Court of Appeal · Decided 3 March 2026
The appellant was given weeks to pay the sums owed or its appeal would be struck out
Owner of the vessel(s) “CHLOE V” v UBS AG
Feedback & support[2026] SGCA 7 · Case no. Court of Appeal / Civil Appeal No 26 of 2025 (Summons No 32 of 2025) · 17 paragraphs
✱ The decision, in one line
Not legal advice
The appellant was given weeks to pay the sums owed or its appeal would be struck out
Summary by laws.sg·Paragraphs [51], [55]
There is no fuller plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
Introduction
Procedural history
- [4]
[4] On 18 September 2021, the respondent commenced HC/ADM 102/2021 (“ADM 102”) against the Vessel. The respondent’s claim was for outstanding sums due under a Facilities Agreement dated 26 June 2019 (the “Facilities Agreement”) entered between the parties, which was secured by a mortgage on the Vessel. On 15 October 2021, the respondent proceeded to enforce its mortgage by arresting the Vessel.
- [5]
[5] On 29 September 2021, the appellant entered an appearance in ADM 102 and filed a counterclaim, in which it alleged that the respondent had breached an implied term and/or duty to not prevent the appellant from performing its obligation, to act rationally in exercising its discretion, and/or to not unreasonably withhold any approval which it may give under the Facilities Agreement. In particular, the appellant relied on the respondent’s refusal to grant the appellant’s request for a Letter of Quiet Enjoyment, which allegedly scuppered the appellant’s negotiations for a new charterparty with Koch Supply and Trading Pte Ltd.
- [6]
[6] On 18 November 2021, Justice S Mohan (the “Judge”) ordered that the Vessel be appraised and sold pendente lite by the court. The Vessel was subsequently sold for US$42,100,000 and the sum of US$42,933,184.45 (the proceeds from the sale of the Vessel and the bunkers onboard) was paid into court on 26 January 2022 (the “Sale Proceeds”).
- [7]
[7] The respondent then applied for summary judgment against the appellant viz HC/SUM 5945/2021 (“SUM 5945”). On 21 March 2022, Assistant Registrar Paul Tan (“AR Tan”) granted judgment in favour of the respondent for the sum of US$43,586,317.36, along with interest. Notably, the Sale Proceeds were insufficient to satisfy the respondent’s judgment debt.
The appellant’s delay in furnishing security for costs for its counterclaim
- [11]
[11] Instead of furnishing the security as ordered, the appellant appealed against AR Seow’s decision viz HC/RA 304/2022 (“RA 304”) which was heard and dismissed by the Judge on 14 November 2022. The appellant was granted a time extension to furnish the security within 14 days, ie, by 28 November 2022.
- [12]
[12] Even then, the appellant failed to meet the extended deadline. On 28 November 2022, the appellant filed HC/SUM 4267/2022 (“SUM 4267”), which was an application for a variation of the order to furnish security to include the option of providing a solicitor’s undertaking, as well as another time extension of three weeks (until 19 December 2022). The application was heard by Assistant Registrar Vikram Raja Rajaram on 21 December 2022, and he granted only the time extension. He also made the following observations:
- [13]
[13] It was on 29 December 2022 – more than three months after AR Seow’s decision – that the appellant finally paid the sum of S$265,000 into court.
The appellant’s refusal to comply with various costs orders
However, the respondent pointed out that Clause 34.5 applied to any payments received against amounts due under the Finance Documents (as defined in the Facilities Agreement), and not to the payment of outstanding costs incurred by a borrower in the course of defending and/or prosecuting an action.
- [18]
[18] In the circumstances, the respondent applied for payment out of the security held in court viz HC/SUM 2422/2023. On 30 August 2023, the Judge, who heard the application, ordered S$21,953.53 to be paid out to the respondent. As of 20 November 2025, S$243,046.67 represents the balance sum from the S$265,000 paid into court.
Further security for costs for the appellant’s counterclaim
The appellant’s refusal to pay costs for its counterclaim
- [25]
[25] On 11 December 2025, the respondent’s solicitors wrote to the appellant’s solicitors, stating that:
(a) S$60,000 had been applied towards the accrued interest and part-payment of the outstanding costs.
(b) Even after the respondent receives the amount of security for costs held in court (S$243,046.67), this would not be sufficient to satisfy the outstanding costs order.
