Court of Appeal · Decided 5 December 2018
Mohamed Affandi bin Rosli v Public Prosecutor and another appeal
Feedback & support[2018] SGCA 87 · Case no. CA/CCA 38/2017|CA/CCA 39/2017
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] The present appeals pertain to the conviction of two accused persons on a pair of drug charges. The appellants are Mohamed Affandi bin Rosli (“Affandi”) and Mohamad Fadzli bin Ahmad (“Fadzli”). Affandi faces one charge of possession, for the purpose of trafficking, of not less than 132.82g of diamorphine, an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) of the Misuse of Drugs Act (Cap 185, 2008 Rev Ed) (“the MDA”). Fadzli faces one charge of abetting by instigating Affandi to be in possession, for the purpose of trafficking, of not less than 132.82g of diamorphine, an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) and s 12 of the MDA. Both charges carry the mandatory death penalty. While both accused faced other non-capital charges in the proceedings below, the Prosecution sought and obtained orders of discharge not amounting to acquittal in respect of these after the High Court judge (“the Judge”) convicted Affandi and Fadzli on five out of seven charges brought against them (with one charge against Affandi reduced): Public Prosecutor v Mohamad Fadzli bin Ahmad and another [2017] SGHC 233 (“the Judgment”) at [121]–[123] (see also [10]–[12] below).
Background
The arrests
- [2]
[2] At the material time, Affandi was a fire safety supervisor working at Marina Bay Sands (“MBS”). He resided at Block 124, Pasir Ris Street 11, and was the registered owner of a vehicle bearing the registration number SJW 9386 M ("Affandi’s car”). Fadzli was a part-time mover who resided with his sister at Block 498L, Tampines Street 45 (“Fadzli’s flat”) and had charge of a vehicle bearing the registration number SGW 4282 Y (“Fadzli’s car”).
- [3]
[3] On 12 July 2013, at about 7.45am, Affandi, who was under surveillance, was seen getting on a motorcycle with another person, who was later identified as one Mansor bin Mohamad Yusoff (“Mansor”), at the carpark of his block. They rode off and later at about 8.10am entered the basement carpark of MBS. Officers from the Central Narcotics Bureau (“CNB”) had noted that Affandi’s car was parked at basement 4M of the same carpark and positioned themselves in the vicinity.
- [4]
[4] At about 3.18pm on the same day, Fadzli left his flat and drove off in his car. At about 3.50pm, Fadzli’s car was seen entering the MBS carpark. It proceeded to basement 4M. Fadzli parked his car near Affandi’s car. He then alighted and met with Affandi behind Affandi’s car. Shortly thereafter, Fadzli returned to his car and drove out of the MBS carpark.
- [5]
[5] At about 4pm, CNB officers intercepted Fadzli’s car and Fadzli was placed under arrest. CNB officers then escorted Fadzli and his car to an open space in the vicinity. At about 4.22pm, a search was conducted. The items recovered and seized as case exhibits include:
(a) one plastic packet (marked as “D1A”) containing:
(i) one packet of white crystalline substance (marked as “D1A1”); and
(ii) one plastic packet (marked as “D1A2”) containing two packets of crystalline substance (collectively marked as “D1A2A”);
(b) one packet of white crystalline substance (marked as “C1”); and
(c) several plastic bags of groceries.
- [6]
[6] The search of Fadzli’s car ended at about 4.45pm. From about 4.50pm to 5pm, a statement (P106A) was recorded from Fadzli by Staff Sergeant Muhammad Fardlie bin Ramlie (“SSgt Fardlie”) in a CNB operational vehicle. At about 5.15pm, Fadzli was escorted to his flat. At about 5.55pm, a search was conducted of the unit. Fadzli surrendered one packet (marked as “E1A”) containing 30 slabs of Erimin-5 tablets (300 tablets, collectively marked as “E1A1”) and one packet (marked as “E1B”) containing 26 slabs of Erimin-5 tablets (being a total of 260 tablets, collectively marked as “E1B1”). From about 6.50pm to 6.55pm, a further contemporaneous statement (P106B) was recorded from Fadzli in a CNB operational vehicle. At about 7.22pm, Fadzli was escorted to the Woodlands Checkpoint where K-9 and backscatter searches were conducted on his car. Nothing incriminating was found. At about 10.35pm, Fadzli was escorted to the Central Police Division lock-up, and placed in the custody of the officers in charge of the lock-up.
- [7]
[7] Meanwhile, shortly after Fadzli’s arrest, at about 4.10pm, CNB officers arrested Affandi at his workplace at the MBS Fire Command Centre. Nothing incriminating was found either at his work station or in his two lockers at work. At about 5.18pm, Affandi was escorted to his car that was parked at the MBS carpark. A search was conducted on the said car and the items recovered and seized as case exhibits include:
(a) from under the last row of passenger seats, eight bundles wrapped in black tape (marked as “B1” to “B8”); and
(b) from the middle row of passenger seats: one plastic packet (marked as “A1A”) containing three packets of white crystalline substance (marked collectively as “A1A1”) and one packet of white crystalline substance (marked as “A1B”).
- [8]
[8] At about 6.03pm, Senior Station Inspector David Ng (“SSI David Ng”) recorded a contemporaneous statement (P105) from Affandi in a CNB operational vehicle (“the CNB vehicle”). After the statement was recorded, Affandi was escorted to the Woodlands Checkpoint where K-9 and backscatter searches were conducted on his car. Nothing incriminating was found. Thereafter, Affandi was escorted to his flat, but again, nothing incriminating was found. Affandi was then held in the custody of the CNB.
The seized substances
- [9]
[9] All seized substances were sent for analysis by the Health Sciences Authority (“HSA”), which found and certified that:
(a) the eight exhibits (marked as “B1A”, “B2a1”, “B3A” to “B8A”) from the eight packets wrapped in black tape and said to have been recovered from the last row of seats in Affandi’s car (see [7(a)] above) contained 132.82g of diamorphine;
(b) the plastic packets recovered from the middle row of Affandi’s car (see [7(b)] above) contained not less than 8.14g of methamphetamine.
(c) the four plastic packets of crystalline substance taken from Fadzli’s car (see [5] above) contained 38.84g of methamphetamine.
(d) the two packets of tablets taken from Fadzli’s flat (see [6] above) contained 560 tablets of nimetazepam.
The charges
- [10]
[10] Fadzli was charged with:
(a) abetting by instigating Affandi to be in possession, for the purpose of trafficking, of 132.82g of diamorphine, which is an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) and s 12 of the MDA (“Charge A”);
(b) trafficking by having in his possession, for the purpose of trafficking, 38.84g of methamphetamine, which is an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) of the MDA (“Charge B”);
(c) having in his possession 560 tablets containing nimetazepam, which is an offence under s 8(a) of the MDA (“Charge C”); and
(d) abetting by instigating Affandi to be in possession, for the purpose of trafficking, of 8.14g of methamphetamine, which is an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) and s 12 of the MDA (“Charge D”).
- [11]
[11] Affandi was charged with:
(a) having in his possession, for the purpose of trafficking, 132.82g of diamorphine, which is an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) of the MDA (“Charge E”);
(b) having in his possession, for the purpose of trafficking, 8.14g of methamphetamine, which is an offence under s 5(1)(a) read with s 5(2) of the MDA (“Charge F”); and
(c) trafficking in 38.84g of methamphetamine, by delivering the same to Fadzli which is an offence under s 5(1)(a) of the MDA (“Charge G”).
