Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 9 Mar 2026

District Court

Zeus Matisse v ESA Security Pte. Ltd.

Feedback & support

[2026] SGDC 82Case no. [2026] SGDC 82

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] In this originating claim, Zeus Matisse (the “Claimant”) claimed against ESA Security Pte. Ltd. (the “Defendant”) for his unpaid wages and other statutory entitlements under the Employment Act 1968 (“Employment Act”), the employer’s CPF contributions on the same and general damages for wrongful dismissal. In particular, the Claimant claimed the following:

  3. [2] The Defendant’s defence is that the Claimant was engaged as an ad hoc security officer pursuant to a contract for service (as opposed to a contract of service) and was therefore not entitled to the protections and statutory benefits afforded under the Employment Act. The Defendant further counterclaimed against the Claimant for

  4. The Claimant’s case

  5. [3] The Claimant claimed that he was appointed by the Defendant as a security officer under the designation of a night shift security supervisor pursuant to a written contract of employment. He claimed that the contract was signed on a date after he had commenced work on 25 June 2017 but despite his repeated requests for a copy of the contract, the Defendant has not provided him with a copy of the contract.

  6. [4] The Claimant claimed that during his employment from 25 June 2017 to 28 February 2023, he only worked at the Tagore 23 Warehouse located at Tagore Lane (“Tagore Site”).

  7. [5] The Claimant claimed that he was not provided with his pay slips by the Defendant regularly. He claimed that when he asked for his pay slips, he was told that Nick Chan (“Nick”) was busy or that the Defendant did not need to issue him with pay slips as he was paid on a daily basis. According to the pay slips in his possession, his basic monthly wage was $1,585 which increased to $1,633 in January 2022.

  8. [6] Employees of the Defendant worked on a shift basis. The day shift at the Tagore Site was from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. while the night shift was from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. The Claimant was paid after every shift he worked as follows:

  9. Overtime Pay

  10. [7] In respect of overtime pay, the Claimant claimed that it was the practice of the Defendant during the period of employment that the Defendant would pay overtime at the rate of 1.5 times the hourly basic rate of pay. On 16 April 2020, the Claimant was informed that he would have to guard the Tagore Site by himself which state of affairs persisted to the end of January 2023. The Claimant therefore claimed wages for one hour per day as he had to forego his dinner breaks and patrol the premises as well as attend to his other related work during such breaks. The total overtime deficit amounts to $64,091.39.

  11. Holiday Pay

  12. [8] In addition, the Claimant claimed that for each public holiday that the Claimant worked from June 2017 to November 2022, the Claimant only received an extra $30 per day over and beyond his normal pay. For the period of December 2022 to January 2023, the Claimant received an extra $50 per day for each public holiday he worked. The total of the shortfall in his wages per day amounted to $5,049.49.

  13. Rest Day Pay

  14. [9] From April 2019 to January 2023, the Claimant consistently worked beyond the 22 days a month and also double shifts on a single day including on days which were supposed to be his rest days. Hence, the Claimant claimed the amount of $24,674.07 as the deficit in payment.

  15. Pay increase

  16. [10] In January 2022, the Claimant’s basic pay increased from $1,585 to $1,633 in 2022. However, he was only paid his basic wage of $75 per day instead of $85 per day. The deficit of $10 per day he would have been entitled to from January 2022 to the end of November 2022 (inclusive) amounted to $3,150.

  17. Medical Bills

  18. [11] On 26 April 2021, the Claimant slipped and fell inside the attached toilet in the fire command centre of the Tagore Site guardhouse. On 30 September 2022, the Claimant slipped and fell at the Tagore Site while on patrol duty. The medical bills incurred for the treatment of his injury sustained in the course of his employment amounted to $492.39.

  19. Annual Leave

  20. [12] The Claimant also claimed the sum of $4,097.85 as payment for the paid leave that he was told he was not entitled to, which was a breach of section 88A(8) of the Employment Act by the Defendant.

  21. Wrongful Dismissal

  22. [13] The Claimant claimed that he was wrongfully dismissed when he sought payment of his just dues as itemised in his Statement of Claim. The Defendant had wanted him to sign a new contract with increased pay, provided that he forego his backdated claims against the Defendant. On 9 December 2022, Lena of the Defendant telephoned the Claimant and threatened him that if he did not sign the new agreement, he would have to look for another job within the next three days. By way of an email dated 4 January 2023, the Claimant requested for time till March 2023 to make up his mind whether to sign the new contract. By an email dated 5 January 2023, Christopher Shaun (“Christopher”), a director of the Defendant stated that he required a guarantee that by giving the Claimant time to consider till March 2023, the Defendant would not be penalised for the back-dated payments. On 1 February 2023, the Defendant sent a notice of termination to the Claimant. In the Notice, it was stated that upon payment of the final month’s salary, the Claimant would not be entitled to any further compensation or claim whether against the Defendant or the Defendant’s clients for any reason whatsoever. The reason that the Claimant was being terminated because the Tagore Site was not renewed was a false pretext and the Claimant was not given an opportunity to continue with his work at another site.

  23. [14] On 5 March 2023, the Claimant received a sum of $5,353.64 from the Defendant but no explanation for or breakdown of the sum was given to the Claimant.

  24. The Defence

  25. [15] The Defence is that the Claimant was engaged for his services as an ad hoc security officer on an as required basis as he was not able to work regularly and only wanted to work when he was able to do so. This was because the Claimant was already employed elsewhere and had another job at the material time.

  26. [16] The Defendant claimed that no written contract was ever entered into between the Claimant and the Defendant. The Claimant had steadfastly refused to enter into a written agreement and the parties proceeded on the basis of an oral agreement in which the Claimant would be engaged by the Defendant on an as-required basis at rates to be agreed for each engagement.

  27. [17] The Defendant averred that the Claimant was always deployed to work at the Tagore Site as he was only prepared to accept assignments to work at this worksite. When the Claimant asked for his pay slip in September 2021, he was informed by Nick that in accordance with the Defendant’s usual company practices, the Defendant does not provide pay slips to ad hoc security officers. The Defendant took the position that the Claimant was engaged as an ad hoc security officer and did not have a basic monthly wage. The Claimant was paid daily and only for the shifts he had accepted and was thereafter deployed to.

  28. [18] The Defendant denied that the Claimant was paid an additional $5 per shift if he manned the site alone. The rate agreed between the Claimant and the Defendant for the engagements was a flat fee of $75 per shift and $85 from December 2022. The Claimant did not raise any issues with the Defendant as regards the fee paid to him.

