual performance was substantially different from that which was reasonably expected by the Plaintiffs (Zockoll Group Ltd v Mercury Communications Ltd [1999] EMLR 385 (“Zockoll (CA)”) at 395).

  155. [128] Under the first question, the Plaintiffs submit that they expected transportation services to and from Genting to be provided directly by Grassland. They did not expect Grassland to be acting as the “agent and/or sub-agent of Zenwan and/or to outsource the transportation services to Zenwan.” They also expected that Grassland would transport them with reasonable skill and care.

  156. [129] The answer to the first question cannot depend on the proper construction of the contract. If this was so, the reasonable expectations of an aggrieved party would be circumscribed by the impugned term itself: Zockoll (CA) at 395. Thus, in considering this question, the courts have not been confined to the four corners of the contract: The Law of Contract in Singapore at para 07.119. Additionally, the reasonable expectations referred to in s 3(2)(b)(i) of the UCTA are those which would have been formed at the time the contract was made: Shearson Lehman Hutton Inc. and another v Maclaine Watson & Co. Ltd., J.H. Rayner (Mincing Lane) Ltd and others [1989] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 570 at 612.

  157. [130] I agree with the Plaintiffs’ submission. The following factors illustrate the reasonableness of the Plaintiffs’ expectation that Grassland would be providing the transportation service.

  158. [131] First, the Booking Form (less cl 19) objectively gives one the impression that Grassland is the provider of the bus transportation service. As I later explain when determining the nature of Grassland’s contractual undertaking, the visual design of the Booking Form, the information conveyed on the front page, and the Booking Form Terms and Conditions (less cl 19) are consistent with Grassland being the transport provider (see [204]–[218] below).

  159. [132] Even if cl 19 is part of the Contracts, I accept that lay persons like the Plaintiffs may remain under the impression that Grassland is the transport provider. The statement that Grassland is only an “agent for passengers in making all arrangements for transportation …” is inconclusive. This is because the label “agent” is not determinative of the person’s status, even in law: Tan Cheng Han, The Law of Agency (Academy Publishing, 2nd Ed, 2017) at para 01.003. In fact, there are at least two meanings of the word agent. The first is a technical legal meaning entailing all the powers and duties associated with agency. The second is a non-technical meaning which refers to any form of intermediary who simply performs functions for others: Bowstead and Reynolds on Agency (Peter Watts gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 22nd Ed, 2020) (“Bowstead and Reynolds”) at para 1-023; John Nelson-Jones & Peter Stewart, A Practical Guide to Package Holiday Law and Contracts (Fourmat Publishing, 2nd Ed, 1989) at 164.

  160. [133] I doubt that the word “agent” will be understood by a lay person in a legal sense. It is entirely possible that a lay person would construe “agent” as a short-hand for travel agency. The word “arrangements” is also vague and, on a plain reading, is not necessarily inconsistent with Grassland being the transport supplier. I maintain this view even though the second sentence of cl 19 references a third-party “supplier”. A possible reading is that Grassland sub-contracted the provision of transport to a third-party (who could be an independent contractor) but remains, vis-à-vis its own customer, the transport provider. I find support for this last-mentioned reading of cl 19 in Inghams Travel and Wong Mee Wan (see [169(b)] below). Clause 19 is, in my judgment, not sufficiently clear to bring home to the reasonable reader that Grassland is not the transport supplier.

  161. [134] In addition, the evidence reveals that Xing Lina (who served Wee) and Lye (who served Manokaran, Barvathi and Priyatharsini) did not draw specific attention to or explain cl 19. Xing Lina admits that if a customer does not ask about cll 18 and 19, she will not explain them. She only claims to explain “important terms, such as the requirement to wear seatbelts, the passport validity, the luggage entitlement, etc.” Similarly, Lye states that if the customer does not have questions about the Booking Form Terms and Conditions, she will only explain terms related to common problems like “leaving behind their passports or handphone on the bus as well as … their passport validity period and also to remind them to fasten their seat belts while travelling on the buses. Other terms and conditions are equally important but [she] would just get the customers to read through other terms and conditions themselves.” Neither Xing Lina nor Lye suggest that the Plaintiffs asked about cl 19. Further, in Suit 1044, Lye admits that she knew, at the time that the Booking Form was signed, that the Manokarans were booked on a Zenwan bus. In other words, she did not provide this information to Manokaran. As such, there was nothing to dispel the Plaintiffs’ expectation that Grassland would be the transport provider.

  162. [135] While the Plaintiffs further allege that they were not notified that the reverse side of the Booking Forms contained additional terms and conditions, I need not go that far. Even if this was done by Xing Lina and Lye, cl 19 was not explained to the Plaintiffs. As stated, cl 19 is not necessarily inconsistent with Grassland being the transport provider. As such, the presence of cl 19 does not make the Plaintiffs’ expectation unreasonable.

  163. [136] The design of the entrances of the Boon Lay Office and Golden Mile Office, which Manokaran and Wee attended respectively, would have strengthened the impression that Grassland was the transport provider. GET or GE’s name, alongside the Grassland logo, was emblazoned at the entrance of each office. A list of destinations at each entrance, which Grassland assumedly serviced, included “Genting” and other destinations in Malaysia (eg, Kuala Lumpur and Seremban). Significantly, Grassland failed to direct my attention to any portion of the photographs of the entrances of the Boon Lay Office and Golden Mile Office (“the Photographs”) which would have indicated to the Plaintiffs that the transport supplier was a third-party like Zenwan. Grassland did, however, put into evidence a poster of a bus (“the Poster”) which was allegedly displayed in the Boon Lay Office and Golden Mile Office. Grassland claims that the bus in the Poster features both Grassland’s and the bus supplier’s name. However, no evidence was led as to where, within each office, the Poster was hung and whether the bus supplier’s name was large enough to be observable by customers.

  164. [137] I also note that because Tan was not called as a witness in Suit 1044, his AEIC (exhibiting the photograph of the entrance of the Boon Lay Office) was not received into evidence in that action. However, even if the Photographs cannot be taken into account in Suit 1044, the factors at [131]–[135] above sufficiently demonstrate the reasonableness of the Plaintiffs’ expectation that Grassland was itself the transport supplier. In so far as Suit 1307 is concerned, while I later dismiss the Photographs as extrinsic evidence which is inadmissible for the purpose of contractual interpretation (see [183]–[187] below), I do not think I am hamstrung by those rules of admissibility when assessing the reasonableness of the Plaintiffs’ expectations under s 3(2)(b)(i) of the UCTA. This is because this inquiry is not undertaken by reference to the principles on contractual interpretation (see [129] above). However, if I am wrong in this regard, my decision similarly remains unchanged in light of the factors at [131]–[135] above.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.