Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 12 Feb 2020

Court of Appeal

Senda International Capital Ltd v Kiri Industries Ltd and others

Feedback & support

[2020] SGCA(I) 01Case no. Civil Appeal No 23 of 201925 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] These appeals arose out of the breakdown of a joint venture between the appellant, Senda International Capital Ltd (“Senda”), and the first respondent, Kiri Industries Ltd (“Kiri”). Together, Senda and Kiri own virtually the entire issued share capital of DyStar Global Holdings (Singapore) Pte Ltd (“DyStar”), the sixth respondent. After disputes arose, Kiri sued Senda for minority oppression in the running of DyStar, and Senda counterclaimed for breaches of the shareholders’ agreement.

  3. Facts

  4. [4] The facts have been set out in detail in our decision in Senda International Capital Ltd v Kiri Industries Ltd and others and another appeal [2019] 2 SLR 1 (“Main Judgment (CA)”), which is the decision on the appeal against the Main Judgment. For the purposes of this judgment, only very brief details of this case will be repeated.

  5. [5] Kiri is a publicly listed company in India and is a well-established player internationally in the dye industry. The managing director of the company is Manishkumar Pravinchandra Kiri (“Mr Manish”), the second respondent. Senda is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Zhejiang Longsheng Group Co Ltd (“Longsheng”), a listed company incorporated in China. Longsheng is also well-known in the business of making and selling dyes. Mr Ruan Weixiang (“Mr Ruan”) is the Chairman and General Manager of Longsheng.

  6. The joint venture

  7. [6] Before Kiri and Longsheng’s involvement in DyStar, there existed a group of companies (“the Pre-Acquisition DyStar”) which was prominent in the dye business. The Pre-Acquisition DyStar was hit by the 2009 global economic crisis. Kiri saw an opportunity. In 2009, Kiri incorporated DyStar and signed an asset purchase agreement with the insolvency administrators of the Pre-Acquisition DyStar. Under this agreement, DyStar was to buy selected assets of the Pre-Acquisition DyStar.

  8. [7] Kiri, however, needed funding to complete the purchase of the Pre-Acquisition DyStar. Mr Manish therefore discussed with Mr Ruan the possibility of Longsheng investing in DyStar. Following that, Well Prospering Limited (“WPL”), a wholly-owned subsidiary of Longsheng, and Kiri executed a term sheet. It provided for an investment from WPL of €22m comprising equity of €3m and debt under a compulsory convertible zero-coupon bond of €19m issued by DyStar. WPL would have an 18.75% shareholding in DyStar before the conversion of the bond. Kiri would subscribe €13m and would hold 81.25% of the shares in DyStar.

  9. [8] Subsequently, Kiri and Longsheng signed two documents: (a) the Share Subscription and Shareholders Agreement (“the SSSA”); and (b) the Convertible Bond Subscription Agreement. Under these two agreements, WPL would provide funding as follows:

  10. (a) WPL would subscribe for one ordinary share in DyStar at a price of S$10, and a €22m convertible zero-coupon bond issued by DyStar that could be converted into ordinary shares of DyStar;

  11. (b) the convertible bond would have a maturity period of five years and seven days during which the debt could be converted to equity at any time; and

  12. (c) WPL would be entitled to convert all or part of the principal amount outstanding under the convertible bond at S$10 per DyStar share. Any part of the outstanding principal amount not converted into shares would be redeemed by DyStar.

  13. [9] In February 2010, Longsheng appointed three directors (“the Longsheng Directors”) to the DyStar board of directors (“the Board”) while Kiri appointed two directors (“the Kiri Directors”). Thereafter, Longsheng controlled the Board through the Longsheng Directors. Selected assets of the Pre-Acquisition DyStar were eventually acquired by DyStar on 4 February 2010. For the acquisition of DyStar, Kiri invested €13m and arranged for bank finance of €65m. The bank finance, as well as the investment of €22m from Longsheng were guaranteed by Kiri. Those were Kiri’s financial contributions to DyStar.

  14. [10] The first Board meeting took place on 5 March 2010. At this meeting, Mr Manish was appointed Chairman of the Board. Two days later, the Board resolved that Mr Ruan be appointed as its co-Chairman. Mr Ruan then gave an assurance that Longsheng would do its best to provide financial support to DyStar, while Mr Manish emphasised that Kiri could not provide any further financial support for DyStar. On 25 May 2012, Mr Manish stepped down as co-Chairman of the Board, but he remained a director.

