Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 8 May 2018

High Court

Tay Wee Kiat and another v Public Prosecutor and another appeal

Feedback & support

[2018] SGHC 114Case no. Magistrate’s Appeals Nos 9079 and 9080 of 201710 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. [1] This is our supplementary judgment pertaining to the matter of compensation in respect of the offences committed by the appellants, Tay Wee Kiat (“Tay”) and Chia Yun Ling (“Chia”). Tay and Chia were convicted of various charges relating to their repeated physical abuse of a domestic helper over a span of two years. They were sentenced by the court below to 28 months’ imprisonment and two months’ imprisonment respectively. On appeal, we affirmed their convictions and increased Tay’s aggregate sentence to an imprisonment term of 43 months: see Tay Wee Kiat and another v Public Prosecutor and another appeal [2018] SGHC 42.

  3. [3] The recent suite of amendments to the CPC via the Criminal Justice Reform Act 2018 (No 19 of 2018), which was passed in Parliament on 19 March 2018, includes amendments to the compensation regime. However, these amendments have not yet come into force. The version of s 359 which is currently operative states:

  4. [4] When the relevant amendments come into force, s 359 will read as follows:

  5. General principles underpinning criminal compensation

  6. [11] Finally, we note that compensation does not necessarily have to be left to the tail-end of the criminal proceedings. Where the accused admits to the offence and is willing to compensate the victim, he should be encouraged to do so at an early stage, even before a plea is recorded. This affords the victim the benefit of early closure and may give him or her some much-needed financial relief, particularly if he or she is unable to work as a result of the offence.

  7. Brief observations on the mechanics of compensation

  8. (a) pain and suffering caused to the victim (eg, Public Prosecutor v Foo Chee Ring [2008] SGDC 298 at [260]);

  9. (b) medical expenses incurred by the victim (eg, Public Prosecutor v Fok Jun Hong Johnson [2016] SGMC 19 at [117], though this case did not involve a domestic maid);

  10. (c) loss or damage to the victim’s property as a result of the offences; and

  11. (d) prospective earnings, ie, income that the victim would have earned but for her being unemployed pending the investigation and trial of the offences (eg, Public Prosecutor v Foo Chee Ring [2008] SGDC 298 at [260] and Public Prosecutor v Anpalaki Muniandy Marimuthu and another [2016] SGMC 56 at [176]).

  12. Application to the facts

  13. [15] As the Court observed in Soh Meiyun at [56] and [60], criminal compensation is prima facie appropriate in maid abuse cases and should generally be a matter of course because the victims are often, if not invariably, impecunious. It will rarely be feasible for them to pursue civil proceedings while working full-time in their employers’ homes, particularly when they are unfamiliar with the legal system. We accept that that was the case for the victim here, who is now working for another employer. We also consider it appropriate to compensate her for the physical and psychological injuries inflicted by the offenders, for which they would have been liable in tort.

  14. [16] In particular, Tay was convicted of inflicting the following injuries on the victim:

  15. (a) slapping the victim once, hard, on her left cheek;

  16. (b) making the victim stand on a plastic stool on one leg and hold up another plastic stool with one hand while he pushed an empty plastic bottle into her mouth, and making her stay in this position for 30 minutes;

  17. (c) pulling the victim by her hand out of the car and onto the ground, causing her to feel pain in her chest;

  18. (d) hitting the victim on her head on four occasions, either with a bundle of three canes or with a bamboo stick;

  19. (e) kicking the victim on her left waist;

  20. (f) pulling the victim by her hair to a room, grabbing her chin and pushing her head such that it hit the edge of a cabinet; and

  21. (g) causing another maid, Moe Moe Than, to slap the victim 10 times.

  22. [17] Chia was convicted of slapping the victim twice and punching her thrice on her forehead.

  23. [18] In our assessment, the victim should be compensated for (1) the pain and suffering she underwent as a result of the offences, and (2) the salary that she would have earned but for being unemployed as a result of the offences.

  24. [19] Regarding compensation for pain and suffering, the Prosecution suggested a sum of $500 per incident of abuse, taking into account the physical and psychological harm suffered by the victim. We agree. The Guidelines for the Assessment of General Damages in Personal Injury Cases (Academy Publishing, 2010) recommend $500 for a single abrasion or contusion and a starting award of $500 to $1500 for multiple contusions on any part of the body. The courts have also awarded similar sums for bruises – for example, $1,500 (bruise on the right side of the face), $1,500 (5cm x 5cm bruise over the medial edge of the left knee) and $500 (small 1cm bruise over left eyebrow) (see Practitioners’ Library – Assessment of Damages: Personal Injuries and Fatal Accidents (LexisNexis, 3rd Ed, 2017) at p 837). Adopting a rough-and-ready measure, since Tay has been convicted of hurting the victim on 10 occasions, this corresponds to a sum of $5,000. For Chia the sum is $1,000.

  25. [20] As for prospective earnings, the Prosecution submits that Chia (being the victim’s employer) should pay her $5,400. When the victim left the offenders’ household in December 2012, she had just re-contracted a further two-year employment term with the offenders at a salary of $450 per month. She left for Indonesia in April 2015 and returned to Singapore on 25 August 2015 to work for a new employer. She was therefore unemployed for a period of 32 months in total, of which 23 months could have been spent working for the offenders under her two-year contract. The Prosecution submits that the victim should be compensated for only one year of unemployment ($450 x 12 months = $5,400), bearing in mind that she may not have completed this contract in any event, and that she would have been required to mitigate her loss under the civil law.

  26. Conclusion