Court of Appeal · Decided 10 May 2024
Zhu Su v Three Arrows Capital Ltd and others and another matter
Feedback & support[2024] SGCA 14 · Case no. Court of Appeal / Originating Application No 37 of 2023 · 8 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Background facts
- [3]
[3] The applicants in OA 37 and OA 38 were respectively Mr Zhu Su (“Mr Zhu”) and Mr Kyle Livingston Davies (“Mr Davies”) (collectively, the “Applicants”), directors of Three Arrows Capital Pte Ltd (“TA-SG”), a Singapore entity. TA-SG owned 100% of the shares in the first respondent, Three Arrows Capital Ltd (“TA-BVI”), a British Virgin Islands (the “BVI”) entity. The liquidators of TA-BVI, Mr Christopher Farmer (“Mr Farmer”) and Mr Russell Crumpler (“Mr Crumpler”), were respectively the second and third respondents in both OA 37 and OA 38. The respondents shall collectively be referred to hereinafter as the “Respondents”.
- [4]
[4] On 9 July 2022, the Respondents filed HC/OA 317/2022 (“OA 317”) for recognition of TA-BVI’s liquidation proceedings in the BVI as a foreign main proceeding under Art 2(f) of the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency (the “Model Law”) as adopted in Singapore in the IRDA, Third Schedule. Various consequential orders were also sought, including recognition of the liquidators (ie, Mr Farmer and Mr Crumpler) as foreign representatives within the meaning of Art 2(i) of the Model Law with standing to make applications for orders or reliefs under the IRDA. The Applicants were non-parties to OA 317. OA 317 was allowed by the Judge on 22 August 2022.
- [7]
[7] The Respondents thereafter filed HC/SUM 2104/2023 and HC/SUM 2105/2023 for orders of committal against Mr Davies and Mr Zhu respectively. The applications were granted by the Judge on 25 September 2023 (the “Committal Orders”), and the Applicants were each sentenced to four months’ imprisonment for contempt of court. Mr Zhu was arrested and committed to prison on 29 September 2023, while Mr Davies has remained out of jurisdiction.
- [9]
[9] Thereafter, on 11 December 2023, the Applications were filed. The Respondents opposed the Applications.
The law
- [11]
[11] Permission to appeal is required under s 29A(1)(c) of the SCJA before an appeal may be brought against a decision of the General Division of the High Court if the case is specified in the SCJA, Fifth Schedule, paras 3, 4(1) and 5(1). For the present purposes, the SCJA, Fifth Schedule, para 3(l) is relevant. It reads:
Our decision
- [16]
[16] As stated above, s 244 of the IRDA was previously s 285 of the Companies Act, which reads:
For the present purposes, it suffices to observe that the provisions are substantially similar.
- [20]
[20] Jumabhoy was followed some years later in PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP and others v Celestial Nutrifoods Ltd (in compulsory liquidation) [2015] 3 SLR 665 (“Celestial Nutrifoods”). The appellants were PricewaterhouseCoopers and two of its audit partners. PricewaterhouseCoopers were the auditors of Celestial Nutrifoods Limited (“Celestial”) for the financial years 2004 to 2009. The respondent was Celestial’s liquidator. The respondent filed an application under s 285 of the Companies Act to compel the appellants to disclose documents in their custody, power or control relating to Celestial’s trade dealings, affairs and property. The respondent asserted that he needed the documents for a proper analysis of Celestial’s consolidated financial statements and year-end balances. These documents would enable him to reconstruct the financial records of Celestial and investigate various suspicious transactions he had uncovered. The application was allowed, and the appellants appealed (Celestial Nutrifoods at [2]).
- [35]
[35] For completeness, we also addressed the issue of whether permission to appeal was required as regards the Leave Orders. The Leave Orders were interlocutory orders as they did not dispose of any substantive rights of the parties and, ordinarily, permission would have been required to appeal them. However, as the Leave Orders had resulted in the Committal Orders being made, and the latter was appealable as of right, the question of permission to appeal the former was merely academic. The appropriate course for the Applicants to have taken was to appeal the Committal Orders.
Conclusion