Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 10 Aug 2021

Court of Appeal

Cheung Teck Cheong Richard and others v LVND Investments Pte Ltd

Feedback & support

[2021] SGCA 77Case no. Civil Appeal No 204 of 2020

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] The history of this dispute as well as the exchange of correspondence reveal that both sides were at loggerheads on just about everything concerning the terms of an intended reference to arbitration for the resolution of the disputes between them. In the light of this conduct, a finding that the parties nonetheless made an ad hoc arbitration agreement which was independent of a clause in the contract that they had thought (incorrectly) was an arbitration agreement would intuitively appear to be questionable.

  3. [2] In Cheung Teck Cheong Richard and others v LVND Investments Pte Ltd [2021] SGHC 28 (“the GD”), the High Court judge (“the Judge”) explained his decision to affirm the decision of the Assistant Registrar (“the AR”) to stay the proceedings in favour of arbitration, finding that there was such an ad hoc arbitration agreement. He also expressed the view in obiter that s 4(6) of the Arbitration Act (Cap 10, 2002 Rev Ed) (“AA”) could operate to deem the formation of an arbitration agreement even if there was no such pre-existing arbitration agreement.

  4. [3] As we have indicated above, we are of the view that the Judge’s finding as to the existence of an ad hoc arbitration agreement cannot be upheld. This appeal thus raised an interesting point of law as to whether s 4(6) of the AA, if it applied on the instant facts, can be relied upon to deem the existence of an arbitration agreement notwithstanding the court’s finding that none existed as a matter of fact. For the reasons set out below, we decide the question in the negative. In our view, for parties who have not denied the existence of an arbitration agreement, s 4(6) of the AA serves the limited purpose of precluding them from relying on the absence of an agreement in writing to challenge the validity of such an arbitration agreement for the purposes of the AA. It cannot be construed to permit the creation or formation of a new arbitration agreement through the operation of its deeming effect.

  5. [4] Having set out our views in brief, we turn now to the facts, before elaborating on the reasons for our decision.

  6. Facts

  7. Parties

  8. Background to the dispute

  9. [6] The underlying disputes between the Purchasers and the Developer arise out of allegations that the Developer had made fraudulent misrepresentations and suppressed material facts that induced the Purchasers into purchasing their respective units in the Mall. In particular, the Purchasers allege that the sizes of their units were smaller than the area that each of them had believed it was buying.

  10. The first attempted arbitration

  11. [7] When the disputes arose, the Purchasers engaged a law firm (the “Former Solicitors”) who advised them to seek recourse through arbitration. The Former Solicitors took the view that cl 20A.1 of the SPAs (which was identical in each SPA) was an arbitration agreement. On 6 May 2019, the Former Solicitors issued a Notice of Arbitration (“the 1st NOA”) against the Developer to commence arbitration under the auspices of the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (“SIAC”). The Developer’s solicitors, Rajah & Tann Singapore LLP (“R&T”), issued 12 responses, each dated 21 May 2019, objecting to the proposed arbitration because the Developer did not agree (a) that the arbitration should be administered by the SIAC; (b) that the arbitration should be conducted according to the SIAC Rules; and (c) that the disputes should be consolidated in a single arbitration. On 19 June 2019, the Court of Arbitration of the SIAC found that it was “not prima facie satisfied that the parties ha[d] agreed that [the] SIAC shall administer these arbitrations, or on the application of the SIAC Rules in these references”. The SIAC accordingly terminated the arbitrations commenced by the 1st NOA. We refer to this as the “1st Attempted Arbitration”.

  12. The second attempted arbitration

  13. [8] On 28 June 2019, the Purchasers’ Former Solicitors issued a second Notice of Arbitration (“the 2nd NOA”), constituting a request for the disputes to be referred to an arbitration to be commenced on an ad hoc basis in Singapore, and nominating a sole arbitrator. On 2 July 2019, in a letter from R&T to the Purchasers’ Former Solicitors, the Developer objected to what it regarded as an attempt “to consolidate different arbitrations” in a single ad hoc arbitration. Further correspondence followed. On 29 July 2019, the Purchasers’ Former Solicitors wrote to the President of the Court of Arbitration of the SIAC seeking the appointment of a single arbitrator. On 2 August 2019, R&T wrote to the SIAC stating the Developer’s position that no ad hoc arbitration had been validly commenced as it was a defective attempt to commence a single consolidated arbitration, and in any event, if all the Purchasers wanted to commence any arbitration there would have to be 12 different ad hoc arbitrations and 12 arbitrators would need to be appointed. It also disagreed with the Purchasers’ nomination of a sole arbitrator.

  14. [9] In September 2019, the Purchasers obtained different legal advice. They discharged the Former Solicitors and engaged their present counsel. On 3 February 2020, the Purchasers notified the SIAC that they did not wish to proceed against the Developer by way of the arbitration proceedings purportedly commenced by the 2nd NOA, and this attempt at arbitration was thus discontinued. We will refer to this as the “2nd Attempted Arbitration”.

  15. Court proceedings

  16. The decision below

  17. [12] The Judge dismissed the Developer’s appeal in RA 111, holding that cl 20A.1 of the SPAs was not an arbitration agreement within the definition of s 4(1) of the AA. He held that the clause “did not objectively evince any intention by the parties to be bound to submit their disputes arising from the SPAs to arbitration” [emphasis in original] (see the GD at [29]). All that cl 20A.1 required was that the parties consider mediation before referring the dispute to either “arbitration or court proceedings”. Clause 20A.1 also could not be read as giving rise to the right to elect for arbitration unilaterally – the only imperative in cl 20A.1 was in relation to considering mediation, and not the submission to either arbitration or litigation (at [33]). No appeal arises from the Judge’s dismissal of RA 111.

  18. [13] As for RA 112, the Judge identified five issues for his determination (see the GD at [24]):

  19. (a) Did the parties conclude a valid and binding arbitration agreement, independent from cl 20A.1 of the SPAs?

  20. (b) Did s 4(6) of the AA apply to the present case to deem an effective arbitration agreement between the parties?

  21. (c) If there was a valid arbitration agreement, was this agreement vitiated by mistake?

  22. (d) If there was no valid arbitration agreement, were the Purchasers estopped from taking the position that there was no valid arbitration agreement?

  23. [14] In relation to the first issue, the Judge held that the parties did conclude a valid and binding arbitration agreement independent from cl 20A.1 of the SPAs (see the GD at [35]). In the Judge’s view, this was clear from the 1st and 2nd NOAs, and the attendant correspondence exchanged in the course of the 1st and 2nd Attempted Arbitrations (at [36]–[37]). The Judge also found that the agreement was recorded in writing as required by s 4(3) of the AA, read with s 4(4) of the AA (at [39]–[43]).

  24. [15] In relation to the second issue, the Judge also found that s 4(6) of the AA applied, and there was deemed to be an effective arbitration agreement as between the parties to the proceedings (see the GD at [45]). He found that there were two main sources of ambiguity in s 4(6) of the AA: (a) what constituted “any other document in circumstances in which the assertion calls for a reply”; and (b) what was meant by the deeming of an “effective arbitration agreement”.

