Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 11 Oct 2019
Contents

High Court

Aljunied-Hougang Town Council and another v Lim Swee Lian Sylvia and others and another suit

Feedback & support

[2019] SGHC 241Case no. Suit Nos 668 and 716 of 2017

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] This is a case involving claims brought by Aljunied-Hougang Town Council (“AHTC”) and Pasir Ris-Punggol Town Council (“PRPTC”) against several current and former town councillors, as well as officers of the Town Councils and business entities controlled by them, on the basis that they had breached fiduciary duties, duties of skill and care, and/or statutory duties in their management of the Town Councils’ affairs.

  3. [3] A vast number of breaches and reliefs have been pleaded – in some instances with no clear link drawn between the two – giving rise to both factual and legal issues of significant complexity and adding in no small part to the length of this judgment. As will be evident to the reader, analysing these issues has been akin to battling the Lernaean hydra (as Edelman J aptly put it in Agricultural Land Management Ltd v Jackson (No 2) (2014) 285 FLR 121 (“Agricultural Land Management”) at [7]), with each step of the analysis on one issue spawning several related and inter-connected issues. As such, a table of contents would be helpful to the reader in navigating this judgment, which is set out here:

  4. Background facts

  5. Dramatis personae

  6. The plaintiffs in Suit Nos 668 and 716

  7. [4] The plaintiff in Suit No 668 of 2017 (“S 668/2017”), AHTC, is a body corporate incorporated in Singapore pursuant to the Town Councils Act (Cap 329A, 2000 Rev Ed) (“TCA”). It should be noted that a number of amendments have been made to the TCA since the occurrence of the events in this case, and the version in force at the time of writing incorporates amendments made by way of Acts 17 and 34 of 2017. The version of the TCA relied upon by the parties is the version in force prior to these amendments, ie, the version in force from 15 August 2005 to 1 May 2017. In the context of this judgment, references to provisions of the TCA, unless otherwise specified, refer to provisions which are common between the TCA as it existed at the relevant time and the TCA at present. The same applies to references to the Town Council Financial Rules (Cap 329A, R 1, 1998 Rev Ed) (“TCFR”).

  8. [8] As a result of the foregoing, the Town Council that is the subject of the present suits was known by different names at different points of time:

  9. In this judgment, except where greater specificity is required, the Town Council shall be referred to consistently as AHTC for the sake of simplicity. For the purposes of identifying the plaintiffs when discussing the positions taken and submissions advanced by them in the present suits, I will refer to them as “the plaintiffs” collectively, or as “AHTC” and “PRPTC” respectively where there is a material difference in their respective positions. In the remainder of this judgment, I will use the term “Town Council” to refer generally to town councils constituted under the TCA.

  10. The defendants in Suit Nos 668 and 716

  11. [9] The first defendant in both suits is Ms Sylvia Lim. From June 2011 to August 2015, she was Chairman of AHTC, and from October 2015 to present she was and continues to be Vice-Chairman of AHTC.

  12. [10] The second defendant is Mr Low Thia Khiang, who was the elected Member of Parliament (“MP”) for the electoral division of Hougang SMC from 1991 to 2011, prior to the 2011 GE. He was Vice-Chairman of AHTC from 3 June 2011 to August 2012.

  13. [11] The third defendant is Mr Pritam Singh, who was also an elected MP of AHTC, as well as Vice-Chairman of AHTC from August 2012 to August 2015, and thereafter Chairman of AHTC from October 2015 to present.

  14. [12] Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang and Mr Pritam Singh, along with Mr Chen Show Mao and Mr Muhamad Faisal bin Abdul Manap (“Mr Muhamad Faisal”), formed the slate of WP candidates elected as MPs for Aljunied GRC at the 2011 GE. Following the merger of ATC and HTC to form AHTC, Mr Yaw Shin Leong also formed part of the group of WP members elected to manage AHTC as town councillors. Mr Yaw Shin Leong was replaced by Mr Png Eng Huat of the WP following a by-election for Hougang SMC held on 26 May 2012. References to the elected MPs in the rest of this judgment thus refer to the MPs who were elected to manage AHTC at the relevant time, although of these elected MPs, only Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang and Mr Pritam Singh are defendants to the present suits.

  15. [13] The fourth and fifth defendants are Mr Chua Zhi Hon (“Mr David Chua”) and Mr Kenneth Foo Seck Guan (“Mr Kenneth Foo”), who were appointed as town councillors to manage AHTC.

  16. [14] Under the TCA, the elected MPs of a Town Council are known as its “elected members” (s 2(1) TCA). Thus, MPs automatically become members of the Town Council without the need for separate appointment. One of the elected MPs (if there is more than one) is appointed Chairman of the Town Council under s 9(1) TCA. The Chairman of the Town Council then appoints other, non-elected, members under s 8(1)(b) TCA. These members are known as its “appointed members” (s 2(1) TCA). The Town Council consists of the elected and appointed members (s 8(1) TCA). The members of the Town Council are commonly known as “town councillors”, which is a term I will also use in this judgment to refer to both the elected and appointed members.

  17. [15] From June 2012, Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Pritam Singh, Mr David Chua and Mr Kenneth Foo were part of the Tenders and Contracts Committee (“the Tender Committee”) following a Town Council meeting on 14 June 2012. Mr Pritam Singh was the Chairman of the Tender Committee. The Tender Committee was responsible for vetting specifications of tenders called by AHTC, evaluating tenders received and deciding on the award of tenders.

  18. [16] The sixth defendant is Ms How Weng Fan, who was married to Mr Danny Loh Chong Meng (“Mr Danny Loh”), and is a personal representative of Mr Danny Loh’s estate, the seventh defendant. Mr Danny Loh was Secretary of AHTC from 1 August 2011 to 31 May 2015, whereas Ms How Weng Fan was Deputy Secretary from 9 June 2011 to 14 July 2015. Ms How Weng Fan was also the General Manager from 1 August 2011 to 14 July 2015. Ms How Weng Fan was also Estate Manager/General Manager/Secretary of HTC from 1991 to 2011, before the 2011 GE. Further, Mr Danny Loh was the sole proprietor of FM Solutions and Integrated Services (“FMSI”). Mr Danny Loh passed away on 27 June 2015. However, for the purposes of identification and attribution, my references to “Mr Danny Loh” include references to his estate when it comes to the positions taken in the present proceedings, as well as on the issue of liability.

  19. [17] The eighth defendant is FM Solutions and Services Pte Ltd (“FMSS”). FMSS was incorporated in Singapore on 15 May 2011 with Mr Danny Loh as the initial sole director and sole shareholder. Ms How Weng Fan was appointed a director of FMSS on 16 June 2011. The next day, on 17 June 2011, new shareholders of FMSS were introduced, namely Ms How Weng Fan, Mr Yeo Soon Fei, Mr Vincent Koh and Mr Chng Jong Ling. Under the new shareholding structure, Mr Danny Loh and Ms How Weng Fan held 50% and 20% of the shares in FMSS respectively, whereas the remaining three shareholders each held 10% of the shares in FMSS.

