Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 12 Oct 2021

Court of Appeal

iVenture Card Ltd and others v Big Bus Singapore City Sightseeing Pte Ltd and others

Feedback & support

[2021] SGCA 97Case no. Civil Appeal No 94 of 2020

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] This appeal is against the decision of the High Court judge (the “Judge”) in iVenture Card Ltd and another v Big Bus Singapore City Sightseeing Pte Ltd and others [2020] SGHC 109 (“the Judgment”) on disputes arising out of a business collaboration on a Singapore tourist attraction pass that ended in a cloud of disagreements.

  3. Facts

  4. [2] The appellants, iVenture Card Limited (“iVenture Card”), iVenture Card International Pty Ltd (“iVenture International”) and iVenture Card Travel Ltd (“iVenture Travel”) are part of the iVenture Group which is engaged in the business of developing and marketing tourist packages worldwide. iVenture Card and iVenture International were the 1st and 2nd plaintiffs in the proceedings before the Judge. iVenture Travel was not a plaintiff below but was the 3rd defendant to the counterclaim.

  5. [3] The first two respondents, Big Bus Singapore City Sightseeing Pte Ltd (“Big Bus”) and Singapore Ducktours Pte Ltd (“Ducktours”) are Singapore companies which are part of the Duck and HiPPO Group of companies, a Singapore tourism business. Since 2006, the Duck and HiPPO Group operated a local Tourist Attractions Aggregator Pass (“TAAP”) called the “Singapore Pass”. This allowed pass-holders to access various tourist attractions in Singapore. The third respondent, Mr James Heng See Eng (“Mr Heng”) was, at all material times, a director and the chief executive of Big Bus and Ducktours. Mr Low Lee Huat (“Mr Low”) was the only other director and shareholder of Big Bus and Ducktours. Mr Low was a defendant below but was not included as a respondent in the appeal.

  6. [4] As there can be confusion in the parties and actions inter se, it would be useful to set out their positions in the proceedings below:

  7. (a) iVenture Card and iVenture International, as 1st and 2nd plaintiffs, sued Big Bus, Ducktours, Mr Heng and Mr Low as 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th defendants respectively;

  8. (b) Big Bus brought a counterclaim against iVenture Card and iVenture International as 1st and 2nd defendants to the counterclaim and added iVenture Travel as a 3rd defendant to the counterclaim; and

  9. (c) iVenture Travel, in turn, brought a counterclaim against Big Bus for repudiation of an agreement which we refer to as the Reseller Arrangement (see [6] below).

  10. Their respective causes of action are set out at [14] below.

  11. [5] We now turn to the relevant facts. On 17 December 2014, the iVenture Group and the Duck and HiPPO Group agreed to a business collaboration by which the iVenture Group’s Smartvisit technology solution would be used in a new co-branded TAAP, the “Singapore iVenture Pass”. The terms of their bargain were recorded in a Singapore Attractions Pass Preliminary Agreement dated 27 December 2014 (the “Preliminary Agreement”). Pursuant to the terms of the Preliminary Agreement, Big Bus and iVenture Card entered into a Licence Agreement, and iVenture Card and Smartvisit Pty Ltd (“Smartvisit”), a related company of iVenture Card, on the one part, and Big Bus, on the other, entered into a Service Level Agreement, both of which were dated 27 March 2015. Under the Licence Agreement, iVenture Card would sell the Singapore iVenture Pass on its online website and grant Big Bus a licence to operate the Singapore iVenture Pass business and to use the iVenture brand in Singapore. In exchange, Big Bus would pay iVenture Card a monthly fee, calculated as a percentage of the sales of the Singapore iVenture Pass. Under the Service Level Agreement, iVenture Card and Smartvisit would provide Big Bus with technical services and access to the “Smartvisit System” and Big Bus would pay the monthly fees to iVenture Card. The “Smartvisit System” was a transaction management system which managed the validation, reporting and invoicing of transactions for TAAPs. A major component of this system included the SORSE System, which allowed the user to “access data and reports, update information or process transactions”. Both the Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement contained a “Mutual Dependency Clause” which essentially stated that one agreement could be terminated immediately by notice in writing once the other had been terminated.

  12. [6] In addition to the foregoing written agreements, the parties also entered into an informal “Reseller Arrangement” which was never reduced to writing. The Judge below stated, at [3(c)] of the Judgment, that under the Reseller Arrangement, both plaintiffs were permitted to resell the Singapore iVenture Pass “on behalf of the defendants”. The Judge went on to note that it was disputed whether this arrangement constituted a contractual agreement, the parties between whom the arrangement was made and its payment terms. Before us, it is disputed which iVenture Group entity entered into the Reseller Arrangement. The appellants claim the Reseller Arrangement was entered into on or about 27 March 2015 and that it was made between Mr Ryan Rieveley (“Mr Rieveley”), Chief Executive Officer of the iVenture Group, and Mr Heng. We shall deal with this and other disputed facts in relation to this issue below. What is undisputed is that the iVenture Group resold Singapore iVenture Passes, collected the proceeds on behalf of Big Bus, deducted their commission and paid the balance to Big Bus.

  13. [7] After the Singapore iVenture Pass was launched, the parties’ relationship deteriorated. Big Bus became unhappy about iVenture Card’s lateness in making payments which had fallen due under the Reseller Arrangement. This culminated in a heated exchange of emails between Ms Teo Zener (“Ms Teo”) of the Duck and HiPPO Group and Mr Rieveley, between 31 October 2017 and 6 November 2017. In the course of this exchange, Ms Teo informed Mr Rieveley on 6 November 2017 that “trading activity” would be temporarily suspended unless an invoice dated 30 September 2017 (the “30 September 2017 Invoice”) for sums due under the Reseller Arrangement by 30 October 2017 was settled before 9 November 2017. Mr Rieveley replied that same day, refusing to do so.

  14. [8] In the meantime, on 8 November 2017, at or around 2.27 pm, Big Bus suspended the sales, activation and redemption of the Singapore iVenture Pass (the “Pass Suspension”). Upon learning of this, iVenture Card retaliated later that same day (sometime between 4.50pm and 5.30pm), locking out Big Bus from access to the SORSE System (the “SORSE System Suspension”). Sometime between 6.30pm that day and 9am of 9 November 2017, Big Bus followed up with another suspension (the “Second Suspension”), the scope of which was disputed.

  15. [9] iVenture Card subsequently paid the 30 September 2017 Invoice on 9 November 2017. However, Big Bus did not lift the Pass Suspension. Instead, by an email from Ms Teo to Mr Rieveley dated 10 November 2017 confirming receipt of payment, she demanded that iVenture Card pay them a “remittance of [S$]150k for sales collected on [Big Bus’s] behalf from 1 [October 2017] to 9 [November 2017], and a banker’s guarantee or drawdown deposit of S$200k to cover forward sales” as a condition for lifting the Pass Suspension. Big Bus also requested that iVenture Card “turn on the SORSE System for [Big Bus] to resume business”. iVenture Card refused this request and demanded that Big Bus immediately rectify their breach of the parties’ agreements.

  16. [10] On that same date, 10 November 2017, Ducktours also launched the HiPPO Singapore Pass, a TAAP which listed similar attractions as the Singapore iVenture Pass, but utilised different technologies for its back-end IT system. While the Singapore iVenture Pass authenticated pass users by a smart chip embedded in the pass itself which was linked to the Smartvisit System, the HiPPO Singapore Pass authenticated its users using QR Code technology and did not utilise the Smartvisit System at all.

