Family Division of the High Court · Decided 22 May 2023
WGE v WGF
Feedback & support[2023] SGHCF 26 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 83 of 2022
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] HCF/DCA 83/2022 is an appeal against a decision of the Family Courts in relation to the division of matrimonial assets and maintenance.
Facts
The parties
- [2]
[2] The Appellant is WGE (“the Wife”).
- [3]
[3] The Respondent is WGF (“the Husband”).
- [4]
[4] The Wife and Husband were married on 26 September 2010 and have one child to the marriage (“D”), who is seven years old this year.
Background to the dispute
- [5]
[5] The Wife commenced divorce proceedings on 22 January 2021 against the Husband on the basis that the Husband had behaved in such a way that she could not reasonably be expected to live with him. The interim judgment was granted on 24 March 2021 on an uncontested basis. This was a marriage of around ten years and four months.
Decision below
- [7]
[7] I first summarise below the District Judge’s (“DJ”) decision.
Division of matrimonial assets
- [8]
[8] In respect of the division of matrimonial assets, the DJ valued the matrimonial assets as at the date of the AM hearing (17 August 2022) and found that the total pool of matrimonial assets available for division was $2,673,518.45. In arriving at this figure for the pool of matrimonial assets, the DJ excluded the Dutch bank accounts and the Husband’s pension policy (from his previous employment) from the matrimonial pool.
- [9]
[9] The house at Sin Min Walk, which was the matrimonial home, was valued at $1,550,000 by the DJ. This valuation is not the subject of any appeal.
- [10]
[10] In respect of the Husband’s current shares in the company KS Pte Ltd (“KS”) , the DJ found that most of the 939,657 current KS shares had been acquired in 2008 before the marriage to the Wife. The DJ excluded these KS shares from the matrimonial pool. Only the 557 KS shares which were acquired by the Husband during the marriage were included in the matrimonial pool.
- [11]
[11] In respect of the Husband’s shares in MS Pte Ltd (“MS”), the DJ found that all 210,000 MS shares should be included in the matrimonial pool. In valuing the shares, the DJ noted that the Husband had tried to downplay the value of MS during the ancillary proceedings and that he had not fully cooperated in the valuation exercise. The DJ rejected the valuation provided by the Husband’s expert. He preferred the approach adopted by the Wife’s expert, who had used both the market and the income approach, but he differed from the Wife’s expert in relation to the discounts he applied for lack of marketability and lack of control. Ultimately, the DJ valued the Husband’s MS shares at $466,561.24.
- [12]
[12] In respect of the Husband’s cryptocurrency assets, the DJ found these to be worth around $487,586.14 at the time of the ancillary matters (“AM”) hearing. He rejected the Husband’s request for these cryptocurrency assets to be divided in specie.
- [13]
[13] Having identified and valued the matrimonial assets, the DJ next considered the parties’ direct financial contributions and indirect contributions. The DJ apportioned the parties’ direct financial contribution in the ratio of 88:12 in favour of the Husband. Noting that the Husband had a significantly higher income than the Wife and that the latter had stopped working from September 2010, the DJ concluded that the Husband would have contributed the lion’s share of indirect financial contributions during the marriage, but that the Wife made significantly larger indirect non-financial contributions to the marriage. The DJ apportioned the parties’ indirect contributions in the ratio of 52:48 in favour of the Wife.
- [14]
[14] The DJ accorded equal weightage to both ratios and arrived at a final ratio of 68:32 in favour of the Husband.
Maintenance orders
- [15]
[15] In respect of the issue of maintenance, the DJ found that the Husband had a much larger income compared to the Wife’s: he had an undisputed income of $14,980 per month, excluding significant dividends from his various shareholdings. Having assessed the Wife’s reasonable monthly expenses to be around $3,013.15 per month, the DJ found that the Wife’s needs would exceed her present income, since her basic monthly salary was $3,000, with a take-home salary of around $2,400 per month after CPF deductions. Based on the amount allowed for the Wife’s reasonable monthly expenses, the DJ found that a reasonable multiplicand for the Wife’s maintenance would be $700 per month.
- [16]
[16] As for the multiplier, the DJ held that four years would be reasonably sufficient for the Wife to weather the transition period following the divorce. He therefore awarded the Wife total maintenance of $33,600.
- [17]
[17] As for maintenance for the child, D, the DJ found that D’s reasonable monthly expenses amounted to $1,732 (excluding those to be reimbursed directly by the Husband). Taking into account the large difference between the Husband’s income and the Wife’s income, and the Husband’s significant dividends from his shareholdings, the DJ held that it would be fair for the Husband to pay 90% of this assessed quantum (ie, $1,560 per month) and to pay in full for the items to be reimbursed, with the Wife paying the remaining 10% of the $1,732.
The parties’ cases on appeal
Wife’s Case
- [18]
[18] The Wife contends on appeal that the DJ erred in determining the pool of matrimonial assets. Per the Wife’s case, the pool of assets should be of much higher value. It is also the Wife’s case that the DJ erred in apportioning the parties’ share of the matrimonial assets in the ratio of 68:32 in favour of the Husband, as she contends that she should have received a larger share in light of her significant indirect contributions to the marriage. In addition, she contends that the DJ erred in terms of the amount of maintenance he awarded her and the amount assessed for D’s monthly expenses, as well as in ordering her to bear 10% of D’s monthly expenses.
Husband’s Case
- [19]
[19] The Husband maintains that no error was made by the DJ in determining the pool of matrimonial assets, in dividing the matrimonial assets, in determining the maintenance amounts awarded for the Wife and D, and in ordering her to bear 10% of D’s monthly expenses.
Issues on Appeal
- [20]
[20] The following issues arose for my determination in the hearing of this appeal:
(a) Whether the DJ erred in finding that only 557 (and not all 939,657) of the Husband’s KS shares were matrimonial assets (“the KS Shares Issue”).
(b) Whether the DJ erred in valuing the Husband’s 210,000 MS shares at S$466,561.24 (“the MS Shares Issue”).
(c) Whether the DJ erred in assessing parties’ indirect contributions in the ratio of 52:48 in the Wife’s favour (“the Indirect Contributions Issue”).
(d) Whether the DJ erred in awarding the Wife lump sum maintenance of S$33,600 (“the Maintenance Issue”).
(e) Whether the DJ erred in awarding S$1,732 for D’s monthly expenses and in ordering the Husband to bear 90% thereof instead of 100% (“the Child Maintenance Issue”).
- [21]
[21] In the paragraphs that follow, I address these issues seriatim.
- [22]
[22] For the record, the Wife has indicated that she has abandoned her appeals in respect of the following other aspects of the DJ’s decision:
(a) The exclusion from the matrimonial pool of three of the Husband’s accounts in Netherlands; and
(b) The refusal to backdate the Wife’s maintenance.
