Court of Appeal · Decided 26 October 2022
An Guang Shipping Pte Ltd (under judicial management) and others v Ocean Tankers (Pte) Ltd (in liquidation)
Feedback & support[2022] SGCA 69 · Case no. Civil Appeal No 56 of 2021
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
- [1]
[1] After a company enters into liquidation, expenses and liabilities incurred by its liquidators for the purposes of the winding up may be accorded priority over the company’s other unsecured debts, pursuant to what is known as the liquidation expenses principle. Although this principle was articulated and developed in the context of liquidation, it also applies by extension in the context of judicial management, where expenses and liabilities are incurred by a company’s judicial managers for the benefit of the company. This was first recognised in Singapore – tentatively but, in our view, rightly – by Kannan Ramesh J in Re Swiber Holdings Ltd [2018] 5 SLR 1358 (“Swiber Holdings”) at [89]. We refer to this as the “judicial management expenses principle” or “the Principle”.
- [2]
[2] The present appeal provides us with an occasion to consider the scope of the Principle and its application to a case involving the retention and use of property by a company’s judicial managers while the company is in judicial management. The appellants are 40 vessel-owning subsidiaries of Xihe Holdings (Pte) Ltd (“the XH Companies”), while the respondent is Ocean Tankers (Pte) Ltd (“OTPL”). Both the XH Companies and OTPL are presently in judicial management and are represented in these proceedings by their judicial managers, whom we refer to as “the XH JMs” and “the OTPL JMs”, respectively. Central to the parties’ dispute is the question whether the XH Companies’ claims under various bareboat charters, which OTPL had entered into with the XH Companies prior to being placed in interim judicial management, fall within the scope of the Principle so as to enjoy priority in OTPL’s judicial management.
- [4]
[4] We begin by setting out the facts and background to the present appeal. Thereafter, we explain in detail the reasons for our decision.
Facts
- [5]
[5] Much of the factual background has been helpfully recounted by the Judge in the GD, and we restate only the facts material to the present appeal. As there are several overlapping categories and classifications of the 76 vessels which are the subject of the parties’ dispute, we also make reference where appropriate to a table which summarises the relevant facts in relation to each of these vessels (“the Table of Vessels”). This Table of Vessels is contained in the Annex to our judgment.
Parties and background
- [6]
[6] Mr Lim Oon Kuin had procured the incorporation of various companies including OTPL, Xihe Holdings (Pte) Ltd (“XH”), Xihe Capital (Pte) Ltd (“XC”) and Hin Leong Trading (Pte) Ltd (“HLT”). XH and XC were part of the Xihe Group. Some of XH’s subsidiaries owned vessels, and 40 such subsidiaries are relevant to the present appeal (“the XH Companies”).
- [7]
[7] Prior to the entry into insolvency processes of OTPL, HLT and certain companies in the Xihe Group, their businesses were connected. In particular, the XH Companies (as shipowners) chartered their vessels to OTPL, principally under bareboat charters. OTPL would then sub-charter those vessels to, or enter into contracts of carriage with, various other parties (including HLT) on time or voyage charters. This formed a significant part of OTPL’s business of ship chartering and ship management (see [2] of the GD).
Events taking place during OTPL’s interim judicial management
18 May 2020 Meeting
- [9]
[9] On 18 May 2020, a meeting took place between the OTPL JMs and the management of the Xihe Group (“the Meeting”) regarding vessels that OTPL had chartered from the XH Companies (see [6] of the GD). In their presentation slides (“the Slides”) for the Meeting, the OTPL JMs stated that due to the market’s loss of confidence in the trading ability of OTPL’s fleet, OTPL was unable to continue servicing its bareboat charter obligations to the XH Companies, and as such wished to consensually terminate the bareboat charters. In this connection, the OTPL JMs proposed arrangements for the physical redelivery of the chartered vessels to the XH Companies, or alternatively for ship management agreements to be entered into between OTPL and the XH Companies.
Termination Notices issued by the XH Companies
- [10]
[10] From 20 May 2020 to 3 June 2020, notices of termination (“the Termination Notices”) were issued by the XH Companies in respect of bareboat charters for 41 vessels, 30 of which are relevant to this appeal. These 30 vessels are identified in Column A of the Table of Vessels.
OS 652 – the XH Companies’ redelivery application
- [14]
[14] No hearing date was fixed for OS 652 as the consent of the mortgagees of the vessels to the termination of the bareboat charters had yet to be obtained, and the terms of redelivery had yet to be worked out between the XH Companies and the OTPL JMs. The discussions on the terms of redelivery did not reach any conclusion (see the GD at [9]–[10]).
Marketing and deployment of the XH Companies’ vessels by the OTPL JMs
- [15]
[15] Concurrently, from 12 May 2020 to 8 September 2020, the OTPL JMs marketed some of the XH Companies’ vessels for hire in the lists of vessels in OTPL’s fleet which were sent to brokers and charterers. Some of these marketed vessels (though not all) were then successfully deployed on sub-charters. The facts pertaining to these vessels are discussed in more detail at [95]–[104] below.
Events taking place after OTPL was placed in judicial management
Notices of Non-Adoption issued by the OTPL JMs
XH Companies’ retraction of the Termination Notices, affirmation of the bareboat charters and discontinuance of OS 652
- [19]
[19] On 1 and 2 September 2020, the XH JMs issued notices to the OTPL JMs retracting the Termination Notices. In response to the Notices of Non-Adoption, between 10 and 15 September 2020, the XH JMs issued notices to the OTPL JMs affirming the bareboat charters. The XH JMs also sought leave to discontinue OS 652 (their application for leave of court for the redelivery of vessels), and this was granted on 28 September 2020 (see the GD at [12]).