  17. [11] Solicitors for iVenture Card, Big Bus and Ducktours then exchanged a series of letters in which iVenture Card alleged that Big Bus and Ducktours had misused confidential information belonging to iVenture Card (“Alleged Confidential Information”) to launch a competing business (the HiPPO Singapore Pass). The Alleged Confidential Information consisted of the following:

  18. (a) Information relating to how the iVenture Card business should be run, ie, a system that standardized and optimized the manner in which such a business was set up and run in each destination in which it operated. This included the operating processes and procedures of the iVenture Card business, including but not limited to how attraction partners, customers and suppliers were to be approached and managed. This also included template supplier and sales agent agreements, pricing models, information on the performance of various product offerings and marketing and branding guidelines.

  19. (b) Information relating to the SORSE System, including the programme management services brief as well as its functions, specifications, user guides and manuals.

  20. [12] The parties’ correspondence culminated in solicitors for Big Bus writing to solicitors for the iVenture Group on 6 December 2017 (the “6 December 2017 Letter”), claiming that iVenture Card had repudiated the Licence Agreement and stating that they regarded both the Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement as at an end. On 8 December 2017, solicitors for iVenture Card responded by letter (the “8 December 2017 Letter”), asserting that Big Bus’s notice of termination amounted to a repudiatory breach of both the Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement and giving notice of iVenture Card’s acceptance of Big Bus’s said breach and, in the alternative, serving notices of termination pursuant to both agreements.

  21. [13] A few months after these events, the appellants launched a replacement TAAP business by collaborating with Luxury Tours and Travel (“Replacement TAAP Business”) to mitigate their loss of profit as a result of Big Bus’s actions.

  22. [14] The various claims made by the parties in the proceedings below are as follows:

  23. (a) iVenture Card claimed damages on the basis that Big Bus had repudiated the Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement and also claimed unpaid fees under these two agreements;

  24. (b) iVenture Card claimed that Ducktours, Mr Heng and Mr Low were liable for damages for inducing Big Bus’s breaches of the Licence Agreement, the Service Level Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement;

  25. (c) iVenture Card and iVenture International claimed that the respondents and Mr Low were liable for damages for an unlawful means conspiracy to injure them;

  26. (d) iVenture Card and iVenture International claimed against the respondents and Mr Low for damages and other remedies for breach of confidence in the unauthorised disclosure and misuse of the Alleged Confidential Information;

  27. (e) Big Bus counterclaimed against iVenture Card and iVenture International for damages on the basis that they had first repudiated the Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement;

  28. (f) Big Bus also counterclaimed against iVenture Card, and alternatively iVenture Travel, for the payment of two outstanding invoices for October and November 2017 under the Reseller Arrangement; and

  29. (g) iVenture Travel counterclaimed damages against Big Bus on the basis that Big Bus repudiated the Reseller Arrangement.

  30. [15] It is evident from the above that although iVenture International was the 2nd plaintiff in the action, it is not a party to any of the agreements. iVenture Travel may be a party to the Reseller Arrangement but was not a plaintiff. However, as noted above, it did make a counterclaim against Big Bus after being named by Big Bus as the 3rd defendant to Big Bus’s counterclaim. On the other side, only Big Bus is a party to each of the three agreements and hence the claims against the other defendants were based on causes of action other than breach of contract.

  31. Decision below

  32. [16] As we elaborate later, the Judge found that the Reseller Arrangement was an oral contractual arrangement between Big Bus and iVenture Card, and not iVenture Travel. The Judge held that although iVenture Travel was the party billed in the invoices issued in respect of the Reseller Arrangement, this was a matter of administrative convenience because iVenture Card had set up the SORSE System to generate invoices in that manner: see the Judgment at [6]–[7]. On that basis, the Judge dismissed iVenture Travel’s claim for the repudiation of the Reseller Arrangement (see [14(g)] above) and Big Bus’s counterclaim against iVenture Travel for the Reseller Arrangement invoices for October and November 2017 (see [14(f)] above).

  33. [17] The Judge also found that a 30-day credit term applied to the Reseller Arrangement as the parties had conducted themselves on that basis and an amorphous credit term was unbelievable as a matter of commercial sense. Thus, in refusing to make payment for the 30 September 2017 Invoice by 30 October 2017, iVenture Card had breached the Reseller Arrangement, but this did not confer a right of termination or suspension on Big Bus: see the Judgment at [8]–[9]. This is not disputed on appeal.

  34. [18] The Judge also found that by the Pass Suspension and the Second Suspension on 8 and 9 November 2017, Big Bus had repudiated the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement but they were not a repudiation of the Service Level Agreement (see the Judgment at [14] and [17]). This finding is also not disputed on appeal. However, as the plaintiffs pleaded that they had only accepted the repudiation on 8 December 2017, the Judge also considered whether iVenture Card itself had repudiated the Licence and Service Level Agreements by the SORSE System Suspension on 8 November 2017 and whether the first two respondents had accepted the alleged repudiation through the Second Suspension. The Judge held that iVenture Card had repudiated the Service Level Agreement (but not the Licence Agreement) by imposing the SORSE System Suspension. However, he also found that that repudiation was not accepted by the Second Suspension on 8 November 2017 but by way of the 6 December 2017 Letter. Furthermore, this letter terminated all three agreements: see the Judgment at [12]–[22].

  35. [19] The Judge found that Ducktours and its shareholders/directors, Mr Heng and Mr Low, were liable for inducing Big Bus’s breach of contract and that the three of them were, together with Big Bus, liable for unlawful means conspiracy. Ducktours was thus jointly and severally liable for Big Bus’ breach of contract. However, Mr Heng and Mr Low could take advantage of the protection against personal liability afforded by the rule in Said v Butt [1920] 2 KB 497 (“Said v Butt”) as they had acted bona fide in the interests of Big Bus: see the Judgment at [23]–[25] and [28].

  36. [20] The Judge also took the view that iVenture Card had not sufficiently proved that there had been a misuse of the Alleged Confidential Information and that there was nothing unconscionable in the respondents’ conduct in launching the HiPPO Singapore Pass, and dismissed the breach of confidence claim. Further, as iVenture International was not a party to the Licence Agreement or the Reseller Arrangement and had no real connection with the respondents’ actions, the Judge dismissed its claims: see the Judgment at [26]–[28]. We pause to note that iVenture Card pleaded that it is iVenture International that develops and promotes flexible travel packages for popular tourist destination worldwide and that its principal product is the “iVenture Card, which is both a brand and a pre-paid electronic card”. They also pleaded that iVenture International, through iVenture Card as licensee, licenses, amongst other things, its intellectual property in respect of, and the right to operate, the business of developing, promoting and distributing iVenture packages, ie, products that are similar to, and possibly co-branded with, the iVenture card. However, as mentioned above, iVenture International is not a signatory to the Licence Agreement nor to the Service Level Agreement.

  37. [21] On the issue of remedies, the Judge took the view that the Pass Suspension and the SORSE System Suspension were both independent causes of the loss of the Singapore iVenture Pass business. Thus, from the time iVenture Card imposed the SORSE System Suspension, Big Bus and iVenture Card were separately liable to each other for such loss until all three agreements were validly discharged on 6 December 2017. He therefore awarded each of them nominal damages of S$1,000. Further, the Judge awarded iVenture Card damages of S$778.32 for the loss of the Singapore iVenture Pass business for one day, 8 November 2017, in which only the Pass Suspension but not the SORSE System Suspension was in effect. This was quantified on the basis of an estimate of iVenture’s projected loss of profit of S$17,123 for the 22-day period from 9 to 30 November 2017 by the appellants’ expert Mr Oliver Watts (“Mr Watts”), whose methodology the Judge preferred to that of the respondents’ expert, Mr Wong Joo Wan (“Mr Wong”): see the Judgment at [30]–[34].