Basis for review by an appellate court of a trial judge’s decision
- [23]
[23] By way of general principle, it is trite that appellate intervention in respect of findings of fact made by a trial judge is warranted only when the trial judge’s assessment is plainly wrong or manifestly against the weight of the evidence (Nambu PVD Pte Ltd v UBTS Pte Ltd and another appeal [2022] 1 SLR 391 at [8]; Tat Seng Machine Movers Pte Ltd v Orix Leasing Singapore Ltd [2009] 4 SLR(R) 1101 (“Tat Seng”) at [41]; Tuitiongenius Pte Ltd v Toh Yew Keat and another [2021] 1 SLR 231 at [19]; Simpson Marine (SEA) Pte Ltd v Jiacipto Jiaravanon [2019] 1 SLR 696 at [59]; North Star (S) Capital Pte Ltd v Yip Fook Meng [2022] 1 SLR 677 at [21]). The rationale for this is that the trial judge is generally in a better place to assess the credibility of witnesses, especially in situations where oral evidence is concerned. In Tat Seng, the Court of Appeal (“CA”) (at [41]) further clarified that where a finding of fact is not based on the veracity or credibility of the witness, but is instead based on an inference drawn from the facts or evaluation of the facts, the appellate court would be in as good a position as the trial judge to make findings of fact. This would involve the appellate court evaluating the cogency of the evidence from the witnesses by testing it against inherent probabilities or uncontroverted facts.
- [24]
[24] In respect of errors of law, the CA in Ng Eng Ghee and others v Mamata Kapildev Dave and others (Horizon Partners Pte Ltd, intervener) and another appeal [2009] 3 SLR(R) 109 at [90] has listed various types of errors of law (citing Halsbury’s Laws of England vol 1(1) (Butterworths, 4th Ed Reissue, 1989) at [70]; see also Mu Qi and another v Management Corporation Strata Plan No 1849 [2021] 5 SLR 1401 at [34]):
Issue 1: Whether the DJ erred in finding that only 557 (instead of all 939,657) of the Husband’s KS shares are matrimonial assets
- [25]
[25] Bearing these general principles in mind, I first address the KS Shares Issue.
Decision below
- [26]
[26] In the proceedings below, the DJ ruled that of the 939,657 KS shares held by the Husband (which had a value of S$492,399.32), only 557 of these shares were to be included in the matrimonial pool for distribution. This was because the DJ found that the Husband had clear documentary evidence to show that 1,000,000 KS shares had been acquired in 2008, whereas 557 shares had been acquired in the course of the marriage, in September 2019.
- [27]
[27] As to the Wife’s argument that the Husband’s entire KS shareholding should be included in the matrimonial pool because her efforts in caring for the home had freed up the Husband to build the business, this was rejected by the DJ. The DJ did not agree that the Wife had substantially improved the assets such that it had been transformed into a matrimonial asset. Instead, he found that KS had already developed the software by 2013 and sold it to MS for S$200,000; that this event had taken place early on in the marriage where both parties were still working; and that nothing much could be said about parties’ respective indirect contributions in that period. Moreover, the position advocated by the Wife was against the weight of authority. Citing USB v USA [2020] 2 SLR 588 (“USB v USA”) at [21]-[22], the DJ observed that the reference to “substantial improvement” of assets necessarily had an economic connotation: the court’s focus had to be on whether there had been some expenditure or application of effort towards the improvement of the asset in an economic sense; and this necessarily entailed either a direct investment or effort having an economic value. Applying USB v USA, the DJ held that the Wife’s efforts in this case did not qualify as efforts going towards the improvement of the KS shares in an economic sense.
- [28]
[28] As to the Wife’s argument that the Husband had utilised his salary and dividends from the KS business for family expenses, and that these acts revealed his clear intention to treat all KS shares as matrimonial assets, this was also rejected by the DJ. The DJ agreed with the Husband that he was utilising the income from the company, as opposed to utilising the assets themselves. In this connection, the DJ distinguished between the usage of proceeds from a sale of the underlying shares on the one hand, and utilisation of income earned from employment in the company as well as dividends paid out from the shares on the other hand.
Wife’s Case
- [29]
[29] On appeal, the Wife submitted that the DJ had read USB v USA incorrectly: the CA in USB v USA (so the Wife claimed) did not rule that indirect non-financial contributions had no economic value for the purpose of the “substantial improvement” exception. The Wife also argued that in USB v USA, the words “in an economic sense” were used by the CA to describe or to qualify the words “the improvement of the asset”, rather than the nature of the effort itself. According to the Wife, therefore, the court should focus, not on the effort, but on “whether there was an improvement in the assets in some measurable sense”.
- [30]
[30] According to the Wife too, the view that indirect non-financial contributions did not qualify for the “substantial improvement” exception was contrary to the position taken in the earlier cases of Hoong Khai Soon v Cheng Kwee Eng [1993] 1 SLR(R) 823 (“Hoong Khai Soon”) and Chen Siew Hwee v Low Kee Guan [2006] 4 SLR(R) 605 (“Chen Siew Hwee”).
Husband’s Case
- [31]
[31] The Husband, on the other hand, submitted that there was no “substantial improvement” made by the Wife to the Husband’s KS shares, because there was no direct causal connection between the Wife’s actions and the value of the shares – such causal connection being a requirement for “substantial improvement” per the CA in USB v USA.
- [32]
[32] Insofar as the Wife had taken care of D and thus freed the Husband up to focus his energies on building the business, her contributions should be characterised as non-financial contributions to the marriage – and not as a “substantial improvement” of the KS shares. In this connection, the Husband submitted that caselaw had established clearly that a spouse’s efforts in taking care of the children of the marriage would not qualify as substantial improvement of the other spouse’s assets. Instead, examples of effort which qualified as “substantial improvement” included cases where a spouse had direct involvement in the business: ie, the spouse took on a role as a director, employee, shareholder or advisor with the company. In this case, the Wife was indisputably not involved in KS in any way, and so could not claim to have substantially improved the KS shares.
- [33]
[33] Further, citing USB v USA (at [22]), the Husband contended that the CA in that case had made it clear that improvement of the asset must entail investment or money’s worth for the improvement of the asset. Such investment referred to “effort of money or money’s worth”; the expression “economic sense” must therefore qualify the effort and not just the outcome.
My Decision
- [34]
[34] Having considered the relevant authorities and parties’ submissions, I reject the Wife’s understanding of the “substantial improvement” exception in USB v USA. I am satisfied that the DJ was correct in finding that the Wife’s efforts in taking care of D did not amount to effort “in an economic sense”, such that it could have substantially improved the KS shares and transformed them into a matrimonial asset within the meaning of s 112(10)(a)(ii) of the Women’s Charter (Cap 353, 2009 Rev Ed) (“Women’s Charter’). My reasons are as follows.
