The text
PERMISSION TO MEMBERS TO BE ABSENT Under the provisions of clause 2(d) of Article 46 of the Constitution of the Republic of Singapore, the following Members have been granted permission to be or to remain absent from sittings of Parliament (or any Committee of Parliament to which they have been appointed) for the periods stated: NameFromTo (2000)(2000) Dr Teo Ho Pin12 Oct18 Oct 23 Oct27 Oct 18 Nov24 Nov NameFromTo (2000)(2000) Mr Loh Meng See12 Oct14 Oct 24 Oct24 Oct 2 Nov4 Nov 7 Nov10 Nov Mr Lim Swee Say13 Oct22 Oct 6 Nov7 Nov Dr Ker Sin Tze15 Oct29 Oct Mr Lim Hng Kiang15 Oct17 Oct Mr Chew Heng Ching16 Oct20 Oct 30 Oct31 Oct Mr Ong Ah Heng17 Oct23 Oct Mr Peh Chin Hua17 Oct27 Oct 14 Nov21 Nov Mr Yeo Guat Kwang18 Oct23 Oct 27 Oct29 Oct Prof S Jayakumar18 Oct23 Oct 11 Nov17 Nov Mr Goh Chee Wee20 Oct28 Oct 17 Nov30 Nov 6 Dec11 Dec 14 Dec20 Dec Mr David Lim T E22 Oct26 Oct 1 Nov3 Nov 12 Nov16 Nov 25 Nov25 Nov Mr Ang Mong Seng23 Oct28 Oct Mr Ong Kian Min23 Oct31 Oct Assoc Prof Toh See Kiat 24 Oct24 Oct 28 Oct2 Nov 6 Nov14 Nov Encik Ibrahim bin Othman25 Oct31 Oct Mr Tan Soo Khoon 27 Oct27 Oct 31 Oct1 Nov 18 Nov24 Nov Mr Inderjit Singh29 Oct3 Nov 27 Nov28 Nov Assoc Prof Yaacob Ibrahim 31 Oct31 Oct Assoc Prof Low Seow Chay31 Oct1 Nov 13 Nov16 Nov Mr S Iswaran31 Oct3 Nov 8 Nov9 Nov 17 Nov24 Nov 15 Dec27 Dec Mr Charles Chong1 Nov4 Nov 6 Nov8 Nov Mrs Lim Hwee Hua4 Nov8 Nov Mr Peter Chen4 Nov16 Nov 18 Nov3 Dec Dr Wang Kai Yuen5 Nov10 Nov Mr Tay Beng Chuan5 Nov12 Nov NameFromTo (2000)(2000) Mr Bernard Chen5 Nov16 Nov Mr Chng Hee Kok6 Nov8 Nov 13 Nov17 Nov Mr Lee Yock Suan9 Nov12 Nov Mr Hawazi Daipi9 Nov16 Nov Mr Abdullah Tarmugi10 Nov12 Nov Mrs Yu-Foo Yee Shoon10 Nov20 Nov Dr Ong Chit Chung11 Nov12 Nov BG George Yong-Boon Yeo11 Nov17 Nov Dr Tony Tan Keng Yam12 Nov20 Nov Dr Ow Chin Hock 13 Nov13 Nov Dr Lee Boon Yang 13 Nov13 Nov Mr K Shanmugam 13 Nov13 Nov Mr Davinder Singh 13 Nov13 Nov Mr Tang Guan Seng13 Nov19 Nov Mr Zulkifli Baharudin14 Nov16 Nov Mr Goh Chok Tong14 Nov17 Nov Mr Noris Ong Chin Guan15 Nov2 Dec Mr Wong Kan Seng18 Nov19 Nov Mr Mohamad Maidin BPM18 Nov30 Nov Mr Lee Kuan Yew19 Nov22 Nov 6 Dec9 Dec Mr Ahmad Mohd Magad19 Nov25 Nov Mr Seng Han Thong21 Nov25 Nov 19 Dec29 Dec Dr Tan Cheng Bock24 Nov27 Nov Assoc Prof Koo Tsai Kee26 Nov29 Nov BG Lee Hsien Loong29 Nov30 Nov RAdm Teo Chee Hean5 Dec15 Dec Dr John Chen6 Dec22 Dec Mr Matthias Yao Chih12 Dec25 Dec Dr Hu Tsu Tau Richard22 Dec5 Jan 01 TAN SOO KHOON Speaker Parliament of Singapore
ASSENT TO BILLS PASSED The following Bills were assented to by the President of the Republic of Singapore on the date stated: 16 October 2000 (i) Compulsory Education Bill; and (ii) Statutes (Miscellaneous Amendments and Repeal) Bill. TAN SOO KHOON Speaker Parliament of Singapore
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE AIRLINES FLIGHT SQ 006 - (Preliminary report) asked the Minister for Communications and Information Technology if he will provide a preliminary report on the causes of the crash of the ill-fated Singapore Airlines flight SQ 006 in Taipei on 31st October 2000.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE AIRLINES FLIGHT SQ 006 - (Preliminary report) asked the Minister for Communications and Information Technology when he expects the investigation of the crash of flight SQ 006 at Taipei to be completed.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE AIRLINES FLIGHT SQ 006 - (Preliminary report) Mr Speaker, Sir, may I have your permission to answer Question Nos. 1 and 2 together?
