Singapore International Commercial Court · Decided 6 September 2023
The Micro Tellers Network Ltd and others v Cheng Yi Han and others
Feedback & support[2023] SGHC(I) 13 · Case no. Suit No 5 of 2020
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] This action was commenced in the High Court (HC/S 916/2019) on 13 September 2019 and was transferred to the Singapore International Commercial Court (“SICC”) as SIC/S 5/2020 (“Suit 5”) on 27 July 2020.
- [2]
[2] The first plaintiff (“Micro Tellers”) is a company incorporated in Hong Kong whose sole director and shareholder is Charles Cuong Tan-Thatch (“Charles”). Charles is a successful businessman who initially worked for Societe Generale in New York and Hong Kong and who, since 2016, has pursued business ventures on his own behalf including various cryptocurrency projects. One of the major projects in which he was involved in his capacity as the chief cryptocurrency officer of Asia Innovations Group (“AIG”) was an Initial Coin Offering (“ICO”) of a cryptocurrency token called “Gifto”.
- [3]
[3] As Charles explained in his second affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”):
- [4]
[4] The second, third and fourth plaintiffs are Singaporean citizens each of whom is also a successful businessman. They met in 2014 or 2015 through a network called Entrepreneurs’ Organisation and together became interested in cryptocurrency investments, more specifically in ICOs, and pooled their resources for such investments. During the trial, the second plaintiff was referred to as “Michael”, the third as “Rio” and the fourth as “Clement”. Together they were referred to as “the Regional Group”. I shall do the same.
- [5]
[5] Until 16 September 2020, the plaintiffs’ claims were made only against the first three Defendants, Cheng Yi Han (“Yi Han”), Ling Hui Andrew (“Andrew”) and Providence Asset Management (“PAM”), a company incorporated in the Cayman Islands, of which Andrew is a director and shareholder. I shall refer to these three defendants together as “the Initial Defendants”.
- [6]
[6] Yi Han did not give evidence. His relationship with Micro Tellers was described by Charles after they had first met in late 2017 in Charles’ second AEIC:
- [7]
[7] Clement also met Yi Han in late 2017 and together with the other Regional Group members supported Yi Han in various ICOs in late 2017 and early 2018 which were successful. Clement stated that by February 2017 “[he] enjoyed working with Yi Han and considered him a friend who could be trusted” and that “[o]verall, I was impressed with Yi Han”.
- [8]
[8] Andrew did give evidence. He explained his relationship with Yi Han as follows in his second AEIC:
Background
The plaintiffs’ claims against the Initial Defendants
- [9]
[9] The plaintiffs’ claims against the Initial Defendants arose out of two incidents referred to in these proceedings as “the Europe Transaction” and “the Private Bank Acquisition”. I shall have to go into greater detail in relation to these incidents later.
- [10]
[10] In simple terms, however, the Europe Transaction occurred in April 2018. It involved a proposed trade of Bitcoin (“BTC”) purchased by the Initial Defendants with the authority of the Regional Group using funds supplied by them which were held in PAM’s bank account. The intention was that those BTC should be sold to buyers in Europe (“the Buyers”) at a profit, the consideration being €5m which was to be paid in cash. In the event, it turned out that the banknotes supplied (“the Banknotes”) were forgeries. The Regional Group claimed that the Initial Defendants were liable to them in deceit, breach of duty and/or trust, unjust enrichment, conspiracy and negligence. Micro Tellers was not involved in the Europe Transaction.
- [11]
[11] The Private Bank Acquisition involved both sets of plaintiffs. In the case of the Regional Group, following the failure of the Europe Transaction, there were some US$2m of the Regional Group’s funds remaining in PAM’s bank account which the Group asked to be returned. This was not done and it was asserted that the Initial Defendants had misappropriated the funds by using them without the Group’s authority as part of the Private Bank Acquisition. Again, relief was sought based on deceit and other related claims.
- [12]
[12] In the case of Micro Tellers, it did authorise the Regional Group to use some US$2.7m of the funds deposited by it in the PAM bank account as part of the Private Bank Acquisition but, it was asserted, this was done following various false representations made by the Initial Defendants to Charles. Once again, claims were made in deceit and other related claims.
- [13]
[13] In their Defence, again in very simple terms, the Initial Defendants sought to place the blame for any misdoings upon Then Feng (“Feng”), now the fourth defendant.
Suit 8 – the action between the Initial Defendants and Then Feng
- [14]
[14] Unbeknown to the plaintiffs, on 2 July 2019, PAM (and a related company 5 and 2 Pte Ltd (“5&2”)) had brought proceedings in the High Court (HC/S 653/2019) against Feng and his wife, Lee Moon Young (“Moon”). On 29 September 2020 the plaintiffs in that action discontinued the claim against Moon. Thereafter that action was transferred to the SICC on 13 October 2020 as SIC/S 8/2020 (“Suit 8”).
- [15]
[15] In Suit 8, the plaintiffs (“the Suit 8 Plaintiffs”) contended that they had been induced to provide funds for the purpose of the Private Bank Acquisition by certain false representations made to them by Feng. Some of the funds advanced were monies deposited in the PAM bank account by the plaintiffs in this action and which are the subject of the claims in relation to the Private Bank Acquisition incident.
- [16]
[16] Although the plaintiffs in this action became aware of the fact that the Initial Defendants were seeking to place the blame on Feng, prior to transfer to the SICC they did not seek to join Feng as a defendant nor did the Initial Defendants seek to join him as a third party.
- [18]
[18] The two actions came for trial before me on 14 June 2021. The subsequent history of the trial is set out in [1]–[13] of the judgment subsequently given in Suit 8 on 22 September 2021 – The Micro Tellers Network Ltd and others v Cheng Yi Han and others and another suit [2021] 5 SLR 328:
- [19]
[19] As indicated in that passage, all findings made in that action, particularly since Feng elected not to give evidence, can have no impact on the determination of the issues in this case. It is, regrettably, necessary to start again. But what may be relevant and admissible are the details of the settlement agreements reached between the plaintiffs and (a) Andrew, PAM and 5 &2 on 7 May 2021 (“the PAM SA”) and (b) Yi Han on 15 June 2021 (“the Yi Han SA”). For convenience redacted copies of these agreements are annexed to this judgment: see Annexes A and B. So far as concerns the PAM SA, it is cl 1.1–1.4 which are particularly relevant:
- [20]
[20] In the case of the Yi Han SA, the material clause is cl 1:
- [21]
[21] In both agreements the plaintiffs’ rights to continue this action against the (then) remaining defendants were specifically reserved.
The persons involved
Then Feng
- [22]
[22] Feng qualified as a solicitor in England in 2007 having had a training contract at a leading London firm of solicitors for whom he then worked. In all he was with that firm for four years when he moved to New York where he was employed for about a year by an equally prestigious US law firm. In 2011 he returned to Singapore and was employed as an assistant solicitor by Walkers Singapore LLP. Walkers Singapore LLP is affiliated to an international law firm based in the Cayman Islands called Walkers and there are other affiliated offices around the world including one in London. All representatives of those affiliates used a common email domain name – “walkersglobal.com”. Unless it is necessary to distinguish between the different affiliates I shall refer to “Walkers” simpliciter. Feng’s contract of employment with Walkers Singapore was terminated in or about November 2018.
