Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 21 Jul 2025

Court of Appeal

Accepting that money paid into court is security did not mean agreeing it be paid out

Singapore Commodities Group Co, Pte Ltd v Founder Group (Hong Kong) L td (in liquidation)

Feedback & support

[2025] SGCA 35Case no. Court of Appeal / Civil Appeal No 47 of 2024

The decision, in one line

Not legal advice

Accepting that money paid into court is security did not mean agreeing it be paid out

Summary by laws.sgParagraphs [82], [88]

There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Facts

  2. [4] The appellant is Singapore Commodities Group Co, Pte Ltd (“SG Commodities”), a Singapore-incorporated company, and the respondent is Founder Group (Hong Kong) Limited (“Founder Group”). Founder Group is a company incorporated in the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (“HKSAR”).

  3. [5] Prior to 2020, both parties were part of a group of companies that was owned and controlled by Peking University Founder Group Company Limited (“PUFG”), a company incorporated in the People’s Republic of China (the “PRC”). In February 2020, reorganisation proceedings were commenced against PUFG in the Beijing First Immediate People’s Court. As part of the reorganisation process, a consortium of strategic investors for PUFG’s reorganisation was formed. These strategic investors acquired some of PUFG’s assets, including SG Commodities. SG Commodities henceforth fell under the ownership and control of the strategic investors, while Founder Group remained under the ultimate ownership of PUFG.

  4. The Alleged Debt and statutory demand

  5. [6] On 19 July 2021, Founder Group was wound up by a court of the HKSAR. On 18 October 2021, the liquidators of Founder Group (the “Liquidators”) were appointed. The Liquidators reviewed the company’s books and discovered that an amount of US$14,117,585.50 in trade debts (equivalent to HK$109,693,639.34 based on the prevailing exchange rate as at 1 December 2021) (the “Alleged Debt”) was purportedly due and payable by SG Commodities to Founder Group. The Alleged Debt was said to have arisen from a copper cathode purchase contract between the parties dated 17 December 2015 (the “Purchase Contract”), pursuant to which SG Commodities agreed to purchase 3,000 tonnes (+/- 5%) of copper cathodes from Founder Group. The existence of the Alleged Debt was said to also be evidenced by an invoice issued by Founder Group to SG Commodities in December 2015 for copper cathodes and two audit confirmations sent from SG Commodities’ auditors in Singapore and the PRC to Founder Group in January 2019.

  6. [7] On or around 1 December 2021, the Liquidators issued a letter to SG Commodities, demanding that the Alleged Debt be paid to Founder Group within 14 days. SG Commodities did not provide a response or make payment for the Alleged Debt.

  7. [8] On 18 February 2022, the Liquidators issued a statutory demand to SG Commodities pursuant to s 125 of the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (2020 Rev Ed) (the “IRDA”) for the sum of HK$109,580,698.65 (as at 11 February 2022) to be paid within 21 days (i.e., by 14 March 2022). The figure of HK$109,580,698.65 was equivalent to US$14,117,585.50 as at 11 February 2022.

  8. [9] On 7 March 2022, SG Commodities requested for copies of the audit confirmations and the underlying contractual documents in support of the Alleged Debt. The Liquidators provided SG Commodities with the relevant supporting documents one day later, and indicated that they would only be willing to give SG Commodities a one-week extension to respond to the statutory demand (i.e., by 21 March 2022). The parties subsequently attempted to negotiate a standstill of all legal proceedings against SG Commodities and amicably resolve the claim, but were ultimately unable to reach any resolution.

  9. [10] In this judgment, for easier comprehension, we will use the terms “Founder Group” and the “Liquidators” interchangeably, and any subsequent references to Founder Group taking a certain action or adopting a certain position must be read to refer to the Liquidators of Founder Group taking such action or adopting such position.

  10. The events leading to the payment of moneys into court

  11. [11] On 12 April 2022, SG Commodities filed a request for arbitration (the “Arbitration”) before the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission (“CIETAC”) pursuant to cl 13 of the Purchase Contract. Clause 13 was an arbitration clause which provided that the parties were to attempt to resolve all disputes in connection with the Purchase Contract or the performance of the Purchase Contract through friendly discussion, failing which, the controversy or claim should be submitted to CIETAC for arbitration, to be conducted in Beijing in accordance with CIETAC’s arbitration rules. Clause 13 further provided that the governing law of the Purchase Contract was PRC law.