  38. [22] The Judge took the view that the appellants’ claim for loss of profits after 27 September 2020 (the end-date for the Licence Agreement and Service Level Agreement) was based on an “incredibly speculative” key assumption that but for Big Bus’s repudiation of the Licence Agreement, the various agreements would have been renewed into perpetuity or iVenture Card would have seamlessly transferred their business to another local partner on comparable or better terms into perpetuity, which was not supported by evidence. He also dismissed iVenture Card’s claim for S$45,757.03 in expenditure allegedly incurred to respond to affected customers and to launch a replacement TAAP business in mitigation due to his finding that the non-operation of the Singapore iVenture Pass business had been caused by both sides and that all three agreements were validly discharged on 6 December 2017: see the Judgment at [35].

  39. [23] The Judge awarded the following sums to the parties:

  40. (a) Allowed Big Bus’s claim against iVenture Card for unpaid invoices under the Reseller Arrangement for October and November 2017 totalling S$145,792.86 (Judgment at [37]);

  41. (b) Allowed iVenture Card’s claim against Big Bus for various unpaid fees totalling S$27,866.34 (Judgment at [36]);

  42. (c) Awarded iVenture Card nominal damages of S$1,000 for Big Bus’s breach of the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement, (see [21] above);

  43. (d) Awarded Big Bus nominal damages of S$1,000 for iVenture Card’s breach of the Service Level Agreement (see [21] above); and

  44. (e) Awarded iVenture Card damages of $778.32 in respect of Big Bus’s breaches of the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement resulting in the loss of the Singapore iVenture Pass business for one day, 8 November 2017, when only the Pass Suspension was in effect (see [21] above).

  45. The Judge set off these various amounts due from each side such that iVenture Card owed a net sum of S$118,926.52 to Big Bus. In addition, the Judge found that Big Bus and Ducktours were jointly and severally liable to iVenture Card for S$1,778.32. He also awarded interest at 5.33% per annum on both sums (Judgment at [39]).

  46. Issues on appeal

  47. [24] The appellants appeal against the Judgment on five grounds, all of which the respondents say are without merit. These five grounds are as follows:

  48. (a) First, the appellants argue that it was iVenture Travel, and not iVenture Card, which was the proper party to the Reseller Arrangement, on the basis that the invoices issued thereunder were billed to iVenture Travel. Further, the existence of a set-off arrangement between the parties negated the possibility of a 30-day credit term, and in fact there was no such credit term.

  49. (b) Secondly, the appellants argue that Big Bus was not entitled to terminate the Service Level Agreement as a result of the SORSE System Suspension. Big Bus’s breach of the Licence Agreement relieved iVenture Card from the need to perform their obligations under the Service Level Agreement because the “continued effectiveness” of the Licence Agreement was a condition precedent to the performance of the Service Level Agreement. This entitled iVenture Card to impose the SORSE System Suspension which in any case was not a repudiatory breach of the Service Level Agreement, because it did not impair the sales, activation and redemption of the Singapore iVenture Pass. By treating all three agreements as at an end, Big Bus therefore repudiated the same, for which Ducktours and Mr Heng were jointly and severally liable in the tort of conspiracy and inducing breach of contract.

  50. (c) Thirdly, the appellants argue that Mr Heng had not been acting in Big Bus’s best interests and had been dishonest. Thus, the rule in Said v Butt did not apply to Mr Heng and did not protect him from personal liability for inducing Big Bus’s breach of contract and for unlawful means conspiracy.

  51. (d) Fourthly, the appellants argued that in dismissing their claim for breach of confidence, the Judge had improperly reversed the burden of proof.

  52. (e) Fifthly, on the assumption that its appeals on the four preceding grounds stated would be successful, the appellants appealed against the Judge’s findings on damages, save for his finding that iVenture Card was liable to Big Bus for S$145,792.86 for unpaid invoices.

  53. [25] We consider each of these issues in turn.

  54. The proper contracting party to the Reseller Arrangement

  55. [26] We first consider whether iVenture Card or iVenture Travel was the contracting party to the Reseller Arrangement. This issue turns on a question of contractual formation, ie, whether, at the material time, the parties intended iVenture Travel or iVenture Card to be the contracting party to the Reseller Arrangement: see ST Group Co Ltd and others v Sanum Investments Ltd and another appeal [2020] 1 SLR 1 at [59]–[60].

  56. [27] The evidence from Mr Rieveley, Ms Teo and Mr Heng was somewhat vague, conflicting and inconclusive on this point. They did not agree on what kind of agreement this was, when this agreement was entered into, what its terms were or, as noted above, even which iVenture entity was involved. Mr Rieveley characterised it as an agreement and part of the Preliminary Agreement. Ms Teo disagreed, variously saying it developed out of the parties’ practice and custom in accordance with the general prescription of the Preliminary Agreement (see [41] below) or an area of collaboration under the Preliminary Agreement. As noted above, Mr Rieveley states that the Reseller Arrangement was entered into between Mr Heng and himself. Mr Heng laconically says it was entered into in March 2015 and uses the phrase “twin collaboration” in referring to the Reseller Arrangement and the Licence Agreement. Ms Teo deposes that the “oral Sales Agency Agreement” was a creation of the plaintiffs after Big Bus filed a counterclaim against iVenture Card (alternatively, iVenture Travel) for outstanding invoices for October and November 2017. Despite Mr Rieveley’s claim that the Reseller Arrangement was part of or contemplated by the Preliminary Agreement, none of its terms referred specifically to such an agreement to be entered into, unlike the specific references to the Licence and Service Level Agreements, drafts of which were attached to the Preliminary Agreement. Clauses 4 and 5 of the Preliminary Agreement, which were relied upon by Mr Rieveley, only referred to the Singapore iVenture Pass being marketed and promoted by iVenture International and iVenture Card affiliates globally and that these entities would promote it through all its existing sales channels. The Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement were, as referenced above, signed on 27 March 2015. We note that under cl 4.3(c) of the Licence Agreement, the iVenture Group entities were, on execution of a standard sales agent agreement, to be provided an opportunity to promote and sell the Singapore iVenture Pass outside of Singapore and earn a commission equal to the greater of 20% or the best commission rate (including overrides or bonuses) offered to any party, 30-day credit payment terms and a basis for termination of the sales agent relationship based only on a breach of the terms of the agreement. However, as noted above, no written agreement was entered into by the parties.

  57. [28] When we turn to the invoices, there appear to be two versions of the first or earliest invoice in the evidence of Ms Teo, one was dated 14 July 2015 and the other was dated 1 July 2015, both covering the same invoice period of 1 to 30 June 2015 and were for the sum of S$4,133.60. The details of the Singapore iVenture Pass sales captured in the first invoice covered sales from 3 to 25 June 2015. The next four invoices exhibited by Ms Teo were for progressively higher sums, viz, S$12,627.20, S$20,323.20, S$16,698.40 and S$33,488.00, which seems consistent with a launch and progressively successful sales.

  58. [29] The bottom line therefore was that iVenture Card or entities within the iVenture Group were reselling Singapore iVenture Passes, starting from 3 June 2015, and entering these sales into the SORSE System. For its part, Big Bus was generating invoices from the SORSE System and addressing them to iVenture Travel, but all relevant and significant discussions and chasing up on payment of these invoices were between Ms Teo and Mr Rieveley. We are therefore of the view that there was an oral agreement, namely the Reseller Arrangement, between iVenture Card (see below) and Big Bus, entered into around the time of the Licence and Service Level Agreements. Under this Reseller Arrangement, iVenture Card would earn a commission on such sales, deduct the same and were required, subject to a 30-day credit period (see below), to remit the balance to Big Bus. All the relevant witnesses (see [27] above) referred in varying ways to the Reseller Arrangement being part of the business collaboration under or linked to the Preliminary Agreement. Given that context and the two written agreements that were entered into, the Reseller Arrangement can be viewed as covering an accessory or incidental activity or an offshoot of the Licence Agreement, providing a benefit to both parties.