- [23]
[23] As well as working for Walkers Singapore, Feng also carried on business on his own behalf using (apparently) a number of Singapore and offshore companies. In particular, the company at the centre of the events underlying the Private Bank Acquisition is a company which was incorporated in June 2015 in the British Virgin Islands under the name Walkers Professional Services Limited (“WPS”). The necessary arrangements for setting up the company were effected by Feng but Moon was named as the sole director and shareholder. WPS had no connection with Walkers.
- [24]
[24] In addition to Suit 8, Feng has been a party to other civil litigation in Singapore and is currently a defendant in a criminal trial in the State Courts. The existence of the latter caused difficulties in allowing Feng to comply with his obligations on discovery in this action and resulted in the late disclosure of a number of documents, some of which were admitted and others which were not.
Lee Moon Young
- [25]
[25] As indicated above, Moon was initially a defendant in Suit 8 but the action against her was discontinued before the trial. She was not originally a defendant in Suit 5. Following judgment in Suit 8, an application was made to join her as a defendant in this action on two grounds: dishonest assistance in relation to Feng’s alleged unlawful acts in relation to the Private Bank Acquisition and conspiracy with Feng to commit those acts. Following a hearing, the application was allowed by me in a decision given orally on 18 May 2022 but which has subsequently been reduced to writing (“the Oral Judgment”): see Annex C. I concluded at [47]–[48] of the Oral Judgment that although the grounds pleaded raised at best a tenuous case for her liability, it was not “doomed to failure” which counsel for Moon accepted was the threshold test.
- [26]
[26] Moon is a Korean citizen and she and Feng were married in May 2015. On their return from their honeymoon Feng asked her to become the sole director and shareholder in WPS, which she agreed to do, and she was the only authorised signatory of the WPS bank account. It is these factors which underlie the case against Moon.
The witnesses
- [27]
[27] Evidence was adduced for the plaintiffs by Charles on behalf of Micro Tellers and by Michael, Rio and Clement on behalf of the Regional Group. No criticism was made of the manner in which they gave their evidence.
- [28]
[28] The principal witness for the Regional Group was Andrew and for the fourth defendant it was Feng himself. In the course of cross-examination, it became apparent that both witnesses have little hesitation in telling lies in the course of their business dealings when it is in their commercial interests to do so. In consequence I was asked in oral submissions on behalf of the plaintiffs to decline to place weight on Feng’s testimony when in conflict with Andrew’s and to prefer the latter’s. Feng, in his closing submissions, made the opposite submission.
- [29]
[29] I do not need to go into the details of the various untruths that were disclosed; suffice it to say that I am satisfied in the circumstances the better route to reaching conclusions as to where the truth lies is to have regard to the contemporaneous documents in seeking to resolve conflicts of evidence.
- [30]
[30] In addition, the plaintiffs adduced evidence from Frederic Willy Gaillard, a former business partner of Feng with whom he had fallen out. Mr Gaillard gave evidence on the first day of the original trial, 14 June 2021, before the hearing was adjourned as a result of the settlements. He did so at the request of the plaintiffs as he had been convicted of a criminal offence relating to one of his business dealings and was due to be imprisoned later in that week.
- [31]
[31] Mr Gaillard swore two AEICs. I excluded much of the first on the basis that it consisted of inadmissible hearsay and a good deal of the remainder of his evidence was of peripheral relevance. Where I see fit to make reference to his evidence, I shall give my reasons for doing so and the weight to be placed on it at the appropriate place.
- [32]
[32] Finally, Moon gave evidence in relation to the case pleaded against her and was cross-examined on her AEICs. In closing submissions little criticism was made of the totality of her evidence and I shall deal with this when considering the issues that arise.
The Europe Transaction
- [33]
[33] The Europe Transaction took place in Nice, France, on 26 April 2018 (it was completed on the evening of 26 April 2018, French time, which was early morning on 27 April 2018, Singapore time). Since this was prior to the events leading up to the Private Bank Acquisition I propose to deal with it first. Micro Tellers was not involved and no claim is made by the Regional Group against Moon in relation to it.
- [34]
[34] As indicated in [10] above, no claim was made initially by the Regional Group against Feng. The Initial Defendants were the sole defendants. Feng was joined as a defendant by amendment on 16 September 2020 and the claims against him were expressly made as being additional to or in the alternative to the claims made against the Initial Defendants. Following the settlement with the Initial Defendants, the Statement of Claim (“SOC”) was further amended on 27 May 2022 so as to delete the claims made against the Initial Defendants and to focus the claims made against Feng.
- [35]
[35] Three claims are made against Feng:
(a) Breach of duties (“the Europe Duties”) owed by Feng to the Initial Defendants, acting in their capacity as agents for the Regional Group. Those duties were owed by Feng acting in his capacity as a solicitor of Walkers engaged by the Initial Defendants to carry out various duties.
(b) Breach of fiduciary duties owed by Feng directly to the Regional Group by reason of his voluntary assumption of the Europe Duties in circumstances giving rise to a relationship of trust and confidence (“the Europe Fiduciary Duties”) .
(c) Negligence:
- [36]
[36] In cross-examination Andrew accepted that Feng was not engaged in his capacity as a solicitor of Walkers in relation to the Europe Transaction and that he was acting solely in his private capacity. In consequence by letter dated 13 March 2023 the solicitors acting for the plaintiffs indicated that they would not be pursuing the allegations made in relation to his conduct as a solicitor in paras 59–60 and 67–68 of the SOC. It necessarily follows that in so far as para 62 relates to Feng’s alleged duties as a solicitor that this was also not being pursued.
- [37]
[37] The case against Feng thus rests on the alleged voluntary assumption of the Europe Fiduciary Duties by him in his private capacity in circumstances giving rise to a relationship of trust and confidence and/or negligence in his failure to carry out the Europe Duties with reasonable skill and care.
Breach of fiduciary duties
The pleadings
- [38]
[38] There are three alleged Europe Duties set out in the SOC:
(a) To ensure that the Regional Group BTC will not be released to the Buyers until payment was duly made;
(b) To carry out due diligence on and engage a competent and professional security firm which would verify that payment was duly made; and
(c) To procure and/or ensure the procurement of valid insurance and/or ensure that the security firm which was engaged had valid insurance, such that the Initial Defendants (acting as agents of the Regional Group) would be fully indemnified against any losses arising from the Europe Transaction.
- [39]
[39] The alleged Europe Fiduciary Duties are set out in the SOC and can be summarised as being the duty to be honest and act in good faith in the interests of the Regional Group, not to advance his own or other external interests in conflict with the interests of the Regional Group and to ensure that the Regional Group’s assets were not misappropriated.
- [40]
[40] Four reasons are given for alleging that Feng owed the Europe Fiduciary Duties to the Regional Defendants:
(a) The Regional Group was vulnerable to the actions of Feng. The Regional Group would not be present in person at the conduct of the Europe Transaction, and had no contact with the security firm to be engaged to verify that payment had been duly made. The Regional Group relied on Feng to carry out the Europe Duties.
(b) Feng had the power to affect the Regional Group’s interests by causing the Regional Group BTC to be released even if payment had not been duly made.