  12. [12] In the Arbitration, SG Commodities sought declaratory relief that the Alleged Debt did not exist. SG Commodities disputed the existence of the Alleged Debt on two bases. First, that the Purchase Contract was “null and void” under Art 146 of the Civil Code of the PRC because the parties had no intention to buy or sell copper cathodes at the time the Purchase Contract was signed. Instead, the Purchase Contract was solely for the purposes of accounting arrangements and bookkeeping. Second, that Founder Group had never delivered any copper cathodes to SG Commodities under the Purchase Contract. Founder Group received a letter from CIETAC enclosing a copy of the request for arbitration on 10 May 2022.

  13. [14] The parties filed their written submissions for CWU 120 on 22 September 2022. SG Commodities disputed the existence of the Alleged Debt and further submitted that the winding-up application should be dismissed in light of the CIETAC arbitration clause. Founder Group took the contrary position that SG Commodities had already admitted to the Alleged Debt in terms of both liability and quantum, and that the available documentary evidence before the court proved the existence of the Alleged Debt. Accordingly, Founder Group argued that SG Commodities was abusing the process of the court by trying to get the winding-up application stayed or dismissed on the basis of the arbitration clause. Founder Group further asserted that, if one was to take SG Commodities’ case at its highest, i.e., that the Purchase Contract was null and void, that would mean that there was no valid arbitration agreement to justify a stay or dismissal of the winding-up application.

  14. [15] On 28 September 2022, before the hearing of CWU 120, SG Commodities applied for leave in HC/SUM 3591/2022 (“SUM 3591”) to provide security for Founder Group’s claim for the Alleged Debt by way of a payment of an equivalent sum of moneys into court (the “Sum”), pending the determination of CWU 120 and the ongoing Arbitration. In the affidavit filed in support of SUM 3591, SG Commodities took the position that, as it was willing to pay the equivalent sum of moneys into court to secure the disputed Alleged Debt, the Liquidators of Founder Group should not be allowed to rely on the claim to support the winding-up application in CWU 120.

  15. The Arbitration

  16. [19] During this period, the Arbitration proceedings were also underway. On 24 June 2022, Founder Group objected to the jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal (the “Tribunal”). The basis for Founder Group’s jurisdictional objection was that the entire premise of SG Commodities’ claim was that the Purchase Contract was fabricated and therefore the arbitration clause contained in the Purchase Contract was, on SG Commodities’ own case, invalid. The jurisdiction issue was eventually dealt with by the Tribunal together with the substantive merits of the claim.

  17. [20] On 14 March 2023, Founder Group submitted its defence in the Arbitration, which was stated to be without prejudice to its objections to the Tribunal’s jurisdiction. Significantly, Founder Group did not file a counterclaim in the Arbitration for a declaration that the Alleged Debt existed or any relief that SG Commodities had to pay the Alleged Debt.

  18. [21] The Arbitration hearing took place on 8 June 2023, and the arbitral award (the “Award”) was issued on 20 November 2023. In relation to the jurisdictional challenge, the Tribunal observed that Founder Group’s jurisdictional objection was premised on SG Commodities’ claim that the Purchase Contract was invalid. The Tribunal held that SG Commodities did not provide sufficient evidence or legal basis for its claim that it did not intend to sign the Purchase Contract and/or that some of the clauses in the Purchase Contract were invalid. Moreover, as the Purchase Contract had been “established and effective in accordance with the law”, it could form the basis for the Tribunal’s determination of the substantive rights and obligations of the parties. As the Purchase Contract was valid and could be used as the basis for the Tribunal’s determination of the rights and obligations of both parties, and Founder Group in fact believed that the contract was valid, the arbitration clause was effective. In any event, Art 19 of the Arbitration Law of the PRC provided that “the arbitration agreement exists independently, and the modification, rescission, termination or invalidity of the contract shall not affect the validity of the arbitration agreement”. For these reasons, the Tribunal held that it had jurisdiction over the dispute and dismissed the jurisdictional challenge.