  25. (a) Applying the ejusdem generis principle of statutory interpretation, the Judge held that “any other document in circumstances in which the assertion calls for a reply” referred to a document made in or for an arbitral or legal proceeding, and which involved participation in such proceeding or formed part of the record of that proceeding (see the GD at [60]). With this definition, the Judge found that notices of arbitration fell within the scope of s 4(6) of the AA and that if a response is given and no objection is raised to the arbitration, s 4(6) would deem there to be an effective arbitration agreement. However, if no response is given to the notice of arbitration at all, then s 4(6) would not apply (at [61]–[62]). On the facts of this case, this requirement was met (at [64]).

  26. (b) On the effect of s 4(6) of the AA, the Judge expressed the tentative view (see the GD at [65]) that there was no need for a pre-existing arbitration agreement, and that s 4(6) can be used to deem the existence of an agreement to arbitrate, ie, it “creates the legal fiction that there is an existing arbitration agreement through that assertion and non-denial in that arbitral or legal proceeding” (at [70]).

  27. [16] The Judge then considered whether the arbitration agreement was vitiated by mistake. As a preliminary point, he noted that the Purchasers had not made clear whether they were relying on the doctrine of common mistake or mutual mistake (see GD at [74]). He then found that the Purchasers had not shown that they were labouring under a mistaken belief that cl 20A.1 was an arbitration agreement, or that the Developer was mistaken as to the effect of cl 20A.1 either (at [81]). They had also not shown that the parties held the mistaken belief that there was a separate, broader agreement to arbitrate apart from cl 20A.1 on an ad hoc basis (at [83]).

  28. [17] Having arrived at the above conclusions, there was no need to decide whether the Purchasers were estopped from denying the existence of a valid arbitration agreement. The Judge observed, however, that he would have struggled to accept the argument on the facts, as there was no reliance or detriment suffered by the Developer in this case (see the GD at [85]–[86]).

  29. [18] On the issue of whether the court should exercise its discretion not to grant a stay of the Suit, the Judge found that the situation was not so exceptional as to warrant refusal of a stay (see the GD at [92]). The Judge therefore upheld the AR’s decision to grant a stay of the Suit in favour of arbitration proceedings.

  30. Parties’ submissions on appeal

  31. Appellants’ case

  32. [19] The Appellants contend that (a) the Judge erred in finding that the parties had entered into an arbitration agreement apart from cl 20A.1 of the SPAs; (b) the Judge erred in finding that an arbitration agreement was deemed to have arisen by virtue of s 4(6) of the AA; (c) even if there was an arbitration agreement, it was vitiated by the operation of the doctrine of mistake; and (d) even if there was an arbitration agreement that was not vitiated by mistake, the facts warranted an exercise of discretion not to stay the Suit.

  33. [20] On whether the parties had entered into an arbitration agreement, the Appellants’ position is: (a) first, that the 1st NOA was not an offer to arbitrate, hence there could also be no acceptance of any offer; (b) second, that there was in any event no final and unqualified expression of assent by the Developer to the 1st NOA; (c) third, that the Developer’s response to the 1st NOA was in the context of the references to cl 20A.1 of the SPAs in the 1st NOA; (d) fourth, that there were no facts to show any separate offer to arbitrate, no facts to show any consideration, and no intention to create legal relations apart from the SPAs. These considerations also applied to the 2nd NOA. Even if the 1st and 2nd NOAs were offers, they were specific offers to arbitrate under the SIAC Rules (for the 1st NOA) and for a single ad hoc arbitration (for the 2nd NOA), both of which were rejected by the Developer.

  34. [21] In relation to s 4(6) of the AA, the Appellants first take issue with the Judge’s finding that the 1st and 2nd NOAs fell within the scope of “any other document in which the assertion calls for a reply”. The Appellants argue that notices of arbitration are not the sort of documents which trigger s 4(6) of the AA as (a) the issuance of a notice of arbitration does not necessarily initiate arbitrations; and (b) notices of arbitration are not, as required by s 4(6) of the AA, “issued in the course of arbitral or legal proceedings”.

  35. [22] The Appellants also argue that the Judge erred in finding that s 4(6) of the AA deems a full and complete arbitration to be in existence, as opposed to merely deeming that such an agreement satisfies the writing requirement under s 4(3) of the AA. They submit that deeming provisions ought to be construed strictly and only for the purpose for which they are resorted to. In their view, s 4(6) of the AA shares the same purpose as Art 7(2) of the 1985 UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (“1985 Model Law”) and, as such, would only operate to deem effective an arbitration agreement that was defective on account of non-compliance with the AA’s writing requirement. Where there was no agreement in the first place, as contended by the Appellants, there was no agreement to be made effective.

  36. [23] As to the issue of mistake, the Appellants clarify that they are relying on common mistake in this case. They argue that the Judge’s main reason for rejecting their earlier arguments was that “the Purchasers and Developers had not in their evidence stated that the [parties] were mistaken as to the effect of cl 20A.1”. To this, the Appellant’s contention is that the mistake was “plain to see” and that the entire body of conduct surrounding cl 20A.1 made it clear that the parties had been mistaken as to its legal effect.

  37. Developer’s case

  38. [26] Turning then to the substantive issues, the Developer submits that there was an arbitration agreement between the parties on a prima facie standard of review. The parties were ad idem that the disputes should be submitted to arbitration, and the express pronouncements by the parties that they had agreed to arbitration could not be interpreted in any other way. In any event, there was also a valid arbitration agreement under s 4(6) of the AA. The Developer supports the Judge’s interpretation of both the scope of documents that would suffice for s 4(6) of the AA to apply and the deeming effect of s 4(6). Further, the Developer also argues that the Appellants are estopped from taking the position that no valid arbitration agreement exists. It also submits that the arbitration agreement entered into was not vitiated by mistake, the allegation of mistake is a “red herring”, and there is no evidential basis for the claim of mistake. Even if the parties were mistaken about the effect of cl 20A.1, this did not mean that the arbitration agreement was vitiated by mistake, as the 2nd NOA was premised not on cl 20A.1 but on the fact that the Developer had agreed to arbitrate.

  39. [27] If an arbitration agreement is found, then, the Developer argues, this court should uphold the stay, and the factors raised by the Appellants do not justify an exercise of discretion otherwise.

  40. Issues to be determined

  41. [28] Based on the foregoing, the issues that arise for our determination are as follows:

  42. (a) Did the Judge err in finding that the parties had entered into an arbitration agreement apart from cl 20A.1 of the SPAs?

  43. (b) Did the Judge err in holding that s 4(6) of the AA would deem there to be an arbitration agreement between the parties?

  44. (c) If the answer to either (a) or (b) is “No”, did the Judge err in holding that the arbitration agreement was not vitiated by a common mistake as to the effect of cl 20A.1 of the SPAs?

  45. (d) Were the Appellants estopped from denying the existence of a valid arbitration agreement?