(c) Feng voluntarily undertook to carry out the Europe Duties and act in the interests of the Regional Group, in circumstances giving rise to a relationship of trust and confidence.
(d) Feng had actual and/or constructive knowledge that the Regional Group BTC used for the Europe Transaction belonged to the Regional Group and/or the owners of the Regional Group BTC.
- [41]
[41] The alleged breaches of the Europe Fiduciary Duties are set out in the SOC:
(a) Feng advised or otherwise caused the release of the Regional Group BTC without ensuring that payment had been duly made. The Banknotes were found to be counterfeit.
(b) Feng engaged SGS Security & Logistik Gesellschaft GmbH (“SGS GmbH”) on behalf of the Initial Defendants (acting as agents of the Regional Group) without carrying out due diligence, and did not ensure that SGS GmbH was competent and fit for the intended purpose of verifying that payment had been duly made.
(i) The paid-up capital of SGS GmbH was only 20,000 Swiss francs.
(ii) SGS GmbH used different company logos on different documents.
(iii) There were no contractual documents establishing the terms of engagement between the Initial Defendants (as agents of the Regional Group) and SGS GmbH.
(c) Feng failed to procure and/or ensure the procurement of valid insurance and/or ensure that SGS GmbH had valid insurance, such that the Initial Defendants (acting as agents of the Regional Group) would be fully indemnified against any losses arising from the Europe Transaction.
(i) The Initial Defendants (acting as agents of the Regional Group) have not been compensated for the losses arising from the Europe Transaction.
(ii) SGS GmbH has failed, neglected and/or refused to indemnify the Initial Defendants (as agents of the Regional Group) for their losses arising from the Europe Transaction.
- [42]
[42] In his Defence Feng asserts that he had only a limited knowledge of and involvement in the Europe Transaction and denies that he was ever engaged to perform the Europe Fiduciary Duties or that he held the BTC and/or the euros on trust.
The law
- [43]
[43] It is necessary to identify the manner in which the law determines (a) when a fiduciary relationship exists between a fiduciary and a third party or parties and (b) what the duties are that equity imposes on a fiduciary once identified.
- [44]
[44] The underlying principles of law are well settled and are not in dispute.
- [45]
[45] The relevant law was well summarised in the Plaintiffs’ Written Closing Statement which I gratefully adopt. It reads:
- [46]
[46] In relation to the Europe Transaction, since it is now accepted that Feng was not acting in his capacity as a solicitor, particular attention has to be directed to the question of whether Feng had voluntarily been placed or had placed himself in the position of a fiduciary.
- [47]
[47] In this respect I was invited to place weight on the suggested analogy between the facts of this case and those in Tan Teck Kee v Ratan Kumar Rai [2022] 2 SLR 1250 (“Tan Teck Kee”). In that case, some investors wished to purchase land in Cambodia and designated the defendant, Mr Tan, to be their representative on the ground in Cambodia to oversee the purchase. The plaintiff, Mr Rai, contended that Mr Tan had significant oversight and control over the purchase such as to give rise to fiduciary obligations. On the facts it was held that Mr Tan had undertaken to manage the purchase and that substantial sums had been paid into his personal bank account. He had thus voluntarily undertaken a position with a high degree of control over the investors’ interests.
- [48]
[48] At [68]–[69] of Tan Teck Kee, Steven Chong JCA said this:
- [49]
[49] He continued at [74]:
- [50]
[50] He concluded at [77]–[78]:
- [51]
[51] Once there is a finding that a person has voluntarily undertaken fiduciary obligations to the beneficiaries and the nature of the obligations which arise have been identified as a question of fact, the law then imposes a duty enforceable in equity on the trustee to conduct themselves in carrying out those obligations in good faith so as to advance and protect the interests of the beneficiaries.
The facts
- [52]
[52] In simple terms the Breach of Fiduciary Duties allegation is founded on the assertion that Feng played a pivotal role in the Europe Transaction analogous to the of Mr Tan in Tan Teck Kee. In his closing oral submissions, Mr Adrian Tan (“Mr Tan”), counsel for the plaintiffs, asked the rhetorical question “who is the major figure in this” and asserted that it was Feng on the basis that he was “in the centre of it” and had placed himself in a position where he had control and undertook to “[give] the green light” to the transfer of the BTC.
- [53]
[53] This is denied by Feng who asserts that he was only peripherally involved. He accepts that he introduced the Initial Defendants to Stefan Lange-Juergen (“Stefan”) (generally referred to as “Stefan Lange” or simply “Stefan”), a Swiss banker, who was a contact that he had made as a result of previous business transactions. It is therefore necessary to make findings of fact as to the parts played by the various parties in the Europe Transaction so as to place the activities of Feng into context. I shall start by considering the facts relating to the setting up of the transaction and then those relating to its implementation.
(1) Setting up of the transaction
- [54]
[54] In the case of the Regional Group the principal part was played by Clement and his primary point of contact was Yi Han. By late January or early February, Clement and Yi Han had established a good working relationship and they discussed whether there were other ways of making money through cryptocurrencies apart from ICOs. Clement said this in his AEIC:
- [55]
[55] Thereafter members of the Regional Group made inquiries to satisfy themselves that Yi Han and Andrew could be trusted to hold the Group’s money in the PAM bank account. They were eventually satisfied that they could be trusted in part by a representation that the PAM bank account held a balance in excess of US$78 million. This representation was false and thus reflects badly upon Yi Han and Andrew and is one of the reasons that caution must be exercised when assessing the weight to be attached to statements made on oath by Andrew and due notice taken of the fact that Yi Han did not give evidence. However, there is no suggestion that Feng was in any way involved with the affairs of PAM or with the Regional Group’s decision to place funds with PAM.
- [56]
[56] Yi Han informed Clement that the proposed Europe Transaction would be carried out in the following manner:
- [57]
[57] Yi Han stated that the Initial Defendants would engage a professional security firm to ensure that the notes were legitimate and, following discussions with Clement, confirmed that insurance had been taken out. Yi Han also made a false representation that the deal would be done through the same broker as the Initial Defendants had used for a previous transaction. However, again, Feng was not involved in the making of these representations.
- [58]
[58] In cross-examination Clement made it plain that he had never met or corresponded with Feng, that the only person he corresponded with prior to the discovery that the Banknotes were false was Yi Han and that he left all decisions on how to verify that the Banknotes were genuine to Yi Han.
- [59]
[59] The evidence of Michael and Rio confirmed that the primary contact so far as the Regional Group was concerned was between Clement and Yi Han.
- [60]
[60] In summary, so far as the Regional Group is concerned, it is accepted that that they were unaware until after the event of the existence of Feng or that he played any part in the arrangements for the Europe Transaction. Their original AEICs, filed before the hearing of this action was adjourned because of the settlements, were directed to the then-subsisting claims against the Initial Defendants and not to the claim against Feng. Each of their assertions in their respective second AEICs that Feng played a pivotal/central/key role in the Europe Transaction was surmise on the basis of what they had been told by Yi Han and Andrew subsequent to June 2019.