SUM 4257 – OTPL’s disclaimer application
- [22]
[22] On 13 November 2020, the XH JMs were appointed judicial managers (see the GD at [10]).
OTPL’s summons for directions
- [24]
[24] On 1 May 2021, the OTPL JMs filed SUM 2085 seeking the court’s directions regarding these claims arising out of OTPL’s bareboat charters of the 76 vessels owned by the XH Companies. These claims fell within two categories: (a) charterhire for the period of use (ie, the period of sub-charter or carriage entered into by OTPL with various parties), and (b) ancillary liabilities (ie, sums other than charterhire payable or to be borne by OTPL under the bareboat charters) incurred during the period of use (see the GD at [23]). The former category of claims will be referred to as “Charterhire Claims” while the latter category will be referred to as “Ancillary Claims”, and both categories of claims arising out of or in connection with the bareboat charters will be collectively referred to as “the Claims”. The OTPL JMs were prepared to admit the Claims (to the extent that the amounts were agreed) as OTPL’s debts, but argued before the Judge that the Principle did not apply to confer priority on them because the OTPL JMs did not choose to retain possession of the vessels for the benefit of the judicial management; they had wanted to return these vessels and had taken steps to do so, and it was the XH Companies’ refusal to take possession of their vessels that had forced them to remain in OTPL’s hands. Accordingly, the OTPL JMs contended that the Claims should be treated as ordinary unsecured debts ranking pari passu with OTPL’s other unsecured debts. The XH JMs, on the other hand, argued before the Judge that the Principle applied to elevate the Claims to priority expenses in OTPL’s judicial management which should be paid in priority to OTPL’s unsecured debts, because the OTPL JMs had retained the vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s creditors and judicial management, and they thereby took a calculated risk that this could lead to the XH Companies having preferential claims against OTPL.
- [25]
[25] After the filing of SUM 2085, the XH Companies’ solicitors asked whether OTPL had put the vessels on the market or advertised their availability for charter, with the intention of chartering the vessels to generate income for OTPL. OTPL’s solicitors responded via e-mail on 3 July 2021 (“the OTPL Solicitors’ E-mail”), stating that it was part of the OTPL JMs’ duties as interim judicial managers to assess initially whether OTPL’s vessels could be redeployed in a commercially viable way, as part of their consideration of the options available for OTPL’s ship management and chartering business. The OTPL Solicitors’ E-mail also stated that, as was common in the ship chartering industry, enquiries from potential customers would be received by OTPL, and suitable vessels would be identified for further discussion. The OTPL chartering team had also telephoned brokers and potential clients to seek new business and/or to make them aware that OTPL remained open to chartering business.
- [26]
[26] To put the practical significance of the parties’ dispute in context, the quantum of the Claims is very large. As we noted in An Guang Shipping Pte Ltd (judicial managers appointed) and others v Ocean Tankers (Pte) Ltd (in liquidation) [2022] 1 SLR 1232 (“An Guang Shipping (SUM 89)”) at [4], treating the Claims as preferred debts would result in applying all of OTPL’s assets towards them, leaving nothing for OTPL’s unsecured creditors. That said, we note that (as OTPL points out) the XH Companies have not provided any figures to quantify the specific Claims they are pursuing in the present appeal.
- [27]
[27] Separately, OTPL also highlights that there are ongoing proceedings in which the XH JMs assert that they are not obliged to pay the sums that they had undertaken to bear (which were expenses incurred by the OTPL JMs in respect of the vessels) as a priority payment in the XH Companies’ judicial management.
- [28]
[28] On 20 September 2021, the Judge delivered his brief oral grounds in respect of SUM 2085 (“the Oral Judgment”), in which he held that the Principle would generally not apply to the XH Companies’ claims. The Judge set out the detailed reasons for his decision in the GD issued on 14 March 2022. We summarise the key aspects of the Judge’s reasoning at [31]–[34] below.
Procedural history
- [29]
[29] On 19 October 2021, the XH Companies filed their Notice of Appeal against the Judge’s decision. As the Judge’s decision was in respect of a summons (namely, SUM 2085), a two-Judge coram of the Court of Appeal was constituted to hear the appeal pursuant to para 4(i) of the Seventh Schedule to the Supreme Court of Judicature Act (Cap 322, 2007 Rev Ed).
- [30]
[30] While not material to the present appeal, we mention by way of background that on 1 November 2021, OTPL applied in CA/SUM 89/2021 to strike out the Notice of Appeal on the ground that the XH Companies had not obtained leave of court before filing the appeal, which OTPL argued was required under s 133(1) of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (Act 40 of 2018) (“the IRDA”). We dismissed this application on 21 February 2022, with our full reasons set out in An Guang Shipping (SUM 89).
Decision below
- [31]
[31] The Judge held that a “clear line” had to be drawn between vessels for which Notices of Non-Adoption were issued from 31 August 2020 to 3 September 2020, and vessels in respect of which no such notices were issued. The Notices of Non-Adoption were an unequivocal statement by the OTPL JMs that they did not wish to retain possession of the vessels for the benefit of the estate and wished to redeliver them. Thus, the Principle generally could not apply to either the Charterhire Claims or the Ancillary Claims for the period of use of the relevant vessels once the Notices of Non-Adoption had been issued by the OTPL JMs (see the GD at [52]). This aspect of the Judge’s decision is accepted by the XH Companies on appeal.
- [32]
[32] However, the Judge also held that the Principle would generally not apply even during the period before the Notices of Non-Adoption were issued. The Judge found that the facts generally demonstrated that the OTPL JMs had been compelled to retain the vessels, at first due to extraneous circumstances, and later due to the actions of the XH JMs (see the GD at [35]):
- [33]
[33] Accordingly, the Judge concluded that the OTPL JMs had not retained the vessels for the benefit of the estate, and the Principle would thus generally not apply to the Claims arising out of the vessels that were the subject of SUM 2085 (see the GD at [35], [57] and [84]).