- [12]
[12] The Judge convicted Fadzli of Charges A, B and C and Affandi of Charge E. As for Charge F, the Judge convicted Affandi on the reduced charge of possession of 8.14g of methamphetamine, which is an offence under s 8 of the MDA (“Reduced Charge F”). The Judge acquitted Fadzli of Charge G and Affandi of Charge D. Thereafter, the Prosecution sought and obtained a discharge not amounting to an acquittal in respect of the non-capital charges (Charges B and C, and Reduced Charge F). These orders were made pursuant to s 232(1)(b) of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cap 68, 2012 Rev Ed) (“the CPC”).
- [13]
[13] The two remaining charges, Charges A and E (against Fadzli and Affandi respectively), read as follows:
- [14]
[14] We have emphasised in bold the seized substances that the two charges relate to at [7(a)] and [9(a)] above. We will refer to them as “the seized diamorphine”, or where we refer to the diamorphine in the form of the packets or bundles, as “the eight bundles”, or where we refer to them as exhibits, as B1A, B2A1, and B3A to B8A and collectively as “the exhibits”.
The statements
- [15]
[15] In the course of the investigations, one contemporaneous statement (in two parts) (P106A and P106B), four cautioned statements (P111–P114, of which P111 pertains to Charge A), and four investigation statements (P119–P122) were recorded from Fadzli. One contemporaneous statement (P105), four cautioned statements (P115–P118, of which only P115 pertains to Charge E) and eight investigation statements (P123–P130) were recorded from Affandi. The statements were admitted in evidence without objection.
Affandi’s statements
- [16]
[16] The Prosecution relies substantially on two statements given by Affandi and we will turn to these before addressing the other statements. The first is the contemporaneous statement in P105, and the second is the cautioned statement recorded in respect of Charge E, P115. We set both out in full.
(1) P105
- [17]
[17] P105 was recorded as a series of questions and answers in English. In this statement, Affandi admitted collecting and safekeeping the seized diamorphine on the instructions of one “Abut”, who he identified to be Fadzli:
- [18]
[18] To understand the context in which P105 was recorded, it is relevant to refer to an earlier conversation that had taken place between Affandi and Staff Sergeant Sanusir bin Othman (“SSgt Sanusir”) (who was in the party of officers who arrested Affandi at his workplace) about half an hour before P105 was taken. While Affandi’s work lockers were being searched, Affandi told SSgt Sanusir “dalam kereta ade something”, which SSgt Sanusir understood to mean that there was something in the car. Then he went on to say in English “If I tell from A to Z, what will happen to me as I wanted to know the real picture”. It appears that Affandi was offering to come clean and reveal all that had happened but before doing so, he wanted to have some sense of what would then transpire. SSgt Sanusir responded that if Affandi came clean, he would seek further instructions from his superiors. Subsequently, before the car was searched, SSgt Sanusir had the following exchange with him:
(2) P115
- [19]
[19] In his cautioned statement, Affandi elaborated on what he had said in P105:
- [20]
[20] Up to this point, Affandi was consistent in his evidence that the seized diamorphine belonged to “Abut” (by which he meant Fadzli), and that he was only in possession of the black bundles until Fadzli was ready to collect them.
(3) Affandi’s eight investigative statements
- [21]
[21] In the investigative statements recorded after P115, Affandi described a different version of events:
(a) On the night of 11 July 2013, he was contacted by one “Mamak”, someone he had met in Johor Bahru two months earlier.
(b) Mamak told Affandi that his car had broken down and asked if Affandi could assist him by receiving a package. He obliged, and as directed by Mamak, went to the Mandai heavy vehicle carpark between 3.50am and 4am on 12 July 2013. There, he received a grey plastic bag containing the black bundles from an unidentified Indian male.
(c) While Affandi had initially claimed to have gone to the heavy vehicle carpark from home, he changed his evidence subsequently and claimed that he had first gone to Malaysia to buy petrol and to wash his car between 12am and approximately “2plus to 3am” on the morning of 12 July 2013, and had then proceeded directly to the heavy vehicle carpark at Mandai. The investigating officer, Inspector Ng Pei Xin (“the IO”), testified that this change of position occurred after Affandi was confronted with records from the Immigration & Checkpoints Authority (“ICA”) which indicated that he was in Malaysia at that time and had only re-entered Singapore through Woodlands at 3.30am. Affandi also stated that after returning to Singapore, he “drove down Woodlands Road and made a U-turn at Ten Mile Junction” before turning into the heavy vehicle carpark next to Ten Mile Junction. That area was monitored by Closed Circuit Television (“CCTV”). When the CCTV footage was subsequently retrieved by the investigators, Affandi’s car was not captured there whether at the time the alleged U-turn had taken place or otherwise. Affandi offered no explanation for this.
(d) After collecting the bundles, he became afraid and decided to drive to MBS instead of going home. When he arrived, he hid all the bundles under the third row passenger seat of his car. He claimed that he had intended to hand over the eight bundles to the police if Mamak failed to contact him before he ended work on 12 July 2013. Affandi claimed that he was frightened because he did not know what was inside the bundles. He also claimed that this was the first time that he had seen such bundles.
(e) Affandi explained that he had implicated Fadzli instead of Mamak because he was scared and confused, “[t]he CNB officer was pressurizing” him, and he felt very “gan jiong” by which he meant that he had been nervous or harried.
(f) Afffandi also explained that although he had mentioned “panas” to the officers in his previous statements or conversations, he was in fact “guessing and [he] really did not know what was in the eight bundles”. He suspected “panas” to be illegal but he had no idea what type of illegal substance it was.
(g) On 11 July 2013, he had bought groceries. He had earlier spoken to Fadzli about some donations of food items that he, Affandi, wished to make for the season of Ramadan. On 12 July 2013, he met Fadzli to hand him the groceries that he had purchased.
Fadzli’s statements
- [23]
[23] There are two other aspects of Fadzli’s statements that ought to be highlighted. First, in the contemporaneous statement taken shortly after Fadzli’s arrest (P106A), he was shown a “digital photo” of Affandi and was asked whether he knew who the person in the picture was. Fadzli claimed not to know the person. The material portion of P106A reads as follows:
- [24]
[24] However, five days later, when a subsequent statement (P120) was being recorded, Fadzli was shown two other photographs of Affandi, and Fadzli identified the person in these photographs to be Affandi. Fadzli also elaborated on the circumstances surrounding the recording of P106A:
- [25]
[25] The IO followed up on this point in the next statement (P121), which was taken on the following day:
- [26]
[26] The second point of note is that Fadzli, in his statement taken on 16 July 2013 (P119), inserted, by way of a handwritten amendment to the original printed version of the statement, the following line:
- [27]
[27] We will return to these two points below at [79] and it would suffice to note, at this juncture, that the Prosecution relied on these two points as lies corroborative of Fadzli’s guilt.
The Judge’s decision
Affandi
- [28]
[28] The Judge found Affandi guilty of Charge E, ie, possessing diamorphine for the purpose of trafficking. A central feature of Affandi’s defence was that serious questions had been raised as to the chain of custody of the drugs such that there was a real possibility that the expert reports were not given in respect of the very same drugs that had been seized from Affandi’s possession. The Judge rejected this. He found that there was no break in the chain of custody. The Judge found it insufficient for the defence to suggest that there was a real possibility of a break in the chain of custody without giving any indication as to when and how the chain of custody might have been broken (Judgment at [32]). Instead, the Judge held that the defence needed to show “that the exhibits [had] left the custody of the officers, or that unauthorised parties had access to them at some time during that period, or that the exhibits [had] been interfered with” (Judgment at [34]). He also found that there was no basis for any complaint as to how the IO had handled the exhibits (Judgment at [36]).