- [35]
[35] As a starting point, s 112(10)(a) of the Women’s Charter defines “matrimonial asset” as follows:
It is trite that pre-marriage assets are excluded from the matrimonial pool unless they were substantially improved by the other spouse or used for family purposes (USB v USA at [19(c)]). As the DJ noted in his grounds of decision, in USB v USA, in elaborating on the meaning of “substantial improvement”, the CA highlighted that it “necessarily has an economic connotation” (USB v USA at [21]). Further, the CA made the following observations (USB v USA at [22]):
- [36]
[36] The Wife’s submission that the words “in an economic sense” were used by the CA to describe or to qualify the words “the improvement of the asset”, rather than the nature of the effort itself, calls for a skewed reading of the final sentence in this passage which ignores everything else said by the CA in the same passage. It is a submission that is plainly wrong. Reading the above passage in its entirety, there can be no doubt that the CA has made clear what “substantial improvement” of an asset involves: either the improvement entails some investment of money or money’s worth, or the improvement arises from effort that can be “understood as having economic value”. In respect of the second limb, the CA provided an illustration by citing the example of a non-owning spouse who develops the business owned by the other spouse, taking pains to point out that minor administrative or public relations activities or being a nominal director might not be enough to be considered effort “having economic value”.
- [37]
[37] Applying USB v USA, I find that while the Wife’s actions in taking care of D were an important and weighty contribution to the marriage as a whole, they did not amount to “substantial improvement” of the Husband’s KS shares: her actions in taking care of D did not constitute an “investment of money or money’s worth” for the improvement of the said asset, nor could they be characterised as the application of effort “having economic value” towards the improvement of the asset.
- [38]
[38] Chen Siew Hwee, which the Wife cited, also does not assist her case. According to the Wife, Chen Siew Hwee established that indirect contributions could amount to “substantial improvement”. The Wife quoted the following passage from Phang J’s (as he then was) judgment (at [51] of Chen Siew Hwee):
- [39]
[39] It must be pointed out, first of all, that Phang J was talking about indirect financial contributions. However, even assuming that his remarks were intended to apply to all indirect contributions (ie, both financial and non-financial), it must also be pointed out that in quoting the above passage, the Wife omitted the earlier portion of this passage. I now reproduce below the omitted portion:
- [51]
[51] I should note that Ms Koh did in fact attempt to argue that the shares had been “substantially improved” by the wife during the subsistence of the marriage through her indirect financial contributions. I rejected this argument for the simple reason that there was no direct causal connection whatsoever between these contributions and the shares (see the Singapore Court of Appeal decisions of Hoong Khai Soon v Cheng Kwee Eng [1993] 1 SLR(R) 823 (“Hoong Khai Soon”) at [11] and Lee Yong Chuan Edwin v Tan Soan Lian [2000] 3 SLR(R) 867 (“Lee Edwin”) at [37]). This is obviously a question of fact (see Hoong Khai Soon at [11]). Indeed, in the context of the present proceedings, there was no substantial improvement of the shares to begin with (see also the Singapore Court of Appeal decision of Shi Fang v Koh Pee Huat [1996] 1 SLR(R) 906). Though Ms Koh cited the Singapore Court of Appeal decision of Koh Kim Lan Angela v Choong Kian Haw [1993] 3 SLR(R) 491, this particular decision is readily distinguishable from the situation in the present proceedings. In that case, the wife concerned did in fact actually assist the husband in the business which had been given to him (the husband) by his father. Mr Khoo cited, on the other hand, the Singapore High Court decision of Chow Hoo Siong v Lee Dawn Audrey [2003] 4 SLR(R) 481 (“Chow Hoo Siong”), where S Rajendran J observed thus (at [13]–[15]):
The wife was not a director, shareholder, employee of or advisor to any of the companies in the group: her only link was that she was the wife of the husband. That being so, the affairs of the Teo companies, even if fully disclosed by the husband to the court, would not have revealed any contributions by the wife: even the wife did not claim that she had made any direct contribution to the Teo Shares. Any “indirect” contribution she may have made – such as looking after the welfare of the family – would not appear in the records of the Teo companies. There was therefore no basis for the district judge to have made the inference from the husband’s conduct that had he made full disclosure the wife’s contribution would have been revealed.
Apart from the adverse inference that the district judge drew from the husband’s conduct, the district judge enumerated the following ‘indirect contributions’ by the wife towards the ‘improvement’ of the Teo Shares:
It was pertinent to note that the Respondent’s admission that his salary in ESC [Eng Seng Cement Products – a company controlled by the Teo companies] remained the same “since graduation. I am the lowest paid because I’m youngest in the generation hierarchy”. Clearly Chow has enhanced the shares through his employment in ESC. By accepting no increment in salary over 13 years of service to the company, he has in fact enhanced the profits of the company and in turn the value of the shares of the companies. His sacrifice would also affect the lifestyle of his wife who, according to the Respondent, was required to share in the family expenses. She also had contributed financially towards the household and hence had participated towards the acquisition of the asset by her efforts towards the family life. …
These “contributions” were, in my view, far too remote and far too insignificant to justify the conclusion that the district judge arrived at that the Teo Shares have been improved by the contributions of the wife during the marriage.
As the wife had not on her own or together with the husband contributed in any way to the improvement of the Teo Shares, these shares should not be included in the pool of matrimonial assets available for division between the parties.
…..
This decision supports, in my view, the proposition to the effect that indirect financial contributions alone are too vague and remote to justify a finding that the spouse concerned had helped to substantially improve an asset within the meaning of s 112(10)…
[emphasis added]
- [40]
[40] From the above, it is clear that Phang J’s starting point vis-à-vis “indirect financial contributions” was that such indirect contributions “alone [were] too vague and remote to justify a finding that the spouse concerned had helped to substantially improve an asset within the meaning of s 112(10) [of the Women’s Charter]”. It is also clear that while Phang J did not rule out the possibility that indirect financial contributions might justify a finding of substantial improvement, he emphasised the need to prove a direct causal connection between the alleged contributions and the improvement of the asset. Indeed, he repeated this caution in the portion of the passage which the Wife cited (see above at [38]).
- [41]
[41] Applying the principle articulated by Phang J, I agree with the Husband that the Wife has no evidence at all to show a direct causal connection between her actions in taking care of D and the value of the KS shares.
- [42]
[42] The Wife also sought to rely on the case of Hoong Khai Soon as authority for the submission that her efforts on the home front qualified as “substantial improvement”. I reproduce below the passage which she quoted from the CA’s judgment in that case (at [11]):
- [43]
[43] I do not find that Hoong Khai Soon assists the Wife’s case. As the DJ observed in his grounds of decision, the above comments were not the ratio decidendi in that case: they were simply made in passing. It must moreover be pointed out that in Hoong Khai Soon, where the wife gave evidence of having done all the domestic chores as well as having looked after her husband’s family and helped out in another business owned by her husband’s father, the CA found that there was no evidence of any direct causal link between her actions and the substantial improvement of the disputed business (at [11]).
Issue 2: Whether the DJ erred in valuing the Husband’s 210,000 MS shares at S$466,561.24
- [44]
[44] I next address the MS Shares Issue.