  19. [22] Turning to the substantive merits of the case, the Tribunal held that SG Commodities had failed to provide sufficient evidence to prove its case that the Purchase Contract was signed solely for “accounts processing” purposes. The Tribunal therefore rejected SG Commodities’ request for declaratory relief that the Alleged Debt did not exist. However, the Tribunal also found that there was reason to doubt Founder Group’s case that the Purchase Contract had actually been performed and that there was a creditor-debtor relationship between the parties. This was because: (a) Founder Group had not submitted any relevant evidence regarding the delivery of the copper cathodes (such as a bill of lading or waybill) and had indicated that it was unclear about the delivery location, the country of origin of the copper cathodes and the quality of the copper cathodes purportedly delivered; (b) the Purchase Contract did not stipulate the delivery terms on which the contract price was based and Founder Group did not provide evidence to explain the delivery conditions of the purported delivery of the copper cathodes; and (c) the audit confirmation letters were insufficient to prove the existence of the Alleged Debt. The Tribunal thus had reason to doubt Founder Group’s claim that it had fulfilled its delivery obligations under the Purchase Contract.

  20. [23] In the result, the Tribunal expressly concluded that, while it rejected SG Commodities’ request for a declaration that the Alleged Debt did not exist, that did not mean that the Tribunal found in favour of, or made any ruling on, Founder Group’s position that the Alleged Debt existed. It was of particular importance that Founder Group had not raised a counterclaim in the Arbitration. In this regard, the material portion of the Award reads:

  21. The application for payment out of the moneys in court

  22. [25] On 18 January 2024, Founder Group responded and objected to the proposed orders. On the same day, Founder Group wrote to inform the court that the Tribunal had “rejected the reliefs sought by [SG Commodities]” and “refused to make a declaration that the [Alleged Debt] did not exist”. Founder Group further requested that the stay of CWU 120 be lifted and for the Sum to be released to itself.

  23. [26] Both parties agreed that the stay of CWU 120 should be lifted. On 1 February 2024, the Judge lifted the stay by consent, and gave directions regarding the filing of affidavits and written submissions for CWU 120. On 29 February 2024, Founder Group applied in HC/SUM 620/2024 for the Sum to be paid out to itself (the “Payment Out Application”).

  24. [28] In its affidavits and written submissions, SG Commodities’ position was that CWU 120 and the Payment Out Application ought to be dismissed. First, SG Commodities submitted that it was entitled to invoke the arbitration agreement between the parties, and that the Award was final and binding on both parties. As the Tribunal had upheld the validity of the arbitration clause, the present case was distinguishable from a separate winding-up application commenced by Founder Group against a related entity of SG Commodities, Singapore JHC Co Pte Ltd, which formed the subject of this court’s decision in Founder Group (Hong Kong) Ltd (in liquidation) v Singapore JHC Co Pte Ltd [2023] 2 SLR 554 (“Founder Group (CA)”). Second, the Award did not constitute a ruling that SG Commodities was liable to Founder Group for the Alleged Debt. SG Commodities relied on a legal opinion prepared by Zhong Lun Law Firm for its submission that, under PRC law, the Award did not find that it was more likely than not that the Alleged Debt existed. Accordingly, the Payment Out Application should be dismissed.

  25. [29] At the first hearing of CWU 120, counsel for Founder Group accepted that, if SG Commodities was correct that the Award did not conclusively determine the existence of the Alleged Debt, it was entirely open for Founder Group to commence fresh arbitration proceedings against SG Commodities in respect of the Alleged Debt. Founder Group’s counsel informed the Judge that, according to the advice of its PRC counsel, there would be no abuse of process concerns, akin to the type arising under the common law rule in Henderson v Henderson (1843) 67 ER 313, that would preclude Founder Group from commencing fresh arbitration proceedings against SG Commodities in relation to the Alleged Debt.

  26. [30] During the hearing, the Judge also raised certain queries as to the nature of the moneys paid into court and the justification for why Founder Group should receive full payment ahead of SG Commodities’ other unsecured creditors, if any. After the hearing, the Judge consolidated his concerns into a list of issues for the parties to address through further written submissions and at a further hearing. These issues raised can be briefly summarised as follows:

  27. (a) Assume that a claimant commences a winding-up application against a defendant in reliance on the presumption of insolvency arising from the defendant’s failure to satisfy a statutory demand, and the defendant disputes the claimant’s debt on substantial grounds and pays money into court to secure a stay of the winding-up application while it challenges the debt. If the defendant “fails in its challenge”, should the money paid into court be released to the claimant in satisfaction of its debt and, whether the payment out would operate to the prejudice of the defendant’s other creditors.

