Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 18 Feb 2022
Contents

Appellate Division of the High Court

POA Recovery Pte Ltd v Yau Kwok Seng and others and another appeal

Feedback & support

[2022] SGHC(A) 7Case no. Civil Appeal No 26 of 20216 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Parties’ clarifications on security for costs

  3. [2] The Judgment was delivered on 3 February 2022. On 4 February 2022, counsel for the respondents, WongPartnership LLP (“WongPartnership”), wrote a letter to the court to draw the court’s attention to the following:

  4. (a) POA Recovery had furnished S$500,000, not S$430,000, in SFC, contrary to what was stated in [92] of the Judgment; and

  5. (b) such SFC had been provided up to the end of trial, and not up to the stage of the exchange of affidavits of evidence-in-chief (“AEICs”).

  6. To be specific, it appears that SFC provided up to exchange of AEICs was only S$250,000, and that an additional sum of S$250,000 was by agreement furnished by POA Recovery for the period after exchange of AEICs up to the end of trial (“the additional SFC”).

  7. [3] On 10 February 2022, counsel for POA Recovery, Rajah & Tann Singapore LLP, confirmed WongPartnership’s position as stated above.

  8. The court’s clarification

  9. [4] The total quantum of SFC provided by POA Recovery up to the exchange of AEICs was in fact S$250,000 and not S$430,000 as incorrectly stated at [92] of the Judgment. The total sum of S$250,000 was furnished pursuant to orders of court, namely HC/ORC 1005/2019 and HC/ORC 7798/2019.

  10. [5] The Judge referred to SFC up to exchange of AEICs (see the Judgment at [35]). Like the Judge, this court was not apprised of the additional SFC. Parties did not point to any supporting documentation evidencing that POA Recovery had in fact furnished additional SFC. While POA Recovery did refer to S$500,000 as the total amount of SFC that was furnished (see POA Recovery’s Appellant’s Case at para 178), the documents referred to did not in fact substantiate such a position; nor did POA Recovery provide in the Appellant’s Case a breakdown of how much SFC could be attributed to each stage of proceedings (ie, how much had been furnished up to the exchange of AEICs, and how much had been furnished thereafter, etc).

  11. [6] As parties have since agreed (via their respective counsel’s letters) that the additional SFC was indeed furnished to cover the period until the end of the trial, this court has taken cognisance of this fact.

  12. [8] Accordingly, the outcome of the Judgment under the sub-heading of “Champerty and maintenance” (ie, Judgment at [84]–[100]) remains despite our acknowledgment of the position on SFC recently raised by parties.