Decision below
- [45]
[45] In the proceedings below, the DJ found that all of the Husband’s 210,000 MS shares formed part of the matrimonial pool. This finding was not disputed by the parties on appeal. The DJ then ascribed to these 210,000 MS shares a value of S$466,561.24.
- [46]
[46] In valuing the shares at S$466,561.24, the DJ adopted a hybrid approach whereby he used both the income approach and the market approach, taking the average of the valuation figures derived under these two approaches. This was the same approach adopted by the Wife’s expert’s Mr Wan Yew Fai (“Mr Wan”). However, the DJ’s approach differed from Mr Wan’s in two key aspects. Firstly, the DJ decided to apply a discount for the lack of marketability (“DLOM”) under the market approach. This contrasted with the position taken by Mr Wan, who declined to apply a DLOM under the market approach. Secondly, the DJ also applied a discount for lack of control (“DLOC”) under both the market approach and the income approach. This contrasted with Mr Wan’s decision to apply a DLOC only under the income approach.
- [47]
[47] By way of clarification, the DLOM is a discount that is applied to account for the difficulty of selling shares in a private company as a result of the typical transfer restrictions that apply in this context and the narrowness of the market, regardless of whether the shares constitute a minority or a majority shareholding in the company concerned (Liew Kit Fah and others v Koh Keng Chew and others [2020] 1 SLR 275 (“Liew Kit Fah”) at [46]; Thio Syn Kym Wendy v Thio Syn Pyn and another [2018] SGHC 54 (“Thio Syn Kym”) at [21]). The DLOC is a discount that is applied to reflect the lack of control that a minority shareholder has over the management of a company in contrast to the control that a larger shareholder has (Liew Kit Fah at [45]; Thio Syn Kym at [21]; also Re Blue Index Ltd; Murrell v Swallow [2014] EWHC 2680 (Ch) at [48]).
- [48]
[48] The DJ’s approach to the application of the DLOM and the DLOC in respect of the MS shares explains why he ended up with a very different valuation figure, compared to Mr Wan – despite both having adopted a hybrid approach of using the market approach as well as the income approach. Mr Wan had valued the 210,000 MS shares at S$724,503 using the hybrid approach of applying both the market approach and the income approach, with a DLOM of 30% under the income approach (totaling one discount applied across the two approaches). The figure which the DJ landed on was significantly lower: having applied an additional DLOM of 30% under the market approach, and an additional DLOC of 25% under both the market approach and the income approach (ie four discounts applied across the two approaches), the DJ arrived at the valuation figure of S$466,561.24,
- [49]
[49] In choosing to adopt the same hybrid approach as Mr Wan, the DJ rejected the valuation report of the Husband’s expert Mr Farooq Ahmad Mann (“Mr Mann”). For one, the DJ noted that Mr Mann had chosen to value the shares as at 24 March 2021 – instead of the date of the AM hearing. The DJ found that this was done upon the Husband’s specific instructions.
- [51]
[51] Further, the DJ pointed out that the value which Mr Mann had ascribed to the shares – S$104,840 – was even lower than the figure which would have been obtained in the most extreme scenario of liquidation – as well as being lower than the dividend payout received by the Husband in 2021.
- [52]
[52] It should be highlighted that in valuing the MS shares, the DJ noted that the Husband had failed to disclose FY 2021 documents relating to the financial status of MS, and that MS’s FY 2021 financial statements had eventually been surfaced in August 2022 only as a result of the efforts of the Wife’s counsel. The FY 2021 financial statements revealed that for FY 2021, the Husband received dividends of S$139,288.61 while the company itself saw its profits increase by 30% from the previous year. The DJ was of the view that the Husband had downplayed the value of the company in the course of the ancillary proceedings and that he had failed to give his full assistance in the valuation exercise. However, the DJ rejected the Wife’s contention that an uplift of 20% should be applied to the value he had arrived at for the MS shares to give effect to the adverse inference to be drawn against the Husband for his non-disclosure of the FY 2021 financial documents. In the DJ’s view, the percentage figure proposed by the Wife was speculative and not backed by the expert. In any event, he reasoned that he had already taken into account the Husband’s non-disclosure by applying a lower DLOM (30%).
Whether MS’s FY 2021 financial statements should have been taken into consideration by the DJ in valuing the Husband’s shares
- [53]
[53] In respect of the MS Shares Issue, the first question which arose on appeal was whether the company’s FY 2021 financial statements should have been taken into consideration by the DJ in valuing the shares. Although the FY 2021 financial statements had become available by the time of the AM hearing, the DJ apparently chose not to direct the experts to consider these FY 2021 financial statements and / or to file further reports to explain the impact of the information therein (if any) on their respective valuations. The DJ did not record his reasons for leaving the FY 2021 financial statements out of the equation, but in his grounds of decision, he alluded (at [60]) to the Wife’s expert Mr Wan having stated in his reply affidavit that he “[would] not be amending the original position about the market value of MS… even where the new partnerships the company [had] with companies such as KBC and Schlumberger were taken into account”. I infer from these remarks that the DJ thought that it was unnecessary to have regard to the FY 2021 financial statements if Mr Wan had not changed the opinion expressed in his first expert report even after becoming aware of some new information.
- [54]
[54] With respect, the DJ was in my view wrong to disregard the FY 2021 financial statements in valuing the shares. Insofar as Mr Wan had stated in his reply affidavit that he “[would] not be amending the original position about the market value of MS… even where the new partnerships the company [had] with companies such as KBC and Schlumberger were taken into account”, it must be pointed out that this reply affidavit was filed on 10 June 2022 without Mr Wan having had sight of the FY 2021 financial statements. These financial statements were only made available in August 2022. Indeed, Mr Wan had expressly highlighted in his reply affidavit that his opinion in both his 1st and 2nd expert reports was formed on the basis of financial information as at 31 December 2020; and that “apart from some new partnership announcements”, he had “not been provided with [nor was he] able to find any significant changes in business circumstances that affected [MS]” between 24 March 2021 and 31 March 2022.
- [55]
[55] Given the above caveats to his valuation, it is clear that Mr Wan’s valuation of the MS shares was hampered by the lack of financial information from the most recent financial year. Indeed, since he had used the income approach for his valuation (as part of his hybrid approach), I accepted that the lack of the most recent financial information would have had a material impact on his valuation. Thus, for example, the much higher figure of 30.8% growth provided in the FY 2021 financial report indicated that Mr Wan’s original estimate of 15% growth in FY 2021 had severely underestimated MS’s profits for FY 2021. The significantly higher actual figures in 2021 would also have had a further knock-on effect on Mr Wan’s projections for all subsequent years, since the trajectory of profit growth would necessarily steepen.