  28. (b) Whether Founder Group took the position that, if the Payment Out Application was dismissed and if the court declined to wind up SG Commodities on the just and equitable ground, there were reasons for the court to nevertheless allow the winding-up application on the basis that SG Commodities was insolvent.

  29. (c) Whether either party took the position that SG Commodities was insolvent in or after May 2024 and, if so, the justification for such a view.

  30. (d) Various clarifications pertaining to the burden of proof adopted by the Tribunal regarding: (i) the issue of whether the parties had entered into the Purchase Contract without an intention to perform it; and (ii) the issue of whether Founder Group had delivered the copper cathodes to SG Commodities, the nature of the Tribunal’s findings on those issues and the effect of the Tribunal’s findings on those issues in a potential future arbitration brought by Founder Group or in CWU 120, amongst other things.

  31. [31] As directed by the Judge, both parties subsequently filed further affidavits and further written submissions to address these issues.

  32. [32] Founder Group maintained its position that SG Commodities had failed to challenge the existence of the Alleged Debt in the Arbitration. Relying on two Hong Kong decisions, Founder Group submitted that the Sum was a “kind of security” for Founder Group’s claim. As SG Commodities had “failed in the Arbitration”, Founder Group was entitled to the payment out of the Sum, considering that SG Commodities was ostensibly cash flow solvent, and hence the payment out would not prejudice SG Commodities’ other creditors. Founder Group also argued that SG Commodities ought to be precluded from raising the same arguments which had already been rejected in the Award, and, as there was no remaining prima facie dispute to be referred to arbitration, CWU 120 should not be stayed or dismissed.

  33. [33] Founder Group also took the position that, in the event that the Payment Out Application was refused, SG Commodities should be wound up on the basis that it was deemed unable to pay its debts given that: (a) notwithstanding the payment of the Sum into court, SG Commodities had not satisfied or secured the statutory demand within the prescribed timeline under s 125(2)(a) of the IRDA; and (b) despite SG Commodities’ ostensible cash flow solvency, there remained material uncertainties regarding the company’s ability to carry on as a going concern. As a further alternative, Founder Group argued that SG Commodities should be wound up on just and equitable grounds arising from concerns as to the conduct of the company’s present management of its financial affairs and bookkeeping, the particulars of which are not of concern in this appeal.

  34. [34] As for the Award, Founder Group submitted that the Tribunal had found that the Purchase Contract was valid and binding under PRC law and that there was no evidence of the alleged “accounts processing”. These findings were binding and, thus, neither party might relitigate these issues in a future arbitration. However, Founder Group asserted that the Tribunal’s observations regarding the adequacy of the documentary evidence adduced by it regarding the Alleged Debt were merely obiter dicta and thus not binding in any future arbitration between the parties.

  35. The 19 July 2024 hearing

  36. [36] At the start of the hearing on 19 July 2024, Founder Group’s counsel, Mr Sarjit Singh Gill, SC (“Mr Gill SC”), informed the Judge that, if SG Commodities agreed to the Payment Out Application, Founder Group would apply for leave to withdraw CWU 120. Counsel for SG Commodities at the hearing, Mr Tan Chuan Thye, SC (“Mr Tan SC”), replied to say that he had no instructions to consent to this. He then set out SG Commodities’ position, namely, that: (a) SG Commodities accepted that the payment in of the Sum was security pending the outcome of the Arbitration; and (b) SG Commodities did not accept that the Tribunal had found that the Alleged Debt was established but accepted that it had “failed in the award”.

  37. [37] In response, Mr Gill SC submitted that SG Commodities had lost the Arbitration, and that implied that the Alleged Debt existed. Referring to local and English authorities, Mr Gill SC then asserted that there was a general principle that the moneys paid into court would be excluded from the general estate of the payor in an insolvency scenario. Alternatively, if the Payment Out Application was refused, Founder Group’s position was that SG Commodities should be wound up.

