Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 24 Nov 2021

Court of Appeal

Shanghai Shipyard Co Ltd v Opus Tiger 1 Pte Ltd and another and other appeals and another matter

Feedback & support

[2021] SGCA 109Case no. Civil Appeal No 179 of 2020 and Summons 81 of 202120 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The background facts to these four appeals have been set out in detail by the judge below (“the Judge”) in his Grounds of Decision (“GD”) and we therefore provide only a brief summary. The appellant, Shanghai Shipyard Co Ltd (“SSY”), is a party to shipbuilding contracts (“the Contracts”) with the first respondent companies in each of these appeals (collectively, “the OT Companies”). The OT Companies are the subsidiaries of Opus Offshore Ltd (“OOL”), a Bermudan-incorporated company. The second respondent, Reignwood International Investment (Group) Co Ltd (“Reignwood”), is a 70% shareholder and a creditor of OOL. Reignwood provided SSY with a guarantee in respect of certain obligations of two of the respondents, Opus Tiger 1 Pte Ltd (“OT1”) and Opus Tiger 2 Pte Ltd (“OT2”).

  3. [2] Sometime in December 2016, disputes arose under the Contracts. OOL became insolvent in February 2017 and was put into provisional liquidation under Bermudan law (see GD at [15]-16]). SSY served a notice terminating the Contract with OT1 in February 2017, and did the same in respect of the Contracts with the remaining OT Companies in March 2017 (see GD at [20]-[21]). Following an unsuccessful demand in May 2017 on Reignwood on the guarantee given in connection with OT1, SSY commenced proceedings against Reignwood in the English courts in November 2018 to enforce that guarantee.

  4. [4] In October 2019, SSY applied to be joined under O 15 r 6(2)(b) of the Rules of Court (Cap 322, R 5, 2014 Rev Ed) (“the Rules of Court”) to the Leave Applications (“the Joinder Applications”). By the time the Joinder Applications were heard by the Judge in August 2020, the Arbitrations were already underway. Before the Judge, SSY argued that it ought to be joined on the basis that it was the intended defendant of the Arbitrations.

  5. [6] The Judge granted SSY leave to appeal against his decision, on the basis that he had decided a general principle of law for the first time - namely, that persons who could be joined under O 15 r 6(2)(b) to a s 216A application were limited to the company’s insiders. However, before us, SSY no longer seeks to be joined on the ground of it being the intended defendant of the Arbitrations, but by virtue of it being a “proper person” within s 216A(1)(c) of the Act (“the Alternative Case”). Sometime before the hearing of these appeals, SSY also filed an application in Summons No 81 of 2021 (“SUM 81”) to adduce further evidence on appeal.

  6. [7] Four issues were placed before us:

  7. (a) whether SUM 81 should be allowed;

  8. (c) whether SSY can satisfy the non-discretionary requirements for joinder in O 15 r 6(2)(b) by virtue of its status as the intended defendant of the Arbitrations; and

  9. (d) whether SSY should be permitted to advance the Alternative Case before us.

  10. Our decision

  11. Whether the court still had the power to order SSY’s joinder after the Leave Applications had been determined

  12. [12] In the De La Sala case, without deciding the issue, we also expressed our reservations about what appears to be a more liberal standard that was adopted by the English High Court in C Inc plc v L and another [2001] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 459 (“C Inc”). In C Inc, the plaintiff sought to add a third-party (the defendant’s husband) as an additional defendant so that he would also be bound by a judgment obtained against the defendant who had, post judgment, claimed to be holding her assets on trust for the husband. The issue was whether the court had the power to join a new party when judgment had been obtained against the only existing defendant. This required a consideration of how the word “proceedings” (in the context of r 19.2(2) of the UK Civil Procedure Rules) were to be interpreted (at [82]). Aikens J held that the word “proceedings” was to be interpreted broadly so that it embraced all stages of an action from the time it has been started until it becomes finally complete or moribund, and so even after a judgment has been obtained, if it has not been satisfied so that further action may still be needed to enforce that judgment, proceedings remained afoot (at [83]).