- [56]
[56] With respect therefore, the DJ was wrong to have considered neither the FY 2021 financial statements, nor any expert reports that had considered the FY 2021 financial statements. In my view, a fair and accurate estimation of the value of the MS shares would be possible only if the FY 2021 financial statements were also taken into consideration. I therefore gave directions for the tendering of further expert reports from the two experts and further submissions from counsel on the MS Shares Issue.
- [57]
[57] I next summarise the further expert reports from Mr Wan and Mr Mann, as well as the parties’ further submissions.
Wife’s further expert report
- [58]
[58] In his further expert report, Mr Wan maintained 31 March 2022 as the operative date for the valuation of the MS shares.
- [59]
[59] In his further report, Mr Wan elected to use only the income approach to value the MS shares. This, he explained, was because MS was in a very niche segment providing services to the oil and gas industry, and there was limited information on comparable companies. He also clarified that the income approach adopted in the further report was substantially similar to the methodology adopted in his first report – save for some parameters which he had updated. Given the assumptions made about the parameters of the company (including revenue projections, predicted gross-profit margins, predicted operating expenses, predicted capital expenditure and predicted taxes), he explained that it was highly unlikely that there would be a material difference between a valuation conducted as at 31 March 2022 (the valuation date he had adopted) and a valuation conducted as at 17 August 2022 (the date of the AM hearing).
- [60]
[60] In applying the income approach in the further report, Mr Wan emphasised that it was important to add back excess cash into the valuation of the company. In 2021, MS had seen its cash holdings increase significantly – by about 58% – to US$1,175,755, even after taking into account the US$430,476 paid out in dividends. Based on historical data, a cash balance of US$1,175,755 was beyond the operating needs of the company; and from the FY 2021 financial statements, all the expenses of the company amounted to only US$869,857. After accounting for the expenses of the company, Mr Wan calculated the excess cash left in the company (as of 31 March 2022) to be US$754,572.
- [61]
[61] Using the income approach, Mr Wan estimated the value of MS to be US$4,990,110 (inclusive of the excess cash of US$754,572), with a pre-excess cash value of US$4,235,538. Mr Wan explained that this pre-excess cash value of US$4,235,538 was 21.8% higher than the figure of US$3,477,876 derived under the income approach in his first report, because more reliable and up-to-date information had resulted in a much higher starting base and a “revised size premium discount”.
- [62]
[62] Applying a DLOM of 30%, a DLOC of 25%, and a USD/SGD exchange rate of 1:1.3548, Mr Wan arrived at a valuation of S$824,506 for the Husband’s 23.23% shareholding (210,000 shares) – as compared to the valuation of S$574,642 which had been derived using the income approach in his first report (now also including a DLOM of 30% and a DLOC of 25% to the previous figure).
- [63]
[63] Mr Wan further explained that this valuation of S$824,506 translated to a value of around US$2.90 per share – which was consistent with other independent measures. In this connection, he noted that a value of US$2.90 per share represented a 20.8% increase in the value of the shares – which was reasonably conservative given the considerably higher 45.5% increase in revenue since 2018, and the even higher 66.3% increase in profit since 2018. The value of US$2.90 per share was also reasonably conservative when comparison was drawn with a 2018 transaction wherein the Husband had purchased 19,000 shares from another shareholder at US$2.40 per share. In Mr Wan’s view, a private sale of a minority lot of shares at US$2.40 per share has already accounted for DLOM and DLOC in its sale price – and this made it a suitable base for independent comparison.
- [64]
[64] In his further report, Mr Wan did not use the market approach as he did not find it suitable. He reasoned that the most recent transaction where the Husband bought shares from another shareholder had taken place in 2018 – and that since this transaction in 2018, the company has experienced rapid growth. No details were available in respect of a more recent transaction in July 2021, wherein one of the directors, Mr H, had appeared to no longer be a shareholder of MS. More specifically, Mr Wan opined that the previous transactions were no longer relevant, as the FY 2021 financial statements showed revenue to have grown by 45% and profits to be up by 66% since the year of the previous transactions.
- [66]
[66] In Mr Wan’s view, a DLOC of 25% was suitable in the case of the MS shares because while the Husband was a director of the company and held a significant number of shares, he was not a majority shareholder, and there were three other directors. In other words, there were limitations to his ability to exercise control over the company. On the other hand, he was not in a situation where he found himself a non-family member in a family-run company, where he held a very small stake with no role at all except as a shareholder. In the latter situation, the appropriate DLOC would be 50%.
- [67]
[67] As for the DLOM, Mr Wan took the position that a DLOM of 30% would be reasonable to reflect the fact that MS was not a listed company and that its shares changed hands irregularly, with various restrictions on the sale of shares. Additionally, MS did not pay regular dividends; and its nature as a software company meant that its success in the longer term was uncertain given the risk of new technologies and competition emerging.
Husband’s further expert report
- [68]
[68] In his further report, Mr Mann maintained 24 March 2021 as the operative date for his valuation of the MS shares.
- [70]
[70] In respect of the income approach, Mr Mann adopted the same methodology as that used by Mr Wan in his first report, while factoring in the change to the figure for net profit after tax in FY 2021 in light of the FY 2021 financial statements. Mr Mann also chose to apply a 25% DLOC and a 50% DLOM – compared to the 30% DLOM applied by Mr Wan in his first report. Although Mr Mann stated that he did not agree with the parameters used by Mr Wan (for the reasons set out in Mr Mann’s second report), he continued to use the parameters which Mr Wan had used in his first report. Applying a 25% DLOC and a 50% DLOM, Mr Mann valued the Husband’s shareholding at US$344,689, or S$466,984.
- [71]
[71] In respect of the market approach, Mr Mann took the position that the shares should be valued at US$2.40 per share. He justified this by reference to Mr Wan’s report which utilised the Husband’s 2018 purchase of 19,000 shares from another shareholder at US$2.40 per share. Reliance was also placed on the fact that 96,000 treasury shares had been retired at US$230,400 in each of the two years in 2018 and 2019. Further, Mr Mann applied a 50% DLOM – as compared to the 30% DLOM applied by the DJ. This yielded a valuation figure of S$256,057.20 in respect of the Husband’s 210,000 shares.
- [72]
[72] In applying a 50% DLOM to the valuation of the MS shares, as opposed to a 30% DLOM, Mr Mann opined that the higher 50% discount he used was justified by the following factors: MS shares were not publicly traded; there were onerous restrictions on share transfers (such as a shareholders’ agreement which required consent from the other shareholders before shares could be sold); the shares were unregistered shares; the close-knit relationship among the company’s owners / shareholders who had previously worked with each other (which might deter other buyers from wanting to enter the company); and a relatively minute and/or thin market for the block of shares in question. Further, Mr Mann opined that MS’s business was extremely niche, since it was tied to specialised software applications relevant only to oil and gas producing companies – and used only for one specific discipline in the industry (ie, process engineering). In Mr Mann’s view, this would lead to an extremely thin or minute market for MS’s business. .