  38. [38] In his oral submissions, Mr Tan SC indicated that he would “keep [his] remarks reasonably brief and to the points … raised [by the Judge] to [Founder Group’s counsel]”. He began by addressing the issue, raised by the Judge, as to whether moneys paid into court could give rise to a security interest. Much of the submissions by Mr Tan SC was centred on his view that the payment in of the Sum did give rise to a security interest in Founder Group’s favour. From the transcript of the hearing, it appears that the Judge was questioning whether it was indeed the case that the Sum was security for Founder Group’s claim for the Alleged Debt. At one point, in the course of his submissions that the payment in of moneys into court could give rise to a security interest, Mr Tan SC said that SG Commodities did not object to the Sum being paid out to Founder Group because SG Commodities had its chance in the Arbitration to prove that the Alleged Debt did not exist, but had failed to discharge that burden.

  39. [39] It is fairly evident from our reading of the transcript of the hearing on 19 July 2024 that Mr Tan SC had set out his client’s position in a rather confusing and convoluted manner. This has resulted in much dispute in this appeal about what position SG Commodities took during the 19 July 2024 hearing and, more specifically, whether Mr Tan SC had abandoned the position taken in his written submissions and his client’s affidavits that the Payment Out Application should be dismissed. Given that this is a key issue arising in this appeal, we address this more fully in our analysis below.

  40. The Grounds of Decision below

  41. [42] The Judge issued his grounds of decision on 29 October 2024, which are set out in Founder Group (Hong Kong) Ltd (in liquidation) v Singapore Commodities Group Co, Pte Ltd [2024] SGHC 280 (the “GD”).

  42. [44] In addressing the first factor, the Judge observed that there were three broad purposes for which a litigant might pay money into court. These were: (a) as an offer of compromise; (b) as the price for seeking and obtaining a forensic advantage; or (c) pursuant to a specific procedural rule that expressly prescribed the sum paid into court as “security” (GD at [76]). The Judge took the view that it was only if the moneys paid into court was pursuant to a specific procedural rule that expressly prescribed the sum paid into court as “security” that the payment in would give rise to a true security interest. Absent a legislative mandate, no security interest could arise over moneys paid into court (GD at [78] and [131]). As the Sum was not paid into court pursuant to a procedural rule with such an express stipulation, the payment in of the Sum did not create a security interest in favour of Founder Group for the Alleged Debt (GD at [132]).

  43. The parties’ cases on appeal

  44. [50] Second, if the transcript of the 19 July 2024 hearing is closely examined, one could ascertain that Mr Tan SC did not concede that SG Commodities was abandoning its primary position that the Sum should not be paid out to Founder Group because Founder Group had not established its legal entitlement to the Alleged Debt in the Arbitration. The statement by Mr Tan SC that SG Commodities did not object to the Sum being paid out to Founder Group, since SG Commodities had lost the Arbitration, should be interpreted as having been made in the context of SG Commodities advancing its alternative case that, if the Judge disagreed with SG Commodities’ primary position, the Judge should allow the Payment Out Application instead of winding up SG Commodities because the Sum was “security” in favour of Founder Group. Third, if there was any such concession by Mr Tan SC, the court should grant permission to SG Commodities to withdraw that concession.

  45. [51] Founder Group argues that there was a clear concession by Mr Tan SC at the hearing on 19 July 2024 that the Sum should be paid out to Founder Group given that SG Commodities had failed in the Arbitration. It argues that SG Commodities’ attempt to resile from its earlier concession on appeal amounts to an abuse of process, and there is no legitimate reason to allow SG Commodities to withdraw its concession.

  46. Issues to be determined

  47. [54] From our review of the parties’ cases, there are three issues that arise for our consideration in this appeal:

  48. Whether the condition or conditions for the court to order the payment out of the Sum to Founder Group had been met

  49. The applicable statutory provision

  50. [58] The Judge held that, absent a provision in O 27 of the ROC 2021 providing for a defendant company in a winding-up application to pay money into court, the parties were agreed that the appellant paid the Sum into court pursuant to O 3 r 2(2) of the ROC 2021 (GD at [35]–[36]). SG Commodities argues for the first time, on appeal, that the applicable provision should be ss 128(2)(a) or 128(2)(f) of the IRDA instead. It is clear from the record that SG Commodities had ample opportunity to contest the applicability of O 3 r 2(2) in the hearing below. Nonetheless, as SG Commodities’ argument pertains solely to a point of law and not fact, we consider its merits.

