Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 30 Aug 2021

Court of Appeal

Golden Hill Capital Pte Ltd and others v Yihua Lifestyle Technology Co, Ltd and another

Feedback & support

[2021] SGCA 85Case no. Civil Appeal No 1 of 2021 (Summons No 61 of 2021)36 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] This application arose out of CA/CA 1/2021 (“CA 1”), which is an appeal by the shareholders (“Shareholders”) of HTL International Holdings Pte Ltd (“the Company”) against the decision of the High Court Judge (“Judge”) in HC/SUM 3963/2020 (“SUM 3963”).

  3. [2] In SUM 3963, the Shareholders applied under s 227R of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed) (“CA”) (now s 115 of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (Act 40 of 2018)) for the court to declare null and void the sale of the Company’s interests in its subsidiaries to Golden Hill Capital Pte Ltd (“Golden Hill Capital”). The named parties to SUM 3963 were the Shareholders and the judicial managers (“JMs”) of the Company. Golden Hill Capital and its beneficial owners (collectively, “the Phua Group”) were also allowed to participate in the proceedings, albeit in their capacity as non-parties.

  4. (a) that the NOA be struck out on the basis that it was not served on the Phua Group;

  5. (b) alternatively, that the Shareholders be barred from seeking orders in CA 1 which directly affect the Phua Group;

  6. (c) in the further alternative, that the documents filed in CA 1 be served on the Phua Group, and that the Phua Group file a Respondent’s Case and be allowed to participate in CA 1 as respondents to the proceedings.

  7. [4] This application raised several novel issues pertaining to the service of the NOA on a non-party. In particular, is it mandatory for an appellant to serve the NOA on a non-party who had participated in the proceedings below? If not, can the court nevertheless direct, in the exercise of its discretion, that the NOA (and other appeal papers) be served on that non-party?

  8. [5] On 22 July 2021, we allowed the Phua Group’s application to the extent of their participation in CA 1 as respondents to the proceedings. We set out the detailed grounds for our decision below.

  9. Facts

  10. Background facts

  11. [6] The Company is the holding company of a group of companies involved in the furniture business (collectively, “the HTL Group”). The original founders and owners of the HTL Group were Mr Phua Yong Tat and Mr Phua Yong Pin (“the Phua Brothers”), who are the beneficial owners of Golden Hill Capital. In 2016, the Company was fully acquired by the Shareholders. Despite the acquisition, the Phua Brothers retained management of the Company and the HTL Group.

  12. [8] On 19 August 2020, another entity, namely Man Wah Holdings (“Man Wah”), made an offer to purchase the Asset. The JMs invited both Golden Hill Capital and Man Wah to provide “anything further” they wished to communicate in relation to their respective offers by 26 August 2020. Upon Man Wah’s request, the JMs extended this deadline to 31 August 2020. On that date, Golden Hill Capital submitted a revised offer of US$100m. Man Wah also submitted an offer of US$100m, with an additional promise to pay US$10m above any offer made by the Phua Group. The JMs subsequently sold the Asset to Golden Hill Capital for US$100m on 7 September 2020.

  13. [9] On 8 September 2020, Man Wah conveyed a further improved offer for the Asset, which was again rejected by the JMs. As Man Wah was the Shareholders’ preferred buyer, the Shareholders commenced SUM 3963 on 18 September 2020 seeking the following relief pursuant to s 227R of the CA:

  14. Proceedings and decision in SUM 3963

  15. [10] On 18 September 2020, a Pre-Trial Conference (“PTC”) for SUM 3963 was held before the Assistant Registrar Karen Tan (“AR Tan”). Counsel for the Phua Group appeared together with counsel for the Shareholders, the JMs and Man Wah. During the PTC, counsel for the Phua Group informed AR Tan that the Phua Group wished to file a reply affidavit in response to the Shareholders’ affidavit. The Shareholders objected to the Phua Group participating in SUM 3963 but AR Tan disagreed and explicitly directed the JMs and the Phua Group to file reply affidavits and submissions in respect of SUM 3963. The Shareholders did not appeal against these orders.