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE AIRLINES FLIGHT SQ 006 - (Preliminary report) Yes.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE AIRLINES FLIGHT SQ 006 - (Preliminary report) First, let me express on behalf of the Singapore Government, our deepest sympathies to the families and friends of those who were affected by the crash of flight SQ 006. The Government is indeed deeply saddened by this tragic accident. I will now update the House on the progress of the investigations. The Aviation Safety Council (ASC) of Taiwan is leading the investigations into the accident, with the support of experts from the USA, Singapore and Australia. The investigators will determine the cause of the accident and recommend measures to prevent future occurrences. As Members already know, preliminary findings revealed that the aircraft had taken off from the wrong runway, 05R, instead of the designated 05L. Investigators are trying to find out how and why this happened. To do this, the investigator-in-charge, Dr Yong Kay of the Aviation Safety Council of Taiwan, has indicated that the investigators would need to gather all factual data and do the necessary analysis. He has indicated that it would take about a year to complete the investigation.
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE AIRLINES FLIGHT SQ 006 - (Preliminary report) Mr Speaker, Sir, may I ask the Minister what is the prospect of our three pilots facing prosecution by the Taiwanese government?
ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS - SINGAPORE AIRLINES FLIGHT SQ 006 - (Preliminary report) Sir, the Taiwanese authorities have stated that they would let the investigations continue before deciding what to do.
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) asked the Acting Minister for the Environment if he will (i) give an update on the outbreak of the hand, foot and mouth disease; (ii) state whether the disease is under control; and (iii) inform what precaution his Ministry will take to avoid similar situation in the future.
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) Mr Speaker, Sir, hand, foot and mouth disease (HFMD) is a common mild childhood disease. Very rarely does it result in deaths. However, on the morning of 30th September, two siblings aged one and two died, within two hours of each other. Upon notification that morning, the Commissioner of Public Health immediately activated the Task Force that was formed two years ago following the outbreaks of HFMD in the region in 1998. The Task Force recommended the closure of all pre-schools effective from 2nd October. The objective was to isolate the children and protect them from contracting the disease. The Minister for the Environment accepted the recommendation. The directive went out immediately to all the pre-schools on the same day. The quick and decisive action by the Government, together with the concerted efforts of the public, pre-schools, media and employers proved to be effective. I am pleased to report to the House that the outbreak has been brought under control. The number of reported cases per day reached a peak of 258 on 4th October, and declined steadily to 9 on 31st October. All pre-schools have reopened since 16th October. The situation is now back to normal. On behalf of the multi-agency task force, I would like to take this opportunity to thank the parents and members of the public, pre-school and kindergarten teachers, doctors at the Kandang Kerbau Women and Children Hospital, the National University Hospital, the Singapore General Hospital and doctors in private practice, affected employers, and various Government agencies for their understanding, support and cooperation. HFMD is spread through close contact among children. The most effective measure to prevent future outbreaks is to maintain a high standard of hygiene in pre-school centres and at home. Parents and teachers also need to remain vigilant, and keep infected children away from other children. The multi-agency task force will continue to strengthen guidelines relating to hygiene standards and sick bay operations to prevent future outbreaks as much as we can.
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) Sir, is the Minister confirming that we have completely eliminated or at least we have brought it down to the level that it was at the previous outbreak status in terms of the number of children contracting the disease? In terms of precaution, is the Minister saying that just cleanliness and hygiene is an issue or can we actually take other medical precautions to prevent our children from contracting this disease in the first place?