- [29]
[29] Second, the Judge also found that Affandi failed to rebut the presumption of knowledge that arose under s 18(2) of the MDA. The Judge found that Affandi’s contemporaneous statement (P105) and cautioned statement (P115) were “voluntary and true statements”. In the light of the conversation that Affandi had with SSgt Sanusir (detailed at [18] above), the Judge found that Affandi was in a “co-operative frame of mind” at the time these statements were recorded (Judgment at [70]).
- [30]
[30] The Judge disbelieved Affandi’s reasons for renouncing the admissions in his contemporaneous and cautioned statements. The Judge observed that several aspects of the cautioned statement (P115) went beyond what was said in the contemporaneous statement (P105), such as how Affandi stored drugs for Fadzli for about a month (Judgment at [57]). When queried on this, Affandi explained that he was “just coming out with stories” to “save [himself]” (Judgment at [58]). But the Judge noted that if Affandi wished to save himself, Affandi could have told the IO that his contemporaneous statement was untrue, and put across to her what he later claimed was the truth (Judgment at [59]).
- [31]
[31] The Judge also pointed out several unsatisfactory aspects of Affandi’s defence which undermined his credibility and his attempt to rebut the presumption:
(a) While Affandi had initially claimed not to have Mamak’s number, he later admitted that he did have Mamak’s number stored in his mobile phone (Judgment at [60]);
(b) Affandi also changed his account about his trip to the Mandai heavy vehicle carpark. Originally, he had claimed to have come from home. Then he claimed to have gone to the vehicle park from Johor Bahru instead. ICA records showed his car entering Singapore on 12 July 2013 at 3.30am. But even this version of events was, at least in part, inconsistent with the CCTV footage (Judgment at [61]–[63] and see further [21(c)] above). The Judge concluded that Affandi had gone to Johor Bahru in the early hours of 12 July 2013 and had returned to Singapore at 3.30am; however, he found that Affandi did not drive to the heavy vehicle carpark but had gone to the MBS carpark directly, had then hid the eight bundles, and gone home (Judgment at [71]).
(c) Affandi also gave different accounts of what he did with the bundles after he received them. In his statement on 15 July 2013, Affandi claimed to have looked into the plastic bag he had received from Mamak on the way home and then taken one bundle and looked at it. However, during the trial, he testified that he only checked the plastic bag and realised that there were eight bundles inside after he reached MBS. When cross-examined on this, Affandi’s answers “equivocated wildly” (Judgment at [65]–[67]).
- [32]
[32] The Judge held that for Affandi to rebut the presumption of knowledge, he had to prove that he did not know that the bundles contained diamorphine. However, Affandi could only say that he thought the bundles contained “panas” which he suspected to be illegal but he did not enquire further or examine them. Given the confusion, equivocation and falsehoods in his evidence, the Judge concluded that the presumption had not been rebutted (Judgment at [73], [75]– [76]), and convicted Affandi of Charge E.
Fadzli
- [33]
[33] The Judge found Fadzli to be guilty of Charge A, ie, abetting by instigating Affandi to possess diamorphine for the purpose of trafficking. The Judge found that P105 and P115 were admissions that could be used against Fadzli pursuant to s 258(5) of the CPC. He accorded them substantial weight and he thought that in these statements, Affandi was telling the truth as to how he came into possession of the eight bundles and who they belonged to (Judgment at [99]). He saw no reason for Affandi to falsely incriminate his friend Fadzli when he could have said that he had collected and held the bundles for Mamak if that were true (Judgment at [96]).
- [34]
[34] Aside from the statements, the Judge considered three other facts (Judgment at [98]):
(a) First, Fadzli and Affandi had made two calls each to the other in the morning of 12 July 2013 when the eight bundles were delivered to Affandi.
(b) Second, Fadzli failed to identify Affandi from his photograph when P106A, his contemporaneous statement, was recorded (see [23] above).
(c) Third, Fadzli lied when he said he was not known as “Abut” in P119, a statement he gave on 16 July 2013 (see [26] above).
Based on the facts at (b) and (c) above, the Judge found that Fadzli was seeking to distance himself from Affandi. He had no reason to do that if he had nothing to hide. The Judge thought in the circumstances that this indicated that he was involved in the activities with Affandi for which they were arrested. The Judge took the view that these lies acted against Fadzli. While they were not evidence of guilt, they damaged his credibility and his defence (Judgment at [108]), and he therefore found Fadzli guilty of Charge A.
The parties’ cases
- [35]
[35] Affandi’s case on appeal is entirely premised on attacking the integrity of the chain of custody of the exhibits, and no attempt was made to rebut the presumptions of knowledge or possession that arose under ss 18 and 21 of the MDA. Counsel for Affandi, Mr Michael Chia, identified two flaws in the Prosecution’s case:
(a) First, there were differing accounts as to who in the arresting party had possession of the exhibits from the time they were seized until they were handed over to the IO.
(b) Second, after the IO took possession of the exhibits, she did not lock them in her safe, but left them on the floor of her office instead.
Mr Chia submitted that in evaluating Affandi’s defence, the threshold should not be set at an unreasonably high level, which would be the case if it were incumbent on the defence to provide a full explanation as to by whom, when and how exhibits had been tampered with. The burden was on the Prosecution to prove and establish the chain of custody and the defence simply would not be in a position to establish the chain, these being matters entirely within the knowledge of the CNB. In the final analysis, the question was whether the Prosecution had proved beyond reasonable doubt that the items in respect of which the expert evidence was led were the very same items seized in the case at hand.
- [36]
[36] Counsel for Fadzli, Mr Ramesh Tiwary, focused his submissions on two aspects. First, he argued that the version of events set out in P105 and P115 could not be relied upon because the statements contained numerous assertions that were “either untrue or suspicious”. Second, in relation to the alleged lies that the Prosecution and the Judge referred to, Mr Tiwary argued that (a) it was unsafe to conclude that Fadzli was lying about not recognising Affandi because the photograph shown to Affandi had not been produced to the Judge and the Judge therefore had no frame of reference against which he could reasonably conclude whether Fadzli had been lying; and (b) Fadzli could have made a genuine mistake about his statement on 16 July 2013 that he was not known as “Abut” to anyone. In addition, Mr Tiwary associated himself with Mr Chia’s arguments on the integrity of the chain of custody of the exhibits.
- [37]
[37] The Prosecution’s arguments closely tracked the reasons of the Judgment. In essence, the Prosecution’s case was premised on the version of events set out in P105 and P115. In respect of Fadzli, the Prosecution also relied on Fadzli’s alleged lies. We will elaborate on the Appellants’ and Prosecution’s arguments in greater detail below.
Our decision
- [38]
[38] Two issues arose for our consideration. First, was there a reasonable doubt as to the integrity of the chain of custody of the exhibits? If there was such a doubt, then both the convictions of Fadzli and Affandi ought to be set aside. Second, if the chain of custody was established, was the version of the events set out in P105 and P115 true?