  59. [30] Having regard to all the facts, we agree with the Judge’s finding that iVenture Card, and not iVenture Travel, was the contracting party to the Reseller Arrangement: see the Judgment at [7]. We say this for three reasons.

  60. [31] First, the evidence of Mr Rieveley and Mr Heng align to the Reseller Arrangement being entered into around the time of the Licence and Service Level Agreements. As noted above, the first recorded transaction in the earliest invoice issued in respect of the Reseller Arrangement (“Reseller Invoice”) was: “Singapore Attraction Pass 2 Ticket Adult – US$ Combo – Online” and it carried the date 3 June 2015. No standard sales agent agreement, or, for that matter, any other written agreement was ever entered into between the parties for the reselling of the Singapore iVenture Pass. The Singapore iVenture Pass was being resold by various iVenture Group entities and it seems highly unlikely that the parties contemplated individual contracts between Big Bus and each such entity that resold the Singapore iVenture Passes. Given the number of transactions and very modest sums involved, it would only have made business sense if these sales were aggregated to one entity within the iVenture Group, which, in this context, was most likely iVenture Card. The business being transacted under the Reseller Arrangement was, as we have noted above, accessory or incidental to the Licence Agreement which was between iVenture Card and Big Bus.

  61. [32] Further, there was no evidence that Big Bus was even aware of iVenture Travel’s existence until after 14 July 2015. Ms Teo, having been told earlier that the SORSE system would automatically generate the Reseller Invoices, sent an email dated 14 July 2015 to Mr Rieveley and one Mr Jonny Loper (“Mr Loper”) (who appears, from his email address at jloper@svs.com.au, to be from Smartvisit), asking for instructions on generating the invoice as Big Bus wished to bill the “June invoice”. On the same day, Mr Loper, gave instructions to Big Bus on how they could automatically generate their invoices from the SORSE System. Mr Loper told Ms Teo:

  62. That was how Big Bus’s first invoice, for the period 1 to 30 June 2015, came to be issued. The Smartvisit System generated the first and subsequent invoices to iVenture Travel with an address at Johnston Road, Wanchai, Hong Kong.

  63. [33] Secondly, and most importantly, whilst we recognise that a lack of knowledge of iVenture Travel on Big Bus’s part does not necessarily preclude iVenture Travel being a nominated party within the iVenture Group to contract with Big Bus for the Reseller Arrangement, one would have expected iVenture Card to be well aware of this fact. Yet in its original statement of claim, the appellants pleaded that iVenture Card and not iVenture Travel was the contracting party to the Reseller Arrangement. It was only on 26 January 2018 that the appellants amended their pleadings to state that iVenture Travel, and not iVenture Card, was the contracting party to the Reseller Arrangement. This lends weight to the view that iVenture Travel was the apparent billing party for convenience as that was how the SORSE System was configured. We note that Ms Teo alleged in her affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”) that this switch in the appellants’ pleaded case to iVenture Travel being the party to the Reseller Arrangement was only made after Big Bus took out an application for summary judgment for the unpaid invoices for October 2017 and November 2017.

  64. [34] Thirdly, as noted above at [27], iVenture Card relies on cl 4.3(c) of the Licence Agreement. However, we agree with the Judge’s observation at [6] of the Judgment that this clause creates no legally binding contract in itself. Clause 4.3(c) expressly states that Big Bus would provide the iVenture Group entities the opportunity “… to promote and sell the Licensee’s iVenture Packages outside of the Territory on execution of a standard sales agent agreement…” [emphasis added]. This was never done. Even assuming iVenture Card’s contention on cl 4.3(c) to be correct, however, we find it difficult to understand why, if it was clear that iVenture Travel was the intended contracting counterparty to the Reseller Arrangement or even became the contracting counterparty to that arrangement subsequently, that very fact failed to be pleaded at the outset.

  65. [35] At this juncture, we turn to consider a difficulty raised by the appellants’ pleaded case. As mentioned above, the appellants originally pleaded, in the Statement of Claim dated 12 December 2017, that the parties to the Reseller Arrangement were iVenture Card and Big Bus. They then amended their pleadings on 26 January 2018 to plead that the parties to the Reseller Arrangement were iVenture Travel and Big Bus, and claimed relief on that basis. Importantly, there was no alternative plea that if iVenture Travel were not the contracting party, then iVenture Card was the contracting party. As we have found that it was iVenture Card and not iVenture Travel which was party to the Reseller Arrangement, is iVenture Card thereby precluded from claiming relief for breach of the Reseller Arrangement (given that they had no longer pleaded that iVenture Card was a party to the Reseller Arrangement)?

  66. [36] In Fan Ren Ray and others v Toh Fong Peng and others [2020] SGCA 117, this court observed at [12] that:

  67. [37] We note that the narrow exception in cases where it is clear that no prejudice will be caused by the reliance on an unpleaded cause of action or issue that has not been examined at the trial (eg, where it is apparent that both sides had come to court to deal with an issue in the case despite its omission from the pleadings), is, however, unlikely to be common: V Nithia (co-administratrix of the estate of Ponnusamy Sivapakiam, deceased) v Buthmanaban s/o Vaithilingam and another [2015] 5 SLR 1422 (“V Nithia”) at [41]. Nonetheless, in our view, an unpleaded cause of action or issue that has not been examined at trial is very different from the situation where A and B sue X claiming damages for repudiation or breach of a contract that was entered into between, not A and/or B, but C and X.

  68. [38] Having said that, we think the circumstances of this case are quite unique. First and foremost, the Judge granted relief to Big Bus on its counterclaim by awarding damages against iVenture Card for Big Bus’s unpaid invoices under the Reseller Arrangement. Consistent with this finding on the correct counterparty to the Reseller Arrangement, the Judge also awarded damages to iVenture Card against Big Bus for the latter’s repudiatory breach of the Reseller Arrangement. It would seem incongruous, having granted relief to Big Bus against iVenture Card for unpaid invoices under the Reseller Arrangement, not to grant relief to iVenture Card if it established a breach by Big Bus of the very same Reseller Arrangement just because iVenture Card did not include an alternative claim in the event it was found to be the correct counterparty. In our view, it is quite inexplicable for iVenture Card to maintain an argument on appeal that iVenture Travel was the correct party to the Reseller Arrangement notwithstanding its acceptance of and its decision not to appeal against the Judge’s award of $145,792.86 to Big Bus in respect of the unpaid invoices under the same Reseller Arrangement.

  69. [39] Secondly, on the pleadings at trial, this was not a case of Big Bus being caught unawares or prejudiced by a “non-party” in the sense of an entity which was not a party to the proceedings, making a claim for damages for repudiation of the Reseller Arrangement. In response to the appellants’ amendment of their Statement of Claim, Big Bus amended their Defence by denying that iVenture Travel had ever been a party to any of the agreements and averred that they only came to know of iVenture Travel’s existence on 14 July 2015 (as referenced at [32] above). Importantly, Big Bus also amended their Counterclaim for the unpaid invoices from iVenture Card with a further or alternative claim of that same sum from iVenture Travel and adding iVenture Travel as a 3rd defendant to the counterclaim in the event iVenture Travel was the correct party to the Reseller Arrangement. Big Bus averred that either one of those entities was liable for the $145,792.86 comprised in the October and November 2017 invoices under the Reseller Arrangement.