  46. (e) If there was a valid arbitration agreement or the Appellants were estopped from denying the existence of such an agreement, did the Judge err in deciding to grant the stay of the Suit?

  47. Clause 20A.1 of the SPAs

  48. [29] Before turning to each of these issues, we begin with a brief consideration of cl 20A.1 of the SPAs. We agree with the Judge that cl 20A.1 is not an arbitration agreement within the definition of s 4(1) of the AA, for the reasons set out by the Judge in the GD. Although there is no cross-appeal by the Developer against the Judge’s finding, it remains relevant to determine whether the Judge’s decision on this point was correct for the purposes of our analysis of s 4(6) of the AA (see [70] and [131] below).

  49. [30] We set out cl 20A of the SPAs in full:

  50. [31] On a plain reading of cl 20A.1, it is clear that there was no agreement to submit the dispute to arbitration, which is the hallmark of an arbitration agreement: see s 4(1) of the AA and Dyna-Jet Pte Ltd v Wilson Taylor Asia Pacific Pte Ltd [2017] 3 SLR 267 (“Dyna-Jet”) at [37]. It is significant that the heading for cl 20A is “Mediation”. The clear purpose of cl 20A.1 is to require the parties to “consider resolving the dispute or difference through mediation” before referring any dispute to arbitration or court proceedings. Indeed, even this obligation to consider mediation did not rise to the level of an obligation to mediate.

  51. [32] Clause 20A.1 in itself does not require the parties to submit the dispute to arbitration. It merely provides that the parties are at liberty to refer the dispute to either arbitration or court proceedings after considering mediation. The options for dispute resolution available to the parties would have been no different absent this clause because the clause was only designed to encourage mediation, leaving the exact form of adjudicatory dispute resolution to be decided by the parties. Clause 20A.1 remains entirely neutral as to what dispute resolution mechanism is to be used after mediation is considered. It does not confer on any party the unilateral right to commence arbitration against the other party without the concurrence of the other party, since the parties have not agreed to arbitration as the binding form of dispute settlement. The Judge was therefore eminently correct to find that cl 20A.1 was not an arbitration agreement.

  52. Did the parties enter into an arbitration agreement independent of cl 20A.1?

  53. [33] Given the absence of an arbitration agreement in the parties’ SPAs, the question is whether the parties had otherwise entered into an arbitration agreement which would justify a stay under s 6 of the AA. With respect, we are unable to agree with the Judge on this point and find that the parties had not entered into an arbitration agreement independent of cl 20A.1 of the SPAs. We begin by explaining our approach to this question, before turning to apply that approach to the facts.

  54. Our approach to this question

  55. [34] An “arbitration agreement” is defined by s 4(1) of the AA. However, even before one considers whether an agreement can be characterised as an arbitration agreement, it goes without saying that there must be an agreement in the first place. The question of whether there is a legally enforceable agreement is one of contract law, specifically, contract formation: see Dyna-Jet at [40].

  56. [35] The standard to be applied to this question, in an application for a stay under s 6 of the AA, is the prima facie standard. As this court held in Sim Chay Koon and others v NTUC Income Insurance Co-operative Ltd [2016] 2 SLR 871 at [5]:

  57. [36] The present dispute raises a specific question in relation to the formation of a contract. Have the parties proceeded simply on the basis of what they believed to be a prior arbitration agreement in cl 20A.1 of the SPAs, or have they agreed, independently of cl 20A.1 of the SPAs, to submit the disputes to arbitration? The problem can be simply restated as follows: if the parties had believed that they were acting in accordance with an existing contractual obligation, could the parties be taken to intend to enter into a separate contract to arbitrate by that same conduct? As a general principle, the answer should be in the negative, unless the evidence discloses an intention by the parties to be bound by a separate and independent agreement. As the learned authors of Chitty on Contracts (H G Beale gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 33rd Ed, 2018) summarise at para 2-191 (“Chitty”):

  58. [37] The authority cited for the proposition emphasised in bold above is an arbitration case, Furness Withy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Metal Distributors (UK) Ltd (The Amazonia) [1990] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 236 (“Furness”), which also discussed an authority relied upon by the Appellants, Altco Ltd v Sutherland [1971] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 515 (“Altco”). Although there is a line of authorities leading to Furness, it is sufficient for present purposes to focus on that case.

  59. [38] The dispute in Furness was between the disponent owners of The Amazonia, Furness Withy (Australia) Pty Ltd (“Furness”), and the sub-charterers of the vessel, Metal Distributors (UK) Ltd (“Metal Distributors”). Metal Distributors had commenced an arbitration on the basis of an arbitration clause in the contract, which, in truth, was void due to the incorporation of certain Australian legislation. Operating under the incorrect assumption that the arbitration clause was effective, however, Furness had agreed to the appointment of one Mr Davies as arbitrator, and the parties exchanged pleadings in the arbitration. When the possibility that the arbitration clause was invalid was brought to its attention, Furness then filed an application in court for a declaration that there were no valid arbitration proceedings between itself and Metal Distributors. The English High Court dismissed the application. On appeal, the Court of Appeal agreed that the arbitration clause was void. Staughton LJ then had to consider whether there was an ad hoc arbitration agreement, on the following factual premise, which, as our discussion of the facts will show, corresponds to the present appeal (Furness at 241):

  60. [39] Staughton LJ first considered the general law of contract, citing an earlier edition of Chitty which reflected the first proposition in the extract quoted at [36] above, before turning to consider Beesly v Hallwood Estates Ltd [1960] 1 WLR 549 and Harvela Investments Ltd v Royal Trust Company of Canada (C.I.) Ltd [1986] AC 207. He then turned to arbitration cases specifically, highlighting two decisions. First, he referred to Westminster Chemicals & Produce Ltd v Eichholz & Loeser [1954] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 99 (“Westminster Chemicals”), in which the plaintiffs had argued that there was no contract between themselves and the defendants, although they had previously appointed an arbitrator and taken part in an arbitration. Devlin J held in that case that they were bound by the arbitration award (Westminster Chemicals at 105–106):

  61. [40] Second, Staughton LJ considered Altco, which the Appellants rely on in the appeal before us. As the parties before us have provided submissions on this case (albeit in the context of their arguments pertaining to the doctrine of mistake), we set out the facts and findings in some detail. In Altco, a dispute arose between one Mr Sutherland and Altco Ltd, commodity brokers. The contract between them provided that the agreement was to be governed by the laws of England, and any controversy was to be determined by the competent courts of London (see Altco at 516). However, at the outset, Mr Sutherland was of the view that the dispute had to be decided by the London Cocoa Terminal Market Association, and Altco Ltd did not dissent from this view. They then proceeded to submit statements of case and defence to the appointed arbitrators, and the arbitrators rendered an award. Mr Sutherland was dissatisfied with the award. The primary issue in Altco was whether Mr Sutherland was properly heard in relation to his arguments, and Donaldson J held that he was not (see Altco at 518). The question then was whether the award could be remitted or whether it had to be set aside. Donaldson J held that the award had to be set aside as there was no arbitration agreement at all in that case, as the contract between Mr Sutherland and Altco Ltd only included a reference to the courts of London and did not make any reference to any trade tribunal (see Altco at 519). Donaldson J also held that there was no ad hoc agreement between the parties to submit the dispute to arbitration (see Altco at 519–520):

  62. [42] However, having found that there was such an agreement, Staughton LJ found that the parties were operating under a common mistake of fact, viz, whether there was an impediment to arbitration by virtue of the Australian legislation, which had to be treated as a mistake of fact given that it was a matter of foreign law. As a result, the arbitration agreement was “vitiated by mistake of fact” (Furness at 246).