Whether there was a reasonable doubt as to the integrity of the chain of custody
- [39]
[39] We begin with the applicable principles when considering whether a reasonable doubt has been raised as to the integrity of the chain of custody. It is well-established that the Prosecution bears the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the drug exhibits analysed by the HSA are the very ones that were initially seized by the CNB officers from the accused. Much of the discussion in this area has been framed in terms of whether such a doubt has been raised as to a possible break in the chain of custody. But this obscures the fact that it is first incumbent on the Prosecution to establish the chain. This requires the Prosecution to account for the movement of the exhibits from the point of seizure to the point of analysis. In the context of the Prosecution establishing the chain of custody, the defence may also seek to suggest that there is a break in the chain of custody. This refers not necessarily to challenging the Prosecution’s overall account but to showing that at one or more stages, there is a reasonable doubt as to whether the chain of custody may have been broken. Where this is shown to be the case and a reasonable doubt is raised as to the identity of the drug exhibits, then the Prosecution has not discharged its burden: Nguyen Tuong Van v Public Prosecutor [2005] 1 SLR(R) 103 (“Nguyen Tuong Van”) at [36], citing Abdul Rashid bin Mohamed and another v Public Prosecutor [1993] 3 SLR(R) 656 (“Abdul Rashid”) at [17]. To put it another way, the Prosecution must show an unbroken chain. There cannot be a single moment that is not accounted for if this might give rise to a reasonable doubt as to the identity of the exhibits: Public Prosecutor v Chen Mingjian [2009] 4 SLR(R) 946 (“Chen Mingjian”) at [4].
- [40]
[40] The importance of ensuring a complete chain is paramount. It is not an understatement to say that it could be a matter of life and death, as Chao J (as he then was) noted in his dissenting judgment in Lim Swee Seng v Public Prosecutor [1995] 1 SLR(R) 32 (“Lim Swee Seng”) at [70]. His comment related to a discrepancy in weight, but it applies all the more strongly when there is doubt as to whether the exhibits relied upon to secure a conviction were the same exhibits seized from the accused in question.
- [41]
[41] That is not to say that speculative arguments about the possibility of contamination will be entertained: Chen Mingjian ([39] supra) at [4]. Neither must the chain of custody be laboriously proved by calling witnesses to testify to each step in every case. As this Court held in Lai Kam Loy v Public Prosecutor [1993] 3 SLR(R) 143 (“Lai Kam Loy”) at [38]:
- [42]
[42] This was reaffirmed in a number of subsequent cases such as Satli bin Masot v Public Prosecutor [1999] 1 SLR(R) 931 (“Satli bin Masot”) at [15], and Public Prosecutor v Yen May Woen [2003] SGHC 60 at [59] (which was upheld on appeal). The fact is that the keeping of proper records will obviate the need to adduce evidence or to prove this in most cases and it is incumbent on the CNB officers to keep such records. But none of this excludes the need for the court to carefully consider the matter where a proper challenge is mounted.
- [43]
[43] In our judgment, a reasonable doubt was raised in respect of the integrity of the chain of custody of the exhibits having regard to the evidence that was led in this case. Specifically, the difficulty is that the Prosecution failed to establish beyond a reasonable doubt the actual chain of custody in the first place. In particular, we were presented with differing accounts of who held the exhibits before they were handed to the IO and this gave rise to a reasonable doubt as to the identity of the exhibits that were relied upon to secure the convictions of the appellants. For this reason, which we will shortly develop, we are satisfied that the Prosecution has not discharged its burden. However, for the avoidance of doubt, we also make it clear that we reject the second argument that was mounted by Mr Chia and which was premised on the way in which the IO stored or handled the exhibits. We now elaborate on both points.
Carriage of the exhibits before handover to IO
- [44]
[44] During the course of the trial, two inconsistent narratives emerged as to how the drugs were handled by officers in the arresting party.
- [45]
[45] The first was recounted by SSI David Ng. According to him, after the eight bundles were seized, they were placed in a black trash bag along with other seized items. The black trash bag was then placed on the front passenger seat of the CNB vehicle. It remained there as the arresting party moved first from MBS to Affandi’s flat and then to Woodlands Checkpoint. It remained inside the vehicle when searches were conducted at the Woodlands Checkpoint. However, SSI David Ng maintained that he took the black trash bag with him when he participated in the search of Affandi’s flat. He said that he then passed the trash bag containing the exhibits to Senior Staff Sergeant Jenny Woo (“SSSgt Jenny Woo”) at about 10.47pm, shortly after he and his team returned to CNB headquarters. He was certain that no one else had touched the trash bag, which contained the exhibits. SSI David Ng’s account that he handed over the exhibits to SSSgt Jenny Woo at 10.47pm is corroborated by an entry (recorded by Senior Staff Sergeant Alwin Wong (“SSSgt Alwin Wong”)) in the field diary covering Affandi’s arrest, which stated that “[a]t 2247 hours, Beckham hand over exhibits to Princess” (“Beckham” and “Princess” being the call signs of SSI David Ng and SSSgt Jenny Woo respectively).
- [46]
[46] As against this, at trial, SSSgt Alwin Wong recounted a different narrative that was inconsistent in material respects with that of SSI David Ng. SSSgt Alwin Wong’s evidence was that he held on to the exhibits from the time the recording of P105 was complete (at about 6.50pm) right until 10.56pm when he handed over the exhibits to SSI David Ng before going for his break. By then, the arresting party had returned to the CNB Supervision A Office and a live ID (which is the ascertainment of the accused’s real identity using his or her fingerprints) had been conducted in respect of Affandi at the Criminal Records Office. He also said that he recalled handing over the exhibits at 10.56pm because he wrote this down on his hand, and because he distinctly recalled handing over the exhibits to SSI David Ng before he went on his break. SSSgt Alwin Wong added that while the team was in the CNB vehicle, the exhibits were locked in the boot because he did not “want the accused to… grab the exhibits”. When the party searched Affandi’s unit and when the backscatter and canine search was being conducted on Affandi’s car, SSSgt Alwin Wong said that he took the exhibits with him and held on to them. Finally, SSSgt Alwin Wong also recalled that the trash bag containing the exhibits was blue.
- [47]
[47] Subsequently, when shown the entry he made in the field diary covering Affandi’s arrest, SSSgt Alwin Wong stuck with the narrative outlined above, claiming that the exhibits were handed over from SSI David Ng to SSSgt Jenny Woo as reflected in field diary but that there could have been a “time lapse”. With respect, this does not seem to us to follow. SSSgt Alwin Wong was very clear in his evidence that the exhibits had been handed over to SSI David Ng at 10.56pm, even stating, as we have noted, that he had written this down on his hand. But it was also SSSgt Alwin Wong who had recorded in the station diary that SSI David Ng had handed over the exhibits to SSSgt Jenny Woo at 10.47pm. The latter was nine minutes earlier than the time at which SSSgt Alwin Wong testified that he had handed the exhibits over to SSI David Ng. This would have been impossible and cannot be explained away as a time lapse.
- [48]
[48] More importantly, however, there were two plausible but irreconcilable versions of the chain of custody of the exhibits between the time of their seizure and about 11pm on the same day, when the exhibits were apparently handled over to the IO and the court was left none the wiser as to which was correct. As the Judge noted, there were “inconsistencies in [the witnesses’] evidence on the time when the exhibits changed hands and the colour of the bags in which the exhibits were held” (Judgment at [31]). However, beyond these general points, the following inconsistencies in particular stood out:
(a) The exhibits could have either been on the front passenger seat of the CNB vehicle or locked in the boot at the time the vehicle was on the move between MBS, Affandi’s flat and the Woodlands Checkpoint.
(b) When the arresting party were searching Affandi’s flat, the exhibits were either held by SSI David Ng or SSSgt Alwin Wong.
(c) When backscatter and K-9 searches were being conducted on Affandi’s car, the exhibits were either inside the CNB vehicle or held by SSSgt Alwin Wong.
(d) At 10.47pm, the exhibits were either handed over to SSSgt Jenny Woo by SSI David Ng, or they were still held by SSSgt Alwin Wong as Affandi was participating in the live ID.