  70. [40] In our view, despite the very serious pleading defect in the appellants’ statement of claim, this is a case where Big Bus itself had pleaded in their counterclaim, that either iVenture Card or iVenture Travel was liable for their claim for unpaid invoices in the sum of $145,792.86. iVenture Travel, although strictly not a party to the claim against Big Bus for repudiatory breach of the Reseller Arrangement, participated at trial as a 3rd defendant to Big Bus’s counterclaim of $145,792.86 as well as a counter-claimant in its counterclaim against Big Bus for damages for repudiatory breach of the Reseller Arrangement. It was not a true non-party in the sense of the hypothetical at [37] above.

  71. [41] Furthermore, Big Bus, the party who would normally be standing in the shoes of the party prejudiced by having to meet an unpleaded case, themselves led evidence contending that iVenture Card was in fact the party to the Reseller Arrangement, and not iVenture Travel. This can be seen from Ms Teo’s AEIC, in which she stated:

  72. [42] We are therefore of the view that the Judge had correctly found that iVenture Card and not iVenture Travel was the party to the Reseller Arrangement and that the failure of iVenture Card to maintain a plea in the alternative in the event that they were held to be the proper party to the Reseller Arrangement does not, in the rather unique circumstances of this case, preclude iVenture Card’s claim for damages for Big Bus’s breach of the Reseller Arrangement, if any.

  73. The existence of the 30-day credit term

  74. [43] It is undisputed that from 29 March 2016, the parties entered into a set-off arrangement to set off the fees due to iVenture Card under the Licence Agreement and the payments to Big Bus for the Reseller Invoices. The appellants submit that this set-off arrangement “negated the possibility” of a 30-day credit term applying to the Reseller Invoices.

  75. [44] We agree with the Judge’s observations at [8] of the Judgment that the parties’ emails dated 29 March 2016 showed that a 30-day credit term applied to the Reseller Invoices. These emails show that Ms Teo had informed Mr Rieveley that, with the set-off arrangement, Big Bus would bill “IV” (which, in our view, referred to iVenture Travel as the party to be billed for the Reseller Invoices) before the 3rd of every month and that bills would be settled before the 3rd of the “preceding month” (which was an error as Ms Teo clearly meant the following month as it would not make sense otherwise). This points to a 30-day payment and billing cycle, or, in other words, a 30-day credit term. The appellants did not protest this. Instead, they subsequently conducted themselves as if this 30-day credit term applied. In an email to one Mr Joost Timmer and Mr Rieveley dated 23 October 2017, Ms Teo sought their assistance for slow payments in respect of the Reseller Invoices issued by Big Bus. Ms Teo recounted the delays for the June (60 days), July (72 days) and August 2017 (43 days and not yet settled) Reseller Invoices and then stated that the “term of agreement” was that the August bill would be out by 1 September 2017 and payment should be made by 30 September 2017 (ie, a 30-day credit term). Ms Teo then stated that they could expect their bills to be paid by Big Bus within 30 days. On 27 October 2017, Ms Teo sent a reminder and on the same day, Mr Rieveley explained they were waiting for payments in Singapore dollars from other parties before making payment and stated: “I can assure you that payment will be processed within the next week for August and we will definitely work toward reducing the payment cycle now that we have a bit of extra margin to play with” [emphasis added]. Tellingly, Mr Rieveley did not dispute the 30-day credit term as claimed by Ms Teo and, in fact, acknowledged the existence of a fixed payment cycle of some kind, which, we observe, appears to be at odds with the appellants’ case in this appeal that there was no applicable credit term. As late as 31 October 2017, Ms Teo sent an email to Mr Rieveley, asking for payment for two Reseller Invoices dated 31 August 2017 and “31 [sic] September 2017” (ie, the 30 September 2017 Invoice) which were stated to be due on 30 September 2017 and 30 October 2017 respectively. This, again, implied a 30-day credit term for each invoice. In his reply to Ms Teo’s email that same day, Mr Rieveley did not dispute the due dates of both invoices; instead, he assured Ms Teo that payment for the 31 August 2017 invoice would be cleared “by the end of the week” and that the 30 September 2017 Invoice would be cleared as soon as possible.

  76. [45] We therefore agree with the Judge that a 30-day credit term applied to the 30 September 2017 invoice, and that iVenture Card’s failure to make payment on that invoice within that period amounted to a breach of the Reseller Arrangement. The Judge found that this breach, however, did not entitle Big Bus to terminate the Reseller Arrangement: see [9] of the Judgment. As observed above, this is not disputed on appeal.

  77. Whether the Service Level Agreement had been repudiated

  78. [46] At this juncture, we pause to recapitulate the legal position as found by us, with some prefatory remarks, before we go further:

  79. (a) We agree with the Judge that iVenture Card was in breach of the Reseller Arrangement when it failed to pay the 30 September 2017 Invoice by the due date for payment. It follows that Ms Teo was entitled to demand that this invoice be paid by 9 November 2017 as the 30-day credit period had expired. When iVenture Card failed to do so, Big Bus was entitled to damages arising from that breach. However, this breach by iVenture Card did not give rise to a right of termination or suspension of the Reseller Arrangement on the part of Big Bus. This is not disputed on appeal.

  80. (b) The Judge found that Big Bus’s imposition of the Pass Suspension on 8 November 2017 was a repudiatory breach of the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement; this is also not disputed on appeal. As noted, iVenture Card’s breach of the Reseller Arrangement did not entitle Big Bus to take such action. However we also note that even before its own deadline of 9 November 2017 for the payment of the 30 September 2017 Invoice had expired, Big Bus had already taken steps to exit its contractual arrangements with iVenture Card.

  81. (c) iVenture Card’s subsequent conduct in locking Big Bus out of the SORSE System on the same day was held by the Judge to be a repudiatory breach of the Service Level Agreement on the part of iVenture Card. With respect, for the reasons set out below, we do not agree with this conclusion of the Judge.

  82. (d) We note that when iVenture Card subsequently paid the 30 September 2017 Invoice on 9 November 2017, Big Bus did not lift the Pass Suspension. Instead, Big Bus imposed additional requirements under the Reseller Arrangement on iVenture Card as conditions for lifting the Pass Suspension, viz:

  83. (i) iVenture Card was to remit the sum of S$150,000 for sales collected on Big Bus’s behalf from 1 October 2017 to 9 November 2017; and

  84. (ii) iVenture Card was to furnish a banker’s guarantee or a drawdown deposit of S$200,000 to cover forward sales.

  85. [47] We now proceed to the issue of whether iVenture Card or Big Bus or both had repudiated the Service Level Agreement. The appellants’ case is that Big Bus had repudiated the Service Level Agreement by treating it at an end in the 6 December 2017 Letter. Thus, in our view, in determining whether Big Bus’s termination of the Service Level Agreement amounted to a repudiatory breach, the following issues arise for determination:

  86. (a) whether iVenture Card had breached the Service Level Agreement by imposing the SORSE System Suspension;

  87. (b) whether any such breach of the Service Level Agreement by iVenture Card was a repudiatory breach; and

  88. (c) whether Big Bus breached the Service Level Agreement by way of the 6 December 2017 Letter terminating the Service Level Agreement, and whether such a breach was repudiatory in nature.

  89. [48] We consider each of these issues in turn.