  51. [59] We are of the view that the applicable statutory provision that would allow the payment of moneys into court, and payment out of moneys from court, in the context of corporate insolvency proceedings, is s 128(2)(f) of the IRDA. Winding-up proceedings against SG Commodities had already commenced at the time it sought to pay the Sum into court. As the insolvency proceedings had started, the operative statutory provision should be in the IRDA. Section 128(2)(f) of the IRDA provides that:

  52. The terms of the Payment In Order

  53. [70] Given that the Tribunal made no finding in the Award that SG Commodities had failed to pay Founder Group under the Purchase Contract, it must mean that Founder Group had failed to establish in the Arbitration that it had an entitlement to the Sum. In its application, Founder Group suggested that the Award may be interpreted as endorsing the existence of the Alleged Debt, but we find that this is contradicted by the plain and unambiguous statement in the Award that the Tribunal’s findings did not mean that the Tribunal supported or made any ruling on Founder Group’s claim. In short, we find that the Award provided no support for Founder Group’s position that it was entitled to payment.

  54. Whether SG Commodities had conceded at the 19 July 2024 hearing that the Sum should be paid out to Founder Group

  55. [75] Founder Group asserts that Mr Tan SC, as SG Commodities’ then counsel, had conceded its case on the Payment Out Application during the hearing on 19 July 2024, and/or that he had admitted that the Payment Out Application should be allowed. According to Founder Group, SG Commodities has attempted to change its position or resile from its earlier concession in this appeal, which amounts to an abuse of the process of the court.

  56. [76] SG Commodities disputes this. As already mentioned (at [50] above), its position is that, during the hearing on 19 July 2024, Mr Tan SC did not abandon its primary position that the Payment Out Application should be dismissed because there was no finding by the Tribunal that the Alleged Debt existed. The statements made by Mr Tan SC that SG Commodities did not object to the Payment Out Application should be understood as part of SG Commodities’ alternative position, that is, if the court disagreed with its primary position, the Judge should grant the Payment Out Application instead of winding up the company.

  57. [81] Reading this, we can discern that Mr Tan SC’s submission here was three-fold: (a) he accepted the authorities indicating that a payment of moneys into court gave rise to a security interest; (b) he had no instructions to consent to the Payment Out Application; and (c) SG Commodities did not accept that the Award established the existence of the Alleged Debt, but agreed that it had not succeeded in its application for declaratory relief in the Arbitration.

  58. [82] In our view, the submissions by Mr Tan SC in this passage do not show that SG Commodities had consented to the Payment Out Application. Mr Tan SC had only accepted the legal proposition that a defendant’s payment of a sum into court conferred a security interest over that sum in favour of the claimant. But the fact that the moneys paid into court are secured for a party’s benefit does not necessarily mean that the moneys should be paid out to that party no matter what the circumstances may be. As explained above, the crucial question in an application for the payment out of moneys held in court is whether the condition (or conditions) for payment out is satisfied. The fact that Founder Group may have acquired a security interest over the Sum by SG Commodities paying the moneys into court does not necessarily mean that the condition for payment out is fulfilled. Mr Tan SC’s acceptance of the weight of the authorities was therefore only limited to the issue of whether the payment in of the Sum gave rise to a security interest and did not extend to an acceptance that the Payment Out Application should be granted.

  59. [84] The second passage is reproduced in full below:

  60. [85] The Judge observed that, in this passage, Mr Tan SC had submitted that SG Commodities did not have a claim to the Sum because it did not succeed in the Arbitration (GD at [145]). However, it is apparent to us that Mr Tan SC had qualified that this was SG Commodities’ alternative position, albeit somewhat ineptly. We acknowledge that the way Mr Tan SC addressed the Judge’s queries made his submissions unclear, and this led to confusion and ultimately, misunderstanding. Mr Tan SC had initially stated that this was SG Commodities’ “primary position” but later corrected that this was instead its “alternate” position. Given that this clarification was almost immediate, we do not think that this amounted to a clear and express abandonment of the position previously taken by SG Commodities in its written submissions and affidavits. In those submissions, SG Commodities had indicated that its primary position was that the Payment Out Application should be dismissed, but that in the event the court disagreed with its interpretation of the Award, the Payment Out Application should be allowed instead of granting the winding-up application. In our view, it is patently apparent that SG Commodities’ main concern was that the Judge might decide to wind up the company in CWU 120, and this was the outcome it was trying to avoid.