These four dichotomies could not be reconciled. In each case, each version was supported by the robust evidence of a senior law enforcement officer. But both could not possibly be true. Nor was any plausible explanation put forward by the Prosecution as to how these inconsistencies were to be reconciled.
- [49]
[49] The evidence of the other officers in the arresting party also did not help in any way to resolve the inconsistencies:
(a) Staff Sergeant Jordi Chew could not remember who had custody of the exhibits.
(b) Staff Sergeant Sunny Tay (“SSgt Sunny Tay”) testified that after the eight bundles were seized, he put them in either a blue or black trash bag and then handed them over to SSI David Ng. While this statement is consistent with SSI David Ng’s evidence, he contradicted SSI David Ng’s account in another respect when he mentioned that it was SSI David Ng who brought the exhibits to the CNB HQ Exhibit Management Room subsequently at about 1.57am the following day, only to change tack when he was informed of the contradiction with the other evidence and say that he only saw SSI David Ng holding a trash bag at that time, but was not certain whether the bag contained the exhibits in question.
(c) SSSgt Jenny Woo did not record the receipt of the exhibits from SSI David Ng in her pocketbook. Neither did she include mention of this in any of her statements. She claimed to have overlooked this because she was “very involved in Fadzli”. She does not recall the colour of the bag that the exhibits were kept in, but she was sure that she received the exhibits from SSI David Ng, and that they were handed over to her at about “10.00-plus at night”. But given that she had made no records in relation to the exhibits, her evidence appeared to be based solely on SSSgt Alwin Wong’s record in one of the two field diaries.
- [50]
[50] On this basis, the Prosecution suggested that both SSI David Ng and SSSgt Alwin Wong “held joint custody of the exhibits until they returned to the CNB Headquarters”. We reject this without hesitation because it contradicts both narratives. Indeed, with respect, this seemed an impossible contention given that the two versions were in direct conflict in material respects. It also bears mention that when SSSgt Alwin Wong was asked to explain the discrepancy between the two narratives, he suggested that since they were in the same vehicle and SSI David Ng did not “give… a clear instruction that he is holding on to the… custody of the drugs… [s]o, [SSSgt Alwin Wong] assumed the role of holding on to the exhibits”. But, with respect, this avoided the real issue, which is that his account was not capable of being reconciled with the account of SSI David Ng in the respects set out at [48] above. On SSI David Ng’s account, he personally held the bag of exhibits at the relevant times, and there was simply no question of him giving any other instructions; and on this account, it would have been impossible for SSSgt Alwin Wong to also have been holding on to the same bag of exhibits, and all the more so when according to the two accounts, the exhibits were simultaneously in two different locations.
- [51]
[51] As we have already noted, we were faced with two complete and mutually exclusive chains of custody of exhibits, neither of which was disproved and this was the insurmountable hurdle that the Prosecution was ultimately not able to overcome. The fact is that either of the two narratives could be true, and as a result, the upshot of this is that neither of the narratives we have described at [45]–[46] above can be said to have been established beyond a reasonable doubt. Each raises a reasonable doubt as to the other in relation to the manner in which what was seized from the accused was then passed to the CNB headquarters and subsequently, the HSA. Because the burden was on the Prosecution to establish the chain of custody of the exhibits, and given that there are two irreconcilable narratives on the evidence, the Prosecution has simply failed to establish that chain. In that sense, it is not so much that the chain has been broken, as it is that it has not been properly strung in the first place.
- [52]
[52] We respectfully disagree with the Judge’s conclusion that the defence had to show “that the exhibits have left the custody of the officers, or that unauthorised parties had access to them at some time during that period, or that the exhibits have been interfered with” (Judgment at [34]). Instead, the onus is first and foremost on the Prosecution to prove the chain of custody beyond reasonable doubt. Until it has done this, there is simply no clarity as to the Prosecution’s case, which the accused is required to meet and it is a fundamental requirement of fairness in our system of criminal justice that the accused is clear as to what that case is: see Mui Jia Jun v Public Prosecutor [2018] SGCA 59 (“Mui”) at [1] and [77]. Neither does the argument that the officers should be considered as a collective and that they were “operating in a team effort” help the Prosecution overcome the lack of certainty over which of the two narratives is to be preferred (cf Judgment at [33]). In the final analysis, the fact that two officers testified to holding the exhibits in a manner that could not be reconciled leaves open the possibility that (a) one of them was not being truthful; or (b) both of them were being truthful. We have no reason or basis to think that either of them would have been untruthful. But, if they were both being truthful, this leaves us with the possibility that there was another bag of exhibits that was somehow in the vehicle at the material time. This is not as implausible as it might come across at first glance, especially when the evidence of SSgt Sunny Tay, which we have set out at [49(b)] above, is also taken into consideration. It is not for the defence or the court to fill gaps in the case led by the Prosecution: see Mui at [72]–[78]. The burden, as we have noted, is on the Prosecution to prove the chain of custody and for the reasons we have outlined at [39]–[41] above, this is a matter of fundamental importance. It cannot discharge that burden by leading evidence in support of a range of options, which are inconsistent with one another, and then inviting the court to choose that which it wishes. Not only is this completely inconsistent with the way facts are to be found, but it is also fundamentally unfair to the accused who, as we have noted above, is left to face a shifting case with moving parts.
- [53]
[53] Finally, although this is not probative in and of itself, it does add to the difficulties we have identified that neither Affandi’s nor Fadzli’s DNA was found on the eight bundles. On the other hand, DNA traces of two other people were found on exhibits B5 and B6. The first is Mr Lim Wen Xiang Wilson (“Mr Wilson Lim”), who was part of the DNA Profiling Lab Staff at HSA. It was likely that any (unintentional) contact with the exhibits occurred in the course of his work since he handled the exhibits, but this occurrence was nevertheless unusual as HSA officers typically take many precautionary measures to minimise contamination, so much so that the incidence rate, according to HSA analyst Ms Wong Hang Yee, is “very, very low” and “[c]lose to zero”. Perhaps more significantly, there was a second set of DNA traces found on the exhibits. This belonged to a profile tagged as “A057576”, later identified to be Ms Jasmin Tan Hui Min (“Ms Jasmin Tan”), a Home Team Specialist from the Forensic Response Team who was not involved in the investigations. She explained that her DNA might have been found on the exhibit because she was the person who restocked the tamper-proof bags used in the exhibit management room, but this was mere speculation. In the final analysis, this again left open the possibility that the exhibits were mixed up with those pertaining to a different case.
The IO’s handling of the exhibits
- [54]
[54] We turn to Mr Chia’s second argument on the chain of custody of the exhibits. The nub of the point that was taken is that the exhibits were left in tamper-proof bags on the floor of the IO’s office, unsealed and unsigned, for approximately 34 hours between 6am on 13 July 2013 and 3.15pm on 14 July 2013. Mr Chia submits that this gave rise to a possibility that the exhibits were tampered with.
- [55]
[55] We reject this argument because it is speculative and is founded purely on the theoretical possibility of the exhibits being tampered. This much is clear from Mr Chia’s line of questioning at trial:
- [56]
[56] As we have observed at [41] above, speculative arguments that seek to raise a theoretical possibility of a break in the chain of custody would not suffice. What must be raised is a reasonable doubt that there was such a break and on the facts, we are satisfied that the defence has failed to establish this in relation to this aspect of its case. The IO’s office was locked and even though the keys to her office were centrally available, there was a clear protocol to be followed. Her personal authorisation was required before anybody else could enter the office. During the period in question, no one had requested such access, and there is nothing to suggest that the protocol had been compromised. In short, this was nothing but a fanciful notion which might have been theoretically possible but was wholly unsupported and baseless.