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) Sir, the hand, foot and mouth disease is an endemic disease, ie, it is there all the time. Last year, before we imposed the compulsory reporting of HFMD, we had about 25 cases a week. During the recent outbreak, it went up to as high as 258 cases per day. Since then, it has come down to about 10 cases per day. 10 cases per day will work out to about 70 cases per week. It would appear to be still higher than the 25 cases per week last year. However, there was no compulsory reporting last year whereas today there is compulsory reporting. Our assessment is that at 10 cases per day, we are now back to the normal situation. Mr Inderjit Singh also asked whether beyond cleanliness, is there a medical solution. Sir, at this moment, there is no medical cure to the hand, foot and mouth disease, in particular, the EV71 virus. There is also no vaccine available. However, I want to highlight that when we say "there is no cure", it does not mean that every child who has contracted the disease will face the danger of death. As an illustration, in the outbreak in Taiwan, there were about 1.4 million cases and over 70 death cases, ie, one casualty out of 20,000 cases. I want to emphasise that there is no need for the public to be alarmed that the hand, foot and mouth disease is there all the time. What is important is for us to continue to take measures to reduce the number and to keep it to as low as possible, bearing in mind that this disease is, generally speaking, not harmful.
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) May I ask the Minister whether, for the control of the disease spread, child care centre operators are being facilitated by his Ministry on correct maintenance of the child care centres and on the proper screening of the students in the centres? May I also ask whether there is a new protocol for vigilance and pro-active closing of an infected centre to curb the disease spread and also avoid a nation-wide closure of the child care centres in the future?
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) Mr Speaker, Sir, there are two types of pre-school centres in Singapore. They are the kindergartens and the child care centres. The child care centres are licensed by the Ministry of Community Development and Sports (MCDS) and the kindergartens by the Ministry of Education. Both types of pre-school centres are subjected to hygiene guidelines issued by the Ministry of the Environment, Ministry of Education and MCDS. In fact, the last time we updated our guidelines was in March this year. As a result of the recent outbreak, the Task Force has decided to further update the guidelines. A new set of guidelines will be issued soon. On Dr Lily Neo's second question regarding the screening of children, it is true that many teachers and parents were not aware of the proper actions to be taken during the recent outbreak. What has happened was that we actually had cases of children who had contracted the hand, foot and mouth disease but continued to attend school. For the child care centres, sick bay is a standard facility. We do not have much problem because the infected children are isolated. But in the case of kindergartens, there is no practice of having a sick bay. As a result, some of the children were allowed to continue to interact with the other children. As a result of the recent outbreak, we have now issued clear guidelines to all kindergartens that for those without sick bay facility, they would still have to isolate the children, using the principal's office or any other facility. At the same time, they have to notify the parents immediately. This practice has been put in place. Over the last one month, we are seeing a very effective decline in the number of cases. So we intend to continue to enforce such hygiene practices so that, hopefully, we will not see another outbreak and we do not have to close the schools in the future.
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) I would like to ask the Minister whether through the process we have identified any highly susceptible facilities like sand bays, playgrounds or swimming pools and so on, that are actually causing a bigger probability of this disease being spread and are we going to review the building and maintenance policy of such facilities. The other question I have, which is still not very clear, is why we have had this disease at a steady state and what was the reason for the sudden increase this time round.
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) Sir, the spread of the disease is basically through direct contact among the children. For example, if a child were to pick up a piece of toy and puts it into his or her mouth and before the saliva dries up another child picks it up and puts into his or her mouth, it can be transmitted. Therefore, in the case of sand bays and so on, it is probably not the primary mode of transmission. What we have done, as I have mentioned earlier, is to enforce the hygiene practices in the schools. For example, in our hygiene guidelines, there is a clear regulation that all toys must be washed at the end of the day every day and any items where the children can put into their mouth are not supposed to be placed in a common area for the children to share. All these guidelines will now be further enforced. As to the sudden increase, prior to 1st October, the hand, foot and mouth disease was not a notifiable disease. As a result, we have to rely on the reporting from the child care centres. The information we were getting was not complete and not up to date. Since 1st October this year, all hand, foot and mouth disease cases will have to be reported because it is now a notifiable infectious disease. Henceforth, we should be able to monitor very closely. Should there be any increase, we will be able to take responsive action before it gets out of control.
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) May I ask the Minister what was the reason for the long delay in confirming the diagnosis of the recent hand, foot and mouth disease occurrence, whether there is now an improved channel for speedier laboratory confirmation of the hand, foot and mouth virus, and whether this virology testing is available to all doctors for earlier and correct diagnosis?