- [34]
[34] Nevertheless, the Judge went on to hold that this general conclusion was subject to certain exceptions. Several categories of vessels had been used for various purposes, and the Judge’s conclusions on each of these categories were as follows:
(a) The first category comprised vessels in respect of which the OTPL JMs had issued Notices of Adoption, and which were thus not the subject of SUM 2085. The Principle applied to any claims arising out of the use of these vessels, which would thus be accorded priority (see the GD at [59]).
(b) The second category comprised vessels which had been used by the OTPL JMs to store and transport cargo prior to the Notices of Non-Adoption, and this use continued after the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption (from May to early December 2020) (“the Second Category”). The Principle applied to both Charterhire Claims and Ancillary Claims for expenses for the period of use of these vessels, though not to repair costs as it was “difficult to establish a link between the repair costs which ought to be borne by OTPL and the use of the vessels in the period of use” (see the GD at [60]–[64]).
(c) The third category comprised vessels which had been used by the OTPL JMs to store and transport cargo after applying for leave in interpleader proceedings (from May to late September or early October 2020) (“the Third Category”). The Principle did not apply as the OTPL JMs needed to retain the vessels to hold on to their cargo while creditors resolved their competing claims in interpleader proceedings, and they thus did not retain these vessels for the benefit of the estate (see the GD at [65]–[66]).
(d) The fourth category comprised vessels which were deployed on sub-charters by the OTPL JMs, and which were used at various times before and after the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption (“the Fourth Category”). The Principle applied to both Charterhire Claims and Ancillary Claims for expenses for the period of use of these vessels after the relevant Notices of Non-Adoption were issued (albeit not to repair costs), because being deployed in sub-charter was clearly for the benefit of the estate. For the five vessels within this category which stopped operating for months at a time, the period of use would not include such periods of inactivity; and whether the Principle applied to the period of use resuming after the Notices of Non-Adoption were issued would depend on why the deployment of these five vessels resumed (see the GD at [67]–[71]).
(e) The fifth category comprised vessels deployed by the OTPL JMs for various in-house services (“the Fifth Category”). The Principle applied to both Charterhire Claims and Ancillary Claims for expenses arising out of these vessels after the relevant Notices of Non-Adoption were issued (albeit not to repair costs), because if the OTPL JMs had redelivered these vessels, they would have needed to secure other vessels to achieve the same purpose, in which case they would have incurred expenses under post-insolvency contracts which would then have enjoyed priority as judicial management expenses. Notably, the Principle also applied to expenses incurred during the periods of downtime when the vessels were not used, because these vessels were nevertheless retained for a purpose regarded as being beneficial to the estate (see the GD at [72]–[74]).
(f) The sixth category, labelled “Others”, consisted of only one vessel (“the Sixth Category”). It was unclear to what use this vessel was put. The Judge thus left the parties to use the guidance provided on the other categories to determine the correct outcome for this category (see the GD at [75]).
- [35]
[35] The vessels falling within the Second to Sixth Categories are identified in Column E of the Table of Vessels.
The parties’ cases
- [36]
[36] The parties’ cases on appeal focus on four main areas of dispute, and we summarise their arguments on each area in the sections that follow. The XH JMs’ key contention, however, should – in the interests of clarity – be stated at the outset. The XH JMs take issue with the Judge’s finding that the Principle would generally not apply to the XH Companies’ Claims in the period before the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption, which in turn was based on the Judge’s inference that the OTPL JMs had wanted to redeliver the vessels during this period but were forced to retain them due to leave of court and the mortgagees’ consent being required for redelivery. The XH JMs’ position is that the Judge erred in so inferring and that the contemporaneous evidence instead shows that the OTPL JMs made a conscious choice to retain the XH Companies’ vessels in furtherance of their judicial management objectives. Let us now turn to the four main areas of dispute.
On the position of interim judicial managers
- [37]
[37] First, the XH Companies submit that the Judge erred in suggesting (at [29] of the GD) that a degree of latitude should be afforded to an interim judicial manager in assessing whether leased property was retained for the benefit of the estate. They contend that OTPL JMs, acting as interim judicial managers, should be held to the same standard as judicial managers because they had already taken concrete steps to advance the restructuring of OTPL to ensure its survival as a going concern, and had retained the vessels in furtherance of that stated goal.
- [38]
[38] In response, OTPL argues that this suggestion did not influence the Judge’s decision that the OTPL JMs had not retained the vessels for the benefit of the estate. In any event, the Judge’s suggestion was correct given that the application of the Principle is fact-sensitive and the factual and legal situation at the interim judicial management stage is very different from that at the judicial management stage.
On whether the OTPL JMs retained vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate
- [39]
[39] Second, the XH Companies submit that the Judge erred in inferring that the OTPL JMs had not retained various groups of vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate in the period up to the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption. The XH Companies argue that the OTPL JMs had retained two (overlapping) groups of vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate:
(a) For the vessels in respect of which Termination Notices were issued and accepted, the predominant reason that redelivery could not take place was that the OTPL JMs withheld redelivery as commercial leverage, to secure technical or commercial management (or ship management) contracts and payment of ROB in full, for the benefit of OTPL’s judicial management. The alleged extraneous reasons impeding redelivery were only secondary reasons for the failure of redelivery.