- [73]
[73] Using the hybrid approach and taking the average of the valuation figures obtained under the income approach and the market approach, Mr Mann came up with a valuation figure of S$361,520.50 for the Husband’s 210,000 MS shares.
Wife’s Case
- [75]
[75] In arguing for Mr Wan’s revised valuation of S$824,506 to be accepted on appeal, the Wife highlighted that the FY 2021 financial statements showed MS had performed exceedingly well in FY 2021, as compared to FY 2020. In particular, the following metrics showed great improvement:
(a) Revenue (increased by 19%);
(b) Gross profit margin (increased by 27%);
(c) Net profit before tax (increased by 39%);
(d) Cash position (increased by 58%); and
(e) Shareholders’ funds (increased by 22%).
In respect of the last item, the 22% increase in shareholders’ funds was arrived at after taking into account the dividend payments of US$430,476 in 2021 – which, per the Wife’s submission, further highlighted the company’s substantially enhanced performance in FY 2021.
- [77]
[77] In the alternative, the Wife submitted that the value of the Husband’s MS shares should be increased to S$723,501.74. This was because the figures in the FY 2021 financial statements indicated a higher valuation of MS than previous valuations based on the FY 2020 financial statements. Indeed, Mr Mann himself – having had sight of the FY 2021 financial statements – had increased his valuation from S$104,580 to S$361,520.50 – ie, an increase of S$256,940.50. The Wife submitted that this amount of S$256,940.50 should be added to the DJ’s valuation figure of S$466,561.24 so as to yield a higher valuation of S$723,501.74. The Wife argued that the Husband could not complain about this alternative course of action since Mr Mann’s increased valuation of S$361,520.50 was based on a 50% DLOM: if the lower DLOM of 30% were to be adopted, Mr Mann’s revised valuation would in fact be even higher than S$361,520.50.
- [78]
[78] As for Mr Mann’s revised valuation figures, the Wife urged me to reject them on the basis that the Husband’s attempt to rely on these revised figures amounted to a backdoor appeal . In the first place, Mr Mann’s revised figures were even lower than the DJ’s figure of S$466,561.24 – and yet the Husband had not filed any cross-appeal to challenge the correctness of the DJ’s figure. Secondly, Mr Mann had continued to use a 50% DLOM in his further report, even though this had been expressly rejected by the DJ in favour of a 30% DLOM.
Husband’s Case
- [79]
[79] Unsurprisingly, the Husband argued for Mr Mann’s further report to be preferred over Mr Wan’s. In relation to the issue of the appropriate DLOM, the Husband argued that Mr Mann’s choice of a 50% DLOM should be preferred over Mr Wan’s opinion because Mr Wan had (allegedly) failed to justify his choice of a 30% DLOM despite having devoted two short paragraphs in his further report to listing the factors “that affect DLOM”. In contrast, the Husband argued that Mr Mann had cited textual authority for the proposition that DLOM generally ranged from 5% to 50%; and he had explained in his report why a DLOM on the higher end of this scale was appropriate in the case of the MS shares.
- [80]
[80] As to the appropriate valuation methodology, the Husband devoted a large portion of his submissions to criticising Mr Wan’s further report. According to the Husband, it was wrong of Mr Wan to abandon the market approach in his further report. The change in methodology to a singular focus on the income approach had led to a new valuation of S$824,506 which was objectively very high and represented a 76.7% increase from the value of S$466,561.24 assessed by the DJ below. The Husband argued that taken at face value, this implied that MS had almost doubled in value for the financial year 2021.
- [81]
[81] In contrast, according to the Husband, the market approach which Mr Wan had abandoned actually relied on past transaction prices; and as the last relevant transaction had taken place in 2018, the FY 2021 financial statements would have no impact on the share value derived from applying the market approach. If Mr Wan had applied the market approach using a 30% DLOM and a 25% DLOC, the value of the MS shares would have been S$358,479.98. The Husband argued, therefore, that by dropping the market approach in his further report, Mr Wan had drastically increased the value of MS by S$233,013.01. Moreover, according to the Husband, Mr Wan’s explanation for dropping the market approach (ie, that revenue and profits had grown) did not hold water because from FY 2018 to FY 2020, revenue and profits had also grown – and yet Mr Wan had found no issues with relying on the 2018 share transaction in his earlier valuation.
- [82]
[82] As for Mr Wan’s application of the income approach, the Husband appeared to take the position that my directions to parties to submit further expert reports which took into account the impact of the FY 2021 financial statements meant that Mr Wan was permitted simply to input the data from the FY 2021 financial statements into his model. Instead, as the Husband claimed, Mr Wan had unjustifiably changed the parameters and assumptions in his model (compared to those used in his first valuation), thereby artificially increasing the value of the MS shares. The Husband argued that Mr Wan should not be permitted to “arbitrarily” change the parameters of his model, as this prevented any meaningful comparison of his further report with his first report. A further element of unfairness, according to the Husband, arose from the fact that his own expert, Mr Mann, had in his further report adopted the parameters from Mr Wan’s first report: Mr Wan’s choice of different parameters in his latest report therefore meant an unfair shifting of the goalposts for the Husband and his expert.
- [83]
[83] The Husband also found fault with Mr Wan’s decision to add a sum of US$754,572 to the value of MS under an “excess cash adjustment”. The Husband argued that Mr Wan had not made such adjustment in his first valuation because of the uncertainty as to whether projects coming online would require cashflow to sustain their continued growth. According to the Husband, this rationale should apply with even greater force in the latest valuation, given that at least six new partnerships had emerged since Wan’s first valuation, all of which would require cash flow to sustain. In other words, there should be even less reason to make an “excess cash adjustment” in the latest valuation, as compared to the first valuation.
- [84]
[84] In gist, the Husband argued for the hybrid approach (using both the income approach and the market approach and taking the average of the two valuation figures) to be adopted on appeal, albeit subject to the substantially higher DLOM and other parameters and assumptions applied by Mr Mann.
My Decision
Whether the appellate court may consider and determine matters relating to the valuation of the MS shares which were not raised by the Wife in her Appellant’s Case or which were not the subject of a cross-appeal by the Husband
- [85]
[85] As a preliminary point, both the Wife and the Husband have made the argument that the court should disregard matters brought up by the opposing side which were not raised by the Wife in her Appellant’s case or which were not the subject of a cross-appeal by the Husband. For example, the Wife argued that Mr Mann’s valuation should be rejected because his revised valuation figures were even lower than the DJ’s figure of S$466,561.24; and yet no cross-appeal had been filed by the Husband to challenge the correctness of the DJ’s figure. In similar vein, the Husband argued that since the DJ had already accepted Mr Wan’s use of a hybrid approach and since the Wife had not objected to the DJ adopting the same hybrid approach, Mr Wan must be precluded on appeal from adopting a new methodology involving the use of only the income approach.