  29. [19] In the Opening Statement, the Defendant took the position that the Claimant was paid an additional fee of $30 for working on a public holiday, which additional fee was increased to $50 in December 2022. In the event that the Claimant covered the shift of a second guard at the Tagore Site, he was paid an additional $35 for each shift. This was no longer paid after April 2020 after the site requirements were adjusted to only one guard per shift. From sometime in or around June 2019, the Claimant negotiated an additional fee of $100 for each month that he worked more than 26 shifts. This was increased to $125 in November 2019, $150 in April 2020 and finally to $160 in January 2021 .

  30. Overtime Pay & Rest Day Pay

  31. [20] The Defendant denied that the Claimant was entitled to overtime pay, pay for working during dinner breaks and working on public holidays or rest day pay as he was engaged pursuant to a contract for service and was paid in accordance with the agreed terms for each engagement. The Defendant claimed that the Claimant was entitled to take dinner breaks and did not instruct or request that the Claimant forgo such breaks. The Claimant was able to decide when he would take his breaks.

  32. Pay increase

  33. [21] The Defendant claimed that the Claimant was not entitled to a pay increase as he was paid according to the terms agreed for each engagement. He had attempted to negotiate a variation in his fee but was told by Nick that the rate that the Defendant was prepared to offer for his services at the Tagore Site was $75 and that if he wanted a higher fee for his services, he could consider another site. The Claimant declined to work at any other site and agreed to the continued rate of $75 for his services.

  34. Medical Bills

  35. [22] In respect of medical bills, the Defendant averred that the Claimant did not report any injury allegedly sustained during the course of his engagement and did not make any claims or present any medical bills at any time.

  36. Annual Leave

  37. [23] The Defendant disputed the Claimant’s calculations which should be based on the respective year’s progressive wage model (“PWM”). The Defendant claimed that the Claimant had acted for all intents and purposes as a person contracted by the Defendant to provide security services. The Claimant determined where and when he would work, and negotiated his fees with the Defendant. The Claimant was not entitled to annual leave or statutory benefits and did not ask the Defendant about any of these benefits until the commencement of the action.

  38. Wrongful Dismissal

  39. [24] The Defendant claimed that the Claimant was never an employee and was not wrongfully dismissed. The Defendant claimed that it had ceased engagement of the Claimant as the client for the Tagore Site had terminated its contract for provision of security services. Since the Claimant had informed the Defendant that he would not accept any assignments to work at any other work site, his provision of services as an ad hoc security officer was no longer required by the Defendant and was accordingly terminated. The Defendant averred that it had undergone a change in beneficial ownership on 1 October 2022 and had discovered that there was no agreement entered into between the parties. With a view to engage and employ the Claimant, the Defendant had offered the Claimant an employment contract as a full-time employee.

  40. [25] The Defendant denied threatening the Claimant with termination if he did not sign the new contract. The Defendant’s representatives had on many occasions asked the Claimant to become a full-time employee of the Defendant instead of an ad hoc officer or the Defendant would no longer engage his services. The Claimant had consistently declined as he intended to have control over the days he would work and the terms of his engagement.

  41. [26] In respect of the termination notice, the Defendant’s position is that the statement that the Claimant would not be entitled to any further compensation or claim was in relation to the Defendant’s engagement of the Claimant’s provision of services as an ad hoc security officer.

  42. [27] After the Claimant received the termination notice, he failed to show up for the assignments he had accepted and was deployed to in the month of February 2023. The Claimant was nevertheless paid the fees due to him for the ad hoc services he was expected to render in the month of February 2023 in spite of this.

  43. The Defendant’s Counterclaim

  44. [28] The Defendant had paid the sum of $5,353.64 to the Claimant in accordance with MOM’s suggestion for the Defendant to pay the Claimant for outstanding claims. The Defendant claimed that it had made the payment by way of goodwill in the belief that it would satisfy the Claimant so that he would not continue with his unfounded claims against the Defendant.

  45. [29] As the Claimant was an ad hoc service provider providing services to the Defendant, the Defendant claimed that they had mistakenly paid for the Claimant’s employee CPF contributions for the period of July 2017 to February 2023 amounting to $40,666 and is entitled to be repaid the same. The Defendant also seeks the return of the $5,353.64 which was paid out of goodwill.

  46. The Claimant’s Defence to the Counterclaim

  47. [30] In respect of the counterclaim, the Claimant’s position was that if it is found that any amount had been paid in error to the Claimant’s CPF, the limitation period for the Defendant’s claim has passed pursuant to section 71(4) of the Central Provident Fund Act 1953 read with section 5(1) of the Central Provident Fund (Refunds) Regulations 2019. Any claim that the Defendant may have should be made by way of an application to the CPF and not against the Claimant.

  48. Issues

  49. [31] This case turned on the pivotal issue of whether the Claimant was an employee of the Defendant and therefore entitled to the various statutory benefits under the Employment Act or whether he was merely a provider of services to the Defendant in which case his claims would fail in their entirety. If he was an employee, further issues would arise as to the quantum of the various statutory benefits that he is entitled to; whether he was wrongfully dismissed and if so, whether he would be entitled to damages; as well as whether the Defendant’s counterclaim can still stand.

  50. Was the Claimant an employee

  51. [32] Under the Employment Act, “employee” means a person who has entered into or works under a contract of service with an employer. A “contract of service” means any agreement, whether written or oral, express or implied, whereby one person agrees to employ another as an employee and that other agrees to serve his or her employer as an employee.

  52. [33] Under the Private Security Industry Act 2007 (“PSIA”), “employ” does not include subcontract or arrange by contract, franchise or otherwise with another person for the purpose of that other person employing or providing persons. In other words, while the PSIA recognizes that subcontracting arrangements may be present in the industry, they are not included when the PSIA refers to the concept of employment; the subcontractor remains the one employing the person.

  53. [34] In determining whether a person is an employee of another, much depends on the circumstances of the case. No single factor is determinative and the Court considers multiple non-exhaustive factors in a holistic analysis of the specific industry and working conditions at hand.

  54. [35] In National University Hospital (Singapore) Pte Ltd v Cicada Cube Pte Ltd [2017] SGHC 53, the Court listed the following non-exhaustive factors to be considered in its analysis: (a) whether the work of the alleged employee was done was an integral part of the business of the alleged employer; (b) whether the alleged employee was paid a regular salary or commission; (c) whether there were stipulations as to working hours; (d) whether the alleged employer contributed to the Central Provident Fund account of the alleged employee; (e) whether the alleged employee was entitled to overtime pay, leave, holidays and medical leave; and (f) whether the alleged employer had the power to dismiss the alleged employee from his service.