(b) For the vessels which the OTPL JMs marketed for hire, these can be further subdivided into: (i) vessels for which Termination Notices were never issued and where no steps were taken by the OTPL JMs to implement redelivery, at least up to the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption; and (ii) vessels for which Termination Notices were issued and which were the subject of redelivery negotiations. For (i), these were retained by the OTPL JMs to rehabilitate OTPL’s chartering business and restore market confidence, or at least to generate income for OTPL’s estate. For (ii), the Judge’s inference that the OTPL JMs were marketing these vessels as potential future ship managers is unsupported; instead, the OTPL JMs used these vessels as commercial leverage. Thus, these vessels were also retained for the benefit of the estate.
- [40]
[40] In reply, OTPL submits that the Judge was correct to infer that the OTPL JMs had not retained the vessels for the benefit of the estate, but instead had been compelled to do so.
(a) For the vessels in respect of which Termination Notices were issued and accepted, the OTPL JMs intended at all times to redeliver the vessels and were actively taking steps towards doing so. However, there were matters subject to ongoing discussions between the OTPL JMs and the management of the Xihe Group, and there were also other unresolved matters which prevented the OTPL JMs from redelivering the vessels – namely, the need to obtain leave of court and the mortgagees’ consent for the termination of the bareboat charters.
(b) For the vessels which the OTPL JMs marketed for hire, this was done to earn revenue to defray the operating expenses that OTPL continued to incur while it was being compelled to retain these vessels for reasons beyond its control.
On the application of the Principle to periods of inactivity between deployments
- [41]
[41] Third, for the vessels which the OTPL JMs deployed on sub-charters, the XH Companies contend that the Judge erred in finding that the Principle did not apply to the periods of inactivity before, between and after redeployment on sub-charters in the period up to the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption. They argue that, given the preparation work (such as marketing and negotiations) that had to be done prior to actual deployment of the vessels, the OTPL JMs’ intention to retain the vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate must have existed once they started marketing the vessels, rather than manifesting only when the vessels were actually deployed.
- [42]
[42] OTPL, on the other hand, submits that the Judge did not err in this regard as the OTPL JMs did not generally retain these vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate during this period (having been forced to remain in possession of these vessels), and the Principle should therefore only apply where the vessels in this category were actually used for OTPL’s business by being deployed on sub-charters.
On the Ancillary Claims
- [43]
[43] Fourth, the XH Companies submit that the Judge erred in requiring them to prove that the Ancillary Claims were linked to the period during which the vessels were beneficially retained by the OTPL JMs before they could constitute judicial management expenses (which they label “the relative approach”). Instead, they contend that any liability which accrues during the period of beneficial retention should be payable in full as a judicial management expense (“the accruals approach”).
Issues to be determined
- [45]
[45] From the parties’ arguments on appeal, four issues arise for this court’s determination:
(a) first, whether the Judge erred in suggesting that a degree of latitude should be afforded to an interim judicial manager in assessing whether leased property had been retained for the benefit of the estate;
(b) second, whether the Judge erred in inferring that the OTPL JMs had not retained various categories of vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate in the period up to the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption;
(c) third, whether, for vessels in the Fourth Category, the Judge erred in finding that the Principle did not apply to periods of inactivity between redeployment on sub-charters in the period up to the issuance of the Notices of Non-Adoption; and
(d) fourth, whether the Judge erred in requiring the XH Companies to prove that the Ancillary Claims were linked to the period during which the vessels were beneficially retained by the OTPL JMs before they could constitute judicial management expenses.
- [46]
[46] The specific vessels relevant to each disputed issue are identified in Column F of the Table of Vessels. Before we consider each of these issues in turn, we set out the applicable legal principles that guide our analysis. These are, in the main, not disputed by the parties, as the focus of their cases on appeal is instead on the Judge’s application of the Principle to the Claims in issue.
The applicable legal principles
- [47]
[47] The statutory starting point is s 227J(3)(b) of the Companies Act (Cap 50, 2006 Rev Ed), which provides that “any remuneration and expenses properly incurred by [a judicial manager]” shall be charged on and paid out of the property of the company in his custody or under his control in priority to all other debts. Although the principal function of s 227J(3)(b) appears to be to confer priority on claims by the judicial manager himself against the company, claims by third parties might also be treated as expenses of the judicial management, and hence may fall within the scope of s 227J(3)(b), if the Principle applies. In such cases, even though these claims are not made by the judicial manager himself, they may be treated as expenses of the judicial management (see Swiber Holdings at [85]–[86] and [90]). For completeness, we note that s 227J(3)(b) of the Companies Act is now s 104(3) of the IRDA.
- [49]
[49] More recently, the principle was explained by the English Court of Appeal in Jervis and others v Pillar Denton Ltd and others [2014] 3 WLR 901 (“Jervis”) at [101] in the terms set out below:
Although the court in Jervis referred to “administration”, the administration procedure in English law is broadly similar to Singapore’s judicial management regime, which was based on the English administration procedure (see Swiber at [81] and [89], and T C Choong & V K Rajah, Judicial Management in Singapore (Butterworths, 1990) (“Choong & Rajah (1990)”) at p 6).
- [50]
[50] It should, however, be noted that the Principle ought to be “restrictive in its application”. It is for the party seeking to rely on the Principle to show why he should have priority over the other creditors. Furthermore, it is “not sufficient that the [judicial manager] retained possession for the benefit of the estate if it was also for the benefit of the [party making the claim]”, and “[n]ot offering to surrender or simply doing nothing [is] not regarded as retaining possession for the benefit of the estate” (see Chaly Chee at [53]–[54], citing Toshoku at [27]–[29]). In Toshoku at [28], Lord Hoffmann (delivering the judgment of the House of Lords) illustrated these points with two cases involving liquidators, which he explained as follows:
(a) In In re ABC Coupler & Engineering Co Ltd (No 3) [1970] 1 WLR 702 (“ABC Coupler”), “the liquidator on appointment closed down the business which had been conducted on the premises, had the company’s plant and machinery valued and thought about what he should do. It was only from the time he decided to put the lease on the market that Plowman J held that he was retaining the premises for the benefit of the winding up and was liable to pay the rent in full” [emphasis added]. In ABC Coupler itself, Plowman J expressly observed that where the official receiver had not indicated an election to retain the lease, and had instead merely left the company’s plant and machinery where he found them, had them valued and took no steps to surrender the company’s interest in the factory, “those were all matters which Lindley LJ in the Oak Pits Colliery case … said were not sufficient to entitle the landlord to be paid in full” (see ABC Coupler at 716G).