HAND, FOOT AND MOUTH DISEASE - (Update on outbreak) Mr Speaker, Sir, in the case of unnatural death, it is a standard practice that we will do a post-mortem. In the process, there are actually two steps involved. The first step is to detect the presence of the relevant virus. And the second step is to identify exactly what strain of virus it is. Take, for example, in the case of the hand, foot and mouth disease, the most common virus is the family under the enterovirus, and there are over 60 different strains. Within a few days, we are able to identify the presence of enterovirus. But the next step is to identify if it is a coxsackie A16 or EV71, or something else. For that to happen, the medical laboratory will have to isolate the sample. They have to culture the virus to see whether there are any reactions. So that typically will take a few weeks. Just to give you an example. We actually did the isolation in parallel in a Singapore facility as well as to send a sample to the CDC (Communicable Disease Centre) in Atlanta. In fact, both centres identified the presence of EV71 almost at the same time. It shows that there was no delay on our part, because even with a very reputable facility in Atlanta, it takes about the same time. This is because we have to go through that period of time for the virus to be cultured, to be grown, and to be identified. Sir, I want to assure the public that we do have an up-to-date facility and that there was no delay in identifying the virus. Unfortunately, the process does take time. But having said that, it does not mean that we will not further invest in upgrading our capability. In fact, the Task Force is now looking into what kind of new facilities and capabilities we ought to invest in Singapore so that in future, should there be any infectious disease outbreak, we will be able to continue to respond very rapidly.
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) asked the Minister for National Development, in view of the rapid increase in oil prices, whether his Ministry is considering any new measures for energy conservation.
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) Mr Speaker, Sir, in 1998, an Inter-Agency Committee on Energy Efficiency (IACEE) was chaired by the Ministry of National Development. It was formed to address the concerns over the increasing consumption of energy in Singapore and to look into improving the efficient usage of energy. When this Committee was formed, oil prices were low at about US$15 per barrel. This shows that the Committee was formed at a time when the prices were low and there was no knee jerk reaction to the present energy prices. But now that it has gone up to over US$30 per barrel, the need to act on energy conservation has become all the more urgent and important. The IACEE has completed its study and released its recommendations to the media in May this year. The recommendations are wide-ranging, long term and attainable. Various agencies are working towards achieving these recommendations. In summary, Sir, these include: Reviewing and developing building regulations on energy efficiency by the Building and Construction Authority (BCA); Expanding the Green Labelling Scheme under the Singapore Environment Council which works in cooperation with the Ministry of the Environment (ENV). Under this scheme, equipment which meets certain efficiency and environment labelling standards would be allowed to have a Singapore Green Label, and I believe SEC will be launching this label very soon; Incorporating energy efficiency as an objective of our land transport policy. Sir, you have heard Dr John Chen announce the hybrid car scheme; and Monitoring and reviewing the pricing of electricity, and creating awareness amongst consumers on using energy efficiently by the Public Utilities Board (PUB). Sir, with the current rapid increase in oil prices, the IACEE is coordinating the efforts of all the various agencies, including PUB, ENV and the Land Transport Authority (LTA), to roll out on an urgent basis a series of programmes to inform and educate the consumers on ways to conserve energy and use energy more efficiently.
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) Sir, can I ask the Senior Parliamentary Secretary which sector is the largest energy consumer, whether it is the residential, commercial or industrial sector? Secondly, he has mentioned a lot of measures to be introduced. Can he tell us whether these measures are recommendations or with some enforcement rules attached to them?
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) To his first question, which property sector consumes the most energy, whether it is residential, commercial or industrial, the answer is, of course, industrial, because they are heavy users of energy, like our petrochemical companies. But these are bottomline focused MNCs, so they know what they are doing. And I am sure that they would have factored the cost of energy into their production, because they need to compete on a world-wide basis. But we found that most of the energy is channelled through air-conditioning as well as refrigeration. So the commercial and residential sectors have more scope to improve their energy efficiency. On the recommendations, whether they are achievable or attainable, yes, of course they are. These are long-term objectives. Although our energy efficiency is quite good, we can always improve further. We have put together various recommendations. The agencies are looking into these recommendations and rolling out their implementation plans.
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) May I ask the Senior Parliamentary Secretary whether the Government will take the lead in this area and set the example by trying to make sure that public buildings continually become more efficient in use of energy.