  20. [18] Between 15 July 2011 and 14 July 2015, FMSS provided managing agent (“MA”) and project management services to AHTC. Further, between 1 October 2011 and 30 June 2015, FMSS also provided emergency maintenance services under the Essential Maintenance Service Unit (commonly known as “EMSU services”). Thus, between 15 July 2011 and 30 June 2015, the following four contracts for these services, which are at the core of the claims in this case, were in place between FMSS and AHTC:

  21. Apart from the four contracts above, Mr Danny Loh, through his sole proprietorship FMSI, also provided EMSU services to HTC, and later AHTC, from 15 October 2007 to 14 October 2012, pursuant to a separate EMSU contract (“the FMSI EMSU contract”). The FMSI EMSU contract was entered into by the former HTC prior to the 2011 GE, and later migrated to AHTC following the amalgamation of HTC and ATC. Following the migration, the services rendered pursuant to the FMSI EMSU contract were for the Hougang residents of AHTC.

  22. [19] Prior to the engagement of FMSS, MA services for ATC and subsequently AHTC were provided by CPG Facilities Management Pte Ltd (“CPG”) pursuant to a contract that was set to expire in July 2013 (“the CPG MA contract”), with an option to extend for a further three years. EMSU services for AHTC, excluding the estates covered by the FMSI EMSU contract, were provided by CPG, with the exception of the Kaki Bukit precinct. The EMSU services for that precinct were provided by EM Services Pte Ltd (“EM Services”). Both CPG and EM Services’ contracts for EMSU services were to expire on 30 September 2011. CPG’s key representative to AHTC was Mr Jeffrey Chua, who also served as General Manager of AHTC from May 2011 to August 2011 and Secretary of AHTC from June 2011 to July 2011.

  23. Circumstances leading to the present suits

  24. [20] On 10 February 2014, AHTC submitted its audited financial statements for the financial year ending 31 March 2013. The auditor’s report prepared by Foo Kon Tan Grant Thornton LLP contained a disclaimer of opinion based on 13 grounds of qualification.

  25. [21] On 19 February 2014, the Deputy Prime Minister, upon the request of the Minister for National Development, exercised his powers under s 4(4) of the Audit Act (Cap 17, 1999 Rev Ed) and directed the Auditor-General to undertake an audit of AHTC’s financial statements. The Auditor-General in turn appointed PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (“PwC”) to undertake an audit of selected aspects of the financial statements on behalf of and acting under the authority of the Auditor-General. The Auditor-General’s Office (“AGO”) issued its final report incorporating the findings of PwC on 9 February 2015 (“the Auditor-General’s Report”), following which the Ministry of National Development (“MND”) commenced proceedings in Originating Summons No 250 of 2015 against AHTC for, inter alia, the appointment of independent accountants.

  26. Undisputed facts and key documents

  27. Correspondence after the 2011 GE up to 30 May 2011

  28. [26] Shortly after the results of the 2011 GE, the MND notified all newly elected MPs of all constituencies by a letter dated 9 May 2011 that the TCA required the formation of Towns on the expiration of 14 days after the publication of the 2011 GE results. The recipients were also informed that after the relevant orders for the declaration and dissolution of Towns were gazetted, the reconstituted Town Councils would assume responsibility for the new areas under their charge with effect from 1 August 2011.

  29. [27] On the same day, Mr Low Thia Khiang sent the following email to the elected MPs (“the 9 May 2011 Email”), copying Ms How Weng Fan in the same email:

  30. [28] It would appear that sometime before 12 May 2011, Mr Low Thia Khiang had a discussion with Ms How Weng Fan concerning the setting up of a company to provide MA services. As a result, on 12 May 2011, Mr Danny Loh applied to ACRA for the company name “FMSS” to be registered.

  31. [29] On 13 May 2011, Mr Low Thia Khiang received an email from a WP supporter by the name of Mr TT Tan who said that according to his source, “it is quite apparent that [CPG] will be withdrawing from ATC”. Mr TT Tan advised Mr Low Thia Khiang to procure the CPG MA contract and seek legal advice on the same, and also to “start employing or ask for tender now”. This email was forwarded by Mr Low Thia Khiang to Ms How Weng Fan, and subsequently to the elected MPs.

  32. [30] Also on 13 May 2011, on Mr Low Thia Khiang’s instructions, Ms How Weng Fan sent a letter to Mr Jeffrey Chua and Ms Png Chiew Hoon, Secretary of Marine Parade Town Council, with the title “Request for Transfer of Documents and Data” (“the 13 May 2011 Letter”). The letter was signed by Ms How Weng Fan as Secretary of HTC. The relevant portions of the 13 May 2011 Letter read as follows:

  33. Based on a list attached to the 13 May 2011 Letter, Ms How Weng Fan asked for, inter alia, the CPG MA contract.

  34. [31] On the very next day, on 14 May 2011, following a query from a Straits Times reporter on whether the elected MPs would “take on all the existing agreements” including the MA agreement with CPG, Mr Low Thia Khiang sent the following email to Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Pritam Singh, Mr Muhamad Faisal and Mr Chen Show Mao, which was later forwarded to Ms How Weng Fan (“the 14 May 2011 Email”):

  35. [32] On 15 May 2011, following approval by ACRA of his application on 12 May 2011, Mr Danny Loh incorporated FMSS with an issued share capital of $500,000 and a paid-up capital of $450,000. He was the sole shareholder and director.

  36. [33] On 16 May 2011, Mr Jeffrey Chua replied to the 13 May 2011 Letter, informing Ms How Weng Fan that CPG was in the midst of compiling the list of existing term contracts requested, and would hand over the documents progressively. In the same email, Mr Jeffrey Chua drew attention to the fact that the existing EMSU contracts with CPG and EM Services were due to expire on 30 September 2011, and attached the EMSU contracts with the hope that this information would facilitate Ms How Weng Fan to “make advance preparation to call tenders for new term contracts accordingly”. Mr Jeffrey Chua did not attach the CPG MA contract to the 16 May 2011 email, and it was not sent to the defendants until 13 June 2011 (see [43] below). In response to Ms How Weng Fan’s request for the contact details of the ATC staff so that they could be considered for employment, Mr Jeffrey Chua informed her that CPG was “able to redeploy them to other alternative postings”.

  37. [34] On 19 May 2011, following a short exchange on possible conflicts of interest that might arise from appointing a representative of a MA to the post of General Manager or Secretary of the Town Council, Mr Low Thia Khiang sent the following email to Ms How Weng Fan:

  38. [35] On 26 May 2011, Mr Low Thia Khiang sent the following email to the elected MPs, copying Ms How Weng Fan. The subject of the email was “Meeting with [ATC] Managing Agent”:

  39. [36] On 28 May 2011, Mr Low Thia Khiang sent a short email to Ms How Weng Fan, stating that “AHTC MA should employ All the existing staff of [HTC], at least for a start”. The next day, on 29 May 2011, Ms Sylvia Lim sent an email to the elected MPs to provide “an update of what has happened and will need to be done”. She informed them that the “existing Managing Agent of [ATC], CPG, will report to us until we release them at such date not later than 1 Aug”, and that “Jeffrey Chua of CPG will continue [as Secretary of TC] until we release him”, and that “[we] will appoint our Secretary when our MA is ready to take over”.