  55. [36] In Public Prosecutor v Jurong Country Club & anor appeal [2019] 5 SLR 554, the Court held that as gym instructor, Yusoff was an independent contractor, taking into account the following factors: (a) Yusoff’s contracts were renegotiated on a nearly yearly basis; (b) Yusoff’s remuneration package was weighted towards commission; (c) Yusoff was not on the list of employees used for budgeting purposes and was not invited to staff functions such as their dinner and dance; (d) Yusoff did not report to the HR department, was not issued the HR manual, was not subject to the employment performance appraisal framework and had no key performance indicators to meet; (e) Yusoff was not eligible for annual increments and any increment to Yusoff’s pay resulted from the renegotiation of his contract; (f) unlike employees who could access all areas and had to sign personal data protection forms, Yusoff was given access only to the gym and was not required to sign personal data protection forms; (g) while he was entitled to CPF contributions, medical benefits, hospitalization leave and medical leave as an employee before 1998, these were removed from his contracts in 1998; (h) the contractual entitlement to insurance was removed in his 2003 contract; (i) his contract in 1998 allowed him to conduct public programmes in the gym after his stipulated working hours, in contrast to the general position that employees were not allowed to engage in personal work at the employer’s premises without permission from the management and doing so would result in dismissal.

  56. [37] In the present case, various factors were looked at in determining whether the Claimant was an employee.

  57. Whether there was a written agreement

  58. [38] While the Claimant claimed that there was a written agreement, neither he nor the Defendant were able to produce one.

  59. [39] The Claimant’s evidence on when he signed the written agreement was equivocal. While his pleaded position is that he signed the contract on a date after he commenced work at the Tagore Site on 25 June 2017 , in his affidavit of evidence-in-chief (“AEIC”), he claimed that it was signed on the first day of work when Nick brought him a copy of the same . While the Claimant claimed that there was a written contract, he was unable to state what the terms of the contract were and whether the written contract dealt with the issue of advances, termination, loans or location of work . In particular, he was unable to state the wage stated in his employment contract .

  60. [40] While the Defendant’s position is that there was no written agreement, when the Claimant asked Nick on 22 September 2021 for a copy of the employment contract which he had previously signed with the Defendant, Nick did not immediately dismiss the request by stating that there were none. While he said that he did not think there was one, he alluded to the fact that there may have been a very old copy before the Claimant quit halfway to become manager a very long time ago . On the stand, the position taken by Lena was that they tried to look for the Defendant’s contract but were simply unable to locate it .

  61. [41] It is also not disputed that the Claimant had rejected changes in the way he was paid on various occasions. On 24 June 2019, Nick had offered to pay the Claimant a monthly basic pay of $1,360 with a weekly advance of $300 . However, this was rejected by the Claimant. On 12 February 2020 , the Claimant told Nick that he had spoken to Edwin Seah (“Edwin”) regarding a full-time supervisor role for the night shift at the Tagore Site. Nick told him that they did not need a supervisor for the night shift at the Tagore Site and that his pay was already the take home rate of a senior security officer. Nick then offered the Claimant a change to a monthly arrangement. In response to the Claimant’s request for an increase to $80 at the Tagore Site, Nick advised the Claimant that he would have to move out of Tagore as a roaming relief to either Tampines Grande or Palais. On 22 September 2021, Nick offered the Claimant a conversion to a permanent senior security officer at a basic monthly pay of $1,585 . Nick told the Claimant the benefits of signing a contract to be a permanently employed officer with the Defendant, including being able to claim for medical leave and having leave and that he would have zero benefits as a relief. However, the Claimant preferred to retain his usual $75 daily pay and an additional $160 when he did 26 shifts . A similar conversation took place on 21 December 2021 when the Claimant asked Nick for some bonus and Nick asked him to convert to a permanent officer instead of a daily paid officer . The Claimant agreed that he rejected the permanent contract as he wanted the flexibility of the daily payments and advances which Nick provided to him . It is clear from these conversations that the understanding between the parties was that the Claimant was a relief worker paid on a daily basis and that the Claimant was told that he would have no medical leave or other leave entitlements and no bonus. However, just because he is not a permanent officer does not mean that he is providing services to the Defendant on a contract for services.

  62. [42] Given that the written contract was not produced and the Claimant was unable to state the terms of the written contract, there is no evidence of a written contract that grounds his monetary entitlement. While I can accept that one may not always recall the terms and conditions of one’s employment contract, one would definitely remember the wage that one is entitled to. Given that the Claimant was cash-strapped and wanted to be paid on a daily basis, he would definitely have remembered the amount that he was entitled to pursuant to the written contract, if there was one, so as to ensure that he was duly paid for his labour. The fact that he could not do suggested that the agreement between the parties was that he would be paid the initial $70 or $75 for every shift he performed, together with both employer and employee CPF contributions to be made by the Defendant. This was supported by the Claimant’s bank statements where there were months in which the payments received fell far short of $1,585 and the Claimant’s CPF Statement of Account for 2017 where the Defendant’s contributions started in July 2017 and varied from month to month. This suggests that the Claimant was not working full-time when he commenced work with the Defendant and there was no monthly basic pay that the Claimant was entitled to.

  63. [43] However, the lack of a written contract, the fact that he was not working full-time and the fact that there was no monthly basic pay were not determinative or indicative as to whether this was a contract of service or contract for services. Both contracts for services and employment contracts can be oral in nature. Full-time workers can be contractors and part-time workers can be employees. Daily rated workers can also be employees. Based on a daily pay of $70 or $75, the monthly pay of the Claimant can go up to $1,540 or $1,650 respectively if he works for 22 days. This was higher than the PWM basic wage floor for security officers, senior security officers and security supervisors in 2017 which was pegged at $1,100, $1,300 and $1,500 respectively . There was therefore no indication that a $70 or $75 per shift pay did not accord with the wages stipulated under the PWM.

  64. Nature of the Claimant’s work

  65. [44] When the Claimant first worked for the Defendant, he was also working full-time for another company. This is clear from the CPF statements and bank statements. However, it is clear from Nick’s AEIC that from around sometime in June 2019, the Claimant was working regularly for the Defendant. Based on the WhatsApp messages between the Claimant and Nick, Nick had offered the Claimant an additional $100 if the Claimant was able to work for 26 days in a month on 24 June 2019 . It is clear from the WhatsApp messages exchanged between the two that for the months of July, August and September 2019, Nick had paid the Claimant the additional $100 . The hours put in by the Claimant were therefore similar to full-time employees of the Defendant who were contractually required to work 6 days per week or 26 to 27 days per month .

