Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 16 May 2025
Contents

General Division of the High Court

The court ordered the defendants to hand over more company records and communications

The Resolution and Collection Corp v Tsuneji Kawabe and others

Feedback & support

[2025] SGHC 92Case no. Suit No 716 of 2021(Registrar’s Appeal No 76 of 2025)4 paragraphs

The decision, in one line

Not legal advice

The court ordered the defendants to hand over more company records and communications

Summary by laws.sgParagraphs [1], [7]

There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] This is an appeal against certain orders of the Assistant Registrar (“AR”) for discovery of documents in HC/SUM 3735/2024 (“SUM 3735”). The appellants are the fourth, sixth and seventh defendants (“Specified Defendants”) in HC/S 716/2021. The respondent is the plaintiff in HC/S 716/2021. The facts of this suit have been set out in several of my previous judgments: see The Resolution and Collection Corp v Tsuneji Kawabe and others [2023] SGHC 100; The Resolution and Collection Corp v Tsuneji Kawabe and others [2024] SGHC 63; The Resolution and Collection Corp v Tsuneji Kawabe and others [2024] SGHC 259. Briefly, the plaintiff is a Japanese-incorporated company which obtained judgments from the Japanese courts (the “Japanese Judgments”) against the first defendant and his company, the second defendant. Following the death of the first defendant, the plaintiff seeks to enforce the Japanese Judgments against the third defendant (the first defendant’s widow) and the fourth defendant (the first and third defendants’ daughter). The sixth and seventh defendants are companies owned by the fourth defendant. The plaintiff’s case is that the first defendant fraudulently misappropriated assets from the second defendant and other companies to various recipients including the other defendants in this suit. The plaintiff alleges that the Specified Defendants hold assets (against which the plaintiff is entitled to enforce the Japanese Judgments) on trust for the first and second defendants. On this basis, the plaintiff contends that the Specified Defendants are liable for unjust enrichment and/or knowing receipt.

  2. [2] On 7 July 2023, the plaintiff sought discovery of 18 categories of documents in SUM 2022/2023 (“SUM 2022”) for two purposes: first, to trace assets that have allegedly been siphoned out of the second defendant and other companies to the Specified Defendants; and second, to seek an explanation of how the Specified Defendants came to be in possession of substantial assets. The AR allowed discovery of 15 out of the 18 categories and the Specified Defendants appealed against the decision. In The Resolution and Collection Corp v Tsuneji Kawabe and others [2024] SGHC 63, I partially allowed the appeal, ordering the Specified Defendants to produce documents subject to certain restrictions under Categories 1 and 2; Categories 4, 5 and 6; Categories 7 and 8; as well as Category 17 (the “Required Documents”). I also granted liberty to the plaintiff to apply for the disclosure of other categories of documents if the Required Documents demonstrated that those other documents were relevant or necessary to trace where the assets went.

  3. [6] Under Categories 8 and 9, the plaintiff wanted discovery of the incorporation documents, minutes of board meetings, board resolutions and all communications relating to the incorporation, assets and management of the sixth and seventh defendants. These communications included those with the first, third and fifth defendants. The AR granted Categories 8 and 9 subject to amended terms by restricting the scope of the “communications” to specified parties (such as communications between the defendants, Lim Khong Shee and related entities) and imposing a time limit from 2001 to 2023.

  4. [7] The fourth defendant beneficially owns the sixth and seventh defendants which hold substantial assets. Their operational history is therefore directly relevant and necessary for the trial court’s determination of the pleaded issues. The plaintiff’s expert has indicated that these additional documents are required to analyse the source of assets held by the Specified Defendants. I accept that even with the Required Documents, there are questions regarding the source of the Specified Defendants’ assets that may only be resolved through examination of these corporate documents and communications. The corporate structure and management decisions of the sixth and seventh defendants may shed light on whether they were used as vehicles for asset dissipation. The categories are sufficiently precise as they are already limited by reference to communications relating to “incorporation, assets and management”. This should naturally exclude irrelevant de minimis transactions while capturing materials relevant to the disputed issues.