  40. Meeting with CPG on 30 May 2011

  41. [37] On 30 May 2011, the meeting referred to at [35] above took place between the elected MPs, Ms How Weng Fan and representatives from CPG, comprising Mr Jeffrey Chua, his personal assistant Ms Pan Wanjing, and the Deputy General Manager of ATC Mr Seng Joo How. At this meeting, the CPG representatives, using presentation slides, gave an overview of the properties under AHTC’s management, the organisational structure of AHTC, handing over preparations and interim management arrangements. These presentation slides indicated 27 May to 31 July 2011 as the “care taking period”, and 1 August 2011 as the “appointed date for handover”. Ms Sylvia Lim took handwritten notes during this meeting, the contents of which largely mirrored that of the presentation slides. Significantly, at the corner of the last page of these handwritten notes, she noted a reference to FMSS.

  42. Presentation by FMSS on 2 June 2011

  43. [38] On 2 June 2011, Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang and Mr Muhamad Faisal met with Mr Danny Loh. Mr Danny Loh made a presentation on behalf of FMSS in relation to the award of the MA contract and the EMSU contract for AHTC. In this presentation, the following was set out as the “Fee Proposal”:

  44. The presentation slides also set out the following “action plan”:

  45. The presentation slides also contained an “Additional Proposal on EMSU” in the following terms:

  46. [39] Also on 2 June 2011, Ms How Weng Fan sent an email to the elected MPs stating that “1 August 2011 handover has never been an issue as this handover refers to TC to TC handover and is mandated by MND”. She further stated that “[with] CPG we have always maintained that there is the possibility that we may require them to continue their service until such time that we deem that all matters are properly handed over to the new MA. Indicative period is by a month ie up to 30 September 2011.”

  47. The first Town Council meeting on 9 June 2011

  48. [40] On 9 June 2011, the first Town Council meeting of the newly reconstituted AHTC was held, and it was attended by, inter alios, all the elected MPs, Ms How Weng Fan, Mr David Chua, Mr Kenneth Foo, Mr Jeffrey Chua, Mr Seng Joo How and Ms Pan Wanjing. The minutes of the meeting reflected that the following was discussed:

  49. Notably, there was no discussion of any award of contracts for MA services EMSU services to FMSS, even though the presentation slides for the 2 June 2011 meeting contained a proposal for FMSS to take over the provision of both services.

  50. Correspondence with AIM regarding TCMS

  51. [41] After the first Town Council meeting, several emails were exchanged regarding the status of the contract between ATC and NCS Pte Ltd (“NCS”) which had been novated to Action Information Management Pte Ltd (“AIM”). The contract (“the AIM contract”) licensed the use of a computer software, described as the Town Council Management System (“TCMS”), owned by AIM to ATC. TCMS was used to operate and manage ATC’s financial system. Ms How Weng Fan sent an email to Ms Sylvia Lim on 9 June 2011, attaching the novation agreement between NCS, AIM and ATC, informing her that since the AIM contract expired in October 2011, “this talk by CPG that NCS will pull out by end July 2011 seems misplaced”, and that AHTC “should therefore not be pressured into rushing into the completion of [its] computer system by 31 July 2011”.

  52. [42] The next day, 10 June 2011, Ms How Weng Fan sent another email to Ms Sylvia Lim, informing her that she had spoken to one Mr Sasidharan of AIM to request use of TCMS until 31 August 2011. Ms How Weng Fan relayed that Mr Sasidharan, who “sounded very nice and helpful”, informed her that AIM would give notice of termination of the AIM contract, but that AHTC could put in a request for extension of AIM’s services before it was received. This request was duly sent to AIM by Mr Jeffrey Chua on the same day. On 24 June 2011, AIM accepted the request for extension until 31 August 2011. In the meantime, on 23 June 2011, Ms How Weng Fan obtained approval from Ms Sylvia Lim to waive the need for quotations before procuring computer services and equipment, on the basis that the “Secretary of [ATC] had advised that AIMs will terminate the provision of the computer systems to the newly established [AHTC] by 31 July 2011”, and that such waiver of quotation was necessary “[i]n view of the urgency to set up the computer system”.

  53. Events in between the first and second Town Council meetings

  54. [43] On 13 June 2011, Mr Jeffrey Chua emailed Ms How Weng Fan a further response to the 13 May 2011 Letter, attaching this time a list of further agreements including the CPG MA contract, which he informed could be obtained from the AHTC office. This would appear to be the first time Ms How Weng Fan, or for that matter, any of the defendants was given the opportunity to view the CPG MA contract. There was no evidence before me of any further attempts to procure the CPG MA contract in the interim between the 13 May 2011 Letter and Mr Jeffrey Chua’s response on 13 June 2011.

  55. [44] On 15 June 2011, a letter of intent was sent by FMSS to Ms Sylvia Lim (“the FMSS LOI”), stating as follows:

  56. Notably, the terms in the FMSS LOI broadly tracked the proposed terms set out in the presentation made by Mr Danny Loh on 2 June 2011, save that there was no reference to the “Additional Proposal on EMSU” services.

  57. [45] As stated at [17] above, Ms How Weng Fan, Mr Vincent Koh and Mr Yeo Soon Fei became shareholders of FMSS two days after the FMSS LOI was sent, ie, on 17 June 2011.

  58. [46] Before the FMSS LOI was signed, Ms Sylvia Lim emailed a copy of the same to the elected MPs on 6 July 2011, informing them that “the rates quoted are similar to the ones CPG is using for [ATC] for its [second year] of service”, and that she intended to sign the FMSS LOI by 8 July 2011 after seeking a clarification on the project management rates.

  59. [47] Ms Sylvia Lim emailed the request for clarification to Ms How Weng Fan on the same day, followed by the further email below a short while later:

  60. Ms How Weng Fan replied to this email on the same day, saying that as there was the FMSS LOI, “the formal appointment can be made any time after 1 August 2011”.

  61. [48] The FMSS LOI was signed on behalf of AHTC by Ms Sylvia Lim on 8 July 2011 and Mr Yaw Shin Leong on 18 July 2011, appointing FMSS as the MA of AHTC for a period of one year. This was the basis of the first MA contract.

