Family Division of the High Court · Decided 2 September 2025
VBR v VBS
Feedback & support[2025] SGHCF 54 · Case no. District Court Appeal No 109 of 2024 · 8 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The Appellant, a Singapore permanent resident (“PR”), aged 48, is an information technology (“IT”) manager at a multi-national corporation. The Respondent, is aged 45 and also a Singapore PR. She was employed as a data analyst, but ceased employment on 23 April 2025. They married in July 2006, and they have a son and a daughter, aged 16 and 13, respectively (the “Children”). The Appellant commenced divorce proceedings on 4 April 2017. Interim Judgment was granted on 16 August 2017 and the Ancillary Matters orders were made on 16 August 2019. The Appellant and Respondent have joint custody over the Children, with the Respondent having sole care and control and the Appellant having access.
- [3]
[3] Specifically, the Appellant appeals as follows:
(a) The DJ overestimated the reasonable expenses of the Children;
(b) he did not consider the Appellant’s position for the reasonable expenses of the Children;
(c) he did not take the Appellant’s expenses into account;
(e) his ruling on the Medical Insurance was ambiguous;
(f) he double counted the Children’s expenses for food;
(g) he did not apply the principle of proportionality in maintenance; and
(h) now the Appellant seeks what he considers to be reasonable expenses for the Children, and the distribution between him and the Respondent.
- [4]
[4] I shall consider (a), (b), (e), (f) and (h) together. They concern the DJ’s decision on the reasonable expenses of the Children. The Appellant contested almost every expense that was decided upon (points (a), (e) and (f)) and argued that the DJ did not consider his position on the reasonable expenses of the Children (point (b)) and proposes his version of what would be reasonable (point (h)). I am of the view that some items require adjustment. The learned DJ below had included expenditure that would have been incurred by the Respondent in any event (even without care and control), into the expenses of the Children. As held in WLE v WLF [2023] SGHCF 14 (“WLE”) at [18], this should not be considered in determining child maintenance. The consequential orders are therefore:
(a) “Internet/Mobile” charges to be reduced from S$20 to S$10 per child. The learned DJ considered S$20 as covering “internet usage” and “a single subscription to a streaming service”. However, the “internet usage” (which is taken to mean “Wi-Fi” expenses) is a cost that would have been incurred by the Respondent (for herself), even if she did not have care and control of the Children. S$10 will remain for the “single subscription to a streaming service”.
(b) “Service and Conservancy Charges” is to be excluded. This is an expense that the Respondent would have incurred in any event.
- [5]
[5] However, I disagree with the Appellant that repairs should be excluded. The wear and tear of items will increase with the number of occupants. Unlike the above-mentioned items, this is not an expense that would have been incurred if the Respondent did not have care and control.
- [6]
[6] Regarding the other points, I find that the DJ’s findings were reasonable. The Appellant’s allegation that the DJ did not consider his position is rejected. The learned DJ had considered the various positions advanced by the Appellant. This is evident from the remarks column, which sets out the Appellant’s objections, and explains why she decided against him. For example, at [25] of his decision, the DJ acknowledged the Appellant’s reservations about the Children requiring a domestic helper but still decided in favour of retaining the domestic helper. Accordingly, save for the amendments to “Internet/Mobile” and “Service and Conservancy Charges”, points (a), (b), (e), (f) and (h) are dismissed.
- [8]
[8] Turning to point (g), the Appellant asserts that his high monthly expenses should be accounted for in the apportionment of child maintenance between himself and the Respondent. The Appellant argues that the financial burden of child maintenance should be borne equally (ie, 50:50), citing TBC v TBD [2015] SGHC 130. However, that position has been clarified in WBU v WBT [2023] SGHCF 3 (“WBU”) at [35], where Ong JAD found that:
- [9]
[9] Therefore, there is nothing wrong in principle with the DJ having apportioned the Children’s maintenance in unequal proportions, based on the parties respective means and capabilities. Furthermore, the Appellant has not shown why the method of calculation that the DJ adopted was wrong. The Appellant claims that the Respondent earns almost an equal amount based on the payslips from near the time of the lower court’s decision and thus should bear an equal proportion. However, it is clear when viewing the IRAS NOA of both parties that their incomes vary significantly. The DJ below correctly adopted this approach as a starting point. In fact, the DJ had also already addressed the Appellant’s point in the decision, by accounting for the Respondent’s increased income capacity, based on those payslips, in the final apportionment.
- [10]
[10] The Appellant also contends that his personal expenses should be accounted for in the apportionment. It is true that when ascertaining the financial capacity of a party significant liabilities and financial commitments of that party have to be considered (see WBU at [38]). The reasonableness of those liabilities and commitments must be taken into account, but from the findings above at [7], the liabilities and financial commitments of the Appellant are unreasonable and self-interested. Therefore, it should not be factored into the apportionment analysis. Accordingly, point (g) is without merit and is dismissed.