High Court · Decided 15 May 2019
Sin Tiong Wah International Pte Ltd v Pee Wee Liang
Feedback & support[2019] SGHC 124 · Case no. HC/Registrar’s Appeal from the State Courts No 4 of 2019 · 9 paragraphs
✱ What happened, in plain English
There is no plain-English summary of this judgment yet.
Ask about this judgment →Grounds of decision
Official text from eLitigation
- [1]
[1] The plaintiff is a Malaysian working for the defendant in Singapore from October 2014 to April 2018. The plaintiff currently works for Castor & Wheel Singapore Pte Ltd (“Castor & Wheel”). Mr Ong, counsel for the defendant is not sure what the plaintiff currently does. He thinks that the plaintiff could be a driver or a storekeeper or both. Mr Michael Han, counsel for the plaintiff, says he is now a driver and occasionally operates the forklift to carry drums.
- [2]
[2] The plaintiff, while working for the defendant, injured himself in November 2017 moving a 200kg drum (“the Accident”). He claims that his back was badly injured by that incident and is suing for damages in tort.
- [5]
[5] In the present case, the evidence shows that the plaintiff was resident in Singapore almost the whole time in the past six years. He has left the defendant’s employ but is now working for Castor & Wheel in Singapore.
- [6]
[6] Mr Ong complains that the plaintiff has no fixed address and is therefore a “flight risk”, a term also adopted by Mr Han, but this is an inappropriate term in an application under civil procedure law, and it is not relevant when determining whether the plaintiff was ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction. The law requires the plaintiff to be ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction, and not that the plaintiff must reside in the same place for any specific period of time for the purposes of determining ordinary residence, unless it is to show that the plaintiff changed his address to evade the consequences of litigation (O 23 r 1(1)(d)). This is not the case here and there is neither submission nor evidence that this was the case.
- [7]
[7] “Ordinarily resident” is not difficult to understand and generally connotes residence in a place with some “degree of continuity” (Tjong Very Sumito and others v Chan Sing En and others [2011] 3 SLR 580 at [22]). The plaintiff has worked in Singapore since 2013, and he has stayed at three addresses in Bedok in the past few years, one of which was his sister-in-law’s home. He has a wife who also works in Singapore, and he goes back to Malaysia once a month to see his 9-year-old daughter who is under the care of his wife’s mother. If asked whether this suggests that the plaintiff is ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction, the answer must be a categorical “no”.
- [8]
[8] That being the case, the application cannot succeed. There is no room for discretion of any sort that would have to be exercised had the court found that the plaintiff was ordinarily resident outside the jurisdiction.
- [9]
[9] The deputy registrar found that the plaintiff was resident outside the jurisdiction but on the evidence, it is very difficult to see how that finding can be made in this case, except, perhaps the deputy registrar was influenced by the merits of the claim and the conduct of the plaintiff.
- [10]
[10] The plaintiff had originally applied for compensation pursuant to section 7 of the Work Injury Compensation Act (Cap 354, 2009 Rev Ed) after he claimed to be injured at work. An assessment in the sum of $26,200 was issued by the Ministry of Manpower, and the plaintiff subsequently withdrew his application, presumably in favour of pursuing a much larger claim in the civil court.
- [11]
[11] The defendant also adduced evidence that shows that the plaintiff probably had a pre-existing injury which he is now claiming to have arisen from the Accident at work. Furthermore, a private investigation report shows an active plaintiff climbing up and down a lorry in his new work-place at Castor and Wheel, long after his alleged injury.