  15. [11] On 14 July 2012, the Board passed a resolution approving the transfer of the convertible bond from WPL to Senda. On 26 December 2012, Senda converted all the debt under the convertible bond into equity. This conversion made Senda the majority shareholder of DyStar: Senda held 4,359,520 shares in DyStar, equivalent to about 62.43% of the total number of shares, while WPL held one share, and Kiri held 2,623,354 shares, equivalent to about 37.57% of the total number of shares.

  16. The breakdown in relationship and the ensuing litigation

  17. [12] Kiri’s unhappiness with Senda began after the conversion. In SICC Suit No 4 of 2017 (“Suit 4”), Kiri claimed that Senda had engaged in a sustained course of commercially unfair conduct and detailed many instances of alleged oppressive conduct. The Judges found that the following instances of oppressive conduct had been established:

  18. (a) Senda caused DyStar to enter into various transactions with Longsheng and Longsheng-related entities contrary to DyStar’s commercial interests (including, as described below, the Related Party Loans);

  19. (b) Senda caused DyStar to make a payment to Mr Ruan of US$2m in 2014 (“the Special Incentive Payment”);

  20. (c) Senda caused DyStar to assign a patent to Longsheng on the basis that such assignment would be temporary but Longsheng thereafter wrongly retained and exploited the patent;

  21. (d) Senda caused DyStar to make payment of substantial fees in 2015 to Longsheng and to make a provision for substantial fees in 2016 for alleged services and support provided by Longsheng to DyStar (“the 2016 Longsheng Fees” and collectively, “the Longsheng Fees”);

  22. (e) Senda caused Kiri and the Kiri Directors to be excluded from meaningful participation in the management of DyStar’s business; and

  23. (f) Senda prevented Kiri from enjoying the benefits of its investment in DyStar as a shareholder by refusing to have the DyStar Board declare a dividend for 2014.

  24. [14] In Suit 4, Senda counterclaimed against Kiri and its related parties for breaches of the non-compete and non-solicitation clause (cl 15) in the SSSA, and for the tort of lawful and/or unlawful means conspiracy. At the same time as Suit 4 was commenced, DyStar commenced SICC Suit No 3 of 2017 (“Suit 3”) against Kiri and its related parties. DyStar claimed, inter alia, for the same breaches of the non-compete and non-solicitation clause in the SSSA as those in the counterclaim in Suit 4. The Judges held that only one instance of breach of cl 15, in relation to one of DyStar’s customers, called FOTL, was established (Main Judgment at [321]). They decided that the breach was only by Kiri and not by its related parties. Senda and DyStar appealed against the Main Judgment in Civil Appeal No 122 of 2018 (“CA 122”) and Civil Appeal No 126 of 2018 (“CA 126”) respectively.

  25. [15] After the Judges delivered their decisions in Suits 3 and 4, they directed that a case management conference (“CMC”) be held. At the CMC on 23 November 2018, parties submitted on the following issues:

  26. (a) whether the valuation of Kiri’s shareholding should be undertaken by (A) the court, (B) a valuer appointed by the court or the parties, or (C) some other method and, if so, what method;

  27. (b) whether a discount should be factored into the valuation of Kiri’s shareholding given that Kiri was a minority shareholder and, if so, how this should be assessed in the valuation process (the “Minority Discount Issue”);

  28. (d) how (if at all) the court’s rulings allowing part of DyStar’s claims in Suit 3 and Senda’s counterclaim in Suit 4 might affect the valuation of Kiri’s shareholding (“the Counterclaim Issue”);

  29. (e) the process and procedure for assessment of the loss caused by the various acts of oppression by Senda we had found; and

  30. The Judges delivered oral grounds of decision on these issues on 8 January 2019 (“Oral GD”) and issued their written grounds of decision on 12 March 2019, in Kiri Industries Ltd v Senda International Capital Ltd and another [2019] SGHC(I) 02 (“Written GD”). At the time of the Oral GD and the Written GD, the appeal against the Main Judgment had not been heard.

  31. Decision below

  32. [18] On the Minority Discount Issue, the Judges held that a minority discount (for lack of control) should not be factored into the valuation of Kiri’s shareholding. The separate question of a discount, if any, due to a lack of marketability on the basis that DyStar is a privately held company was left to be determined as part of the valuation of Kiri’s shareholding. This part of the decision has not been appealed against.

