Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 21 Jun 2021

Court of Appeal

CBX and another v CBZ and others

Feedback & support

[2021] SGCA(I) 4Case no. Civil Appeal No 197 of 20203 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Background

  3. [4] The proceedings were then re-designated as SIC/OS 1/2020. At the time of the transfer, parties had already filed their first round of affidavits. Thereafter, four further affidavits were filed and both parties put in written submissions before proceeding to the hearing. The proceedings were heard before the learned International Judge (“the Judge”) over several hours on the morning of 15 June 2020 and his decision, CBX and another v CBZ and others [2020] 5 SLR 184 (“the Merits Judgment”), was delivered on 16 July 2020.

  4. The appeals

  5. The applicable costs regimes

  6. [9] A different approach is taken in SICC cases. As can be seen, Rule 46 is much less prescriptive – no numerical ranges are specified, instead, the general rule as laid down in Rule 46(1) is:

  7. Thus, the question of amount of costs that a successful party should recover is at large and the judge is tasked to determine what is “reasonable”, a determination which can be guided by many factors moving far beyond the type of proceeding, the number of hearing hours and the kind of transcription service employed (though these factors will also be relevant, of course). It would immediately be appreciated that when a case started in the High Court (and thereby subject to Appendix G in relation to costs) is transferred to the SICC, the costs implications of such transfer may be of concern to the parties to the action as the losing party may no longer be able to rely on Appendix G as of right to influence the quantum of costs awarded.

  8. The grounds and the challenge

  9. (a) Whether the Judge erred in finding that Appendix G would not (at least) be applicable to costs incurred pre-transfer of proceedings to the SICC;

  10. (b) Whether the Judge erred in entirely disregarding the guidance of Appendix G in assessing the reasonableness of costs incurred post-transfer to the SICC; and

  11. (c) Whether the Judge erred in finding that the sum of $150,000 (all-in) was “reasonable” in the circumstances.

  12. The first two issues engage points of principle whilst the third relates to the exercise of the Judge’s discretion. Before we consider the first two issues, we will set out the Judge’s reasoning which led him to the conclusions that are now challenged.

  13. [16] At this stage, we will not discuss the factors that the Judge took into account in concluding that $150,000 was a reasonable figure. We consider that the issues of principle must be resolved before the issue of quantum can be handled.

  14. Our decision

  15. The IJ then went on to take Appendix G as a starting point in his assessment of the costs. He decided that in the case before him it was not appropriate to depart from Appendix G and he also emphasised, towards the end of his judgment (at [20]), that it was “not necessarily the case that the reasonable costs approach posited in CPIT [would] yield a different result” from that obtained by reference to Appendix G.

  16. BYL (Costs) and our views

  17. Quantum

  18. Conclusion