  66. [45] The Defendant has chosen to describe the Claimant’s work arrangement as ad hoc and argued that $75 daily with an additional sum upon completion of 26 days of work in a month was an arrangement for an ad hoc or relief officer. In this regard, I note that Nick did not describe the Claimant as an ad hoc worker in the WhatsApp messages with the Claimant but a relief officer and who was nevertheless entitled to overtime pay . While the Claimant may have worked for the Defendant on an ad hoc basis when he commenced work for the Defendant in July 2017, it was clear that from around sometime in June 2019, the Claimant’s work became as regular as a permanent full-time employee of the Defendant. It would therefore be odd to describe his work arrangements as ad hoc when, in reality, he was putting in regular hours with the Defendant. Hence, the Claimant may have been a daily rated worker who worked sporadically when he started work but from around June 2019, his work arrangements acquired a degree of permanency which may be better described as a regular relief worker who is only deployed to the Tagore Site. That said, nothing turns on the label that a worker is a relief worker. A relief worker can still be an employee.

  67. Industry-specific factors

  68. [46] The Defendant made the point that it was common for a security officer to undertake full time employment with one security agency, while also undertaking ad hoc work with a second security agency , subject to the requirement that a licensed security agency must inform the Police Licensing and Regulatory Department of the proposed employment or termination of employment of the security officer. Under section 16 of the PSIA, a person (whether or not a licensed security agency) who employs or is about to employ as a security officer any person who is a licensed security officer must (a) before employing the licensed security officer; and (b) not later than 14 days after terminating the employment of the licensed security officer, inform the licensing officer in the prescribed form and manner of the proposed employment or termination of employment, as the case may be.

  69. [47] Bearing in mind that the definition of the word “employ” in the PSIA merely excluded subcontracting arrangements, I do not think that reference to a person undertaking ad hoc work for a second security agency would necessarily render such work to be work performed under a contract for services. A security officer who works for two security agencies simultaneously is also not prevented from being regarded as the employee of both security agencies. Much would depend on the facts.

  70. [48] The Defendant argued that it was not uncommon that security officers who are engaged on an ad hoc basis will not have written contracts as they are engaged individually for each job depending on whether or not they are willing to accept the offered terms . As set out earlier, the fact that there appears to be no written contract is not indicative as to whether the nature of the agreement is one for services or one of services.

  71. [49] The Defendant also made the point that the security industry has been subject to a PWM from September 2016 where full-time officers’ wages are gradually increased incrementally on an annual basis from 1 January 2018 . At $75 a day, if the Claimant were to work 26 days in a month, which according to Nick would be the minimum requirement for an employee of the Defendant , he would be entitled to $1,950. With an additional $100, he would be entitled to $2,050.

  72. [50] The PWM basic wage floor of security officers (“SO”), senior security officers (“SSO”) and security supervisors (“SS”) are as follows:

  73. 2018

  74. 2019

  75. 2020

  76. 2021

  77. 2022

  78. SO

  79. $1,100

  80. $1,175

  81. $1,250

  82. $1,400

  83. $1,442

  84. SSO

  85. $1,300

  86. $1,360

  87. $1,420

  88. $1,585

  89. $1,633

  90. SS

  91. $1,500

  92. $1,560

  93. $1,620

  94. $1,785

  95. $1,839

  96. [51] Compared to what the Claimant was receiving, it is not clear how the Claimant’s pay would be contrary to the PWM framework or inconsistent with a contract of service. In addition, it would appear that the payment of an incentive of $100 was not unique to the Claimant given Nick’s WhatsApp message that $100 was the rate applicable to “almost all of esa”, the Defendant. Even if the Claimant’s pay does not conform to the PWM framework, this is not determinative of the question of whether the Claimant is an employee. A security agency which fails to pay an employee in accordance with the PWM framework may face penalties or other regulatory actions for non-compliance but the breach does not change the status of the employee.

  97. How the Claimant was paid

  98. [52] It was clear from the Claimant’s bank statements that he was not paid on a monthly basis, unlike the representation in the payslips. However, the fact that he is paid on a daily basis does not mean that he is an independent contractor.

  99. [53] Based on the WhatsApp messages, the Claimant would be entitled to $100 more a month, if he worked for 26 or more night shifts in a month . The Claimant agreed that he was paid $75 for a full 12-hour shift and he was paid for each shift . He would be paid an additional $30 if he worked on a public holiday . For instance, the Claimant was paid holiday pay of $30 on 9 August 2019 . Although he denied that he would receive an additional $35 per shift if he covered the shift of a second guard , this appeared to be the case from the WhatsApp messages .

  100. [54] It was not disputed that the Claimant was not issued payslips regularly before 2021 . However, the Claimant was issued payslips from July 2021 to February 2023, except that payslips for September 2021 and December 2021 were not before the Court .

  101. [55] Based on the WhatsApp messages exchanged on 21 March 2020 , the Claimant asked for payslips for November 2019 to January 2020 which Nick appeared to say have been given to the Claimant monthly and which Nick asked the Claimant to keep in the future. Sometime on 20 and 21 September 2021 , the Claimant had also asked Nick for his July and August 2021 payslips in order to process his claim for his absence from work from 2 to 23 August 2021 due to being infected with Covid. On 25 October 2021, the Claimant had also requested Vijay to give him his pay slip for September 2021, which he had been receiving for years and that these were dropped off at the Tagore Site at the beginning of every month . The Claimant conceded that he asked for payslips when he needed it . It is not disputed that the pay slip does not reflect his daily pay of $75 per shift but a basic monthly pay of $1,585 for the months of July, August, November and December 2021 . The extra pay for public holiday is reflected in the pay slip of July 2021, as well as the overtime hours, rate per hour and overtime paid. The attendance allowance of $160 was also reflected in the pay slips commencing October 2021. In fact, when he received his pay slips for July and August 2021, the Claimant questioned Nick as to why his August payslip reflected him as still earning pay and receiving CPF when he did not work for the whole month of August 2021 .

  102. [56] Hence, I accept that the pay slips which reflect a monthly salary do not reflect the reality that the Claimant was in fact paid on a daily basis at the rate of $75 for each shift that he completed. The Claimant was not able to correlate his daily pay to the amount reflected in the pay slips . According to Nick, the numbers on the payslip were calculated by Edwin, the previous owner of the Defendant, using $75 a day and the days the Claimant worked by applying a complex formula. Even after the Defendant underwent a change of ownership on 1 October 2022, Lena continued to issue payslips to the Claimant.

  103. [57] The Defendant submits that the irregular provision of pay slips was inconsistent with employment and the fact that the payslips do not reflect reality and were inaccurate indicate that they were issued for occasional administrative convenience rather than employment recognition supporting the Defendant’s case that the Claimant was an ad hoc worker under a contract for services. In my view, the fact that the Defendant was willing to issue monthly pay slips for the Claimant, occasionally at first but regularly from July 2021, indicates that it treated the Claimant as an employee. Although the pay slips did not reflect the reality that the Claimant was paid daily on a per shift basis, the net pay varied from month to month depending on the overtime, reflected the attendance allowance and CPF contributions from both the employer and employee that the Defendant made on the Claimant’s behalf and did not differ substantially from what the Claimant was in fact paid. Hence, the pay slips were nevertheless a representation that the Claimant was an employee of the Defendant.