  90. Whether iVenture Card had breached the Service Level Agreement

  91. [49] The appellants assert that they had not breached the Service Level Agreement by imposing the SORSE System Suspension. In support of this, they advance three arguments:

  92. (a) The “essential bargain”, ie, the continued operation of the Singapore iVenture Pass from which all of iVenture Card’s fees under the Licence Agreement are derived was a condition precedent to their continued performance of the Service Level Agreement. The Pass Suspension therefore relieved iVenture Card of the need to perform the Service Level Agreement any further, and therefore the SORSE System Suspension was not a breach of the Service Level Agreement.

  93. (b) iVenture Card was entitled to impose the SORSE System Suspension under cl 7.5 of the Service Level Agreement.

  94. (c) The Pass Suspension prevented iVenture Card from performing its obligations under the Service Level Agreement, or made such performance futile.

  95. (1) Whether the Pass Suspension obviated the need to perform the Service Level Agreement

  96. [50] We begin with the appellants’ argument that the “essential bargain” under the Licence Agreement was a condition precedent to their continued performance of the Service Level Agreement. By imposing the Pass Suspension, Big Bus had refused to perform substantially all of its obligations under the Licence Agreement. This relieved the appellants from the need to perform the Service Level Agreement any further. The SORSE System Suspension was therefore not a breach of the Service Level Agreement.

  97. [51] As support for their argument that the performance of the Licence Agreement was a condition precedent to continued performance under the Service Level Agreement, the appellants pointed to cll 3.2a and 8.2(e) of that agreement, which state:

  98. [52] We do not think that these provisions render the performance of the Licence Agreement a condition precedent to continued performance under the Service Level Agreement. Under cl 3.2a, what is required for the Service Level Agreement to remain afoot is that the Licence Agreement must be “in effect”. However, as the Judge observed at [17] of the Judgment, despite Big Bus’s imposition of the Pass Suspension, the Licence Agreement was not and could not be discharged without more: see RDC Concrete Pte Ltd v Sato Kogyo (S) Pte Ltd and another appeal [2007] 4 SLR(R) 413 (“RDC Concrete”) at [90]. The Licence Agreement also was not automatically terminated in the event of a breach of contract (as the Pass Suspension indisputably was); cll 17.1, 17.5, 17.6 and 18.1 of that agreement, when read together, point to the need for written notice of the breach, an obligatory 30-day “cure” period and only if the party in breach failed to rectify the breach within the 30-day period, would the innocent party be entitled to bring the contract to an end by a written notice of termination. As for cl 8.2(e), it obliges Big Bus to have, at all times, a valid Licence Agreement to use the services provided by iVenture Card under the Service Level Agreement. The key question, therefore, is what a “valid Licence Agreement” means. The appellants’ argument is essentially that the Pass Suspension would somehow render the Licence Agreement “invalid”. We are unable to accept that argument. The word “valid” is legally defined in Black’s Law Dictionary (Bryan Garner ed) (West, 9th Ed, 2009) at p 1690 as “legally sufficient; binding”. Thus defined, a valid Licence Agreement is one which remains legally binding on the parties. As we have said, the Pass Suspension did not cause the Licence Agreement to cease to be legally binding without more. We therefore find that the appellants’ reliance on cll 3.2a and 8.2(e) in support of their assertion that the SORSE System Suspension was not a breach of the Service Level Agreement is misconceived.

  99. [53] The appellants also argue that the performance of the Licence Agreement was a condition precedent to further performance of the Service Level Agreement as it was “consistent with the reasonable and probable expectations of the parties” (relying on Y.E.S. F&B Group Pte Ltd v Soup Restaurant Singapore Pte Ltd (formerly known as Soup Restaurant (Causeway Point) Pte Ltd) [2015] 5 SLR 1187 at [63]). The appellants assert that the Smartvisit System was specifically licensed to Big Bus only to support the Singapore iVenture Pass business, and that Big Bus was not entitled to use the Smartvisit System for any other purpose. Thus, once the Singapore iVenture Pass business had ceased, iVenture Card was no longer obligated to provide Big Bus with any further access to the SORSE System.

  100. [54] We are unable to accept this argument, which appears to take an overly narrow view of both the Singapore iVenture Pass business as well as the Smartvisit System. It seems to us that the argument presupposes that the Singapore iVenture Pass business consisted only of the sales and activation of the Singapore iVenture Pass, which was the part of the business stopped by the Pass Suspension. It ignores, however, the administrative and strategic aspects of the business which relied on Big Bus having access to the data stored in the SORSE System. The evidence before us shows that such data included sales reports and customer data. The SORSE System also enabled Big Bus to create reports and invoices to manage their financial accounts and management reporting requirements. None of these functions became otiose with the Pass Suspension and we therefore do not think it likely that, in entering into the Service Level Agreement, Big Bus intended the performance of the Licence Agreement to be a condition precedent to the continued performance of all of iVenture Card’s obligations under the Service Level Agreement.

  101. (2) Whether iVenture Card was entitled to impose the SORSE System Suspension

  102. [55] We next turn to the question of whether iVenture Card was entitled to impose the SORSE System Suspension under cl 7.5 of the Service Level Agreement, which states:

  103. [56] The appellants argue that, once Big Bus had imposed the Pass Suspension, it was reasonable for iVenture Card to question the need or motive for access to the Smartvisit System by Big Bus’s employees, since any such access was granted strictly for the purpose of operating the Singapore iVenture Pass business, and therefore the SORSE System Suspension was a justified restriction of Big Bus’s access to the SORSE System. We do not accept this argument, given our conclusions that a breach of the Licence Agreement did not automatically release iVenture Card and Smartvisit Pty Ltd from their contractual obligations under the Service Level Agreement and that the Pass Suspension, which impacted the sales end of the Singapore iVenture Pass business, did not obviate Big Bus’s continued need to access the data and functions of the SORSE System for the purposes of the administrative and strategic aspects of the Singapore iVenture Pass business. For these reasons, iVenture Card’s imposition of the SORSE System Suspension appears neither reasonable nor justified.

  104. (3) Whether the Pass Suspension made performance of the Service Level Agreement impossible or futile

  105. [57] We now turn to the final argument advanced by the appellants in contending that they had not breached the Service Level Agreement. The argument is that the Pass Suspension rendered the performance of the Service Level Agreement impossible or futile. The appellants rely on two authorities in support of this argument.

  106. [58] The first is the principle in Stirling v Maitland (1864) 5 B & S 841 (“Stirling”) (cited in Evergreat Construction Co Pte Ltd v Presscrete Engineering Pte Ltd [2006] 1 SLR(R) 634). This principle states that if a party enters into an agreement which can only take effect by the continuance of a certain existing state of circumstances, there is an implied engagement on his part that he shall do nothing of his own motion to put an end to that state of circumstances, under which alone the arrangement can be operative.

  107. [59] The second is the principle in Peter Turnbull & Co v Mundus Trading Co (1953–1954) 90 CLR 235 (“Peter Turnbull”) (cited in Straits Engineering Contracting Pte Ltd v Merteks Pte Ltd [1995] 3 SLR(R) 864, which, in turn, was cited in Siti and another v Lee Kay Li [1996] 2 SLR(R) 934). The principle states that an innocent party is excused from performing its obligations under a repudiated contract where the repudiation has made the performance of such obligations futile.