  16. [11] Subsequently, the matter was heard before the Judge on 9 November 2020. During the hearing, counsel for the Phua Group made submissions on the Phua Group’s behalf and, consistent with AR Tan’s directions, the Judge allowed the Phua Group, the JMs and the Shareholders to participate and be heard. During the hearing itself, no objections were taken as regards the Phua Group’s participation in the matter.

  17. [12] On 24 November 2020, the Judge dismissed the Shareholders’ application. On 15 April 2021, the Judge delivered his detailed grounds of decision in Re HTL International Holdings Pte Ltd [2021] SGHC 86 (“GD”). For present purposes, we summarise only the aspects of the Judge’s decision which are material to the present application:

  18. (a) The court would not interfere with the JMs’ decision under s 227R of the CA unless it could be shown that the JMs’ conduct had been plainly wrongful, conspicuously unfair, or perverse (GD at [43]).

  19. (b) The JMs’ assessment that Golden Hill Capital’s offer promised superior shareholder returns was justified on the evidence before the court (at [63]).

  20. (c) The exigencies of the situation facing the Company were such that the JMs had to make a decision that would resolve the Company’s problems sooner rather than later (at [67]). On the facts, Man Wah’s offer would take a longer time to resolve the Company’s problems than Golden Hill Capital’s offer (at [74]).

  21. (d) There was fair consideration by the JMs of the various alternative offers. The JMs provided equal opportunities to Man Wah and Golden Hill Capital to put in “anything further” in respect of their original offers by 26 August 2020. Even when the Phua Group had emphasised the urgent need to complete the SPA, the JMs had agreed to Man Wah’s request to extend the deadline to put in further matters to 31 August 2020 (at [75] and [77]).

  22. (e) The Shareholders had not established that the JMs had caused them any prejudice, much less unfair prejudice. The JMs could not be faulted for any plainly wrongful, conspicuously unfair or perverse conduct (at [83]).

  23. Events leading up to present application

  24. [15] On 28 May 2021, the Shareholders filed the Appellant’s Case, the Form of the Core Bundle, the Appeals Information Sheet, and the Form of the Record of Appeal in CA 1. Again, none of these documents were served on or otherwise provided to the Phua Group by the Shareholders. The Phua Group only came to know of the existence of these documents when the JMs’ solicitors sent them to the Phua Group’s solicitors later that same day.

  25. [16] On 1 June 2021, the Phua Group’s solicitors wrote to the JMs’ and Shareholders’ solicitors seeking their confirmation that the Phua Group was entitled to file a Respondent’s Case in CA 1. On the same day, the JMs’ solicitors confirmed that the JMs had no objections to the Phua Group filing a Respondent’s Case. On 3 June 2021, the Shareholders’ solicitors replied to object to the Phua Group’s participation on the basis that there was “no necessity and basis” for it to do so.

  26. [17] Following this, the Phua Group requested that a Case Management Conference (“CMC”) be held for the parties to obtain directions on the Phua Group’s entitlement to participate in CA 1. During the CMC, which was held before AR Gan Kam Yuin (“AR Gan”) on 10 June 2021, the Shareholders reiterated their objection to the Phua Group’s participation in the appeal. AR Gan considered that it was for this Court to give the directions sought by the Phua Group. Consequently, AR Gan gave timelines for the Phua Group to file the present application, in the event that the Shareholders continued to object to its participation in the appeal. To avoid holding up the timelines, AR Gan also directed the Phua Group to serve its Respondent’s Case on the Shareholders and the JMs (without filing the Case on eLitigation) by 30 June 2021.

  27. [18] As the Shareholders continued to object to the Phua Group’s participation in CA 1, the present application was filed on 18 June 2021.

  28. The parties’ cases

  29. The Phua Group’s arguments

  30. The Shareholders’ arguments

  31. [21] For their part, the Shareholders contended that the issues that arise in CA 1 are (a) whether the JMs were justified in their assessment that Golden Hill Capital’s offer was “at least comparable or equal” to Man Wah’s offer in terms of shareholder returns; (b) whether the JMs had incorrectly determined that Man Wah had agreed to waive certain inter-company debts; and (c) whether the JMs had, by refusing to accede to Man Wah’s requests for certain financial accounts of the Company and its subsidiaries, adversely affected Man Wah’s ability to put its best offer on the table. These issues had “nothing to do” with the Phua Group and the Phua Group’s participation in the appeal would thus be “superfluous”.