  104. [58] The Claimant was able to ask for and receive advances but this was a neutral factor, given that advance payments would be applicable in both contracts of service and contracts for services.

  105. Payment of CPF contributions

  106. [59] It is not disputed that the Defendant paid into the Claimant’s CPF account both the employer and employee contributions from July 2017 to February 2023 . Given that the Claimant was paid on a daily basis, the Defendant paid both the employer and employee CPF contributions based on the amount that the Claimant was paid in any given month. The Defendant claimed that this was done erroneously on the mistaken belief that they were required to make CPF contributions to all security officers, including part-time and relief officers .

  107. [60] Based on the evidence, the Defendant’s contributions to the Claimant’s CPF accounts started in July 2017, along with contributions from Ocean IFM Pte Ltd (“Ocean IFM”) and STS Security Services P/L . While the contributions made by STS Security Services P/L were minimal, the monthly contributions made by the Defendant in 2017 varied and were significantly smaller in quantum than the constant monthly contributions made by Ocean IFM. In 2018, the monthly contributions made by the Defendant to the Claimant’s CPF account stabilized and amounted to approximately half of that contributed by Ocean IFM . From 2019 to February 2022, the Defendant was the sole contributor to the Claimant’s CPF accounts .

  108. [61] Given that the contributions made by Ocean IFM in December 2017 and November 2018 were almost double the CPF contributions deposited in other months of the respective year, it was argued by the Defendant that such contributions indicated that a 13th month bonus was paid by Ocean IFM and that the Claimant was employed full-time by Ocean IFM. The Claimant agreed that that was the case and that the job at Ocean IFM was his day job .

  109. [62] While the Claimant could not have been a full-time employee of the Defendant between June 2017 and November 2018, this does not mean that he could not have been a part-time employee of the Defendant in the same period or a full-time employee of the Defendant after that. The fact that the Claimant was not working full-time for the Defendant between June 2017 and November 2018 does not negate a finding of an employment relationship, given that the Employment Act acknowledges that employees can work part-time for less than 35 hours a week. While the payment of CPF contributions is not determinative, it does indicate the Defendant’s treatment of the Claimant as an employee, right from the beginning. There is no rule that a worker who is paid on a daily basis cannot be an employee for the purposes of the Employment Act. There is also no rule that a worker cannot be concurrently employed by two or more employers.

  110. How the Claimant was deployed

  111. [63] It was not disputed that the Claimant was only deployed to the Tagore Site. This was unlike full-time employees of the Defendant who would be deployed to any site as operationally required.

  112. [64] From the WhatsApp messages between the Claimant and Nick on 24 June 2019 , the Claimant had spoken to Nick for a raise. Nick had offered him to pay him on a monthly basis instead of a daily basis. This was however rejected by the Claimant who preferred to be paid on a daily basis, as it did not clash with his day job. He had asked Nick if there was a site in Ang Mo Kio where there was a job in the day shift for three to four days where he could work and go straight to the Tagore Site. Nick had offered him 3 sites: Tampines, Grande and Le Grove. However, the Claimant did not take up any of these sites . The Claimant agreed that he was not required by Nick to go to any of these sites and it was up to him if he could help . The Claimant claimed that his contract required him to work as a full-time night shift supervisor at Tagore . The offer to work at other sites was over and above his contract so he was able to decide not to take up these other sites when offered to him . The Claimant claimed that these relate to additional day shifts over and above his night shift at Tagore .

  113. [65] On 4 September 2019, the Claimant asked Nick if he could do day shifts at a day site on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday while continuing to do night shifts 6 days a week . On the stand, the Claimant agreed that he had asked Nick to work more days so that he could earn more money . The Claimant had also previously explored possible sites and assignments which he could take up in the day for which no CPF was paid .

  114. [66] I accepted that the Claimant was only deployed to the Tagore Site and was paid on a daily basis, only when he worked. Outside of his night shift duties at the Tagore Site, he remained free to decide whether to take up additional jobs in the day to earn more income. While this was unlike that of full-time employees who would be deployed to any site as operationally required, I did not think that such a work arrangement was necessarily inconsistent with an employment relationship.

  115. [67] The Claimant disputed that he could decide which days he would work . He claimed that Vijay who was in charge of deployment would tell them when they are supposed to work, taking into account their off day and they may be asked to cover on the days when the Defendant did not have enough manpower. He would only go to Nick for finance matters . When he informed Nick that he would not be working, the message was for the purpose of payment and he would already have informed Vijay of the same for the purposes of deployment.

  116. [68] Given that the Claimant was working consistently at the Tagore Site for 26 days in a month, I accepted the Claimant’s evidence that when he informed Nick that he would not be working, it was for the purpose of payment and he would have already informed Vijay for the purpose of deployment. This is supported by the WhatsApp messages between the Claimant and Nick which indicated that Vijay was the one in charge of operations on site . The fact the Claimant was able to state in advance when he was going to work for which any advance could be offset was consistent with his evidence that his work was scheduled by the Defendant. The Claimant’s message on 10 December 2019, 14:42 that he had already informed Vijay of his unavailability to work that evening , the fact that he had to take urgent off when he had an accident on 27 January 2021 and his message on 30 August 2021 at 12:02 p.m. that he has already informed Vijay that he would be starting work on 3 September 2021 following his recovery from Covid indicate that he could not just determine when he was going to perform his work and that he had to inform Vijay if he did not turn up for work. In addition, the Claimant did not have to find a replacement for the site if he was unable to work . The Defendant remained responsible for ensuring that the Tagore Site was adequately manned. The WhatsApp messages also indicate that when the Claimant was infected with Covid, the Defendant was the one who had to bear the expenditure for the cleaning and testing of all staff and it was the Defendant who had to submit the approval for the Claimant to return to the Tagore Site . In my view, these were factors which indicates a contract of service.

  117. Nature of work arrangements

  118. [69] The work of the Claimant was done as an integral part of the business of the Defendant. There was mutuality of obligations in that the Defendant rostered the Claimant to work and the Claimant had to turn up for work and hand over his duty to the next officer . While the Claimant had control over how he performed his tasks such as patrolling and when he would take breaks , this was, in my view, a neutral factor, given that the Claimant was the only one on site and there was in essence no one to supervise his work.

  119. [70] Nevertheless, there was a chain of reporting where he would have to put up reports in the occurrence book and he would generally wear the company uniform . There was also evidence that the Claimant had to complete clocking for his scope of work , hand over his duties to the next officer on duty as well as account for his absence from the facility control centre during his shift .