(b) In In re HH Realisations Ltd (1975) 31 P & CR 249, it was held that “a company ceased to be liable to pay the rent in full from the time it gave notice to the landlord that it was seeking authority to disclaim the lease, even though it remained in occupation for nearly two months longer” [emphasis added].
- [52]
[52] Ultimately, the critical question is whether the property was retained and used “for the benefit of” the estate. This will depend on the purpose of the judicial managers in retaining possession of such property (see ABC Coupler at 709B). The judicial managers’ purpose, in turn, “will be found or will be inferred from what [they] in fact did”, rather than being “dependent on the subjective processes in [their] mind[s]” (see Downer Enterprises at 1466H). Thus, as the Judge observed (at [27] of the GD), the mere fact of retention is not the focus of the inquiry, and the assessment of the purpose of retention is an objective one based on the judicial managers’ conduct. It will also be apparent from what we have said above that determining whether the Principle applies in a given case is necessarily a highly fact-sensitive inquiry, the answer to which will turn on the precise facts as well as all the circumstances of each case.
- [53]
[53] With these principles in mind, we turn to the four issues in dispute in the present appeal.
Issue 1: Application of the Principle to interim judicial managers
- [54]
[54] The XH Companies first contend that the Judge erred in venturing to suggest that, “in assessing whether an interim judicial manager has retained the property for the benefit of the estate, some degree of latitude ought to be afforded to the interim judicial manager given the purpose of his appointment” [emphasis added] (at [29] of the GD). This suggestion was made by the Judge in the context of his holding that the Principle would apply even where a company was in interim judicial management, as “interim judicial managers are also faced with decisions that need to be made for the benefit of the estate” (at [28] of the GD). We stress that the applicability of the Principle to interim judicial managers is not contested by the parties; the only point in dispute in this regard is whether any latitude should be afforded to interim judicial managers in applying the Principle.
- [55]
[55] It is unclear what role this point serves in the context of the present appeal in so far as the XH Companies are concerned. As OTPL points out, the XH Companies have not identified how this suggestion led the Judge into error and, if so, what that error is. At no point in the GD did the Judge indicate that he was in fact affording any latitude to the OTPL JMs in assessing the purpose of retaining the vessels prior to 7 August 2020, when they were acting in their capacity as interim judicial managers. Instead, the Judge considered whether, on the facts, the OTPL JMs’ retention of the vessels could be said to be for the benefit of the estate. Although the XH Companies suggest in their skeletal submissions that the Judge’s “faulty starting premise” (that an interim judicial manager should be afforded a degree of latitude) may have led the Judge to draw overly charitable inferences in the OTPL JMs’ favour and omit to examine the correspondence between the parties from 12 June to 1 July 2020, we do not think this assertion is borne out by our own examination of the available evidence (as will be seen below).
- [56]
[56] The question of whether and how the position of interim judicial managers should differ from that of judicial managers with regard to the application of the Principle thus does not arise for our determination in the present appeal. Nevertheless, we express, for completeness, our tentative views on the matter.
- [57]
[57] The starting point is that the Principle applies in principle to both interim judicial managers and judicial managers, and the central question in both contexts is whether the property was retained for the benefit of the estate. However, in ascertaining whether an interim judicial manager has in fact retained property for the benefit of the estate, it must be borne in mind that the position of an interim judicial manager differs from that of a judicial manager because of the nature of this appointment. The purpose of appointing an interim judicial manager under s 227B(10)(b) of the Companies Act (now s 92 of the IRDA) is typically to protect the assets and business of a company where there is an immediate danger thereto, pending the appointment of judicial managers (see the High Court decision of Re KS Energy Ltd and another matter [2020] 5 SLR 1435 (“KS Energy”) at [14]–[16]; see also the decision of this court in Hin Leong Trading (Pte) Ltd (in liquidation) v Rajah & Tann Singapore LLP and another appeal [2022] SGCA 28 (“Hin Leong Trading”) at [18]). In this regard, a parallel may be drawn between the appointment of an interim judicial manager and the appointment of a provisional liquidator (see KS Energy at [17]). As we have explained (at [50] and [52] above), the mere fact of retention is not determinative, and what is crucial is the purpose behind the retention. This point takes on particular significance in the context of interim judicial management, the overarching aim of which is essentially protective. As we highlighted to counsel at the hearing of the appeal, an interim judicial manager may rightly be cautious about taking irrevocable steps to dispose of property that may later be important for the company’s business. Contrary to what the XH Companies suggest, this protective aim is not incompatible with the interim judicial manager also taking steps to advance the restructuring of the company.