  32. [22] Furthermore, since the Phua Group had not been a respondent in SUM 3963, it followed, procedurally, that the Phua Group could not be a respondent in CA 1. The Phua Group’s participation in SUM 3963 had been allowed pursuant to the exercise of a discretion by AR Tan and not pursuant to any legal rule.

  33. Issues to be determined

  34. [24] The issues before this Court were as follows:

  35. (a) Whether the Phua Group should have been served with the NOA pursuant to O 57 r 3(6) of the ROC?

  36. [25] We examine these questions in turn.

  37. Whether the Phua Group should have been served with the NOA pursuant to O 57 r 3(6) ROC

  38. [27] Parliamentary debates and other legislative materials do not shed light on the history behind O 57 r 3(6) of the ROC. However, the provision is in pari materia with O 59 r 3(5) of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1965 (UK) (“RSC 1965”) (formerly O 58 r 2 of the Rules of the Supreme Court 1883 (UK) (“RSC 1883”)), and is likely to have been adopted therefrom.

  39. [29] Therefore, the primary issue in so far as O 57 r 3(6) was concerned was whether the Phua Group constituted “parties to the proceedings in the Court below who [were] directly affected by the appeal”. In answering this question, we found it helpful to refer to existing authorities on the interpretation and application of O 57 r 3(6) of the ROC, which we briefly summarise below.

  40. Existing authorities

  41. Local authorities

  42. [31] On appeal, this Court accepted that the third defendant ought to have been made a party to the proceedings, but held that Lai J had erred in dismissing the appeal outright instead of adjourning the matter for an application to be made to join the third defendant as a respondent: see Goh Gin Chye and another v Peck Teck Kian Realty Pte Ltd [1981–1982] SLR(R) 482 (“Goh Gin Chye (CA)”). Consequently, the matter was remitted to the High Court to complete the hearing of the District Court appeal. This Court did not comment on the correctness of Lai J’s interpretation of O 57 r 3(6) of the ROC.

  43. [32] It is noted that, unlike the present case, the examination of the issue as to whether the third defendant was “directly affected by the appeal” in Goh Gin Chye (HC) was made in the context of a party who had already been made a party to the proceedings below.

  44. UK authorities

  45. [34] The majority of the English Court of Appeal (“ECA”) held, referencing O 58 r 2 of the RSC 1883, that the NOA did not have to be served on the third parties as they could not be said to be “directly affected” by the appeal. Of particular note are the following remarks by Fry LJ (at 363):

  46. [35] Again, it is noteworthy that Fry LJ’s remarks were made in the context of third parties who, unlike the Phua Group, had already been joined to the proceedings below.

  47. [36] Salmon was subsequently endorsed by the House of Lords in Regina v Rent Officer Service and another, ex parte Muldoon [1996] 1 WLR 1103 (“Rent Officer Service”). In that case, the issue before the court was whether the Secretary of State ought to have been served with a summons pursuant to O 53 r 5(3) of the RSC 1965, which provided that a notice of motion or summons for judicial review had to be served on “all persons directly affected” by the decision. The House of Lords considered that the principles expounded by Fry J in Salmon (albeit in the context of the service of a NOA) were equally applicable to the facts of the case before it. Lord Keith, with whom the other Lords agreed, elaborated on the meaning of the phrase “directly affected” as follows (at 1105):

  48. Malaysian authorities

  49. As with the UK authorities already cited, Sateras was also concerned with a situation where the interveners were already parties to the proceedings below and the only issue in dispute pertained to the other limb of the rule, ie, whether the interveners were “directly affected by the appeal”.

  50. Analysis

  51. [38] In our view, it is apparent, both from a plain reading of O 57 r 3(6) and from our examination of the abovementioned authorities, that the provision is intended to limit the necessity for service of the NOA on those who are “parties to the proceedings in the Court below”, and whose rights are “directly affected by the appeal”. These are two separate albeit conjunctive requirements and should not be conflated. We elaborate further on these requirements below.