  120. How the Claimant saw his work

  121. [71] While the Claimant disagreed that he saw himself as an ad hoc and relief worker on the stand, he previously took the position that he was a relief worker. On 28 August 2019 , the Claimant referred to doing “relief” work. In the Claimant’s WhatsApp message on 10 October 2019 , he referred to his night pay as “relief night pay”. Based on the WhatsApp messages exchanged on 12 February 2020 , the Claimant had messaged Nick to inform him that he had spoken to Edwin regarding a full-time supervisor night shift at Tagore and asked Nick for advice as to how much he would get as supervisor. The Claimant then asked if the pay for “Tagore relief” can be increased to $80, which Nick informed him that any increase would be attendance based and his pay would only be increased if he were to move out of Tagore as a “roaming relief”. On 22 September 2021 , when Nick mentioned that the Claimant was a relief officer who was paid on a daily basis, the Claimant did not object.

  122. Treatment of Claimant by Defendant

  123. [72] The Claimant was paid for attending training under the Defendant’s name. The Claimant attended training in the Defendant’s name on 22 and 23 July 2019 as well as attended training on 19 October 2022, for which he was paid .

  124. [73] In particular, Nick had highlighted the availability of a government grant of $1,000 for low-income workers affected by Covid. In order for the Claimant to process his claim for the grant in respect of his absence from work due to Covid, Nick issued him a letter on 28 August 2021 which states that he joined the Defendant as a Senior Security Officer (“SSO”) on 25 June 2017 and worked as a night shift SSO at 23 Tagore Lane with a basic pay of $1,585 per month excluding overtime and allowance. Even though the letter does not use the word “employee” or “employment”, the letter was a clear representation to public agencies that the Claimant was an employee with the Defendant with a basic pay of $1,585 and who was entitled to overtime and allowances. While the Defendant argued that the letter was issued for compassionate reasons to support the Claimant’s grant application, the fact that Nick had highlighted the grant to the Claimant and had no issues with issuing the letter was nevertheless indicative that the Defendant treated the Claimant as an employee who was eligible for such grant.

  125. [74] In addition, the Defendant afforded the Claimant benefits such as the government-paid paternity leave (“GPPL”) pursuant to the Child Development Co-Savings Act 2001 (“CDCA”) which provides for paternity leave benefits for “a male employee who is the natural father of a child” and which defines “employee” similarly as the Employment Act as “any person who has entered into or works under a contract of service with an employer in Singapore”. The Defendant argued that the payment of GPPL was made on MOM’s administrative direction and out of a desire to avoid further entanglements with MOM and did not amount to an admission of the Claimant’s employment status. I did not accept this, given that the Defendant was entitled during MOM’s investigations to take the position that it is taking now that the Claimant was not an employee and should not be paid GPPL.

  126. [75] The Defendant had also referred to the Claimant as an employee in various correspondence.

  127. [76] On 5 January 2023, Christopher wrote an email to the Claimant stating the following :

  128. [77] Even though Christopher only joined the Defendant in October 2022, there was nothing to indicate that the change in ownership or management of the Defendant had changed the status of the Claimant. While the correspondence happened in the course of negotiations between the Claimant and Defendant, the correspondence clearly indicated that the Defendant treated the Claimant as an employee in respect of whom the Defendant had to comply with MOM rules and regulations.

  129. [78] In the Claimant’s termination letter dated 1 February 2023, the Defendant referred to a clause which refers to obligations of confidentiality, non-solicitation and intellectual property which are “obligations under your employment contract and other agreements that you may have signed during your employment with the Company” and which are still in effect notwithstanding the termination of his employment . This suggests that there was an employment contract and reflects the Defendant’s position that the Claimant was an employee.

  130. [79] While Lena testified that the clause relied on in the termination letter was adopted from that of a day shift employee , the fact that the Defendant had considered it appropriate to do so and the fact that they provided notice of the termination meant that they treated the Claimant as an employee. The fact that Lena did not know that they could just let the Claimant go without notice of termination meant that the Defendant did not really treat the Claimant as an ad hoc worker who would come and go but an employee who was entitled to a termination notice.

  131. Whether the Claimant was entitled to employee benefits

  132. [80] The Defendant claimed that the Claimant did not inform Nick in the WhatsApp messages that he suffered a fall at the workplace. However, it is clear in the WhatsApp message that the Claimant sent to Nick on 26 April 2021 at 13:28 that he had just come back from Alexandra Hospital and his knee was injured. While he was given 3 days MC, he would only take that night off. He would be back at work the next day and had already informed Vijay . The Claimant also did not inform the Defendant about the incident on 30 September 2022 where he suffered a fall at the site. However, it was clear that he had filed an incident report . On the stand, the Claimant testified that he had informed his operations department as well as filled up the incident report and occurrence book, as per the standard operating procedure . He had also informed Viyaj, the operations executive of the incident .

  133. [81] In my view, whether the Claimant was entitled to employee benefits was not determinative. If it were so, it would be easy for employers to deny workers such benefits and point towards the lack of such benefits in arguing that they are not employees, making claims for such benefits impossible. Hence, I did not place much weight on the failure of the Claimant to apply for annual or medical leave or to seek overtime pay as he may simply be ignorant of such entitlement or rights.

  134. Conclusion

  135. [82] In the present case, while the Claimant was unable to produce evidence of a written contract, it is important to note that section 2 of the Employment Act recognises oral and implied agreements. Taking into account all the circumstances above, I am of the view that the Claimant was in a contract of service with the Defendant. In arriving at such a conclusion, I had taken into account the fact that the Defendant had consistently paid both the employer and employee contributions into the Claimant’s CPF account. The fact that the Defendant did not deduct the employee portion from the Claimant’s salary stemmed from the fact that the Claimant was paid on a daily basis and did not detract from the nature of these payments. The Defendant also issued pay slips to the Claimant indicating that the payments made to him were in the nature of salary payments and reflecting employee benefits such as overtime and public holiday allowances as well as CPF contributions. The Defendant scheduled the Claimant for work and the Claimant had to inform the Defendant if he was unable to turn up as well as follow certain procedures at work. The Defendant paid the Claimant for attending training and issued him a letter stating his salary in support of his application for a government grant. Even when matters came under scrutiny, the Defendant treated the Claimant as an employee in the notice of termination, afforded him the GPPL as well as paid him an amount in respect of the encashment of leave for 2022 and 2023 (as indicated in the Claimant’s pay slip of February 2023) and accepted MOM’s findings on the premise that the Claimant was an employee. Given that CPF contributions and GPPL were statutory obligations involving employees, I do not think that the payment by the Defendant can be dismissed as purely administrative convenience. The Defendant did not take the position that the Claimant was serving under a contract for services until the commencement of this suit which made it a clear afterthought. In the circumstances, I find that the Claimant was employed by the Defendant pursuant to a contract of services and was therefore entitled to the minimum conditions of service provided for in the Employment Act.