  63. [43] In a concurring judgment, Dillon LJ observed (Furness at 248):

  64. On an alternative analysis of a continuing agreement, which approached the issue as one of a continuing agreement to arbitrate which gave rise to a separate agreement by each particular submission to arbitration, Dillon LJ would have also found there to be a separate contract:

  65. [44] The following conclusions can be gleaned from the above authorities. Given the clear statement by the English Court of Appeal in Furness, we agree with the Developer that it is not appropriate to rely on the broad approach taken in Altco to invariably find the absence of an ad hoc agreement in such circumstances. Instead, as Furness shows, the question must be whether there is a sufficient factual basis on which to conclude that the parties had entered into a separate arbitration agreement notwithstanding their erroneous belief that there was an arbitration agreement or the absence of such an agreement in the underlying contract. In the following, we proceed on the basis of the general contractual analysis, rather than adopt any theory of a continuing agreement, given the absence of any arbitration agreement at all in the first place (in contrast to the arbitration clause which was invalidated in Furness).

  66. [45] On the basis of the foregoing, we adopt the following approach. At each stage, we determine whether the parties had acted exclusively on the assumption that cl 20A.1 was an arbitration agreement. If so, we then consider whether there was nevertheless evidence of an agreement to add terms to or depart from what cl 20A.1 of the SPAs already provided, such that it can be said that the parties were intending to enter into an agreement apart from cl 20A.1.

  67. Application to the facts

  68. [46] In our view, the parties had at all times acted exclusively on the assumption that cl 20A.1 was an arbitration agreement. While the 1st and 2nd NOAs did contain offers to arbitrate that were on terms additional to cl 20A.1, and, therefore, could be construed as offers to enter into separate arbitration agreements apart from cl 20A.1, those offers were never accepted by the Developer. It follows that there was never any separate arbitration agreement on the facts of this case.

  69. The 1st Attempted Arbitration

  70. [47] We begin with the 1st NOA. In our view, it is clear that the Purchasers were referring to cl 20A.1 of the SPAs as the sole basis on which the arbitration was being brought. After all, cl 20A.1 was the only provision or agreement referred to under the heading “THE ARBITRATION AGREEMENT” (at para 62 of the 1st NOA) and was identified as the express basis of the submission to arbitration (at para 64). The Purchasers then set out their position at para 65 that the arbitration was to be administered by the SIAC, conducted by a single arbitrator jointly appointed by the parties, and conducted in Singapore in accordance with the SIAC Rules.

  71. [48] In its responses to the 1st NOA, the Developer objected to the proposal for the arbitrations to be administered by the SIAC and conducted in accordance with the SIAC Rules, and to the consolidation of the arbitrations. At para 5 of each of the responses, the Developer referred to cl 20A.1 of the SPAs and noted that it did not refer to the SIAC or the SIAC Rules. On the basis of cl 20A.1, the Developer argued against the SIAC’s involvement and the application of the SIAC Rules. The Developer added that it agreed that the arbitration should be seated in Singapore and the AA applied. This reference to the seat of the arbitration appears to be a response to para 65(c) of the 1st NOA which stated that the “arbitration shall be conducted in Singapore”.

  72. [49] From 28 to 30 May 2019, the parties engaged in correspondence with the SIAC (see also the GD at [9]). We note, in particular, the following:

  73. (a) On 28 May 2019, the Purchasers’ Former Solicitors summarised the position as follows:

  74. (b) That the Developer did not deny “that there is an arbitration agreement” was confirmed in passing on 29 May 2019 in an email sent by the Developer’s solicitors to the SIAC.

  75. [50] In the context of the 1st NOA and the responses to the 1st NOA, it is clear that the reference to “arbitration agreement” in the correspondence was only to cl 20A.1 of the SPAs. There was no other basis for the arbitration to be invoked in any of the earlier documents or discussions. It would be entirely unrealistic to assume that the parties, after discussing cl 20A.1 exclusively, should then discuss an arbitration agreement independent of cl 20A.1 in the exchanges. Further, we observe that the statements were to the effect that the Developer had agreed that there was an existing arbitration agreement, not that the Developer was agreeing to arbitrate in the course of the exchange of the 1st NOA and the responses.

  76. [51] Having established that the parties were operating thus far under the assumption that cl 20A.1 was an arbitration agreement and that their conduct and correspondence was referable only to that assumption, the question we now consider is whether there was nonetheless a separate agreement concluded between the parties by virtue of this conduct and correspondence.

  77. [52] Contrary to the Appellants’ submissions, we find that there was an offer to arbitrate independently of cl 20A.1 in the 1st NOA. An offer “must consist of a definite promise to be bound, provided that certain specified terms are accepted” (Gay Choon Ing v Loh Sze Ti Terence Peter and another appeal [2009] 2 SLR(R) 332 at [47]). We find that the Purchasers were offering to arbitrate their disputes in an arbitration (a) administered by the SIAC; (b) conducted by a single arbitrator; (c) conducted in accordance with the SIAC Rules; and (d) which consolidated all the disputes into a single arbitration. The Purchasers also nominated one Mr Kalvin Lee as sole arbitrator. These were terms apart from cl 20A.1, as cl 20A.1 only mentioned “arbitration” and did not refer to the SIAC, SIAC Rules, the number of arbitrators, or the identity of any arbitrator. It follows that the Purchasers were offering to alter their legal position and to be bound by terms additional to those set out in what they believed to be the arbitration agreement in cl 20A.1. In our view, it was clear that the Purchasers intended to be bound by these terms – they were promising to be bound by the offer to arbitrate on those terms if the terms were accepted, and for the arbitration to proceed accordingly.

  78. [53] In this regard, we are unable to accept the submission put forward by counsel for the Developer, Mr Lee Eng Beng SC (“Mr Lee”), that the offer was an unconditional offer to arbitrate coupled with additional terms proposed for consideration. First, if the 1st NOA were to be construed as an unconditional offer to arbitrate, we would have great difficulty in finding that this offer was made independently of what the Purchasers believed was their entitlement under cl 20A.1 of the SPAs, since their act of submitting the dispute to arbitration would have been equally consistent with a reliance on cl 20A.1. It would be entirely artificial to view the 1st NOA as an unconditional offer to arbitrate in this context, and something more (in this case, the additional terms referred to above) would be needed to establish a separate arbitration agreement. Second, Mr Lee’s proposed approach to paras 64 and 65 of the 1st NOA was, with respect, unrealistic. The fact that the terms in para 65 were put forward at the same time as the proposal to arbitrate strongly suggests that the offer was put forward together as a complete package. Objectively construed, the Purchasers’ intention in the 1st NOA was to arbitrate on those terms and there is no indication at all that the Purchasers would have been willing to forgo those terms as long as the Developer agreed to arbitration in the abstract.