  33. [19] The Judges held that there was no presumption or general rule as to when a minority discount ought to be applied to a company, such as DyStar, that was not a quasi-partnership. They held that in such cases, the court had to adopt a fact-sensitive approach (Written GD at [11]). The Judges found two facts particularly relevant in coming to their decision that no minority discount should be awarded. First, Senda’s oppressive conduct was directed at worsening the position of Kiri as shareholder so as to compel it to sell out: the SICC considered that the common thread connecting Senda’s commercially unfair actions was that they were designed to extract benefits or value from DyStar for Senda at the expense of Kiri (Written GD at [12]–[14]). Second, Senda’s oppressive conduct was entirely responsible for the breakdown in the parties’ relationship and the result could not be attributed in any way to the actions of Kiri or the Kiri Directors (Written GD at [15]).

  34. [20] The Judges did not consider it appropriate or necessary for Senda to adduce further evidence for the purpose of the Minority Discount Issue (Written GD at [16]). Senda had sought to introduce further evidence on the parties’ respective contributions to DyStar, Kiri’s conduct as a shareholder including conduct not raised at the trial, whether Kiri was an unwilling seller, whether the oppressive conduct was directed at worsening the position of Kiri as a shareholder so as to compel it to sell out or was motivated by other considerations, and whether Kiri’s conduct contributed to the oppressive conduct complained of. The Judges found that these matters were within the issues canvassed at trial and were dealt with in the Main Judgment. For instance, on the parties’ respective contributions to DyStar, the thrust of Senda’s defence in relation to certain conduct alleged by Kiri to be oppressive was precisely that such conduct was justified because of Senda’s contributions to DyStar since 2010 (Written GD at [17]).

  35. [21] On the Counterclaim Issue, the Judges disagreed with Senda that a 20% discount should be applied to the value of Kiri’s shareholding on the basis of cl 16 of the SSSA. Clause 16 of the SSSA states:

  36. (b) In respect of Suit 3, as against Kiri, DyStar was entitled to 10% of the costs of its claim. While DyStar succeeded in some respects in its claims against Kiri, it failed in establishing most of its allegations, in particular, as regards breaches of the non-compete and non-solicitation clauses in the SSSA. As DyStar had failed entirely in its claims against the other defendants to Suit 3, the other defendants were entitled to have their costs paid by DyStar.

  37. The parties’ cases on appeal

  38. [25] On the issue of the minority discount, Senda first submits that the Judges erred in disallowing further evidence on whether a minority discount should be awarded. This is because the Main Judgment only dealt with the question of liability of Senda and the question of whether to apply a minority discount was not an issue. The determination of whether a minority discount should be applied depends on all the circumstances of the case, going beyond simply whether the majority had acted unfairly. Not all relevant evidence was before the court at the liability stage to determine whether a minority discount should be applied.

  39. [27] On the other hand, Kiri supports the Judges’ assessment that all the relevant evidence in respect of the matters was before the Judges. Kiri points out that the factors based on evidence of whether the alleged oppressive conduct was directed at worsening Kiri’s position as a shareholder so as to compel it to sell out and evidence of Kiri’s conduct contributing to the oppressive conduct complained of clearly relate to the main issue at the liability trial of whether there was minority oppression. Kiri submits that the Judges did consider the entire factual matrix of the case and specifically stated that the matters which Senda sought to adduce evidence of “were within the issues canvassed at trial, and were dealt with in the Main Judgment” (Written GD at [16]). Kiri avers that Senda had already relied on evidence of the parties’ relative contributions in its submissions both before the Judges and the Court of Appeal in CA 122. Evidence of Kiri’s attempted sale of its shares in DyStar to the State General Reserve Fund (“Reserve Fund”) was also before the trial court and formed part of the matters considered in the Main Judgment.

  40. (b) whether the minority shareholder has received any dividends: Re McCarthy Surfacing Ltd Hecquet v McCarthy [2009] BCC 464 at [100]–[101].

