Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 30 Sep 2020
Contents

Singapore International Commercial Court

Beyonics Asia Pacific Ltd and others v Goh Chan Peng and another

Feedback & support

[2020] SGHC(I) 20Case no. Suit No 10 of 2018 (Summons No 56 of 2020)12 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [1] Judgment in this action was given on 28 May 2020 in Beyonics Asia Pacific Limited and others v Goh Chan Peng and another [2020] SGHC(I) 14 and terms not defined here shall have the same meaning as in that judgment. Two separate issues arose for consideration, the Henderson v Henderson Issue and the Substantive Issue. The Defendants succeeded on the Henderson v Henderson Issue with the result that the action was struck out for abuse of process. However, neither party had sought to have the Henderson v Henderson Issue tried as a preliminary point and the trial therefore also addressed the Substantive Issue and judgment was given on this as well.

  2. [2] On the Substantive Issue, had the action not been struck out, the Plaintiffs’ claims for the Diversion Loss and the Total Loss would have failed but their claims for the return of the bonus and the payments made under the Resignation Agreements would have succeeded.

  3. [9] Both parties have filed written submissions and have agreed that the matter should be decided without the need for an oral hearing.

  4. [10] Section 34(2) of the SCJA provides:

  5. [11] Paragraph 1 of the Fifth Schedule provides:

  6. [12] The Plaintiffs put their case succinctly in paragraph 2 of their written submissions:

  7. [13] In support of this reliance is placed on the Court of Appeal decision in Qilin World Capital Ltd v CPIT Investment Ltd and another appeal [2019] 1 SLR 1 (“Qilin”).

  8. [16] The respondent’s solicitors are recorded in [7(a)] of the Court of Appeal’s judgment as contending:

  9. [17] Paragraph 9 of Qilin reads as follows:

  10. [27] Be that as it may, for the reasons I have given, I am satisfied that no separate notice of appeal is required but appellants would be well advised as a matter of caution to seek to amend any substantive notice of appeal until the Court of Appeal clarifies that this is unnecessary.

  11. [28] This is therefore sufficient to dispose of this application. If no notice of appeal is required, it follows that leave to appeal is not necessary either. But that leaves the Plaintiffs in a somewhat invidious position if the Court of Appeal were to consider that the reasoning in Clearlab mandates the filing of a separate notice of appeal for which leave has been given.

  12. [31] The Defendants contend, strongly, that this should not be done as the application for leave was made out of time and that there was no good reason for the delay. They submit that this is particularly the case where the failure relates to a notice of appeal where the interest of justice requires that there be finality. However, in this case, there is to be the Substantive Appeal and finality will only occur once judgment is given by the Court of Appeal. There is thus no reason to adopt a strict approach to the granting of an extension of time. In the circumstances where the law is said to be unclear, where the delay is a short one and the delay is not going to affect the ultimate date on which finality is reached, it is appropriate that leave should be given.

  13. Conclusion

  14. Simon Thorley

  15. International Judge