  61. [86] The exchange in the third passage occurred shortly after the second passage. In response to SG Commodities’ (alternative) submission that the Payment Out Application may be allowed, the Judge queried whether the Tribunal’s mere refusal to find that the Alleged Debt did not exist was a sufficient basis to grant the Payment Out Application. To this, Mr Tan SC stated that SG Commodities did not object to the payment out of the Sum to Founder Group because SG Commodities had failed to discharge its burden of proof in the Arbitration:

  62. [87] Given that this exchange followed closely after the discussion in the second passage, our view is that the statement by Mr Tan SC that his client did not object to the Payment Out Application should be understood as an elaboration of SG Commodities’ alternative position.

  63. [88] In the final analysis, after having reviewed the entire transcript of the proceedings before of the Judge on 19 July 2024, we do not agree that the above passages, when read in context, showed that Mr Tan SC, on behalf of SG Commodities, had unequivocally abandoned its primary position that the Payment Out Application should be dismissed. SG Commodities therefore cannot be said to be abusing the process of the court in adopting its present position in this appeal. Further, as SG Commodities did not concede its case on the Payment Out Application, this is not a basis for granting of the Payment Out Application. Given our views as expressed above, that is, that there was no concession by Mr Tan SC of SG Commodities’ primary position at the hearing on 19 July 2024, no issue of the withdrawal of concession arises for our decision.

  64. Conclusion and orders made

  65. [92] In so far as Founder Group continues to rely on the Alleged Debt as a basis to wind up SG Commodities in CWU 120, a material consideration is that the Alleged Debt remains disputed. As we have explained above, the Award did not lead to a resolution of the dispute over the existence of the Alleged Debt. In Pacific Recreation Pte Ltd v S Y Technology Inc and another appeal [2008] 2 SLR(R) 491 (“Pacific Recreation”) and AnAn Group (Singapore) Pte Ltd v VTB Bank (Public Joint Stock Co) [2020] 1 SLR 1158 (“AnAn”), this court set out the approach a court should adopt when faced with a winding-up application where there is a dispute as to the defendant company’s indebtedness. These principles were recently re-affirmed in Founder Group (CA). In short, if the defendant company has raised triable issues, by showing that there exists a substantial and bona fide dispute in relation to a cross-claim or the existence of the debt, the insolvency court cannot determine the underlying dispute and will typically dismiss or, exceptionally, stay the winding-up application (Pacific Recreation at [23] and [25]; Founder Group (CA) at [28(a)]). If the liability is contested but the dispute is not raised in good faith or disputed on substantial grounds, the application to wind up the defendant company may be granted, subject to the statutorily stipulated conditions for winding up being satisfied (Founder Group (CA) at [28(b)]). If, however, the disputed debt is subject to an arbitration agreement, the prima facie standard should apply such that the winding-up proceedings will be stayed or dismissed as long as: (a) there is a valid arbitration agreement between the parties, and (b) the dispute falls within the scope of the arbitration agreement (AnAn at [56]). If satisfied, the court will in most cases dismiss the winding-up application, provided that the dispute is not being raised by the defendant company in abuse of the court’s process (AnAn at [110]).

  66. [93] In deciding CWU 120, it will be necessary to determine the validity of the arbitration agreement in the Purchase Contract and whether the dispute over the Alleged Debt falls within the scope of the arbitration agreement (see [92] above). In examining these issues, one key consideration is whether Founder Group is precluded by the doctrine of issue estoppel from taking certain positions regarding the arbitration agreement, given the Tribunal’s rejection of Founder Group’s argument that the arbitration agreement was invalid, and the Tribunal’s findings as to the validity of the arbitration agreement and whether the dispute over the Alleged Debt falls within the scope of the arbitration agreement.

  67. Further observations about the Payment In Order

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.