  79. [54] This offer in the 1st NOA, however, was rejected by the Developer, as indicated in its responses to the 1st NOA. The Developer took issue with the administration of the proposed arbitration by the SIAC and the conduct of the arbitration according to the SIAC Rules. At para 16 of the responses, it also rejected the nomination of Mr Kalvin Lee as the sole arbitrator. While there was agreement that the arbitration should be seated in Singapore and the AA applied, this was clearly premised on the existence of an arbitration agreement and cannot possibly be construed as an unqualified acceptance of the offer since that very offer had in fact been expressly rejected by the Developer. In any event, the agreement on the seat of the arbitration and on the application of the AA are equally applicable to the parties’ view of cl 20A.1, rather than grounding a separate agreement to arbitrate.

  80. [55] At this point, we clarify that the question of whether the parties had in fact entered into an agreement and the question of whether the agreement was an arbitration agreement should not be conflated. The Developer had argued, and the Judge had similarly reasoned in the GD at [38], that there were only three essential terms required for an arbitration agreement under s 4(1) of the AA: (a) the parties; (b) a defined legal relationship between these parties; and (c) the intention to be bound to submit disputes arising from this legal relationship to arbitration. There is no need for the parties to agree on the arbitral procedure, rules, or even the seat of arbitration, for an agreement to qualify as an arbitration agreement under s 4(1) of the AA: see the GD at [28], citing KVC Rice Intertrade Co Ltd v Asian Mineral Resources Pte Ltd and another suit [2017] 4 SLR 182. While this is true for the purpose of determining whether an agreement should be characterised as an arbitration agreement under the AA, that is distinct from the logically anterior question of whether an agreement was formed in the first place. That prior issue turns on the question of contract formation, which in turn is a matter of offer and acceptance. Therefore if additional terms including the applicable rules and procedure are part of an offer, and there is no unqualified acceptance of that offer, there is accordingly no agreement to speak of. Hence, the fact that the Purchasers had made the offer to arbitrate conditional on the terms proposed in the 1st NOA and that the Developer did not accept those terms necessarily leads to the conclusion that there was no agreement, even if those terms would not have been necessary for an arbitration agreement to be found under s 4(1) of the AA. This vital distinction, with respect, was overlooked by the Judge.

  81. The 2nd Attempted Arbitration

  82. [56] In the 2nd NOA, the Purchasers again referred to cl 20A.1 of the SPAs. It was at para 64, after repeating paras 62 and 63 of the 1st NOA, that the Purchasers “note[d] that the [Developer] has agreed on record that there is a valid arbitration agreement between the parties” in its email to the SIAC dated 29 May 2019. At para 65, the Purchasers then repeated para 64 of the 1st NOA, stating that they “elect[ed] to submit this dispute to arbitration, pursuant to Clause 20A.1 of the SPA which confers on parties the option to refer to arbitration any dispute relating to the SPA.” The difference here was that the 2nd NOA referred to an ad hoc arbitration seated in Singapore, noting the Developer’s previous acceptance of a Singapore-seated ad hoc arbitration.

  83. [57] On 2 July 2019, in response, R&T, on behalf of the Developer, replied objecting to the consolidation of the 12 claims into a single arbitration. This objection was repeated in correspondence dated 10 July 2019. In these letters, the Developer did not object to the assertion in the 2nd NOA that there was an arbitration agreement. On 11 July 2019, the Purchasers responded and summarised the position as follows:

  84. [58] On 29 July 2019, the Purchasers wrote to the Court of Arbitration of the SIAC seeking the appointment of an arbitrator. At para 3 of this letter, the Purchasers stated that “the Parties have agreed that there is a valid and binding arbitration agreement between them, and that the seat of arbitration is Singapore.”

  85. [59] The Judge placed emphasis on para 64 of the 2nd NOA and the correspondence quoted at [57] above in finding that the parties had agreed to submit their disputes to an arbitration independently of cl 20A.1 (see the GD at [37]). With respect, however, we disagree with the Judge’s view of the 2nd NOA and the correspondence and find, instead, that the parties were at all times only referring to cl 20A.1.

  86. (a) First, as we have found above, any prior discussion under the 1st NOA was entirely in the context of the Purchasers’ invocation of cl 20A.1. Any agreement about the existence of an “arbitration agreement” arising from the correspondence surrounding the 1st NOA could only be read as referring to cl 20A.1, which the parties believed to be the arbitration agreement. There is no reason to suspect that the parties had in mind an “arbitration agreement” which was distinct from cl 20A.1. Hence, the email dated 29 May 2019 referred to at para 64 of the 2nd NOA can be construed only as a reference to cl 20A.1, not a separate arbitration agreement. Further, although the 2nd NOA referred to the parties’ agreement that the arbitration would be an ad hoc arbitration seated in Singapore, these two “terms” were seen as consequences of cl 20A.1 rather than as part of a separate agreement. This is clear from para 67 of the 2nd NOA which identified these two as consequences of how cl 20A.1 of the SPAs was drafted. It follows that any reference to an arbitration agreement in the 2nd NOA was likewise a reference to cl 20A.1 of the SPAs.

  87. (b) Second, a contextual analysis of the statement in para 64 of the 2nd NOA shows that this was a point intended to supplement the invocation of cl 20A.1 and not to establish a separate basis for arbitration. Paragraph 64 followed from the invocation of cl 20A.1 in para 63 of the 2nd NOA, which was in turn, identical to the invocation of that clause in para 63 of the 1st NOA. Following that, at para 65, the 2nd NOA stated that the Purchasers thereby elected to submit the dispute to arbitration “pursuant to Clause 20A.1”. There was no reference to any other arbitration agreement.

  88. (c) Third, these statements in the 2nd NOA and the correspondence referred to an agreement about an agreement to arbitrate, ie, that the parties were agreed that there was an arbitration agreement, not that they had agreed in the course of the 1st Attempted Arbitration to arbitrate. If the latter was intended, the statements should have been that “parties have agreed to arbitrate”, rather than that “the [Developer] has agreed on record that there is a valid arbitration agreement between the parties”. This prevents these statements from being read as referring to a separate agreement to arbitrate arising from the 1st NOA and the subsequent correspondence. At the highest, this statement could be read to mean that the parties had agreed in the course of the 1st Attempted Arbitration that there was a prior arbitration agreement before the 1st NOA was issued, ie, that cl 20A.1 of the SPAs was an arbitration agreement, but does not go so far as to establish a separate, independent arbitration agreement

  89. [60] Accordingly, on the facts, there was no reference to an independent agreement apart from cl 20A.1. At the absolute highest, there may have been an agreement between the parties that cl 20A.1 was a valid arbitration agreement. However, as this is not the case run by the Developer on appeal and no cross-appeal has been brought against the Judge’s finding that cl 20A.1 was not an arbitration agreement, we do not need to pursue this line of inquiry further. In any event, as we have observed at [32] above, any such cross-appeal would have failed.

