Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 8 Mar 2024
Contents

General Division of the High Court

The Resolution and Collection Corp v Tsuneji Kawabe and others

Feedback & support

[2024] SGHC 63Case no. Suit No 716 of 2021(Registrar’s Appeal No 211 of 2023)7 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] The plaintiff, a Japanese-incorporated company, obtained judgments in Japan (“the Japanese Judgments”) in 2001 against the first defendant (“Mr Kawabe”) and his company, the second defendant. Mr Kawabe has died, and the plaintiff wants to enforce the judgments against the third defendant, who is the first defendant’s widow (“Mrs Kawabe”). The plaintiff is also pursuing the action against the fourth defendant (“Ms Michiyo”) who is the daughter of the first and third defendants. The fifth defendant is an associate of the first defendant, but he is in Thailand and has not entered an appearance in this action. The sixth and seventh defendants are companies owned by Ms Michiyo. The plaintiff’s claim under the Japanese judgments as pleaded is “¥17,483,893,290”, which would be approximately S$157,000,000.

  2. [2] It does not seem to be in dispute that Mrs Kawabe inherited the assets in the estate of Mr Kawabe, assets that the plaintiff claims to be entitled under the Japanese Judgments. Ms Michiyo had denounced her claim to her father’s assets, and so, under Japanese law, it is accepted that she would not have been entitled to his assets. But the plaintiff claims that somehow, Ms Michiyo is in possession of those assets — that purportedly should have been received by Mrs Kawabe.

  3. [3] The plaintiff obtained a Mareva injunction against Ms Michiyo and her companies, but that injunction had been set aside. In the interim, the sixth defendant had disclosed that it has assets worth S$23m. The plaintiff then obtained leave to amend its statement of claim, but that is not presently relevant. It then filed SUM 2022 of 2023 (“SUM 2022”) for discovery of various categories of documents.

  4. [6] Under Categories 1 and 2, the plaintiff wants discovery of the account opening forms and subsequent bank statements of Ms Michiyo’s bank accounts here in Singapore. Under Categories 4, 5, and 6, the plaintiff wants discovery of Ms Michiyo’s income tax returns from 2000 to date. Under Categories 7 and 8, the plaintiff wants the financial statements and returns of the sixth and seventh defendants, respectively. The sixth defendant, a company incorporated in Singapore on 27 April 2016, is wholly owned by the seventh defendant, incorporated on 2 August 2018 in the British Virgin Islands. It is alleged that Ms Michiyo and the fifth defendant control the seventh defendant. Ms Michiyo claims to beneficially own the sixth and seventh defendants. Under Categories 9 and 10, the plaintiff wants the incorporation documents, minutes of meetings, board resolutions and communications of the sixth and seventh defendants, respectively.

  5. [8] Category 17 is the plaintiff’s request for “any other document showing the source of [Ms Michiyo’s] assets”, and Category 18 is the request for communications between Ms Michiyo and her mother (the third defendant) and the fifth defendant “since the commencement of proceedings” that “relate to the Plaintiff’s claim against the Specific Defendants for the tracing of assets that have been allegedly siphoned out of the [second] defendant”. The Rules of Court applicable to this application and appeal are the Rules of Court (2014 Rev Ed).

  6. [10] In this case, we have a plaintiff with a judgment in hand against a defendant who has died, but he leaves behind his widow and a daughter. The latter has two companies, one of which is in possession of S$23m worth of assets. That is a large amount, but is a fraction of the judgment debt. The daughter claims to have worked as an architect and opened her own architecture firm previously. She claims to have subsequently “ventured into the vacation rental and travel business”. It is possible that the assets came into her hands legitimately, or it may not. That is likely to be a focal point at trial.

  7. [11] It will be crucial that she explains her fortune, the question is whether she has to do so now, and by way of disclosing the documents that the plaintiff seeks. No one should, of course, be compelled to disclose matters out of the whim and fancy of the opposing party. Hence relevance and the likelihood of those documents being in her hands are important factors. There is merit in Mr Khoo’s argument that the plaintiff here is switching the burden of proof around. Of course, the plaintiff is not entitled to do that. It cannot demand that Ms Michiyo and her companies show every document that they have.