  62. [49] On 13 and 14 July 2011, a series of emails were exchanged between Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang, Mr Yaw Shin Leong and Ms How Weng Fan on the subject of postponement of the date for the second Town Council meeting, originally scheduled for 21 July 2011. This began with the following email from Ms Sylvia Lim on 13 July 2011:

  63. [50] Mr Yaw Shin Leong replied to this email on the same day, expressing his view that “we should be rather transparent” and that “[s]ince we have nothing to hide, Jeffrey’s presence should not be a hindrance for the council to deliberate + to decide the appointment of FM Solutions & Services”. Mr Yaw Shin Leong added that based on his interactions with Mr Jeffrey Chua thus far, he “has found him to be a reasonable and responsible person”. However, Mr Low Thia Khiang took a different view, and sent out the following email on 13 July 2011:

  64. [51] Ms Sylvia Lim then replied to everyone in the email chain on 14 July 2011, agreeing to “release Jeffrey as secretary and appoint Danny on 1 Aug” and to “have AHTC meeting ASAP after 1 Aug i.e. on 4 Aug, to appoint the MA”. There was also a query as to who should write up a report on the assessment of and the decision to appoint FMSS, to which Mr Low Thia Khiang replied that “Danny can provide the draft report and assessment under your instruction”.

  65. [52] Further to this correspondence, Ms Sylvia Lim then prepared a draft report to be tabled at the second Town Council meeting in her name, which was sent by her to Mr Low Thia Khiang and Mr Yaw Shin Leong via email on 3 August 2011 (“the Report on MA appointment”). This report was a revised version of a draft report prepared by Mr Danny Loh. This email was also copied to Mr Danny Loh and Ms How Weng Fan, with the message “cc Danny and Ms How Weng Fan – fyi and any comments on whether it will pass the auditors’ eyes – esp re waiver of tender” [emphasis added]. The material portions of the Report on MA appointment read as follows:

  66. [53] Subsequently, Mr Yaw Shin Leong raised a query on whether there was “a need to disclose to fellow town councilors [sic] regarding the husband & wife relationship of Danny & Ms How”, to which Mr Low Thia Khiang replied that most councillors “know both of them but no harm to mention it at the meeting”. Mr Yaw Shin Leong followed up with a further query on whether there was “a need to reveal the exact *stakeholdership(s) [sic] of [FMSS] in the TC minutes/report”, to which Ms Sylvia Lim replied that “we can / should enclose the ACRA search....let me arrange”.

  67. The second Town Council meeting on 4 August 2011

  68. [54] The second Town Council meeting took place on 4 August 2011, and was attended by the elected MPs with the exception of Mr Muhamad Faisal. Mr Kenneth Foo was present at this meeting, but not Mr David Chua. No representatives from CPG were present, but Mr Danny Loh and Ms How Weng Fan were in attendance and were noted to be representing FMSS. The minutes of meeting recorded that Mr Danny Loh presented FMSS’s MA proposal to all present, after which Mr Danny Loh and Ms How Weng Fan were excused from the meeting to facilitate the discussion by the town councillors. Following the discussion, Mr Danny Loh and Ms How Weng Fan were invited back into the meeting, and “informed of AHTC’s decisions” awarding the first MA contract to FMSS, in response to which “Mr Danny Loh accorded his appreciation for the award”. The minutes also recorded Mr Danny Loh’s declaration that he was the Managing Director and Ms How Weng Fan a director and the General Manager of FMSS. The minutes of the discussion which took place in the absence of Mr Danny Loh and Ms How Weng Fan largely mirrored the contents of the Report on MA appointment, and also recorded the fact that AHTC unanimously agreed to waive the calling of a tender for MA services for one year and to appoint FMSS as MA for the same period. There was no record of any discussion on the contract for the provision of EMSU services.

  69. Events following the second Town Council meeting

  70. [55] The next day, on 5 August 2011, AHTC released a media statement on the appointment of FMSS. The decision not to call a tender for MA services was justified on the basis of the “urgency of the timelines […], and the overriding concern that Town Council services should not be disrupted to the detriment” of the residents, and that there was “insufficient time” to do so. It was also said that “[no] Workers’ Party member has any interest in FMSS”, and that “AHTC does not incur additional MA fees from appointing FMSS, as FMSS has agreed to assume the scope of works and pricing of the former MA [for ATC]”.

  71. [56] On 11 August 2011, AHTC and CPG entered into a deed of mutual release with effect from 1 August 2011, stating that “both parties are desirous to be released and discharged from the further performance” of the CPG MA contract and that “they have mutually agreed to release and discharge each other” from further performance of the same. Also on 11 August 2011, AHTC and CPG entered into a project management contract for CPG to provide three staff members for a one-month parallel run of computer services at AHTC, and to provide project management services for three improvement works and repainting projects which were in progress.

  72. Correspondence leading to the award of the first EMSU contract to FMSS

  73. [57] As noted above at [33], Mr Jeffrey Chua notified Ms How Weng Fan on 16 May 2011 that the existing contracts with CPG and EM Services for EMSU services were set to expire on 30 September 2011. The same point was noted in the presentation slides used at the presentation on 2 June 2011 (see above at [38]), and was also made by Mr Jeffrey Chua at the first Town Council meeting on 9 June 2011.

  74. [58] On 26 August 2011, Ms How Weng Fan sent a letter to Mr Jeffrey Chua as the Managing Director of CPG, concerning the “extension of term contract for [EMSU services] from 1 October 2011 to 31 March 2012”:

  75. A similar letter was sent to EM Services.

  76. [59] On 7 September 2011, EM Services replied, stating that they were declining the request for extension. Thus, the provision of EMSU services by EM Services would terminate on 30 September 2011.

  77. [60] The third Town Council meeting was held on 8 September 2011. At this meeting, the following discussion pertaining to EMSU contracts with CPG and EM Services was recorded in the minutes:

  78. [61] On 14 September 2011, Mr Jeffrey Chua sent an email to Ms How Weng Fan on behalf of CPG, apparently to follow up from a telephone conversation the same morning, stating that “[a]s explained, it will not be appropriate for us to continue providing the EMSU services to your Town Council when the current extended contract ends on 30 Sept 2011”.

  79. [62] Two days later, on 16 September 2011, Ms Sylvia Lim emailed the town councillors to apprise them of the “important news re EMSU services”:

  80. [63] This email was followed by a meeting on 18 September 2011 of the committee mentioned in the minutes of meeting at [60] above (“the EMSU Committee”), which comprised Mr Chen Show Mao, Mr Muhamad Faisal, Mr Anthony Teo and Ms Sylvia Lim. The EMSU Committee compared the EMSU contracts of the existing providers in the market, CPG, EM Services and Integrated Solutions, and made decisions as to the scope of EMSU services to be awarded. The EMSU Committee also noted that there were “advantages of awarding the MA contract and the EMSU contract at the same time”, and recommended to award the EMSU contract for the interim period from 1 October 2011 to 30 June 2012 “given the urgency”, so that the tenders for the subsequent MA and EMSU contracts could be called at about the same time.