  90. [61] Having established that the 2nd NOA and the subsequent correspondence do not refer to an arbitration agreement apart from cl 20A.1, the question is whether the parties nonetheless did enter into such an agreement by reason of an offer and acceptance of terms apart from cl 20A.1. For reasons that are similar to those given in relation to the 1st NOA (see [52] above), we are of the view that the 2nd NOA constituted an offer to arbitrate. The Purchasers proposed that the disputes between the Purchasers and the Developer were to be resolved in a single arbitration conducted by a single arbitrator, Mr Kalvin Lee, which were terms not found in cl 20A.1. Even if the Purchasers subsequently took the position in a letter dated 11 July 2019 that the issue of consolidation was to be considered by the arbitral tribunal, it is sufficiently clear that there was at least an offer to submit the dispute to a single arbitrator for arbitration and, further, that the tribunal should have the power to consider consolidating the disputes and to make the necessary orders.

  91. [62] This conditional offer to arbitrate was clearly rejected by the Developer. First, it did not agree to the appointment of Mr Kalvin Lee. Further, and perhaps more importantly, it never-proposed an alternative arbitrator for the Purchasers’ consideration. This omission signalled its disagreement with even the proposal for a single arbitrator to hear the disputes. Second, it rejected the proposal for all 12 disputes to be heard in a single arbitration. In its view, there was therefore no valid commencement of an arbitration.

  92. [63] The rejection was then clearly restated in the Developer’s letter to the Court of Arbitration of the SIAC dated 2 August 2019, which was in response to the Purchaser’s request that the President appoint an arbitrator pursuant to s 13 of the AA. The primary position taken in that letter was that no arbitration had been validly commenced as the parties had entered into 12 SPAs, which required the commencement of 12 separate arbitrations by virtue of cl 20A.1 in each of the SPAs. As we pointed out to Mr Lee at the hearing, the letter was clear evidence that the Developer was proceeding on the basis of cl 20A.1 and not a separate arbitration agreement, and that it was a clear rejection of any offer by the Purchasers to arbitrate the disputes in a single arbitration. Indeed, the Developer made its views very clear: “[e]ach of [the] twelve different SPAs contains a separate and independent arbitration agreement [and] each of the Purchasers, to invoke arbitration against [the Developer], does so under a separate and independent arbitration agreement”. Further, this letter raised two significant points. First, in relation to the appointment of an arbitrator, the Developer’s position was that there was no validly commenced arbitration, and hence, that there should be no appointment of an arbitrator. This was a clear rejection of the Purchasers’ nomination of Mr Kalvin Lee, and was also a refusal to accept that the President of the Court of Arbitration should make such an appointment. There was also no counter-proposal of an arbitrator.

  93. [64] Second, in relation to the consolidation of the 12 disputes, while the Purchasers were willing at that point for this issue to be resolved by the arbitral tribunal to be appointed, the Developer took the position that the tribunal would not have the power to consolidate the proceedings unless the parties agreed to confer that power on the tribunal. In this regard, the Developer stated clearly that it did not agree to any consolidation, and also did not agree to confer any such power on any tribunals eventually constituted. “Hence,” in the Developer’s words, “there [was] no agreement between the parties pursuant to which such arbitrations may be consolidated”.

  94. [65] It is clear, therefore, even on a prima facie standard, that as late as 2 August 2019, there was no agreement at all on the submission of the disputes to arbitration based on the offers to arbitrate made by the Purchasers. While there was a broad agreement that there was a valid arbitration agreement, that was only in relation to cl 20A.1, and there was nothing to indicate an agreement independent of cl 20A.1. There were no further developments after 2 August 2019. On 3 February 2020, the Purchasers wrote to the SIAC stating that they did not wish to proceed with the second attempted arbitration. Therefore, on the facts, none of the specific offers to arbitrate were accepted, and no agreement to arbitrate was formed independently of cl 20A.1.

  95. [66] Having rejected the Appellants’ two offers for arbitration (which was entirely within the Developer’s prerogative), it seems incongruous for the Developer to then apply for a stay of the Suit on the basis of a purported ad hoc arbitration agreement. In truth, the Developer had spurned the opportunity to arbitrate. We therefore conclude that there was no basis on which to find an arbitration agreement apart from cl 20A.1 and reverse the Judge’s finding on this point.

  96. Did s 4(6) of the AA deem there to be an arbitration agreement in this case?

  97. [67] Given our finding that there was no separate arbitration agreement, the application and effect of s 4(6) of the AA become live issues for our determination in this appeal. Section 4(6) of the AA reads:

  98. We observe that s 4(6) of the AA is in pari materia with s 2A(6) of the International Arbitration Act (Cap 143A, 2002 Rev Ed) (“IAA”).

  99. [68] We agree broadly with the Judge that there are three requirements for s 4(6) to apply (see the GD at [46]). First, as a threshold requirement, s 4(6) only applies in the context of “any arbitral or legal proceedings”. Second, there must be an assertion of the existence of an arbitration agreement in a pleading, statement of case, or any other document in circumstances in which the assertion calls for a reply. Third, the assertion must not be denied by the other party. If these three requirements are met, then “there shall be deemed to be an effective arbitration agreement as between the parties to the proceedings”. We turn to address the three requirements before turning to consider the effect of s 4(6).

  100. Does s 4(6) apply?

  101. [69] In the first place, we are of the view that the threshold requirement, that s 4(6) only applies in “any arbitral or legal proceedings”, is not satisfied in the present case. We note that this phrase is only found in our domestic legislation and not in the provisions in the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration on which s 4(6) of the AA is based, and further, that it has yet to receive judicial attention. Before us, Mr Lee argued that the phrase “arbitral or legal proceedings” could not be restricted to valid proceedings, as that would defeat the purpose of s 4(6) of the AA. His argument appears to have been that if s 4(6) of the AA was intended to cure an invalidity in the arbitration agreement, then, ex hypothesi, apart from s 4(6), any such arbitration proceedings would also be invalid, and to construe “arbitration … proceedings” as referring only to valid proceedings would render the provision otiose. While we accept as a matter of logic that the phrase “arbitral or legal proceedings” could not be taken to exclude arbitration proceedings where the underlying arbitration agreement is invalid and only cured by s 4(6) of the AA, this does not take Mr Lee far enough. Regardless of how one construes the phrase in terms of the validity of the proceedings, it is clear to us that in the present case, there were simply no arbitration proceedings to speak of, valid or otherwise. In the 1st Attempted Arbitration, all that was done was a response to the 1st NOA (rejecting the commencement of arbitration) and correspondence with the SIAC, which eventually resulted in the SIAC terminating the nascent proceedings. In the 2nd Attempted Arbitration, the matter ended before the President of the SIAC Court of Arbitration appointed an arbitrator. In both instances, no substantive steps were taken and the matters ended with both parties at loggerheads on whether arbitration was even validly commenced. We are unable to see how there were any “arbitration … proceedings” at all in the present case.