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) Mr Speaker, Sir, this is indeed one of the recommendations of the report published in May. The public sector is a large sector, and we intend to use the public sector as the leading sector to promote energy efficiency. But having said that, most of the public buildings are quite new and they are really very energy-efficient. So the scope for improvement may be limited. But, nonetheless, we are attempting for a start to band the energy efficiency of all the bigger public buildings. The BCA has compiled an initial list and it would be circulated internally to all the various statutory boards and Ministries. So within the Ministries, they will know which building is more efficient, which is less efficient vis-a-vis the other Ministry's buildings, and this will be compiled on the basis of floor area, usage hours, things like that.
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) Hearing the Government's intent to band and grade their own buildings, would it be possible for this list to be shared with experts and practitioners from the private sector, so that we can have more transparency into how different buildings are performing?
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) Mr Speaker, Sir, we will take that suggestion into consideration. This is only the beginning. So we thought we will try out with the public sector buildings first, because it is easier for us to collect energy data. But certainly it is a step that we want to advance in the future.
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) Would the Senior Parliamentary Secretary consider some incentives for private sector to be more efficient in their buildings?
ENERGY CONSERVATION - (New measures) We are looking at the examples of other countries to see how we can encourage developers, for example, to be more conscious of energy efficiency. We are exploring this. BCA, I believe, is talking to URA and at some time they will talk to REDAS and all the other contractors to see how we can make our buildings more efficient.
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME asked the Minister for National Development what is the current demand for public housing and whether the Government will revise the public housing development programme to match the actual demand for the next 5 to 10 years.
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Mr Speaker, Sir, in the first nine months of this year, HDB received 9,600 applications under its Registration for Flats System (RFS). The average monthly application for new flats this year therefore works out to about 1,100 per month, compared to about 800 in 1999 and 700 in 1998. As at September 2000, there were 35,600 applicants on the waiting list for HDB flats. HDB will continue to monitor the demand closely and adjust its building programme according to the demand.
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Sir, it appears that HDB has achieved its primary role of providing affordable housing to most Singaporeans. Is it time now for HDB to reduce its role, ie, to give the private sector more opportunities to meet the increasing sophisticated housing demands of Singaporeans?
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Mr Speaker, Sir, I think there is a role for both the public and the private sectors to play in housing our population. In fact, the HDB has more than achieved its purpose of creating communities where our people can live in good quality public housing. At the present moment, more than 85%, roughly 86%, of our people live in public housing. It has been discussed in both the public and private domains that a long-term target is to have more Singaporeans living in private housing. Indeed, this, I believe, is the aspiration of many Singaporeans, to be able to upgrade to private housing. In the 1991 Concept Plan, for example, there was discussion about increasing the mix of private housing vis-a-vis public housing. This is now currently under discussion in the present Concept Plan review and this is where we will be discussing the matter more extensively - URA together with members of the public and other interested parties. When that discussion is complete, I think we will have a rough idea of which direction we are heading.
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME May I ask the Minister, now that the number of applications for HDB flats has lessened and the waiting time is less, can HDB give a more accurate completion time? There are a lot of applicants who are told of a certain time they can take over the flat, but now, for example, they are very often told that in one year or 11/2 years the flat will be ready, and they get panicky because they are not ready financially or physically. Can HDB give a more accurate target date for the completion of the flats?
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Mr Speaker, Sir, I think the Member's point is a valid one. In fact, we have been receiving quite a lot of feedback from Members of Parliament that, where in the past, applicants had to wait for a long time for their flats, now they are actually getting their flats faster than they want them, primarily because they have not been able to accumulate enough savings in their CPF in order to pay for the downpayment. I think it is a happy state of affairs, in some ways. But it is also incumbent upon the HDB now, with slowing demand and with greater control over the building programme, to be able to monitor more closely the progress of the building programme and to therefore give a more accurate assessment, as the Member has mentioned just now. HDB will be looking into ways and means of matching supply and demand more accurately.
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Sir, in relation to the Minister's answer, I believe that the HDB has a scheme to allow the 20% deposit payment to be made in two instalments for those who cannot afford it. May I ask the Minister to extend this to 5-room flats too?
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Sir, this change or revision to the policy of allowing the deposit of 20% to be split into two instalments was primarily to allow younger couples who are not able to afford the 20% downpayment to therefore get the HDB flat, as it were. The reason why the decision was taken to restrict this concession to the 4-room flats was that if you are actually applying for a 5-room flat and therefore your deposit is larger, then affordability should not be in the picture. Therefore, in so far as this being a concession is concerned, the relaxation is only for the 4-roomers. It is a question of affordability as well as being able to get their flats faster.