- [57]
[57] In sum, we find that the Prosecution has failed to establish the chain of custody of the exhibits, given the inconsistent accounts given by different members of the arresting party. We therefore set aside Affandi’s conviction. Given that Fadzli’s liability is accessorial, we also set aside Fadzli’s conviction. Both appeals are therefore allowed.
Whether the version of the events set out in P105 and P115 was true
- [58]
[58] Given the conclusions we have reached, it is not necessary for us to consider this issue. Nevertheless, we will briefly explain why, in our judgment, even if the chain of custody was found to have been established beyond a reasonable doubt and Affandi had been convicted on Charge E, Charge A would not have been made out.
- [59]
[59] The version of events that the Prosecution urged us to accept is that set out in P105 and P115: in particular, it is said that Affandi was collecting the bundles of drugs on behalf of Fadzli because he was cash-strapped and needed money to pay off his debts, and for each trip that Affandi ran on behalf of Fadzli, he stood to earn between $400 and $500 (see [19] above). The Prosecution submitted on this basis that Fadzli was the mastermind behind and instigator of Affandi’s involvement with the seized diamorphine.
- [60]
[60] We are unable to accept the Prosecution’s version of events as they have not satisfied their burden of proving their case beyond a reasonable doubt. As we recently emphasised in Mui at [76], the principle that the Prosecution must prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt is a cornerstone of our criminal law. While the Prosecution does not have to dispel all conceivable doubts, the Prosecution would, at least, have to dispel all doubts that are relatable to and supported by the evidence presented: Jagatheesan s/o Krishnasamy v Public Prosecutor [2006] 4 SLR(R) 45 (“Jagatheesan”) at [61]. It should also be emphasised that none of the presumptions under the MDA are applicable in the present case because the eight bundles of diamorphine were found in Affandi’s possession. Moreover, the charge against Fadzli (Charge A) was that of abetment by instigation and the MDA does not provide for presumptions in respect of the elements to be proved: namely (a) the “active suggestion, support, stimulation or encouragement” of the primary offence (the actus reus), and (b) the intention for the primary offender to carry out the conduct abetted (the mens rea) (see Ali bin Mohamad Bahashwan v Public Prosecutor [2018] 1 SLR 610 at [34] and Chan Heng Kong and another v Public Prosecutor [2012] SGCA 18 at [34]).
- [61]
[61] Whether the elements of the offence under Charge A were made out turned on whether we accepted the Prosecution’s version of events – which is that Fadzli instigated Affandi’s involvement with the seized diamorphine. After considering the parties’ submissions and all the facts of the case, we find that there are a number of doubts as to the Prosecution’s version of events that have not been dispelled. It follows that in our judgment, the Prosecution has not proved its case against Fadzli beyond a reasonable doubt, and neither the actus reus nor mens rea of the offence under Charge A has been made out. In the rest of this section, we will first address the factors that militate against the acceptance of the Prosecution’s version of events. Secondly, we will elaborate on the inconsistencies and difficulties inherent in the account of events that Affandi presented in P105 and P115 – the two statements that the Prosecution premised its case on. Thirdly, we will address the alleged lies that the Judge relied on to establish guilt on Fadzli’s part, before finally turning to the calls made to Fadzli early in the morning on 12 July 2013.
Factors that suggest that Fadzli was not the mastermind and instigator
- [62]
[62] There are three key factors that cause us to doubt the submission that Fadzli was the mastermind behind Affandi’s involvement in the trafficking of the seized diamorphine. First, the amount of seized diamorphine was sizeable. Its weight was several times that at which capital punishment would be imposed and it had a considerable street value. Yet Fadzli left the eight bundles with Affandi even after they met in the afternoon of 12 July 2013. In fact, what was even more confounding was that on the evidence that was led, Fadzli did not even check the bundles of diamorphine: when CNB officers found these bundles in Affandi’s car, they were still wrapped in black tape (see [7(a)] above). The short duration of this meeting (less than ten minutes) supported the conclusion that Fadzli did not even look at or examine the bundles on the surface, although it should be noted that none of the CNB officers stationed at the MBS carpark occupied a vantage point that allowed them to see precisely what transpired during their meeting.
- [63]
[63] Second, Affandi had direct access to Mamak, who was identified by the Prosecution as Fadzli’s drug supplier. Affandi’s phone records revealed that Affandi and Mamak had communicated with each other from as early as 18 April 2013. On 12 July 2013, the day on which the eight bundles were transferred, there were records of six communications between Affandi and Mamak between 4.14am and 4.36am comprising two outgoing calls from Affandi, two text messages from Affandi and two text messages from Mamak. The Judge was cognisant of this, as noted in [68] of the Judgment. In addition, it was put to Affandi that an earlier call at 3.35am to Mamak was made to notify Mamak that he had received the items that he was supposed to collect. This direct connection between Mamak and Affandi raises a question as to just what Fadzli’s involvement was. If Mamak was content to contact Affandi directly, what meaningful role did Fadzli play as the middleman? He would have been superfluous in this arrangement and nothing was advanced to explain this.
- [64]
[64] Third, the Prosecution’s entire case against Fadzli rested on two of Affandi’s statements. One of these was his contemporaneous statement (P105) and the other was his cautioned statement (P115). However, Affandi subsequently retracted these allegations against Fadzli in the investigative statements that he later made. In these, as noted at [21] above, he said that what he had said in P105 and P115 (which implicated Fadzli) was untrue. Instead, he stated that he had been acting on the directions of Mamak. There are three important points to be made in this context:
(b) Second, this was especially relevant here, where the Judge did harbour concerns over Affandi’s credibility (see [31]–[32] above).
(c) Third, the foregoing two points should have weighed even more heavily given that even the Prosecution accepted that Mamak was not some imaginary figure but was in fact Affandi’s supplier of the drugs. This becomes especially troubling given what we have set out at [63] above.
Reasons for rejecting the version of events in P105 and P115
- [65]
[65] Following from this, we turn to the version of events set out in P105 and P115, which formed the foundation of the Prosecution’s case against Fadzli and explain why we reject this account of the relevant events. In our judgment, a closer scrutiny of the two statements reveals that they are riddled with untruths and inconsistencies.
- [66]
[66] We begin with P105, which is Affandi’s contemporaneous statement. As Mr Tiwary observed, this statement essentially stood for six propositions:
(a) Affandi collected and stored the diamorphine on Fadzli’s instructions;
(b) He collected the diamorphine the night before from “Kranji after the 10-mile junction big carpark”;
(c) He collected “panas” but he does not know what that actually is;
(d) He had met Fadzli earlier;
(e) He borrowed money from Fadzli during the earlier meeting;
(f) The earlier meeting was the first time he delivered ice to Fadzli.
- [67]
[67] Of these six assertions, (a) was the conclusion that the Prosecution wanted to reach, and (d) was neutral. Every other assertion was untrue, doubtful or inconsistent with P115. As regards (b), it was not clear whether he did in fact go to the heavy vehicle carpark near Ten Mile Junction to collect the diamorphine bundles. As mentioned above at [21(c)] and [31(b)], Affandi changed his original account of going to the carpark from his home after he was confronted with the ICA records which revealed that his car only returned to Singapore from Malaysia at about 3.30am on 12 July 2013. Further, there remain doubts as to whether he took the route he described because his car was not captured in CCTV footage of the area during the material period. Indeed, as we have noted at [31(b)] above, the Judge actually found that he never went to the carpark in question.