  81. [64] On 18 September 2011, Ms Sylvia Lim emailed the town councillors, reiterating that CPG has confirmed its unwillingness to extend its EMSU services beyond 30 September 2011. She stated that this “came as a surprise on 14 Sep and was contrary to the verbal agreement that they were willing to extend for 6 months”. She further stated that as EMSU was a critical service, a waiver of tender for EMSU services was required due to the “urgency of the requirement and the public interest necessity”. She concluded by stating that FMSS had offered to supply the EMSU services in accordance with the scope of works approved by the EMSU Committee, and for the period October 2011 to June 2012, following which an open tender would be called. AHTC’s approval was sought to waive the tender for EMSU services and to award the contract to FMSS. Approval was unanimously provided via email circulation.

  82. Events leading up to the award of the second MA contract and second EMSU contract to FMSS

  83. [65] At the ninth Town Council meeting on 8 March 2012, it was discussed that FMSS’s provision of MA and EMSU services under the first MA and EMSU contracts would be expiring in July 2012, and that tenders would need to be called soon. The meeting then decided to appoint a committee to consider the MA and EMSU tenders. This committee is the Tender Committee referred to at [15] above.

  84. [66] At the tenth Town Council meeting on 12 April 2012, it was noted that the Tender Committee had met twice to review and make amendments to the tender documents and specifications used by ATC for MA and EMSU services, which would be used for the calling of tenders the next day. Representatives from FMSS, which included Mr Danny Loh and Ms How Weng Fan, were then excused from the meeting. After they re-joined the meeting, they were informed that AHTC would call for quotations to appoint a firm to audit the process of appointment of the MA.

  85. [67] A tender notice for the provision of MA and EMSU services, each for a term of three years, was published in the Straits Times on 13 April 2012, with the tender closing on 4 May 2012. On 16 April 2012, tender documents were collected by CBM Pte Ltd and EM Services. FMSS subsequently collected tender documents on 26 April 2012. FMSS submitted the sole bid for the second EMSU contract and second MA contract on 4 May 2012.

  86. [68] The minutes of the Town Council meeting of 10 May 2012 recorded that the Tender Committee had “appointed M/s RSM Ethos at $6,000 as the firm to audit the process of the appointment of the Managing Agent”.

  87. [69] On 19 June 2012, Ms Sylvia Lim sent Ms How Weng Fan and Mr Danny Loh the following email which gave them a heads up as to what the Tender Committee would seek explanation on:

  88. Mr Danny Loh replied to this email on the same day with revised calculations on FMSS’s rates. The revised calculations show FMSS’s proposed rates for 2012 to have increased from $5.96 per equivalent dwelling unit (“EDU”) in 2010 to $7.00 per EDU, representing a 17.28% increase in MA fees. Mr Danny Loh also said that he “[a]ppreciate[d] the heads up”.

  89. [71] The Tender Committee reconvened one month later on 21 July 2012 to evaluate the MA tender submitted by FMSS, and this time queried why FMSS’s project management rates did not price in any rate reduction for larger projects. Mr Danny Loh responded that since FMSS focused on managing only one town, it did not enjoy the economies of scale in project management enjoyed by other companies.

  90. [72] On 26 July 2012, Ms Sylvia Lim received an email from Kelly Services in response to a prior request to review the salaries of FMSS staff. The representative from Kelly Services stated that the salaries reviewed were “generally acceptable and within range of market norms”.

  91. [73] At the 13th Town Council meeting held on 2 August 2012, the council considered the tender evaluation reports submitted by the Tender Committee, and adopted its recommendations to award the second MA and EMSU contracts to FMSS at the agreed upon prices. Representatives from FMSS were absent at that meeting. An ACRA search showing the shareholding of Mr Danny Loh, Ms How Weng Fan and other FMSS representatives was part of the documents put before the Tender Committee during the preparation of their tender evaluation report, but this was not put before the Town Council at this meeting.

  92. [74] The day after the Town Council meeting, a letter of acceptance of FMSS’s tender for the second MA contract, for the contract period from 15 July 2012 to 14 July 2015, was sent by Ms Sylvia Lim to FMSS. On 7 August 2012, FMSS’s tender for the second EMSU contract was accepted similarly for a period of three years.

  93. Circumstances leading to the award of miscellaneous contracts to third party contractors

  94. [75] The plaintiffs’ claims also include various contracts which they say were improperly awarded to third party contractors. None of these contractors has any connection to Mr Danny Loh, Ms How Weng Fan or FMSS. The circumstances leading up to these appointments, as gleaned from undisputed documentary evidence, will be briefly summarised here.

  95. (1) LST Architects

  96. [76] On 31 August 2012, AHTC invited tenders for the appointment of architectural consultants to a panel for a period of three years, for the provision of consultancy services at pre-agreed rates based on the value of the awarded project. Tenders were received from LST Architects and Design Metabolists, and it was recorded in the tender evaluation report that for projects between the values of $0.5m and $3.66m, LST Architect’s prices were lower, whereas Design Metabolists’ prices were lower for projects under $0.5m or above $3.66m.

  97. [77] LST Architects and Design Metabolists were given a performance assessment score of 42 and 41 respectively by AHTC’s Property Officer on 20 September 2012, suggesting that they were broadly even in terms of performance. On 7 November 2012, the Tender Committee decided that both tenderers ought to be appointed to the panel of consultants. LST Architects and Design Metabolists subsequently entered into appointment agreements with AHTC for the contract period 1 December 2012 to 30 November 2015.

  98. [78] Based on the review by KPMG of ten projects which were subsequently awarded to LST Architects, LST Architects was actually higher-priced than Design Metabolists for seven of those projects.

  99. (2) Red-Power

  100. [79] In April 2012, AHTC called for a tender for the maintenance of transfer and booster pumps, automatic refuse chute flushing system and roller shutters. At the material time, AHTC had contracts with Digo Corporation Pte Ltd (“Digo”) and Terminal 9 Pte Ltd (“Terminal 9”) for the same services, which could have been extended at AHTC’s option for a maximum of two years at the same rates. On 11 June 2012, Red-Power Electrical Engineering Pte Ltd (“Red-Power”), the sole tenderer, was awarded a term contract for the maintenance of transfer and booster pumps, automatic refuse chute flushing system and roller shutters for AHTC for a period of three years.

  101. [80] Punggol-East had a separate contract with EM Services for the same services, which contract could not have been further extended after its expiry on 31 March 2015. At the time of the expiry of the said contract, AHTC had in place the contract with Red-Power mentioned in the preceding paragraph, as well as a separate contract with Tong Lee Engineering Works Pte Ltd (“Tong Lee”) which covered different precincts of AHTC. It would appear that Tong Lee was not obliged to extend their coverage to include Punggol-East. On 12 December 2014, a letter was sent to Red-Power to confirm that Punggol-East would be added to AHTC’s existing term contract with Red-Power at the same rates, terms and conditions, with effect from 1 April 2015.