  136. Quantification of the Claimant’s Claims

  137. [83] From June to December 2017, the Claimant was paid $70 for each shift and an additional $5 per shift if he manned the site alone. He was paid $75 for each 12-hour shift that he worked from January 2018. This was increased to $85 per shift in December 2022. If he worked on a public holiday, he was paid an additional $30, which was increased to $50 in December 2022. In the event that he covered the shift of a second guard (prior to the reduction in site requirements in April 2020), he was paid an additional $35 per shift. If he worked more than 26 shifts in a month, he would be paid an additional $100, which was increased to $125 in November 2019, to $150 in April 2020 and finally to $160 in January 2021 .

  138. [84] The Claimant’s principal claim concerns unpaid overtime and public holiday wages over his period of employment from June 2017 to January 2023 amounting to $69,140.88. However, the Claimant was unable to explain how he arrived at the overtime claim, other than the fact that he obtained the numbers from his bank statements and calculated the figures based on MOM’s advice and had used a MOM online calculator for which he had used the basic monthly pay of $1,633 instead of $85 a day .

  139. Overtime Pay

  140. [85] Pursuant to section 40(4) of the Employment Act which relates to shift workers, any employee who at the request of his employer works more than an average of 44 hours per week over any continuous period of 3 weeks must be paid for the extra work in accordance with section 38(4). Under section 38(4), the employee must be paid for the extra work at the rate of not less than one and a half times the employee’s hourly basic rate of pay irrespective of the basis on which the employee’s rate of pay is fixed. As defined in section 41 of the Employment Act, “week” in sections 36, 38 and 40 means a continuous period of 7 days commencing at midnight on Sunday.

  141. [86] In quantifying the Claimant’s claim under this head to be $64,091.39, the Claimant claimed to have computed the figures in accordance with MOM’s official formulas using the official tools provided by the MOM in respect of the calculators for employees for “Overtime Pay” . However, no evidence was adduced as to where such calculators can be found, the inputs for such calculations and the assumptions or methodology for the calculations. In the Claimant’s further written submissions setting out how the claim under this head had been calculated, the Claimant had used the monthly basic pay of $1,585 in its calculations to derive the basic hourly rate of $8.31. I did not agree that this was the right premise given my earlier finding that the Claimant was paid on a per shift basis and not on a monthly basis. In particular, while I acknowledge that the letter dated 28 August 2021 from the Defendant indicated that the Claimant’s basic pay was $1,585 per month, given the clear evidence that the Claimant was paid on a daily basis, I agree with the Defendant that the amount of $1,585 cannot have been the basic monthly wage for the entire period of the Claimant’s employment from June 2017 to December 2021. Given the evidence that the payslips were worked out based on what the Claimant was actually paid, it would not be accurate to rely on the monthly wage stated in the Claimant’s payslips in calculating the Claimant’s overtime pay.

  142. [87] As the Claimant was paid daily whenever he completed a shift, the hourly basic rate of pay would be $5.83 (being $70 divided by 12) from June 2017 to December 2017 or $6.25 (being $75 divided by 12) from January 2018 to November 2022 and $7.08 (being $85 divided by 12) from December 2022. At one and a half times, the hourly basic rate of pay amounts to $8.75 from June 2017 to December 2017 or $9.38 from January 2018 to November 2022 and $10.62 from December 2022. As the Claimant had already been paid for the shifts he performed, the differential hourly basic rate of pay which should be applied to his overtime hours would be $2.92 from June 2017 to December 2017 or $3.13 from January to November 2022 and $3.54 from December 2022.

  143. [88] As for the overtime hours worked, this was worked out using the evidence available before the Court, including the Claimant’s bank statements and the WhatsApp messages between the Claimant and Nick, indicating the nature of the payments. On the basis that the Claimant was paid a fixed sum after each shift he had completed, I was prepared to accept from the fact of payment that this constituted the Defendant’s acknowledgement that he had completed a shift. Hence, on days where the Claimant received $70, $75, $85, $105 or $110 as the sum may be, in duplicate or a mix of these sums, I was prepared to accept that he had completed two shifts.

  144. [89] In doing so, I did not accept the Claimant’s submission that he was unable to take his one-hour meal break when he was alone at the site and this constitutes an additional hour of overtime per day. There was no evidence that the Defendant required the Claimant to do so.

  145. 2017

  146. [90] Based on the Claimant’s bank statements , the Claimant received $70 on 28 June, 5, 12, 19, 26 and 31 July 2017, $75 on 3, 6, 8, 9, 10, 13, 16, 17, 21, 22, 23, 24, 27, 29 and 30 July 2017 as well as $105 on 26 June 2017. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 3 July to 23 July 2017, the Claimant worked for a total of 14 shifts comprising 168 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated an overtime of 36 hours. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $2.92 per hour amounting to $105.12.

  147. [91] Based on the Claimant’s bank statements , the Claimant received $70 on 4, 10 and 30 August 2017, $75 on 1, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 13, 14 and 15 August and $105 on 9 and 10 August 2017 and $75 twice on 31 August 2017. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 24 July to 13 August 2017, the Claimant worked a total of 18 shifts comprising 216 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 84 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $2.92 per hour amounting to $245.28.

  148. [92] Based on the Claimant’s bank statements , the Claimant received $70 on 6, 13, 20 and 27 September, $75 on 5, 13, 14, 19, 22, 25, 26 and 29 September, $105 on 1 September, and $75 twice on 3 September 2017. The Claimant did not exceed an average of 44 hours per week over any continuous period of 3 weeks from 14 August to 24 September 2017.

  149. [93] The Claimant received $70 on 4, 11, 18 and 25 October, $75 on 1, 2, 4, 5, 9, 15, 16, 23 and 28 October, $150 on 8, 12 and 18 October, $105 on 18 October, $110 on 29 October, $75 twice on 30 October 2017. Given that there is no evidence on why the amount of $150 was received on 18 October 2017, despite the Claimant having already received $70 and $105 on the same day and whether these were advances or wages for days worked and for which days in the week, I am unable to ascertain which days the Claimant had worked in respect of the sum of $150 received on 18 October 2017. On the available evidence, over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 25 September to 15 October 2017, the Claimant worked a total of 16 shifts comprising 192 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 60 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $2.92 per hour amounting to $175.20.