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME May I remind the Minister that because of the shorter waiting period as well as the reduced CPF payments due to the economic crisis, the ability to build up enough balances in the CPF for the 20% deposit has been greatly impaired. In that case, may I again ask the Minister whether he will consider the 5-room option too, Sir?
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Sir, as I said, it is a question of affordability. And if it is a matter of not being able to build enough balances in the CPF for a 5-room flat, then I would suggest that the young couple consider a 4-room flat instead where together with the split, delayed or deferred instalment, I think affordability would no longer be an issue.
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME In meeting the demand for housing of Singaporeans, may I ask the Minister to clarify the HDB's position on the building of smaller and smaller flats while it seems that Singaporeans have a great energy for retaining the existing flats or even bigger and bigger flats?
PUBLIC HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME Sir, this matter came to the attention of the public recently by way of media reports that HDB was downsizing its flats. Over the last 10 to 15 years, there is no doubt that there had been several demographic changes taking place, not least of which is the downsizing of the family unit. So the average household size over the last 10 to 15 years has come down, to around four today and, if the trend persists, to something less than four. That is one of the changes that is taking place that HDB has taken into account in its building programme. But having said that, there is no intention at this point in time for HDB to further downsize its flats. It has already done so slowly over the last many, many years. And currently, the intention is for HDB to continue to build flats of this size because this is the level of comfort and the level of public housing that we believe is affordable for Singaporeans and also affordable for the state. I think HDB has made it quite clear that there is no intention to further downsize the flats at this point in time.
SINGTEL SHARES - (Probe on spurt buying) asked the Deputy Prime Minister whether the Singapore Exchange (SGX) has completed its probe on the last minute spurt buying of SingTel shares on 13th October 2000 resulting in the sudden upward surge of STI index.
SINGTEL SHARES - (Probe on spurt buying) Mr Speaker, Sir, on 13th October 2000, there was a 30% increase in the share price of Singapore Telecommunications Limited ("SingTel") resulting in a sudden upward surge of the STI index on that day. The increase in share price was due to a last minute order to buy 2 million SingTel shares at $3.50 each, keyed in by Nomura Securities Singapore Pte Ltd. The order was given at 5.04 pm, just 1 minute before the end of the pre-close session on the Singapore Exchange Securities Trading. 662,000 shares, representing all the outstanding sell positions during the pre-close session, were matched at $3.50, causing SingTel shares to close at that price. The Singapore Exchange ("SGX") had confirmed that the trade was not an error trade. As a regulator of the securities and derivatives market, SGX is concerned with unusual price or volume fluctuations on any share counter. SGX will take action against market participants engaged in trading activities aimed to create a false market in contravention of SGX's rules and bye-laws. Based on its investigations, SGX has ascertained that there could be a possible violation of the Securities Industry Act. It is an offence under the Securities Industry Act to create a false or misleading appearance in the market for a share counter. Accordingly, based on advice from MAS, SGX has referred the matter to the Commercial Affairs Department for further investigation.
SINGTEL SHARES - (Probe on spurt buying) Sir, is the Commercial Affairs Department now investigating the matter and how long would it take to complete its investigation?
SINGTEL SHARES - (Probe on spurt buying) Mr Speaker, Sir, as I have said, the Exchange has referred the matter to CAD and I assume that CAD is now investigating the matter. I have not heard when they will complete the investigation.
DEGREE COURSES BY PUBLIC AND PRIVATE INSTITUTIONS - (Recognition of qualifications) asked the Prime Minister, with the proliferation of degree courses being offered by various public and private institutions, whether the Public Service Commission will release a list of recognised and preferred qualifications so that members of the public may make an informed choice when enrolling for a course.
DEGREE COURSES BY PUBLIC AND PRIVATE INSTITUTIONS - (Recognition of qualifications) Mr Speaker, Sir, the Public Service Commission does not assess or grant recognition to degrees awarded by overseas universities for employment purposes as it is not in the position to judge qualifications awarded by institutions all over the world. Moreover, each individual employer in the private or public sector should be left to decide on the criteria for recruitment based on its organisational strategies and needs. This includes the type of qualification acceptable for employment in each organisation.
TEACHERS - (Resignation and retirement) asked the Minister for Education (i) how many primary, secondary school and junior college teachers have resigned, (ii) how many such teachers have retired, and (iii) how many foreign teachers have been recruited to fill the vacancies in the last five years since 1995 and up to the first half of this year, giving breakdown figures for each year.