  13. The liberal standard is not part of Singapore law

  14. [14] With respect, we disagree with the approach taken by the Judge and we hold that the liberal standard in C Inc is not part of Singapore law. This is so for a few reasons. First, the liberal standard has troubling implications for finality in litigation as it adopts a much broader conception of what constitutes a thing that “remains to be done” so that proceedings would be considered ongoing even after a final judgment had been extracted and attempts at enforcement had commenced. Thus, the joinder of new parties would be possible so long as a single cent of judgment debt remained unpaid (see De La Sala at [200]-[201]).

  15. Whether something “remains to be done” after a complainant has been granted or refused leave in a s 216A application

  16. Whether SSY can satisfy the non-discretionary requirements for joinder in O 15 r 6(2)(b)

  17. [22] Our conclusion above disposes of these appeals, but we go on to make some observations about SSY’s standing to be joined given that this is the first case before us in which the intended defendant seeking to be joined to a s 216A application is not also an insider of the company.

  18. [24] We agree with the Judge that the sole issue in a s 216A application is whether the court ought to sanction a deviation from the principle of majority rule by compelling a company to litigate contrary to the will of its shareholders and directors. That issue, which is one concerning the management of the company, is exclusively for its insiders. From a legal perspective an intended defendant who is not also an insider of the company can have no interest in the management of the company, even if it is concerned not to be sued by the company. To allow an intended defendant of proposed derivative proceedings to have a say on how the company’s claim against itself should be managed smacks of the most extreme conflict of interest. Permitting the joinder of such a party to a s 216A application will therefore run contrary to the notion that the affairs of a company should be run in its best interests. One of the main factors that a court hearing a s 216A application has to consider is whether granting the application would be in the company’s interests. A prospective defendant, even one who has some basis to believe that the intended claim will fail, can have nothing relevant to say on that point.

  19. [25] Since the issues arising in a s 216A application in no way concern an intended defendant who is not also an insider of the company, the nonjoinder of such an intended defendant will not prevent the complete and effectual determination of the s 216A application, and so the non-discretionary requirements for joinder under the “necessity” limb will not be satisfied.

  20. [26] Where the “just and convenient” limb in O 15 r 6(2)(b)(ii) is relied on, the party seeking to be joined must show that there is a question or issue involving itself which relates to an existing question or issue between the existing parties (De La Sala at [204]). While there is no requirement that the question or issue involving the third-party be common with the existing question or issue in the main dispute (Lim Meng-Eu Judy v RSP Investments (S) Pte Ltd [1998] 2 SLR(R) 525 at [13]), a mere factual overlap between the two will not suffice and the third-party question or issue must have the “requisite relationship” with the main dispute (De La Sala at [204]).

  21. [27] Before the Judge, SSY argued that whether the proposed derivative proceedings had merits was one such issue (see GD at [147]). The Judge rejected SSY’s argument. He held that the threshold on the merits which a complainant must clear to prove that the proposed derivative proceedings are prima facie in the interests of the company was not the converse of the threshold on the merits with which an intended defendant would be concerned on an application to strike out the derivative proceedings once they were commenced (GD at [148]). We agree with the Judge. The issue relating to the merits of the proposed derivative proceedings with which an intended defendant is concerned is hardly one which bears the “requisite relationship” with any of the issues in a s 216A application. At this stage the application is not concerned with the substantive merits of the contemplated derivative proceedings, but only whether those proceedings are legitimate or arguable, and not frivolous, vexatious or bound to be unsuccessful (see Fong Wai Lyn Carolyn v Airtrust (Singapore) Pte Ltd and another [2011] 3 SLR 980 at [10] and Urs Meisterhans v GIP Pte Ltd [2011] 1 SLR 552 at [25]).

  22. [28] Where the court grants the complainant leave in a s 216A application, it facilitates the initiation of proceedings against the intended defendant, so that it is now engaged in litigation that it otherwise would not have been. In these circumstances, the interest of an intended defendant who is not also an insider of the company in the s 216A application cannot be characterised as anything but a mere commercial interest in its outcome. That, however, will not suffice for the purposes of O 15 r 6(2)(b), which requires that a party seeking to be joined must at least have some legal interest that is directly related or connected to the subject matter of the action between the existing parties (see Singapore Civil Procedure Vol I (Cavinder Bull SC gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 2021) at para 15/6/9).