  108. [60] In our view, neither principle assists the appellants. We say this for three reasons. First, the Pass Suspension did not make iVenture Card’s and Smartvisit’s continued performance of the Service Level Agreement impossible. Big Bus’s access to the SORSE System could have been maintained without interference from iVenture Card even if the Singapore iVenture Pass business ceased and rendered the front-end of the Smartvisit System dealing with the sales and activation of the Singapore iVenture Pass futile. The Stirling principle therefore had no application here. Secondly, the Pass Suspension also did not amount to a breach of Big Bus’s contractual obligations under the Service Level Agreement (which were to pay the contractually-prescribed fees to iVenture Card for the provision of the services) and accordingly we do not think that iVenture Card was in the position of an “innocent party” vis-à-vis the Service Level Agreement so as to bring it within the Peter Turnbull principle. Thirdly, and in any case, the cessation of the revenue-generating side of the Singapore iVenture Pass business as a result of the Pass Suspension did not render the administrative and strategic aspects of the business served by the SORSE System futile. The Peter Turnbull principle therefore had no application here as well.

  109. [61] For these reasons, we are of the view that by imposing the SORSE System Suspension, iVenture Card had breached the Service Level Agreement. As noted above, the Judge had awarded Big Bus nominal damages of S$1,000 for said breach (Judgment at [33]). The appellants’ submission on appeal is only that no sums should be awarded to Big Bus as it had not breached the Service Level Agreement. There is no appeal by either side on the Judge’s quantification of damages for the aforesaid breach. Further, for completeness, as we go on to conclude below, the SORSE System Suspension was not an operative cause of any part of the loss of the Singapore iVenture Pass business (see [109]–[110] below). We therefore see no reason for us not to affirm the Judge’s award of nominal damages of S$1,000 to Big Bus.

  110. Whether the SORSE System Suspension was a repudiatory breach of the Service Level Agreement

  111. [62] We now consider whether, by imposing the SORSE System Suspension, iVenture Card had gone beyond a breach and in fact repudiated the Service Level Agreement, such as to entitle Big Bus to terminate the same.

  112. (1) The law on repudiatory breaches of contract

  113. [63] We first set out the applicable legal framework, laid down by this court in RDC Concrete, which entitles an innocent party to terminate a contract in the absence of an express provision to do so. RDC Concrete set out three scenarios:

  114. (a) Scenario 1: Where the party in breach renounces its contract inasmuch as it clearly conveys to the innocent party that it will not perform its contractual obligations at all: RDC Concrete at [93]. This amounts to a repudiation of the contract by the party in breach.

  115. (b) Scenario 2: Where the party in breach breaches a condition of the contract that the parties had contemplated was so important that a breach would give rise to a right of termination: RDC Concrete at [97].

  116. (c) Scenario 3: Where the breach in question would deprive the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit it intended to obtain from the contract: RDC Concrete at [99]. This is the approach laid down in Hongkong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd [1962] 2 QB 26 at 70, under which an innocent party will be entitled to terminate the contract if the nature and consequences of the breach are so serious as to “go to the root of the contract” (otherwise termed a fundamental breach of the contract).

  117. (2) Scenario 1

  118. [64] A renunciation of contract occurs when one party by words or conduct evinces an intention not to perform or expressly declares that he is or will be unable to perform his obligations in some material respect, and short of an express refusal or declaration, the test is to ascertain whether the action or actions of the party in default are such as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that he no longer intends to be bound by its provisions. For example, the party in default may intend to fulfil the contract but may be determined to do so only in a manner substantially inconsistent with his obligations, or may refuse to perform the contract unless the other party complies with certain conditions not required by its terms: San International Pte Ltd (formerly known as San Ho Huat Construction Pte Ltd) v Keppel Engineering Pte Ltd [1998] 3 SLR(R) 447 at [20].

  119. [65] The Judge found that iVenture Card had repudiated the Service Level Agreement because it had refused to perform its contractual obligations thereunder unless Big Bus performed its obligations under the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement. iVenture Card therefore evinced an intention not to perform its obligations within the four corners of the Service Level Agreement. However, a refusal to perform a contract unless the other party complies with an invalid condition will not necessarily amount to a repudiation and much depends on all the facts and circumstances of the case: Mayhaven Healthcare v Bothma and another (trading as DAB Builders) [2009] 127 Con LR 1 at [30]. The question is whether iVenture Card’s refusal to perform the Service Level Agreement on condition that Big Bus performed the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement would lead a reasonable person to conclude that it no longer intended to be bound by the Service Level Agreement.

  120. [66] In ascertaining whether iVenture Card had such an intention, it is necessary to determine whether the Licence Agreement, the Service Level Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement ought to be read together as representing the parties’ full bargain rather than separately. As this court observed in Sunny Metal & Engineering Pte Ltd v Ng Khim Ming Eric [2007] 3 SLR(R) 782 (“Sunny Metal”) at [30]:

  121. [67] Clause 10 of the Preliminary Agreement states:

  122. [68] The above makes clear that the Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement were always intended to be read together as containing all the terms of the parties’ business collaboration to launch the Singapore iVenture Pass. As for the Reseller Arrangement, its raison d’etre was to permit iVenture Card to resell the Singapore iVenture Pass. It stood and fell with the Singapore iVenture Pass business. It therefore formed part of the same transaction as the Licence Agreement and the Service Level Agreement. Thus, in our view, the three agreements formed part of the same bargain and therefore should be read together. It is clear to us that the parties’ complete bargain was for a business collaboration with respect to the creation and bringing to market of the Singapore iVenture Pass. This business consisted of two aspects. The revenue-generating aspect of the business was governed by the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement by setting out the terms of the parties’ collaboration on issues such as marketing, sales and profit-sharing (eg, commissions). The technology and operations aspect of the business, on the other hand, was governed by the Service Level Agreement, which dealt with issues such as the terms on which the Smartvisit System (which included the SORSE System) was to be provided and used. The benefit of the Singapore iVenture Pass business collaboration obtained by Big Bus from this bargain was the profits from the sale of the Singapore iVenture Pass and business and operational support provided by iVenture Card. iVenture Card’s benefit of the bargain was the various fees and commissions it stood to earn under the Licence Agreement, the Service Level Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement.

  123. [69] In our view, on the evidence before the court, the imposition of the SORSE System Suspension was clearly intended to pressure Big Bus to lift the Pass Suspension. Given that the SORSE System Suspension was in place for so long as the Pass Suspension (which prevented the continuance of the Singapore iVenture Pass business) remained in effect, it was a plain attempt at pressuring Big Bus into restoring the status quo ante, or in other words, to resume the parties’ business collaboration before matters got out of hand, where the parties performed all their respective contractual obligations under the Licence Agreement, Service Level Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement. On 8 November 2017 at 5.26pm, after discovering that the Pass Suspension had been imposed, Mr Rieveley sent Mr Heng (with Ms Teo copied) the following email :

  124. Later that same day at 7.54pm, Mr Rieveley sent Mr Heng the following email (again with Ms Teo on copy) :

  125. [70] On 10 November 2017, Ms Teo sent a request to Mr Rieveley, imposing the conditions referred to at [46(d)] above, and asking for the SORSE System to be turned on “for [Big Bus] to resume business”. Mr Rieveley refused her request, saying, in an email sent on 11 November 2017:

  126. [71] Further, on 13 November 2017, Mr Rieveley sent the following email to Ms Teo, which further underscored his attempt to bring matters back to the status quo ante:

  127. [72] In these circumstances, we are of the view that iVenture Card’s conduct did not objectively convey the impression that it no longer intended to be bound by its contractual obligations under the Service Level Agreement. Indeed, the opposite appears to be true. Accordingly, we are of the view that Scenario 1 of RDC Concrete is not established on the facts. We add a postscript to reinforce our view. On 28 November 2017, iVenture Card instructed their solicitors to send Big Bus a two-page letter giving notice and details of the breaches of the iVenture Licence Agreement by Big Bus as well as the issue of the HiPPO Singapore Pass. The letter also demanded that Big Bus, inter alia, resume the Singapore iVenture Pass business with immediate effect and to cease and desist from assisting or permitting Ducktours from carrying on the business of the HiPPO Singapore Pass. It also gave notice under cl 26.1 of the Licence Agreement for the first stage of the agreed mode of dispute resolution by asking Mr Heng to contact iVenture Card to commence mutual negotiations to resolve the dispute.