  52. “Parties to the proceedings in the Court below”

  53. [39] First, O 57 r 3(6) provides that the NOA need only be served on persons who were already parties to the proceedings below. It is not intended to require service of the NOA on persons who are affected by the appeal, notwithstanding their status as non-parties to the proceedings.

  54. [43] Recognising this difficulty, the Phua Group asserted that its status as a “non-party” was irrelevant since the Shareholders were themselves non-parties to HC/OS 425/2020 (“OS 425”), being the main action from which SUM 3963 arose. As OS 425 was the Company’s application for judicial management, the only named party to OS 425 was the Company itself. With respect, however, this argument was without merit as the Shareholders had initiated SUM 3963, being the relevant “proceeding” from which CA 1 arose, and were named as the applicants therein. Furthermore, and in any event, the Phua Group’s status as parties or non-parties was wholly independent of the Shareholders’ status as such.

  55. [44] Consequently, the Phua Group’s application under O 57 r 3(6) of the ROC failed on this basis alone. Nevertheless, we briefly considered the second requirement since the Phua Group had made submissions on the same.

  56. “Directly affected by the appeal”

  57. [45] The second requirement under O 57 r 3(6) stipulates that the party in question must be “directly affected by the appeal”. Therefore, in a situation where an appeal is filed against a decision vis-à-vis some but not all of the parties below, there would be no need to serve such a notice on parties who would not be directly affected by the appeal.

  58. [46] As for the meaning of “directly affected by the appeal”, we agree with the High Court in Goh Gin Chye (HC) (see [30] above) that the word “affected” entails some kind of impact on the status and legal rights of the party in question. We further endorse Lord Keith’s view in Rent Officer Service that being “directly” affected refers to being affected “without the intervention of any intermediate agency”. In our view, therefore, a party can only be said to be “directly affected by the appeal” if his status and legal rights would be affected by the substantive decision in the appeal, without the intervention of any intermediate agency. Such an approach is consistent with the ECA’s holding in Salmon that the third party who had provided an indemnity to the defendant could not be said to be “directly affected by the appeal”, since his legal obligation to indemnify the defendant would only arise “through the intervention of the right of indemnity” (see [36] above).

  59. [48] However, this was insufficient for the Phua Group to invoke O 57 r 3(6) since, as mentioned above, the members of the Phua Group were never parties to SUM 3963 in the first place. Consequently, O 57 r 3(6) was not engaged and it followed that there was no basis for the Court to strike out the NOA. The second alternative remedy sought by the Phua Group, viz. that the Shareholders be barred from seeking the remedies that would “directly affect” the Phua Group, was equally inappropriate because that remedy was likewise predicated on the Shareholders’ non-compliance with O 57 r 3(6).

  60. Whether the Phua Group should be allowed to participate in CA 1 in any event

  61. [51] Hasselblad was subsequently followed in Berg v Glentworth Bulb Company Ltd (English Court of Appeal, 30 September 1988, unreported) which concerned, inter alia, an application by a non-party to be joined to the appeal proceedings. Woolf LJ opined that the non-party’s application would be “most conveniently dealt with” under O 59 r 8(1) of the RSC 1965 and remarked that the following considerations would apply in the context of that provision:

  62. [52] Having regard to the principles set out above, we were of the view that the Phua Group ought to be allowed to participate in CA 1 pursuant to O 57 r 10(1) of the ROC.

  63. [56] We also considered it unlikely that the Phua Group’s participation would cause the appeal proceedings to become unnecessarily protracted, as AR Gan had directed that the timelines for CA 1 would continue to run pending this Court’s decision on this summons. In accordance with AR Gan’s directions, the Phua Group had already served its Respondent’s Case on the Shareholders and the JMs on 30 June 2021, prior to our decision on this summons.

  64. [57] Accordingly, although case law dictates that the Court’s power to allow a non-party to participate in an appeal under O 57 r 10(1)–(2) of the ROC is to be “sparingly exercised”, the circumstances of this case were such that we decided that the Phua Group’s participation ought to be allowed.

  65. Conclusion