- [58]
[58] The XH Companies rely on the English decision of MK Airlines Property Ltd v Katz [2014] BCC 103 (“MK Airlines”) (which the Judge referred to at [28] of the GD) for the proposition that questions of whether it is beneficial to retain property can arise regardless of whether the company is in judicial management or interim judicial management. That is certainly true. However, this does not take the XH Companies very far. The issue in MK Airlines was whether the liquidation expenses principle was applicable to a provisional liquidation (see MK Airlines at [33]–[34]). Nicholas Strauss QC, sitting as a deputy High Court judge in the Chancery Division (Companies Court), answered this question in the affirmative. It was in this context that he held as follows (see MK Airlines at [35]–[36]):
- [59]
[59] When the decision in MK Airlines is read more closely, we do not think it stands for the proposition that the position of interim judicial managers is the same as that of judicial managers vis-à-vis the application of the Principle. To be clear, the same inquiry is to be undertaken in both contexts: the question is whether the property was retained for the benefit of the estate. However, this does not mean that the court should be precluded from taking into account the different aims of interim judicial management and judicial management, and the differences in the respective positions of interim judicial managers and judicial managers, in answering this question.
- [63]
[63] Be that as it may, the ultimate question for the court is still whether the OTPL JMs could be said to have retained the vessels for the benefit of the estate. Had the OTPL JMs exercised the power to disclaim the bareboat charters and the vessels chartered thereunder, this might have placed it beyond doubt that they did not intend to retain the vessels for the benefit of the estate. However, the fact that the OTPL JMs did not exercise this power does not, conversely, show that they did retain the vessels for the benefit of the estate. Whether this is so will, as we have stated at [52] above, require an examination of the precise facts and all the circumstances of each case.
- [64]
[64] We return at this juncture to the Judge’s suggestion that a “degree of latitude” should be given to interim judicial managers in assessing whether they have retained property for the benefit of the estate. In our view, this should be read as no more than an expression of the common-sense principle that the purpose, powers and position of interim judicial managers should be borne in mind by the court in determining whether the Principle applies in a given case. In this regard, we note that it was, for a time, the position in English law that the Principle would not apply automatically or inflexibly in the context of administration, unlike in the context of liquidation. In In re Atlantic Computer Systems plc [1992] Ch 505 (“Atlantic Computer Systems”) at 526G and 527E–528H, the English Court of Appeal held as follows:
- [65]
[65] The English Court of Appeal’s judgment in Atlantic Computer Systems, including the qualification as to how the Principle should apply in the context of administration (in contrast to liquidation), was referred to by Ramesh J in Swiber at [88]–[89] in holding that the Principle applied to judicial management under Singapore law. The flexible approach in Atlantic Computer Systems has since hardened into a rule more akin to the liquidation expenses principle, following the English Court of Appeal’s subsequent decision in Jervis (see John Birds et al, Boyle & Birds’ Company Law (Jordan Publishing, 10th Ed, 2019) at para 21.20). As noted in Goode on Principles of Corporate Insolvency Law (Kristin van Zwieten gen ed) (Sweet & Maxwell, 5th Ed, 2018) at para 11–112:
- [66]
[66] Nevertheless, in our view, the reasoning in Atlantic Computer Systems remains instructive in respect of the application of the Principle to interim judicial managers. As we have stated at [52] above, determining whether the Principle applies in a given case is a highly fact-sensitive inquiry, and part of the relevant factual matrix is the context in which the Principle is being applied. The English Court of Appeal’s reasoning in Atlantic Computer Systems that some “breathing space” should be accorded in view of the “interim and temporary” nature of administration applies a fortiori to interim judicial management in our context. For the avoidance of doubt, this is not to say that a more relaxed “test” should apply to interim judicial managers: the central question remains whether the property was retained for the benefit of the estate (see [57] above). Our view is, instead, that the court may take cognisance of the position of interim judicial managers in determining whether the property has indeed been retained for the benefit of the estate in the case before it.
Issue 2: Whether the Principle applies to the OTPL JMs’ retention of vessels
- [67]
[67] We turn now to the main issue in dispute in the present appeal – namely, whether the Judge erred in inferring from the material before him that the OTPL JMs did not retain two overlapping groups of vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate, but had instead been compelled to retain these vessels. As outlined at [39] above, these are: (a) the vessels in respect of which Termination Notices were issued by the XH Companies and accepted by the OTPL JMs (identified in Column A of the Table of Vessels), and (b) the vessels which the OTPL JMs marketed for hire, including vessels in respect of which Termination Notices were never issued and no steps were taken by the OTPL JMs to implement redelivery. We deal with each group of vessels in turn.
Vessels in respect of which Termination Notices were issued and accepted
- [68]
[68] In so far as the 30 vessels in respect of which Termination Notices were issued and accepted are concerned, the XH Companies’ case has two main aspects. First, the XH Companies submit that the OTPL JMs withheld the redelivery of these vessels as commercial leverage to secure valuable ship management contracts for OTPL and the payment of ROB in full, both of which were for the benefit of OTPL’s estate, as well as to preserve optionality. Second, the XH Companies submit that the need to obtain leave of court and the consent of the vessels’ mortgagees (ie, the financing banks) for the redelivery of the vessels were at best only secondary reasons for the failure of redelivery, which served the purpose of buying more time for the OTPL JMs for negotiations on the payment of ROB and the entry into ship management contracts and which concurrently gave the OTPL JMs the opportunity to generate income by deploying these vessels. They were not genuine concerns in the minds of the OTPL JMs.
- [69]
[69] This argument by the XH Companies necessitates a closer examination of the OTPL JMs’ conduct from May 2020 (when OTPL was placed in interim judicial management) up to 2 September 2020 (when the relevant Notices of Non-Adoption were issued). There are, in our view, three key events that took place during this period: (a) the Meeting; (b) the correspondence between the OTPL JMs and the XH Companies from 27 May 2020 to 1 July 2020; and (c) the OTPL JMs’ Interim Judicial Managers’ Report dated 7 July 2020 (“the OTPL IJM Report”).