- [61]
[61] So far as concerns the Initial Defendants, Yi Han did not give evidence. The overall nature of the part that he played can however be discerned from the documents and the evidence of other witnesses. He was the primary point of contact with the Regional Group and appears to have been the one who started the negotiations with the counterparty to the Europe Transaction, one J C Roguet (“JC”). In his second AEIC Andrew stated that he could not recall whether the suggestion of the deal came from Yi Han or Feng. In cross-examination he was shown an e-mail of his dated 29 April 2018 in which he gave details of the manner in which the Initial Defendants were introduced to JC and on reviewing it said this:
- [62]
[62] Earlier in the cross-examination, Andrew accepted that Feng was not in contact with JC or Yi Han, that Yi Han was in contact with the Regional Group and that he, Yi Han, and a person called Leonard Lee Kah Yeen (“Leonard”), a business associate of Yi Han and Andrew, were in contact with JC. On the basis of this evidence, I am satisfied that Feng was not the person who suggested the deal and that he had no contact with JC.
- [63]
[63] In his second AEIC Andrew deposes to the parts played by the various parties in making the arrangements for the Europe Transaction:
- [64]
[64] In cross-examination, Andrew accepted that Feng was involved in his personal capacity and not in his capacity as a solicitor and asserted that he relied on Feng’s expertise and contacts.
- [66]
[66] In his first AEIC Feng’s evidence concerning the part in the preparations for the transaction was brief. He said this:
- [67]
[67] The fees involved for the introduction were €250,000. In his second AEIC, Feng disputes much of Andrew’s narrative of the events leading up to the transaction which is summarised in his second AEIC as follows:
- [68]
[68] In the closing submissions attention was focused on the part played by Feng in the appointment of SGS and his alleged responsibility for and failure to satisfy himself as to (a) the standing and repute of SGS and (b) that SGS carried the necessary insurance cover.
- [69]
[69] So far as concerns KippCo, no reliance is placed in the pleadings by the Regional Group on the part played by Feng. It is common ground that KippCo was appointed to carry out the banking and transfer of the money. In cross-examination it was put to Feng that it was Stefan who introduced KippCo and Feng agreed to this.
- [70]
[70] Whilst there was some debate as to when the Investment Contract between KippCo and PAM (dated 17 April 2018) was actually signed, nothing turns on this and I shall not consider it further.
- [71]
[71] The full name of SGS is SGS Security & Logistik Gesellschaft GmbH and the dealings with it were through their Zurich office. The contemporaneous documents relating to the appointment of SGS consist mainly of WhatsApp messages passing between members of a number of different chat groups. From the chat group which contained Andrew and JC it can be seen that initially, it was intended to use a security company called Brinks to handle the money and the change to SGS is recorded in a chat from Andrew at 10.16pm on 19 April 2018.
- [72]
[72] Andrew received the following information from Feng earlier on 19 April 2018 as is shown in this extract from the chat between them:
- [73]
[73] The reference to the Banker is a reference to Stefan. As indicated above it was Feng who introduced Stefan to Andrew and Feng knew Stefan as a result of previous successful business ventures in Europe. Equally it is not in dispute that Stefan was a Swiss Banker working for HSBC and in oral closing submissions Mr Tan accepted that there was no suggestion that Stefan was anything other than a respectable Swiss banker. As with Feng, it was agreed that Stefan would receive €250,000 for the part that he was to play in the arrangements for the transaction once it has been successfully transacted.
- [74]
[74] It was at one time suggested that by the use of the term “Banker”, Feng was seeking to hide the identity of Stefan from Andrew. This does not appear to be the case as his name is freely used in other chats: see [86] below.
- [75]
[75] Feng suggests that Stefan dealt directly with Andrew to arrange the services of SGS whereas Andrew asserts that the introduction to SGS was effected by Feng with no mention being made of the part played by Stefan. There are no documents prior to the date of the failed transaction which indicate any direct contact between Stefan and Andrew and I therefore reject the suggestion that there was any such contact. But, equally it is clear that Andrew was well aware of Stefan’s existence, that he was a Swiss banker and that he was being relied upon to establish a relationship with SGS.
- [76]
[76] In cross-examination, Andrew agreed that while Stefan was introduced by Feng it was Stefan that arranged for SGS to be the security company.
- [77]
[77] The only evidence which suggests that SGS was not a competent security firm comes from Mr Gaillard. Mr Gaillard stated that he had recommended that Feng should hire a reputable security firm such as “Ferrari, Malca Amit, Brinks or SGS (Société Générale de Surveillance SA)”. He goes on to say that subsequently he found out that Feng had hired SGS and not the French SGS company. Whilst he states that he referred to SGS, meaning the French company, he does not state that he told Feng that he had in mind a French company rather than a Swiss entity using the same initials, SGS, and it was not suggested to Feng in cross-examination that he did.
- [78]
[78] Feng stated in cross-examination that it was Stefan who had contacts with SGS and that in one of their previous dealings Stefan had used SGS:
- [79]
[79] When Andrew became aware that SGS services were going to be used he did a Google search which revealed the existence of SGS and it appeared to him to be a big company such that he did not see the need to ask for any insurance papers. He confirmed that he did not become aware that there was also a French security company using the initials SGS:
- [80]
[80] It is thus clear from the documents that SGS was appointed on the recommendation of Stefan. The evidence does not establish that any of the participants had any reason to believe that SGS was not an efficient security company and none was aware that there was an alternative French security company trading under a name including the initials SGS.
- [81]
[81] Further there is no indication in the documents that Feng was ever asked to carry out a due diligence investigation into SGS nor that he volunteered to do so.
- [82]
[82] Turning then to the question of the part played by Feng in relation to the insurance cover provided by SGS, the Regional Group is unable to point to any documentary evidence in support of the assertion that Feng was charged by Andrew to ensure that SGS carried adequate insurance cover. The furthest Andrew could state was that Feng had told him that SGS was fully insured. The matter was expanded upon in cross-examination from which it is clear that it was Stefan and not Feng who made the representation concerning insurance cover and that Andrew never thought of asking Feng for any documents from SGS evidencing the indemnity coverage because of the Google search he did on SGS.
- [83]
[83] On the basis of the foregoing, I find, on the balance of probabilities that in relation to Feng’s involvement in the making of the arrangements for the transaction, the facts were as follows:
(a) Feng used his previous relationship with Stefan to obtain his assistance in making arrangements for the security aspects of the transaction and agreed with Andrew the basis on which he would be rewarded for that assistance on the successful conclusion of the Transaction.
(b) The sum agreed was a substantial sum amounting to €250,000.
(c) Stefan was a respectable Swiss banker who was also going to be rewarded by payment of €250,000.
(d) Stefan selected SGS as the security company because he had had previous dealings with them.
(e) Andrew himself did a Google search to satisfy himself that SGS was a reputable company and did not ask or rely on Feng to do a due diligence search into SGS.
(f) Feng did not volunteer to carry out a due diligence investigation into SGS.
(g) At no time was there any belief on the part of either Andrew, Stefan or Feng (or any of the other participants) that SGS was anything otherwise than a reputable company.
(h) Andrew did not ask or rely on Feng to obtain any documents verifying SGS’s insurance coverage.
(i) Feng did not volunteer to obtain any documents verifying SGS’s insurance coverage.