- [68]
[68] As regards (c), Affandi claimed that he used the word “panas” despite not knowing what it meant because he overheard SSgt Sanusir using it. However, this is simply untenable. As the Judge found at [70] of the Judgment, Affandi knew that the “panas” was something illegal and this explains why he felt scared when he took over possession of the bundles, and why he decided to hide the bundles under the last row of passenger seats.
- [69]
[69] Both statements (e) and (f) are inconsistent with P115. In P105, Affandi mentioned receiving a loan of $1,500, but he claimed to receive remuneration of $400 to $500 per collection in P115. In P105, Affandi mentioned that the present case was the first time he had received and delivered drugs on behalf of Fadzli, but in P115, he claimed to have been doing it for a month, at a frequency of once or twice a week. None of these inconsistencies were resolved.
- [70]
[70] Turning to P115, Affandi claimed that the number of packages that he received on 12 July 2013 was abnormally large because he would usually only receive one or two bundles. Mr Tiwary submits that if the number of packages had indeed been so large, Affandi should have contacted Fadzli to check with him, but he had not done this. Further, if this indeed was an unusually large consignment, then it made it even more implausible that Fadzli did not seem to have even cursorily checked on the bundles when they met in the MBS carpark.
- [71]
[71] In the proceedings below, the Judge accorded great weight to P105 and P115 as they were the earliest statements recorded, and they were thought to be untainted by pressure or suggestion. The Judge found that Affandi was in a “co-operative frame of mind” when he gave both statements (Judgment at [70]). In addition, the Judge saw no reason why Affandi would “falsely incriminate his friend Fadzli when he could have said that he had collected and held the bundles for Mamak, if that were true” (Judgment at [96]).
- [72]
[72] In a statement recorded on 16 July 2013, Affandi explained that he had mentioned “Abut” in P105 and P115 because SSI David Ng had “pressuriz[ed]” him, and made him feel “scared and confused”:
- [73]
[73] As to this, the Prosecution submitted that there was no reason for Affandi, who supposedly felt scared and pressurised by a CNB officer, to fabricate a fake story that would nevertheless incriminate himself. Further, it seemed highly unlikely that Affandi was truly affected by SSI David Ng as he provided details in P115 that went over and beyond what he mentioned in P105, when there was no suggestion that the IO, who recorded P115, had imposed any such pressure on him. Affandi in fact testified that he had “no complaints” against her. When cross-examined on this, Affandi claimed that he “was just coming out with stories”, and “deliberately fabricating lies” to “save himself”; he could not, however, explain how telling more lies would achieve that end.
- [74]
[74] In our judgment, Affandi’s actions were not as inexplicable as the Judge and the Prosecution found them to be. Affandi was caught by the CNB officers with a large amount of drugs. Right before the contemporaneous statement was taken, SSI David Ng told Affandi that it was likely that he would face a capital charge:
- [75]
[75] It is not surprising that the prospect of having to face a capital charge would have caused Affandi to feel scared and confused, as Affandi testified in court. In fact, SSgt Sanusir testified in court that Affandi was visibly nervous and afraid from the point of arrest till after the search of the car.
- [76]
[76] Affandi’s actions might be explained on the basis that he might have hoped that by providing “assistance”, such as by identifying someone with greater involvement in the drug activities he had been caught red-handed in, he would be minimising his role and this might somehow benefit him. It would be recalled that he had asked SSgt Sanusir just prior to P105: “if I tell you A to Z, what will happen to me as I wanted to know the real picture” (see [18] above). The evidence he gave at trial is also indicative of this:
- [77]
[77] We therefore do not share the same reservations as the Judge did in rejecting the admissions in P105 and P115 (cf Judgment at [59] and [96]).
The alleged lies that were corroborative of Fadzli’s guilt
- [78]
[78] We turn to the alleged lies that the Judge thought were factors that supported a finding of guilt on the part of Fadzli.
(1) Failure to recognise Affandi when shown Affandi’s photograph
- [79]
[79] The first relates to Fadzli’s inability to recognise Affandi when he was shown a photograph of Affandi while his contemporaneous statement (P106A) was being taken by SSgt Fardlie (see [6] and [23] above). In a subsequent statement, he claimed that this was because he saw the first photo and was unable to recognise the person in it. He then thought that the second photo displayed a picture of the same person (see [24] above).
- [80]
[80] At trial, Fadzli claimed in examination-in-chief that it was an unidentified Chinese officer, and not SSgt Fardlie, who had showed him two photos on a hand phone while P106A was being recorded. He also claimed that he was shown the photos at an open space outside the CNB vehicle (and not while inside the vehicle (cf [6] above)). He claimed that he was unable to recognise Affandi because at the time he was shown the two photos, his body was restrained such that he could not hold the mobile phone (which displayed the photos), and there was glare from the sun that made it difficult for him to see the photos clearly.
- [81]
[81] When Fadzli was cross-examined, he further clarified that he was actually able to have a good look at the first photo (which he claimed to be one that was not of Affandi), but he was not able to get a good look at the second photo because of the angle of the phone that was used to display the photos, and also the glare from the sun. Fadzli therefore assumed that the second photo was the same as the first photo because the individuals shown in the photos were wearing shirts of the same colour.
- [82]
[82] Fadzli’s evidence on what he saw in the first photograph was not clear. First, he claimed that the first photograph was that of Mansor:
Fadzli then claimed to not know who Mansor was (even at the date of the hearing):
Fadzli then clarified that he was only assuming that the photograph was that of Mansor:
- [83]
[83] The Judge did not accept Fadzli’s explanation for his failure to identify Affandi. First, he found that there was no reason for SSgt Fardlie not to show the photographs to Fadzli, given that he had the photographs on his phone, and he did not have to rely on or report to anyone about the usage of the photographs. Second, he found that the contemporaneous statements clearly showed that the photographs were shown to Fadzli when he was questioned by SSgt Fardlie (Judgment at [106]). The Judge then went on to find that Fadzli’s failure to recognise Affandi from the photograph that was shown to him during the recording of his contemporaneous statement, while not evidence of his guilt, damaged his credibility and defence. It suggested that Fadzli was intentionally trying to distance himself from Affandi because he had been involved in some activities with Affandi for which they were being arrested (Judgment at [108]). On appeal, the Prosecution submitted that this lie was corroborative of Fadzli’s guilt, placing reliance on the principle in Regina v Lucas (Ruth) [1981] 1 QB 720, which was cited with approval recently by this Court in Public Prosecutor v Ilechukwu Uchechukwu Chukwudi [2015] SGCA 33 (“Ilechukwu”).
- [84]
[84] With respect, we do not agree with the Judge. First, and we consider this to be the overriding point, the failure to recognise Affandi from the photos shown to him cannot be relied on because the Judge had not even satisfactorily established for himself a proper frame of reference within which he could assess Fadzli’s evidence. We agree with Mr Tiwary that there were difficulties on at least three levels:
(a) First, there was no direct evidence as to exactly which photo was shown by the officer who took Fadzli’s contemporaneous statement (P105).
(b) Second, none of the photos before the Judge were in digital form and specifically as a digital representation on a mobile phone, when this was the form in which Fadzli was shown the relevant photo. Neither was there any evidence as to the device used to show Fadzli the photo of Affandi. This was so, despite the fact that Fadzli had consistently mentioned the glare which prevented him from having a good look of the photographs he was shown. Without having been shown the relevant photographs in a similar way that Fadzli had been shown them, still less would the Judge have had a proper frame of reference to assess his evidence.