  102. (3) Rentokil

  103. [81] On 12 July 2013, AHTC called a tender for pest control services. Tenders were received from Rentokil Initial Singapore Pte Ltd (“Rentokil”) and Pest-Pro Management Pte Ltd (“Pest-Pro”), with Pest-Pro’s bid being the lowest. On 17 August 2013, interviews were conducted with both Rentokil and Pest-Pro by the Tender Committee. On 26 August 2013, Rentokil was awarded a term contract for the inspection, extermination and eradication of pests for AHTC for a period of three years.

  104. [82] Punggol-East had a contract for pest control services with Clean Solutions Pte Ltd (“Clean Solutions”) which expired on 31 March 2015. On 12 December 2014, a letter was sent to Rentokil to confirm the addition of Punggol-East into the existing contract at the same rates, terms and conditions, with effect from 1 April 2015.

  105. (4) Titan and J Keart

  106. [83] PRPTC had contracts for conservancy and cleaning works, and servicing and maintenance of fire protection systems with Titan Facilities Management Pte Ltd (“Titan”) and J Keart Alliances Pte Ltd (“J Keart”) respectively. Both contracts expired on 31 March 2015, and contained an option to extend for a further 12 months on the same terms and rates. This option was not exercised. Instead, AHTC called for fresh tenders.

  107. [84] Three bids were received for the provision of conservancy and cleaning works, and a new contract for these works was awarded to the lowest bidder, Titan, for the period 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2018. Similarly, three bids were received for the maintenance of fire protection systems, and a new contract was awarded to the lowest bidder, J Keart, for a period of three years. In other words, new contracts for the same services were awarded to the existing contractors when the existing contracts could have been extended. It is not disputed that the new contracts with Titan and J Keart were at a higher rate than the existing contracts with the same contractors.

  108. Parties’ cases

  109. [85] The parties’ cases will be briefly summarised here, and will be dealt with in greater detail when I set out my decision beginning at [160] below. Even though the arguments made by the parties do not always entirely overlap, a distinction will only be made here between the arguments made by AHTC as opposed to those by PRPTC, and the arguments made by the first to fifth defendants as opposed to those by the sixth to eighth defendants, when it is relevant and appropriate to do so. The parties’ arguments will be analysed with greater specificity in the latter portions of this judgment.

  110. The plaintiffs’ case

  111. [86] The focus of the plaintiffs’ complaint against the defendants relates to the appointment of FMSS as MA and provider of EMSU services under the first MA and EMSU contracts and subsequently the second MA and EMSU contracts (collectively, “the first and second MA and EMSU contracts”) and the payments made thereunder, as well as the payments made to FMSI pursuant to the FMSI EMSU contract following the merger of HTC and ATC. I will thus canvas the arguments relating to this complaint before moving on to the other claims concerning the appointment of third party contractors and the payments that were made to them.

  112. [87] As the plaintiffs’ cases were largely conducted on a joint basis, their positions as pleaded and argued will be treated here as applying to them both, except where they are expressly stated to apply to only one of them.

  113. The defendants owe fiduciary duties to the plaintiffs and/or were trustees

  114. [88] The first issue is a preliminary one, and pertains to the nature of the legal relationship between the defendants and AHTC, which has implications on the duties owed by the defendants to AHTC and the remedies that can be sought for the breach of those duties. The plaintiffs argue that the defendants, with the exception of FMSS and FMSI, were fiduciaries of AHTC in their respective capacities as town councillors and appointment holders. It is argued that Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang, Mr Pritam Singh, Mr David Chua and Mr Kenneth Foo therefore were custodians of the residents’ monies and public monies in their capacity as town councillors, whereas Ms How Weng Fan and Mr Danny Loh similarly owed fiduciary duties as Deputy Secretary/General Manager and Secretary respectively. It is pointed out that the defendants had possession or control of assets and property of AHTC, and AHTC reposed trust and confidence and relied on them to discharge their functions, which is consistent with them being custodians and fiduciaries.

  115. [89] The plaintiffs therefore argue that the first to seventh defendants owed to AHTC fiduciary duties which included duties of loyalty and fidelity, good faith, not to put oneself in a position of conflict and not to make a profit other than through their legal entitlements, and by extension a duty to inquire into facts that would have awakened the suspicion of a prudent person, and a continuing duty to disclose and rectify breaches of the aforementioned duties.

  116. [90] PRPTC further claims in the alternative that the first to seventh defendants were trustees of AHTC’s assets and property. In their opening statements, the plaintiffs take the further position that the first to seventh defendants were custodial fiduciaries of AHTC’s assets.

  117. The defendants breached their duties in the award of the first and second MA and EMSU contracts

  118. [91] As noted earlier, the plaintiffs’ claim centres on four crucial contracts (see above at [18]) – the first MA and EMSU contracts awarded in 2011 and the second MA and EMSU contracts awarded in 2012 – under which the substantial portion of the allegedly improper payments were made to FMSS. The plaintiffs argue that the award of the first MA and EMSU contracts to FMSS without the calling of a tender was a breach of the defendants’ duties to AHTC, as the circumstances did not justify the waiver of a tender. The discussion that follows presents the plaintiffs’ case jointly to the extent that the narrative is common between AHTC and PRPTC. As I discuss below at [303], PRPTC’s claim is broader as it alleges breaches of fiduciary duties against the first to seventh defendants, rather than just Ms Sylvia Lim and Mr Low Thia Khiang. Nonetheless, the focus in the ensuing discussion is on the essence of the case run by the plaintiffs rather than the particular defendants against whom the claims are made.

  119. (1) The first MA contract

  120. [93] According to the plaintiffs, the evidence shows that the defendants made a calculated decision to not hold CPG to the CPG MA contract and to instead appoint Ms How Weng Fan and Mr Danny Loh to provide services to AHTC without calling a tender. This is evident from the emails exchanged between the defendants shortly after the 2011 GE, as well as the manner in which FMSS was appointed via a delegation of authority to Ms Sylvia Lim. Further, there was no discussion about preparing for a tender and no steps taken to invite a tender, which shows that there was never an intention to do so. This was even though the elected MPs were aware of the requirement to call a tender.

  121. [94] The plaintiffs say that even if CPG was unwilling to continue as MA, this was irrelevant since CPG was obliged to perform the CPG MA contract until at least July 2013 and possibly until July 2016. This was because the CPG MA contract was set to run until July 2013, with an option to extend for a further period until July 2016 (albeit on terms to be agreed). The CPG MA contract also allowed AHTC to require CPG to extend its MA services to HTC following its amalgamation with ATC. The defendants’ case that it would be difficult to work with an unwilling MA was also undermined by the fact that CPG continued to provide EMSU services until October 2011 – that the defendants trusted CPG to continue to provide such critical services to AHTC showed that the defendants did not find it difficult to work with CPG.