(2) The implementation of the transaction
- [84]
[84] The Banknotes, which turned out to be counterfeit, were handed over in Nice, France on the evening of 26 April 2018. At the time Andrew was in the People’s Republic of China, Feng was in Malaysia, Stefan was in Switzerland and Leonard was on the ground in Nice. The interaction between them is contained in a series of WhatsApp messages divided between three groups. The first involved Andrew and Feng, the second involved Andrew, Yi Han and Shawn Lin (a business colleague of Andrew and Yi Han) (“the PPG group”) and the third involved Andrew, Feng, Stefan and Leonard (“the Nice group”).
- [85]
[85] These contemporaneous documents provide the best record of how the events of that day progressed and are to be preferred to any documents prepared subsequently after it was discovered that the Banknotes were counterfeit or to the recollections of individuals sometime later.
- [86]
[86] The Nice group was formed at 10.10pm (Singapore time) on 26 April 2018 between Andrew, Feng and Leonard. Stefan was added at 11.34pm. The following extracts from that chat group demonstrate the relationship between the participants and the part each played over the next few hours.
- [87]
[87] The documents referred to in those interchanges can be seen as attachments to a report written by Leonard on or before 29 April 2018.
- [88]
[88] The comment by Stefan at 24/7/18, 1:37:23 AM (underlined above) was copied and pasted into the PPG group by Andrew a few moments later and thereafter the BTC were transferred:
- [89]
[89] The written and oral evidence of Andrew and Feng does not add anything to this. It is fair to say that in his evidence Andrew sought to maximise the part played by Feng and Feng sought to minimise it. Andrew did however accept that (a) Leonard was instructed by and answerable to PAM through Andrew, and not by Feng, and (b) that it was Stefan, not Feng, who confirmed that risk had passed to SGS which gave Andrew comfort to conclude the deal.
- [90]
[90] So far as concerns Feng, his statements to the effect that he was merely a conduit for the passing of information between Andrew and Stefan was challenged on the basis that he was being promised a great deal of money if the deal went through for playing such a limited part. This would indeed appear to be the case but the amount of money cannot alter the state of affairs as disclosed in the documents.
- [91]
[91] Finally, there was a good deal of evidence directed to the part that Feng played in seeking to assist in recovering the money and/or claiming on the SGS insurance policy. This was relied upon in the Plaintiffs’ Closing Statement as being one of the matters that Feng was responsible for. I do not believe that the evidence supports this. Once it was discovered that the Banknotes were counterfeit all the parties appear to have pulled together to try to recover their loss. I shall not however go into this in any detail as I fail to see what the relevance is to the alleged breaches of Feng’s duties pleaded in the SOC which all relate to his conduct leading up to the release of the BTC: see [41] above.
- [92]
[92] Drawing this all together, I am satisfied on the balance of probabilities that during the events of 26 April 2018, Feng played only a minor part. The transaction was being overseen by Andrew. The money to be used to purchase the BTC which was then going to be transferred in return for the euros was in PAM’s bank account. The decision to transfer was made by the members of the PPG group, Andrew, Yi Han and Shawn. Affairs in Nice were handled by Leonard who took instructions from Andrew. It was Leonard who oversaw the testing and counting of the Banknotes.
- [93]
[93] Feng did offer advice that Leonard should not sign anything until Stefan had verified the authenticity of the SGS receipt documents, so that the risk would pass to SGS and be covered by its insurance, and that all documents should be on SGS’s letterhead. However, he played no part in giving the confirmation that the correct authentic documents had been obtained. This fell to Stefan who was in direct contact with SGS and it was following his confirmation that the risk had passed to SGS that the BTC were released. Those BTC were never under Feng’s control and he played no part in deciding to transfer them.
The analysis
- [94]
[94] With that I can return to the Regional Group’s cause of action. The Europe Fiduciary Duties are defined in the SOC as being, in essence, duties to act in good faith and to advance the interests of the Regional Group. It was asserted that the Regional Group relied on Feng to carry out the Europe Duties and that he voluntarily undertook to carry out the Europe Duties in circumstances giving rise to a relationship of trust and confidence.
- [95]
[95] This brings one back to the duties defined in the SOC as being the Europe Duties. There are three of them which for convenience I shall repeat here:
(a) to ensure that the Regional Group BTC will not be released to the Buyers until payment was duly made;
(b) to carry out due diligence on and engage a competent and professional security firm which would verify that payment was duly made; and
(c) to procure and/or ensure the procurement of valid insurance and/or ensure that the security firm which was engaged had valid insurance, such that the Initial Defendants (acting as agents of the Regional Group) would be fully indemnified against any losses arising from the Europe Transaction.
- [96]
[96] I turn then to assess the part played by Feng in relation to those three aspects of the transaction.
- [97]
[97] As to the first, Feng never had control over the BTC and was not present in Nice. The relevant documents were assessed by Stefan who discussed the matter directly with SGS. The only part that he played was in advising what documents should be obtained.
- [98]
[98] As to the second, Feng was never asked to carry out due diligence on SGS. He was tasked with using his contacts in Europe to identify a suitable security firm. This he did by introducing Stefan who in turn selected SGS and it was Stefan who then worked with SGS. Feng acted reasonably in identifying Stefan, as a reputable Swiss banker with whom he had enjoyed a successful business relationship. Such due diligence as was done was done by Andrew.
- [99]
[99] So far as concerns insurance, the evidence is clear. Andrew never asked Feng to look into the question of insurance; it appears to have been assumed by all parties that there would be insurance and any representation that there was insurance came from Stefan and not Feng.
- [100]
[100] In my judgment the part played by Feng in relation to the three alleged duties was a minor one. Overall control over the operation was exercised, remotely by Andrew and Yi Han and on the ground in Nice by Leonard. It cannot be said that Feng had any real degree of control either over the preparations for or carrying out of the operation. He provided assistance when this was sought but decisions in relation to his input were taken by one or other of those three. Feng was not a decision maker.
Applying the facts to the law
- [101]
[101] The relevant relationship was between Feng and Andrew, acting on behalf of the Initial Defendants. At all material times no member of the Regional Group was aware of Feng’s existence or that he was to play any part in the Europe Transaction and Feng was unaware that the Regional Group had provided the funds for the Europe Transaction. As the SOC makes clear, it is alleged that Feng was engaged by the Initial Defendants to carry out the Europe Duties and that they were acting as agents for the Regional Group. If therefore the Regional Group cannot establish that Feng owed the Europe Fiduciary Duties to the Initial Defendants, then its case must fail.
- [102]
[102] Since Feng was not acting in his capacity as a solicitor, any relationship between Feng and Andrew does not fall within any of the recognised categories of fiduciary relationships. It is thus necessary to determine whether there are “the hallmarks of a fiduciary relationship” by examining all the factual circumstances so as to evaluate the specific role played by the putative fiduciary and the degree of control which he exerted: see [45]–[50] above.
- [103]
[103] The facts as I have found them are in sharp contrast with the facts in Tan Teck Kee. In Tan Teck Kee, Mr Tan voluntarily undertook a position which possessed a high degree of control over the handling of the investors' interest in the Cambodian business venture (at [78]) and the investors were particularly vulnerable to Mr Tan's exercise of power. In the present case, Feng did not possess a high degree of control over the Europe Transaction; in truth he exercised little or no control. His input, when sought, was not that of a controlling mind but of a person seeking to assist the controlling minds, Andrew and Yi Han. It was they who made the crucial decisions having evaluated the material available to them, including that provided by Feng. This was not a case where it could be said that the other participants in the Europe Transaction were particularly vulnerable to Feng’s exercise of power. Rather, this was a case where the various participants in the transaction had their own roles to play in the team, with Feng playing a relatively minor role. Decision making was left to others.