Meeting between the OTPL JMs and the management of the Xihe Group
- [71]
[71] It should be noted, at this juncture, that the position in the Slides quoted above was stated generally in respect of the entire fleet of vessels chartered by OTPL, and not only the subset of vessels in respect of which Termination Notices would later be issued by the XH Companies. We also highlight that the need for a “consensual” termination of the bareboat charters would have been particularly significant in this context given the nature of the property involved in this case – namely, vessels. The OTPL JMs could not simply have abandoned the vessels, especially given the hardship to the crew (for those vessels which had crew on board), the risk of pollution and the danger to shipping that this would have posed. As counsel for OTPL, Mr Narayanan Sreenivasan SC (“Mr Sreenivasan”), put it during the hearing, it was “not like locking up premises, going to the landlord, and dropping off the keys”. Moreover, as we pointed out during the hearing, it would also not have been sensible for the OTPL JMs to have dry docked the vessels as this would have incurred further expenses.
- [72]
[72] In the handover plans referred to in the Slides, the fleet of vessels chartered by OTPL was divided into six groups.
(a) For Groups 1 to 4 (which comprised 83 off-hire vessels in total), the Slides indicated that OTPL wished to physically redeliver the vessels in June or July 2020; and that, as an “alternative” to physical redelivery, OTPL was willing to consider entering into ship management agreements with the XH Companies.
(b) For Group 5 (which comprised 36 off-hire vessels which were unencumbered and had no known contingent claims against them), OTPL would “consider further whether it wishe[d] to retain any of these vessels on varied bareboat hire terms mutually agreeable” with the relevant XH Companies; and for those vessels OTPL did not wish to retain, OTPL wished to physically redeliver the vessels in July 2020. As an “alternative” to physical redelivery, OTPL was willing to consider entering into ship management agreements with the XH Companies.
(c) For Group 6 (which comprised 21 vessels then employed with third parties), the Slides stated that “OT[PL]’s preference [was] to continue to bareboat charter the relevant vessels” with a variation of terms (relating to the payment of bareboat hire), but for the vessels to be redelivered upon completion of employment.
- [73]
[73] From 20 May 2020 to 3 June 2020, Termination Notices were then issued by the XH Companies in respect of 30 of the vessels in issue in this appeal. Of these 30 vessels, 27 vessels fell within Groups 1 to 4, two fell within Group 5 (the “Ocean Pride” and the “Ocean Princess”) and one fell within Group 6 (the “Ocean Summer”). The OTPL JMs accepted these Termination Notices and agreed to redelivery subject to payment of ROB.
- [74]
[74] We read the Slides as stating in no uncertain terms that OTPL wished to “consensually terminate” the bareboat charters and needed to “urgently plan for the possibility of a redelivery of vessels” to the XH Companies. In our view, the general position taken in the Slides is indicative of the OTPL JMs’ central desire from the outset, which was for the vessels to be redelivered to the XH Companies. The Slides also made proposals for the redelivery of the vessels falling within Groups 1 to 4 as a first resort; entry into ship management agreements with the XH Companies was simply something OTPL was willing to consider as an “alternative” [emphasis added] to the physical redelivery of these vessels. As for the two vessels falling within Group 5 and the vessel falling within Group 6, although OTPL was prepared to retain these vessels on varied bareboat hire terms, the fact that Termination Notices were ultimately issued and accepted for these vessels suggests that this variation did not materialise. In that event, the OTPL JMs would have wished to redeliver these vessels as well. In our view, the Slides evince the OTPL JMs’ clear intention at the outset to terminate the bareboat charters and redeliver the vessels, as OTPL simply did not have the financial means to continue servicing its bareboat charter obligations to the XH Companies.
Correspondence between the OTPL JMs and the XH Companies
- [75]
[75] We turn next to consider why the vessels were not in fact redelivered. To this end, it is necessary to peruse the relevant e-mail correspondence between the OTPL JMs and the XH Companies’ representatives from 27 May 2020 to 1 July 2020 where they discussed redelivery for some of the vessels. In our judgment, this correspondence – read as a whole and in context – is consistent with the OTPL JMs’ position that they did not wish to retain the vessels for the benefit of OTPL’s estate.
- [76]
[76] On 27 May 2020, the OTPL JMs wrote to the XH Companies’ representatives (“the 27 May E-mail”). This e-mail made reference to the Termination Notices that had been issued and reiterated the OTPL JMs’ previous queries regarding whether the XH Companies had obtained the requisite consent from the mortgagee banks to terminate the bareboat charters. They noted that this was an issue which “impact[ed] the validity of the Termination Notices” and asked the XH Companies’ representatives to “address these requests and queries before the re-delivery of the vessels”. Subject to their review of the master bareboat charters and the requirement of the mortgagees’ consent for termination, the OTPL JMs were “prepared to agree to re-delivery of the Vessels to the respective [XH Companies] whereupon [they understood] that [the XH Companies’] intention [was] for [OTPL] to take over as technical and crewing managers for the Vessels on terms to be agreed”. The 27 May E-mail went on to set out the OTPL JMs’ suggestions regarding the redelivery of 40 vessels. They stated that they could effect the redelivery of the 35 vessels which were not then under employment “relatively promptly” once certain matters were resolved, such as the XH Companies’ payment of ROB due to OTPL upon redelivery and the finalisation of the terms under which OTPL would act as the managers of the vessels. As for the remaining five vessels which were then mid-voyage and/or still under employment, OTPL would only be in a position to effect redelivery to the XH Companies following the completion of the voyages and the discharge of the cargo on board these vessels. The 27 May E-mail concluded with the OTPL JMs asking the XH Companies to provide the requested documents and input regarding the above “as promptly as possible to enable [them] to progress matters”.