- [86]
[86] Both parties are wrong in their understanding of the High Court’s powers when hearing an appeal from the Family Courts. Since the present case involves an appeal to the Family Division of the High Court from ancillary orders made by a DJ of the Family Court, r 831(3)(a) and (4) of the Family Justice Rules 2014 (“FJR”) are applicable (see r 821(a)). Rule 831(3) and (4) of the FJR provides that:
Whether it was open to Mr Wan to adopt a different approach from the hybrid approach adopted in his previous expert report
- [89]
[89] I turn to another preliminary issue: the Husband’s contention that the Wife’s expert Mr Wan should be precluded from adopting a different approach from the hybrid approach adopted in his first expert report and/or from changing the parameters and assumptions behind his model under the income approach. In gist, the Husband argued that my directions for further expert reports limited both sides’ experts to simply inputting the data from the FY 2021 financial statements into the models used in their earlier reports.
- [90]
[90] The Husband’s argument is a wholly incorrect characterisation of the further directions I gave. In giving directions for the filing of further expert reports, I had expressly informed parties that I required the experts to explain whether and how the FY 2021 financial statements would impact their original valuations. Clearly, the experts were not limited to considering how the new information disclosed in the FY 2021 financial statements would impact the figures in their earlier reports: there was no reason why they were precluded from concluding, on examining the new information, that their valuation approach would need to be changed or modified – so long as they had cogent reasons for making such changes or modifications.
- [92]
[92] To sum up on this point: nothing in my further directions could be construed as limiting the experts to simply inputting the data from the FY 2021 financial statements into the models used in their earlier reports. Both experts were entitled to conclude, after examining the FY 2021 financial statements, that their valuation approach would need to be changed or modified – so long as they had cogent reasons for making such changes or modifications.
The parties’ experts
- [93]
[93] Having dealt with the preliminary issues, I next address the contents of the expert reports.
- [94]
[94] First, as a general point, having considered the reports presented by each expert, I have reservations about the reliability of Mr Mann’s report. For one, I note that Mr Mann chose 24 March 2021 as the operative date for valuing the shares – both in his first expert report and in his further report. The DJ found that Mr Mann chose this valuation date on the specific instructions of the Husband – and the Husband has not challenged this finding on appeal. The general position is that matrimonial assets should be valued as at the date of the AM hearing (per the CA in TDT v TDS and another appeal and another matter [2016] 4 SLR 145 (“TDT v TDS”) at [50]; also WAS v WAT [2022] SGHCF 7 at [4]; VTU v VTV [2022] SGHCF 23 at [2]; VOW v VOV [2023] SGHCF 9 at [10]). As the CA noted in Yeo Chong Lin v Tay Ang Choo Nancy and another appeal [2011] 2 SLR 1157 at [39], “[o]nce an asset is regarded as a matrimonial asset to be divided, then for the purposes of determining its value, it must be assessed as at the date of the hearing”. The court does of course retain the discretion to depart from the AM hearing date – if there are facts shown to warrant the exercise of such discretion (TDT v TDS at [50]).
- [95]
[95] In the present case, no effort has been made by the Husband – either in the proceedings below or on appeal – to put forward facts which would warrant the court exercising its discretion to depart from the AM hearing date. This is in spite of the DJ’s express criticism of Mr Mann’s decision to value the shares as at 24 March 2021 instead of using the date of the AM hearing. Given that Mr Mann valued the MS shares at a date nearly a year and a half before the actual AM hearing date, it seems to me likely that the accuracy of his valuation will be adversely affected. At the very least, Mr Mann should have furnished an explanation as to why the (significantly) earlier valuation date would have had no material impact on the accuracy and reliability of his valuation, as compared to a valuation conducted as at the date of the AM hearing.
- [96]
[96] It is true that the Wife’s expert Mr Wan also did not use the AM hearing date as the operative date for his valuation of the MS shares: Mr Wan valued the shares as at 31 March 2022. However, I do not find the accuracy of Mr Wan’s expert report to have been adversely affected. The date he used – 31 March 2022 – was less than six months before the AM hearing date. In his report, Mr Wan expressly noted that he had not used the AM hearing date of 17 August 2022 – and he took pains to explain that it was highly unlikely that there would be a material difference between a valuation as at 31 March 2022 and a valuation as at 17 August 2022 (the ancillary hearing date). In gist, Mr Wan explained that he had conducted the valuation on a going concern basis; that there had been no significant changes in the industry and market outlook of MS between the two dates; and that his consideration of updates and latest news from MS throughout 2022 made it highly unlikely that there would be a material difference between a valuation done at both dates.
- [97]
[97] Next, I note that in addition to having departed from the AM hearing date without giving any reasons, Mr Mann adopted in his further report the valuation approach adopted by Mr Wan in his first expert report – despite the fact that he had, in his second report, heavily criticised Mr Wan’s approach. In his second report, Mr Mann had decried Mr Wan’s use of the market approach valuation methodology as being clearly inappropriate and unsound (besides being incorrectly applied, according to Mr Mann). As for Mr Wan’s use of the income approach in his first report, Mr Mann had asserted that it was “improper” for Mr Wan to have chosen the income approach; further, that the assumptions and projections relied on by Mr Wan under the income approach were erroneous and inherently unreliable.
- [98]
[98] Given his detailed criticism of Mr Wan’s valuation approach, I find it disconcerting that in his further report, Mr Mann has nevertheless elected to adopt, firstly, the market approach substantially similar to that which was relied on in Mr Wan’s first report. Mr Mann also chose in his further report to adopt the income approach, applying substantially the same parameters used in Mr Wan’s first report. Unfortunately, Mr Mann did not provide any explanation for this apparent about-face. In light of these circumstances, I am inclined to question the objectivity of Mr Mann’s expert opinion, and the reliability of the valuation figure(s) put forward by him.
- [99]
[99] This does not mean that I endorse in entirety the approach adopted by Mr Wan in his further report, wherein he jettisoned the hybrid approach and relied solely on the income approach. In the next section of this judgment, I explain my reasoning.
Whether Mr Wan had erred in abandoning the market approach
- [100]
[100] In gist, Mr Wan justified his decision to jettison the market approach on the basis that the FY 2021 financial statements showed considerable growth in the company’s revenue and profits. Aside from the increase in revenue and profits, Mr Wan did not give any other explanation for his decision to drop the market approach in his further report.
- [101]
[101] It should be highlighted that in his first report, Mr Wan had actually explained in detail his rationale for adopting a hybrid approach whereby he applied both the market approach and the income approach before taking the average of the two valuation figures obtained. For ease of reference, I reproduce below the relevant passages from Mr Wan’s earlier report:
- [102]
[102] Per Mr Wan’s reasoning in his earlier report, it appears that a key consideration in the use of the market approach would be the availability of current or at least recent transactions in the shares. As he noted (above), a purchase price derived from transactions closer than “2-3 years ago” would be considered more current and would accordingly justify a larger than 50% weightage for the market approach. In the present case, since the relevant transactions had taken place “2-3 years ago”, he chose to assign a 50% weightage to the market approach in the application of the hybrid approach. He did not at any point caveat that an increase in the company’s revenue and profits would also affect the weightage to be assigned to the market approach.