- [104]
[104] On the basis of the facts as I have found them, I have concluded that the role played by Feng in the Europe Transaction, both in assisting in the preparations and participating on the day, fall way short of constituting conduct bearing the hallmarks of a fiduciary relationship. No such relationship existed between Feng and Andrew, so it must follow that the pleaded duties were not owed to the Regional Group.
- [105]
[105] For the reasons given therefore, the Regional Group’s claim for breach of fiduciary duties must fail.
Negligence
- [106]
[106] The applicable legal principles are not in dispute and are summarised in the Plaintiffs’ Closing Statement as follows:
- [107]
[107] Under the Spandeck test, factual foreseeability is in fact a preliminary inquiry that is almost always satisfied in that it relates to factual foreseeability, which simply means that the defendant ought to have known that the claimant would suffer damage from his carelessness (Spandeck at [75]). The main substance of the question of whether a duty of care arises is addressed at the stage of proximity.
- [108]
[108] The case of negligence is pleaded in the alternative in the SOC and the claim made against Feng in relation to his capacity as a solicitor has likewise been dropped. The substance of the pleading is based on the same factual assertions with regard to the Europe Duties. It reads as follows:
- [109]
[109] In their Written Closing Statement the plaintiffs express the position with regard to factual foreseeability in the following terms:
- [110]
[110] On the facts, I accept that Feng ought to have known that if he were careless in whatever his role in the transaction was, the plaintiffs might suffer damage. Hence, factual foreseeability is satisfied. However, the requirement of proximity is not satisfied in the circumstances of this case as Feng had not undertaken the Europe Duties, and the minor part that he did play was not sufficiently proximate to the loss suffered by the plaintiffs. Hence, a duty of care did not arise such as to render him liable in negligence.
- [111]
[111] The case based in negligence cannot succeed unless Feng had undertaken the Europe Duties which I have held that he did not. The case in negligence thus also fails.
The Private Bank Acquisition
- [112]
[112] Both Micro Tellers and the Regional Group bring claims against Feng in relation to his involvement in the Private Bank Acquisition but the underlying factual matrix is somewhat different. It is thus necessary to consider their respective claims separately.
Micro Tellers’ claims
- [113]
[113] Micro Tellers claim that Feng is liable to them (a) in fraud, (b) breach of trust and/or fiduciary duties and (c) unjust enrichment.
Fraud
- [114]
[114] The applicable principles are not in dispute and are summarised as follows in the Plaintiffs’ Written Closing Statement:
- [115]
[115] The representations relied upon are representations not made directly to Micro Tellers but to Andrew said to be acting as their agent which the plaintiffs contend is sufficient in law to constitute the intention required under (b) above as is set out in the Plaintiffs’ Written Closing Statement:
- [116]
[116] The representations relied upon are set out in the SOC as follows:
- [117]
[117] By his Defence, first, Feng asserts that at all times Andrew was aware that WPS was managed by Feng and used as his personal vehicle and that he did not represent that he offered legal services through WPS. Secondly he denies that he was ever aware of the existence of either Micro Tellers or the Regional Group or that the Initial Defendants were acting as their agents. Hence he denies that any representation that he may have made to the Initial Defendants was a representation made with the intention that it should be acted on by Micro Tellers or a class of persons which includes Micro Tellers. This raises a disputed question of law as well as issues of fact.
- [118]
[118] There are two issues of fact. First, what representations were made by Feng to the Initial Defendants in relation to WPS and the WPS bank account (“the WPS Issue”). Secondly, there are a number of factors arising out of or related to the allegation that there was an agency relationship between Andrew and Micro Tellers: (a) was there an agency relationship; (b) what knowledge if any, did Feng have of this; and (c) what knowledge did Feng have (if any) of the persons who were providing funds to PAM for the purpose of the acquisition? I shall refer to this as “the Agency Issue” although it is to be remembered that the test in law for fraud is, as set out above, an intention that the false representation should be acted upon “by a class of persons which includes the plaintiff”. Proof of agency per se may not constitute the requisite intention.
Breach of trust and/or fiduciary duties
- [120]
[120] Although expressed in different language, these particulars mirror the representations relied upon in relation to the fraud claim. The underlying law on the existence and breach of trusts was not in dispute.
- [121]
[121] The area of dispute between the parties lay in (a) the factual dispute as to the alleged misappropriation of the funds held in the WPS bank account, which is the same as the WPS Issue; and (b) the correct approach to the question of the circumstances in which a trustee owes an obligation to a third party unknown to the trustee but who is alleged to be a principal for whom the actual beneficiary is acting as agent. This raises questions of both law and fact, but the factual issues are equivalent to those raised under the Agency Issue.
- [122]
[122] It is convenient therefore to make findings of fact first before considering the questions of law that arise on the facts found under the Agency Issue both in relation to the fraud claim and the claim for breach of trust.
The WPS issue
- [123]
[123] The factual assertion made by Micro Tellers is that the Initial Defendants transferred money from PAM’s bank account to the bank account in the name of WPS in the erroneous belief, induced by Feng, that:
- [124]
[124] The starting point is when Feng and Moon, who were married in May 2015, returned from their honeymoon. On his return to Walkers Singapore’s offices Feng became aware that Walkers had announced a “Major Expansion in Response to Client Demand” dated 21 May 2015. Included within this expansion was to be the launch in mid-June of a corporate and fiduciary services business under the name “Walkers Professional Services”. This document contains the name Walkers in a particular typeface together with a shield type logo:
- [125]
[125] Shortly thereafter on 15 June 2015, WPS was incorporated at Feng’s instigation naming his wife as the sole director and shareholder. On 30 June 2015, Moon signed the necessary forms to open the WPS bank accounts with her as the sole signatory.
- [126]
[126] Feng was cross-examined at length on his motives for incorporating WPS under that name when it had no association with Walkers. The thrust of his evidence was that he thought it would be funny to adopt the name and did it as a joke, but that whenever he used the company to interact with clients of Walkers that he was already acting for, he would make it clear that WPS had nothing to do with the law firm, Walkers. Dealing through WPS, he said, arose when his clients requested him to do things that he could not do in his capacity as a solicitor; he would offer to do it in his personal capacity for a fee using his personal phone number and e-mail rather than his Walkers’ phone and e-mail address. He gave the example of the provision of assistance in obtaining a visa. He accepted that he never told his employer, Walkers, that he was carrying out services for Walker’s clients and receiving fees from them in his private capacity trading under the WPS name. He never sought to clarify the position with the partners of Walkers because he considered they would be grateful to him for solving problems for their clients which would lead to further business for Walkers.
- [127]
[127] There is however no evidence as to whether WPS was involved in any of Feng’s private dealings between June 2015 and February 2018 when Feng met Andrew. Far less is there any evidence demonstrating that Feng did act towards any client of Walkers in the manner indicated by him so as to leave that client in no doubt that the services provided by WPS were not provided under the auspices of Walkers.