  41. Discussion and Decision

  42. The Minority Discount Issue

  43. The Preliminary issue

  44. [33] As stated earlier, the preliminary issue canvassed by the parties was whether the Judges should have admitted further evidence before deciding whether or not a minority discount was to be applied. Senda argues that the Judges should have allowed further evidence to be adduced on Kiri’s acquisition of the shares, other instances of Kiri acting with unclean hands, the parties’ respective contributions to DyStar between 2010 and 2018, and the circumstances surrounding Kiri’s attempts to sell its shares (ie, whether it was a willing seller). Such evidence, according to Senda, would not have been directly relevant to defeating an allegation of oppressive conduct but would have been wholly relevant to the question of applying a minority discount.

  45. [34] On this point, we agree with the Judges that the matters on which Senda seeks to adduce further evidence were within the issues canvassed at trial and were dealt with in the Main Judgment even if as Senda now asserts they were not directly relevant to proving oppression. We note that at the trial of liability, Senda highlighted its extensive financial contributions to justify some of its oppressive acts, such as the Related Party Loans, the Special Incentive Payment and the Longsheng Fees. In this regard, it introduced evidence on its contributions to DyStar: for example, Mr Viktor in his affidavit produced a table detailing the amount of direct loans, entrusted loans, advance payments received through triangle business, amount of guaranteed loans and amount of cash guarantee provided by Longsheng and its related entities over the years from 2010 to 2016. Kiri’s confirmation of its inability to provide financial support to Dystar after its initial injection of capital, was also in evidence. Senda relied on the significant disparity in the financial contributions made by Senda and Kiri in its written submissions submitted for the CMC, and in its submissions to us in CA 122. While in its submissions at the CMC, Senda contended that full evidence on the extent of its contributions had not been adduced, we agree with the Judges that sufficient evidence has been adduced on the existence of the relative contributions. The relevant evidence on the issue of whether Kiri is a “willing seller”, such as its attempt to sell its shares in DyStar to the Reserve Fund, has also been adduced. Thus, we see no reason to intervene regarding the Judges’ holding that no further evidence was required.

  46. Minority discount – substantive points

  47. [35] In the recent appellate decision of Thio Syn Pyn v Thio Syn Kym Wendy and others and another appeal [2019] 1 SLR 1065 (“Wendy Thio CA”), this court established that there is no presumption that a discount applies in the context of non-quasi-partnerships, and the court has to “look at all the facts and circumstances of the case in arriving at its decision” (at [19], [25], [32] and [33]). The holding of the lower court to this effect, on which the Judges here had relied, was approved (see Thio Syn Pyn CA at [19]).

  48. [39] Our decision is fortified by the consideration that Kiri’s misconduct will be accounted for in the damages that Kiri would have to pay for its breaches of the SSSA. The amount assessed as damages would be paid to DyStar and, given that DyStar would, after the buy-out, be a fully-owned beneficiary of Senda, such payment would constitute a benefit entirely to Senda.

  49. [42] Senda avers that even on the existing state of evidence, a minority discount should be applied in consideration of the following additional factors not considered by the Judges:

  50. (a) the minority acted in a way that deserved its exclusion from the company;

  51. (b) the minority had acquiesced over the years in the majority’s mode of management and did not contribute to the growth of the business in any substantial or meaningful way;

  52. (c) the value of the company had increased so substantially during the period when the petitioners had played no part in its management; and

  53. (d) whether a petitioner would be over-compensated for the oppressive conduct of the majority.

  54. [43] We do not see any merit in the submissions recounted in [42] above. We have already dealt with the first point. As for the others, it was Senda’s position in the trial that Kiri was only expected to play a “limited role” in DyStar’s management and that was why it was justified in withholding information. Having taken that stand it cannot now say a minority discount should be applied for lack of management participation. More substantially, however, as Kiri submits, it did play an active role in management for some time up to 2012. Mr Viktor testified that Kiri had provided critical support to DyStar. In any event, there was no evidence that thereafter Senda complained about Kiri taking a back seat. Indeed, it excluded Kiri from management in that it did not seek Kiri’s input on certain transactions and as we stated at [137] of the Main Judgement (CA) it “obstructed the Kiri Directors’ discharge of their functions as directors”.

  55. [44] In our view, having taken (or attempted to take) considerable value out of DyStar via the Lonsheng Fees, the Related Party Loans and the Special Incentive Payment, it does not lie in Senda’s mouth to complain that a minority discount should apply because it was the efforts of the majority rather than those of the minority that led to the great increase in DyStar’s value. There is no justification on the facts of this case for concluding that Kiri would obtain a windfall if a minority discount is not applied.

  56. The Costs Issue

  57. Conclusion