  122. [95] The plaintiffs also argue that there was a lack of full and proper disclosure at the second Town Council meeting on 4 August 2011 on two bases. First, that Ms Sylvia Lim and Mr Low Thia Khiang had procured the town councillors’ ratification and/or approval of the first MA contract at this meeting without disclosing the shareholding and ownership of FMSS, despite knowing that this was material information. Second, the alleged urgency which was offered as justification for the waiver of the tender was false, because CPG was contractually obliged to provide MA services until 31 July 2013 under the CPG MA contract, which meant that sufficient time to call a tender could have been secured.

  123. (2) The first EMSU contract

  124. [96] The plaintiffs contend that the award of the first EMSU contract to FMSS without a tender in 2011 was similarly a breach of the defendants’ fiduciary duties. The plaintiffs assert that there is no evidence that bears out Ms Sylvia Lim and Mr Low Thia Khiang’s attempt to justify the waiver of tender on the basis of a verbal agreement between AHTC and CPG for the latter to carry on providing EMSU services beyond 30 September 2011. Rather, the evidence shows that the plan all along was for FMSS to take over both MA and EMSU services for AHTC, and that the calling of a tender would have foiled it.

  125. [97] Further, the plaintiffs say that r 81 TCFR was breached as there was no written contract entered into for the first EMSU contract. The plaintiffs point out that the breach was conceded by Ms Sylvia Lim. PRPTC also argues that there was a breach of r 76(4) TCFR, which precludes a MA from participating in the evaluation and recommendation for a waiver of tender pursuant to r 74(17). In this case, FMSS had recommended itself as the supplier of EMSU services, which PRPTC says amounts to participation in the evaluation and recommendation process.

  126. (3) The second MA contract and second EMSU contract

  127. [98] On the plaintiffs’ case, the reasons and motives which drove the defendants to waive tenders and appoint FMSS under the first MA and EMSU contracts rendered the subsequent award of the second MA and EMSU contracts in 2012 a fait accompli notwithstanding that a tender was called. This was because the defendants’ actions in ousting CPG and installing their own supporters in 2011 made it a foregone conclusion that industry players would not have wanted to participate in the tenders for the second MA and EMSU contracts in 2012. In other words, the plaintiffs argue that the defendants’ breaches of duties in waiving tender and awarding the first MA and EMSU contracts to FMSS in 2011 continued to persist and tainted the award of the second MA and EMSU contracts in 2012.

  128. [99] According to the plaintiffs, the defendants continued to show partiality towards FMSS throughout the tender process, in that Ms Sylvia Lim quietly fed Ms How Weng Fan and Mr Danny Loh inside information on what the Tender Committee’s likely questions would be. This “heads-up” enabled Mr Danny Loh to come armed with slides addressing the questions that were likely to be raised by the Tender Committee at the presentation on 21 June 2012. Further, the plaintiffs argue that Ms How Weng Fan’s assertion at this presentation that it would not be possible to project AHTC’s cashflow for the next three years was a deliberate misrepresentation because she knew that AHTC’s budget surplus would be wiped out by FMSS’s proposed rate increases. This was evident from the fact that whilst FMSS’s profit rose 300% over the next two financial years, AHTC became financially imperilled over the same period. In this regard, reference was made to the KPMG report and the unchallenged evidence of Mr Owen Hawkes that such projections could have been prepared.

  129. [100] The plaintiffs further argue that the award of the second MA and EMSU contracts were also highly irregular in several aspects. Whereas the first MA contract expired on 14 July 2012, AHTC’s decision to award the second MA contract on 2 August 2012 to take effect from 15 July 2012, meant that FMSS provided MA services in the intervening period – 15 July 2012 to 2 August 2012 – despite a tender not being called or waived. This was also the case for the second EMSU contract. Further, since the contracts were issued more than two weeks after FMSS started providing MA and EMSU services, PRPTC also alleges that this is a breach of r 81(6) of the TCFR. The appointment of RSM Ethos to audit the tender process did not improve the integrity of the process as they did not have access to material facts and also did not review substantive aspects of the tender process.

  130. [101] Lastly, the plaintiffs also argue that Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang, Ms How Weng Fan and Mr Danny Loh once again failed to disclose that the latter two were shareholders of FMSS, which tainted the award of the second MA and EMSU contracts.

  131. The defendants breached their duties in failing to ensure meaningful oversight over payments to FMSS and FMSI

  132. [102] The plaintiffs make various other allegations which extend beyond the award of the first and second MA and EMSU contracts. It is alleged that the defendants set up a system where payments made to FMSS pursuant to these four contracts were authorised or made by conflicted persons, namely, persons who had an interest in FMSS but concurrently held positions in AHTC. This allowed the conflicted persons to certify that works were done or that payments were owing to FMSS without proper verification by independent persons. In other words, the entire payment approval process was facilitated by the very people to whom the payments were made. This exposed AHTC to the risk of improper use and misappropriation of public funds.

  133. [103] The plaintiffs submit that the standing instruction put in place at the third Town Council meeting on 8 September 2011 that required these payments to FMSS to be ultimately co-signed by the Chairman and Vice-Chairman of AHTC, was not a sufficient safeguard. The defendants rely on the standing instruction in their defence. The plaintiffs’ contention here is that it was unlikely that the Chairman or Vice-Chairman would have been informed by independent parties as to whether the payments were justified, or be in a position to personally verify the adequacy of the works. Instead, Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang and Mr Pritam Singh, in co-signing the cheques for payment, relied on supporting documents prepared by FMSS and approved by conflicted persons. This represented a significant shortcoming in the payment process. This lack of oversight was compounded by the fact that the Property Officer who certified the works as complete would often simply confirm that the sums in the supporting documents tallied with the amounts stated in the cheques before payment was made, rather than verify that the works had in fact been satisfactorily completed.

  134. [104] Thus, the plaintiffs contend that the payments made to FMSS under the first and second MA and EMSU contracts constituted improper payments which ought to be recovered.

  135. [105] AHTC, but not PRPTC, further argues that payments to FMSI under the FMSI EMSU contract were similarly made in breach of Ms Sylvia Lim’s and Mr Low Thia Khiang’s fiduciaries duties, as conflicted persons were also involved in the payment approval process without meaningful oversight.

  136. [106] Several specific categories of improper payments to FMSS were identified by the plaintiffs, which I describe below.

  137. (1) Project management fees paid to FMSS

  138. [107] One category identified was payments which were made to FMSS for project management fees. This is a claim that only AHTC makes. These are fees paid to FMSS for project management services charged at 3.5% of the progress payments made to third party contractors engaged to undertake certain works, and were in addition to FMSS’s fees for MA services. On AHTC’s case, some $1,220,697 in project management fees were wrongly paid to FMSS as a result of incorrect classification of those services as project management services. The argument is that invoices totalling $611,786 were in reality for a combination of project management services and MA services, and further invoices totalling $608,911 were in fact for MA services. In short, AHTC alleges that FMSS was not entitled to receive additional payment for those services as they ought to have been performed by FMSS under the first and second MA contracts at no extra charge.