  102. [70] Turning to the second requirement, we are also of the view that there was never an assertion of an arbitration agreement. In the context of s 4 of the AA, it is clear that “arbitration agreement” must have the meaning given to it in s 4(1) of the AA. As noted above at [32], the Judge found, and we agree, that cl 20A.1 of the SPAs is not in and of itself an arbitration agreement. There has also been no appeal against that finding. Hence, although the parties did at various times refer to cl 20A.1 as though it was an arbitration agreement, that is irrelevant to the present analysis, which is concerned with whether the existence of some other arbitration agreement was asserted and not denied in circumstances where it ought to have been. On the facts, we have explained that there was never any such assertion, there being, at highest, conditional offers to arbitrate made by the Purchasers in the 1st and 2nd NOAs which were then rejected by the Developer. It follows that s 4(6) cannot apply in the present case.

  103. [71] If, speaking hypothetically, there were arbitral proceedings and if there were an assertion of an arbitration agreement apart from cl 20A.1 of the SPAs, we express the tentative view here that assertions in notices of arbitration generally would be sufficient for s 4(6) of the AA to apply. The express language of s 4(6) of the AA clearly takes a broad view of the documents that would suffice, expanding beyond “statement of claim” to “pleading, statement of case or any other document” [emphasis added]. Given the characteristics of a “pleading” and “statement of case”, we agree with the Judge that a notice of arbitration (if it is taken up and the arbitration proceeds) would fall within the category of “any other document”. This is also consistent with the view expressed in the 36th session of the Working Group of the 1985 UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration as amended in 2006 (the “2006 Model Law”) when it was suggested that the reference to “an exchange of statements of claim and defence” was vague and potentially misleading, as “reference to the existence of an arbitration agreement was often made at an earlier stage of arbitral proceedings, such as in a notice of arbitration within the meaning of article 3 of the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules” (United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, Report of the Working Group on Arbitration on the work of its thirty-sixth session (New York, 4-8 March 2002), UN GAOR, 35th Sess, at para 32, UN Doc A/CN.9/508 (2002)). In response, it was pointed out by other members of the Working Group (at para 35) that:

  104. This suggests that it was anticipated in Art 7(5) of the 2006 Model Law that the phrase “statement of claim and defence” would extend to a notice of arbitration. Given that s 4(6) of the AA is broader than Art 7(5) of the 2006 Model Law in the language used to describe the class of documents that the assertion can be made in, it appears to us to follow that a notice of arbitration could also fall within s 4(6) of the AA.

  105. [72] In this regard, we also tentatively express our agreement with the distinction drawn by the Judge between a situation where the respondent responds to the notice of arbitration and when the respondent does not, such a distinction being drawn from the phrase “in circumstances in which the assertion calls for a reply”. A respondent does not have a duty to reply to a notice of arbitration: Rakna Arakshaka Lanka Ltd v Avant Garde Maritime Services (Pte) Ltd [2019] 2 SLR 131 at [73]–[77]. However, if the respondent does reply but does not deny the assertion of an arbitration agreement, and if the arbitral proceedings do proceed, then we accept that the assertion of an arbitration agreement in the notice of arbitration and the non-denial of that assertion would be sufficient for s 4(6) of the AA to apply. We agree with the Judge that this is a sensible result and is fitting given the character and role of a notice of arbitration: see the GD at [61] and Vitol Asia Pte Ltd v Machlogic Singapore Pte Ltd [2021] 4 SLR 464 (“Machlogic”) at [70]–[71]. This, however, is a tentative view and we leave it for determination in a suitable case, as it is not necessary for our determination of this appeal, given our findings that there were no arbitral proceedings at all, no assertion of an arbitration agreement, and, as we will come now to elaborate, s 4(6) of the AA would not have the effect contended for by the Developer in any event.

  106. Does s 4(6) deem there to be an arbitration agreement between the parties when there is no agreement otherwise?

  107. [73] The central issue concerning s 4(6) of the AA as argued before us turns on the interpretation of the last clause in s 4(6): “there shall be deemed to be an effective arbitration agreement as between the parties to the proceedings”. As cl 20A.1 of the SPAs was not an arbitration agreement (for the reasons set out above at [32]) and there was no arbitration agreement independent of cl 20A.1, s 4(6) should thus be examined on the basis that there was neither a valid arbitration clause in cl 20A.1 nor an ad hoc arbitration agreement independent of cl 20A.1. The question is whether s 4(6) can nonetheless deem an effective arbitration agreement to be in existence notwithstanding this finding. The Judge in obiter observed that it could. We hold a contrary view.

  108. [74] As the Judge did, we also adopt the purposive approach identified by this court in Tan Cheng Bock v Attorney-General [2017] 2 SLR 850 (“Tan Cheng Bock”) at [37]: (a) first, to ascertain the possible interpretations of the provision having regard to text and context; (b) second, to ascertain the legislative purpose or object of the statute; and (c) third, to compare the possible interpretations against the purposes or objects of the statute.

  109. Possible interpretations based on text and context

  110. [75] We first set out s 4 of the AA to provide the context for the discussion below:

  111. [76] Section 4 of the AA can be understood as a gateway for the AA to apply to a particular agreement. The first hurdle is to establish the existence of an arbitration agreement that qualifies under the AA – these requirements must be satisfied for the agreement to be enforced as an arbitration agreement in Singapore: see Arbitration in Singapore: A Practical Guide (Sundaresh Menon editor-in-chief) (Sweet & Maxwell, 2nd Ed, 2018) at para 7.006. The primary requirement is that such an agreement must satisfy the conditions set out in s 4(1) of the AA. Section 4(2) clarifies that the arbitration agreement can be an agreement on its own or a clause in a broader agreement. In addition, the AA imposes a formality requirement in s 4(3) that the arbitration agreement shall be in writing. Section 4(4) further defines what being “in writing” means. When we speak of formal validity in this context, we are therefore referring to the writing requirement imposed under s 4(3) of the AA, which is the only formality requirement mandated by the AA for an arbitration agreement to be given effect to under the legislation.

  112. [77] Turning then to the specific phrase in dispute, there are three possible layers of meaning contained in the phrase, “effective arbitration agreement”: (a) that there is an agreement, ie, a contract; (b) that the agreement is an arbitration agreement as defined by s 4(1) of the AA; and (c) that the arbitration agreement is a formally valid agreement which can be given effect to under the AA. The Judge’s view was that all three of these are in view when s 4(6) of the AA deems there to be an “effective arbitration agreement”, which the Developer also submits is the case. In contrast, the Appellants argue that only the third is in view, and the first two aspects must be established independently of s 4(6) of the AA. We refer to these as the “broad” and “narrow” views respectively. The crux of the difference between the parties is whether s 4(6) of the AA can deem there to be an arbitration agreement even if the parties did not actually enter into such an agreement.