- [103]
[103] Indeed, as the Husband pointed out, revenue and profits had also risen between FY 2018 and FY 2020: this was evident from the financial statements already available prior to August 2022 (which included the FY 2020 financial statements) – and yet Mr Wan had not found any issues with relying on the 2018 share transactions in his earlier valuation. As the Husband pointed out, in the period between FY 2018 and FY 2020, the company’s revenue increased by 22% and its profits increased by 27%; whereas in the period between FY 2018 and FY 2021, the increase in revenue and profits amounted to 45.5% and 66.2% respectively. Mr Wan has not explained in his further report why an increase in revenue and profits of 45.5% and 66.2% respectively would render the market approach unsuitable for use in valuing the shares – whereas an increase in revenue and profits by 22% and 27% respectively would not.
- [104]
[104] In the circumstances, I find that Mr Wan was unable to proffer any reasonable explanation for his decision to abandon the market approach in his further report. I agree with the DJ that the hybrid approach is appropriate in the present case, ie, applying both the market approach and the income approach with a 50% weightage for each approach, and then taking the average of the two valuation figures. I add that I have chosen to maintain the 50% weightage for each approach in view of the absence of any submissions from either party for the weightage to be modified.
Whether DLOM and DLOC should be applied to the shares under the market approach
- [105]
[105] Having determined that a hybrid approach should be used to value the MS shares, I next address the issue of whether under the market approach, a DLOM and a DLOC should be applied in the valuation of the shares. It will be recalled that the Husband argued for this, on the basis of Mr Mann’s opinion evidence; whereas the Wife argued against it, on the basis of Mr Wan’s opinion evidence.
- [106]
[106] In Kiri Industries Ltd v Senda International Capital Ltd and another and other appeals and other matters [2022] SGCA(I) 5 (“Kiri Industries”), the CA held (in the context of minority oppression proceedings) that “[l]ack of marketability would be industry specific”; and it would be best left to the expertise of an independent valuer to decide whether to apply the DLOM to the valuation exercise of the shares (at [241]-[243] of Kiri Industries). In the present case, given that the two experts have given differing opinion evidence on the applicability of a DLOM (and a DLOC) to the valuation of the MS shares under the market approach, it fell to the court to decide the issue based on its evaluation of the experts’ evidence.
- [107]
[107] In his earlier report, Mr Wan explained that in valuing the shares under the market approach, he did not apply a DLOM and a DLOC to the Husband’s 2018 purchase of 19,000 shares at US$2.40 per share because the transaction was already subject to DLOM and DLOC conditions. This was because the 2018 share purchase was carried out at a time when the company was not listed; and the shares which changed hands in that transaction also formed a non-majority and non-controlling stake. Given these factors, Mr Wan explained that applying a DLOM and a DLOC to the US$2.40 figure would be double counting the discounts.
- [108]
[108] Mr Mann disagreed with Mr Wan and maintained that a DLOM of 50% and a DLOC of 25% should apply in the context of both the market approach and the income approach. According to Mr Mann, a non-controlling interest in an unlisted company would normally be valued at a discount of the equivalent shares of the same company (if listed) given the lack of a ready market for shares in an unlisted company and the potential share transfer restrictions that may have existed.
- [109]
[109] Having considered the experts’ evidence and the parties’ submissions, I am of the view that Mr Wan’s position is the correct one. My reasons are as follows.
- [110]
[110] So far as I can tell, when the 19,000 MS shares changed hands in 2018, the purchaser (the Husband) and the seller (his fellow shareholder) were acting as rational players dealing at arm’s length with each other. The International Valuation Standards (“IVS”) defines an “at an arm’s length transaction” as one that is conducted “between parties who do not have a particular or special relationship, eg. parent and subsidiary companies or landlord and tenant, that may make the price level uncharacteristic of the market or inflated”. Per this definition, the “Market Value transaction is presumed to be between unrelated parties, each acting independently”.
- [111]
[111] Mr Mann has highlighted that the shareholders of MS previously worked together in another company, and for that reason, he has sought to characterise their relationship as being a “tightly knit” one. However, on the evidence available, there is nothing to suggest that their previous experience of working together had forged such an intimate or special relationship between the MS shareholders that each of them would not have been capable of acting independently in the sale and purchase of shares as among themselves. As such, there is no reason for me to doubt that in the 2018 transaction, the Husband and his fellow shareholder would have factored into the pricing those considerations relating to the lack of marketability and lack of control which a minority shareholding in a company such as MS (non-listed, niche business, restrictions on share transfers, etc.) necessarily entailed.
- [112]
[112] The inference I draw above is buttressed by the fact that 96,000 treasury shares were retired in each of the two years in 2018 and 2019 at US$230,400 – which worked out to US$2.40 per share as well. To my mind, the retirement of treasury shares must (in the absence of evidence otherwise) be taken to be an assessment of the market value by the MS shareholders. As I have noted, there is nothing in the evidence to suggest any sort of special relationship as between the MS shareholders which would have caused them not to act independently. In the retirement of treasury shares, therefore, I would expect the shareholders to have acted independently, in a manner consistent with their own commercial interests. There was no reason why the shareholders would have wanted to retire the treasury shares for anything other than what they believed to be market value, given the likelihood of these past transactions being relied on to arrive at a valuation in future sales of MS shares.
- [113]
[113] For the reasons explained above, therefore, I am of the view that the US$2.40 figure seen in the Husband’s 2018 purchase of shares and in the retirement of treasury shares represented the market value of the shares, as perceived by the shareholders themselves. This means the figure would already have factored in those considerations relating to lack of marketability and lack of control. As Mr Wan put it in his first report, the value of US$2.40 per share would have been based on the collective knowledge and decision by the shareholders of the company premised on the outlook as well as the potential of the company. I agree with Mr Wan that to apply further discounts to this value by way of a DLOM and a DLOC would be to double-count the considerations of lack of marketability and lack of control.
- [114]
[114] For completeness, I note that Mr Mann has said that the IVS requires valuers to consider the application of both a DLOM and DLOC under the market approach. I reproduce below the relevant portion of the IVS cited by him:
- [115]
[115] I do not think the above extract is of any assistance to the Husband’s case. From this extract, it is clear that although a DLOM and DLOC may be something for a valuer to consider when utilising the market approach, it is not mandatory for both forms of discount to be applied whenever the market approach is adopted. Rather, a DLOM should be applied under the market approach when the comparables are deemed to have superior marketability to the subject asset. Likewise, the DLOC should be applied under the market approach to reflect differences between the comparables and the subject asset. In the present case, since the comparables and the subject asset under the market approach adopted are one and the same (ie, past transactions of MS shares are used to derive the present market value of MS shares), it would follow that the DLOM and the DLOC should not be applied.
The appropriate DLOM to apply
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.