(c) The respondent demands for “immediate and full payment of all sums owing under [the outstanding costs order]”. This was calculated to be S$633,510.24, £85,900, US$83,626.76 and CHF 93,875.12.
Again, the appellant did not respond.
- [26]
[26] The events described at [21]–[25] above took place after the appellant had filed CA 26 on 23 September 2025 against the decision in The “CHLOE V”. On 26 December 2025, the respondent filed the present application.
Application for stay or dismissal pending payment of outstanding costs
Applicable law
- [28]
[28] The substance of O 92 r 4 of the ROC 2014 can now be found in O 3 r 2(2) of the ROC 2021, which states:
The appeal should be stayed pending the appellant’s payment of the outstanding costs
(a) First, the respondent has not provided any calculation to show how this figure is derived.
(b) Second, the respondent should have given credit for the security which the appellant has already provided (S$303,046.47, comprising the balance sum of S$243,046.67 held in court and S$60,000 in the form of a solicitor’s letter of undertaking). Without taking interest into account, only S$386,939.06 remains outstanding from the appellant.
(c) Third, the respondent’s calculation of S$633,510.24 is incorrect. According to the appellant:
- [41]
[41] The appellant submits that, in these circumstances, it was reasonable “to await proper quantification rather than make a payment on the basis of an inflated or uncertain figure to avoid overpayment/underpayment”.
- [42]
[42] We find the appellant’s explanation to be entirely contrived for the following reasons.
- [43]
[43] First, it cannot be said that the respondent did not provide any calculation to show how its figure was derived. On 11 December 2025, the respondent’s solicitors provided the appellant with a breakdown of its start and end dates, the total number of days calculated, the interest rate applied, the interest accrued in the respective original currencies, the exchange rate for the foreign currencies and the interest accrued in the local currency. Given this information, which we think is sufficient, the appellant cannot claim that it was unable to understand how the respondent’s figure was arrived at.
- [44]
[44] Second, the appellant’s position – stated unequivocally in the affidavit of Mr Alexandros Lamprinakis, the appellant’s in-house legal counsel – was that it only took issue with the respondent’s calculation of the sum of S$633,510.24, and not the sums in foreign currencies. As such, there was no reason not to repay the amounts that were not disputed. We also add that: (a) the discrepancy between the parties’ calculations was quite minor and did not offer any credible reason to withhold the payment entirely; and (b) it is in any event the appellant who has erred in its calculation: applying the appellant’s own formula above (at [40(c)]), the figure it should have arrived at is S$2,216.65, not S$2,229.62.
(a) First, we calculated the interest accrued from each component of the outstanding costs order for the 22-day period from 11 November to 3 December 2025:
(b) Next, we converted the accrued interest in foreign currency to Singapore dollars:
(c) We then applied the S$60,000 received from the appellant’s solicitors to settle the accrued interest (amounting in total to S$3,524.71), resulting in a balance of S$56,475.29. This balance was then applied to partially satisfy the principal of the outstanding costs order, resulting in a balance of S$633,510.24, £85,900, US$83,626.76 and CHF 93,875.12 in outstanding costs.
(d) Finally, we applied the S$243,046.67 held in court to partially satisfy the principal of the outstanding costs order, resulting in a final balance of S$390,463.57, £85,900, US$83,626.76 and CHF 93,875.12 in outstanding costs.
- [51]
[51] If the appellant fails or omits to make payment of the sum of S$390,463.57, £85,900, US$83,626.76 and CHF 93,875.12 to the respondent within the four weeks period, CA 26 is deemed to be struck out automatically.
Application for further security
Conclusion
- [55]
[55] In the result, we allow the present application without an oral hearing and make the following orders:
(a) The balance security of S$243,046.67 held in court shall be released to the respondents forthwith in partial satisfaction of the outstanding cost order.
(b) The appellant is ordered to provide additional security for the appeal in the sum of S$100,000 within four weeks from the date hereof.
(c) CA 26 is hereby stayed for four weeks from the date hereof pending payment of the balance outstanding costs in the sum of S$390,463.57, £85,900, US$83,626.76 and CHF 93,875.12 and the provision of the additional security of S$100,000. If the appellant fails or omits to make payment of the said sum to the respondent or provide the additional security within the four-week period, CA 26 is deemed to be struck out automatically.
(d) The appellant is ordered to pay the respondent the costs of this application fixed in the sum of S$31,052.70 (inclusive of disbursements) forthwith.