  113. [78] In our view, the context of s 4(6) leans in favour of the narrow view. First, s 4(6) of the AA is found in a series of sub-sections (sections 4(3) to 4(8) of the AA) that deal only with the issue of whether an agreement is in writing. The words “effective arbitration agreement” in s 4(6) of the AA, found in the midst of this discussion (about what constitutes an arbitration agreement in writing), should likewise be interpreted in a manner consistent with those subsections. The Judge favoured the broad view as he took the view that “effective” could not be read as equivalent to the words “in writing” (see the GD at [69]). He instead concluded that “effective arbitration agreement” suggested “an arbitration agreement that is valid, complete and enforceable”. With respect, this argument does not account for the fact that what is considered “effective” depends on the context in which the issue is raised. In the present context, s 4(6) of the AA is not only found among provisions dealing exclusively with what constitutes an arbitration agreement in writing, but is also part of a clear statutory sequence and structure that focuses the later parts of s 4 of the AA on the writing requirement for an arbitration agreement. Section 4(1) starts at the greatest level of generality: what is an arbitration agreement? Section 4(2) of the AA provides for the different forms that such an agreement can take: it can be a standalone agreement or a clause in another. And from s 4(3) onwards, s 4 of the AA concerns itself with a specific requirement, that the arbitration agreement be in writing. Understood in that light, “effective” in s 4(6) of the AA appears to be limited to the writing requirement, ie, that the agreement would be “effective” for the purposes of qualifying under the AA in relation to this formality requirement.

  114. [79] Second, we also find it significant that s 4(6) is situated in s 4 of the AA, which is a definition provision and opens with the heading, “Definition and form of arbitration agreement”. It would be surprising to us if a definition provision should be interpreted to create substantive rights, which would be the consequence if we find that s 4(6) of the AA can be used to deem the existence of an arbitration agreement notwithstanding the court’s finding that none exists as a matter of fact. However, to address any residual ambiguity, we proceed to consider the legislative purpose or object of s 4(6) of the AA.

  115. Legislative purpose or object

  116. [80] To uncover the legislative purpose or object of s 4(6) of the AA as it now stands, it is necessary to consider the legislative history of this provision, in particular, its relationship with the 1985 Model Law and the 2006 Model Law. In the following, we undertake a chronological analysis of this history.

  117. (1) The 1985 Model Law

  118. [81] Section 4(6) of the AA traces its origins to Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law. Article 7 reads as follows:

  119. It is worth noting here that the requirement in Art 7(2) “is not merely a requirement that there be written evidence of an agreement; the agreement itself must be in writing” [emphasis in original]: Howard M Holtzmann and Joseph Neuhaus, A Guide to the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration: Legislative History and Commentary (Kluwer Law International, 1989) (“Guide to the 1985 Model Law”) at p 260.

  120. [82] The introduction of the material parts of Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law came about in the following manner, as recounted in the Report of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law on the work of its eighteenth session, UN GAOR, 40th Sess, Supp No 17, at para 87, UN Doc A/40/17 (1985):

  121. [84] Put another way, Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law was concerned with formal validity, in this context, compliance with the writing requirement: see Gary B Born, International Commercial Arbitration (Kluwer Law International, 3rd Ed, 2021) at p 739. For an arbitration agreement to be enforced under Art 7 of the 1985 Model Law, it had to meet the formality requirement of being in writing. However, an agreement arising from the parties’ conduct, in particular, by way of tacit or implied consent, would not be an agreement in writing. If the national law provides that such tacit or implied consent would give rise to a legally enforceable agreement, Art 7(2) then enables that agreement to be recognised as valid despite not being in writing. These materials show that Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law is not itself a legal basis for recognising that tacit or implied consent as giving rise to an agreement – it only responds once an agreement is found by other means and prevents parties from challenging the reliance on that agreement on the basis that it was not in writing.

  122. [85] In this regard, we disagree with the Judge’s approach to the rationale of Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law (see the GD at [54]–[55]), where he suggested that it was “eminently sensible” for the parties to be treated as having concluded an arbitration agreement in the exchange of documents, so as to prevent parties who participated in an arbitration, without complaining of the absence of an arbitration agreement, from subsequently claiming that the tribunal lacked jurisdiction. In the first place, this appears to be at odds with the Judge’s earlier finding in the GD at [52], where he stated that Art 7(2)’s effect was only in respect of formal validity, a conclusion which we agree with. Second, while we agree that it is eminently sensible for such a result to be reached, the question remains whether Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law is the correct means by which that result is reached, or whether other doctrines of contract law are more appropriate to achieve that result, which Art 7(2) ensures would not be hindered by the formality requirement. While we agree with the Judge, in broad terms, that the provision was “intended to prevent parties who participate in an arbitration, without any complaint that there was no arbitration agreement, from subsequently claiming that the arbitral tribunal lacked jurisdiction over them because there was in fact no arbitration agreement” (GD at [55]), this does not mean that Art 7(2) provides a basis for finding there to be such an agreement where the parties in fact did not agree. That same purpose could be achieved by construing Art 7(2) to prevent a party from seeking to resile from the agreement, established independently of Art 7(2), on the basis of formal invalidity. Indeed, we find on the basis of the above materials that Art 7(2) was intended only to prevent a party from claiming that the writing requirement was not fulfilled in such cases.

  123. (2) Introduction into domestic legislation and amendments to the IAA

  124. [86] Domestically, what is now s 4(6) of the AA was first introduced as s 4(4) of the Arbitration Act 2001 (Act 37 of 2001) (“2001 AA”). The material parts of s 4 of the 2001 AA read:

  125. [87] The origin of the 2001 AA lay in the recommendations made by the Review of Arbitration Laws Committee (“RALC”) within what was then known as the Law Reform and Revision Division of the Attorney-General’s Chambers, in consultation with various bodies. At the introduction of the 2001 AA, it was explained in Parliament that the introduction of this legislation was to “align our domestic laws with the Model Law” (see Singapore Parliamentary Debates, Official Report (5 October 2001), vol 73 at col 2214 (Assoc Prof Ho Peng Kee, Minister of State for Law)). The Minister explained that the 2001 AA was largely based on the Model Law and also incorporated provisions from the United Kingdom’s Arbitration Act 1996 (c 23). Following that, the Minister explained the key features of the bill, highlighting especially where the legislation differed from the 1985 Model Law. However, there was no specific discussion of what became s 4(4) of the 2001 AA in Parliament.

  126. [88] The key differences between s 4(4) of the 2001 AA and Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law lay in (a) the express requirement that s 4(4) only applied in “arbitral or legal proceedings”; (b) the scope of documents triggering s 4(4); and (c) the language used to describe the effect of the provision. In respect of the last-mentioned difference, whereas Art 7(2) applies to define an “agreement in writing” to include an agreement contained in the exchange of statements of claim and defence in the situation described, s 4(4) of the 2001 AA (like the later s 4(6) of the AA) provided that there was deemed to be an “effective arbitration agreement”. Despite this difference in language, however, we are of the view that there was no intention to depart from the specific purpose of Art 7(2) of the 1985 Model Law in the introduction of s 4(4) of the 2001 AA.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.