Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 15 Jan 2020

Court of Appeal

BZD v BZE

Feedback & support

[2020] SGCA 01Case no. Civil Appeal No 134 of 201910 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Facts

  2. [2] The parties were married in 1996. The husband is a British national. He was a banker during the marriage and remains so at present. The wife is a Taiwanese national. She was a homemaker throughout the marriage and has not sought employment since the divorce. The husband filed his writ for divorce on 7 September 2007. Interim judgment was granted on 7 March 2008, which was made final on 10 January 2011. The parties have two children to the marriage and were granted shared care and control of them. The son is currently 17 years old and is studying at a boarding school in the UK. The daughter is 19 years old and is studying at a university in the UK.

  3. (a) The husband shall pay the wife a sum of $6,400 per month being her maintenance ($3,500 for her personal expenses, $2,500 for rent, and $400 for maid expenses);

  4. (b) The husband shall pay the wife a sum of $600 per month being maintenance contribution for the children for the period they are with her;

  5. (c) The husband shall pay for the air fare expenses for the two children for two visits to Taiwan per year;

  6. (d) The husband shall pay the wife holiday expenses in respect of the children at $1,000 for both children per visit to Taiwan;

  7. (e) The husband shall pay for all the children’s educational and medical expenses;

  8. (f) All maintenance payment shall commence from 1 March 2011.

  9. Decision below

  10. (a) That the rental component of $2,500 per month and the maid component of $400 per month shall cease with effect from 1 August 2019; and

  11. (b) That the husband shall continue to pay to the wife the $3,500 per month for her personal expenses and the $600 per month for any period she spends with the children up to 1 February 2020 only.

  12. [7] The Judge dismissed the wife’s application in SUM 1722 to increase the maintenance payable on the basis that it was speculative since there was no evidence of the wife having taken any steps to move to the UK. She also found that the wife’s decision to move to the UK was a self-induced change of circumstances that was unreasonable having regard to the circumstances.

  13. [8] CA 134 of 2019 is the wife’s appeal against the Judge’s decision to dismiss the wife’s application in SUM 1722 while CA 135 of 2019 is the main appeal by the wife against the Judge’s decision to allow the husband’s application in SUM 609, effectively terminating maintenance payments to her for her personal expenses as well as the expenses during the time spent with the children. The wife is not appealing against the decision as regards rental and maid expenses.

  14. Decision on the appeals

  15. [9] The starting point in determining the appeals is s 118 of the Women’s Charter which reads:

  16. (a) Such change being alleged is a change from circumstances prevailing during the ancillary matters hearing;

  17. (b) Such change arose after the ancillary matters hearing; and

  18. (c) Such change is sufficient enough to satisfy the court that a variation of maintenance is necessitated.

  19. CA 135 of 2019

  20. [13] The question then is whether the fact that the husband’s income has increased substantially beyond that of the increase in the children’s educational expenses, it can still be said that there is a material change in the circumstances. In our view, the answer must be in the negative for two reasons.

  21. The wife lives in the apartment on Devonshire Road and rents out the Martin Place apartment at $3,800 per month, which she uses to service the mortgage loan on that property. She has approximately $102,572.40 in cash in her bank accounts.

  22. [17] It is clear that the two properties she owns remained heavily mortgaged and that the sum of their net values, should they be liquidated, do not constitute a significant increase from the amount of matrimonial assets she received from the divorce.

  23. [19] In the first place, we do not think that the husband raised the issue of the wife’s ability to work as a material change of circumstances supporting his application for variation. At best, there is merely a suggestion by the husband that the wife can and should obtain employment when she moves back to Taiwan, where she is guaranteed residency status.

  24. [20] In our view, the husband’s submission as regards the wife’s employment status remains speculative. There is no evidence that the wife has found or is about to find employment in Taiwan. It cannot be overlooked that the wife has not been working since the marriage almost 25 years ago. It is therefore not realistic to expect her to find employment at a level sufficient to displace the current monthly maintenance which she is receiving from the husband. In short, there is no evidence of any material change in circumstances vis-à-vis the wife’s employment status to justify any change in the monthly maintenance payable to her.

  25. CA 134 of 2019

  26. [21] We turn then to the wife’s application to increase the maintenance payable to her because she intends to relocate to the UK as she is concerned for the well-being of the children.

  27. [22] We find the wife’s appeal to be unmeritorious. We agree with the Judge that the application is entirely speculative. Till today, there is no evidence before this court that the wife has taken any steps, preparatory or otherwise, to move to the UK. Moreover, any such move would be an unreasonable decision bearing in mind inter alia the fact that the children are now 17 and 19 years old and are engaged in full-time study on campus. We note that the wife has not visited the children in the UK since they moved over. Having said that, we do not think this has any material bearing on the care and control of the children shared by the parties.

  28. Conclusion