Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 1 Nov 2023
Contents

Family Division of the High Court

VUG v VUF

Feedback & support

[2023] SGHCF 46Case no. District Court Appeal No 79 of 20235 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. [7] Mr Yap submits that the correspondence set out above with LAB and the CPF Board makes it clear that LAB had given him the impression that the amendments he had proposed had been conveyed to the CPF Board, and the CPF Board had seen his amendment when they replied favourably. Counsel argues that he, and his client, were misled into accepting the final draft put forward by LAB.

  2. [11] Ms Ang urges that court to take into account the Wife’s concern with the refund of her CPF account. She says that the Wife needs cash and would have financial problems if the $78,957.83 was refunded to her CPF account. She submits that the Husband had not suffered “even a real or substantive prejudice” by having to now make CPF refunds to his own account. First, the Husband may not even sell the matrimonial property at all. Second, he can still use his CPF money to purchase another property, or withdraw them when he reaches the statutory age for withdrawal. In Ms Ang’s words, the “prejudice allegedly suffered by the Husband is therefore hypothetical”.

  3. [14] Secondly, although LAB was not representing the Husband and was not obliged to copy Mr Yap on their correspondence to the CPF Board, as a matter of fairness, they ought to have attached the most updated draft which included Mr Yap’s proposed amendments. Having failed to do so, it cannot now be argued that Mr Yap ought to have seen it coming and ought to have proceeded with the list of checks now being suggested. This is not reasonable.

  4. [15] Thirdly, I disagree with Ms Ang’s submission that it was reasonable for LAB to take the position that Mr Yap’s additional clause was irrelevant. It was not reasonable for LAB to do so. In Mr Yap’s letter to LAB (dated 6 September 2022), he had stated to LAB that:

  5. From the outset, it should have been clear to LAB that the Husband’s acquiescence to paying the Wife in cash, was subject to the condition that the Husband “not be liable nor responsible for any refund your client has to make to the CPF Board”. That was what Mr Yap’s proposed amendment was supposed to protect the Husband from (at [2] above).

  6. [16] Fourthly, I do not accept Ms Ang’s submission that the Husband would not be prejudiced by having to refund money into his CPF account. Ms Ang submits that the Wife would be prejudiced if she had to now refund money to her CPF account (at [11]), The same must apply to the Husband. Both the Husband and the Wife clearly want cash in hand rather than having their money in their CPF accounts.