- [128]
[128] Indeed, there is, to my mind, a significant illogicality in naming a company with a name that incorporates the name of your employer in circumstances where you accept that the first thing that you must do is to distinguish the company from your employer or as having any association with your employer. It does not make sense.
- [130]
[130] The plaintiffs contend that this was the belief held by Andrew when the Initial Defendants started exploring business opportunities with Feng. Reliance is placed on contemporaneous documentary evidence as to how Feng explained the services that WPS could offer to Andrew and PAM at this time.
- [131]
[131] The first document (in time) is a WhatsApp exchange between Yi Han and Charles which it is agreed contains no date but is accepted to have been on 3 March 2018 when Micro Tellers and the Initial Defendants were considering certain BTC deals. Charles asserts that Yi Han told him “that the monies meant for the Private Bank Acquisition … would be held by Walkers Professional Services, which was owned and controlled by the law firm known as Walkers”.
- [132]
[132] This cannot be correct as on its face since the WhatsApp exchange relates to the purchase and sale of cryptocurrency and the opportunity to acquire a private bank was not first considered until April 2018. However, the contents of the exchange are nonetheless revealing:
- [133]
[133] Whilst this exchange does not refer to WPS, it is consistent with Feng and the Initial Defendants having formed a working relationship whereby funds would be held in escrow by Walkers.
- [134]
[134] The next document takes the form of a WhatsApp exchange between Andrew and Feng on 9 March 2018. It is a long extract but, in the light of Feng’s explanation as to how he would make it clear that WPS had nothing to do with the law firm Walkers, it is necessary to set it out in full:
- [135]
[135] It is plain from the language used that Andrew was seeking access to US$ Singapore bank accounts that could provide “escrow” services for the purpose of a proposed business activity and that Feng was representing that the services he offered were provided and authorised by his employer. This is demonstrated by the extract at timestamp 14:47 (“will speak internally”) and at 14:52 (“I have one off clearance to facilitate this for you”). Yet the bank account named is WPS’s US$ account and not an account controlled by Walkers which is not the impression created by the words used by Feng. These words are consistent, and only so, with Feng having obtained authority to provide the service. This was wholly unnecessary if WPS had nothing to do with Walkers and was controlled by him. This therefore contradicts any suggestion that Feng would have made it clear to Andrew that WPS had nothing to do with Walkers.
- [136]
[136] Andrew gave evidence that on the basis of this exchange he “believed that WPS was owned and controlled by Walkers, and was used by Walkers to provide escrow services for Walkers’ clients”.
- [137]
[137] This evidence was challenged on the basis that Feng had made it clear to Andrew before 17 February 2018 that Walkers “does not do escrow for btc (bitcoin)” as he relayed this information to Yi Han and Shawn in a WhatsApp exchange on that date:
- [138]
[138] Later, following the exchanges on 9 March 2018, on 19 March 2018 there was a further WhatsApp exchange between Andrew, Yi Han and Shawn which reads as follows:
- [139]
[139] In cross-examination, Andrew explained that as he understood it the concern about dealing in BTC was a concern of Walkers’ insurers, and that subsequently Feng had indicated to him that Walkers was doing this as a special arrangement with PAM which had resulted in other parties wishing to do the same, which upset Walkers.
- [140]
[140] Feng was in turn cross-examined on these documents. Much of this focused on the words “internal clearance” in the WhatsApp exchange of 9 March 2018 which Feng sought to suggest was his own internal clearance because he preferred to provide banking facilities through one of his other personal companies. As counsel for the plaintiffs pointed out it would have been easier to say that he had decided to facilitate this through WPS rather than that he had obtained clearance to do this.
- [141]
[141] I found this to be an unedifying aspect of Feng’s evidence. I prefer to place weight on the language actually used in the contemporaneous documents. To my mind, the words “internal clearance” coupled with the identification of the bank as being “Walkers Professional Services” is susceptible of only one understanding, namely, that Walkers had agreed for one of its bank accounts to be used for the proposed transaction.
- [142]
[142] Contemporaneously, steps were being taken for Terms of Engagement to be agreed between Walkers and PAM to provide Cayman legal advice and other professional services. The draft Terms of Engagement were headed with the name Walkers in the same typeface and shield type logo as in the document referred to in [124] above.
- [143]
[143] It was following this, in April 2018, that the question of purchasing a private bank arose. The bank in question was Alexandria Bancorp Ltd (“Alexandria Bank”), a company established in the Cayman Islands. According to Andrew the purpose of doing so was to obtain a cryptocurrency-friendly bank holding a banking licence to facilitate cryptocurrency transactions. Feng indicated that whilst he would be providing legal advice to PAM in his capacity as a consultant at Walkers, he also wished to invest funds in the purchase in his personal capacity. The legal advice was to be provided pursuant to the Terms of Engagement.
- [144]
[144] It will be necessary to consider the manner in which this proposed purchase progressed in more detail below but for present purposes it is sufficient to record that in preparation for the purchase, sums of money amounting to US$5,268,000 and S$1,223,000 were transferred from the PAM bank account to WPS’s bank account between April and November 2018. These sums included the money claimed in this action by both Micro Tellers and the Regional Group.
- [145]
[145] During the course of the dealings between the Initial Defendants and Feng over the proposed purchase, a number of documents and WhatsApp exchanges are relied upon by the plaintiffs as reinforcing Andrew’s belief that WPS was owned and controlled by Walkers. I shall refer first to two documents whose authenticity is challenged.
- [146]
[146] The first is an invoice issued bearing the Walkers’ name and logo dated 22 June 2018 which is reproduced below:
- [147]
[147] On its face this document purports to be an invoice issued by Walkers, the law firm, but seeking payment into the WPS bank account. The authenticity of this document is challenged by Feng.
- [148]
[148] The second is a summary of PAM assets (“The Account – Client Summary”) held as of 23 October 2018 which is reproduced below:
- [149]
[149] As can be seen, again, this uses the same Walkers’ typescript and logo but refers to money held in the WPS account. The authenticity of this document is also challenged by Feng,
- [150]
[150] As to the first, Feng challenged the authenticity of the invoice when it was first produced on discovery. In response Andrew produced photographs from his mobile phone showing that he received the invoice on 25 June 2018. Due to the fact that his phone had been impounded by the Singapore authorities as part of the criminal investigations involving Feng, the photographs were provided by the authorities. In cross-examination, Andrew explained the process by which he obtained the documents from the Singapore authorities and drew attention to Exhibit AL-10 showing an extract resembling the heading on the invoice and later a blurred image of the invoice. This material satisfies me, on the balance of probabilities, that the invoice is an authentic document which was sent to Andrew on 25 June 2018.
- [151]
[151] So far as concerns the Account – Client Summary, this was first referred to in Andrew’s first AEIC which was sworn on 21 May 2021 and it featured prominently at the trial of Suit 8. It was not suggested at that trial that the document was a forgery. No evidence was adduced in Feng’s witness statements in this action, sworn on 24 May 2021 and 4 June 2021, purporting to show that it was a forgery. No suggestion was made in Feng’s Written Submissions before trial that the document was a forgery and no further written evidence was sought to be adduced by Feng in support of a contention that the document was a forgery.
