Skip to content
Grounds publishedDecided 14 May 2018

High Court

Public Prosecutor v Fiz ul Asrul bin Efandi

Feedback & support

[2018] SGHC 119Case no. Magistrate’s Appeal No 9003/2018/018 paragraphs

What happened, in plain English

There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.

Ask about this judgment

Laws this judgment relies on

Grounds of decision

Official text from eLitigation

  1. Introduction

  2. Facts

  3. [3] The respondent was 30 years old and the victim, Chong Kok Soon, was 54 years old at the time of the incident. The offence took place at around 11pm on 11 September 2016 at the three-lane road in front of Block 4A Woodlands Centre Road, Singapore, which leads into a car park. Each of the three lanes was separated by road dividers and could accommodate the width of only one vehicle. Vehicles in the lanes therefore could not switch lanes.

  4. [4] That night, the respondent drove his car into the innermost left lane. He stopped his car, turned off its engine and alighted to go to a nearby ATM to withdraw money. There was a female passenger in his car. Its hazard lights were not turned on at that time. Sometime later, the victim drove into the same lane without realising that the respondent’s car ahead of him was stationary. As a result, his way forward was blocked and the only way out was for the victim to reverse his car out of the lane. However, this was complicated by a third car which subsequently came up behind the victim’s car.

  5. [5] When the respondent returned to his car several minutes later, the victim sounded his horn. The respondent confronted the victim through the latter’s wound-down car window, saying: “You cannot wait ah?” The victim replied that he could not. The respondent then challenged the victim to step out of the car and the victim did so. The respondent spat on the victim’s face. The victim spat back but apparently his spittle did not reach the respondent. The respondent then punched the victim once on the right side of his face at the lower cheek area, knocking him to the ground.

  6. The proceedings in the District Court

  7. (a) First, while the requirements in s 42(2)(a) and (b) of the RTA were satisfied, the DJ was not entirely convinced that the commission of the offence “arose from or was connected with a dispute between the offender and that other person over the use of the road or public place” within the meaning of s 42(2)(c). The first punch did not appear to arise directly from the respondent’s indiscriminate parking but happened as a result of the victim’s sounding of his horn which agitated the respondent. The incident did not arise from the driving behaviour of the victim or the respondent and neither was it a situation connected to driving. The second punch arose from the respondent’s agitation over the victim’s use of the mobile phone. The section therefore did not apply on the facts of the case.

  8. (c) Third, while the respondent was aggressive and younger and bigger in build than the victim, it was not apparent that the victim was intimidated and had disengaged himself from the confrontation. This was shown by the exchange of vulgarities and the spitting incidents.

  9. (d) Finally, the respondent’s parking did not cause significant inconvenience to road users. The victim could have reversed his car and entered another lane, although doing so would have required coordination with the driver of the car that was behind the victim’s.

  10. The Prosecution’s submissions on appeal

  11. (a) First, the offence in the present case was one that arose from or was connected with a dispute over the use of a road within the meaning of s 42(2)(c) of the RTA. The Prosecution submitted that the DJ’s approach, which analysed the respondent’s motivation in relation to each punch (see [8(a)] above), was unjustifiably narrow and wrongly imposed a requirement that the offence must arise directly and only from the dispute over the use of the road.

  12. My decision

  13. [11] The first question was whether the statutory requirements in s 42(2) of the RTA were satisfied. The present offence was clearly one which arose from or was connected with a dispute over the use of a road within the meaning of s 42(2)(c) of the RTA. The respondent and the victim were two drivers who got into an argument because of the respondent’s indiscriminate parking which blocked off one lane of traffic without warning other drivers, thereby trapping the victim’s car in that lane even if it was temporary. One action then led to a corresponding reaction but they were all linked causally and closely to the respondent’s irresponsible and selfish hoarding of the road space.

  14. [12] It is not realistic to dissect the sequence of events into distinct parts and assign a specific reason for each part when they flowed continuously as part of one incident. The actions of the persons involved should be viewed as an overall assessment to see whether those actions could be said, as a matter of common-sense, to have occurred as a result of a dispute over the use of the road or public place. Actions which are far removed in time, place and context from the said dispute could, where appropriate, be considered not to have arisen from or connected with such dispute.

  15. [15] From the respondent’s previous road-related violence antecedent (see [9(b)] above) and the circumstances leading to the present offence, it can be seen that the respondent is a person who does not stop to think before resorting to violence whenever he is agitated. The unfortunate incident could have been averted if he had not been too lazy to do a short walk (as he admitted he was) and had moved his car another 20m or so into the carpark ahead. Alternatively, he should have at least turned on the car’s hazard lights to signal that he would be stopping in the lane for a while. Further, once he realised that he was impeding the movement of other vehicles, he could have waved to signify that he was sorry or apologised for having obstructed the road. Instead, he chose to be rude.

  16. [16] When the victim responded, the respondent became confrontational and behaved in a totally uncivil manner by spitting at him. One can appreciate the victim’s outrage at being spat at but, as a mature man with a young daughter next to him, he should have restrained himself from responding in kind. Nevertheless, the respondent delivered the first punch to a vulnerable part of the victim. The second punch was calculated to prevent the already shaken victim from calling the police (see [6] above). This, as the DJ pointed out correctly, was reprehensible and an aggravating factor in sentencing as the victim had already moved away from the respondent and was trying to call for police assistance. The respondent had to be restrained by his female passenger. It is clearly in the public interest that aggressive drivers who do not control their anger and who pose a danger to the safety of other road users should not be allowed to drive for an appropriate period of time.

  17. [19] The respondent informed me that he is presently doing whatever odd jobs came his way. He would work and save up to pay for the rented car that he was driving and which he drove to Court to attend the hearing of the appeal. He is supporting his wife and four young children financially and they are expecting a fifth child soon. He said he needed to drive his two oldest children to school because their schools were in different areas in Singapore and school transport would be expensive. However, I did not think those reasons were sufficient to displace the need for disqualification in this case. It was also odd that the respondent believed that maintaining a rented car would be more viable economically than paying for his two children’s school transport.

  18. Conclusion