  128. (3) Scenario 2

  129. [73] In its Defence and Counterclaim (Amendment No. 2) and the 6 December 2017 Letter, Big Bus appears to rely on a Scenario 1 type of repudiatory breach. However, for completeness, we turn to consider whether Scenarios 2 and/or 3 of RDC Concrete can be established on the facts here as these are advanced in the Respondent’s Case. This turns on whether cl 4.4 read with Schedule 3 of the Service Level Agreement and the Program Management Services Brief attached thereto, which obliged iVenture Card to provide Big Bus with access to the SORSE System, was a condition. In other words, did the parties consider the obligation to provide Big Bus with access to the SORSE System so important that they intended that the failure to provide such access would entitle Big Bus to discharge the Service Level Agreement?

  130. [74] In our view, cl 4.4 was not a condition of the Service Level Agreement. The parties did, in that agreement, expressly designate certain terms as “conditions”. For instance, cl 3.2a of the Service Level Agreement, which as we observed above imposes a requirement that the Licence Agreement be in effect, was an express condition of the Service Level Agreement. The inference which can be drawn from this is that the conditions of the Service Level Agreement would be manifest in the express language of that agreement itself. Thus, a term not expressly designated as a “condition” of the Service Level Agreement would, on a balance of probabilities, not have been intended as such. We note cll 13.3 and 13.4 of the Service Level Agreement provide that any condition or warranty implied into the Service Level Agreement is excluded to the extent permitted by law. The use of such terminology would lead one to expect that, unless a term was expressly designated in the Service Level Agreement as a “condition” or a “warranty”, it is not to be construed as such. It follows that cl 4.4 is not a condition of the Service Level Agreement since it was not expressly designated as one in the Service Level Agreement. We are therefore of the view that Scenario 2 of RDC Concrete is not made out on the facts.

  131. (4) Scenario 3

  132. [75] Whether Scenario 3 of RDC Concrete is established on the facts here depends on whether the SORSE System Suspension would deprive Big Bus of substantially the whole benefit it intended to obtain from the Service Level Agreement. We do not think it would have done so. The SORSE System formed one part of the Smartvisit System which iVenture Card was obligated to provide under the Service Level Agreement. The SORSE System handled the administrative back-end of the Singapore iVenture Pass business, with the front-end of the Smartvisit System handling the validation, reporting and invoicing of transactions for TAAPs. It was Big Bus which deprived itself of the benefit of the front-end of the Smartvisit System by imposing the Pass Suspension and ceasing revenue-generating activities for the Singapore iVenture Pass business. Seen in this light, we do not think it can be said that the SORSE System Suspension deprived Big Bus of substantially the whole benefit it intended to obtain from the Service Level Agreement when Big Bus’s own Pass Suspension deprived itself of at least as much, if not more, of the benefit of that agreement. Scenario 3 of RDC Concrete is not, in our view, made out on the facts.

  133. [76] We therefore, with respect, depart from the Judge’s finding that iVenture Card had, in imposing the SORSE System Suspension, repudiated the Service Level Agreement. Big Bus was therefore not entitled to rely on that suspension to terminate the Service Level Agreement. The question, then, is whether Big Bus itself had in turn repudiated the Licence Agreement and/or the Service Level Agreement by the 6 December 2017 Letter.

  134. Whether Big Bus repudiated the Licence Agreement and/or the Service Level Agreement by the 6 December 2017 Letter

  135. [77] In the 6 December 2017 Letter to iVenture Card’s solicitors, which was in reply to iVenture Card’s solicitor’s notice of breaches of the Licence Agreement dated 28 November 2017 (see [72] above), Big Bus’s solicitors stated:

  136. [78] The appellants’ pleaded case was that, by the 6 December 2017 Letter, Big Bus had wrongfully terminated the Licence Agreement and thereby repudiated the same. Alternatively, Big Bus had repudiated the Licence Agreement by imposing the Pass Suspension. The repudiation of the Licence Agreement also breached the Mutual Dependency Clause which was a condition of the Service Level Agreement and thus also constituted a repudiation of that agreement as well. The repudiation of these two agreements also constituted a repudiation of the Reseller Arrangement. The repudiations were accepted in the letter of 8 December 2017 from iVenture Card’s solicitors.

  137. [79] In our view, the facts show that Big Bus had breached both the Licence Agreement and the Reseller Arrangement by imposing the Pass Suspension on 8 November 2017. While it is not disputed on appeal that this was repudiatory (see [46(b)] above), iVenture Card did not proceed to treat that as a repudiation but instead implemented the retaliatory SORSE System Suspension within a few hours of the former. In these often highly-charged breach of contract and/or repudiation allegations and counter-allegations, it is well to recall the famous words of Asquith LJ in Howard v Pickford Tool Co Ltd [1951] 1 KB 417 at 421:

  138. It follows that any apparent repudiation of the said agreements by the Pass Suspension is only relevant insofar as it discloses breaches of the agreements. However, as mentioned, iVenture Card alleged that it had subsequently accepted a later repudiation by virtue of the 6 December 2017 Letter by its lawyer’s letter dated 8 December 2017. It is therefore necessary to consider the effect of the 6 December 2017 Letter.

  139. [80] For the reasons set out above, iVenture Card breached the Service Level Agreement with its SORSE System Suspension but the evidence and circumstances surrounding that retaliatory measure did not, in our view, amount to a repudiation. As noted above, iVenture Card was clearly trying to pressure Big Bus to cease hostilities and revert to the position before the disputes, in their view, got out of hand. The 6 December 2017 Letter sent by Big Bus’s solicitors, however, was a wrongful repudiation of the Licence and Service Level Agreements. Given that these agreements were afoot at the time of the 6 December 2017 Letter, Big Bus’s repudiation of these agreements is clear from the terms of its letter (quoted at [77] above). We further find that this letter amounted to a repudiation of the Reseller Arrangement as well. We say this because first, as the Judge below found, at [22] of the Judgment, it was a commercially necessary and sensible implied term in the Reseller Arrangement that it would be in effect insofar as the Licence and Service Level Agreements subsisted. He viewed the Reseller Arrangement as a “secondary arrangement” which if the parties had thought about it, would not have intended it to continue if their main collaboration had come to an end. There was no appeal from this finding. Secondly, we are in complete agreement with the Judge. The Reseller Arrangement was an accessory or incidental or offshoot agreement that was dependent on the existence of the Licence Agreement. The entire business under the Reseller Arrangement was reselling the Singapore iVenture Passes for a commission and that disappeared once the Licence Agreement was ended. It is clear the Reseller Arrangement, as an agreement, could not have stood on its own without the Licence Agreement just as the Service Level Agreement made little commercial sense without the existence of the Licence Agreement. The parties themselves saw these three agreements as part of their business collaboration under the Preliminary Agreement. Although the 6 December 2017 Letter only mentions the Licence and Service Level Agreements, it necessarily included therefore, by implication, the Reseller Arrangement. The appellants accepted this wrongful repudiation of the Licence Agreement, Service Level Agreement and, by implication, the Reseller Arrangement as well, by their solicitors’ letter of 8 December 2017.

  140. Whether Mr Heng was protected by the rule in Said v Butt

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.