  139. (2) Invoice of $106,559 paid to FMSS on 30 June 2011 and invoice of $166,591 paid to FMSS on 31 July 2011

  140. [108] Another instance of improper payment to FMSS related to invoice FMSS/0601 dated 30 June 2011 for the sum of $106,559, which included the sum of $92,000 for the provision of MA services to Hougang SMC for the month of June 2011, and reimbursement for the salary of HTC staff. On PRPTC’s case, since FMSS’s appointment was with effect from 15 July 2011, there was no contractual basis for FMSS to issue the invoice for services allegedly provided before the effective date of appointment. It is unclear what AHTC’s case on invoice FMSS/0601 is, although this invoice does form a head of claim by AHTC.

  141. [109] Additionally, PRPTC amended its statement of claim to include a claim for the sum of $166,591 paid to FMSS under invoice no. FMSS/0701 issued on 31 July 2011. PRPTC argues that FMSS was not entitled to issue this invoice because it was for services rendered before 15 July 2011, which was the date on which FMSS’s appointment took effect.

  142. (3) Miscellaneous improper payments to FMSS and FMSI

  143. [110] The KPMG report identifies several other instances of “detectable improper payments” to FMSS and FMSI, which pertain to payments for electrical parts, overtime and so on. While these payments do not appear to form specific heads of claim by AHTC or PRPTC as they are encompassed within the broader pleaded claim for improper payments to FMSS and FMSI, I shall nonetheless deal with them separately at [382] below since parties focused some attention on them during the trial.

  144. The defendants improperly awarded contracts to various third parties

  145. [111] The plaintiffs additionally claim that the defendants who were members of the Tender Committee, ie, Mr Pritam Singh, Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr David Chua and Mr Kenneth Foo, improperly awarded contracts at prices which were significantly higher than those offered by existing contractors or by other contractors who submitted lower bids. This, they say, is contrary to the requirements in rr 74(13), 74(15) and 74(16) TCFR which constrain Town Councils to accept the lowest tender meeting specifications unless reasons for not doing so are justified and recorded. Whereas the bulk of these claims are pursued only by PRPTC, the claim in relation to LST Architects is common to both PRPTC and AHTC. PRPTC’s claims are also broader in that they are against not just the members of the Tender Committee, but each of the first to seventh defendants.

  146. (1) LST Architects

  147. (2) Red-Power

  148. (3) Rentokil

  149. [114] PRPTC challenges the award of the contract to Rentokil for pest control services for a three-year period. PRPTC contends that as Pest-Pro had submitted a lower bid and had also achieved a higher Price Quality Method (“PQM”) score, the tender ought to have been awarded to them. For similar reasons as above, this was, on PRPTC’s case, in breach of rr 74(13), 74(15) and 75(16) TCFR.

  150. (4) Breaches following the expiry of contracts for services in Punggol-East

  151. [115] PRPTC had contracts with EM Services, Clean Solutions, Titan and J Keart for various services in Punggol-East. The contracts expired on 31 March 2015.

  152. [117] Upon the expiry of the contract with Clean Solutions, AHTC included Punggol-East in the contract with Rentokil (see above at [114]) instead of inviting a new tender for pest control services for Punggol-East. PRPTC argues that as the award of the pest control contract to the Rentokil was improper, by the same token, the inclusion of Punggol-East in the Rentokil contract was similarly improper.

  153. [118] AHTC had the option to extend the contract with Titan for an additional period of 12 months. Instead of doing so, it invited a new tender for the provision of conservancy and cleaning works for Punggol-East, and awarded the contract to the same contractor, ie, Titan, but at much higher rates. The same thing happened upon the expiry of the contract with J Keart – instead of exercising the option to extend the original contract, a fresh contract was awarded to J Keart at a higher rate. The defendants rely on an email from Mr Philip Lim informing them that there was no option to extend the Titan and J Keart contracts. PRPTC argues that this does not allow the defendants to disclaim liability as they should have reviewed the contracts themselves to ascertain if there were options to extend. PRPTC thus claims that awarding fresh contracts to J Keart and Titan at higher rates was improper and a breach of the duties owed by the defendants.

  154. The first to fifth defendants failed to ensure that payments made to third parties were substantiated by supporting documents or subject to properly authorised and certified invoices

  155. [119] Apart from the award of contracts to third parties, PRPTC also claims that two particular categories of payments to third parties were irregular.

  156. (1) 12 invoices totalling $171,112.62

  157. [120] PRPTC alleges that in November 2015, AHTC made payments to third parties on 12 invoices for expenses of Punggol-East which were not accompanied by required supporting documents that showed that the work had been carried out. Six of these invoices did not have monthly service reports, whereas there was no verification of work done for the remaining six.

  158. (2) 56 invoices totalling $674,388.70

  159. [121] In November 2015, AHTC made payments to third parties on 56 invoices which ought to have been certified by the Head of Department under r 56(4) TCFR. Instead, these invoices were signed by the Property Officer or finance and admin executive. PRPTC alleges that this is a breach of r 56(4) TCFR and the defendants’ fiduciary duties.

  160. [122] It was clarified during trial that these 56 invoices include the 12 invoices mentioned at [120] above.

  161. The defendants are not entitled to rely on s 52 of the TCA

  162. [123] The plaintiffs submit that the defendants are not entitled to rely on s 52 of the TCA on the basis that the defence therein does not apply where town councillors and officers breach their duties to the Town Council. Rather, s 52 only applies where the claim is by a third party against them. In any case, s 52 does not apply since the defendants did not act in good faith.

  163. Remedies sought

  164. [124] The nature of the remedies sought by AHTC and PRPTC in S 668/2017 and S 716/2017 respectively is slightly different, and the permissibility of the remedies sought will be discussed in greater detail from [527] below. The remedies are briefly set out here.

  165. (1) AHTC

  166. [125] AHTC claims, as against Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang, Ms How Weng Fan and Mr Danny Loh, the total sum of $33,717,535, being the amounts paid pursuant to the first and second MA and EMSU contracts as well as the FMSI EMSU contract, subject to the defendants “showing otherwise in a proper account and inquiry”.

  167. [126] In the alternative, AHTC claims against Ms Sylvia Lim and Mr Low Thia Khiang:

  168. [127] AHTC also seeks an account of any profits against Ms Sylvia Lim, Mr Low Thia Khiang, Ms How Weng Fan and Mr Danny Loh, or a declaration that such profits (or their traceable proceeds) are held on constructive trust (or subject to an equitable lien) in favour of AHTC.

  169. [128] AHTC claims that FMSS holds on constructive trust and is liable to account for the payments made to it (or the traceable proceeds thereof) in breach of fiduciary duties by the defendants, by virtue of its knowing receipt and/or dishonest assistance of the same. AHTC also claims equitable compensation in respect of the same wrongful payments, subject to FMSS “showing otherwise in a proper account and inquiry”. In the alternative, AHTC wishes to rescind the first and second MA and EMSU contracts and obtain restitution of all payments made to FMSS thereunder. AHTC makes the same claims against FMSI.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.