  150. [94] The Claimant received $70 on 1, 8, 15, 22, $75 on 1, 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, 14, 25, 26, 28 and 30 November, $110 on 7 and 26 November, $150 on 15 November 2017. There is no evidence on why the amount of $150 was received on 15 November 2017, despite the Claimant having already received $70 on the same day. Even if I take $75 to be wages paid in respect of an additional shift that day, it is unclear whether the additional $75 is an advance or wages for days worked and for which days in the week. As such, I am unable to ascertain which day the Claimant had worked in respect of the additional $75 received on 15 November 2017. Read with the records in October 2017, over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 16 October 2017 to 5 November 2017 the Claimant has worked a total of 13 shifts comprising 156 hours exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated an overtime of 24 hours. This is payable at $2.92 per hour amounting to $70.08. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 6 November to 26 November 2017, the Claimant has worked a total of 13 shifts comprising 156 hours exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated an overtime of 24 hours. This is payable at $2.92 per hour amounting to $70.08.

  151. [95] The Claimant received $70 on 6 December 2017, $75 on 1, 2, 5, 7, 16, 17, 22, 23, 24 and 28 December and $75 twice on 12, 15, 19 and 26 December. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 27 November to 17 December 2017, the Claimant worked a total of 13 shifts comprising 156 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 24 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $2.92 per hour amounting to $70.08.

  152. 2018

  153. [96] The Claimant received $75 on 3, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 21, 23, 24, 26 and 27 January 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 18 December 2017 to 7 January 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 12 shifts comprising 144 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 12 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $37.56. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 8 January to 28 January 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 13 shifts comprising 156 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 24 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $75.12.

  154. [97] The Claimant received $75 on 3, 9, 13, 14, 15, 16, 22 and 24 February 2018, $75 twice on 1, 6, 20 and 27 February 2018 and $105 on 17 February 2018. The Claimant did not exceed an average of 44 hours per week over any continuous period of 3 weeks from 29 January to 18 February 2018. However, over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 5 to 25 February 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 12 shifts comprising 144 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 12 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $37.56.

  155. [98] The Claimant received $75 on 2, 3, 5, 6, 10, 13, 14, 15, 20, 21, 22, 24, 27, 29 and 30 March 2018, $75 twice on 8 March 2018, $150 on 15 March 2018, and $105 on 28 and 31 March 2018. There is no evidence on why the amount of $150 was received on 15 March 2018, even though the Claimant had already received $75 on the same day. Even if I take $75 to be wages paid in respect of an additional shift that day, it is unclear whether the additional $75 is an advance or wages for days worked and for which days in the week. As such, I am unable to ascertain which day the Claimant had worked in respect of the additional $75 received on 15 March 2018. However, based on the available evidence, over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 26 February to 18 March 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 13 shifts comprising 156 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 24 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $75.12.

  156. [99] The Claimant received $75 on 5, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 19, 24, 26, 27, 28 April 2018, $75 twice on 3 April 2018, and $105 on 5, 7, 21, 25 April 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 19 March to 8 April 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 14 shifts comprising 168 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 36 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $112.68. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 9 April to 29 April 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 14 shifts comprising 168 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 36 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $112.68.

  157. [100] The Claimant was paid $75 on 1, 3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 29, 31 May 2018, $75 twice on 18 May and $105 on 1 and 30 May 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 30 April to 20 May 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 15 shifts comprising 180 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 48 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $150.24.

  158. [101] The Claimant was paid $75 on 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11, 13, 14, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 26, 27, 28, 29 and 30 June 2018, $105 and $5 on 15 June 2018 and $110 on 16 June 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 21 May to 10 June 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 15 shifts comprising 180 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 48 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $150.24. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 11 June to 1 July 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 15 shifts comprising 180 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 48 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $150.24.

  159. [102] The Claimant received $75 on 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28 and 31 July and $75 twice on 11 July 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 2 July to 22 July 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 15 shifts comprising 180 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 48 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $150.24.

  160. [103] The Claimant received $75 on 1, 2, 8, 9, 11, 14, 15, 16, 21, 22, 24 and 31 August, $105 on 10, 18 and 23 August and $110 on 25 August, $50 on 16 August and $25 on 17 August 2018. There is no evidence as to why the sums of $50 and $25 was transferred into the Claimant’s account on 16 and 17 August 2018 respectively. Hence, I am not able to find that they relate to payment for shift work completed by the Claimant. However, based on the available evidence, over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 23 July to 12 August 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 12 shifts comprising 144 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 12 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $37.56. The Claimant did not exceed an average of 44 hours per week over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 13 August to 2 September 2018.

  161. [104] The Claimant received $75 on 1, 4, 5, 6, 8, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28 and 29 September 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 3 September to 23 September 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 14 shifts comprising 168 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 36 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $112.68.

  162. [105] The Claimant received $75 on 4, 5, 6, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 25, 26, 27, 30 and 31 October and $150 on 3 October 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 24 September to 14 October 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 15 shifts comprising 180 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 48 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $150.24.

  163. [106] The Claimant received $75 on 1, 2, 3, 6, 8, 9, 10, 13, 14, 16, 17, 21, 22, 23 November, $75 twice on 30 November, $125 on 7 November 2018 and $50 on 29 November 2018. There is no evidence on why he received $50 on 29 November 2018 and whether this constitutes advances or wages and for which day in the week. However, based on the available evidence, over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 15 October to 4 November 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 13 shifts comprising 156 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 24 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $75.12. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 5 November to 25 November 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 12 shifts comprising 144 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 12 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $37.56.

  164. [107] The Claimant received $75 on 4, 7, 8, 11, 13, 17, 19 and 20 December and $75 twice on 5 and 14 December and $110 on 12 December 2018. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 26 November to 16 December 2018, the Claimant worked a total of 12 shifts comprising 144 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 12 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $37.56. The Claimant did not exceed an average of 44 hours per week over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 17 December 2018 to 6 January 2019.

  165. 2019

  166. [108] The Claimant was paid $75 on 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 22, 23, 24, 29 and 30 January and $75 twice on 25 and 31 January 2019. Over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 7 January to 27 January 2019, the Claimant worked a total of 15 shifts comprising 180 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 48 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $150.24.

  167. [109] The Claimant received $75 on 2, 5, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 20, 21 and 28 February, $110 on 6 February and $105 on 7 February 2019. While the Claimant also received an additional sum of $100 on 16 February and $50 on 19, 23, 26 and 27 February 2019, there is no evidence as to whether these sums relate to payment for shift work completed by the Claimant and for which days in the week. However, based on the available evidence, over the continuous period of 3 weeks from 28 January to 17 February 2019, the Claimant worked a total of 14 shifts comprising 168 hours, exceeding an average of 44 hours per week and accumulated 36 hours of overtime. As the Claimant had already been paid for these shifts, the differential overtime rate which should be applied to these hours is $3.13 per hour amounting to $112.68.

The judgment continues past this page. Read the rest at eLitigation.