- [152]
[152] However, when Feng was cross-examining Andrew, he sought, in effect, to introduce evidence directed to demonstrating that the document was a combination of a number of underlying documents and not, of itself, a single genuine document. He sought to do this by an analysis of the metadata underlying the document.
- [153]
[153] Counsel for the plaintiffs objected to this course both on the ground that he had been taken by surprise by the late attempt to introduce this evidence and by the fact that, if it were to be given, it would constitute expert evidence which Feng was not qualified to give. The matter was ventilated fully at the end of day two of the trial and again at the beginning of day three. At the end of those submissions I informed parties that I was not going to allow cross-examination in relation to the metadata underlying the document and indicated that I would give my reasons in this judgment.
- [154]
[154] These are my reasons. Whilst I am deeply conscious of the fact that the burden falling on Feng as a litigant-in-person is a heavy one which was not made any easier by the concurrent criminal investigations, nonetheless he is a qualified lawyer who has been deeply immersed in these proceedings for many years. He claims that the first time he obtained the evidence necessary to demonstrate the forgery was in December 2022. This may be so, but it does not alter the fact that he must have known that it was not a genuine document when he first saw it disclosed on discovery. He must have appreciated during the trial of Suit 8 the importance that the plaintiffs in that action were placing on that document as supporting the assertion that Feng had falsely represented that WPS was part of Walkers. Yet he said nothing. Having seen the Judgment in Suit 8 which placed weight on the contents of the document, again he said and did nothing. He did not seek to adduce further evidence of fact nor seek leave to adduce expert evidence in this action. I am satisfied that if the matter were to be fully investigated, this would require an adjournment to allow further evidence, probably expert evidence, to be adduced. In circumstances where Feng could and, in my judgment, should have drawn the court’s attention to his contention that a document was a forgery at an early stage, even if at that stage he did not have the means of proof, I consider that it would be wrong in the overall interests of justice to prolong these proceedings further by an adjournment.
- [155]
[155] Following this, Feng continued his cross-examination on the document seeking to have Andrew agree that the document was in some respects inaccurate and to suggest that the inaccuracies were due to manipulation of the data by Andrew. However, this was directed to the figures in the document and not to the fact that it bore the Walkers’ name and logo and referred to an escrow account when it was common ground that the only sums held on behalf of PAM were held in the WPS account. When Feng was cross-examined on this, he maintained that the document was not a genuine document but accepted that he would have sent something similar to the document and that he had a template on his phone with the Walkers name and logo. More specifically in answer to questions from the court, he said this:
- [156]
[156] Accordingly, I can proceed on the basis that a document was sent similar to the Account – Client Summary document with the Walkers name and logo, possibly with the word escrow somewhere on it. Feng sought to suggest that the use of the Walkers’ name and logo was a joke between Andrew and him. This was never put to Andrew and runs contrary to the contemporaneous documents. I do not accept, on the balance of probabilities, that Andrew was aware of the fact that Feng misused the Walkers’ name and logo in the course of his private business.
- [157]
[157] To the contrary, I accept Micro Tellers’ submission that these documents served to reinforce in Andrew’s mind that WPS was a company associated with and controlled by Walkers solicitors.
- [158]
[158] The next relevant document is a WhatsApp exchange between Feng and Andrew dated 11 August 2018. In this exchange Andrew asks Feng to prepare a letter to Blue Summit (a corporate vehicle to be used by Micro Tellers to hold its share in the Private Bank once acquired) calling for the remaining funds to be transferred “into walkers trust account for imminent completion … ” [emphasis added] (“the Call for Funds Letter”). Feng responded by saying that he understood “the need to hold the funds on account till completion” [emphasis added]. Andrew then emphasised that “most impt is call for funds to walkers trust acc” and Feng undertook to have the letter on the “firm letterhead” [emphasis added].
- [159]
[159] Feng sought to suggest that this interchange was understood by both parties as being a document for internal use to placate Yi Han’s uncle to satisfy him to provide funds to PAM and that this was consistent with Feng’s understanding that PAM represented a family office.
- [160]
[160] Whilst it may well be that this was a purpose of having the Letter drafted on Walkers’ letterhead, it is clear from the text that the Letter was also to be sent to Blue Summit and expressly referred to the “Walkers trust account” on two occasions. The only natural understanding that flows from this is that Feng was acting in his capacity as a solicitor employed by Walkers and that the account in which the funds were to be held was a trust account controlled by Walkers.
- [161]
[161] The next document I should refer to is a Shareholders Agreement dated 8 October 2018 between Micro Tellers and Blue Summit Investments Ltd. Cl 2.1 reads as follows:
- [162]
[162] It is thus apparent that Micro Tellers were content to use the WPS bank account to hold the sums “on trust” pending the successful completion of the purchase of the offshore bank. It is a proper inference from this that Micro Tellers were working on the basis that the WPS bank account was controlled by Walkers, a regulated firm of solicitors used to handling client money. This is confirmed by a WhatsApp exchange between Yi Han and Charles on 4 October 2018:
- [163]
[163] I do not propose to refer to all the WhatsApp exchanges which the plaintiffs claim further reinforces this understanding. It is sufficient to quote from the Plaintiffs’ Closing Statement:
- [164]
[164] Feng sought to suggest that the reference to the word “accounts” was merely an attempt by him to make it appear that the size and scope of WPS’s operation was larger than it was. I do not accept this. The plain and ordinary meaning of the word “accounts” as used in the exchanges is consistent and only consistent with being a reference to the accounts department of Walkers.
- [165]
[165] The primary evidence relied upon by Feng as demonstrating that at all times Andrew was aware that WPS was Feng’s personal vehicle and that he was never under the impression that it was associated with Walkers lies in a Statutory Declaration sworn by Andrew in mid-June 2019. This is dealt with in Andrew’s first AEIC. In summary, Andrew accepts that he swore the declaration at Feng’s request on the basis that it would buy time to get the funds to repay the plaintiffs. Having signed it he was troubled about the fact that it was not true and took legal advice. As a result, he asked Feng to destroy the Declaration and Feng confirmed by a WhatsApp chat instruction to his solicitors to do so.
- [166]
[166] This evidence was not materially challenged in cross-examination and I accept it.
- [167]
[167] Although the initial proposal was to purchase Alexandria Bank, as matters turned out the Initial Defendants then turned their attention instead to seek to buy a Curacao bank, Banco Provincial and/or a bank in the Union of Comoros, Freelance Bank. Whilst Micro Tellers was aware of the change to the Curacao bank, it was unaware of the possibility of purchasing Freelance Bank. In the event it appears that only Freelance Bank was purchased for significantly less than the funds that had been deposited in the WPS account. Andrew thereafter sought a refund of the surplus sums in December 2018.
- [168]
[168] It is not necessary to follow the course of events between December 2018 and June 2019 during which Feng was requested to make the refund and failed to do so which led to the Initial Defendants commencing Suit 8 on 2 July 2019.
(1) Conclusion in relation to the WPS issue
- [170]
[170] Referring back to [116] above, I therefore find that that the Initial Defendants transferred money from PAM’s bank account to the WPS account in the erroneous belief, induced by Feng, that:
- [171]
[171] These remaining funds deposited in the WPS account included the sums claimed by both Micro Tellers and the Regional Group in this action.
The Agency Issue
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.