- [77]
[77] We pause here to note that, of the 30 vessels in respect of which Termination Notices had been issued, 28 were included in these redelivery suggestions (only the “Ocean Pride” and “Ocean Princess”, which were on time charter, were omitted), albeit that two of those 28 vessels were then mid-voyage and/or still under employment (namely, the “Ocean Neptune” and the “Ocean Summer”).
- [78]
[78] In our view, the 27 May E-mail further supports the OTPL JMs’ position that they were working towards the redelivery of the vessels for which Termination Notices had been issued. Indeed, they appeared to be eager to “progress matters” (see [76] above). Nevertheless, there remained some outstanding matters that had to be resolved before redelivery could take place, such as the mortgagees’ consent, the payment of the ROB due to OTPL upon redelivery, the finalisation of the terms of the ship management agreements, and of course the completion of the voyages for the vessels which were then still under employment. Notably, as the OTPL JMs point out, para 3 of this e-mail recorded the OTPL JMs’ understanding that it was the XH Companies’ “intention … for [OTPL] to take over as technical and crewing managers for the Vessels on terms to be agreed”.
- [79]
[79] A meeting then took place on 28 May 2020 regarding the redelivery of the vessels. On 30 May 2020 at 11.05am, the XH Companies’ representatives wrote to the OTPL JMs informing them that they had written to the mortgagees to inform them about the terminations of the bareboat charters. Later on the same day, at 7.11pm, the OTPL JMs responded (“the 30 May E-mail”) stating that, with respect to the vessels which were not under employment or laden with cargo, they accepted the Termination Notices “to the extent that [OTPL] intends to re-deliver the Vessels to the [XH Companies], concluding the [bareboat charters], and transition from its present role as bareboat charterers to its future role as technical managers for the Vessel”. On 31 May 2020, the XH Companies’ representative replied, stating (among other things) that any future possible role OTPL might play in the technical and crew management of the vessels was “a separate matter” and “[would] not affect the obligation to redeliver”. This e-mail also stated that the XH Companies “look[ed] forward to discussing the terms of the technical and crew management so that if there [was] an agreement, [they would] have a clear working relationship with [OTPL] as managers in the employment of [their] vessels”.
- [80]
[80] Subsequently, on 12 June 2020, the XH Companies sent the OTPL JMs the proposed redelivery protocol, which (in brief) was that OTPL would “take over the current crew contracts in its capacity as a crew manager …with the same existing terms and conditions” and would also “enter into a crew management agreement with Xihe”. In reply, the OTPL JMs stated on 15 June 2020 that “at this stage OTPL takes no position on the redelivery protocol nor any plans for redelivery of the 41 vessels”, as they had queries regarding “the terms upon which the [XH Companies] wish to engage OTPL as crew manager as referenced in the redelivery protocol”, and further sought the XH Companies’ “clear agreement” that they would pay for the ROB for each vessel prior to any redelivery. The OTPL JMs ended this particular e-mail by stating that, without the above information and confirmations, it was “not reasonable for the [XH Companies] to ask OTPL to take any position on the redelivery protocol”.
- [81]
[81] On 17 June 2020, the XH Companies responded, expressing surprise that OTPL did not take any position on the redelivery of the vessels, and stating that OTPL’s failure to redeliver the vessels promptly might cause them and/or the lenders losses by reason of claims against those vessels and because they had not been able to deploy them. The XH Companies then highlighted various sums due from OTPL in respect of the vessels, before stating that they were nevertheless “prepared to discuss a resolution of the redelivery process”. The XH Companies also provided an Interim Shipman Agreement for the technical and crew management of the vessels, which would be effective from the date of physical redelivery of the vessels, and asked that redelivery be effected “over the weekend or early next week”.
- [82]
[82] The OTPL JMs replied two weeks later (on 1 July 2020), with their comments on the Interim Shipman Agreement and with their proposal on dealing with the ROB on the vessels. After this time, there appears to have been no further correspondence between the XH Companies and OTPL on this point.
- [83]
[83] The XH Companies argue that the correspondence above shows that the OTPL JMs only contemplated redelivery of the vessels being conditional on the XH Companies granting the ship management contracts to OTPL, which would have furthered the survival of OTPL’s business as a going concern. We disagree with this reading of the correspondence. Instead, what emerges from this correspondence is that, although the redelivery of the vessels may have been hindered by the OTPL JMs’ insistence on resolving certain outstanding issues before redelivery could be effected, at no point did the OTPL JMs express any intention to retain the vessels, or to make redelivery conditional on the XH Companies acceding to their wishes regarding the ship management contracts. As the OTPL JMs submit, the correspondence shows that both parties were discussing and working towards redelivery. In these circumstances, we do not think that the Judge erred in finding that “the evidence suggested that the OTPL JMs were merely exploring options and seeking input from the [XH Companies]”, as was in line with their duties as (then) interim judicial managers; and that, “at its highest, the OTPL JMs’ conduct was equivocal, and hardly qualifies as evincing an intention to retain the vessels for the benefit of the estate” (at [46] of the GD).
OTPL IJM Report
- [84]
[84] The XH Companies’ position is further undermined by the OTPL IJM Report dated 7 July 2020, which was submitted to the court on the same date. This was the day after the XH Companies had filed OS 652 seeking leave of court for redelivery of some of the vessels (on 6 July 2020). We set out the salient portions of the OTPL IJM Report below.
- [85]
[85] The section of the OTPL IJM Report on the stabilisation of OTPL’s business operations noted that the OTPL JMs were “currently in discussion with the shipowners for redelivery of 39 vessels without employment which are bareboat chartered from SPVs under the Xihe Group”.
- [86]
[86] The section of the OTPL IJM Report on the vessels in OTPL’s fleet for which Termination Notices had been received stated as follows:
The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.