(c) The third point relates to the recording of P121 (see [25] above). Fadzli was able to recognise Affandi when the IO showed him a particular print version of a photo which she claimed to be the same photograph as the one shown to Affandi when P105 was recorded. But even if this was true (and it should be noted that Fadzli denies being shown this photograph: see his third answer in P121 at [25] above as well as his evidence at [82] above), it was a print copy magnified to A4 size. Whatever image it was and in whatever medium it was, it was not a print copy of A4 size that Fadzli was shown at the time that P105 was recorded. What the IO referred to was a much enlarged copy of what might have been shown to Affandi.
- [85]
[85] In addition to this, Fadzli’s evidence at trial was consistently that he would have recognised Affandi in the photos he was shown if he could actually have seen the photo clearly. In fact, when Fadzli was interviewed by the IO on 17 and 18 July 2013 for the recording of P120 and P121, which was shortly after his contemporaneous statement was recorded, he was forthcoming and quick to say that he recognised and knew who Affandi was (see [24]–[25] above). This being the case, it does not in fact seem that Fadzli had any real desire to distance himself from Affandi.
- [86]
[86] The Prosecution also raised the following arguments:
(a) First, Fadzli could not have thought that the two photographs shown to him for the recording P106A were the same when the ninth question in P106A was whether he met the “both of them”, implying that the two photographs he was shown were of two different people.
(b) Second, Fadzli would have seen the recorder’s notes which referred to Affandi when he signed the contemporaneous statement.
(c) Third, if Fadzli was somehow prevented from having a good look of the photographs, he could have asked SSgt Fardlie to allow him to have a better look at them, instead of answering that he did not know the people in the photographs.
(d) Fourth, Fadzli gave conflicting accounts about whether he was able to recognise Mansor or not (see [82] above).
- [87]
[87] Some of these were addressed by Fadzli at trial. As regards the first, Fadzli explained that:
As regards the second, Fadzli explained that:
These explanations do not seem plainly implausible and it does not appear they were pursued under cross examination; but the more important point is that none of the Prosecution’s arguments could overcome the difficulties we have noted at [84] above. In the final analysis, the Judge could not have been clear as to just what Fadzli was being shown. Accordingly, he could not then have concluded that Fadzli was lying and then placed reliance on this “lie” to support the conviction of Fadzli.
(2) The statement that he was not known as “Abut”
- [88]
[88] We turn to Fadzli’s inclusion of the following words to the print version of P119, his statement dated 16 July 2013:
- [89]
[89] At trial, Fadzli testified that he had made a mistake and that he meant to say that “[he] was not known as Abut to anyone except to [his] family members and to those friends who has [sic] come to [his] house before”.
- [90]
[90] The Judge thought that this inclusion showed that Fadzli had something to hide because he was involved in activities with Affandi for which they were arrested (Judgment at [108]). The Prosecution also submitted that a clear inference to be drawn was that Fadzli was trying to dissociate himself from Affandi and the drugs found on the day of the arrest.
- [91]
[91] In our judgment, these conclusions were not the only ones that could inexorably be drawn from the circumstances. As Mr Tiwary noted, Fadzli had not denied knowing and meeting Affandi in his cautioned statement given just three days earlier:
This displaces any weight being placed on this addition as an indication of Fadzli’s desire to distance himself from Affandi. We therefore find that this insertion was neutral in that it could possibly have been a genuine mistake, as Fadzli testified at trial.
Calls between Fadzli and Affandi on the morning of 12 July 2013
- [92]
[92] We turn to the final point: the calls between Fadzli and Affandi on the morning of 12 July 2013. Specifically, these calls were made between Affandi and Fadzli at 3.38am, 5.37am, 6.21am and 6.23am (Judgment at [68]).
- [93]
[93] At trial, and in the Prosecution’s submissions before us, the focus was on Affandi’s call to Fadzli at 3.38am. Both Affandi and Fadzli testified that there was an arrangement between them that the person who wakes up first would call and wake the other person up for a pre-dawn meal since it was the month of Ramadan.
- [94]
[94] The Judge did not address the explanation proffered by the accused. He found that on the morning of 12 July 2013, there was “a high level of communication” between Affandi and Fadzli as well as between Affandi and Mamak after Affandi returned from Johor Bahru, and that this “showed that something was going on between them which required them to stay up in the early hours of the morning and communicate with one another” (Judgment at [68]–[69]).
- [95]
[95] On appeal, the Prosecution submitted that the accused’s explanation for the 3.38am call was not plausible because on Affandi’s account, he would have just collected the bundles under suspicious circumstances in a deserted heavy vehicle carpark and he claimed to be so afraid that he decided not to drive directly home. It would therefore seem unlikely that Affandi would have the presence of mind to call Fadzli for a pre-dawn meal. Further, Affandi also said that he set a phone alarm to call Fadzli, and this could not be reconciled with their account that the arrangement was for the person who woke up first to call the other.
- [96]
[96] Mr Tiwary submitted that there was no objective evidence of what was said during the calls, and that it was unsafe to conclude that the calls “had something to do with the eight bundles of heroin in Affandi’s car”.
- [97]
[97] We agree with Mr Tiwary’s submissions. There was insufficient evidence to conclude one way or the other whether Affandi’s call to Fadzli at 3.38am was connected to delivery of the eight bundles of diamorphine. It should be noted that Fadzli was not the only person that Affandi was in touch with in the early morning of 12 July 2013. As the Judge noted, there was also a heightened level of communication between Affandi and Mamak after 3.30am (Judgment at [69]).
- [98]
[98] In fact, even prior to the 3.38am call, there was a call from Affandi to Mamak at 3.35am. Affandi’s evidence was that he received calls from Mamak asking him to meet a friend on his behalf at the carpark after Ten Mile Junction and that he acceded to this request when Mamak called at “3.00-plus am”. (In relation to this piece of evidence, there was a discrepancy with the phone records which showed that the call at 3.35am (which was the only call between Affandi and Mamak from 3am to 4am of 12 July 2013) was an outgoing call from Affandi; nonetheless, we do not find this to be of such materiality that we ought to disregard the substance of Affandi’s evidence entirely). Between 4.14am and 4.36am, there were also two outgoing calls from Affandi to Mamak, two messages sent by Affandi and two messages received from Mamak. Affandi’s evidence was that he was trying to ask Mamak what was in the bundles he received, but Mamak rebuffed him, telling him that he was busy, and Affandi therefore never got to verify the contents of the bundle with Mamak.
- [99]
[99] This takes us back to our observations at [63] above – that Affandi was in close contact with Mamak, who was identified to be Fadzli’s drug supplier. In fact, there was a flurry of communications between Affandi and Mamak on the morning of 12 July 2013, the date on which Affandi took possession of the bundles alleged to contain diamorphine. In our judgment, it was equally plausible that Mamak and Affandi were in touch for the delivery of the bundles, and that Fadzli was not involved. We therefore do not find that the calls between Fadzli and Affandi on the morning of 12 July 2013, even if they might have been suspicious, would have sufficed to support the Prosecution’s account of the events.
Conclusion
- [100]
[100] We therefore allow the appeals against the convictions on Charges A and E. Our primary finding is that the Prosecution has failed to establish the chain of custody of the relevant exhibits.
Introduction
- [102]
[102] I have had the advantage of reading in draft the judgment of Menon CJ with which Chao SJ concurs. I shall refer to that judgment as “the majority Judgment”. For easy reference, I adopt the same abbreviations and references used in the majority Judgment unless otherwise stated.
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.