  23. [29] For the foregoing reasons, we agree with the Judge that an intended defendant who is not also an insider of the company cannot satisfy the non-discretionary requirements for joinder under both the “necessity” and “just and convenient” limbs of O 15 r 6(2)(b). In the circumstances, there is no need for us to consider the discretionary requirements of O 15 r 6(2)(b).

  24. [30] For completeness, we also make two related observations. First, we endorse the Judge’s decision that SSY cannot be joined to the Leave Applications pursuant to the court’s inherent jurisdiction (see GD at [205]). The inherent jurisdiction of the court should only be invoked in exceptional circumstances where there is a clear need for it and the justice of the case so demands. Since SSY cannot even satisfy the non-discretionary requirements for joinder under O 15 r 6(2)(b), there can be no circumstances of necessity which justify the court’s exercise of its inherent jurisdiction.

  25. The Alternative Case

  26. [32] Turning to the Alternative Case, SSY argues that it is a “proper person” within s 216A(1)(c) of the Act and so will satisfy the requirements for joinder under O 15 r 6(2)(b). This is because, notwithstanding it being the single largest creditor in any liquidation of each of the OT Companies by virtue of its claims under the Contracts, and the general principle that the economic interests of creditors come to the fore when a company is insolvent or near-insolvent, SSY has no power to influence management and so is in a position akin to that of a minority shareholder.

  27. [34] In their skeletal submissions, SSY stated that the Alternative Case was not a departure from their case before the Judge and they were now merely contending that the Judge’s ruling that an outsider of the company may not be joined to a s 216A application was erroneous as there were circumstances where an outsider may nevertheless have an interest in the management of the company for the purposes of joinder. SSY has mischaracterised the Judge’s decision. While the implication of the Judge’s decision - that only the company’s insiders can be joined under O 15 r 6(2)(b) to a s 216A application - is that outsiders of the company will not come within the category of persons that can be so joined, the Judge did not decide, as a general proposition, that outsiders of the company cannot be joined to a s 216A application.

  28. [35] Second, by advancing the Alternative Case, which contradicts its case before the Judge, SSY comes close to acting in abuse of the appellate process by discarding the entire basis on which the Joinder Applications had proceeded before the Judge and seeking to re-argue the Joinder Applications afresh before us. This is precisely what we had cautioned against in JWR Pte Ltd v Edmond Pereira Law Corp and another [2020] 2 SLR 744.

  29. [36] In any event, we will add that there are no merits whatsoever in the factual contention underlying the Alternative Case - that SSY is the single largest creditor in any liquidation of each of the OT Companies. As the Judge has pointed out, the claims by SSY against each of the OT Companies under the Contracts remain unadjudicated (see GD at [171]). More critically, SSY’s factual contention is fundamentally misplaced because it presupposes that the OT Companies are already insolvent (when they were not yet subject to any formal insolvency proceedings but were only rendered insolvent as a result of the insolvency of OOL, on which they are dependent for funding: see GD at [13]-[14]) and that SSY is in fact the largest creditor of each of the OT Companies. If that were indeed the case, SSY could have simply applied for the winding-up of the OT Companies. Obviously, SSY must have known that it has no basis to do so, but yet it seeks to achieve that same result by attempting to make this argument before us.

  30. [37] We note that the Judge has suggested that a “proper person” within s 216A(1)(c) of the Act may constitute an “insider” of the company and so will satisfy the non-discretionary requirements under O 15 r 6(2)(b) to be joined to a s 216A application (see GD at [111], [114], [146] and [216]). Given that we are not prepared to consider the Alternative Case, we also express no concluded view on this point and reserve it for an appropriate occasion in the future. The only provisional observations we make at this time are the following. First, even if those managing an insolvent company that has not been liquidated have a duty to prioritise the interests of the creditors, that does not mean a creditor can take over managing the company without instituting insolvency proceedings. Second, it seems to us there are legislative provisions designed to deal with this concern, for instance in the prohibition against and remedies available in the event of fraudulent or wrongful trading.

  31. Conclusion